AD4 Seal

Supreme Court of the State of New York
APPELLATE DIVISION
Fourth Judicial Department

Decisions - March 19, 2010

 
Cattaraugus
CONVERSE, MARIA A. v MCCOWN, PATRICIA A.384CAF 09-00892(V-02035-06/08D)
JAMES, ELLIOTT I., PEOPLE v312KA 08-02223(I07-123)
LEARN, STACY v ATWATER, LINDA430CAF 08-02150(V-1714-04/07C)
MALLARDS DAIRY, LLC, v E&M ENGINEERS & SURVEYORS, P.C.,151CA 09-01903(70747)
RICKARD, MARTIN P., PEOPLE v164KA 08-01431(I07-061)
 
Cayuga
DIMATTEO, JR., FRANK v COSENTINO, ANN MARIE192CA 09-01062(08-912)
JUSTICE, JOHN D. v STATE OF NEW YORK,258CA 09-00449(114445)
TAYLOR, RUDY v CORCORAN, MICHAEL353KAH 09-00418(2008-0982)
 
Chautauqua
ATKINS, VIOLET v UNITED REFINING HOLDINGS, INC.,296CA 09-02196(I2008-509)
BENNICE, DONALD v RANDALL, MARGUERITE M.282CA 09-02068(2007-641)
BLIXT, DANIEL S. v BLIXT, HILARY J.339CAF 08-01412(V-3953-3954-02/07E&F)
CARLSON, SWAN E. v JAMESTOWN HOUSING AUTHORITY,1442CA 09-00848(K1-2007-383)
TONKIN, KRYSTAL v WIDEWATERS LAKEWOOD VILLAGE CENTER, COMPANY391CA 09-02176(K1-2006-1441)
 
Erie
1093 GROUP, LLC, v TIME WARNER CABLE, INC.,322CA 09-02024(I 2008-3919)
A., DEMARIAH, MTR. OF318CAF 09-00663(B-18842-07, B-18853-07)
ABRAM, IDELLA v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN RI,325TP 09-01934(2009-7317)
ART CAPITAL PARTNERS, LP, v TYCO ACQUISITION CORP. XVIII,98CA 09-01762(I2004-673)
BARTON, JANICE v KOHLER, JENNIFER L.260CA 09-00831(2005-4168)
BULLS, ROBBIE v MASSARA, JR., ROBERT126CA 09-01796(2005-4147)
CORSIVO, SARAH v M&S HOTELS, LLC,412CA 09-01410(2008-000831)
CUMBO, SUSAN v SMITH BROTHERS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY,435CA 09-02241(I2006-7968)
DALEY, PATRICK L. v COUNTY OF ERIE,79CA 09-01670(I2007-7962)
DELANEY, ARTHUR, PEOPLE v267KA 09-00195(I2008-0509)
DIEL, JULIE v BRYAN, DDS, AMY232CA 09-01791(I-2001-1138)
DISCOVER BANK, v ESCHWEGE, ELLEN S.146CA 09-00641(I07-005562)
DOVE, JR., NATHANIEL v ROSE, KATRICE M.143CAF 07-02168(V-00391-97/06A, V-00391-
DOVE, JR., NATHANIAL v ROSE, KATRICE144CAF 09-00463(V-00391-07/06A,)
DUQUIN, JON, PEOPLE v307KA 09-00199(I2008-2403)
EBERHARDT-DAVIS, EMILY v DAVIS, PETER J.359CA 09-02268(2005-902773)
FACEN, DORIAN, PEOPLE v132KA 08-01240(I2007-1597)
FACEN, DORIAN, PEOPLE v133KA 08-01241(S28947)
FARRELL, THOMAS, PEOPLE v424KA 09-00502(I2008-0380)
FLAX, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v272KA 09-00600(I1591-1992-001)
FLOOD, DIANE v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,261CA 09-01849(2008-1318)
FRIEND, SR., KENNETH v TOWN OF WEST SENECA,101CA 09-01904(2008-13158)
GEICO INSURANCE COMPANY, v PIERCE, SHARON212CA 09-01557(I-2007-1250)
GRILLO, WILLIAM v WILLIAMS, THOMAS341CA 09-02259(I 2006-4107)
H., JANASIA, MTR. OF448CAF 09-00628(B-05151-06, B-05152-06,)
HUNTER, REUEL C., PEOPLE v335KA 08-02632(I00283-2008)
JONES, DAVID D., PEOPLE v308KA 09-00598(S30318)
KINDRED, JOSEPH, PEOPLE v159KA 09-01830(94-1985-001)
LANE, DAMARIO, PEOPLE v350KA 09-00102(I2008-0318)
LARD, LONNIE, PEOPLE v316KA 09-00022(S21799)
LARD, LONNIE, PEOPLE v311KA 09-01280(S2152-2002)
LATONA, ROBERT v ROBERSON, M.S., P.T., MICHAEL392CA 09-02232(2004-10726)
LUSCHER, JERAMY, PEOPLE v347KA 09-00294(I2008-0106)
M., KEYARIE, MTR. OF428CAF 08-01784(NA-15936-07)
MANUEL, DAVID, PEOPLE v377KA 09-02046(02861-2005)
MARRACINO, WENDE v ALEXANDER, D.D.S., GARY J.42CA 09-01825(2008-11994)
MAYE, JR., IRVIN, PEOPLE v244KA 08-01377(I2007-0573)
MELSON, REGINALD, PEOPLE v371KA 09-00290(S30645)
MENDEZ, JATHNIEL ESTRADA v FISCHER, BRIAN264TP 09-01906(2009-2391)
MILHELM ATTEA & BROS., INC., v PHILIP MORRIS USA, INC.,283CA 09-00346(I2008-13145)
MURPHY, THOMAS W., PEOPLE v313KA 09-00770(S29885)
NIAGARA FRONTIER TRANSPORTATION AUT, v NIAGARA FRONTIER TRANSPORTATION AUT, HORITY61CA 09-01705(2009-3152)
NIAGARA HOMEMAKER SERVICES, INC., v DAINES, M.D., RICHARD F.303CA 09-02023(2008-7454)
NIX, EVAN, PEOPLE v419KA 09-00138(I2008-0674)
NOWACKI, HANNA v BECKER, DEAN E.388CA 09-01723(2007-1854)
OKONGWU, DOMINIC, PEOPLE v68KA 08-00144(I91-2386-001)
POINTER, TODD, PEOPLE v378KA 09-01494(I00314-2008-R01)
PORTER, DESTINY, PEOPLE v351KA 08-02211(I2007-1935)
PRINGLE, KENNETH, PEOPLE v271KA 08-02067(I2004-2634)
RICKS, THOMAS C., PEOPLE v250KA 09-00380(I2005-1271)
SCOTT, JOHN, PEOPLE v157KA 09-00352(I0602600, 0602656)
SUTTON, DOMINICK, PEOPLE v73KA 06-03787(I00936-2005)
TRENT, MTR. OF342CA 08-02583(X2008-164)
TRONOLONE, CAESAR v NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF TRANSP, ORTATION366CA 09-01073(111315)
TRUEHEART, NATHAN, PEOPLE v266KA 08-02513(I2005-2413)
WILLIAMS, HOOVER v KENTUCKY FRIED CHICKEN,278CA 09-02194(2005-011909)
 
Genesee
DAWSON, ERIC S., PEOPLE v374KA 09-00382(S08-073)
FORD MOTOR CREDIT COMPANY LLC, v MIKE OGNIBENE FORD, INC.,305CA 09-02289(55895)
LAVILLA, STEPHEN P., PEOPLE v352KA 08-02644(I5152)
MCGAUGHEY, CARRIE v NAIK, ASHOK451CA 09-02069(50961)
 
Jefferson
BERNELL, FRANK, PEOPLE v438KA 09-00585(IC-501-08)
PETERKIN, TRAVIS, PEOPLE v88KA 09-00405(I626-00)
 
Lewis
CLEMENT, RYAN J., PEOPLE v291KA 09-00599(S2008-018)
 
Livingston
DALE, ALAN W., PEOPLE v440KA 08-00377(I2007-116)
 
Monroe
BLUNT, JEFFREY K., PEOPLE v48KA 06-02808(I0927/2005)
BOYDE, IV, THOMAS W., PEOPLE v248KA 08-00374(I2006-0849A)
BROWN BARK I, L.P., v GRANT, ELIZABETH S.96CA 09-01413(07-4009)
CALLOWAY, JOSEPH, PEOPLE v381KA 07-01125(I2005-0854B)
CATERING SPECIALISTS, LLC, v AIR CHARTER TEAM, INC.,363CA 09-01609(2009/01705)
FORBES, JR., ROBERT A., PEOPLE v442KA 07-00403(I212/06)
GREEN, GERALD, PEOPLE v396KA 08-01802(2003/05991) & (I2003-0241)
GROSS, DOUGLAS D., PEOPLE v1385KA 06-00043(I2005-0308)
GROTH, MATTHEW S., PEOPLE v66KA 09-01769(2008-0104)
GUTTMACHER, M.D., LAURENCE v M., MELVERTON453CA 09-00012(C
HERNANDEZ, ALEXANDER, PEOPLE v402KA 07-00910(I2006-0167)
HOLLOWAY, CHAD T., PEOPLE v358KA 07-01557(I2006-0461)
HOWARD, RANDY T., PEOPLE v249KA 07-00413(I946/2005)
HURLEY, DANIEL P. v HURLEY, AMANDA H.321CA 09-00374(4749/05)
JOANNIS, ERIC v CAHILL, KATHLEEN J.231CA 08-02533(2006-13530)
JOHNSTON, HEATH E., PEOPLE v425KA 08-01024(I2006-0301)
JONES, TERRANCE J., PEOPLE v330KA 07-00392(I2006-0304)
KELLY, THOMAS, PEOPLE v443KA 06-01921(I590/05)
KRAUSE, EDWARD, PEOPLE v422KA 07-01024(I06/804)
LATTIMORE ROAD SURGICENTER, INC., v MERCHANTS GROUP, INC.,41CA 09-01601(2005-13911)
LEWIS, TRAVIS, PEOPLE v243KA 07-01356(I06/764)
LOPEZ, ANTHONY, PEOPLE v441KA 07-00540(I271/06)
N., ANGELA v SUHR, SONJA369CA 09-01944(2006-6525)
NEWMAN, JOHN D., PEOPLE v427KA 06-03665(I2005-0649)
O., JR., COLLIN D., PEOPLE v336KA 07-00668(S2006-4272)
O'BRIEN, MONIKA v LOMBARDO, THERESA A.346CA 09-02292(3635-08)
OAKLEY, JR., COLLIN D., PEOPLE v331KA 07-00729(I2005-0834)
POTTINGER, ERROL L., PEOPLE v379KA 07-00829(I2006-0537)
R., ZACKORY, MTR. OF337CAF 09-02090(D-12136-08)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v GRANT, CHARLES408CA 08-02443(2008-1057)
T., CHRISTOPHER, MTR. OF52CAF 08-01791(D-4387-08)
TAYLOR, ALONZO P., PEOPLE v315KA 07-00394(I0053/06)
WERNER, ANDREW, PEOPLE v289KA 07-00840(S3182/05)
WILKINS, WENDY W., PEOPLE v310KA 07-01124(I06-0519)
 
Niagara
ANDREWS, PUSATERI, BRANDT, SHOEMAKE, v NIAGARA COUNTY SEWER DISTRICT NO. 1,16CA 09-01750(133986)
BARKER, RUSSELL v MOBILE PALLET TRUCK, INC.,1681CA 09-01115(118472)
CALDWELL, RONDELL L., PEOPLE v437KA 09-00862(I2006-567)
DEXTER, RUBIN P., PEOPLE v417KA 08-02116(I2007-570-V)
ELDER, JARVIS, PEOPLE v348KA 09-00602(I2007-478, 2008-040)
ELDER, JARVIS, PEOPLE v349KA 09-00603(I2008-040)
JOHNSON, KELVIN, PEOPLE v445KA 09-00289(I2008-007)
KESSINGER, DENNIS v SHARPE, JEREMY38CA 09-00851(125669)
PORTER, DALLAS, PEOPLE v416KA 09-00492(I2007-466)
ROUSE, KENNETH, PEOPLE v242KA 09-01047(I2008-028)
STREETER, BENNY D., PEOPLE v309KA 08-02382(I2007-021)
 
Oneida
CARR, MARCUS W., PEOPLE v245KA 08-02302(II07-370)
CELIA, ERIC v TOWN OF WHITESTOWN,189CA 09-01745(2006-2547)
CHARGO, SHANE v SIMONS, BENJAMIN344CA 09-01551(CA2007-1640)
CONTE, FRANK A., PEOPLE v270KA 08-01209(II07-352)
DORN, DORENE K., PEOPLE v446KA 09-02156(08-407)
ESQUERDO, TOMMY, PEOPLE v176KA 08-01386(I07-199)
KEVILLY, ROMAN v CONNELL, SUSAN452CA 08-02505(CA2008-2241)
PEREZ, LENORA M. v PEREZ, MELISSA385CAF 09-00402(V-03285-04/08B)
PLAYTIME BOUTIQUE, INC., v FRACCOLA, PHYLLIS431CA 09-02166(CA-2002-001819)
THOMAS, IV, GEORGE T. v BROWN, STEPHANIE L.317CAF 09-00295(V-05765-06/08D)
WILLIAMS, DEREK v CONNELL, SUSAN326TP 09-01966(CA2009-36)
 
Onondaga
A-PLUS, v NEW YORK STATE LOTTERY,14TP 09-01651(09-4225)
B., MALASHIA, MTR. OF382CAF 09-00573(B-50-07)
B., MALASHIA, MTR. OF383CAF 09-00693(B-50-07)
BENEDICT, MATTHEW A., PEOPLE v418KA 07-01390(I2006-0293-1)
CITY OF SYRACUSE, v FITCH STREET PROPERTIES, LLC,60CA 08-02407(2008-0333)
COLUCCI, JOHN D., PEOPLE v403KA 09-00516(92-0750) & (I92-0445-1)
DILLON, PAUL, PEOPLE v286KA 07-01271(I2005-360-1)
ESTATE OF RAY C. JOHNSON, v CIARPELLI, M. ANN345CA 09-01757(2008-7389)
FORD, TIMOTHY v CARDIOVASCULAR SPECIALISTS, P.C.,190CA 09-01530(08-9824)
FRANZA, SHARON v OLIN, DUANE C.194.1CA 09-01223(2008-7065)
HAYES, IV, ROBERT, PEOPLE v332KA 09-02273(2006-0588-1)
HENDERSON, R. TODD v MARTIN, JR., LLOYD F.410CA 09-02003(2008-8079)
INTERNATIONAL ELECTRON DEVICES (USA, v MENTER, RUDIN & TRIVELPIECE, P.C.,434CA 09-01949(8324-08)
JACKSON, TOMMY, PEOPLE v290KA 07-00811(I2006-0989-1)
JAMISON, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v225KA 08-01716(I2007-0272-1 & 20070281-
JAMISON, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v224KA 07-02171(I2007-0281-1)
MADISON, ORTEZ, PEOPLE v175KA 07-00838(I2005-0395-1)
MARTIN, JR., LLOYD F. v HENDERSON-JOHNSON, CO., INC.,409CA 09-02002(2009-3508)
PETERSON, CARLOS, PEOPLE v162KA 08-02022(I2008-0576-1)
PYRAMID BROKERAGE COMPANY, INC., v ZURICH AMERICAN INSURANCE COMPANY,59CA 09-01593(2003-6229)
R., ALEXIS C., MTR. OF429CAF 09-00625(B-434-436-07/08B,)
STANTON, KEITH, PEOPLE v329KA 07-01859(I2006-1119-2)
STATE OF NEW YORK, MTR. OF1466CA 08-02046(CA08-0001)
STATE OF NEW YORK, MTR. OF1465CA 08-02045(CA08-0001)
SYRACUSE UNIVERSITY, v GAMES 2002, LLC,1616CA 09-01210(2007-0808)
SYRACUSE UNIVERSITY, v PROJECT ORANGE ASSOCIATES SERVS.,208OP 09-01732
T., DANA, MTR. OF35CAF 09-00334(NN-2614-08)
TUPPER, JOSEPH v CITY OF SYRACUSE,301CA 09-02157(2008-0089)
WAL-MART STORES EAST, L.P., v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN RI,274TP 09-01951(2009-5071)
 
Ontario
APPLEBY, SHAWN, PEOPLE v1688KA 08-02117(I00-04-081)
STEELE, TOSHA, PEOPLE v287KA 08-00604(S07-DI-240)
T., L. v TEVA PHARMACEUTICALS USA, INC.,83CA 09-01800(96454/05)
TUSZYNSKI, DAVID F., PEOPLE v115KA 08-00340(I07-04-047)
 
Oswego
B., DUSTIN, OSWEGO COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL, v185CAF 08-02565(NN-784-787-08,)
CLEMONS, JR., RAYMOND, PEOPLE v241KA 08-02677(I07C-178)
LAYOU, MICHAEL J., PEOPLE v49KA 09-00389(I08C-0055)
MCLEAN, KENNETH G., PEOPLE v399KA 08-01026(I07C-101)
RYAN, DAVID v SANTANA, M.D., HECTOR B.1681.5CA 09-00369(02-2061)
 
Seneca
KAVAZANJIAN, RICHARD v WILLIAMS, MELVIN1433KAH 09-01030(42038)
PRICE, KEYAN R. v STATE OF NEW YORK,300CA 09-00212(111635)
RICCARDO, SAMUEL v WILLIAMS, MELVIN1689KAH 09-00695(41362)
 
Steuben
BURROUGHS, LORCEN, PEOPLE v269KA 08-02369(I2007-350)
CARLINEO, VINCENT P. v AKINS, JR., BRUCE G.1622CA 09-00813(2006-94622)
KULYESHIE, STEPHANIE, PEOPLE v334KA 09-00348(I2006-199)
 
Wayne
OLOMONSA, OHNJA, PEOPLE v375KA 09-00476(I08-59)
 
Wyoming
BOYD, SHAWN v FISCHER, BRIAN263TP 09-02061(20813-09)
CATES, ANDRE v FISCHER, BRIAN265TP 09-02060(20785-09)
CHAVIS, MICHAEL v DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONAL SERVICES,393KAH 09-00113(20,761-08)
MARTIN, CORNELIUS v LEMONS, JR., HENRY415CA 09-01230(20,806-09)
SECREST, WILLIAM v FISCHER, BRIAN285TP 09-02204(20827-09)
    
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS