Welcome
Home
THE COURT
    Overview of the Appellate Division
    Justices of the Court
    The Courthouse
DECISIONS
    Latest Decisions
    Decision Release Dates
    Search
CLERKS OFFICE
    Clerk and Deputy Clerk of the Court
    Contact Information
    Terms of the Court
    Court Calendars
    Rules of Practice
    Frequently Asked Questions
    Forms and Practice Aids
    Latest Court News
    Employment Opportunities
ATTORNEY MATTERS
    Admission to the Bar
    Attorney Discipline
    Attorney Registration Delinquency
    Registration as In-House Counsel
    Retirement
    Voluntary Resignation
PROGRAMS & AUXILIARY AGENCIES
    Assigned Counsel Program
    Attorneys for Children Program
    Attorney Grievance Committees
    Court Examiners
    Indep. Judicial Election Qual. Comm.
    Law Library
    Mental Hygiene Legal Service
    Pro Bono Policy and Program
RELATED LINKS
   Court sites
   Legal sites




Decisions - February 6, 2009

ADAMS, RODNEY, PEOPLE v11KA 07-01627(I2003-5336)
ALLAH, WAHEEM v HODSON, TIM48TP 08-01457(40993)
ALLPORT, BRIAN L., PEOPLE v212KA 07-01644(I06-62)
ANDERSON, THOMAS v TOWN OF CHILI PLANNING BOARD,1360CA 08-00311(5930-07)
ARNOLD, JANET v ERIE COUNTY MEDICAL CENTER, CORPORATION1640CA 08-00743(I2007-2871)
B., CLARK C. v FULLER, II, NEIL1466CA 07-01831(03-1985)
BARON, RICHARD v KLEWIN BUILDING COMPANY, INC.,251CA 08-02156(2003-12753)
BELILE, THOMAS J., PEOPLE v214KA 08-00018(I05-64)
BETSY ROSS REHABILITATION CENTER,, INC. v BIRNBAUM, MICHAEL J.1489CA 08-00507(01-00995)
BLACK, GORDON S. v DOLIN, LONNY H.156CA 08-01088(13648/02)
BLACK, DARRYL, PEOPLE v1563KA 08-00676(2007-0815)
BLOOM, ROBERT W. v HENSEL, ESQ., RENE F.1419CA 08-01064(2005-8014)
BOYD, PATRICK, PEOPLE v213KA 06-02298(II05-226)
BRITO, WILFREDO, PEOPLE v211KA 06-02286(I2005-1165-1)
BROOKS, KIMBERLY, PEOPLE v210KA 07-00151(I06C-050)
BROWN, HOMER, PEOPLE v32KA 05-02601(I2005-314)
BROWN, LAMAR, PEOPLE v1606KA 06-02121(S21871)
BRYANT, THOMAS v FISCHER, BRIAN47TP 08-01530(20613-08)
BUNNELL, GERRI L., PEOPLE v55KA 06-03548(I4701)
BURSHTYNSKY, LOMA, PEOPLE v231KA 08-00628(S07-73)
BUTCHER, ORLANDO, PEOPLE v2KA 07-01725(II07-170)
C.,  MADISON, MTR. OF61CAF 07-01094(NA-03975-05, NA-03976-05
CANNON, TYRONE, PEOPLE v103KA 06-03543(I-2005-0377-1)
CARABALLO, FRANSISCO, PEOPLE v123KA 03-02272(I631/02)
CARDINELL, JACK A. v CHERUNDOLO, BOTTAR & LEONE, P.C.,155CA 08-01631(2005-4040)
CARR, ERIC D., PEOPLE v58KA 07-01927(I01872-2006)
CARTER, DAMARIUS, PEOPLE v82KA 03-01746(02-937-1)
CATARACT SPORTS & ENTERTAINMENT, GROUP, LLC v ESSEX INSURANCE COMPANY,1658CA 08-01419(11491)
CHABOT, JASON A. v CHABOT, LISA177CAF 07-01801(V-00178-98/06M)
CLAPP, DOLLY, PEOPLE v4KA 07-02430(I00575-2006)
CLIFFORD, SEAN D., PEOPLE v187KA 07-02424(SID07-0024)
CONKLIN, EDWIN v BONGIOVANNI, MICHAEL160CA 08-01841(2005--524)
COOPER, JESSIE JAMES, PEOPLE v1566KA 03-02013(I122/03)
COOPER, JESSIE JAMES, PEOPLE v1567KA 03-02014(I066/03)
COR ROUTE 5 COMPANY, LLC, v SARACENE, ALFRED226CA 08-01645(2007-5158)
COUNTY OF ONTARIO, v MIDDLEBROOK, BRUCE EDWIN1621CA 08-01073(98384)
COWARD, BOBBY M., PEOPLE v166KA 06-02819(I2005-1414-1)
CRANDALL, ERIK v WRIGHT WISNER DISTRIBUTING CORP.,1615CA 08-01166(2005-2143)
CUNNINGHAM, ARLENE K. v JACKSON, II, LOUIS J.174CAF 07-01578(V-78-00/06V)
DALEY, PATRICK L. v COUNTY OF ERIE,1661CA 08-00606(2007-7962)
DANIELS, DAMIEN, PEOPLE v56KA 07-02197(I2006-2892)
DARTNELL ENTERPRISES, INC., v HEWLETT-PACKARD COMPANY,1532CA 08-00746(2006/02709)
DECAPUA, ROCKY, PEOPLE v233KA 07-00952(I17/03)
DOZIER, TIMOTHY, PEOPLE v165KA 07-02563(I02185-2006)
DRECHSEL, CHERI ANN v NARBY, GEORGE M.1683CA 08-00167(I2001-10053)
DUDLEY, JUDITH E. v TOWN BOARD OF TOWN OF PRATTSBURGH,1708OP 08-01586
DUNBAR, JESSIE M. v ORTON, WILLIAM G.113CA 08-01223(04-1852)
DUNBAR, JESSIE M. v ORTON, WILLIAM G.115CA 08-01847(04-1852)
E., ANTHONY, MTR. OF13CAF 08-00720(B-1960-06, B-1961-06)
EBLING, STEPHEN v TOWN OF EDEN,134TP 08-01582(2008-4256)
EDWARDS, KEVIN M., PEOPLE v145KA 07-02487(S28859)
ELDERWOOD HEALTH CARE CENTER, v NOVELLO, M.D., ANTONIA C.18CA 08-01547(2006-7928)
ELLSWORTH, ROBERT W., PEOPLE v170KA 07-02648(I06-481)
ERB, RUDY E., PEOPLE v1369KA 07-02140(CR 04-687) & (I2004-447)
EVOLUTION IMPRESSIONS, INC., v LEWANDOWSKI, JAMES D.1531CA 08-00297(2005/06051)
F., MARIA, MTR. OF83CAF 08-00595(B-00575-07, B-00577-07)
FARROW, THOMAS, PEOPLE v25KA 06-01033(SI-2004-0965-1)
FASANO, VIRGINIA v J.C. PENNEY CORPORATION,1698CA 08-00093(14213-06)
FASANO, VIRGINIA v J.C. PENNEY CORPORATION,1699CA 08-00094(14213-06)
FLAGG, JAUQERE, PEOPLE v218KA 06-01497(I2005-0895-1)
FLEMMING, RICKY, PEOPLE v219KA 06-01620(I2006-020)
FOSTER, TIMOTHY v BARTLETT, BARBARA131CAF 07-01913(V-01242-03/07C, V-01242-
FOSTER, ANTHONY, PEOPLE v238KA 05-01036(I04-856)
FRIEDHABER, KENNETH H. v TOWN BOARD OF TOWN OF SHELDON,228CA 07-02495(38491)
GAGNE, STEPHEN v FISCHER, BRIAN72TP 08-01529(20605-08)
GAGNER, JOHN D., PEOPLE v106KA 07-00814(I06-07-078)
GARCIA, EDWIN v BARIE, NORA1676CAF 07-00708(F-01034-96/06B)
GARDNER, MATTHEW, PEOPLE v239KA 06-01216(I05-0815-1)
GARDNER, JACOB, PEOPLE v186KA 06-02853(I464/02)
GIMENEZ, EDWIN, PEOPLE v1666KA 07-01385(I2005-2028-001)
GONYOU, CRYSTAL M. v SANMARTIN, JUSTIN M.21CA 08-01715(2006-366)
GOUGH, JAMES R. v SCHILD, JEAN G.202CA 08-01460(07/06383)
GRACE, ELEANOR B. v GRACE, DANIEL W.60CAF 07-02450(V-00910-03/07C, V-00911-
GRACE, DANIEL W. v GRACE, ELEANOR B.59CAF 07-02449(V-00910-03/07B, V-00911-
GRAY, JOSEPH v KIRKPATRICK, ROBERT A.1680CA 07-01353(I2006-10116)
GREEN, DEMAR, PEOPLE v232KA 08-00373(I2007-1454)
GROTH, RICHARD N. v BJ'S WHOLESALE CLUB, INC.,1660CA 08-00072(05-4197)
GUTZMER, CARL A. v SANTINI, MYRIAM L.1526CAF 07-02724(V-00039-98/07S, V-00039-
HAMILTON, THERESA, PEOPLE v125KA 05-02437(I2004-816)
HAMPTON, JR., FRANKLIN JOEL THOMAS v DENNISON, ROBERT80KAH 07-02532(07-Writ-6)
HANSON, PAUL v LABRIOLA, A.162.1TP 08-01484(08-34708)
HARRIS, WILLETTE v JACKSON, EILEEN70CA 08-01056(1-2004-589)
HERRING, CLAYTON E., PEOPLE v144KA 07-02328(I2006-558)
HINCKLEY, LISA v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,117CA 08-01401(I2003-7777)
HINKSON, WAYNE R., PEOPLE v24KA 07-01827(I06-10-134)
HINKSON, WAYNE, PEOPLE v49KA 07-01825(S05-DI-237)
HOLLINS, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v163KA 05-02671(I2005-45)
HOME INSULATION & SUPPLY, INC., v BUCHHEIT, JR., GERALD A.1642CA 08-01428(2004-11838)
HUNT, ROBERT L., PEOPLE v28KA 08-00008(I2002-158)
IGLESIAS, TAMMY v BROWN, ANNE183CA 08-01627(2005-5035)
IOCOVOZZI, VINCENT D. v GETNICK LIVINGSTON ATKINSON GIGLIOT,89CA 08-01663(2380/04)
IVEYS, III, RAYMOND M., PEOPLE v73KA 08-00158(S2006-484)
J., KASEEM, MTR. OF201CAF 07-01072(B-03088-06, B-03089-06)
JACKSON, ANTHONY v GRAHAM, HAROLD1KAH 08-00495(2007-0695)
JACKSON, CONSTANTINE, PEOPLE v124KA 06-03044(I2004-0231-1-V)
JACKSON, ISAAC, PEOPLE v27KA 07-02668(II07-100)
JAMES, WILLIAM, PEOPLE v50KA 07-01947(S2004-4191)
JOHNSON, DARRELL v ALEXANDER, GEORGE133TP 08-01531(20619-08)
JONES, DANIEL v CITY OF BUFFALO,71CA 07-01836(I2007-1272)
JUHASZ, DANA v JUHASZ, STEPHEN1418CA 08-00284(SF900151/2004)
K., BRITTANY, MTR. OF85CAF 07-01606(B-00437,B-00438, B-00439
K., SAMANTHA, MTR. OF246CAF 08-00290(B-06344-06)
KAPP, JOSHUA, PEOPLE v128KA 06-03797(I2006-0774-4)
KERNAHAN, HASHIM, PEOPLE v51KA 07-02661(I2006-1137)
KERNAHAN, HASHIM, PEOPLE v52KA 07-02662(I2006-1952)
KNIERY, PATRICIA v COTTRELL, INC.,1618CA 08-01388(I2007-5120)
LAIDLAW ENERGY & ENVIRONMENTAL, INC, v TOWN OF ELLICOTTVILLE,1659CA 08-01183(I-2007-11259)
LAKE, DALE v KALEIDA HEALTH,109CA 08-01658(I2003-9117)
LANZARA, KEVIN R., PEOPLE v29KA 07-01247(I2006-102(1))
LEBARON, DENNIS v ERIE INSURANCE COMPANY,43CA 08-01444(96663)
LEE, MILTON, PEOPLE v193KA 07-00774(I00-457)
LEGGIO, JOHN v HOGAN, DANIEL D.111TP 08-01711(I2007-4663)
LIGHTHOUSE POINTE PROPERTY, ASSOCIATES LLC. v NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF, ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATI1330CA 08-00835(2007/9731)
LONG, KEITH v CELLINO & BARNES, P.C.,1620CA 07-01737(2005-7708)
LORD, MICHAELJON H., PEOPLE v240KA 07-01767(I06-035)
LOREE, PHILIP J. v BARNES, JAMES G.108CA 08-01697(98846)
LOWERY, MARIANNE v COLE, ONI176CAF 08-00692(F-2846-00/07D)
LUNDY, GEORGE v CITY OF OSWEGO,87TP 08-01579(07-1512)
LUPPINO, JAMES v O'BRIEN, WILLIAM E.181CA 08-00776(I2004-3571)
LUPPINO, JAMES v O'BRIEN, WILLIAM E.180CA 07-02704(I2004-3571)
LUTHRINGER, KEVIN v LUTHRINGER, GREGORY1423CA 08-00716(I2006-007833)
M., JOSHUA, MTR. OF1633CAF 08-01257(D-233-07/07A)
M., SHAHIDA, MTR. OF130CAF 08-00458(B-15154-55-07)
MAGUIRE, KEITH v CORCORAN, MICHAEL23KAH 08-01196(2007-1153)
MAKARCHUK, ARDA v MAKARCHUK, EDWARD1681CA 08-01118(CA2006-2081)
MALLABER, JOSEPH K., PEOPLE v173KA 07-02185(96355) & (S2007-67W)
MARTIN-GRANDE, DIANE M. v GRANDE, PAUL J.135CA 08-01743(84742)
MARTINEZ, LUIS, PEOPLE v1632KA 04-00585(I2003/0278)
MATTHEWS, CYNTHIA J. v SMALLRIDGE, KEVIN T.1641CA 08-01110(2005/8151)
MAXON, JOSEPH P. v WOODS OVIATT GILMAN LLP,107CA 08-01842(05-13220)
MAYNARD, KAREN, PEOPLE v1485KA 07-02198(I06-78)
MCCALL, JAMAR, PEOPLE v75KA 07-02562(I2006-2215)
MCENNIS, JONATHAN, PEOPLE v189KA 07-02655(I2007-1466)
MCLEOD, LYSA L. v MCLEOD, JAMAR A.241CAF 07-02573(O-821-07, V-00860-71. V-
MCNALLY, PETER R., PEOPLE v98KA 04-02819(S2004-3975)
MCNAUGHTON, RYAN A., PEOPLE v57KA 07-01499(I2006-204)
MCPHEE, JEREMY M. v JOHN D. BRUSH, INC.,22CA 08-01003(2006/9347)
MOORE, WILLIAM, PEOPLE v152KA 07-01083(I01772-2005)
MOORE, MATTHEW, PEOPLE v215KA 07-00825(I0012-2005)
MOORE, RICHARD, PEOPLE v3KA 08-00137(I2006-2800)
MORGAN, GERALD L., PEOPLE v78KA 08-00637(I07-173)
MORRIS, MARLENE v SCHEPP, CHRISTOPHER J.19CA 08-01174(52390)
MOSKAL, IRENE v UTICA COLLEGE,90CA 08-01391(CA2006-002747)
MOSLEY, CHARNELL, PEOPLE v102KA 07-00892(I2004-0306)
MOSLEY, CHARNELL, PEOPLE v101KA 05-00310(I306/04)
MOTHERSELL, ROBERT, PEOPLE v188KA 06-03549(I2006-0433-1)
NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN RI, v VILLAGE PLAZA FAMILY RESTAURANT,1523TP 08-01413(008884/2007)
NEWTON, JR., RAYMOND F., PEOPLE v150KA 07-00719(I06C-091)
O'BRIEN, DANIEL E., PEOPLE v121KA 08-00246(I2002-075-V)
OLIPHANT FINANCIAL CORPORATION, v ANGELO, JAMES T.138CA 08-01587(96171/05)
OUCHIE, CARLA, PEOPLE v6KA 07-00846(I2006-0919A)
PARRIS, YUSEFF v GOORD, GLENN S.230TP 08-01592(CA2007-1827)
PENNINGTON, JAMES E. v WOYTASH, JAMES1513CA 07-01431(2006/7722)
PETERS, DAVID, PEOPLE v10KA 06-03779(I2006-0774-3)
PETTIGREW, SR., DAVID C., PEOPLE v95KA 08-00245(I2007-320)
PIERCE, THERESA, PEOPLE v237KA 08-00686(ILC-15192)
POREDA, HELGA v KROFSSIK, AIMEE222CA 08-01363(2005/306)
RAFI, MIAN v RUTGERS CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY,1601CA 08-00800(68813)
RAMSEY, KAREEM, PEOPLE v1546KA 06-00067(I2003-0385-1)
RAPLEY, KENYATTA L., PEOPLE v7KA 05-01491(I2004-0642)
RAPLEY, KENYATTA L., PEOPLE v8KA 05-01492(I2004-0675)
RATEAU, NATHALIE v DAPA COMMUNICATIONS, INC.,1519CA 08-00574(2005/70626)
RAUX, JR., RONALD J. v CITY OF UTICA,157CA 08-01546(CA2004-1370)
REASIN, MATTHEW K., PEOPLE v100KA 07-00757(S06-DI-055)
RHODES, DAVID v LEMPKE, JOHN185TP 08-00759(40735)
RICHMOND, TIMOTHY C. v ORTON, WILLIAM G.114CA 08-01224(04-1987)
ROBINSON, BRIAN, PEOPLE v252KA 08-01262(S28297)
RODRIGUEZ, ROBERT v FISCHER, BRIAN119TP 08-01730(CA2008-001552)
ROGERS, SPENCER, PEOPLE v1564KA 08-01159(2007-0815)
ROSPIERSKI, LEONARD v HAAR, D.D.S., M.D., JEAN G.1554CA 08-01067(I2003-4830)
ROYCE, FREDERICK K., PEOPLE v167KA 07-02684(I07-26)
RUGGIO, KATHLEEN v PCCB, INC.,206CA 08-01755(07-1365)
SANTIAGO, RENEE S. v SPINUZZA, WENDY A.44CA 08-01291(K1-2004-576)
SANTIAGO, JOSE, PEOPLE v96KA 02-02514(I671/01)
SAUNDERS, JR., JAMES M. v AIELLO, DONNA M.1677CAF 08-00991(F-07934-02/07B)
SCALA, FELICE v SCALA, VENERA1534CA 07-02361(06-3150)
SCERBO, ALBERT, PEOPLE v1629KA 08-00198(I2007-383-1)
SCERBO, ALBERT, PEOPLE v1630KA 08-00199(I2007-383-1)
SCHENA, DEBORAH, PEOPLE v164KA 08-00687(I5054)
SCHULTZ, HENRY V. v LYNESS, STEPHANIE200CAF 08-00535(V-02471-07)
SHAPARD, CHRISTOPHER M., PEOPLE v1573KA 07-01566(I00178-2006)
SHORT, JOY, PEOPLE v120KA 08-00119(I2006-1801)
SIMMONS, JR., LEROY v STATE OF NEW YORK,247CA 07-01936(113313)
SMITH, ANTWON, PEOPLE v127KA 07-01151(4839/04) & (I04-318)
SMITH, TRAVIOUS JUAN, PEOPLE v146KA 05-00426(I35/04)
SOULIER, CHARLES v RADIATOR SPECIALTY COMPANY,1619CA 08-01163(2006-2184)
SPERDUTI, ROSE v NEW YORK STATE EXECUTIVE,42CA 07-02498(2007-4389)
STERN, VIVIAN v THE CHARTER OAK FIRE INSURANCE COMP,16CA 08-01630(2002-5595)
STROMAN, STEVE, PEOPLE v1648KA 99-02082(I97-118A)
SWAN, JR., RAYMOND S. v INGERSOLL, ANDREW J.1686.2CA 08-01105(I 2006-10721)
SWEENEY, KATHLEEN M. v LINDE, JOAN M.65CA 08-00494(I2004-1562)
SWEENEY, KATHLEEN M. v LINDE, JOAN M.66CA 08-00496(I2004-1562)
T., CORY, PEOPLE v1621.1KA 08-00498(SCI 26707)
TABB, CHRISTIAN, PEOPLE v1647KA 06-00771(I01979-2004)
TABONE, SAMUEL L. v LEE, M.D., KEUN Y.1415CA 08-01085(129947)
TANTAO, ENRIQUE v BERBARY, JAMES L.118TP 08-01798(i2007-12403)
TANTILLO, R. MICHAEL, MTR. OF1643KA 08-01441(40713(A))
TARTAN TEXTILE SERVICES, INC., v ST. JOSEPH'S HOSPITAL HEALTH CENTER,88CA 08-00529(01-02761)
TAYLOR, RONALD, PEOPLE v126KA 07-02660(I2006-227)
TELFER, WALTER K. v PICKARD, NICOLE L.86CAF 08-00612(V-00119-06/07B)
TELFER, WALTER, PEOPLE v99KA 07-00627(I2006-1270-1)
THE LINKS AT BLACK CREEK, LLC, v BALLANTYNE DEVELOPMENT, LLC,17CA 08-00820(2007/03035)
THOMPSON, SARAH B., MTR. OF1711CAF 08-00599(F-00198-01/07E)
TORRES, III, GUILLERMO, PEOPLE v151KA 05-02578(I04-968)
TOWN OF CHEEKTOWAGA, MTR. OF184CA 08-01595(I-2008-873)
TRALA, TIMOTHY C. v AFIF, HUSSEIN1686CA 08-01406(2005/11254)
TRENCA, PAULETTE v CULETON, ROBERT1694CA 08-01376(2004-1231)
TRUPO, FRANCIS v PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY,1535CA 08-00833(10661-04)
TYGER, ALICIA, PEOPLE v149KA 08-00485(I07-080-1)
UTICA CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT, v FEHLHABER, CRAIG S.91CA 08-01578(CA2007-1911)
VIRELLA, III, CONCEPCION v ALLSTATE HOME CARE OF BUFFALO, INC.,1696CA 08-01099(I-2006-000520)
VIRELLA, III, CONCEPCION v ALLSTATE HOME CARE OF BUFFALO, INC.,1697CA 08-01100(2006-520)
WALLACE, JOSEPH, PEOPLE v1631KA 08-01305(93-2030)
WARD, GEORGE v CORCORAN, MICHAEL1674KAH 07-02096(2007-0696)
WATSON, KURT W. v WATSON LANDSCAPING, INC.,116CA 08-00992(2001-6852)
WEBSTER, STEPHEN E. v TOTAL IDENTITY CORP.,110CA 08-01066(2005/00211)
WESTFIELD FAMILY PHYSICIANS, PC, v HEALTHNOW NEW YORK, INC.,1359CA 08-01079(K1-2003-459)
WHEELER, MATTHEW, PEOPLE v236KA 08-01597(2006-372)
WHITLOCK, JONATHAN, PEOPLE v143KA 07-02091(I2006-1190)
WILLIAMS, CASSANDRA v CLINTON CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,40CA 08-01596(CA2005-2617)
WILLIAMS, DEQUAN, PEOPLE v97KA 06-03803(I2003-1147-2)
WILSON, ANTWON R., PEOPLE v147KA 08-00161(I2006-592)
WILSON, KIM MATTHEW, PEOPLE v129KA 06-01046(I2005-0402)
WINDSONG LANE FARMS, v TELMARK, LLC,158CA 07-02244(2004-2341)
WINKLER, ELIZABETH L. v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN RI,1584TP 08-01313(2008-5789)
WURTHMANN, DENNIS v KIRKPATRICK, ROBERT A.1653KAH 07-02186(I-2007-3730)
    
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS