Welcome
Home
THE COURT
    Overview of the Appellate Division
    Justices of the Court
    The Courthouse
DECISIONS
    Latest Decisions
    Decision Release Dates
    Search
CLERKS OFFICE
    Clerk and Deputy Clerk of the Court
    Contact Information
    Terms of the Court
    Court Calendars
    Rules of Practice
    Frequently Asked Questions
    Forms and Practice Aids
    Latest Court News
    Employment Opportunities
ATTORNEY MATTERS
    Admission to the Bar
    Attorney Discipline
    Attorney Registration Delinquency
    Registration as In-House Counsel
    Retirement
    Voluntary Resignation
PROGRAMS & AUXILIARY AGENCIES
    Assigned Counsel Program
    Attorneys for Children Program
    Attorney Grievance Committees
    Court Examiners
    Indep. Judicial Election Qual. Comm.
    Law Library
    Mental Hygiene Legal Service
    Pro Bono Policy and Program
RELATED LINKS
   Court sites
   Legal sites




Decisions - March 19, 2010

 
Cattaraugus
CONVERSE, MARIA A. v MCCOWN, PATRICIA A.384CAF 09-00892(V-02035-06/08D)
JAMES, ELLIOTT I., PEOPLE v312KA 08-02223(I07-123)
LEARN, STACY v ATWATER, LINDA430CAF 08-02150(V-1714-04/07C)
MALLARDS DAIRY, LLC, v E&M ENGINEERS & SURVEYORS, P.C.,151CA 09-01903(70747)
RICKARD, MARTIN P., PEOPLE v164KA 08-01431(I07-061)
 
Cayuga
DIMATTEO, JR., FRANK v COSENTINO, ANN MARIE192CA 09-01062(08-912)
JUSTICE, JOHN D. v STATE OF NEW YORK,258CA 09-00449(114445)
TAYLOR, RUDY v CORCORAN, MICHAEL353KAH 09-00418(2008-0982)
 
Chautauqua
ATKINS, VIOLET v UNITED REFINING HOLDINGS, INC.,296CA 09-02196(I2008-509)
BENNICE, DONALD v RANDALL, MARGUERITE M.282CA 09-02068(2007-641)
BLIXT, DANIEL S. v BLIXT, HILARY J.339CAF 08-01412(V-3953-3954-02/07E&F)
CARLSON, SWAN E. v JAMESTOWN HOUSING AUTHORITY,1442CA 09-00848(K1-2007-383)
TONKIN, KRYSTAL v WIDEWATERS LAKEWOOD VILLAGE CENTER, COMPANY391CA 09-02176(K1-2006-1441)
 
Erie
1093 GROUP, LLC, v TIME WARNER CABLE, INC.,322CA 09-02024(I 2008-3919)
A., DEMARIAH, MTR. OF318CAF 09-00663(B-18842-07, B-18853-07)
ABRAM, IDELLA v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN RI,325TP 09-01934(2009-7317)
ART CAPITAL PARTNERS, LP, v TYCO ACQUISITION CORP. XVIII,98CA 09-01762(I2004-673)
BARTON, JANICE v KOHLER, JENNIFER L.260CA 09-00831(2005-4168)
BULLS, ROBBIE v MASSARA, JR., ROBERT126CA 09-01796(2005-4147)
CORSIVO, SARAH v M&S HOTELS, LLC,412CA 09-01410(2008-000831)
CUMBO, SUSAN v SMITH BROTHERS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY,435CA 09-02241(I2006-7968)
DALEY, PATRICK L. v COUNTY OF ERIE,79CA 09-01670(I2007-7962)
DELANEY, ARTHUR, PEOPLE v267KA 09-00195(I2008-0509)
DIEL, JULIE v BRYAN, DDS, AMY232CA 09-01791(I-2001-1138)
DISCOVER BANK, v ESCHWEGE, ELLEN S.146CA 09-00641(I07-005562)
DOVE, JR., NATHANIEL v ROSE, KATRICE M.143CAF 07-02168(V-00391-97/06A, V-00391-
DOVE, JR., NATHANIAL v ROSE, KATRICE144CAF 09-00463(V-00391-07/06A,)
DUQUIN, JON, PEOPLE v307KA 09-00199(I2008-2403)
EBERHARDT-DAVIS, EMILY v DAVIS, PETER J.359CA 09-02268(2005-902773)
FACEN, DORIAN, PEOPLE v132KA 08-01240(I2007-1597)
FACEN, DORIAN, PEOPLE v133KA 08-01241(S28947)
FARRELL, THOMAS, PEOPLE v424KA 09-00502(I2008-0380)
FLAX, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v272KA 09-00600(I1591-1992-001)
FLOOD, DIANE v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,261CA 09-01849(2008-1318)
FRIEND, SR., KENNETH v TOWN OF WEST SENECA,101CA 09-01904(2008-13158)
GEICO INSURANCE COMPANY, v PIERCE, SHARON212CA 09-01557(I-2007-1250)
GRILLO, WILLIAM v WILLIAMS, THOMAS341CA 09-02259(I 2006-4107)
H., JANASIA, MTR. OF448CAF 09-00628(B-05151-06, B-05152-06,)
HUNTER, REUEL C., PEOPLE v335KA 08-02632(I00283-2008)
JONES, DAVID D., PEOPLE v308KA 09-00598(S30318)
KINDRED, JOSEPH, PEOPLE v159KA 09-01830(94-1985-001)
LANE, DAMARIO, PEOPLE v350KA 09-00102(I2008-0318)
LARD, LONNIE, PEOPLE v316KA 09-00022(S21799)
LARD, LONNIE, PEOPLE v311KA 09-01280(S2152-2002)
LATONA, ROBERT v ROBERSON, M.S., P.T., MICHAEL392CA 09-02232(2004-10726)
LUSCHER, JERAMY, PEOPLE v347KA 09-00294(I2008-0106)
M., KEYARIE, MTR. OF428CAF 08-01784(NA-15936-07)
MANUEL, DAVID, PEOPLE v377KA 09-02046(02861-2005)
MARRACINO, WENDE v ALEXANDER, D.D.S., GARY J.42CA 09-01825(2008-11994)
MAYE, JR., IRVIN, PEOPLE v244KA 08-01377(I2007-0573)
MELSON, REGINALD, PEOPLE v371KA 09-00290(S30645)
MENDEZ, JATHNIEL ESTRADA v FISCHER, BRIAN264TP 09-01906(2009-2391)
MILHELM ATTEA & BROS., INC., v PHILIP MORRIS USA, INC.,283CA 09-00346(I2008-13145)
MURPHY, THOMAS W., PEOPLE v313KA 09-00770(S29885)
NIAGARA FRONTIER TRANSPORTATION AUT, v NIAGARA FRONTIER TRANSPORTATION AUT, HORITY61CA 09-01705(2009-3152)
NIAGARA HOMEMAKER SERVICES, INC., v DAINES, M.D., RICHARD F.303CA 09-02023(2008-7454)
NIX, EVAN, PEOPLE v419KA 09-00138(I2008-0674)
NOWACKI, HANNA v BECKER, DEAN E.388CA 09-01723(2007-1854)
OKONGWU, DOMINIC, PEOPLE v68KA 08-00144(I91-2386-001)
POINTER, TODD, PEOPLE v378KA 09-01494(I00314-2008-R01)
PORTER, DESTINY, PEOPLE v351KA 08-02211(I2007-1935)
PRINGLE, KENNETH, PEOPLE v271KA 08-02067(I2004-2634)
RICKS, THOMAS C., PEOPLE v250KA 09-00380(I2005-1271)
SCOTT, JOHN, PEOPLE v157KA 09-00352(I0602600, 0602656)
SUTTON, DOMINICK, PEOPLE v73KA 06-03787(I00936-2005)
TRENT, MTR. OF342CA 08-02583(X2008-164)
TRONOLONE, CAESAR v NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF TRANSP, ORTATION366CA 09-01073(111315)
TRUEHEART, NATHAN, PEOPLE v266KA 08-02513(I2005-2413)
WILLIAMS, HOOVER v KENTUCKY FRIED CHICKEN,278CA 09-02194(2005-011909)
 
Genesee
DAWSON, ERIC S., PEOPLE v374KA 09-00382(S08-073)
FORD MOTOR CREDIT COMPANY LLC, v MIKE OGNIBENE FORD, INC.,305CA 09-02289(55895)
LAVILLA, STEPHEN P., PEOPLE v352KA 08-02644(I5152)
MCGAUGHEY, CARRIE v NAIK, ASHOK451CA 09-02069(50961)
 
Jefferson
BERNELL, FRANK, PEOPLE v438KA 09-00585(IC-501-08)
PETERKIN, TRAVIS, PEOPLE v88KA 09-00405(I626-00)
 
Lewis
CLEMENT, RYAN J., PEOPLE v291KA 09-00599(S2008-018)
 
Livingston
DALE, ALAN W., PEOPLE v440KA 08-00377(I2007-116)
 
Monroe
BLUNT, JEFFREY K., PEOPLE v48KA 06-02808(I0927/2005)
BOYDE, IV, THOMAS W., PEOPLE v248KA 08-00374(I2006-0849A)
BROWN BARK I, L.P., v GRANT, ELIZABETH S.96CA 09-01413(07-4009)
CALLOWAY, JOSEPH, PEOPLE v381KA 07-01125(I2005-0854B)
CATERING SPECIALISTS, LLC, v AIR CHARTER TEAM, INC.,363CA 09-01609(2009/01705)
FORBES, JR., ROBERT A., PEOPLE v442KA 07-00403(I212/06)
GREEN, GERALD, PEOPLE v396KA 08-01802(2003/05991) & (I2003-0241)
GROSS, DOUGLAS D., PEOPLE v1385KA 06-00043(I2005-0308)
GROTH, MATTHEW S., PEOPLE v66KA 09-01769(2008-0104)
GUTTMACHER, M.D., LAURENCE v M., MELVERTON453CA 09-00012(C
HERNANDEZ, ALEXANDER, PEOPLE v402KA 07-00910(I2006-0167)
HOLLOWAY, CHAD T., PEOPLE v358KA 07-01557(I2006-0461)
HOWARD, RANDY T., PEOPLE v249KA 07-00413(I946/2005)
HURLEY, DANIEL P. v HURLEY, AMANDA H.321CA 09-00374(4749/05)
JOANNIS, ERIC v CAHILL, KATHLEEN J.231CA 08-02533(2006-13530)
JOHNSTON, HEATH E., PEOPLE v425KA 08-01024(I2006-0301)
JONES, TERRANCE J., PEOPLE v330KA 07-00392(I2006-0304)
KELLY, THOMAS, PEOPLE v443KA 06-01921(I590/05)
KRAUSE, EDWARD, PEOPLE v422KA 07-01024(I06/804)
LATTIMORE ROAD SURGICENTER, INC., v MERCHANTS GROUP, INC.,41CA 09-01601(2005-13911)
LEWIS, TRAVIS, PEOPLE v243KA 07-01356(I06/764)
LOPEZ, ANTHONY, PEOPLE v441KA 07-00540(I271/06)
N., ANGELA v SUHR, SONJA369CA 09-01944(2006-6525)
NEWMAN, JOHN D., PEOPLE v427KA 06-03665(I2005-0649)
O., JR., COLLIN D., PEOPLE v336KA 07-00668(S2006-4272)
O'BRIEN, MONIKA v LOMBARDO, THERESA A.346CA 09-02292(3635-08)
OAKLEY, JR., COLLIN D., PEOPLE v331KA 07-00729(I2005-0834)
POTTINGER, ERROL L., PEOPLE v379KA 07-00829(I2006-0537)
R., ZACKORY, MTR. OF337CAF 09-02090(D-12136-08)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v GRANT, CHARLES408CA 08-02443(2008-1057)
T., CHRISTOPHER, MTR. OF52CAF 08-01791(D-4387-08)
TAYLOR, ALONZO P., PEOPLE v315KA 07-00394(I0053/06)
WERNER, ANDREW, PEOPLE v289KA 07-00840(S3182/05)
WILKINS, WENDY W., PEOPLE v310KA 07-01124(I06-0519)
 
Niagara
ANDREWS, PUSATERI, BRANDT, SHOEMAKE, v NIAGARA COUNTY SEWER DISTRICT NO. 1,16CA 09-01750(133986)
BARKER, RUSSELL v MOBILE PALLET TRUCK, INC.,1681CA 09-01115(118472)
CALDWELL, RONDELL L., PEOPLE v437KA 09-00862(I2006-567)
DEXTER, RUBIN P., PEOPLE v417KA 08-02116(I2007-570-V)
ELDER, JARVIS, PEOPLE v348KA 09-00602(I2007-478, 2008-040)
ELDER, JARVIS, PEOPLE v349KA 09-00603(I2008-040)
JOHNSON, KELVIN, PEOPLE v445KA 09-00289(I2008-007)
KESSINGER, DENNIS v SHARPE, JEREMY38CA 09-00851(125669)
PORTER, DALLAS, PEOPLE v416KA 09-00492(I2007-466)
ROUSE, KENNETH, PEOPLE v242KA 09-01047(I2008-028)
STREETER, BENNY D., PEOPLE v309KA 08-02382(I2007-021)
 
Oneida
CARR, MARCUS W., PEOPLE v245KA 08-02302(II07-370)
CELIA, ERIC v TOWN OF WHITESTOWN,189CA 09-01745(2006-2547)
CHARGO, SHANE v SIMONS, BENJAMIN344CA 09-01551(CA2007-1640)
CONTE, FRANK A., PEOPLE v270KA 08-01209(II07-352)
DORN, DORENE K., PEOPLE v446KA 09-02156(08-407)
ESQUERDO, TOMMY, PEOPLE v176KA 08-01386(I07-199)
KEVILLY, ROMAN v CONNELL, SUSAN452CA 08-02505(CA2008-2241)
PEREZ, LENORA M. v PEREZ, MELISSA385CAF 09-00402(V-03285-04/08B)
PLAYTIME BOUTIQUE, INC., v FRACCOLA, PHYLLIS431CA 09-02166(CA-2002-001819)
THOMAS, IV, GEORGE T. v BROWN, STEPHANIE L.317CAF 09-00295(V-05765-06/08D)
WILLIAMS, DEREK v CONNELL, SUSAN326TP 09-01966(CA2009-36)
 
Onondaga
A-PLUS, v NEW YORK STATE LOTTERY,14TP 09-01651(09-4225)
B., MALASHIA, MTR. OF382CAF 09-00573(B-50-07)
B., MALASHIA, MTR. OF383CAF 09-00693(B-50-07)
BENEDICT, MATTHEW A., PEOPLE v418KA 07-01390(I2006-0293-1)
CITY OF SYRACUSE, v FITCH STREET PROPERTIES, LLC,60CA 08-02407(2008-0333)
COLUCCI, JOHN D., PEOPLE v403KA 09-00516(92-0750) & (I92-0445-1)
DILLON, PAUL, PEOPLE v286KA 07-01271(I2005-360-1)
ESTATE OF RAY C. JOHNSON, v CIARPELLI, M. ANN345CA 09-01757(2008-7389)
FORD, TIMOTHY v CARDIOVASCULAR SPECIALISTS, P.C.,190CA 09-01530(08-9824)
FRANZA, SHARON v OLIN, DUANE C.194.1CA 09-01223(2008-7065)
HAYES, IV, ROBERT, PEOPLE v332KA 09-02273(2006-0588-1)
HENDERSON, R. TODD v MARTIN, JR., LLOYD F.410CA 09-02003(2008-8079)
INTERNATIONAL ELECTRON DEVICES (USA, v MENTER, RUDIN & TRIVELPIECE, P.C.,434CA 09-01949(8324-08)
JACKSON, TOMMY, PEOPLE v290KA 07-00811(I2006-0989-1)
JAMISON, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v225KA 08-01716(I2007-0272-1 & 20070281-
JAMISON, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v224KA 07-02171(I2007-0281-1)
MADISON, ORTEZ, PEOPLE v175KA 07-00838(I2005-0395-1)
MARTIN, JR., LLOYD F. v HENDERSON-JOHNSON, CO., INC.,409CA 09-02002(2009-3508)
PETERSON, CARLOS, PEOPLE v162KA 08-02022(I2008-0576-1)
PYRAMID BROKERAGE COMPANY, INC., v ZURICH AMERICAN INSURANCE COMPANY,59CA 09-01593(2003-6229)
R., ALEXIS C., MTR. OF429CAF 09-00625(B-434-436-07/08B,)
STANTON, KEITH, PEOPLE v329KA 07-01859(I2006-1119-2)
STATE OF NEW YORK, MTR. OF1466CA 08-02046(CA08-0001)
STATE OF NEW YORK, MTR. OF1465CA 08-02045(CA08-0001)
SYRACUSE UNIVERSITY, v GAMES 2002, LLC,1616CA 09-01210(2007-0808)
SYRACUSE UNIVERSITY, v PROJECT ORANGE ASSOCIATES SERVS.,208OP 09-01732
T., DANA, MTR. OF35CAF 09-00334(NN-2614-08)
TUPPER, JOSEPH v CITY OF SYRACUSE,301CA 09-02157(2008-0089)
WAL-MART STORES EAST, L.P., v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN RI,274TP 09-01951(2009-5071)
 
Ontario
APPLEBY, SHAWN, PEOPLE v1688KA 08-02117(I00-04-081)
STEELE, TOSHA, PEOPLE v287KA 08-00604(S07-DI-240)
T., L. v TEVA PHARMACEUTICALS USA, INC.,83CA 09-01800(96454/05)
TUSZYNSKI, DAVID F., PEOPLE v115KA 08-00340(I07-04-047)
 
Oswego
B., DUSTIN, OSWEGO COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL, v185CAF 08-02565(NN-784-787-08,)
CLEMONS, JR., RAYMOND, PEOPLE v241KA 08-02677(I07C-178)
LAYOU, MICHAEL J., PEOPLE v49KA 09-00389(I08C-0055)
MCLEAN, KENNETH G., PEOPLE v399KA 08-01026(I07C-101)
RYAN, DAVID v SANTANA, M.D., HECTOR B.1681.5CA 09-00369(02-2061)
 
Seneca
KAVAZANJIAN, RICHARD v WILLIAMS, MELVIN1433KAH 09-01030(42038)
PRICE, KEYAN R. v STATE OF NEW YORK,300CA 09-00212(111635)
RICCARDO, SAMUEL v WILLIAMS, MELVIN1689KAH 09-00695(41362)
 
Steuben
BURROUGHS, LORCEN, PEOPLE v269KA 08-02369(I2007-350)
CARLINEO, VINCENT P. v AKINS, JR., BRUCE G.1622CA 09-00813(2006-94622)
KULYESHIE, STEPHANIE, PEOPLE v334KA 09-00348(I2006-199)
 
Wayne
OLOMONSA, OHNJA, PEOPLE v375KA 09-00476(I08-59)
 
Wyoming
BOYD, SHAWN v FISCHER, BRIAN263TP 09-02061(20813-09)
CATES, ANDRE v FISCHER, BRIAN265TP 09-02060(20785-09)
CHAVIS, MICHAEL v DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONAL SERVICES,393KAH 09-00113(20,761-08)
MARTIN, CORNELIUS v LEMONS, JR., HENRY415CA 09-01230(20,806-09)
SECREST, WILLIAM v FISCHER, BRIAN285TP 09-02204(20827-09)
    
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS