Welcome
Home
THE COURT
    Overview of the Appellate Division
    Justices of the Court
    The Courthouse
DECISIONS
    Latest Decisions
    Decision Release Dates
    Search
CLERKS OFFICE
    Clerk and Deputy Clerk of the Court
    Contact Information
    Terms of the Court
    Court Calendars
    Rules of Practice
    Frequently Asked Questions
    Forms and Practice Aids
    Latest Court News
    Employment Opportunities
ATTORNEY MATTERS
    Admission to the Bar
    Attorney Discipline
    Attorney Registration Delinquency
    Registration as In-House Counsel
    Retirement
    Voluntary Resignation
PROGRAMS & AUXILIARY AGENCIES
    Assigned Counsel Program
    Attorneys for Children Program
    Attorney Grievance Committees
    Court Examiners
    Indep. Judicial Election Qual. Comm.
    Law Library
    Mental Hygiene Legal Service
    Pro Bono Policy and Program
RELATED LINKS
   Court sites
   Legal sites




Decisions - October 2, 2009

 
Allegany
STATE OF NEW YORK, MTR. OF1043.1CA 09-01213(35314)
 
Cattaraugus
AUSTIN, SANDRA A. v TRI-COUNTY MEMORIAL HOSPITAL,1017CA 09-00343(67478)
BEAN, TERRY L., PEOPLE v1052KA 08-00344(I06-245)
THOMPSON, MARK, PEOPLE v1164KA 08-01254(S04-059)
 
Cayuga
BARSKI, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v1045KA 09-00325(2006-134)
GLANVILLE, PATRICIA v CAYUGA COUNTY BOARD OF HEALTH,1059TP 08-01804(2007-1483)
GORDON, JOHN v GRAHAM, HAROLD1210TP 09-00560(2008-0326)
HINTON, JR., ROBERT C. v GRAHAM, HAROLD1073KAH 07-01507(2007-0160)
HINTON, JR., ROBERT C. v GRAHAM, HAROLD1074KAH 07-01800(2007-0160)
SWIFT, SAMMY, PEOPLE v1136.1KA 08-02244(I94-91)
THE BALK FAMILY TRUST, v SCHMIDT, JOHN1103CA 09-00338(06-921)
VENTURA, RAMON v FISCHER, BRIAN976TP 09-00344(2008-1199)
 
Chautauqua
BIRT, BARBARA v RATKA, JR., DAVID R.1019CA 09-00484(K1-2005-1590)
GIZOWSKI, STANLEY A. v STATE OF NEW YORK,998CA 08-01910(112634)
VERLENI, THOMAS v CITY OF JAMESTOWN,1015CA 09-00252(K1-2007-1330)
 
Erie
AHMED, ABDUL v JACK G. SMITH CORP.,1179CA 09-00458(I2007-11812)
ARCELORMITTAL LACKAWANNA LLC, v CITY OF LACKAWANNA,1021CA 08-01826(2008-3196)
BELL, FREDERICK, PEOPLE v1162KA 08-00620(I2006-2674)
BOCCIO, DIANA M. v CITY OF BUFFALO,1180CA 09-00571(2005-4732)
BRYNDLE, DANEIL C. v SAFETY-KLEEN SYSTEMS, INC.,1067CA 08-02170(I2003-9689)
BRYNDLE, DANIEL v SAFETY-KLEEN SYSTEMS, INC.,1066CA 08-01735(I20039689)
COBLE, JAMES, PEOPLE v1146KA 08-01693(I2007-1446)
COOGAN, RICHARD E. v D'ANGELO, DANIEL A.1176CA 09-00210(I2006-6495)
CZORA, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v1076KA 07-02645(I00481-2006)
DALE, DAVID v GENTRY, WALETTA1183CA 09-00697(2007-12258)
DIETZ, JAMES, PEOPLE v1070KA 08-00641(I2006-2377)
DOLE FOOD COMPANY, INC., v LINCOLN GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY,1224CA 08-02075(I-2008-003019)
EATMON, KEVIN, PEOPLE v1160KA 06-03281(I2005-0129-S01)
EXUM, JAMAR, PEOPLE v982KA 07-01846(I2005-1829)
GENTILE, JOSEPH v GENTILE, CAROL988CA 08-02032(1991-7679)
GENTILE, JOSEPH v GENTILE, CAROL987CA 08-00195(1991-7679)
HECKL, ROSANNA E. v C., AIDA994CA 08-02653(SF2006-902242)
JACKSON, KENNETH, PEOPLE v1095KA 08-01557(I2007-2625)
KLOSIN, PHILIP v BERBARY, JAMES L.1117KAH 08-01156(I-2008-2433)
KOBZA, JAMES, PEOPLE v1053KA 07-02433(I02464-2006)
KREINHEDER, JACQUELYN v WITHIAM-LEITCH, M.D., MATTHEW1207.1CA 09-00970(05/6423)
L., SHANIA, MTR. OF1207.2CAF 09-00241(B-01363-67-08)
LAING, DARIEN, PEOPLE v1007KA 08-00130(I2007-0089)
LEAGUE FOR THE HANDICAPPED, INC., v SPRINGVILLE GRIFFITH INSTITUTE CENT,1068CA 09-00676(2008-12790)
LEGACY DEVELOPMENT, v LIBERATORE, VICTOR1082CA 09-00610(2007-010175)
MANTIONE, ANGELO, BONITO, EVELYN v1181CA 08-02616(2004-2161)
MCCRAY, DEMETRIUS, PEOPLE v984KA 07-02438(I2006-0711)
MEEGAN, JR., ROBERT P. v BROWN, BYRON W.1133CA 09-00433(2008-1249)
MELENDEZ, MICHAEL v BERBARY, JAMES1069TP 09-00361(2008-13492)
MUHAMMAD, SHAHID, PEOPLE v979KA 04-02915(I02-2442)
NEWSOME, JR., PATRICK, PEOPLE v1010KA 08-00844(I2006-2919)
PADILLA, BARBARA v VERCZKY-PORTER, M.D., KINGA M.1203CA 09-00576(I2003-11883)
PALMER, PARRIS H. v HORTON, PORTIA L.1126CA 09-00446(2006/647)
PELLAM, DAWN M. v DOUGHTY, TIMOTHY1084CA 09-00336(2006-5236)
PELUSO, ANTHONY v ERIE COUNTY INDEPENDENCE PARTY,970CAE 09-01640(2009-69)
PEOPLES, PEOPLE v1100KA 08-00152(I2007-0209)
PRESCOTT, TYRONE, PEOPLE v1009KA 05-01142(I2004-0711)
RANNE, JOHN v HUFF, NELSON1200CA 09-00413(7928-96)
RAY, ROBERT J. v NATIONAL HOCKEY LEAGUE PLAYERS',1020CA 09-00648(I2008-0596)
REFERMAT, SEAN, PEOPLE v1211KA 08-01556(S29239)
SCHEFF, SUSAN v TAUB, JEFFREY1207CA 09-00372(V-180-06)
SCHLAU, JEFFREY, PEOPLE v1161KA 08-00887(I2006-2230)
SHERIDAN CAR WASH, INC., v MOUNTAIN VALLEY INDEMNITY COMPANY,1136CA 09-00301(3065/05) & (4339/05)
SUNSHINE IMAGING ASSOCIATION/WNY, v GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES INSURANCE CO,1101CA 09-00474(2006-7421)
SUPHANKOMUT, TIMOTHY v YU, M.D., CHI-TEH1016CA 08-02328(2005/5753)
THOMPSON, JUSTINE v COOPER, MICHAEL1079CA 08-01469(2007/4973)
THOMPSON, JUSTINE v COOPER, MICHAEL1080CA 08-01470(2007-4973)
TOWN OF EVANS, MTR. OF1085CA 09-00488(2008-8712)
VELASQUEZ, JIMMY, PEOPLE v1170KA 07-02596(I2006-0650)
WESTERN NEW YORK LAND, CONSERVANCY, INC. v CULLEN, JOHN S.1173CA 08-02034(I2007-496)
WESTERN NEW YORK LAND CONSERVANCY, CULLENWOOD FARMS, LLC, v1174CA 09-00070(2006-5184)
WRIGHT, DAVID, PEOPLE v1002KA 08-01300(I2007-2343)
 
Genesee
ARMSTRONG, SR., JASON A. v ROBINSON, HEATHER L.1021.1CAF 08-01323(V-00197-07/07A)
CANZONERI, JOSEPH R. v CANZONERI, GINA1013CAF 09-00356(F-00427-07)
CRANDALL, STEVEN, PEOPLE v1163KA 07-02074(I4985)
CRUZ-HERNANDEZ, FABIAN, PEOPLE v1003KA 08-01185(I5052)
 
Herkimer
VIVYAN, KEVIN J. v ILION CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,1055CA 08-02587(00086312)
VOGEL, HARRY, PEOPLE v1026KA 07-01778(I06-75)
 
Jefferson
M., SETH, MTR. OF1150CAF 08-01247(B-01640-07, B-01641-07)
MASSEY, TAKIYAH S. v EVANS, DAVID A.1034CAF 09-00537(U-02409/06)
 
Lewis
KANSAS STATE BANK OF MANHATTAN, v HARRISVILLE VOLUNTEER FIRE DEPT,1089CA 09-00250(2006-00249)
 
Livingston
WITHERSPOON, DAVID, PEOPLE v1167KA 06-03422(I2005-076)
WITHERSPOON, DAVID, PEOPLE v1166KA 06-03421(I2004-254)
 
Monroe
ALLEN, BRANDON J., PEOPLE v1123KA 07-01409(S2006-3602)
ANDERSON, PATRICK, PEOPLE v1121KA 07-02527(S2006-3298)
BANKS, SHYTRECE T., PEOPLE v1192KA 09-00417(0677/2007)
BARKLEY, JAMES D., PEOPLE v1122KA 05-02293(I0153/05)
BELL, DENNIS, PEOPLE v1193KA 07-01226(I2005-0454)
BRINK, ALLEN v ANTHONY J. COSTELLO & SON,1158CA 09-00515(8338-04)
BRUMFIELD, JAMIE E. v AMERICAN TRANSIT INSURANCE COMPANY,1063CA 09-00342(2008-6343)
BUCKMAN, DANA, PEOPLE v1072KA 06-00789(I551/05)
BUSH, ROBERT EARL, PEOPLE v1212KA 06-01634(I2005-0336)
C., SHAKIRRAH, MTR. OF1219CAF 08-01792(D-400-08)
CLARK, TONY J., PEOPLE v1094KA 05-02810(I2004-0698)
CLARK, WILLIE, PEOPLE v1023KA 07-01908(99/05550) & (I99-0277)
CLARK, JR., PRINCE R., PEOPLE v1214KA 06-00788(I2005/0618B)
CNP MECHANICAL, INC., v ALLIED BUILDERS, INC.,986CA 09-00255(07-8310)
CNP MECHANICAL, INC., v ALLIED BUILDERS, INC.,985CA 09-00254(07-8310)
CUBERO, JR., ARIEL, PEOPLE v1213KA 06-01296(I2005-0327)
DAVIS, ERIC, PEOPLE v1120KA 06-01931(I2005-0628)
DEROSIA, BOBBI LYNN v GASBARRE & SZATKOWSKI ASSOCIATION,1106CA 09-00057(2006-1498)
DICKERSON, JONATHON, PEOPLE v1029KA 06-01628(I2005-0634)
F., ISAAC L. T., MTR. OF1196CAF 08-01679(B-06203/06/07A,)
H., SHARDE, MTR. OF1197CAF 09-00391(D-6626-08)
HILL, DAVID, PEOPLE v1209KA 06-01052(I2005-745)
HILL, HADJI, PEOPLE v1185KA 06-01291(I2005-0900)
HILL, ROBERT, PEOPLE v1191KA 06-02483(I2005-0885)
JONES, ISAAC, PEOPLE v1139KA 06-01411(I2005-190)
JONES, JR., HORACE, PEOPLE v1190KA 07-00799(I2004-1078)
L., DOMINICK, MTR. OF1216CAF 08-00047(D-9196-07)
LAZCANO, RAUL, PEOPLE v1188KA 06-00669(I2005-478)
LIBOLT, KEITH v TOWN OF IRONDEQUOIT ZONING BOARD OF,1060CA 09-00279(2008-1890)
LOGAN, VERNAL, PEOPLE v1189KA 06-02130(I2005/576)
M., HOWARD, MTR. OF1032CAF 08-02082(D-14579-07)
M., EMMERAN T., MTR. OF1215CAF 08-00735(B-08895-05)
MAIS, CARL v AJC ASSOCIATES, LP,1000.1CA 08-01937(06-11194)
MORRISON, ALTON L., PEOPLE v1186KA 06-01725(I2005-0540)
NELSON, MALIKA F. v SANTINI, MICHAEL J.1202CA 09-00617(1606-07)
NELSON, PHILLIP, PEOPLE v1119KA 06-02143(I0938/05)
NORMAN, KEITH, PEOPLE v1187KA 07-01027(I2005/600)
OWENS, KEYVIO, PEOPLE v1116KA 06-00966(I2005/0541)
PARKS, JR., KEVIN JEROME, PEOPLE v1118KA 05-00992(I2004-86)
RICHARDSON, MORRIS E. v BRYANT, THOMAS G.1090CA 09-00273(2006-15724)
ROCHESTER POLICE LOCUST CLUB, INC., MTR. OF1108CA 09-00547(5404/08)
SIPLIN, EBONY, PEOPLE v1096KA 06-03040(I113/06)
SMITH, SENNA, PEOPLE v1099KA 06-00967(I2005/895)
TOMPKINS, AARON A., PEOPLE v1030KA 04-00299(I03-00109)
URBANSKI, ADAM v CITY OF ROCHESTER,1091CA 09-00513(2007-13742)
WALKER, JAMES, PEOPLE v978KA 06-02486(I811/05)
WEST FLATT ASSOCIATES, v MAGGIULLI, CHRISTOPHER A.1157CA 09-00623(07-6780)
WHITE, CALVIN, PEOPLE v1047KA 06-00402(I2005-0278B)
WHITE, CALVIN, PEOPLE v1048KA 06-00403(I2005-0235B)
WHITE, CALVIN, PEOPLE v1046KA 06-00401(I2004-1145B)
WOFFORD, MAWAHI, PEOPLE v1078KA 07-00938(I947/05)
ZEINER, GERALD, PEOPLE v983KA 06-01625(I2005-0637)
 
Niagara
CARMER, LAURIE v ODD FELLOWS,1131CA 09-00553(130735/07)
DEURO-NAUGHTON, DEBORAH A. v STATE OF NEW YORK,1061CA 08-00963(CLAIM NO. 111334)
NIAGARA COUNTY PROBATION, DEPARTMENT v FERRO, DENISE1011CAF 07-01360(F-00566-04/06E)
SHARAKY, ALY v REID PETROLEUM CORP.,1112CA 09-00427(130964)
STASKIEWICZ, HELEN T., HYATT, JENNIFER v1132CA 08-01483(76663)
WALKER, JR., CHRISTOPHER T., PEOPLE v1169KA 09-00428(S2007-231)
WALKER, JR., CHRISTOPHER T., PEOPLE v1168KA 09-00249(2007-027)
 
Oneida
B., ALANDREA, MTR. OF1033CAF 08-00904(NA-05173-05)
BERRY, ARTHUR v MCCLUSKY LAW FIRM, LLC,1036CA 09-00551(ca 2007-1405)
DELLERBA, JOSEPH v MORGAN, CYNTHIA1206CA 08-02597(2006-002141)
HALL, DAVID v MADISON-ONEIDA COUNTY BOARD OF COOP,1130CA 09-00586(CA2008-442)
HALL, DAVID v MADISON-ONEIDA COUNTY BOARD OF COOP,1129CA 09-00578(CA2008-442)
LAPE, PAMELA J. v LAPE, DANIEL E.1081CA 08-02667(D2006-042335)
MERCER, CLEOTIS, PEOPLE v1027KA 05-01293(I04-168)
MOHAWK VALLEY ORTHOPEDICS, LLP, v CARCONE, ANDREA M.1000TP 09-00620(CA2008-3571)
NANCY ROSE STORMER, P.C., v COUNTY OF ONEIDA,1154CA 09-00431(CA2006-001171)
SAVAGE, MARTIN N. v COTA, JULIANNE1218CAF 08-00404(V-01856-07/07A)
SULLIVAN, MATTHEW T., GATEHOUSE MEDIA NEW YORK HOLDINGS,, v1228.3CA 09-01556(2009-146)
TABRIZI, M.D., FIROOZ N. v FAXTON-ST. LUKE'S HEALTH CARE,1102CA 08-02627(CA2008-1052)
THAYER, WILLIAM C. v BROOKS, SEAN W.1064CA 08-02620(CA2008-000673)
THE CITY OF UTICA URBAN RENEWALAGENCY, MTR. OF1228.1CA 09-00687(2008-001368)
WRIGHT, LEON F., PEOPLE v980KA 07-01500(II06-380)
 
Onondaga
BROWN, EDDIE, PEOPLE v1050KA 07-00512(I2006-0434-1)
CHRYSLER, SANDRA MARY v FABIAN, SR., LEONARD A.1147CAF 08-01568(V-05951-05/08I)
DAVIS, TIFFANEY E. v DAVIS, SR., NATHANIEL1148CAF 08-02165(V-2210-08)
DIMARCO, STEPHEN v BOMBARD, PATRICK J.992CA 09-00459(2003-0433)
FITCH, CHRIS v MEAD, BRIAN J.1088CA 09-00331(05-5983)
KEARSE, MAURICE K., PEOPLE v1142KA 08-00841(I2003-0631-7)
KEARSE, RUFUS, PEOPLE v1092KA 08-00842(I2003-0631-11)
MANUFACTURERS AND TRADERS TRUST, COMPANY v FANELLI, JOAN SMALL1043CA 08-02176(04-0026)
MCGEE, AARON v VAN ERDEN, DALE H.1113CA 09-00558(2007-1996)
MUHINA, NOOR, PEOPLE v1068.1KA 09-00453(08-1416) & (I2008-1250-1)
NGUYEN, QUAN, PEOPLE v1025KA 06-02135(I2005-0708-1)
O'., TRACY C. v F., DOUGLAS A.1058CAF 09-00232(P-06996-08)
PELOSE, JOHN v BISHOP GRIMES JR./SR. HIGH SCHOOL,989CA 09-00485(2009-000062)
QUIGG, TERRENCE L. v MURPHY, THOMAS J.1124CA 09-00367(2000-0104)
REESE, ALLAH, PEOPLE v1005KA 08-01027(3-0631-12)
SHAW, BRIAN, PEOPLE v1098KA 06-01907(I2005-0724-1)
STROHMAN, HENRY, PEOPLE v981KA 08-00399(I2003-631-45)
SURF CITY ENTERPRISES OF SYRACUSE,, INC. v VAN WERT, LAURA1128CA 09-00442(2007-0892)
VRIESENDORP, M.D., HUIBERT M. v STATE OF NEW YORK,1037CA 08-02531(109507)
WHITE, III, LEWIS J. v KNAPP, BARBARA J.1014CAF 07-02683(F-25-80)
WILLIAMS, LINWOOD, PEOPLE v1137KA 08-01029(I2003-0631-34)
YOUNG, ERIC, PEOPLE v1145KA 07-00820(I2006-0922-2)
 
Ontario
BARBER, CARL, PEOPLE v1028KA 07-01769(I07-01-005)
DARRISAW, TIMOTHY C., PEOPLE v1115KA 08-01194(I07-07-086)
HALTER, ROBERT C., PEOPLE v1138KA 07-02336(S07-DI-139)
JAROCHA, HENRY J., PEOPLE v1049KA 07-02441(I06-07-106)
RUDAT, PAUL v MARK COLF EXCAVATING CONTRACTING, I,1109CA 08-02053(96084)
SINGLETON, WILLIE, PEOPLE v1143KA 07-02575(I06-10-153)
 
Orleans
CROPSEY, CONRAD F. v COUNTY OF ORLEANS INDUSTRIAL, DEVELOPMENT AGENCY1018CA 08-02426(07-33821)
JACKSON, III, JESSIE B., PEOPLE v1165KA 08-01263(I07-33-2)
POWLESS, JAMES H., PEOPLE v1006KA 08-01751(I00-83)
WELCH, ELBERT v KHAHAIFA, S.1022TP 08-02279(08-35159)
 
Oswego
FORTINO, STEVEN, PEOPLE v1031KA 09-00500(06-C-187)
TODD, KELLY A. v JOHNSON, WAYNE L.1198CAF 08-01243(F-00580-01/07H)
 
Seneca
RIVERA, LUIS v FISCHER, BRIAN977TP 09-00443(42158)
SPENCER, CARTY v WILLIAMS, MELVIN1051KAH 09-00172(40990)
 
Steuben
ADAMS, BILLY, PEOPLE v1008KA 08-00616(53268) & (I2007-161)
HATCH, GLENN D., PEOPLE v1227KA 09-00984(2008-275)
HERRINGTON, JOY L. v AMES, ORLIN L.1012CAF 08-02304(V-03477-03/08E)
HURD, CYNTHIA B. v HURD, MICHAEL O.1223CA 08-01603(98393)
SWEENEY, SONJA v PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY,1039CA 08-02332(93483)
 
Wyoming
BELLES, PAULA v UNITED CHURCH OF WARSAW,1184CA 08-02316(35808)
G., BRAYANNA, MTR. OF1035CAF 08-00721(B-00024-07, B-00033-07,)
HAYNES, TIMMIE L. v ALEXANDER, GEORGE997CA 07-01877(20,474-07)
 
Yates
J., DEJA, MTR. OF1149CAF 08-01477(A-00233-07)
    
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS