Welcome
Home
THE COURT
    Overview of the Appellate Division
    Justices of the Court
    The Courthouse
DECISIONS
    Latest Decisions
    Decision Release Dates
    Search
CLERKS OFFICE
    Clerk and Deputy Clerk of the Court
    Contact Information
    Terms of the Court
    Court Calendars
    Rules of Practice
    Frequently Asked Questions
    Forms and Practice Aids
    Latest Court News
    Employment Opportunities
ATTORNEY MATTERS
    Admission to the Bar
    Attorney Discipline
    Attorney Registration Delinquency
    Registration as In-House Counsel
    Retirement
    Voluntary Resignation
PROGRAMS & AUXILIARY AGENCIES
    Assigned Counsel Program
    Attorneys for Children Program
    Attorney Grievance Committees
    Court Examiners
    Indep. Judicial Election Qual. Comm.
    Law Library
    Mental Hygiene Legal Service
    Pro Bono Policy and Program
RELATED LINKS
   Court sites
   Legal sites




Decisions - June 11, 2010

 
Allegany
BOXHORN, LESLIE v ALLIANCE IMAGING, INC.,564CA 09-02581(31996)
 
Cattaraugus
HOMAN, LESTER v COUNTY OF CATTARAUGUS DEPARTMENT,614CA 09-02369(76064)
HORN, LAURA L. v HORN, JEFFREY H.806CAF 09-01170(V-01420-08/08A)
REES, SHAWN, PEOPLE v753KA 09-00583(I05-036)
SECRIST, ROBERT D., PEOPLE v818KA 09-00532(I07-131)
STROUD, ROBERT M. v VAHL, MARY HOLLENDER539CAF 09-02422(F-1020-00)
 
Cayuga
BROWN, CLARENCE R., PEOPLE v599KA 08-02462(I2007-040)
HENRY, KEVIN P., PEOPLE v840KA 08-01497(I2007-038)
SMITH, III, JOHN W., PEOPLE v857KA 09-00824(I2008-118)
TRATT, KIMBERLY A. v COUNTY OF CAYUGA,809CA 09-01667(2007-0712)
 
Chautauqua
THE RESOURCE CENTER, v NYSARC, INC.,610CA 09-02573(K1-2007-95)
 
Erie
AIKEN, LANCE, PEOPLE v708KA 09-00222(I2007-0122)
ALLSAFE TECHNOLOGIES, INC., v BENZ, CHARLES634CA 09-02548(2007-8492)
B., MADDISON, MTR. OF828CAF 09-01562(B-19082-08)
BENEVENTO, RICHARD v CITY OF BUFFALO,572CA 09-02612(I2005-4819)
COOPER, ELIZABETH v COOPER, RICHARD L.866CAF 10-00216(F-03614-08)
D., ELIJAH, MTR. OF805CAF 09-00876(B-15667-2007)
DOHERTY, JENNIFER M. v MERCHANTS MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY,1617CA 09-01495(2005-6135)
DOZIER, DANIEL, PEOPLE v729KA 09-00852(I2008-0664)
DUGAN, JESSICA ANN, PEOPLE v757KA 09-01578(I2008-2598)
FALK, PATRICIA A. v FALK, BRUCE R.791CA 10-00106(SF 2003-902961)
GARZA, ESMERALDA v TARAVELLA, MICHAEL721CA 10-00339(2006-4045)
GIBSON, JEFFREY D., PEOPLE v204KA 08-00891(I2005-2678)
GOLDEN, RODNEY v BROWN, JAMES P.794CA 09-02639(I-2006-3496)
HARRIS, KENNETH L. v CITY OF BUFFALO,810CA 10-00124(I 2007-7984)
HARRIS, DARIUS, PEOPLE v801KA 09-00540(I2007-2384)
HERNANDEZ, LUIS, PEOPLE v820KA 08-02135(I2006-1534)
HILL, SPENCER, PEOPLE v688KA 08-02637(I2007-1253)
J., CYNTHIA v P., DAVID C.698CA 09-02620(2007/9950)
JOHNSON, KIMBERLY v CANTIE, FRANK500CA 09-01064(I2006-11594)
JOHNSON, SHANNON L. v YARUSSI CONSTRUCTION, INC.,655CA 09-01993(2005-6258)
JOHNSON, TERRANCE, PEOPLE v441KA 07-02677(I00031-2007)
LAUFFER, ALYSIA J. v MACEY, JENNIFER L.768CA 10-00234(2007-6330)
LIEBEL & MERLE SALES, INC., v POLYMER CONVERSIONS, INC.,593CA 09-02500(I 2005-8897)
LORENZO, DAWN M. v KAHN, M.D., KENNETH R.302CA 09-01027(I2000/10059)
LYMAN, RICHARD v TOWN OF AMHERST,792CA 09-02267(I2004-11950)
MANCUSO, JULIE J. v KOCH, M.D., TODD B.567CA 09-00893(2001/9618)
MANCUSO, JULIE J. v KOCH, M.D., TODD B.568CA 09-00894(2001/9618)
MEEGAN, JR., ROBERT P. v BROWN, BYRON W.762CA 09-01748(6718-2008)
MEEGAN, JR., ROBERT P. v BROWN, BYRON W.763CA 09-01749(6718-2008)
NAZARIO, EDWELL, PEOPLE v730KA 09-01190(I2008-2466)
ORLANDO, ROCCO C. v GAUDA, ROGER C.741CA 10-00304(I2006-11835)
P., SERENITY, MTR. OF824CAF 09-00969(NN-18659-08, NN-18660-08
PAONE, VINCENT, PEOPLE v755KA 09-01188(I2007-2463)
PIERI, SR., DUANE v B&B WELCH ASSOCIATES,542CA 09-02328(2006-9035)
PRUCHNICKI, JR., DANIEL, PEOPLE v759KA 09-00833(I2007-1895S)
RODRIGUEZ, ADA v WESTERN REGIONAL OFF-TRACK BETTING,742CA 09-02342(I2009-5357)
S., DEVRE, MTR. OF808CAF 09-00627(NA-4991-92-08)
SAFFORD, JERMAINE, PEOPLE v781KA 08-02242(I2006-3040)
SHAPARD, CHRISTOPHER M., PEOPLE v727KA 09-00749(I2006-0178)
SIMON, STEPHEN, PEOPLE v821KA 09-00922(I2007-00950)
STEGURA, MICHELLE T. v FOX, SCOTT M.722CA 09-02115(2007-011349)
STOJEK, JANICE M. v CLEAR-ALL,851CA 09-02246(I2007-2104)
T., MAJERAE, MTR. OF693CAF 09-01376(NN-14239-08)
THE NEW KAYAK POOL CORPORATION, v KAVINOKY COOK, LLP,813CA 10-00073(2007-860)
TOM GREENAUER DEVELOPMENT, INC., v BURKE BROTHERS CONSTRUCTION, INC.,595CA 09-02502(I 2004-9153)
TRONOLONE, DANIEL G. v JANKOWSKI, BERNARD F.478CA 09-02372(2007-5201)
VEGA, JOSEPH, PEOPLE v777KA 09-00793(S30271)
W., ELIZABETH, MTR. OF696CAF 09-00543(NN-03363-08, NN-03364-08
WILLIAM, BASKWALI, PEOPLE v710KA 09-00510(I2008-0718)
YARGEAU, ALICE v LASERTRON,725CA 09-02211(2008/013494)
YARGEAU, ALICE v LASERTRON,724CA 09-02102(I2006-13494)
YOUNG, MALCOLM, PEOPLE v856KA 09-00390(I2008-1406)
 
Genesee
BAKER, KEVIN, PEOPLE v728KA 09-01369(S09-043)
E., RYAN M., PEOPLE v776KA 09-01368(I WY-5706)
KIRKUP, ROBERT, PEOPLE v798KA 08-02469(S08-065)
PIECHOCKI, III, ROBERT v TOWN OF ALEXANDER,736CA 10-00220(57850)
WILLIAMS, ROBERT L., PEOPLE v780KA 09-00160(I5091)
 
Herkimer
SUTTON, APRIL J. v SUTTON, JOSEPH E.787CAF 09-02630(V-00841-08/08AB)
 
Jefferson
PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK v LAWRENCE, SR., JAMES238CA 09-01671(2008-3041)
RODRIGUES, SARA N., PEOPLE v759.1KA 09-00196(I08-014-08)
TAITT, FRANCES J. v SNELLING, CHARLES D.769CA 09-01406(2006-843)
TAITT, FRANCES J. v SNELLING, CHARLES D.770CA 09-01408(2006-843)
 
Livingston
DAVIDSON, LAURALEE v COACH USA, INC.,748CA 10-00070(131-2007)
DAVIDSON, LAURALEE v COACH USA, INC.,749CA 10-00072(131-2007)
L., JR., JAMES, MTR. OF672CAF 09-01855(S-1335-08)
L., JR., JAMES, MTR. OF673CAF 09-01857(S-1335-08)
ROACH, MICHAEL v COACH USA, INC.,747CA 10-00069(131-2007)
ROACH, MICHAEL v COACH USA, INC.,746CA 10-00068(131-2007)
 
Monroe
ALLIED BUILDERS, INC., v GREECE CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,127CA 09-01415(2006-06007)
ALLIED BUILDERS, INC., v GREECE CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,128CA 09-01417(6007-06)
ANDERSON, ROBERT K. v GREAT EASTERN MALL, L.P.,635CA 09-01229(13221-03)
BRYANT, KEVIN C., PEOPLE v711KA 10-00250(2003/392)
C.P. WARD, INC., v DELOITTE & TOUCHE LLP,771CA 10-00039(2000/8356)
DEACON, ARRINE O., PEOPLE v756KA 07-01957(I2006-0908)
ESSLER, SHAWN, PEOPLE v775KA 10-00291(2008-0960)
GILBERT, JENNIFER, PEOPLE v707KA 07-01648(I07/94)
GOLDSTEIN, D.D.S., NEIL v BROOKWOOD BUILDING CORPORATION,717CA 10-00121(07/6649)
GUTIERREZ, JOSE, PEOPLE v779KA 03-02419(I2002-0223)
HENNER, MICHAEL v EVERDRY MARKETING AND MANAGEMENT,676CA 09-01832(06-11603)
HENNER, MICHAEL v EVERDRY MARKETING AND MANAGEMENT,677CA 09-01833(2006/11603)
JEFFERSON, DONNELL, PEOPLE v622KA 08-02121(I92-0053)
LABAR, JODI S. v MOSEZELL, PHILLIPS849CA 10-00350(2644-08)
LETMAN, DERICK, PEOPLE v819KA 07-01380(I06/716)
MANCUSO, CHRISTOPHER M., PEOPLE v804KA 07-01488(I2006/0139B)
MCKEE, MARGUERITE v PLONSKY, STEVEN679CA 09-02113(2008/5729)
MONTALVO, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v778KA 09-00292(2006/511) & (I2006-0016)
NILSEN, PATRICK R., PEOPLE v796KA 09-00277(I2006-0346)
OPHARDT, ANDREW v VASQUEZ, JULIO591TP 09-00945(08/013191)
OPHARDT, ANDREW v VASQUEZ, JULIO592CA 09-01337(08-13191)
PARRIS, ULYSEES, PEOPLE v842KA 08-01203(I2005-0712)
POE, HEIDI v POE, MARK C.719CA 10-00060(2006-05661)
PORTER, MICHAEL T. v NESBITT, JULIE A.695CAF 09-00640(V-10508-06/08A)
ROUSE, JACOB, PEOPLE v758KA 07-00127(I2006-0235)
SAMPSON, DEMETRIUS F., PEOPLE v862KA 08-00486(I2006-0550)
SCHREIBER, DEAN v UNIVERSITY OF ROCHESTER MEDICAL CEN,743CA 09-02275(2001-004198)
SCHUYLER, DOLORES N. v STRONG MEMORIAL HOSPITAL,654CA 09-01854(15497-06)
STEVENS, TERRY L. v ALLIED BUILDERS, INC.,630CA 09-02563(12363-08)
X-MED, INC., v WESTERN NEW YORK SPINE, INC.,297CA 09-01693(07-10414)
YELDER, JR., ORLANDO, PEOPLE v800KA 08-01374(I2006-0266B)
 
Niagara
ALLEN, GILBERT H. v KALEIDA HEALTH,830CA 10-00181(127053)
BANKS, RODNEY, PEOPLE v691KA 09-01326(I2007-545)
BARTO, DAVID A. v NS PARTNERS, LLC,472CA 09-02417(130235)
CHAFFEE, JENNIFER v LOCKPORT MEMORIAL HOSPITAL,854CA 10-00044(126524)
COLEMAN, CLYDE v ISG LACKAWANNA SERVICES, LLC,764CA 10-00340(121359)
CROSS, CORNELIUS, PEOPLE v686KA 09-01365(I2004-141)
MARKEL, ANTHONY, PEOPLE v752KA 09-01285(I2008-384)
MARTINO, JENNIFER D. v STOLZMAN, MICHAEL A.651CA 09-02359(131926)
PERNA, MICHAEL R., PEOPLE v726KA 09-01045(I2007-201-V)
PERNA, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v731KA 09-01046(I2007-201)
SEVENSON ENVIRONMENTAL SERVS., INC., v THOMAS JOHNSON, INC.,613CA 09-02516(129354)
WALLACE, LICIA A., PEOPLE v795KA 09-01201(I2006-027-V)
WORKMAN, SR., ANTHONY G., PEOPLE v684KA 09-00475(I2005-406)
ZARAGOSA, GILBERT, PEOPLE v835KA 09-00204(I2007-064-1)
 
Oneida
ADZAJLIC, ALEN, PEOPLE v860KA 09-02036(I04-155)
FULLER, CHRISTOPHER E., PEOPLE v685KA 08-01923(II07-335)
H., SEAN, MTR. OF783CAF 09-00816(B-04711-06/08D,)
KOSS, WLODEK v MICHAUD, CHRISTINE L.645CAF 09-02237(V-00508-07/08E)
MURAD, JACQUELYN E. v RUSSO, JOSEPHINE761CA 10-00156(CA2008-000831)
PINK, RAYMOND v RICCI, MATTHEW656CA 09-02395(2008-423)
RAMIREZ, ADELYN v VELAZQUEZ, ERIC L.629CAF 09-00738(V-02561-08, V-02562-08)
S., FRANCHESCA L., MTR. OF826CAF 09-01576(B-04992-05, B-04993-05)
SITTS, JOSEPH B. v SITTS, ALLISON L.479CA 09-02607(D2008-043805)
THE INDIUM CORPORATION OF AMERICA, v MCP GROUP SA,740CA 10-00112(2009-934)
 
Onondaga
FERRIS, SR., JON DENNIS v BENBOW CHEMICAL PACKAGING, INC.,772CA 10-00109(2008-2706)
GILLIAM, TYSAMOE T., PEOPLE v799KA 08-02609(I2005-0055-1-V)
GRUNINGER, MICHAEL v NATIOINWIDE MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPAN,637CA 09-02001(2007-6335)
GUIFFRIDA, MICHAEL v STORICO DEVELOPMENT, LLC,829CA 10-00300(2005-3142)
H., MICAH, MTR. OF784CAF 09-01572(B-7801-08)
RODRIGUEZ, JUAN, PEOPLE v836KA 07-01177(SI-2001-0648-1-V)
SCERBO, ALBERT, PEOPLE v559KA 09-01688(I2007-383-1)
SCHWIMMER, PHILIPPE R. v ROTH, JOAN716CA 09-02298(2007-4498)
SCHWIMMER, PHILIPPE R. v ROTH, JOAN715CA 09-02297(2006-5892)
SIMCOE, HAROLD, PEOPLE v837KA 08-01518(I2007-1002-1)
SOMMERS, III, ALBERT C., PEOPLE v754KA 08-00521(I2007-0966-1)
WHITING, LAURIE J. v PALUMBO, JOSEPH846CAF 09-01907(F-01758-02/08I)
WYNIT, INC., v SMARTPARTS, INC.,473CA 09-02469(2009-2240)
 
Ontario
ANTHONY, ROBERT E., PEOPLE v713KA 08-01142(I07-07-107)
COLON-VELAZQUEZ, FRANKIE C., PEOPLE v709KA 08-01683(I06-10-139)
COLON-VELAZQUEZ, FRANKIE C., PEOPLE v704KA 08-01684(I06-10-138)
CONSILIO, CARYN, PEOPLE v733KA 10-00030(08/01-027)
GANNETT CO., INC., v DORAN, CRAIG J.699OP 09-02287
HUNT, RACHEL L., PEOPLE v581KA 08-00893(I07-07-095)
POTTER, STEPHEN N., PEOPLE v687KA 09-01459(I08-10-146)
 
Orleans
DASH, RANDY L., PEOPLE v839KA 08-02481(I08-32)
EIBL, LISA v SNYDER, STEVEN760CA 10-00253(06-32224)
SHANNON, ARCHIE v KHAHAIFA, SIBATU864KAH 09-00045(08-35058)
 
Oswego
BRAND, NORBERT F., PEOPLE v705KA 09-01023(I06C-237)
KENNEDY, THOMAS R., PEOPLE v802KA 10-00158(08-110)
WOOLWORTH, JOAN, MTR. OF701CA 10-00127(06248)
 
Seneca
ALSTER, STEVEN v FISCHER, BRIAN750TP 09-02568(43160)
HAQUE, ANWAR v LEMPKE, JOHN751TP 10-00263(43324)
 
Steuben
JOHNSON, CONNIE L. v ROSE, JOSHUA G.850CA 09-02524(99047)
STILES, MATTHEW v EDWARDS, JILL M.875.1CAF 09-02618(V-00454-06/09B,C,D)
 
Wayne
KONSTANTINOU, GEORGE v PHOENIX INSURANCE COMPANY,811CA 10-00162(61775)
LOUDER, III, FRANKIE, PEOPLE v803KA 09-00274(I08-107)
SANCHEZ, RABI R., PEOPLE v706KA 07-00806(I06-48)
TAFT, NADIA v VILLAGE OF NEWARK PLANNING BOARD,790CA 09-02276(62612)
 
Wyoming
JOHNSON, MARK v STATE OF NEW YORK,870CA 09-02112(105385)
POWELL, CALVIN v NYS DEPT CORRECTIONAL SERVICES,692KAH 08-01509(20,636-08)
 
Yates
BORUM, CORI A. v BORUM, DAVID865CAF 09-01730(V-00352-08)
    
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS