Decisions - December 22, 2006


Allegany 
G., JACK R. v G., PAULA E.   1438   CAF 06-00178   (V-00070-98/05G)  
H., LISA M. v H., GERALD C.   1459   CAF 06-00656   (F-804-03)  
 
Cattaraugus 
N., DAKOTA, MTR. OF   1521   CAF 06-00406   (A-02453-04)  
P., NATHANIAL, MTR. OF   1520   CAF 06-00405   (A-00760-05)  
RIGGS, RALPH A. v CATTARAUGUS COUNTY COUNCIL OF ALCO,   1461   CA 06-02110   (66109)  
SCHULZ, JEFFREY A. v ERIE & NIAGARA INSURANCE ASSOCIATIO,   1579   CA 06-01979   (69253)  
 
Cayuga 
LOWE, ROBERT JAMIE v STATE OF NEW YORK, EXECUTIVE, DEPARTMENT, DIVISION OF   1640   CA 06-01343   (104523)  
 
Chautauqua 
B., THOMAS, MTR. OF   1656   CAF 05-01720   (B-1811-04)  
C., NICHOLAS E. v D., KRISTINA L.   1546   CAF 05-01981   (V-3339-3340-04, O-3297-0  
L., MARIJKA E. v L., WILLIAM W.   1547   CAF 05-01078   (F-489-99)  
Z., FRANCISCO G., MTR. OF   1655   CAF 06-02563   (D-2349-04/05)  
 
Erie 
ACHTZIGER, WILLIAM F. v MOLLENBERG-BETZ, INC.,   1442   CA 06-01938   (I-2000-8129)  
AKERS, ERIC, PEOPLE v   1537   KA 04-03082   (I00859-2004)  
ALLISON, TIMOTHY v ERIE COUNTY INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT, AGENCY   1364   CA 06-00008   (i2001-2788)  
AMOS, RAYMOND, PEOPLE v   1561   KA 05-02021   (S25051)  
ANDERSON, DERRICK, PEOPLE v   1493   KA 05-01250   (I02617-2004)  
B., AARON, MTR. OF   1439   CAF 05-02528   (NN-15546-04, NN-15547-04  
BENJAMIN, ALAN, PEOPLE v   1454   KA 04-02763   (I00229-2003-R01)  
BOLIS, KIMBERLY A. v FITZPATRICK, JR., MICHAEL A.   1196   CA 06-00484   (I2001/11668)  
BOLIS, KIMBERLY A. v FITZPATRICK, JR., MICHAEL A.   1195   CA 06-00483   (I2001/11668)  
BOYD, TERRENCE v BUFFALO BOARD OF EDUCATION,   1534   CA 05-02277   (I2000-6061)  
BOYD, TERRENCE v BUFFALO BOARD OF EDUCATION,   1532   CA 05-02275   (I2000-6061)  
BOYD, TERRENCE v BUFFALO BOARD OF EDUCATION,   1533   CA 05-02276   (I2000-6061)  
CASACCI, DANIEL J. v U.S. DRIVES, INC.,   1646   CA 06-01314   (I2005-011708)  
CYTROWSKI, RICHARD, PEOPLE v   1471   KA 05-00870   (I2003-05038)  
D., MARTIN G. v F., LUCILLE A.   1636   CAF 05-02268   (F-22440-02/04A)  
DAVENPORT, DARRELL, PEOPLE v   1634   KA 05-00497   (I2003-04691)  
DIINA, ROCCO J., RODRIGUEZ, DAVID v   1490   TP 06-00685   (I2004/3843)  
DIPIRRO, ROMEO C. v CLARENCE FIRE DISTRICT NO. 1,   1194   CA 06-01116   (2000-9535)  
DONALDSON, JIMMY, PEOPLE v   1567   KA 05-01159   (I00556-2004)  
EVANS, SHANTEL, PEOPLE v   1583   KA 05-00691   (I2176-2004)  
FISHER, CHARLES J., PEOPLE v   1632   KA 05-01269   (I589-2004)  
FISHER, CHARLES J., PEOPLE v   1631   KA 05-01265   (I5017-2003)  
FLANAGAN, JR., TIMOTHY M. v KLEIN, JOHN D.   1440   CA 06-01100   (I2004-7034)  
FRANKS, DAVID, PEOPLE v   1650   KA 06-00082   (I2004-1653)  
GALLION, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v   1430   KA 05-00844   (I2004-00951)  
GANDY, JAMES F., PEOPLE v   1411   KA 06-00071   (I1995-0389)  
GINTHER, GEORGE EAGAN v JONES, PAUL F.   1526   CA 06-00659   (I2005-6904)  
GLOSS, RICHARD v MURRAY, TIMOTHY J.   1455   KAH 05-02280   (I-2005-4452)  
GOSCIAK, JOAN v SLADE GROUP LLC,   1446   CA 06-01087   (2002/13565)  
GRIFFIN, LINDA M., PEOPLE v   1429   KA 05-01243   (I2004-01249)  
H., DEMETRIUS v M., MIKHAILA C.   1501   CAF 05-02444   (F-12384-04/04A)  
HALL, JON, PEOPLE v   1435   KA 06-01884   (01560-2005)  
HOWARD, MICA, PEOPLE v   1563   KA 05-01063   (I0613-2004)  
HUMBER, ALMON, PEOPLE v   1491   KA 04-03102   (I01-0120-001)  
HUNTER, EPHRIAM, PEOPLE v   1538   KA 04-01898   (I02-02128)  
JACKSON, CHARLES   1498   KAH 04-02970   (I-2004-10713)  
JOHNSON, MARLICA A., PEOPLE v   1560   KA 05-00494   (I05172-2003)  
KILMER, MARY v STREK, BEATA J.   1641   CA 06-00988   (04-9755)  
KNUPFER, DEBORAH v THE HERTZ CORPORATION,   1555   CA 06-02108   (2005-7118)  
LAMENDOLA, GINO P. v NEW YORK STATE THRUWAY AUTHORITY,   1575   CA 05-02175   (93 133)  
LEFORT, DOUGLAS, PEOPLE v   1492   KA 05-01151   (S24793)  
LOBELLO, KATHLEEN v BFI WASTE SYSTEMS OF NORTH AMERICA,, INC.   1443   CA 06-01363   (I-2000-8138)  
M.-V., GIOVANNIE, MTR. OF   1569   CAF 06-00609   (B-04412-05)  
MARTIN, TRAVIS, PEOPLE v   1453   KA 04-00562   (00-1313-001)  
MC CULLUM, HARDY, PEOPLE v   1472   KA 05-01275   (S24295)  
MCDANIEL, JULIUS v BERBARY, JAMES L.   1436   KAH 05-02803   (I-2005-9408)  
MCGRAIN, BRIAN, PEOPLE v   1582   KA 05-00849   (I05213-2003)  
MID CITY DODGE, INC., v UNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS INSURANCE CO,   1553   CA 06-00806   (I-1999-3633)  
MORALES, WANDA I., PEOPLE v   1452   KA 04-02818   (I04558-2003-AG-S01)  
NEW YORK CENTRAL MUTUAL FIRE INSUR., v MCLEARY, TAMMY A.   1645   CA 06-02037   (2005-09503)  
OKOLO, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v   1627   KA 05-00201   (I04706-2003)  
PARKER, JR., JAMES A. v SPRAGUE, KEITH M.   1441   CA 06-00571   (I2003-9982)  
PLACE, JENNA R. v COOPER, THOMAS J.   1597   CA 06-00873   (I2004/6084)  
POSCH, MARILYN L. v FEINBERG, M.D., MICHAEL S.   1643   CA 06-01797   (3041/98)  
PRICE, ARCHIE LEE, PEOPLE v   1543   KA 03-00069   (I01-1874-001)  
PRO-BIZ ENTERPRISES, INC., v KOZAN, CHRISTOPHER E.   1447   CA 06-01136   (2002-6665)  
RUMORE, PHILIP v BOARD OF EDUCATION OF CITY SCHOOL,   1445   CA 06-01627   (I2006-223)  
RUTHERFORD, JEFFREY v ERIE COUNTY INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT, AGENCY   1365   CA 06-00013   (i2001-2794)  
S., KAHLIL, ERIE COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL, SERVICES v   1424   CAF 05-01467   (B-15366-03)  
SCALICE, SHIRLEY v CARTER, MONICA E.   1509   CA 06-01503   (I2005/3200)  
SCALICE, SHIRLEY v CARTER, MONICA E.   1508   CA 06-01502   (I2005/3200)  
SEDA, ANGEL M., PEOPLE v   1375   KA 05-00089   (I05250-2003)  
SHOMO, JOSE v ZON, ANTHONY   1536   TP 06-01261   (2005-168)  
SIMPSON, ROBERT, PEOPLE v   1451   KA 05-00191   (I005315-2003)  
STACHOWSKI, MICHAEL v STACHOWSKI, DONNA   1571   CA 06-02074   (SF 2003-900675)  
STEWART, RONNIE, PEOPLE v   1433   KA 05-00683   (I04-00489)  
TUCKER, JON v M&T INSURANCE AGENCY, INC.,   1266   CA 06-01284   (I2005-3122)  
VILLAGE IMPORT AUTO SALES & SERVICE, v MOTORS INSURANCE CORPORATION,   1503   CA 06-00985   (05-1780)  
WHITE, WILLIE, PEOPLE v   1604   KA 05-00503   (I4449-2003)  
Z., JR., TERRELL, ERIE COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL, SERVICES v   1425   CAF 05-01468   (AS-23247-04)  
 
Genesee 
G., MYRIAM L. v GUTZMER, CARL A.   1594   CAF 05-02847   (V-00039-98/02A)  
G., CARL A. v G., MYRIAM L.   1593   CAF 05-02083   (O-00792-05)  
SCROGER, JR., JERRY K., PEOPLE v   1513   KA 05-00991   (S04-03)  
WETMORE, SHAWN C., PEOPLE v   1608   KA 05-02291   (S2004-116W)  
 
Jefferson 
B., DANIEL R. v M., LEDYARD   1545   CAF 05-01384   (V-2279-03/04A)  
EVES, SCOTT C., PEOPLE v   1450   KA 05-00697   (IC-356-03)  
MCKNIGHT, VINCENT H., PEOPLE v   1377   KA 04-03035   (I03-457-03)  
PAPINEAU, JR., VINCENT H. v MARTUSEWICZ, KIM   1499   OP 06-01815    
 
Lewis 
R., DENIS R. v R., BARBARA A.   1614   CAF 05-02164   (V-00150-01/04F, V-00151-  
 
Livingston 
DAVIS, SEPHORA K. v KOHOUT, JOAN S.   1437   OP 06-01392    
GREEN, JR., JOE, PEOPLE v   1496   KA 05-00757   (I2004-226)  
 
Monroe 
ADVOCATES FOR PRATTSBURGH, INC, v STEUBEN COUNTY INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPME, NT AGENCY   1665   CA 06-02213   (06/04099)  
ARENAS, THEODORE v THE BON-TON DEPARTMENT STORES, INC.,   1485   CA 06-01400   (98/5574)  
BLACKBURN, JAMES D. v DEL PRINCE, PETER   1618   CA 06-01167   (04-10755)  
CAVIGLIANO, RALPH, PEOPLE v   1542   KA 05-00749   (I91-0112)  
CLINKSCALES, CALVIN FLOYD, PEOPLE v   1609   KA 03-02031   (I155/03)  
DAVIDSON, EVAN v TOWN OF CHILI,   1572   CA 06-01312   (03/13565)  
DE GROOTE, JAN v TOWN OF GREECE BOARD OF ZONING APPE,   1444   CA 06-00814   (2005-5353)  
DOE, THERESA v WESTFALL HEALTH CARE CENTER, INC.,   1623   CA 06-00756   (1394/98)  
FAIN, PHILIP A. v GLEASMAN, KEITH E.   1460   CA 06-01311   (05/9327)  
GATES, DOUGLAS S. v ARREAZA, EDUARDO E.   1160   CA 04-02704   (02-11363)  
GREECE CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT, FISHER, BEVERLY A. v   1482   CA 06-02007   (2004-14432)  
GREEN, DERRICK, PEOPLE v   1474   KA 03-02448   (I75/03)  
GREEN, ROBERT, PEOPLE v   1610   KA 05-00119   (I103V/91 & Waiver No. 65  
HABTE, NEAMEN F., PEOPLE v   1476   KA 04-00296   (134/03)  
HARRIS, JAMES, PEOPLE v   1473   KA 03-02486   (I749/02)  
HUNTER, LEMAR v GALLAND, JUDITH   1192   CA 06-01118   (2001-4007)  
LOVERDE, JR., NICHOLAS J. v 8 PRINCE STREET ASSOCIATES, LLC,   1527   CA 06-01888   (03-6127)  
MARSHALL, DEATRICK, PEOPLE v   1612   KA 04-00377   (I02/0592)  
MARTIN, KEVIN L., PEOPLE v   1588   KA 03-02421   (I02-201)  
MASSARE, PETER v DINARDO, BRIAN   1287   CA 06-01095   (12866/00)  
MOORE, MELVIN, PEOPLE v   1515   KA 05-00868   (I461/85)  
MOORE, JAMES ALEXANDER, PEOPLE v   1431   KA 04-01999   (I24/03)  
MURRELL MECHANICAL, INC., v GRAYSTONE CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT S,   1237   CA 06-00462   (6492/03)  
MURRELL MECHANICAL, INC., v GRAYSTONE CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT S,   1238   CA 06-00463   (6492/03)  
OPTIC PLUS ENTERPRISES, LIMITED, v BAUSCH & LOMB INCORPORATED,   1598   CA 06-00844   (05-06749)  
OPTIC PLUS ENTERPRISES, LIMITED, v BAUSCH & LOMB, INC.,   1603   CA 06-01123   (05-06749)  
OWENS, ROBERT, PEOPLE v   1651   KA 04-00319   (W3817/03)  
OWENS, ROBERT, PEOPLE v   1652   KA 04-00320   (W3818/03)  
P.-D., ARELLA D., MONROE COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN, AND HEALTH SERVICES v   1523   CAF 05-01728   (B-14554-03, B-14555-03)  
PERKINS, DARYL, PEOPLE v   1432   KA 05-00752   (I98-0731)  
PERRY, AMMON R. v EASTMAN KODAK COMPANY,   1525   CA 06-01462   (2002/04307)  
ROMANA, MARIO, PEOPLE v   1566   KA 05-00754   (I93-0250)  
S., DOUGLAS E., MTR. OF   1615   CAF 06-00874   (E-12592-05)  
SCOTT, JOHN, PEOPLE v   1590   KA 05-00910   (B6657/84)  
SOFIA, GEORGE R. v JIMENEZ-RUEDA, M.D., CARLOS   1573   CA 06-00720   (04-13483)  
SUN, QING KAI v NEW YORK STATE LIQUOR AUTHORITY,   1417   CA 06-01749   (9784/05)  
T., JEFFREY v B., JULIE   1522   CAF 06-00167   (V-02680-01/05C & D)  
T., JEFFREY, PEOPLE v   1434   KA 04-03073   (I46/04)  
WILSON, ROBERT, PEOPLE v   1584   KA 04-01993   (I143/03)  
WRIGHT, RICARDO v SHAPIRO, JAMES J.   1580   CA 06-01101   (2003-012401)  
 
Niagara 
BRYER, MAUREEN v TOWN OF WILSON,   1549   CA 06-02036   (10846)  
CITIZENS AGAINST SPRAWL-MART, v CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS,   1464   CA 06-01817   (124309)  
GAMBINO FORD, INC., v MUNDY, MARK E.   1642   CA 06-02026   (122394)  
NATIONWIDE MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY, v MICHAELS, KATHERINE M.   1462   CA 06-02033   (123539)  
SKUPIEN, THOMAS J., PEOPLE v   1605   KA 00-02615   (I1998-195)  
STAATS, JOHN W. v WEGMAN'S FOOD MARKETS, INC.,   1189   CA 06-00984   (109262)  
 
Oneida 
BETSY ROSS REHABILITATION CENTER, I, v BIRNBAUM, MICHAEL J.   1548   CA 06-01260   (01/995)  
BROCKWAY, RONNIE R., PEOPLE v   1540   KA 06-01874   (2005-056)  
ENDIEVERI, ANTHONY F. v COUNTY OF ONEIDA,   1617   CA 06-02107   (00001509)  
FOLEY, THOMAS R., PEOPLE v   1564   KA 05-02398   (I97-158)  
GODFREY, TURRON, PEOPLE v   1541   KA 04-02392   (II03-021)  
GOSIER, WILLIE, PEOPLE v   1565   KA 05-01615   (I2004-338)  
JEFFERSON, DONNELL v GOORD, GLENN S.   1524   CA 04-01968   (CA2004-1184)  
KAPLAN, RICHARD E. v JULIAN, TIMOTHY   1663   CA 06-01690   (32-05-0101)  
MORGAN, DENNIS v GOORD, GLENN S.   1448   TP 06-01967   (2005-2348)  
PAPELINO, CHARLES v TACO BELL CORP.,   1601   CA 06-01772   (02-002285)  
PAYNE, KATHLEEN A. v GLADWIN, RICHARD J.   1554   CA 06-00189   (G-2004-0003)  
PICENTE, ANTHONY, PEOPLE v   1494   KA 04-03056   (II03-289)  
T., ANTHONY, MTR. OF   1478   CAF 06-00494   (B-01691-05, B-01692-05,  
 
Onondaga 
C., KAYLA, MTR. OF   1458   CAF 05-01326   (D-8159-04)  
C., KAYLA, MTR. OF   1457   CAF 05-01325   (D-8158-04)  
CHUNIKHIN, IGOR v BEAUDRY, GUY   1480   CA 06-02039   (2003-7204)  
CITY OF SYRACUSE, v S & S ENVIRONMENTAL,   1466   CA 06-01346   (05-2669)  
DOWDELL, JEFFREY L., PEOPLE v   1635   KA 05-00740   (I2004-0431-1)  
FRAVEL, JOHN, PEOPLE v   1125   KA 03-02570   (I2002-0714-1)  
GUNN, DARRELL, PEOPLE v   1568   KA 05-00836   (I2003-0242-1)  
HOME BUILDERS ASSOCIATION OF CENTRA, v TOWN OF ONONDAGA,   1484   CA 06-02000   (95-5571)  
J.B. STAUFFER CONSTRUCTION CO.,, INC. v MAILLOUX, ROSE MARIE   1486   CA 06-02006   (2001-0103)  
JONES, PATRICIA DODD v GINGOLD, M.D., SCOTT I.   1467   CA 06-02221   (2003-5936)  
K., DESTINY, MTR. OF   1592   CAF 06-00382   (NN-5-9828/9830-9831-04)  
K., DESTINY, MTR. OF   1591   CAF 06-00381   (NN-5-9828/9830-9831-04)  
MANN, DIANE M. v TOWN OF CAMILLUS,   1600   CA 06-01990   (2003-7302)  
MCNALLY, PAUL J. v SWIFT TRANSPORTATION CO., INC.,   1556   CA 06-01876   (2002-7544)  
MERCIER, GEORGE v POWELL, VINCENT   1595   CA 06-01272   (2004-0509)  
P., POLLYANNA M. v E., SR., EDWARD A.   1637   CAF 06-00527   (V-01291-97/05 0 & P)  
PETERSON, JAVON, PEOPLE v   1470   KA 05-00306   (I2003-0631-30)  
PINNACLE CONSTRUCTION, INC., v CITY OF SYRACUSE,   1483   CA 06-02031   (2004-2216)  
R., DAVID, MTR. OF   1479   CAF 06-00252   (nn-3696-05)  
SNAGG, IAN, PEOPLE v   1654   KA 04-01482   (I2002-360)  
TROUTMAN, TIA W. v SYRACUSE HOUSING AUTHORITY,   1578   CA 06-02189   (2005-3763)  
WILLIAMS, LINWOOD, PEOPLE v   1475   KA 05-00057   (I2003-0631-034)  
WILLIAMS, SEARS A., PEOPLE v   1629   KA 04-02666   (I2002-0684-1)  
 
Ontario 
CARPENTER, STEPHEN G. v RAPINI, ARTHUR J.   1481   CA 06-01996   (91349)  
DEBEER, STACY A., PEOPLE v   1626   KA 04-02507   (I04-01-020)  
DEBEER, BRIAN P., PEOPLE v   1630   KA 05-00007   (I04-01-021)  
GOODWIN, JAMES, PEOPLE v   1649   KA 06-00123   (I04-04-061)  
SMITH, ROBERT, PEOPLE v   1585   KA 04-01688   (S04-DI-042)  
TANEY, KIMBERLY v TANEY, SEAN   1489   CA 05-00761   (94957)  
 
Orleans 
HAYNES, TIMMIE L., PEOPLE v   1497   KA 05-01751   (I04-73)  
 
Oswego 
BARTOSZEWSKI, DAVID v TOWN OF HANNIBAL ZONING BOARD OF AP,   1664   CA 06-01775   (2005-1113)  
DOE, JANE v FULTON SCHOOL DISTRICT,   1468   CA 06-02175   (05-1201)  
FREEMAN, WENDY L. v STATE OF NEW YORK, EXECUTIVE, DEPARTMENT, DIVISION OF   1602   CA 06-02271   (98967)  
 
Seneca 
CROGAN, SHELDON W. v POOLE, THOMAS M.   1456   KAH 06-00075   (36720)  
 
Steuben 
B., CASEY R., PEOPLE v   1477   KA 05-02509   (I2004-51W)  
KEARSE, CARRIE L., PEOPLE v   1449   KA 05-01801   (I2004-369D)  
LEWIS, ANTHONY, PEOPLE v   1587   KA 04-02801   (I99-93A)  
LEWIS, ANTHONY, PEOPLE v   1586   KA 04-02800   (I99-259)  
 
Wayne 
BOSWELL, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v   1512   KA 06-00533   (S05-W48)  
HALE, BRENDA K. v WILMORITE, INC.,   1577   CA 06-01714    
HALE, BRENDA K. v WILMORITE, INC.,   1576   CA 06-01666   (54764)  
WILBERT, SCOTT, PEOPLE v   1518   KA 06-01940   (90-199)  
 
Wyoming 
BRANCH, ARTHUR v GOORD, GLENN S.   1581   TP 06-01991   (20245-06)  
COLEMAN, JAMES v GOORD, GLENN S.   1428   TP 06-01994   (20281-06)  
DACEY, JAMES P. v PERRY CENTRAL SCHOOLS,   1621   CA 06-01565   (36265)  
GOODMAN, COLLYER v GOORD, GLENN S.   1647   TP 06-01993   (20255-06)  
HAYWOOD, KEITH v SMITH, PAT   1662   CA 06-00602   (36665/05)  
HAYWOOD, KEITH v DROWN, CURTIS   1661   CA 06-00601   (36664/05)  
IGBINOSUN, FERGUSON A., PEOPLE v   1539   KA 05-01625   (I5222)  
JENKINS, ARTHUR v STATE OF NEW YORK, EXECUTIVE, DEPARTMENT, DIVISION OF   1599   CA 06-00464   (106790)  
S., WILLIAM v C., JESSICA   1500   CAF 05-02846   (V-00701-04/05B)  
WASHINGTON, KAWAND v GOORD, GLENN S.   1469   TP 06-01992   (20252-06)  
 
Yates 
BAILEY, BRANDON L., PEOPLE v   1514   KA 05-02384   (I04-38)  
HARTY, JOHN M., PEOPLE v   1516   KA 05-02549   (S98-44)  
HAWLEY, ROBERT v VILLAGE OF PENN YAN,   1616   CA 06-00971   (05-092)  
HAWLEY, ROBERT v VILLAGE OF PENN YAN,   1620   CA 06-01205   (04-290)  
THOMPSON, KASHANDRA A., PEOPLE v   1628   KA 06-00392   (I05-37)  
       
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS      

To download a free version of Adobe Acrobat click on the link below:

Adobe Acrobat Reader