Welcome
Home
THE COURT
    Overview of the Appellate Division
    Justices of the Court
    The Courthouse
DECISIONS
    Latest Decisions
    Decision Release Dates
    Search
CLERKS OFFICE
    Clerk and Deputy Clerk of the Court
    Contact Information
    Terms of the Court
    Court Calendars
    Rules of Practice
    Frequently Asked Questions
    Forms and Practice Aids
    Latest Court News
    Employment Opportunities
ATTORNEY MATTERS
    Admission to the Bar
    Attorney Discipline
    Attorney Registration Delinquency
    Registration as In-House Counsel
    Retirement
    Voluntary Resignation
PROGRAMS & AUXILIARY AGENCIES
    Assigned Counsel Program
    Attorneys for Children Program
    Attorney Grievance Committees
    Court Examiners
    Indep. Judicial Election Qual. Comm.
    Law Library
    Mental Hygiene Legal Service
    Pro Bono Policy and Program
RELATED LINKS
   Court sites
   Legal sites




Decisions - April 30, 2010

 
Cattaraugus
GLACIAL AGGREGATES, LLC, v TOWN OF YORKSHIRE,1116CA 07-02611(69015)
KNUTH, JENNIFER R. v WESTFALL, TROY J.669CAF 09-00622(V-01187-03/09H)
MURPHY, BRADLEY W. v PEACE, REA M.628CAF 09-02467(V-1591-06/09D,)
THOMAS, STEVEN D., PEOPLE v139KA 08-02246(S08-105)
WILDER, SHANNON v WILDER, THOMAS489CAF 09-00478(V-1209, 1210-05)
 
Cayuga
CLYDE, RAYMOND, PEOPLE v405KA 08-00851(I2007-021)
CLYDE, RAYMOND, PEOPLE v404KA 08-00850(I2007-021)
GAMLEN, CLINTON B., PEOPLE v603KA 09-00508(S2008-208)
SYRELL, BRIAN J., PEOPLE v580KA 09-00511(S2008-106)
 
Chautauqua
BENSON, SHELIA v LILLIE, TREVOR M.611CA 09-02366(I 2007-1557)
CHIPLEY, MORGAN L. v STEPHENSON, M.D., GRANT W.436CA 09-00059(2004-1410)
FARNHAM, MITCHELL v MEDER, BRIAN J.501CA 09-02169(K1-2003-639)
KALB, SHANE P., PEOPLE v598KA 08-02643(S07-011)
KIM, CHANG HAN v CLYMER CENTRAL SCHOOL,433CA 09-01999(200/775)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v FARNSWORTH, DANIEL387CA 09-01424(MH K1/2008-943)
 
Erie
1093 GROUP, INC., v CANALE, MARY JANE476CA 09-02411(2008-6263)
A., DEMARIAH, MTR. OF538CAF 09-00688(B-18842-07, B-18853-07)
ALEKSANDROWICZ, PETER v CANTELLA & COMPANY, INC.,516CA 09-02528(05-008289)
ALLISON, KYLE, PEOPLE v506KA 08-01761(I2007-0935)
AYALA, ANDRES, PEOPLE v508KA 08-01055(I84-1726-2)
BOBAK, ADAM, MTR. OF1331CA 09-00404(I2008-11187)
BROWN, NADIRAH, PEOPLE v461KA 09-01460(I2007-2646)
BURRIS, GENEVA L. v LOVING, ROBERT J.K.626CAF 09-00887(F-15238-08/08A)
C., ERIC v NEW YORK STATE POLICE,389CA 09-01880(I-2008-10654)
CLYBURN, ATO v KADIEN, GREGORY J.480TP 09-02471(2009-11096)
COLTON, JUDY v TOWN BOARD OF TOWN OF AMHERST,658CA 09-02348(2008-2482)
COOPER, SHARON v NEW YORK CENTRAL MUTUAL FIRE INSUR.,454CA 09-02108(2008/9343)
COOPER, BRIAN, PEOPLE v444KA 08-01771(I2008-0276)
DAIL, BERTHA v MERCHANTS MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY,390CA 09-02231(2008007755)
ERIE COUNTY SHERIFF'S POLICE BENEVO, LENT ASSOCIATION v COUNTY OF ERIE,657CA 09-02152(2008-4274)
FRANCIS, JUSTIN W. v FRANCIS, SUZANNE547CA 09-02327(2008-900248)
GAFFNEY, THOMAS J. v CHIACCHIA & FLEMING LLP,171CA 09-01528(2007-07938)
GINTHER, GEORGE EAGAN v CRAWFORD, JR., ROBERT A.608CA 09-00915(2005-11539)
GLENN, LEE A., PEOPLE v485KA 08-01015(I2005-1558)
GOODRUM, BRUCE, PEOPLE v659KA 09-00509(I2008-0718)
GROSS, SUZANN v HERTZ LOCAL EDITION CORP.,340CA 09-01622(I2005-10493)
GUINYARD, LAWRENCE, PEOPLE v423KA 08-02394(I2007-1004)
GUINYARD, LAWRENCE, PEOPLE v423.1KA 10-00730(I2007-1004)
HARRIS, ANTWOIN, PEOPLE v226KA 08-02549(I2008-0877I)
HARRIS, ANTWOIN, PEOPLE v227KA 08-02547(I2008-0714A)
HARRIS, ANTWOIN, PEOPLE v228KA 08-02548(I2008-0714I)
HARRIS, JR., VARNER, PEOPLE v624KA 08-02379(I2006-2937)
HSBC BANK USA, NA, MTR. OF323CA 09-02136(2002-0295)
JONES, DAVON, PEOPLE v600KA 09-00918(I2008-2158)
K., KYLE, MTR. OF540CAF 09-00875(B-4327,8-06)
KRAFT, LISA A. v ROUSSEAU, CANDICE671CAF 09-01164(V-04086-08/08A)
LEWIS, JOAN M. v LUSTAN, FRANK148CA 09-01645(i2007/1795)
MAYBACK, JR., JONATHAN, PEOPLE v557KA 09-00300(S29986)
MISLIN, BARBARA A. v CITY OF TONAWANDA SCHOOL DISTRICT,633CA 08-02568(I2007-4040)
NASH, REESEIE, PEOPLE v509KA 08-02186(I2006-1732)
NEW HAMPSHIRE INSURANCE COMPANY, MTR. OF1330CA 09-00333(I2008-7414)
NEWBERN, JAMAICA, PEOPLE v530KA 09-00937(I2008-1322)
NEWBERN, JAMAICA, PEOPLE v531KA 09-00938(I2008-1681)
POBLACKI, ARTHUR R., PEOPLE v664KA 09-02358(00988-2008)
POULSEN, BRIAN v LIGHTHOUSE ASSEMBLY AT HIGH FALLS,543CA 09-02393(2008-011156)
R., EDUARDO, MTR. OF165CAF 09-01563(D-17329-08)
R., EDUARDO, MTR. OF490CAF 09-02454(D-17329-08)
RIOS, ELVIN, PEOPLE v198KA 09-01198(I2008-001094)
RIOS, ELVIN, PEOPLE v197KA 08-02141(I2008-0357)
ROUSSEAU, CANDICE v KRAFT, LISA A.670CAF 09-01163(V-04086-08/09B,)
SHUBBUCK, JUSTIN M. v CONNERS, SEAN W.450CA 09-01104
SHUGATS, JOSEPH A. v ERIE COUNTY MEDICAL CENTER CORPORAT,513CA 09-02331(2009-3505)
SORRENTO LACTALIS, INC., v POLANSKI, JR., NORMAN L.609CA 09-01345(I2009-6546)
TURNER, STEPHEN v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,1248CA 09-00073(I2004-2110)
TURNER, STEPHEN v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,550CA 09-00759(2004-2110)
TURNER, STEPHEN v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,553CA 09-01614(I2004-2110)
TURNER, STEPHEN v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,552CA 09-01613(I2004-2110)
TURNER, STEPHEN v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,551CA 09-01612(I2004-2110)
WOODS, RONNIE, PEOPLE v483KA 09-00206(I2006-1635)
WORKMAN, JAMES, PEOPLE v663KA 08-02016(I95-0417-001)
ZAFUTO, BRENT, PEOPLE v620KA 09-00736(I2008-0488)
 
Genesee
CONNOLLY, JONATHAN, PEOPLE v555KA 09-01025(I5191)
FIGGINS, ANDREW, PEOPLE v554KA 08-01018(I5043)
GAYLE, JUNIOR, PEOPLE v533KA 09-00181(I5164)
KNAUBER, DEBRA, PEOPLE v601KA 07-02650(I4949)
NICHOLS, TERESA v VANAMERONGEN, DEBORAH262TP 09-02063(58711)
STODDARD, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v576KA 09-00933(S08-098)
TOOLEY, MARK, PEOPLE v558KA 09-00315(S07-040)
 
Herkimer
EDGETT, MICHELLE v NORTH FORK BANK,650CA 09-02526(2002-77997)
KLOCK, EDWARD v KLOCK, MAUREEN668CAF 09-00426(F-0012-08/08A)
 
Jefferson
FOSTER, MICHIAL E., PEOPLE v1517KA 08-02523(I434-97)
KAMGUIA, M.D., PIERRE v MCWAYNE, FREDERICK573CA 09-02466(2005-2388)
RICHARDSON, RAJSHEEM L., PEOPLE v510KA 08-01188(I230-07)
 
Lewis
FOTI, ANTHONY v NOFTSIER, JR., ROBERT ROMEYN575CA 09-02549(CA2007-00422)
 
Livingston
BUTLER, TRACI v STAGECOACH GROUP, PLC,524CA 09-01533(1541-2008)
COWAN, COURTNEY v STAGECOACH GROUP, PLC,525CA 09-01536(1539-2008)
EDWARDS, SHEILA ELIZABETH v ERIE COACH LINES COMPANY,528CA 09-01548(1452-2005)
EDWARDS, SHEILA ELIZABETH v ERIE COACH LINES COMPANY,529CA 09-01549(1452-2005)
EDWARDS, SHEILA ELIZABETH v ERIE COACH LINES COMPANY,527CA 09-01547(1452-2005)
GLOVER, TINA, BERLING, KIMBERLY v537CAF 08-02592(V-16-07/07B,)
GODWIN, MEAGAN v STAGECOACH GROUP, PLC,526CA 09-01539(53-2007)
HUNT, CARL B., LEWIS, RYDELLE v643KAH 08-02094(1193-2008)
HUNTER, IAN, PEOPLE v394KA 07-02497(I2007-046A)
THIELE, KENNETH, PEOPLE v504KA 09-00156(I99-183SCI)
 
Monroe
BRADLEY, FELDER, PEOPLE v639KA 06-02980(I0466/05)
BRUNSON, MICKEY v STRONG, LONNELL649CA 09-02572(2136/08)
BUTLER, TRACI v STAGECOACH GROUP, PLC,518CA 09-01531(1541-2008)
BUTLER, TRACI v STAGECOACH GROUP, PLC,519CA 09-01532(1541-2008)
CALDERON, JR., JOHN v WALGREEN CO.,386CA 09-01623(07/1779)
CHACON-CHAVEZ, HARRY v CITY OF ROCHESTER,652CA 09-02067(06-1175)
COBB, CHARLES S., PEOPLE v484KA 07-00255(I04-0264A)
COWAN, COURTNEY v STAGECOACH GROUP, PLC,521CA 09-01535(1541-2008)
COWAN, COURTNEY v STAGECOACH GROUP, PLC,520CA 09-01534(1541-2008)
GARZONE, EMANUEL, PEOPLE v535KA 07-01050(S05/9000)
GODWIN, MEAGAN v STAGECOACH GROUP, PLC,523CA 09-01538(53-2007)
GODWIN, MEAGAN v STAGECOACH GROUP, PLC,522CA 09-01537(53-2007)
GOLLEL, MAUREEN ANN v GOLLEL, RICHARD MICHAEL681CA 09-02322(2009-09031)
GOLLEL, MAUREEN ANN v GOLLEL, RICHARD MICHAEL680CA 09-02321(2009-09031)
GOOSSEN, KAREN v GOOSSEN, JOHN541CAF 09-01176(O-1266-08)
GOOSSEN, JOHN R. v GOOSSEN, KAREN536CAF 09-00998(V-11824/11829-07)
GREEN, CHAZARAY A., PEOPLE v560KA 07-01136(I06/306)
GREGORY, DYANI A., PEOPLE v357KA 07-00824(I2006-0504)
HANCOCK, ALVIN, PEOPLE v486KA 07-01649(I07/207)
HANCOCK, ALVIN, PEOPLE v481KA 08-00120(I06-471)
HEARD, ALEX J., PEOPLE v641KA 07-02556(I2006-0557)
HUCKS, MARQUIS C., PEOPLE v578KA 08-02401(1993/2394) & (I93-W0165)
JOHNSON, BRYANT, PEOPLE v665KA 07-01061(I06/575)
KHEEL, THOMAS H. v KHEEL, JULIAN MARK411CA 09-02252(12689/08)
LEWIS, WINFORD H. v LEWIS, MARY ELIZABETH491CA 09-01013(06/7444)
LEWIS, WINFORD H. v LEWIS, MARY ELIZABETH492CA 09-01015(06-7444)
LEWIS, TRAVIS, PEOPLE v577KA 08-00859(I2007-0828A)
MORGAN, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v137KA 06-03804(I023/06)
MUNDRICK, DEBORAH PATRICIA v MUNDRICK, RICHARD THOMAS237CA 09-00613(99/6856)
NICHOLS, STEPHEN v XEROX CORPORATION,277CA 09-01916(03-8370)
PARKER, JAMES A., PEOPLE v314KA 08-00305(I2006-0502)
PARKWAY PEDIATRIC AND ADOLESCENT ME, v VITULLO, M.D., BENEDETTO284CA 09-02291(2006-1585)
RIVENBURG, JANICE v HIGHLAND HOSPITAL OF ROCHESTER, INC,495CA 09-01848(03-11694)
RIVENBURG, JANICE v HIGHLAND HOSPITAL OF ROCH.,494CA 09-00913(11694-03)
ROBLES, LUIS R., PEOPLE v354KA 06-00792(I2005-0383)
SAUNDERS, WILLIAM P. v ROCHESTER CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT,636CA 09-01994(06/7020)
VANGORDER, FRED, PEOPLE v597KA 08-01065(98-3568) & (I98-0207)
WILSON, CHRIS T., PEOPLE v465KA 07-01270(I2006-0418)
WOOD, LAURIE v LYNCHESKY, ROBERT606CAF 09-01275(V-00060-01/07C)
 
Niagara
BURNS, PATRICK E. v KROENING, LEE A.499CA 09-01074(116058)
FEDESON, RUTH v HOWARD JOHNSON TIKI RESORT INN,632CA 09-02383(135107)
FIOCCO, MARLE M. v DOYLE, SHANNON M.281CA 09-01617(130393)
GIACOMETTI, AMY G. v DOYLE, SHANNON M.280CA 09-01618(127487)
LEVEILLE, II, FRANK, PEOPLE v487KA 09-01251(S2008-206)
LEVEILLE, II, FRANK, PEOPLE v482KA 09-01252(S2008-421)
MCLAUGHLIN, SAMUEL A., PEOPLE v562KA 09-01373(S2009-038)
PROGRESSIVE HALCYON INSURANCE, COMPANY v GIACOMETTI, AMY G.279CA 09-01619(128231)
RAMOS, GABRIEL L. v RAMOS, DARCY A.585CAF 09-00425(V-00404-01/08Q)
SICOLI, BENJAMIN M., PEOPLE v619KA 09-01126(I2007-437)
STEWART, DALE M., PEOPLE v466KA 09-01284(I2008-129)
STODOLKA, CHARLES K. v STARPOINT CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,647TP 09-02312(137420)
 
Oneida
BALLS, BRITTANY LOUISA v DOLLIVER, RYAN607CAF 09-01947(V-04892-08)
BOUSE, JOSEPH, PEOPLE v556KA 09-02064(II05-008)
CITY OF ROME, v RAILROAD PROPERTY DEVELOPMENT CORP.,475CA 09-00897(2004-1051)
EDWARDS, CARMELLA v ST. ELIZABETH MEDICAL CENTER,548CA 09-02605(CA2006-5757)
FRACCOLA, JR., ALBERT G. v FRACCOLA, PHYLLIS545CA 09-02308(2008-000430)
FULTON, DERRICK R., PEOPLE v579KA 08-01906(II08-078)
H., AARON, MTR. OF563CAF 09-00129(NA-02428-07, NA-02429-07
INGERSOLL, HEATHER A. v PLATT, LONNIE S.470CAF 09-00248(V-04310/11-06/07C)
J., DONATAE, MTR. OF469CAF 09-01184(NN-04916-08)
KOZIOL, LEON R. v WALSH-HOOD, MARTHA648OP 09-02550
PROKOPIENKO, MICHAEL A., PEOPLE v372KA 09-00950(IIDV2007-5013)
PROKOPIENKO, MICHAEL A., PEOPLE v373KA 09-00958(IIDV2007-5042-V)
R., JAVIER, MTR. OF449CAF 09-02234(D-04994-08)
 
Onondaga
BARNISH, THOMAS, PEOPLE v439KA 06-01347(I2005-0405-1)
FARNETI, ALDO v AT&T,589CA 09-02525(2009-5133)
GRIFFIN, DAVON M., PEOPLE v251KA 03-02629(I2003-0103-1)
H., JANE, MTR. OF625CAF 09-00889(NN-8114-08)
J.-M., ROMANYA, MTR. OF627CAF 09-00542(NN-8145-07)
LIFSON, ALEXANDER v CITY OF SYRACUSE,365CA 09-01739(01-0877)
LIFSON, ALEXANDER v CITY OF SYRACUSE,364CA 08-02666(01-0877)
LIVERPOOL PUBLIC LIBRARY, MTR. OF596CA 09-02604(2009-3048)
MANUFACTURERS AND TRADERS TRUST COM, MTR. OF498CA 09-01787(00-02357)
MATTHEWS, GUADALUPE v MATTHEWS, EDWARD644CAF 06-01035
MM 1, LLC, v LAVANCHER, SHERRY254CA 09-02043(2008-6211)
ONEIDA INDIAN NATION, v HUNT CONSTRUCTION GROUP, INC.,496CA 09-01346(2008-5453)
S., DONELL, MTR. OF586CAF 09-00079(NN-8659-8660-07)
STEPHENS, BRUCE C., PEOPLE v534KA 05-02423(I2004-0418-1)
STOUGHTENGER, LISA v CARRIONS, GLADYS140TP 09-01423(2008-3051)
TYSZKA, SHAWN v MAKE AND TAKE HOLDING, LLC,612CA 09-01876(5064/08)
 
Ontario
COUNTY OF ONTARIO, v HELSER, SUSAN M.653CA 09-01879(100140)
WHITFIELD, AHKEEM, PEOPLE v582KA 08-01035(I07-07-088)
ZANGHI, DANIEL, PEOPLE v623KA 09-00406(S00-DI-038)
 
Orleans
CALEB, BRENT C. v SEVENSON ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES,324CA 09-01997(22723)
 
Oswego
PRINGLE, BRYAN D., PEOPLE v640KA 09-00815(S06C-167)
WAHRENDORF, DAVID v CITY OF OSWEGO,574CA 09-02032(2008-1111)
 
Seneca
HAWKINS, BRYAN R. v FISCHER, BRIAN306TP 09-02172(43183)
LEMPKE, JOHN, ROBINSON, EDDIE M. v463TP 09-02606(43248)
SMITH, MELVIN v WILLIAMS, MELVIN584KAH 09-01462(42372)
 
Steuben
ALLICK, IMRAN A., PEOPLE v602KA 07-01768(I2006-195B)
E., ANDREA, MTR. OF605CAF 09-00708(B01171-08)
 
Wayne
GLANTON, ROMARIS, PEOPLE v398KA 09-00582(I08-11)
GLANTON, ROMARIS, PEOPLE v397KA 09-00581(I07-127)
NEW YORK MUNICIPAL INSURANCE RECIP, v W.P. MAHONEY ENTERPRISES, INC.,569CA 09-01657(60149/07)
QUINN, NAPOLEON v MORRISSEY, J.P.642KAH 09-00211(08-WRIT-11)
T., ROYSTAR, MTR. OF488CAF 09-00834(B-064-08)
 
Wyoming
KALWASINSKI, MITCHELL v FISCHER, BRIAN517CA 09-01444(20.643-08)
TARANTINO, STEPHEN, PEOPLE v505KA 09-02574(5839)
 
Yates
BOYZUCK, TRACI, PEOPLE v376KA 09-00947(I08-29)
    
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS