Welcome
Home
THE COURT
    Overview of the Appellate Division
    Justices of the Court
    The Courthouse
DECISIONS
    Latest Decisions
    Decision Release Dates
    Search
CLERKS OFFICE
    Clerk and Deputy Clerk of the Court
    Contact Information
    Terms of the Court
    Court Calendars
    Rules of Practice
    Frequently Asked Questions
    Forms and Practice Aids
    Latest Court News
    Employment Opportunities
ATTORNEY MATTERS
    Admission to the Bar
    Attorney Discipline
    Attorney Registration Delinquency
    Registration as In-House Counsel
    Retirement
    Voluntary Resignation
PROGRAMS & AUXILIARY AGENCIES
    Assigned Counsel Program
    Attorneys for Children Program
    Attorney Grievance Committees
    Court Examiners
    Indep. Judicial Election Qual. Comm.
    Law Library
    Mental Hygiene Legal Service
    Pro Bono Policy and Program
RELATED LINKS
   Court sites
   Legal sites




Decisions - June 5, 2009

A., CAESAR, FAXTON-ST. LUKE'S HEALTHCARE, v738CA 08-02578(CA08-001846)
A., III, DENNIS K., WYOMING COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL, SERVICES v821CAF 08-00174(B-00722-07, B-00721-07)
A., SARAH, MTR. OF692CAF 08-01830(B-21278-06)
ADAIR, ROBIN v MUNICIPAL UTILITY COMMISSION OF THE,739CA 08-02607(93218)
AFRIKA, NACHE, PEOPLE v682KA 06-01933(I2001-0163)
AIKENS, JUANITA v NELL, KENNETH MARK897CAF 08-01179(F-01472-06)
ALEXANDER, RICHARD, PEOPLE v726KA 07-02423(S07-DI-152)
ANDERSON, JACK, PEOPLE v775KA 07-02013(I2005-0244)
ARNOLD, TONY v BALDWIN REAL ESTATE CORPORATION,781CA 08-02132(2007/01059)
B., BRANDY v EDEN CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,671CA 08-01924(I2003-10908)
B., BRANDY v EDEN CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,663CA 08-01856(I2003-10908)
BANKSTON, MARIO, PEOPLE v774KA 08-00148(I2007-0311&2006-0487)
BARBATO, MARGARET J. v BOWDEN, BRENT D.652CA 08-01996(2007-4731)
BARNES, CATHERINE v FIX, DEAN E.478CA 08-02152(123267)
BARTON, SUSAN, PEOPLE v705KA 08-00484(II07-226)
BENEFICIAL NEW YORK, INC., v HUNTER, JERRY842CA 08-02259(06/08058)
BENTLEY, MICHAEL J., PEOPLE v790KA 07-02425(I2006-585)
BESAW, PAUL, PIERCE, BRUCE v713CA 09-00128(2006-0065PF)
BRADY, SHAWN M. v FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF NEW YORK,, INC.767CA 08-01640(2006 08133)
BREWER, CHRISTOPHER D., PEOPLE v733KA 08-01153(S02-DI-092)
BRITT, CARMEN v BUFFALO MUNICIPAL HOUSING AUTHORITY,696.1CA 08-02508(I 2004-9897)
BRITT, CARMEN v STADELMEYER, JILL696CA 08-02662(I2008-3118)
BROWN, STANLEY A., PEOPLE v859KA 08-01165(277-06)
C., JESSICA, MTR. OF778CAF 09-00242(S-01853-08)
CANSDALE, REGGIE v CONN, POLLY783CA 08-00898(2006-3893)
CAPPS, EVONY, PEOPLE v812KA 08-00581(I2005-2346)
CHAPMAN, DONNA M. v PYRAMID COMPANY OF BUFFALO,787CA 08-01909(I2005-2582)
CHEAL, DAVID, PEOPLE v854KA 07-02196(II07-185)
CIVIL SERVICE EMPLOYEES, ASSOCIATION, INC. v COUNTY OF ERIE,572CA 08-02276(I2007-8672)
CLARKE, DARLTON v CITY OF SYRACUSE,694CA 08-00921(2003-4403)
COHEN, KENNETH S. v COHEN, AMY J.901CA 09-00146(SF1999-901648)
COLEMAN, SHAWN v FISCHER, BRIAN700TP 08-02396(2008-646)
COLEMAN, RAMONA v LORUSSO, JACQUELINE V.766CA 08-02172(I2007/2629)
COLLINS, JR., VINCENT, PEOPLE v756KA 08-00630(I2006-0331)
CONGDON, WILLIAM R. v EVERETT, BRITA M.590CA 08-02297(72569)
COSMO, ROGER A. v TOWN OF EVANS,720CA 08-02114(I2006-5730)
CROMWELL, DENNIS R. v HESS, KENNETH E.872CA 08-02395(I2005-11630)
CUSTOM TOPSOIL, INC., CITY OF BUFFALO, v413CA 08-01639(2007-008048)
CUSTOM TOPSOIL, INC., CITY OF BUFFALO, v411CA 08-01637(I2007 008048)
CUSTOM TOPSOIL, INC., CITY OF BUFFALO, v412CA 08-01638(2007-008048)
DANIELLO, ALLYSON N. v POWELL, JUSTIN J.902CA 09-00106(2006-1839)
DAVISON, EDISON, PEOPLE v584KA 08-00221(I588-05)
DENNIS, DAWN v VANSTEINBURG, ROBERT780CA 09-00018(2006-85293)
DEPEW COLLISION AND FRAME SERVICE,, INC. v GURNEY, BECKER & BOURNE, INC.,849CA 08-01625(I2004-12852)
DESTINY USA DEVELOPMENT, LLC, v NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF, ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATIO647CA 08-01855(08-1015)
DICIENZO, DINO v NIAGARA FALLS URBAN RENEWAL AGENCY,898CA 08-02087(122547)
DICIENZO, DINO v NIAGARA FALLS URBAN RENEWAL AGENCY,899CA 08-02164(122547)
DUNN, JAMES J. v KADIEN, GREGORY J.749TP 09-00067(I-2008-10134)
DURAND, ADAM, PEOPLE v559KA 06-01796(I05-99)
E., ANTHONY, MTR. OF691CAF 08-00551(B-01960-06, B-01961-06)
E., JR., GIOVANNI, MTR. OF862CAF 07-02301(NN-00100-07)
F., JALEEL, MTR. OF588CAF 08-00925(B-17588-06, B-17579-06,)
F., KAIDEN F., MTR. OF838CAF 08-01559(NN-00941-07, NN-00942-07
F., THOMAS M. v A., LORI A.916CAF 08-01777(V-10448-10449-07C)
FARNSWORTH, ALEXANDER, PEOPLE v855KA 08-01213(I08-36)
FIELDS, FUQUAN, PEOPLE v793KA 07-01152(I2005-1979D)
FIELDS, FUQUAN, PEOPLE v794KA 07-01153(I06-1244)
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH OF OLEAN, v GREY, JOHN S.435CA 08-01418(73662)
FOSTER, ANTHONY v DEALMAKER, SLS, LLC,826CA 08-01601(07-2638)
FOULK, DIANE M. v CARRION, GLADYS800TP 09-00093(101121)
FRANCIS, ROCKEL BYRON, PEOPLE v836KA 05-02382(I707/2004)
FRANCISCO, JOSE, PEOPLE v619KA 07-02191(I06-10-159)
FRANCISCO WALTERS, DAWN R. v FRANCISCO, REX R.758CAF 08-00589(V-00146-00/07AB)
FRAZIER, DEMONE R., PEOPLE v814KA 07-02526(I2006-0977)
G., QUANEESHA S., ONEIDA COUNTY ATTORNEY, v839CAF 08-01954(D-03672-05/08E)
GALLAGHER, KATHLEEN v CORASANTI, JAMES693CA 08-01874(06/3802)
GDANIEC, DEBORAH v CORIGLIANO, JOSEPH598.1CA 08-01661(I-2005-1432)
GILPATRICK, TIMOTHY, PEOPLE v820KA 08-00466(I2005-1784)
GONZALEZ, JOSE L., PEOPLE v753KA 06-02570(I0175/05)
GRANDIN, DEVON, PEOPLE v732KA 08-01030(S2007-590A)
GRASSO, DONALD v TOWN OF WEST SENECA,803CA 07-02277(I2007-7685)
GRASSO, DONALD v TOWN OF WEST SENECA,804CA 07-02278(I2007-7685)
H., TONJALEAH, MTR. OF759CAF 08-01044(B-01651-07)
HALL, NELSON, PEOPLE v873KA 06-03241(I2005-1269-1)
HALLQUIST, AMY J. v CHAUTAUQUA COUNTY,637CA 08-02298(K1-2004-1238)
HARRINGTON, AMANDA L. v HARRINGTON, II, JOHN D.779CAF 08-01634(O-02029-07, V-2027-07,)
HARRIS, FRANK v GRAHAM, HAROLD688KAH 08-00147(2007-0720)
HARRIS, III, WILLIAM D., PEOPLE v874KA 08-00383(I2007-2110)
HASKELL, TIFFANY J., PEOPLE v704KA 07-02169(I06-044)
HASKELL, TIFFANY J., PEOPLE v703KA 07-01904(S06-045)
HAYEK, CHERYL A. v HAYEK, GEORGE M.712CA 08-02512(SF 1966-901385)
HBE CORPORATION, v SIRIUS AMERICA INSURANCE COMPANY,409CA 08-01227(123024)
HERNANDEZ, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v773KA 08-00243(S27393)
HILL, JAMES v FISCHER, BRIAN748TP 08-02625(20629-08)
HOGAN, MICHAEL v TRITSCH, GEORGE829CA 09-00140(I 2006-1208)
HOLLY, LARRY C. v COUNTY OF CHAUTAUQUA,630CA 08-02453(I 2006-1090)
HOLMES, WOODROW, PEOPLE v856KA 08-01500(I2007-1338-1)
INNOVATIVE TRANSMISSION & ENGINE, COMPANY, LLC v MASSARO, JR., RICHARD S.408CA 08-01175(I2001-4809)
J., III, CHRISTOPHER, MTR. OF895CAF 08-01304(B-619-621-06/07B)
JOHNS, LESTER A. v LESTER JOHNS, INC.,918CA 08-00552(51334)
JOHNS, LESTER A. v LESTER JOHNS, INC.,917CA 08-00059(51334)
JOHNSON, JABAD, PEOPLE v833KA 06-01050(I2005-130)
JOHNSON, SHAUN, PEOPLE v681KA 08-00837(S25969)
JOHNSTON, CAROL R. v JOHNSTON, DANIEL S.626CA 08-02452(SF2005-0902877)
JONES, ROY v PETTIES-JONES, RENE764CA 08-01995(SF2005-901293)
JONES, TERRENCE X., PEOPLE v659KA 07-01788(I2005-570)
JONES, SHANNON, PEOPLE v835KA 08-00675(I07-97)
JOSEPH, III, RAYMOND E., PEOPLE v883KA 07-02578(I5017)
JOSEPH, III, RAYMOND E., PEOPLE v882KA 07-02063(I5017)
KALENDA, CHERYL v MAR-WAL CONSTRUCTION CO., INC.,847CA 08-02391(I-2006-3992)
KENNELTY, DENIS J. v KENNELTY, KATHLEEN W.719CA 09-00099(2004-040906)
LANOS, JERMAINE E., PEOPLE v791KA 06-02303(I2005-0476)
LATSON, BRANDON, PEOPLE v830KA 07-00613(I04-1148)
LAURIA, CYNTHIA M. v DOWNEY-GOODLEIN ELEVATOR CORP.,631CA 08-02477(829/01)
LEOPOLD, LEONARD A., PEOPLE v811KA 08-01192(I2008-APP-046)
LOCKPORT SMART GROWTH, INC., v TOWN OF LOCKPORT,612CA 08-01913(132001)
LOMACK, WILLIAM T., PEOPLE v880KA 07-01966(I2004-0415)
LOVALL, JOANNE v GRAVES BROS., INC.,556CA 07-01515(05/10912)
LOVALL, JOANNE v GRAVES BROS., INC.,555CA 07-00219(05-10912)
M., TASHA, MTR. OF799CAF 08-00980(NN-15353-06)
MACDONALD, SCOTT, PEOPLE v519KA 06-03542(I2006-0079-1)
MARGERUM, EUGENE v CITY OF BUFFALO,651CA 07-02219(I2007/1462)
MASTOWSKI, DEXTER, PEOPLE v686KA 07-02640(I02-10-210)
MAYER'S CIDER MILL, INC., v PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY,526CA 08-01969(2007-016010)
MCCLAM, JOSEPH G., PEOPLE v684KA 08-00335(I02-01-056)
MCCOOEY, JOSEPH R. v ALENIKOV, GAIL L.885CAF 08-01157(V-00457-98/07V,)
MCCOOEY, JOSEPH R. v ALENIKOV, GAIL L.886CAF 08-01158(V-00459-98/07AC)
MILLER, WALTER, PEOPLE v706KA 07-02657(I2187-2006)
MITCHELL, ERVIN v UNGER, DAVID689KAH 07-02238(07-33390)
MOAR, COLIN, PEOPLE v701KA 08-00129(S23259)
MONTGOMERY, THOMAS, PEOPLE v816KA 07-02566(I2006-2885)
MOORER, ROBERT C., PEOPLE v687KA 06-02494(I2004-1089)
MOTZER, MICHAEL C., PEOPLE v788KA 07-01525(I03-19)
MURPHY, MAUREEN M. v WOODS, JOHN B.545CAF 08-02503(V-02508-07/07A)
MYERS, STEPHEN L., PEOPLE v831KA 07-01041(I06-237)
MYERS, STEPHEN L., PEOPLE v832KA 07-01042(I06-239)
NWORA, ALEXANDER I. v CITY OF BUFFALO,894CA 09-00036(2005-10116)
OWENS, CHERYL B. v GARNER, WADE K.673CAF 08-00088(V-06983-03/07K, V-06984-
P., RONNIE, MTR. OF547CAF 07-02245(B-00111-06)
PAIGE, SAMUEL, PEOPLE v751KA 08-00153(I2007-0465)
PATTISON, GREGORY R., PEOPLE v724KA 06-01419(I03-052)
PAUL, MARK v LECLAIRE, LUCIEN680TP 08-02557(CA2007-000959)
PERRY, JR., MAURICE v KORMAN, JAMIE L.636CAF 08-01583(V-10191-00/07F)
PETERS, BRIAN v THE KISSLING INTERESTS, INC.,498CA 08-01936(I2006-1495)
PINA, NAOTA M. v PRUYN, PATRICIA J.822CA 09-00234(I 2006-5710)
POLLARD, PENINA v POLLARD, RAHEEM798CAF 08-01324(V-1866-06/08E,)
POPE, MARY v NEW YORK STATE OFFICE OF CHILD FAM,771TP 09-00065(2008-002239)
PRINDLE, MICHAEL EDWARD, PEOPLE v709KA 06-01061(I236-05)
R., AKURA, MTR. OF837CAF 08-01167(NN-05368-05/08A)
R., BRENDA v D., RONALD795CAF 08-01400(F2822-01 (P-1102-00))
R., JONATHAN, PEOPLE v813KA 08-01186(I2007-1949)
REAGAN, MARK v VILLAGE OF NORTH SYRACUSE,903CA 08-02425(2004-2897)
RENTAS, WILLIAM, PEOPLE v750KA 07-01938(I2006-0579-1)
RIOS, ORLANDO v BEZIO, NORMAN R.768TP 08-01893(CA2008-001623)
ROBINSON, JR., JERRY, PEOPLE v815KA 06-00549(I05/352)
ROGERS, JAMES S., PEOPLE v810KA 08-01025(S2007-050)
ROMANO, MICHAEL C., PEOPLE v752KA 08-00649(I07-04-060)
RUGGIERI, MARLENE M. v BRYAN, SHIRLEY861CAF 08-01152(V-1610-98/07J&K)
SABUNCU, JOHN K. v THANEY & ASSOCIATES CPAS, P.C.,848CA 08-02303(2007/010665)
SANTIAGO, LUIS A., PEOPLE v878KA 08-00836(I2005-335W)
SCARBOROUGH, JR., MICHAEL J. v NAPOLI, KAISER & BERN, LLP,558CA 08-01565(06-609)
SCHROEDER, RANDALL L., PEOPLE v735KA 08-01437(I03-58-03)
SCOTT, JASON L., PEOPLE v729KA 07-02179(I05-07-064)
SEELER, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v708KA 06-02790(I2005-666)
SENECA PIPE & PAVING CO., INC., v CHRISTA CONSTRUCTION CO., INC.,629CA 08-00798(34570)
SENECA PIPE & PAVING CO., INC., v SOUTH SENECA CENTRAL SCHOOL, DISTRICT627CA 08-00795(34140)
SENECA PIPE & PAVING CO., INC., v SOUTH SENECA CENTRAL SCHOOL, DISTRICT628CA 08-00796(34141)
SEYLER, JASON, PEOPLE v702KA 08-00847(I2003-141-V)
SHAPARD, CHRISTOPHER v ZON, ANTHONY891CA 06-03320(I-2005-11695)
SHOAF, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v884KA 07-00142(I589/05)
SIMMONS, OTIS, PEOPLE v736KA 08-01588(05-0848) & (I2005-0725-1)
SINGLETARY, LAVERNE, PEOPLE v875KA 05-01531(I04-00949)
SMITH, BRIAN J. v KOHLI, ROMESH K.808CA 08-02043(I2006/9071)
SMITH, KWAMELL v FISCHER, BRIAN770TP 08-02681(20630-08)
SMITH, DAVID M. v STATE OF NEW YORK,533CA 08-00696(M-73976)
SMITH, DAVID M. v STATE OF NEW YORK,534CA 08-01705(M74847)
SMITH, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v876KA 06-00410(I2005-381)
SMITH, WILLIAM D., PEOPLE v792KA 08-00636(I2006-0783)
SMITH, JUSTIN CHAD, PEOPLE v725KA 08-00020(S03-07)
SPANOS, RONALD v FANTO, MICHAEL R.904CA 08-02604(2006-2262)
STAATS, JOHN W. v WEGMANS FOOD MARKETS, INC.,649CA 08-01944(109262)
STANDARD FIRE INSURANCE COMPANY, v NEW HORIZONS YACHT, HARBOR, INC.596CA 08-02424(56321)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v ZIMMER, RICHARD W.633CA 08-00767(CA2007-002605)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v ZIMMER, RICHARD W.634CA 08-00768(CA2007-002605)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v ZIMMER, RICHARD W.635CA 08-00769(CA2007-002605)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v ZIMMER, RICHARD W.632CA 08-00766(CA2007-002605)
STEWART, CARL, PEOPLE v683KA 08-01879(I02486-1990)
STIVERS, ROBERT v BROWNELL, JEFFREY R.482CA 08-02157(36316)
STURGIS, DAVID, PEOPLE v858KA 06-00408(I2005-356)
SUNDBY, CANDACE v KAY, TERRY R.843CA 08-01816(36677)
TAG MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, INC., v V.I.P. STRUCTURES, INC.,385CA 08-01126(04-2520)
TAYLOR, COTY v REEVES, MARY S.889CA 09-00037(06-1505)
THE NIAGARA VENTURE, v NIAGARA FALLS URBAN RENEWAL AGENCY,900CA 08-02086(124390)
THOMAS, RAND A., PEOPLE v728KA 08-01148(I5036)
TOOLEY, NEAL v FERN R. CORP,740CA 08-01490(2007-382)
TORRES, HYDI v LOCKPORT HOUSING AUTHORITY,906CA 08-01745(126102)
TORRES, HYDI v LOCKPORT HOUSING AUTHORITY,908CA 08-01854(126102)
TORRES, HYDI v LOCKPORT HOUSING AUTHORITY,907CA 08-01853(126102)
TOWN OF GENEVA, v CITY OF GENEVA,597CA 08-02501(100897)
U.S. BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION, v PATTERSON, TRACY598CA 08-01899(I200611961)
VILLAGE OF ILION, v COUNTY OF HERKIMER,608CA 08-01700(83207)
VILLAGE OF ILION, v COUNTY OF HERKIMER,609CA 08-02120(83207)
VILLAGE OF WARSAW, v ALMETER, DAVID782CA 08-02054(28021)
VIVIAN, CHRISTEN v CARRION, GLADYS844TP 09-00216(135112)
W., EMILY, MTR. OF548CAF 07-02246(B-00112-06)
W., EMILY, MTR. OF549CAF 07-02468(B-00111-06, B-00112-06)
W., LA'DERRICK, MTR. OF587CAF 08-00802(B-368-07, B-369-07)
WATKINS, GREGORY ALLAN, PEOPLE v879KA 08-00433(I07-59)
WILDER, DANIEL P., PEOPLE v730KA 08-00901(S2007-132)
WILLIAMS, TRACY L. v JOHNSON, MARTIN887CA 09-00226(2008-017379)
WILLIAMS, DANIEL v FISCHER, BRIAN772TP 08-02626(20668-08)
WOOD, IBN J., PEOPLE v727KA 04-02864(I2003-0358)
WOODARD, JAMES C., PEOPLE v877KA 08-00333(I04-07-068)
YOUNG, CHRISTOPHER v MONROE COUNTY CLERKS OFFICE,825CA 08-01255(2006-10290)
ZULAWSKI, JR., PAUL THOMAS v TAYLOR, RICHARD614CA 08-01829(I2004-12400)
ZULAWSKI, JR., PAUL THOMAS v TAYLOR, RICHARD615CA 08-01929(I2004-12400)
    
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS