Decisions - February 1, 2008


A., JEREMY J. v A., CARLEY13CAF 06-02765(V-3087-04, V-3088-04, V-
ADVOCATES FOR PRATTSBURGH, INC., v STEUBEN COUNTY INDUSTRIAL, DEVELOPMENT AGENCY1497CA 07-00847(06/04099)
ADVOCATES FOR PRATTSBURGH, INC., v STEUBEN COUNTY INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPM,1496CA 07-00386(06/4099)
ALDEN STATE BANK, v SUNRISE BUILDERS, INC.,1502CA 06-02408(I-2001-10109)
ALDEN STATE BANK, v SUNRISE BUILDERS INC.,1503CA 07-00867(i2001-10109)
AMENDOLA, FRANK A. v KENDZIA, BARBARA1547CA 06-02102(113370)
AMYELL DEVELOPMENT CORP., v IKON OFFICE SOLUTIONS, INC.,162CA 07-01527(05/1087)
AMYELL DEVELOPMENT CORP., v IKON OFFICE SOLUTIONS, INC.,161CA 07-00405(05/1087)
ANDERSON, GEORGE, PEOPLE v84KA 06-01616(I02624-2004)
BAGGOTT, DECLAN D. v CORCORAN, LORRAINE A.1589CA 07-00843(I2005-3658)
BAILEY, VICKI v BAILEY, JAMES T.1332CA 06-02777(SF 2004-900688)
BAILEY, VICKI L. v BAILEY, JAMES T.1333CA 07-00265(SF2004-900688)
BANKS, WILLIAM E., PEOPLE v196KA 06-02868(I2004-0059A)
BANKS, WILLIAM E., PEOPLE v197KA 06-02869(I2003-0450B)
BARRON, JOHN v DUBE, DONNA58CA 07-00752(CA2006-632)
BENNETT, SR., ELUID, PEOPLE v9KA 05-01450(10410/04)
BENNETT, SR., ELUID, PEOPLE v4KA 05-01449(10735/04)
BLACK, SHAUN D., PEOPLE v1489KA 06-02653(I00940-2003)
BLAZYNSKI, SALLY ANN v A. GARELECK & SONS, INC.,1526CA 06-02685(2003-8559)
BLAZYNSKI, SALLY ANN v A. GARELECK & SONS, INC.,1525CA 06-01554(2003/8559)
BLUE, ANTHONY, PEOPLE v42KA 05-02386(I03-67)
BOSS, BRYAN E., PEOPLE v1KA 06-02640(I5426)
BOYD, TIMOTHY L., PEOPLE v1490KA 05-02221(I2004-0782-1)
BRADLEY, JR., CHESTER W., PEOPLE v1466KA 06-01227(I2005-156)
BRENT-PRIDGEN, DAWAN, PEOPLE v49KA 04-02753(I2004-0063-3)
BRITT, CARMEN v BUFFALO MUNICIPAL HOUSING AUTHORITY,1581CA 06-01374(I-2004-9897)
BRITT, CARMEN v BUFFALO MUNICIPAL HOUSING AUTHORITY,1586CA 06-02447
BROWN, SABRINA v SANGERTOWN SQUARE, LLC,99CA 07-01049(2004-002720)
BROWNELL, CLARENCE G., PEOPLE v168KA 06-02966(I4142VOP-T)
BRUMMER, STEPHEN F. v TOWN OF TONAWANDA,1405CA 06-02840(2002-573)
BRUNO, ROSEANN v GOSY, M.D., EUGENE J.1469CA 07-00967(9720/99)
BRUNO, ROSEANN v GOSY, M.D., EUGENE J.1468CA 06-02250(99-09720)
BUDELMANN, JON E. v LEONE, THOMAS GUY1634OP 07-01942
BUFFALO PROFESSIONAL FIREFIGHTERS A, v MASIELLO, ANTHONY1157CA 06-02379(I-2005-9450)
BURGESS, HERBERT v FISCHER, BRIAN167TP 07-01545(20400-06)
C., ALEXANDRIA, MTR. OF35CAF 06-02856(N-21-06)
CANALES, JOSE V., PEOPLE v213KA 07-00964(II02-245)
CAPLASH, JOLLY v ROCHESTER ORAL & MAXILLOFACIAL, SURGERY ASSOCIATES, LLC1449CA 07-00440(06/9758)
CARDUCCI, NICHOLAS, PEOPLE v132KA 06-00701(I04-0673)
CARNCROSS, JAMES, PEOPLE v1597KA 07-00591(S06-100704)
CARROLL, JOSEPH v COUNTY OF ERIE,119CA 07-00280(I 2004-4169)
CHAREST, PATRICK J. v MORRISON, SANDRA A.1582CA 06-03252(K1-2006-1272)
COBOS, GINO RUDOLPH v DENNISON, ROBERT60CA 07-01118(i2006-7950)
COLLADO-RODRIGUEZ, RENE, PEOPLE v46KA 05-00316(I04-57)
COLOSI, JAMES v FOLEY, ROGER L.1491CA 06-02627(115809)
COLOSI, JAMES v FOLEY, ROGER L.1498CA 06-03167(115809)
CONLEY, WANDA v WARNER, ANDREW E.160CA 06-00930(04-3882)
COOLEY, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v173KA 05-02463(I01403-2004)
COOPER, KEVIN, PEOPLE v50KA 04-02859(I342/04)
COSGROVE, EDWARD C. v WARD, JR., JOHN TAYLOR1477OP 07-01123
COUNTY OF NIAGARA, v TOWN OF NIAGARA,102CA 07-01541(128612)
COUNTY OF NIAGARA, v TOWN OF ROYALTON,97CA 07-01542(128615)
CRAVEN, RON D., PEOPLE v1595KA 06-02326(I2006-019)
CULVER, STUART J., PEOPLE v3KA 06-01073(S25640)
CUMMINGS, DARNELL, PEOPLE v108KA 05-01645(I461/03)
D., JAMES D. v W., PATRICIA A.134CAF 06-02678(V-00352-02/05C)
D., JR, LORAL T., PEOPLE v2KA 05-00429(I2004-0502)
DANIELS, WENDELL, PEOPLE v107KA 06-01008(I02203-2004)
DAVIS, DEMETRIUS, PEOPLE v149KA 05-00917(I280/04)
DAVIS, BOBBY L., PEOPLE v1305KA 04-01127(I2003-0429)
DAVIS, BOBBY L., PEOPLE v1304KA 04-01126(I2003-0429)
DEAL, DOUGLAS W. v WOOD, JAMES185CA 07-00180(33029)
DEEP, JR., NORMAN P. v CLINTON CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,1337CA 06-03487(2006-001384)
DELAROSA, RAFAEL, PEOPLE v199KA 06-00798(I04-10-110)
DEMMING, LYNN M. v DENK, M.D., MICHAEL J.1636CA 07-01791(I2002-5265)
DICKENS, ROBERT E., PEOPLE v10KA 06-01213(I2002-181)
DUFFY, MICHAEL v STONE, GILBERT H.123CA 06-03559(2001 DR 01229/A)
ERIE COUNTY MEDICAL CENTER, v PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT RELATIONS BOARD,188TP 07-01430(2007-845)
ESTATE OF JAMES J. WITZIGMAN, v DREW, JOHN R.1546CA 06-03153(CA2004-001441)
F., CHRISTINA F. v C., STEPHEN T.230CAF 07-02009(V-874-99/03)
FEAR & FEAR, INC., v N.I.I. BROKERAGE, L.L.C.,1495CA 07-01287(2057/07)
FELTON, ROBERT C., PEOPLE v52KA 06-02929(I2005-0680)
FERRELL, COLIN P., PEOPLE v23KA 05-01617(I742/04)
FIGGINS, ANDREW, PEOPLE v27KA 04-02128(I475/03)
G., LISA E. v THE GENESEE HOSPITAL,78CA 07-00120(539/94)
GARDNER, DANIEL v TOWN OF TONAWANDA,142CA 07-01719(I2005 4708)
GREEN, ELLIOTT, PEOPLE v51KA 05-01937(I2004-1054-1)
GRUBBS, JOHNNY L., PEOPLE v1596KA 04-02131(I2003-0712-1)
H., JASON D. v C., TONIMARIE115CAF 06-00102(v-00446-01/04l, v-00446-
H., SEAN, MTR. OF12CAF 07-00481(NN-03010-05, NN-03011-05
HALL, RANDY, PEOPLE v7KA 06-00538(I2004-316A)
HAWKES, JOYCE, PEOPLE v113KA 05-01051(I000492)
HOLKA, JOSEPH S., PEOPLE v125KA 07-00143(I2006-078)
HULLINGS, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v85KA 07-00256(S06-57)
I., WAYNE T. v C., LATISHA T.1516CAF 07-00181(P-1125-94/05D)
IBRAHIM, BAJHAT, PEOPLE v189KA 05-01735(S04-0623-1)
ISAAC, MYRON Q., PEOPLE v126KA 05-02211(I2005-0195-1)
J., JOSEPH A., PEOPLE v169KA 06-01635(S05-DI-199)
J. JR., MATTHEW, MTR. OF94CAF 06-02801(NN-13331-2005, NN-13332-
JACKSON, PARIS, PEOPLE v31KA 06-02793(S26684)
JACKSON, MATTHEW, PEOPLE v174KA 06-00434(I05-10-114)
JACOBI, JESSICA v MAJEWSKI, JEREMY208CA 07-00139(I 2003-12146)
JIM LUDTKA SPORTING GOODS, INC., v CITY OF BUFFALO SCHOOL DISTRICT,211.1CA 07-01327(I2006-8136)
JOHNNER, CATHERINE v MIMS, PERCY D.211CA 06-03351(MM-2004-204)
JOHNSON, DANIEL v DENNISON, ROBERT J.139CA 07-00989(I-2006-7687)
JOHNSON, PHILLIP, PEOPLE v86KA 05-01922(I665/03)
JONES, LIONEL, PEOPLE v1258KA 06-02805(I2005-0294)
JONES, JOHNNIE, PEOPLE v151KA 06-02652(2005-001986) & (I2005-3140)
JOYCE, CPA, JAMES A. v BORELLI, JOYCE & LIPUMA, LLP,1475CA 06-02089(2001/6958)
K., ERIN v C. SR., JOHNNIE56CAF 06-03176(F-06786-01/06A)
KESSEL BRENT CORP., v CITY OF UTICA,181CA 06-03608(CA2006-1232)
KESTER, FRANKLIN W. v NOLAN, MICHAEL P.1228CA 07-01006(I2006-011581)
KING, TOMMY R., PEOPLE v1579KA 06-02796(I2005-539)
KUNZ, ROBERT, PEOPLE v112KA 07-01538(01514-2006)
L., CHUNG v N., SOTHEA154CAF 07-01464(v-01975-06/06a)
L., DONNA PRINCE v WATERS, MIKE1448CA 07-01233(2003-6853)
LAMAR ADVERTISING OF PENN, LLC, v STATE OF NEW YORK,1093CA 06-03429(2005-0901)
LAVILLA, STEPHEN P., PEOPLE v1622KA 05-00159(S2000-3379)
LEGRETT, JOSEPH A., PEOPLE v223KA 06-02965(I06-DI-123)
LIGUORI, JOHN A. v TOWN OF RUSHFORD,1425OP 07-00790
LUNDY, TIMOTHY P., PEOPLE v32KA 03-00905(I304/02)
M., KENNETH v M., MONIQUE1560CAF 06-03655(V-17867-02/06F)
M., CHRISTINA M. v B., SHONDELL R.1629CAF 06-02831(V-01967-98/05F)
M., CORRINE A. v M. JR., THOMAS W.205CAF 07-00351(V-766-06)
MACKILLOP, DAWN v CITY OF SYRACUSE,1611CA 06-02670(1997-5425)
MACKILLOP, DAWN v CITY OF SYRACUSE,1610CA 06-02192(1997-5425)
MALEC, SCOTT v SNYDERMAN, M.D., MICHAEL1411CA 06-03359(2004-7886)
MALEC, SCOTT v SNYDERMAN, M.D., MICHAEL1410CA 06-01964(2004-7886)
MALEC, SCOTT v SNYDERMAN, M.D., MICHAEL187.1CA 07-01996(2004-7886)
MARTINEZ, PATRICIA v COUNTY OF MONROE,1562CA 06-02591(433-05)
MATTIOLI, CAROL v MATTIOLI, JOSEPH1453CA 06-00868(1998/05418)
MCCULLOUGH, THEO, PEOPLE v144KA 05-01809(I632/04)
MCKAYLA, MTR. OF116CAF 07-01157(A-1401-06)
MILLS, DONALD, PEOPLE v217KA 07-00727(I94-1025-2)
MITCHELL, GEORGE, PEOPLE v133KA 04-01478(W3030/04)
MORGAN SERVICES, INC., v ABRAMS, SANDRA62CA 06-03572(I2003-5435)
MORRISON, DAVID J., PEOPLE v30KA 06-03605(I2005-1919)
MORRISON, DAVID J., PEOPLE v25KA 07-00660(I01-0143-001)
MURPHY, CLAUDIA v FAIRPORT CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,18CA 07-01729(2004/01179)
N., RONALD v UTICA CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT,143CA 07-01539(CA2005-1668)
NATH, HEATHER v BROWN, MARY J.1523CA 07-00023(2003-6242)
NEWMAN, RONALD v MCDONALDS RESTAURANTS OF NEW YORK,1479CA 07-00376(12653/2003)
NIAGARA FALLS WATER BOARD, v CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS,19CA 07-01051(127017)
NICOL, SHAWN, PEOPLE v88KA 06-01068(I2004-404-1)
O'CONNELL ELECTRIC COMPANY, INC., v HUNT CONSTRUCTION GROUP, INC.,118CA 06-03633(96797)
ORTIZ, YALIDSA, PEOPLE v227KA 07-02142(0790a&b/2006)
P., HARRY v W., CINDY204CAF 07-00832(V-10749-06/07A)
P., JOHN v CHILDREN'S HOSPITAL OF BUFFALO,82.1CA 07-01532(10763-04)
PALLACI, MARY LOUISE v ALBIN, JOSEPH F.1433CA 06-03085(105617)
PALMER, JASON v CIMINELLI-COWPER CO., INC.,1639CA 07-02071(I2004-12725)
PALMER, SHAWN v CIMINELLI-COWPER CO., INC.,1638CA 07-02001(I2004-12726)
PALMER, SHAWN v CIMINELLI-COWPER CO., INC.,1640CA 07-02072(I2004-12725)
PALMER, JASON v CIMINELLI-COWPER CO., INC.,1637CA 07-02000(I2004-12725)
PARKER, JOSEPH D. v FU, FAY YUEN1504CA 07-00868(I2002-0668)
PHELPS, DAVID N., MTR. OF1499CA 06-03236(2004-49072/A)
PIGNATARO, ANTHONY S. v SCINTA, DENIS A.98CA 06-03157(34810)
PIGNATARO, ANTHONY S. v AMODEO, THOMAS P.103CA 07-01734(I-2006-5464)
PILATO, DAVID v NIGEL ENTERPRISES, INC.,1430CA 07-00802(8695/04)
PILLICH, KEITH, PEOPLE v70KA 06-00273(I00861-2005)
PLIANT CORP., v ASSESSOR OF TOWN OF MACEDON,1614CA 07-01434(59873)
PLIANT CORP., v ASSESSOR OF TOWN OF MACEDON,1613CA 07-01377(59873)
PLIANT CORP., v ASSESSOR OF TOWN OF MACEDON,1608CA 07-01433(59874)
PLIANT CORP., v ASSESSOR OF TOWN OF MACEDON,1607CA 07-01376(59874)
POWELL, EGAN J., PEOPLE v146KA 06-01235(I00649-2005)
PYRAMID WALDEN COMPANY, L.P., v THE BUFFALO UNIT, LLC,159CA 07-00948(2004-3388)
Q., VALERIE v H., ARTURO36CAF 06-00983(F-04846-04/05B)
R., MARY L. v B., VERNON155CAF 06-03518(V-15617-06, V-15618-06,
R., ANTHONY v ERIE COUNTY CHILDREN'S SERVICES,1561CAF 07-00427(V-15341-06)
RAMSEY, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v91KA 01-00517(98-73)
RANDALL, CURT, PEOPLE v127KA 07-00384(I2004-281)
REESE, ALLAH, PEOPLE v128KA 07-00317(I2003-631-12)
RICHARDSON, CAROLYN v SCALISE, D.104TP 07-01728(07-33087)
RIEDMAN CORPORATION, v GALLAGER, ROBERT D.1602CA 06-03295(2001-0459)
RIVERA, JUAN L., PEOPLE v175KA 06-01232(I05-07-072)
ROBINSON, DAVID v CYCLE STOP, INC.,121CA 07-01109(02/14782)
ROBINSON, TOMMIE v BARONE, ANTHONY C.1584CA 07-00168(114411)
ROBINSON, MARK, PEOPLE v87KA 06-01605(S26205)
ROOTS, WILLIE G., PEOPLE v6KA 06-03560(I2004-307)
S., BRANDON N., MTR. OF206CAF 06-03374(NN-04594-03/05E)
S., BRANDON N., MTR. OF207CAF 07-00642(B-0111-06)
SALEMAN, FREDERICK, PEOPLE v67KA 06-02429(S26292)
SCHLOSSIN, ROBERT v TOWN OF MARILLA,1267CA 06-03509(I 2005-2379)
SCHWIMMER, PHILIPPE R., MTR. OF1604CA 07-00529(2006-5892)
SCHWIMMER, PHILIPPE R. v ROTH, JOAN1603CA 07-00194(2006-5892)
SESSION, JIMMIE, PEOPLE v89KA 05-00370(I582/04)
SHERMAN, EDWARD G. v LISCIANDRO, JOHN225CA 07-01303(K1-2004-1611)
SMALL, ANDREW, PEOPLE v220KA 04-02856(I252/04)
SMITH, THERNELL, PEOPLE v194KA 06-03286(I2006-018)
SMITH, MIA L., PEOPLE v1534KA 06-01722(I05-32)
STAATS, JOHN W. v WEGMANS FOOD MARKETS, INC.,1246CA 07-00969(109262)
STAATS, JOHN W. v WEGMANS FOOD MARKETS, INC.,59CA 06-03376(109262)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v SANTARO INDUSTRIES, INC.,210CA 07-00472(2004-5950)
STEWART, AARON, PEOPLE v66KA 06-01465(I2005-131)
SUTTON INVESTING CORPORATION, v CITY OF SYRACUSE,1451CA 06-03146(2890)
T., CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v1415KA 06-02425(S26706)
T., NAGI v T., MAGDIA74CAF 07-00859(v-9945-9946-06)
T., KRISTI L. v V., ANDREW R.1630CAF 07-01093(V-00311-01/06L)
TABOR, DAN, PEOPLE v195KA 06-02794(II04-483)
TAYLOR, TIMOTHY L., PEOPLE v22KA 07-00615(S06-120)
TILLMAN, GARRIEN, PEOPLE v215KA 06-00783(I2004-091A)
TOM L. LAMERE & ASSOCIATES, INC., v CITY OF SYRACUSE BOARD OF EDUCATION,40CA 06-03561(2003-3046)
TORMEY, JR., THOMAS M. v THE AMERICAN TOBACCO COMPANY,77CA 06-03334(2005-0506)
TORRES, ERIC, PEOPLE v29KA 05-00360(I2004-0461)
TRAPP, NICHOLAS E., PEOPLE v148KA 06-03082(I2006-034)
URENA, RAFAEL v STATE OF NEW YORK,37CA 06-01883(110555)
V., AARON, PEOPLE v1624KA 06-01480(I05-07-066)
VANACORE, JOSHUA, PEOPLE v106KA 06-03660(S26972)
VAUGHAN, JAMES, PEOPLE v92KA 99-01241(I658A/98)
VIBBERT, ANDREW, PEOPLE v171KA 06-00950(S2005-146)
VILLAGE OF PHILADELPHIA, v FORTISUS ENGERGY CORPORATION,1605CA 07-00318(2003-2346)
W., ANTHONY, MTR. OF75CAF 06-01376(NA-11712-05 - NA-11716-0
W., SHADAZIA, MTR. OF54CAF 07-00074(B-8766-8768-05)
WALL, JAMES F. v ROBERTSON STRONG APGAR ARCHITECTS,, P.C.122CA 07-01190(i2005-0952)
WALL, ANTHONY W., PEOPLE v216KA 05-02594(II04-407)
WARREN, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v170KA 05-01107(I2004-1024)
WHITLEY, MARY v PIERI, KENNETH1567CA 06-03703(I-2006-9973)
WHITMORE, DARLENE L. v DOMENICO, DEAN A.157CA 07-01701(001922/05)
WHYTE, WILLIAM G., PEOPLE v24KA 06-02234(I05-10-111)
WILLEY, AARON M., PEOPLE v198KA 06-03285(SI03-062)
WILLIAMS, CLEVELAND, PEOPLE v218KA 06-03644(I2005-066)
WILLIAMS, III, DANIEL H. v COPPOLA, DOUGLAS S.76CA 07-00612(I-2002-7443)
WILSON, STANLEY, PEOPLE v203KA 05-00928(I65/04)
WOJTASIK, DONNA JO v STATE OF NEW YORK,1406CA 06-02663(95722)
YOUNG, EDWIN A., PEOPLE v43KA 07-00589(I4881)
ZUPA, ELEANOR v CHRISTOPHER, LUCILLE17CA 07-00523(2004-2226)