Welcome
Home
THE COURT
    Overview of the Appellate Division
    Justices of the Court
    The Courthouse
DECISIONS
    Latest Decisions
    Decision Release Dates
    Search
CLERKS OFFICE
    Clerk and Deputy Clerk of the Court
    Contact Information
    Terms of the Court
    Court Calendars
    Rules of Practice
    Frequently Asked Questions
    Forms and Practice Aids
    Latest Court News
    Employment Opportunities
ATTORNEY MATTERS
    Admission to the Bar
    Attorney Discipline
    Attorney Registration Delinquency
    Registration as In-House Counsel
    Retirement
    Voluntary Resignation
PROGRAMS & AUXILIARY AGENCIES
    Assigned Counsel Program
    Attorneys for Children Program
    Attorney Grievance Committees
    Court Examiners
    Indep. Judicial Election Qual. Comm.
    Law Library
    Mental Hygiene Legal Service
    Pro Bono Policy and Program
RELATED LINKS
   Court sites
   Legal sites




Decisions - December 30, 2009

 
Allegany
C., ASHLEY L., MTR. OF1549CAF 08-01180(NN-22-24-07, NN-80-82-07
 
Cattaraugus
ERON, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v1472KA 08-01890(I03-191)
KRAFT, SHIRLEY, MTR. OF1558CA 07-02154(2006-32387)
LINN, TAMERA v WILSON, CLIFTON1591CAF 08-01927(V-1203-06/08 D, E & F)
WALSH, JOHN v ASSESSOR OF THE TOWN OF ALLEGANY,1477CA 09-00590(74412/72847)
ZULIANI, ROGER P., PEOPLE v1520KA 08-02221(I07-188)
 
Cayuga
HANNIG, MICHAEL E., PEOPLE v1627KA 08-02187(S2008-093)
HENRY, GENE D., PEOPLE v1605KA 09-00078(S2008-154)
LANGLER, JAMES v COUNTY OF CAYUGA,1601TP 09-01267(08-451)
PREDMORE, JR., RICKY, PEOPLE v1560KA 08-02229(I2008-040A)
ROBINSON, MICHAEL v GRAHAM, HAROLD1474KAH 09-00208(2008-0644)
TOWN OF SENNETT TOWN BOARD, v RYBACH & RIG PROPERTIES, LLC,1673CA 08-01865(2008-1114)
WILKINSON, JESSICA v STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INS.,1653CA 09-00755(2007-01094)
 
Chautauqua
BIGELOW, DANIEL D. v ZIELINSKI, RACHEL L.1555CA 08-02500(K1-2007-286)
BLAIR, BEVERLY A. v KELLY, DONNA S.1662CA 09-01218(K1-2008-746)
C., LASHANTA M. R., MTR. OF1547CAF 08-02475(B-1431-08)
FINCH, JR., FRANCIS G. v RYDER TRUCK RENTAL, INC.,1557CA 09-01224(K1-2007-252)
MORRISON, GREGG W., PEOPLE v1650KA 07-00916(I06-399)
PLP, II LP, v NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRO,1482CA 09-01183(132001)
TESTERMAN, ROBERT C. v ZIELINSKI, RACHEL L.1553CA 08-02423(K1-2007-286)
TESTERMAN, ROBERT C. v ZIELINSKI, RACHEL L.1554CA 08-02498(K1-2006-1334)
TOWN, TODD A. v SIDIYAHYA, NINA C.1497CA 09-00669(K1-2006-568)
TOWN, TODD A. v SIDIYAHYA, NINA C.1498CA 09-00670(K1-2006-568)
 
Erie
ADAMS, GILBERT, PEOPLE v1536KA 08-00655(I2004-2488)
ADNEY, FRANCES v MORTON, III, HERBERT J.1548CAF 08-02189(V2182/V2183/06/08C)
AQUINO, MICHAEL v HIGGINS, MICHAEL1249CA 09-00847(2007-2709)
AURORA MEDICAL GROUP, P.C., v GENEWICK, M.D., TIFFANY1595CA 09-01393(2009-2199)
B.R., JUSTIN, PEOPLE v1490KA 08-01979(S27997)
BERMUDEZ, JASON v BERBARY, JAMES L.1510TP 09-01247(2009-2020)
BORZILLIERI, MICHAEL v JONES, DOUGLAS G.1355CA 08-01317(I2006/5775)
BRODERICK, DAVID S. v TRIVEDI, M.D., JAGDISH M.1550CA 09-01521(116466)
CARUSO, MICHAEL G. v VILLAGE OF KENMORE,1556CA 09-01433(2008/9738)
COLE, AHMIR, PEOPLE v1585KA 07-02429(I2006-0952)
DANIELS, MARK, PEOPLE v1489KA 08-02217(I2007-1327)
DEGEORGE, JOANNE M. v BAUMAN, MATTHEW F.1486CA 09-01351(2007-89)
DUQUIN, ROBERT v CHAMELI, ANDREW1661CA 09-01130(2006-2005)
GINTHER, GEORGE EAGAN v PHOTIADIS, GREGORY P.1500CA 08-02389(2005-6054)
GUSTAFSON, WILLIAM v STANSBERRY, R.P.A., ANDREW J.1398.1CA 09-01543(I2004/566)
GUSTAFSON, WILLIAM v DIPPERT, D.O., PAUL C.1398CA 08-02596(I2004/566)
GUSTAFSON, WILLIAM v DIPPERT, D.O., PAUL C.1397CA 08-02595(I2004/566)
HALLING, CHRISTOPHER v STATE OF NEW YORK,1639CA 08-02035(107751)
HARTLOFF, NORMAN G. v LORIGO, LLC,1310CA 09-01008(I2007-3553)
HARTRICH, DANIEL, PEOPLE v1540KA 09-00840(I2007-0222)
HARTRICH, DANIEL, PEOPLE v1539KA 08-01430(I2007-1469)
HERDZIK, ALAN J. v CHOJNACKI, TOM1104CA 08-02182(2006-2961)
HERDZIK, ALAN J. v LOMMER, SR., JAMES1105CA 08-02183(I2006-2961)
HILL, GREGORY v KAIDEN, GREGORY J.1545KAH 09-00235(2008-6880)
HOME THERAPY EQUIPMENT, INC., v HART, BRENDA LEE1506CA 09-01354(2009-3867)
HUGHES, LAKICIA M. v DAVIS, LIONEL L.1387CAF 08-01244(V-20788-06/07A)
HUNTER, EPHRIAM, PEOPLE v1469KA 08-01886(S28882)
HUNTER, EPHRIAM, PEOPLE v1468KA 08-01887(I2007-0773)
JOHNSON, CLAUDIA S. v JOHNSON, LARRY1440CA 08-02618(SF2006-902415)
JOHNSON, CLAUDIA S. v JOHNSON, LARRY C.1441CA 08-02619(902415/06)
KANE, ROBERTA A. v UTICA FIRST INSURANCE COMPANY,1350CA 09-00306(I2002-7500)
KIRKLAND, WESLEY, PEOPLE v1646KA 08-01038(I2007-0950)
LE, STEPHEN, PEOPLE v1564KA 08-01370(I2007-0935)
LONG, KEITH, MTR. OF1476CA 08-02191(I2005-7708)
M., DEON, MTR. OF1546CAF 08-02154(B-7310-07)
M&T BANK CORPORATION, v GEMSTONE CDO VII, LTD,1552CA 09-01402(2008-7064)
MCCLINTIC, DOUGLAS P. v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,1601.1CA 09-00775(2006-006083)
MONILE, MICHAEL J. v NEW YORK STATE LIQUOR AUTHORITY,1575CA 09-01197(2008-13354)
MULDOWNEY, KELLY M. v ROGOWSKI, JEFFREY J.1698CA 09-01228(I2007-11657)
O'DONNELL, JOHN v FERGUSON, ROBERT1416CA 09-00221(I1999/9634)
PATTON, JONATHON, PEOPLE v1492KA 08-01894(S30016)
PAYNE, BASIL S., PEOPLE v1651KA 08-01366(I2006-2189)
PELC, ROBERT J. v BERG, F. STEVEN1368CA 09-00523(I 2005/3007)
POKORSKI, KENNETH v GANNETT CO., INC.,1619CA 09-00826(08-000995)
POKORSKI, KENNETH v GANNETT CO., INC.,1620CA 09-00956(08-000995)
RADDER, DENNIS v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,1551CA 09-00415(I2005-8536)
READING, BEVERLY J., PEOPLE v1537KA 08-02014(S00632-2008)
ROBINSON, ANDREW v FISCHER, BRIAN1444CA 08-01930(I-2007-12364)
ROSWELL PARK CANCER INSTITUTE CORP, v SODEXO AMERICA, LLC,1501CA 09-01222(TPI-2007/2862)
S., RICHELIS, MTR. OF1228.2CAF 09-00117(B-15013-06)
SAWICKI, MARGARET ANN v SPAICH, TIMOTHY1674CA 09-00843(2005-10457)
SCHIENER, JOHN R. v TOWN OF SARDINIA,1244CA 08-02551(2006-008945)
STABLEY, DAVID L. v CACI-STABLEY, PHYLLIS A.1435CAF 09-00872(F-13659-07/07A)
STORY, THOMAS W., PEOPLE v1542KA 08-02011(I2007-2123)
SYKES, ERIC T., PEOPLE v1541KA 08-02108(I00658-2008)
TAFELSKI, PHILIP v THE BUFFALO CITY CEMETERY, INC.,1654CA 09-01220(I2005-8552)
THE PARK COUNTRY CLUB OF BUFFALO,, INC. v TOWER INSURANCE COMPANY OF, NEW YORK1599CA 09-00808(2007-6450)
VILLAGE OF LANCASTER, v COUNTY OF ERIE,1672CA 09-01360(2008-5304)
 
Genesee
CUNNINGHAM, JONATHAN A., PEOPLE v1648KA 08-02074(IFile No. I08-2008)
GUEVARA, CARLOS, PEOPLE v1544KA 08-00536(I5059)
GUTZMER, CARL A. v SANTINI, MYRIAM L.1691CAF 09-00572(O-00508-08)
KLINE, ROBERTA E., PEOPLE v1581KA 09-00174(S08-24)
SCROGER, LISA A. v SCROGER, JERRY K.1612CAF 09-00313(O-01041-08)
 
Herkimer
DIGEORGIO, MICHAEL, MTR. OF1642CA 09-01127(08-88606)
FIA CARD SERVICES, N.A., MTR. OF1571CA 09-01290(88718/2008)
 
Jefferson
GOSIER, GUY E. v AUBERTINE, SCOTT G.1659CA 08-01932(2008-1823)
SMITH, ANDREA M. v NATALI, SR., JACK B.1593CAF 09-00621(V-01308-06/08 I)
 
Livingston
SZCZESNIAK, STEPHEN v WHITFORD, MARK1457CA 09-00329(497-2005)
 
Monroe
AIR CHARTER TEAM, INC., v CATERING SPECIALISTS LLC,1700CA 09-01553(7775-09)
ARIENO, JOSEPH J. v SWB FUNERAL SERVICES, INC.,1531CA 08-01916(07/07084)
BRAULT, BARBARA A. v SMUGORZEWSKI, DEBORAH K.1692CAF 08-02192(V-12789-04)
CARMICHAEL, ROYAL, PEOPLE v1473KA 06-03284(I550/2005)
CHASE MANHATTAN BANK, v UNIVERSITY OF ROCHESTER,1364CA 09-00836(1956TT00443)
CLARK, JEFFREY W., PEOPLE v1583KA 07-00622(S2001-9077)
COAN, MARY LOUISE v THOMPSON, THOMAS N.1279CAF 08-01933(F-12998-03)
EMERGENCY ENCLOSURES, INC., v NATIONAL FIRE ADJUSTMENT CO., INC.,1333CA 09-00311(08-2041)
EMERGENCY ENCLOSURES, INC., v NATIONAL FIRE ADJUSTMENT CO., INC.,1332CA 09-00309(08-2041)
FILIACI, THOMAS v FILIACI, JERI-LYNN1660CA 08-02613(2006-14326)
GEE, LENO W. v M & T BANK,1679CA 08-01973(2007/11090)
GOFF, GLEN M., PEOPLE v1649KA 09-01289(06/516)
GREEN, DAVID K., PEOPLE v1628KA 05-01294(I359A/2004)
GREEN, STEVEN, PEOPLE v1632KA 07-00129(I0373/06)
GRIFFITH OIL COMPANY, INC., v NATIONAL FIRE INSURANCE, COMPANY OF PITTSBURG, PA996CA 08-02656(01/03787)
GRIFFITH OIL COMPANY, INC., v NATIONAL UNION FIRE INSURANCE CO.,995CA 08-00930(3787/01)
HALLER, THERESA v GACIOCH, M.D., GERALD M.1570CA 08-02612(7653-04)
HALLER, THERESA v GACIOCH, GERALD M.1569CA 08-02127(7653/04)
HAMMONS, JR., THOMAS L., PEOPLE v1652KA 06-00040(I1156/04)
HOUSEHOLD FINANCE REALTY CORPORATIO, v ROBINSON, DAVID W.1505CA 09-01221(2003-13364)
HUTCHERSON, BRYANT v ROCHESTER CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT,1574CA 09-01306(8718/08)
KABIR, YASMIN v COUNTY OF MONROE,1086CA 09-00017(05-11613)
KALEN, CHRISTOPHER M., PEOPLE v1345KA 06-03244(I2005-818)
KEENAN, LAURENCE L. v APPEALS BOARD OF ADMINISTRATIVE ADJ,1487TP 09-01362(2009-4980)
KHAMMONIVANG, VANG, PEOPLE v1512KA 07-00826(I45/06)
KHAMMONIVANG, VANG, PEOPLE v1519KA 07-00828(I791/05)
KLIM, RICHARD, MTR. OF1509TP 09-01111(2007-11664)
LAMPLEY, JR., LESTER L., PEOPLE v1584KA 07-01330(I2005-0905)
LUPIEN, KRISTIN v LUPIEN, JR., GORDON1657CA 09-01356(5861/08)
MARTINEZ, JESUS, PEOPLE v1565KA 05-01871(I310/04)
MUTO, ELEANORE v ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH OF ST. JOHN T,1636CA 09-01131(2007-5810)
NATHAN, DARYL v ROCHESTER HOUSING AUTHORITY,1697CA 09-01400(2006-9163)
ROCHESTER EQUIPMENT & MAINTENANCE, v ROXBURY MOUNTAIN SERVICE, INC.,1655CA 09-01292(2006-5341)
ROWLAND, PAUL v WILMORITE, INC.,1596CA 09-01403(10148/06)
SCHMITZ, DONNA LEE v CALDWELL & COOK, INC.,1038CA 09-00355(2007-2151)
SEARLEY, STEVEN v WEGMANS FOOD MARKETS, INC.,1635CA 09-01133(2004-7026)
SWANK, KELLY, PEOPLE v1666KA 06-03138(I0920/05)
TAYLOR, EUGENE D., PEOPLE v1513KA 06-01615(I2005-0545)
WEAVER, GERALD F. v TOWN OF PENFIELD,1633CA 09-01491(10205/02)
 
Niagara
BRADBERRY, DARREN, PEOPLE v1445KA 07-02326(I2006-109)
BREWER, TOMELL T., PEOPLE v1604KA 08-02674(IT06-2257)
BREWER, TOMELL T., PEOPLE v1603KA 08-02675(S2008-237)
DABROWSKI, JR., WALTER T., PEOPLE v1538KA 08-02080(I2001-385-V)
DEMMIN, TRACY v SMIECH, STANLEY1313CA 09-00966(2005-123038)
MANGUS, RHONDA, MTR. OF1600TP 09-01245(136504)
MATTESON, MARK A. v NEWFANE CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT BOA,1365CA 09-00977(129915)
TOWNSEND, RAYMOND T., PEOPLE v1630KA 07-02570(I2006-104)
 
Oneida
BENDERSON DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, LLC., v ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS,1663CA 09-01457(CA2008-001381)
BILLINS, JEFFREY C., PEOPLE v1645KA 07-01495(II07-063)
BROWN, MICHAEL v ROME UP & RUNNING, INC.,1479CA 09-01116(2007-00018)
DAVIS, TOUSSAINT, PEOPLE v1256KA 07-01886(I06-113)
DISCHIAVI, GARY M. v CALLI, WILLIAM S.1453CA 09-00801(2007-1283)
DISCHIAVI, GARY M. v CALLI, WILLIAM S.1452CA 09-00798(2007-1283)
DISCHIAVI, GARY M. v CALLI, WILLIAM S.1456CA 09-00804(2007-1283)
DISCHIAVI, GARY M. v CALLI, WILLIAM S.1455CA 09-00803(2007-1283)
DISCHIAVI, GARY M. v CALLI, WILLIAM S.1454CA 09-00802(2007-1283)
DRAKE, JR., THOMAS J., PEOPLE v1625KA 08-01207(I07-322)
K., GIOVANNI, MTR. OF1590CAF 08-02593(B-04046-05/08C)
KESSEL BRENT CORPORATION, v BENDERSON PROPERTY DEVELOPMENT, INC,1481CA 09-00357(2005-001511)
MADDOX, COLLIS B., PEOPLE v1470KA 08-01112(II07-078)
MCLIESH, JR., ALBERT P. v TOWN OF WESTERN,1389CA 09-00879(ca 2008 -2348)
PERKINS, NATASHA L. v WATSON, SR., CURTIS1592CAF 08-02590(O-04452-08)
PROCANICK, WILLIAM M., PEOPLE v1562KA 09-01355(07-278)
SAWYER, DONALD, MTR. OF1530CA 09-00439(CA 2008-003161)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v MUENCH, KARL1394CA 08-01301(CA2007-3337)
SUMTER, IBRIEL, PEOPLE v1467KA 08-01123(II07-272)
TAMBURRINO, JAMES T., PEOPLE v1587KA 08-00997(2005-394)
TAMBURRINO, JAMES T., PEOPLE v1586KA 06-02628(2005-394)
 
Onondaga
ATWATER, BRIAN R. v THUNDER BAY HOMES,1644CA 09-00618(2005-0219)
BERSANI, M.D., FRANK A. v TEXACO, INC.,1504CA 09-01270(2007-0115)
CITY OF SYRACUSE INDUSTRIAL, DEVELOPMENT AGENCY v KAUFMANN'S CAROUSEL CENTER, INC.,1461CA 09-00001(05-7106)
DART, JAMES R. v WOOLMAN, MARION G.1527CAF 09-00238(V-07172-06/08b)
DECICCO, DOMINIC v CITY OF SYRACUSE,1597CA 09-00549(2008-2288)
DICKINSON, VIOLA v DAINES, M.D., RICHARD F.1246CA 09-00711(2008-4831)
DYKES, PHILLIP K., PEOPLE v1626KA 07-00033(I2005-0224-2)
H., IRIS L. v ONONDAGA COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF, SOCIAL SERVICES1521CAF 08-02240(V-01566-08)
LAHEY, JAMES R. v LAHEY, KATHRYN E.1287CA 09-01005(M-0904-97)
LT PROPCO, LLC, v CAROUSEL CENTER COMPANY LP,1460CA 09-00002(07-3883)
LT PROPCO, LLC, v CAROUSEL CENTER COMPANY LP,1458CA 08-02265(07-3883)
LT PROPCO, LLC, v CAROUSEL CENTER COMPANY LP,1459CA 08-02266(07-3883)
NICOL, SHAWN, PEOPLE v1493KA 08-00979(I2004-0404-1)
O., NESTOR H., MTR. OF1522CAF 08-02195(B-4858-07)
PALMER, MORGAN T. v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,1057CA 09-00148(2005-1727)
PALMER, MORGAN T. v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,1056CA 09-00035(2005-1727)
R., JR., RAUL, MTR. OF1693CAF 08-00899(B-792-07/07A)
RAWSON, DAWN v STATE OF NEW YORK,1534CA 08-01706(105379)
SALISBURY, JR., STEPHEN D. v CHRISTIAN, JONELLE K.1335CA 08-00939(2004-6424)
SALISBURY, JR., STEPHEN D. v CHRISTIAN, JONELLE K.1336CA 09-00438(2004-6424)
SMITH, ANTHONY v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF PAROLE,1589KAH 08-01858(2008-3243)
SMITH, VIRGIL v SHERWOOD, HAZEL E.1634CA 09-01333(2003-6210)
TOWN OF ONONDAGA, v GRIMM, MICHAEL1694CA 09-01110(2007-0078)
 
Ontario
LAGASSE, PRESTON M., PEOPLE v1495KA 08-01046(S07-DI-136)
LOMBARDI, JOSEPH T., PEOPLE v1588KA 08-00862(I07-07-077)
MARVIN, JR., KENNETH J., PEOPLE v1514KA 08-00326(I06-04-052)
MARVIN, JR., KENNETH J., PEOPLE v1515KA 08-00327(I06-04-050)
MARVIN, JR., KENNETH J., PEOPLE v1516KA 08-00328(I06-04-049)
MASSA CONSTRUCTION, INC., v GEORGE M. BUNK, P.E., P.C.,1507CA 09-01377(97022)
MURPHY, JR., PHILIP L., PEOPLE v1518KA 08-00342(I07-10-121)
RUSS, BRYON K., PEOPLE v1471KA 08-02635(I00-04-102B)
SCHMIDT, CHARLES R., PEOPLE v1647KA 08-02077(I99-01-062)
STATE FARM FIRE & CASUALTY COMPANY, v GRIFFITH ENERGY, INC.,1594CA 09-00867(94450/04)
 
Orleans
HARVEY, SCOTT M. v GAULIN, NICOLE1637CA 09-00973(07-33818)
HARVEY, SCOTT M. v GAULIN, NICOLE1638CA 09-00974(07-33818)
JOCK, DEVIN M., PEOPLE v1665KA 08-02482(I08-39)
NAVAREZ, JOHN, MTR. OF1511TP 09-00013(08-35697)
SANDERSON, JOSEPH F., PEOPLE v1494KA 07-02178(I06-59 and 07-25)
 
Oswego
PHILIPS, JR., CLIFFORD B. v ELLSWORTH, DAVID C.1220CA 09-00696(06-1796)
 
Seneca
MAZZONI, PATRICIA A. v VILLAGE OF SENECA FALLS,1656CA 08-02179(36715)
 
Steuben
GREENE, TERRANCE D. v AVOCA CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,1640CA 09-01132(94967)
 
Wayne
CONNORS, DAVID v GRAY, JON E.1484CA 09-01477(63093)
TAILLIE, EUGENE v ROCHESTER GAS AND ELECTRIC CORP.,1658CA 09-00534(55381)
WEAVER, TONY, PEOPLE v1631KA 09-00392(I08-80)
YOUNG, MATTHEW, PEOPLE v1582KA 08-02126(I07-23)
 
Wyoming
ADELINE, SCOTT v UNGER, DAVID1559TP 09-01009(20794-09)
BRAMER, II, JAMES F. v UTICA MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY,1643CA 09-01336(39613)
DUDAS, DAVID v FISCHER, BRIAN1598CA 09-00557(20,716-08)
KALWASINSKI, MITCHELL v FISCHER, BRIAN1502CA 08-00789(20,419-07)
KALWASINSKI, MITCHELL v FISCHER, BRIAN1503CA 09-00965(20,419-07)
KALWASINSKI, MITCHELL, MTR. OF1508CA 08-00785(20,589-07)
 
Yates
KEARNS, JEFFREY M., PEOPLE v1491KA 08-02002(I06-27)
    
    
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS