AD4 Seal

Supreme Court of the State of New York
APPELLATE DIVISION
Fourth Judicial Department

Decisions - April 24, 2009

 
Allegany
F., MEREDITH S., MTR. OF646CAF 07-02303(B-120-06)
MYERS, STEPHEN v MACCREA, WILLIAM R.530CA 08-01476(30671)
 
Cayuga
CLARK, TAMARA D., PEOPLE v640KA 08-00522(I2005-064B)
COLEMAN, RICHARD L., PEOPLE v523KA 08-02092(I2000-143)
 
Erie
ABRAMS, JOHN F. v CITY OF BUFFALO ZONING BOARD OF, APPEALS535CA 08-01820(2008-2382)
BAILEY, CHARLES J. v DALY, JOHN318CA 08-01917(I2004-7251)
BOLENDER, JOHN v TOPS MARKETS, LLC,664CA 08-02450(I2004-3137)
BONDS, ELAINE F. v LAIDLAW TRANSIT, INC.,386CA 08-02173(I2005-2425)
BURCZYNSKI, WILLIAM v RODGERS, STEPHANIE568CAF 08-01200(V-18065/01/07D,)
C., CONNOR, MTR. OF496CAF 08-00975(D-00415-08)
CANAZZI, DAVID v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,387CA 08-01659(I2004-7241)
CANAZZI, DAVID v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,388CA 08-01660(I2004-7241)
CROCODILE BAR, INC., v DRYDEN MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY,434CA 08-01393(I2006-6847)
D., VINCENT, MTR. OF497CAF 08-00976(D-00416-08)
DDRC ORCHARD PARK, LLC, v ASSESSOR OF TOWN OF ORCHARD PARK,648CA 08-02314(I2005-6614) & (I2006-6666)
EVANS, SR., DAVID v STRICKLER, JEFFREY A.575CA 08-02315(2007-5642)
GMAC INSURANCE COMPANY, v JONES, JR., ROCKIE430CA 08-02061(2008-1607)
GONZALEZ, SANTO, PEOPLE v642KA 98-05446(47,279A)
GREEN, KARLA R. v PASSENGER BUS CORPORATION,499CA 08-01420(I-2003-11494)
GREEN, KARLA R. v PASSENGER BUS CORPORATION,500CA 08-01421(I-2003-11494)
H., ISAIAH, MTR. OF473CAF 07-02445(B-16740-06)
HAWKES, FREDERICK R. v HAWKES, BONNIE M.668CA 08-00462(SF2005-901097)
HAWKES, FREDERICK R. v HAWKES, BONNIE M.669CA 08-01723(SF2005-901097)
HAWKES, FREDERICK R. v HAWKES, BONNIE M.670CA 08-02076(2005/901097)
HERNANDEZ, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v616KA 08-00244(I0998I-2007)
HOLCOMB, SHELBY, PEOPLE v420KA 08-00693(I2006-1712)
HOLCOMB, SHELBY R., PEOPLE v421KA 08-00694(S02817-2004)
HOLCOMB, SHELBY, PEOPLE v419KA 08-00691(I2006-1519)
J., DEMARIO, MTR. OF674CAF 07-02228(B-21002-05, B-21003-05,
JULICHER, JOSEPH J. v TOWN OF TONAWANDA,527CA 08-02449(2007-12043)
JUSTICE, JOHN D. v HUDSON, MICHAEL E.607CA 08-01542(08-3337)
M., JONATHAN, MTR. OF494CAF 08-00973(D-16745-07)
M., JOSHUA, MTR. OF495CAF 08-00974(d-16748-07)
MAJOR, STEVEN D., PEOPLE v603KA 04-02006(I02409-2001)
MASSEY, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v660KA 08-00141(I2006-2436)
MATTHIS, WALTER, PEOPLE v580KA 08-00627(I2007-1803)
MCGILL, MERRISA A., PEOPLE v618KA 08-00322(I2007-1959)
METAL GOODS AND MANUFACTURERS, INSURANCE TRUST FUND v ADVENT TOOL & MOLD, INC.,593CA 08-02340(05-6418)
MILLER, JEREMY, PEOPLE v644KA 08-00218(I2006-2392)
MOAR, COLIN, PEOPLE v537KA 08-00562(I2006-2238)
OSTROWSKI, WALTER v TOWN OF WEST SENECA,573CA 08-02339(2005/2882)
R. BREANNA, MTR. OF351 CAF 08-01760(NA-18733-2006)
SELVA, JOSEPH v LILLIE, M.D., MEDELINE AMBRUS656CA 08-02506(I2003-9349)
SEYLER, JOSHUA v HASFURTER, SARA672CAF 08-02324(v-01389-02/06)
SHERWOOD TERRACE APARTMENTS, v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN,249TP 08-00988(2008-604)
SIEDLECKI, DAVID v CITY OF BUFFALO,595CA 08-02442(2005/10445)
SMITH, KIMBERLY A. v BESANCENEY, CARRIE EMMA337CA 08-02168(I-2006-001546)
SPICOLA, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v661KA 08-02336(2432-2006)
VERSE, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v582KA 08-00651(I2005-1940)
VILLAGE OF SPRINGVILLE, v REYNOLDS, III, WALTER F.407CA 08-02029(2006-6742)
WIELBON, JERRY A. v PETRUS, CHARLES R.139CA 08-01810(I2005-7360 TP1)
WZONTEK, PAUL A. v A & L, INC.,574CA 08-01939(I2004-6741)
ZIEGLER, TERRELL, PEOPLE v564KA 08-02489(01558-2007)
 
Genesee
ALWARDT, ADAM, PEOPLE v600KA 08-01147(S07-074)
CHONG-HWAN WEE, DR. JOHN v UNITED MEMORIAL MEDICAL CENTER,452CA 08-02062(56192)
CORDEIRO, JONATHAN, PEOPLE v517KA 08-01191(I4990)
PEREZ-RAMIREZ, BONIFACIO, PEOPLE v26KA 07-01628(I4995)
 
Herkimer
DORSEY, JANET EVELYN v HERKIMER COUNTY COMMUNITY COLLEGE,507CA 08-02129(88533)
DUFF, DAVID C. v KRUKOWSKI, CHRIS M.577CA 08-01825(00083925)
HYGEIA OF NEW YORK, INC., MTR. OF571TP 08-02167(88531)
SPONBURGH, GREGG, PEOPLE v601KA 08-00654(I07-001)
STEIN, EDWARD R., PEOPLE v522KA 08-00009(S04-096)
 
Jefferson
FISH, KYLE J., PEOPLE v417KA 07-01695(SI-06-418-06-V)
FISH, KYLE J., PEOPLE v418KA 07-01696(SI-06-071-06-V)
 
Lewis
BEYER, DANIEL v TOWN/VILLAGE OF LOWVILLE PLANNING, BOARD613CA 08-02124(CA2008-00119)
 
Livingston
MACULA, ANTHONY J. v BOARD OF EDUCATION, GENESEO CENTRAL,342CA 08-01901(000686-2008)
 
Monroe
BRADFORD, DANA R., PEOPLE v606KA 05-01857(I2004-0084)
BRAYER, MICHAEL L., PEOPLE v599KA 07-00130(S2006-3925)
CAMPOPIANO, LAURA L. v VOLCKO, PAUL J.365CA 08-01720(2005/6834)
CAMPOPIANO, LAURA L. v VOLCKO, PAUL J.363CA 08-01273(05/06834)
CINTRON, KEITH J., PEOPLE v376KA 04-00219(I466/02)
COLLINS, ROLLIE V., PEOPLE v643KA 07-01624(6163/91) & (I91-0433)
ENGLERT, LEONARD M. v SCHAFFER, JR., ESQ., GERALD W.436CA 08-02193(2006/12365)
FLOYD, FRANKLIN, PEOPLE v518KA 06-01049(W2005-4232)
GROELL, VALERIE v GROELL, RITA T.429CA 08-02146(2006-005210)
HANKERSON, RICHARD, PEOPLE v623KA 06-01243(I2004-689)
HOLLINGSWORTH, JANET K. v CAPAN, BRUCE625CA 08-02499(11415/06)
HUBBARD, CHARLES, PEOPLE v579KA 06-00272(I2005-0384)
MITCHELL, WONDELL, PEOPLE v560KA 05-02650(W2005-3940)
MONTANO, GREGORY A., PEOPLE v544KA 05-00504(I182/04)
RIBIS, JOHN V. v EAST IRONDEQUOIT CENTRAL SCHOOL DIS,532CA 08-02317(07/7018)
SALAMONE, JAMES, PEOPLE v566KA 04-00639(I247/03)
SANDERS, WILLIE BERNARD, PEOPLE v583KA 06-03246(I3908/2006)
SEGURA, HECTOR J., PEOPLE v617KA 05-01172(I2003-0317A)
STAPLES, DONALD, PEOPLE v604KA 05-02390(I660/04)
WEATHERSBY, LESHUN, PEOPLE v520KA 07-01858(2002-002462) & (I2002-0087)
WHITCOMBE, KEVIN E. v PHILLIPS, REBECCA650CA 08-02429(8732-07)
WILLIAMS, ROBERT H., PEOPLE v521KA 04-00104(I152/03)
 
Niagara
BENTON, SEAN, PEOPLE v581KA 08-01013(I2007-284)
KAGELS, SUSAN L. v LEWISTON RECREATIONAL CENTER,553CA 08-02349(122930)
KILMER, AMANDA S. v TOWN OF PORTER,359CA 08-02044(120253)
PARKER, WILLIE K., PEOPLE v639KA 08-01041(I2007-221)
SISTRUNK, COURTNEY D., PEOPLE v561KA 08-01017(I2007-289)
SONBERG, NORMAN C., PEOPLE v395KA 08-00861(S2007-142A)
TABB, WAYNE A., PEOPLE v620KA 08-01034(I2007-257)
TAYLOR, LANIQUE J. v GROFFENBERG, LINDSEY L.525CAF 08-01358(V-00822-06/07B)
 
Oneida
BHATT, SUKEERTI v NATIONWIDE MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY,576CA 08-01734(CA2005-001027)
SCULLY, RANCE P., PEOPLE v443KA 07-01786(II02-134)
 
Onondaga
ADAMS, DARRELL W., PEOPLE v605KA 04-01401(I2003-0988-1)
ALEXANDER, TROY v NYS DIVISION OF PAROLE,586KAH 08-00398(2007-7506)
BAKER, JAMES M. v MURASKI, RICHARD J.479CA 08-02204(2002-7509)
BROWN, SPARTACUS, PEOPLE v641KA 06-03039(I2006-0294-1)
FULTON, JOVAN, PEOPLE v638KA 06-01723(I2005-1204-1)
GINOCCHETTI, TIMOTHY, PEOPLE v514KA 07-02568(I2007-0320-1)
GRADY, CAMERON, PEOPLE v602KA 07-01593(SI-2007-0417-1-V)
GROOVER, TERRELL J., PEOPLE v308KA 07-02591(I2006-1273-1)
HUNOLD, ANNE v COMMUNITY GENERAL HOSPITAL OF, GREATER SYRACUSE228.2CA 08-02161(2007-1443)
HUNOLD, ANNE v COMMUNITY GENERAL HOSPITAL OF, GREATER SYRACUSE228.1CA 08-01520(2007-1443)
LANDO, TIMOTHY, PEOPLE v539KA 07-02058(I2006-0275-1)
NOLAN, SHANNON v ONONDAGA COUNTY AND ONCENTER,655CA 08-02387(2005-2948)
PLACIDI, JEFFREY JOSEPH v SLEIERTIN, DIANA LYNN353CAF 08-00741(V-02607-04/06A)
PREGO, MICHAEL A. v GUTCHESS, DAVID554CA 08-02289(2007-4900)
SCOTT, HENRY, PEOPLE v393KA 07-00913(S06-101606)
SCOTT, HENRY, PEOPLE v392KA 07-00821(I2006-1216-1)
WHITE, JEREMY, PEOPLE v562KA 06-03119(I2005-0399-2)
WILLIAMS, BILLY G., PEOPLE v538KA 06-02148(I2005-0639-1, 2005-0640-
 
Ontario
BALLMAN, DANIEL J., PEOPLE v285KA 07-02056(I07-04-044)
BOOTH, RYAN M., PEOPLE v194KA 07-01135(06-07-110)
CHAMBERLAIN, DANIEL v DUNDON, LARISSA504CA 08-01606(98015/06)
CHAMBERLAIN, DANIEL v DUNDON, LARISSA505CA 08-01607(98015/06)
CHAMBERLAIN, DANIEL v DUNDON, LARISSA503CA 08-01604(98015/06)
M., JOSH, MTR. OF448CAF 08-00264(B-01031-07)
MORRICE, KEVIN R., PEOPLE v543KA 08-02419(I07-04-070)
PEPSON, JASON A., PEOPLE v565KA 07-01850(I06-10-149)
SLATER, TERRENCE, PEOPLE v9KA 07-01853(I07-01-027)
WARREN, JOHN J. v ELLIS, III, LAWRENCE R.406CA 08-02057(97072)
 
Orleans
S., LEAH, ORLEANS COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL, SERVICES v569CAF 08-00426(NA-496-07, NA-497-07)
WILSON, PATRICIA v STATE OF NEW YORK,453CA 07-02464(111995)
 
Oswego
FORTINO, JR., ANTHONY P., PEOPLE v585KA 07-02579(I06C-0186)
KORTHAS, JAMES v U.S. FOODSERVICE, INC. DOING BUSINE,578CA 08-02435(2003-1619)
 
Seneca
LOZADA, THOMAS v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF PAROLE,552TP 08-02335(41699)
WAID, CHARLES W. v LEMPKE, JOHN540KAH 08-00868(40789)
 
Steuben
GAUSS, DENNIS R. v GAUSS, JENNIFER L.531CAF 08-01062(V-01643/07/07A,)
HALL, LAKILA, PEOPLE v515KA 08-00359(I2006-333)
HALL, LAKILA, PEOPLE v516KA 08-00360(I2006-334)
PUTNAM, DENNIS v COUNTY OF STEUBEN,456CA 08-00708(93164)
PUTNAM, DENNIS v COUNTY OF STEUBEN,457CA 08-00709(93164)
 
Wayne
BUSINESS LOAN CENTER, INC., v WAGNER, GREG D.611CA 08-00913(48340)
STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN RIGHTS, v VOLLERTSEN, JAMES550TP 08-02412(61494)
W., BRANDON H., MTR. OF570CAF 08-02418(D-625-08)
 
Wyoming
LM PROPERTY AND CASUALTY COMPANY, v EVANS, DOUGLAS L.592CA 08-01325(37516)
RING, III, JOHN H. v BUSH, JEFFREY454CA 08-01394(38245)
RING, III, JOHN H. v BUSH, JEFFREY455CA 08-01395(38245)
    
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS