AD4 Seal

Supreme Court of the State of New York
APPELLATE DIVISION
Fourth Judicial Department

Decisions - October 2, 2009

 
Allegany
STATE OF NEW YORK, MTR. OF1043.1CA 09-01213(35314)
 
Cattaraugus
AUSTIN, SANDRA A. v TRI-COUNTY MEMORIAL HOSPITAL,1017CA 09-00343(67478)
BEAN, TERRY L., PEOPLE v1052KA 08-00344(I06-245)
THOMPSON, MARK, PEOPLE v1164KA 08-01254(S04-059)
 
Cayuga
BARSKI, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v1045KA 09-00325(2006-134)
GLANVILLE, PATRICIA v CAYUGA COUNTY BOARD OF HEALTH,1059TP 08-01804(2007-1483)
GORDON, JOHN v GRAHAM, HAROLD1210TP 09-00560(2008-0326)
HINTON, JR., ROBERT C. v GRAHAM, HAROLD1073KAH 07-01507(2007-0160)
HINTON, JR., ROBERT C. v GRAHAM, HAROLD1074KAH 07-01800(2007-0160)
SWIFT, SAMMY, PEOPLE v1136.1KA 08-02244(I94-91)
THE BALK FAMILY TRUST, v SCHMIDT, JOHN1103CA 09-00338(06-921)
VENTURA, RAMON v FISCHER, BRIAN976TP 09-00344(2008-1199)
 
Chautauqua
BIRT, BARBARA v RATKA, JR., DAVID R.1019CA 09-00484(K1-2005-1590)
GIZOWSKI, STANLEY A. v STATE OF NEW YORK,998CA 08-01910(112634)
VERLENI, THOMAS v CITY OF JAMESTOWN,1015CA 09-00252(K1-2007-1330)
 
Erie
AHMED, ABDUL v JACK G. SMITH CORP.,1179CA 09-00458(I2007-11812)
ARCELORMITTAL LACKAWANNA LLC, v CITY OF LACKAWANNA,1021CA 08-01826(2008-3196)
BELL, FREDERICK, PEOPLE v1162KA 08-00620(I2006-2674)
BOCCIO, DIANA M. v CITY OF BUFFALO,1180CA 09-00571(2005-4732)
BRYNDLE, DANEIL C. v SAFETY-KLEEN SYSTEMS, INC.,1067CA 08-02170(I2003-9689)
BRYNDLE, DANIEL v SAFETY-KLEEN SYSTEMS, INC.,1066CA 08-01735(I20039689)
COBLE, JAMES, PEOPLE v1146KA 08-01693(I2007-1446)
COOGAN, RICHARD E. v D'ANGELO, DANIEL A.1176CA 09-00210(I2006-6495)
CZORA, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v1076KA 07-02645(I00481-2006)
DALE, DAVID v GENTRY, WALETTA1183CA 09-00697(2007-12258)
DIETZ, JAMES, PEOPLE v1070KA 08-00641(I2006-2377)
DOLE FOOD COMPANY, INC., v LINCOLN GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY,1224CA 08-02075(I-2008-003019)
EATMON, KEVIN, PEOPLE v1160KA 06-03281(I2005-0129-S01)
EXUM, JAMAR, PEOPLE v982KA 07-01846(I2005-1829)
GENTILE, JOSEPH v GENTILE, CAROL988CA 08-02032(1991-7679)
GENTILE, JOSEPH v GENTILE, CAROL987CA 08-00195(1991-7679)
HECKL, ROSANNA E. v C., AIDA994CA 08-02653(SF2006-902242)
JACKSON, KENNETH, PEOPLE v1095KA 08-01557(I2007-2625)
KLOSIN, PHILIP v BERBARY, JAMES L.1117KAH 08-01156(I-2008-2433)
KOBZA, JAMES, PEOPLE v1053KA 07-02433(I02464-2006)
KREINHEDER, JACQUELYN v WITHIAM-LEITCH, M.D., MATTHEW1207.1CA 09-00970(05/6423)
L., SHANIA, MTR. OF1207.2CAF 09-00241(B-01363-67-08)
LAING, DARIEN, PEOPLE v1007KA 08-00130(I2007-0089)
LEAGUE FOR THE HANDICAPPED, INC., v SPRINGVILLE GRIFFITH INSTITUTE CENT,1068CA 09-00676(2008-12790)
LEGACY DEVELOPMENT, v LIBERATORE, VICTOR1082CA 09-00610(2007-010175)
MANTIONE, ANGELO, BONITO, EVELYN v1181CA 08-02616(2004-2161)
MCCRAY, DEMETRIUS, PEOPLE v984KA 07-02438(I2006-0711)
MEEGAN, JR., ROBERT P. v BROWN, BYRON W.1133CA 09-00433(2008-1249)
MELENDEZ, MICHAEL v BERBARY, JAMES1069TP 09-00361(2008-13492)
MUHAMMAD, SHAHID, PEOPLE v979KA 04-02915(I02-2442)
NEWSOME, JR., PATRICK, PEOPLE v1010KA 08-00844(I2006-2919)
PADILLA, BARBARA v VERCZKY-PORTER, M.D., KINGA M.1203CA 09-00576(I2003-11883)
PALMER, PARRIS H. v HORTON, PORTIA L.1126CA 09-00446(2006/647)
PELLAM, DAWN M. v DOUGHTY, TIMOTHY1084CA 09-00336(2006-5236)
PELUSO, ANTHONY v ERIE COUNTY INDEPENDENCE PARTY,970CAE 09-01640(2009-69)
PEOPLES, PEOPLE v1100KA 08-00152(I2007-0209)
PRESCOTT, TYRONE, PEOPLE v1009KA 05-01142(I2004-0711)
RANNE, JOHN v HUFF, NELSON1200CA 09-00413(7928-96)
RAY, ROBERT J. v NATIONAL HOCKEY LEAGUE PLAYERS',1020CA 09-00648(I2008-0596)
REFERMAT, SEAN, PEOPLE v1211KA 08-01556(S29239)
SCHEFF, SUSAN v TAUB, JEFFREY1207CA 09-00372(V-180-06)
SCHLAU, JEFFREY, PEOPLE v1161KA 08-00887(I2006-2230)
SHERIDAN CAR WASH, INC., v MOUNTAIN VALLEY INDEMNITY COMPANY,1136CA 09-00301(3065/05) & (4339/05)
SUNSHINE IMAGING ASSOCIATION/WNY, v GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES INSURANCE CO,1101CA 09-00474(2006-7421)
SUPHANKOMUT, TIMOTHY v YU, M.D., CHI-TEH1016CA 08-02328(2005/5753)
THOMPSON, JUSTINE v COOPER, MICHAEL1079CA 08-01469(2007/4973)
THOMPSON, JUSTINE v COOPER, MICHAEL1080CA 08-01470(2007-4973)
TOWN OF EVANS, MTR. OF1085CA 09-00488(2008-8712)
VELASQUEZ, JIMMY, PEOPLE v1170KA 07-02596(I2006-0650)
WESTERN NEW YORK LAND, CONSERVANCY, INC. v CULLEN, JOHN S.1173CA 08-02034(I2007-496)
WESTERN NEW YORK LAND CONSERVANCY, CULLENWOOD FARMS, LLC, v1174CA 09-00070(2006-5184)
WRIGHT, DAVID, PEOPLE v1002KA 08-01300(I2007-2343)
 
Genesee
ARMSTRONG, SR., JASON A. v ROBINSON, HEATHER L.1021.1CAF 08-01323(V-00197-07/07A)
CANZONERI, JOSEPH R. v CANZONERI, GINA1013CAF 09-00356(F-00427-07)
CRANDALL, STEVEN, PEOPLE v1163KA 07-02074(I4985)
CRUZ-HERNANDEZ, FABIAN, PEOPLE v1003KA 08-01185(I5052)
 
Herkimer
VIVYAN, KEVIN J. v ILION CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,1055CA 08-02587(00086312)
VOGEL, HARRY, PEOPLE v1026KA 07-01778(I06-75)
 
Jefferson
M., SETH, MTR. OF1150CAF 08-01247(B-01640-07, B-01641-07)
MASSEY, TAKIYAH S. v EVANS, DAVID A.1034CAF 09-00537(U-02409/06)
 
Lewis
KANSAS STATE BANK OF MANHATTAN, v HARRISVILLE VOLUNTEER FIRE DEPT,1089CA 09-00250(2006-00249)
 
Livingston
WITHERSPOON, DAVID, PEOPLE v1167KA 06-03422(I2005-076)
WITHERSPOON, DAVID, PEOPLE v1166KA 06-03421(I2004-254)
 
Monroe
ALLEN, BRANDON J., PEOPLE v1123KA 07-01409(S2006-3602)
ANDERSON, PATRICK, PEOPLE v1121KA 07-02527(S2006-3298)
BANKS, SHYTRECE T., PEOPLE v1192KA 09-00417(0677/2007)
BARKLEY, JAMES D., PEOPLE v1122KA 05-02293(I0153/05)
BELL, DENNIS, PEOPLE v1193KA 07-01226(I2005-0454)
BRINK, ALLEN v ANTHONY J. COSTELLO & SON,1158CA 09-00515(8338-04)
BRUMFIELD, JAMIE E. v AMERICAN TRANSIT INSURANCE COMPANY,1063CA 09-00342(2008-6343)
BUCKMAN, DANA, PEOPLE v1072KA 06-00789(I551/05)
BUSH, ROBERT EARL, PEOPLE v1212KA 06-01634(I2005-0336)
C., SHAKIRRAH, MTR. OF1219CAF 08-01792(D-400-08)
CLARK, TONY J., PEOPLE v1094KA 05-02810(I2004-0698)
CLARK, WILLIE, PEOPLE v1023KA 07-01908(99/05550) & (I99-0277)
CLARK, JR., PRINCE R., PEOPLE v1214KA 06-00788(I2005/0618B)
CNP MECHANICAL, INC., v ALLIED BUILDERS, INC.,986CA 09-00255(07-8310)
CNP MECHANICAL, INC., v ALLIED BUILDERS, INC.,985CA 09-00254(07-8310)
CUBERO, JR., ARIEL, PEOPLE v1213KA 06-01296(I2005-0327)
DAVIS, ERIC, PEOPLE v1120KA 06-01931(I2005-0628)
DEROSIA, BOBBI LYNN v GASBARRE & SZATKOWSKI ASSOCIATION,1106CA 09-00057(2006-1498)
DICKERSON, JONATHON, PEOPLE v1029KA 06-01628(I2005-0634)
F., ISAAC L. T., MTR. OF1196CAF 08-01679(B-06203/06/07A,)
H., SHARDE, MTR. OF1197CAF 09-00391(D-6626-08)
HILL, DAVID, PEOPLE v1209KA 06-01052(I2005-745)
HILL, HADJI, PEOPLE v1185KA 06-01291(I2005-0900)
HILL, ROBERT, PEOPLE v1191KA 06-02483(I2005-0885)
JONES, ISAAC, PEOPLE v1139KA 06-01411(I2005-190)
JONES, JR., HORACE, PEOPLE v1190KA 07-00799(I2004-1078)
L., DOMINICK, MTR. OF1216CAF 08-00047(D-9196-07)
LAZCANO, RAUL, PEOPLE v1188KA 06-00669(I2005-478)
LIBOLT, KEITH v TOWN OF IRONDEQUOIT ZONING BOARD OF,1060CA 09-00279(2008-1890)
LOGAN, VERNAL, PEOPLE v1189KA 06-02130(I2005/576)
M., HOWARD, MTR. OF1032CAF 08-02082(D-14579-07)
M., EMMERAN T., MTR. OF1215CAF 08-00735(B-08895-05)
MAIS, CARL v AJC ASSOCIATES, LP,1000.1CA 08-01937(06-11194)
MORRISON, ALTON L., PEOPLE v1186KA 06-01725(I2005-0540)
NELSON, MALIKA F. v SANTINI, MICHAEL J.1202CA 09-00617(1606-07)
NELSON, PHILLIP, PEOPLE v1119KA 06-02143(I0938/05)
NORMAN, KEITH, PEOPLE v1187KA 07-01027(I2005/600)
OWENS, KEYVIO, PEOPLE v1116KA 06-00966(I2005/0541)
PARKS, JR., KEVIN JEROME, PEOPLE v1118KA 05-00992(I2004-86)
RICHARDSON, MORRIS E. v BRYANT, THOMAS G.1090CA 09-00273(2006-15724)
ROCHESTER POLICE LOCUST CLUB, INC., MTR. OF1108CA 09-00547(5404/08)
SIPLIN, EBONY, PEOPLE v1096KA 06-03040(I113/06)
SMITH, SENNA, PEOPLE v1099KA 06-00967(I2005/895)
TOMPKINS, AARON A., PEOPLE v1030KA 04-00299(I03-00109)
URBANSKI, ADAM v CITY OF ROCHESTER,1091CA 09-00513(2007-13742)
WALKER, JAMES, PEOPLE v978KA 06-02486(I811/05)
WEST FLATT ASSOCIATES, v MAGGIULLI, CHRISTOPHER A.1157CA 09-00623(07-6780)
WHITE, CALVIN, PEOPLE v1047KA 06-00402(I2005-0278B)
WHITE, CALVIN, PEOPLE v1048KA 06-00403(I2005-0235B)
WHITE, CALVIN, PEOPLE v1046KA 06-00401(I2004-1145B)
WOFFORD, MAWAHI, PEOPLE v1078KA 07-00938(I947/05)
ZEINER, GERALD, PEOPLE v983KA 06-01625(I2005-0637)
 
Niagara
CARMER, LAURIE v ODD FELLOWS,1131CA 09-00553(130735/07)
DEURO-NAUGHTON, DEBORAH A. v STATE OF NEW YORK,1061CA 08-00963(CLAIM NO. 111334)
NIAGARA COUNTY PROBATION, DEPARTMENT v FERRO, DENISE1011CAF 07-01360(F-00566-04/06E)
SHARAKY, ALY v REID PETROLEUM CORP.,1112CA 09-00427(130964)
STASKIEWICZ, HELEN T., HYATT, JENNIFER v1132CA 08-01483(76663)
WALKER, JR., CHRISTOPHER T., PEOPLE v1169KA 09-00428(S2007-231)
WALKER, JR., CHRISTOPHER T., PEOPLE v1168KA 09-00249(2007-027)
 
Oneida
B., ALANDREA, MTR. OF1033CAF 08-00904(NA-05173-05)
BERRY, ARTHUR v MCCLUSKY LAW FIRM, LLC,1036CA 09-00551(ca 2007-1405)
DELLERBA, JOSEPH v MORGAN, CYNTHIA1206CA 08-02597(2006-002141)
HALL, DAVID v MADISON-ONEIDA COUNTY BOARD OF COOP,1130CA 09-00586(CA2008-442)
HALL, DAVID v MADISON-ONEIDA COUNTY BOARD OF COOP,1129CA 09-00578(CA2008-442)
LAPE, PAMELA J. v LAPE, DANIEL E.1081CA 08-02667(D2006-042335)
MERCER, CLEOTIS, PEOPLE v1027KA 05-01293(I04-168)
MOHAWK VALLEY ORTHOPEDICS, LLP, v CARCONE, ANDREA M.1000TP 09-00620(CA2008-3571)
NANCY ROSE STORMER, P.C., v COUNTY OF ONEIDA,1154CA 09-00431(CA2006-001171)
SAVAGE, MARTIN N. v COTA, JULIANNE1218CAF 08-00404(V-01856-07/07A)
SULLIVAN, MATTHEW T., GATEHOUSE MEDIA NEW YORK HOLDINGS,, v1228.3CA 09-01556(2009-146)
TABRIZI, M.D., FIROOZ N. v FAXTON-ST. LUKE'S HEALTH CARE,1102CA 08-02627(CA2008-1052)
THAYER, WILLIAM C. v BROOKS, SEAN W.1064CA 08-02620(CA2008-000673)
THE CITY OF UTICA URBAN RENEWALAGENCY, MTR. OF1228.1CA 09-00687(2008-001368)
WRIGHT, LEON F., PEOPLE v980KA 07-01500(II06-380)
 
Onondaga
BROWN, EDDIE, PEOPLE v1050KA 07-00512(I2006-0434-1)
CHRYSLER, SANDRA MARY v FABIAN, SR., LEONARD A.1147CAF 08-01568(V-05951-05/08I)
DAVIS, TIFFANEY E. v DAVIS, SR., NATHANIEL1148CAF 08-02165(V-2210-08)
DIMARCO, STEPHEN v BOMBARD, PATRICK J.992CA 09-00459(2003-0433)
FITCH, CHRIS v MEAD, BRIAN J.1088CA 09-00331(05-5983)
KEARSE, MAURICE K., PEOPLE v1142KA 08-00841(I2003-0631-7)
KEARSE, RUFUS, PEOPLE v1092KA 08-00842(I2003-0631-11)
MANUFACTURERS AND TRADERS TRUST, COMPANY v FANELLI, JOAN SMALL1043CA 08-02176(04-0026)
MCGEE, AARON v VAN ERDEN, DALE H.1113CA 09-00558(2007-1996)
MUHINA, NOOR, PEOPLE v1068.1KA 09-00453(08-1416) & (I2008-1250-1)
NGUYEN, QUAN, PEOPLE v1025KA 06-02135(I2005-0708-1)
O'., TRACY C. v F., DOUGLAS A.1058CAF 09-00232(P-06996-08)
PELOSE, JOHN v BISHOP GRIMES JR./SR. HIGH SCHOOL,989CA 09-00485(2009-000062)
QUIGG, TERRENCE L. v MURPHY, THOMAS J.1124CA 09-00367(2000-0104)
REESE, ALLAH, PEOPLE v1005KA 08-01027(3-0631-12)
SHAW, BRIAN, PEOPLE v1098KA 06-01907(I2005-0724-1)
STROHMAN, HENRY, PEOPLE v981KA 08-00399(I2003-631-45)
SURF CITY ENTERPRISES OF SYRACUSE,, INC. v VAN WERT, LAURA1128CA 09-00442(2007-0892)
VRIESENDORP, M.D., HUIBERT M. v STATE OF NEW YORK,1037CA 08-02531(109507)
WHITE, III, LEWIS J. v KNAPP, BARBARA J.1014CAF 07-02683(F-25-80)
WILLIAMS, LINWOOD, PEOPLE v1137KA 08-01029(I2003-0631-34)
YOUNG, ERIC, PEOPLE v1145KA 07-00820(I2006-0922-2)
 
Ontario
BARBER, CARL, PEOPLE v1028KA 07-01769(I07-01-005)
DARRISAW, TIMOTHY C., PEOPLE v1115KA 08-01194(I07-07-086)
HALTER, ROBERT C., PEOPLE v1138KA 07-02336(S07-DI-139)
JAROCHA, HENRY J., PEOPLE v1049KA 07-02441(I06-07-106)
RUDAT, PAUL v MARK COLF EXCAVATING CONTRACTING, I,1109CA 08-02053(96084)
SINGLETON, WILLIE, PEOPLE v1143KA 07-02575(I06-10-153)
 
Orleans
CROPSEY, CONRAD F. v COUNTY OF ORLEANS INDUSTRIAL, DEVELOPMENT AGENCY1018CA 08-02426(07-33821)
JACKSON, III, JESSIE B., PEOPLE v1165KA 08-01263(I07-33-2)
POWLESS, JAMES H., PEOPLE v1006KA 08-01751(I00-83)
WELCH, ELBERT v KHAHAIFA, S.1022TP 08-02279(08-35159)
 
Oswego
FORTINO, STEVEN, PEOPLE v1031KA 09-00500(06-C-187)
TODD, KELLY A. v JOHNSON, WAYNE L.1198CAF 08-01243(F-00580-01/07H)
 
Seneca
RIVERA, LUIS v FISCHER, BRIAN977TP 09-00443(42158)
SPENCER, CARTY v WILLIAMS, MELVIN1051KAH 09-00172(40990)
 
Steuben
ADAMS, BILLY, PEOPLE v1008KA 08-00616(53268) & (I2007-161)
HATCH, GLENN D., PEOPLE v1227KA 09-00984(2008-275)
HERRINGTON, JOY L. v AMES, ORLIN L.1012CAF 08-02304(V-03477-03/08E)
HURD, CYNTHIA B. v HURD, MICHAEL O.1223CA 08-01603(98393)
SWEENEY, SONJA v PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY,1039CA 08-02332(93483)
 
Wyoming
BELLES, PAULA v UNITED CHURCH OF WARSAW,1184CA 08-02316(35808)
G., BRAYANNA, MTR. OF1035CAF 08-00721(B-00024-07, B-00033-07,)
HAYNES, TIMMIE L. v ALEXANDER, GEORGE997CA 07-01877(20,474-07)
 
Yates
J., DEJA, MTR. OF1149CAF 08-01477(A-00233-07)
    
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS