Welcome
Home
THE COURT
    Overview of the Appellate Division
    Justices of the Court
    The Courthouse
DECISIONS
    Latest Decisions
    Decision Release Dates
    Search
CLERKS OFFICE
    Clerk and Deputy Clerk of the Court
    Contact Information
    Terms of the Court
    Court Calendars
    Rules of Practice
    Frequently Asked Questions
    Forms and Practice Aids
    Latest Court News
    Employment Opportunities
ATTORNEY MATTERS
    Admission to the Bar
    Attorney Discipline
    Attorney Registration Delinquency
    Registration as In-House Counsel
    Retirement
    Voluntary Resignation
PROGRAMS & AUXILIARY AGENCIES
    Assigned Counsel Program
    Attorneys for Children Program
    Attorney Grievance Committees
    Court Examiners
    Indep. Judicial Election Qual. Comm.
    Law Library
    Mental Hygiene Legal Service
    Pro Bono Policy and Program
RELATED LINKS
   Court sites
   Legal sites




Decisions - October 1, 2010

 
Cattaraugus
BIRD, JOHN J. v BIRD, VICKIE L.1047CA 09-01404(73548)
O'BRIEN, DAVID M., PEOPLE v1129KA 09-01837(I08-112)
SLADE, AARON S. v HOSACK, TONYA S.1086CAF 08-02490(V-748-06/08B, C)
 
Cayuga
GOD OF THUNDER PRODUCTIONS, LTD, v STAROPOLI, ALESSANDRO985CA 09-01686(2008-1493)
MAGIC CIRCLE MUSIC, LTD., v STAROPOLI, ALESSANDRO1112CA 10-00729(2008-1408)
PARR, RUBEN v MONGARELLA, ANDREW J.1117CA 09-01655(06-524)
SPINOSA, LANCE v BECK, CHARLES F.1113CA 09-01282(2007-1097)
 
Erie
ACCURSO, NINA A. v KLOC, NICOLE M.933CA 10-00561(2008-0110)
AMERICAN DIABETES ASSOCIATION, v ABBEY, MECCA & CO., INC.,992CA 10-00388(2007-12579)
ARIEL, RAFIQA v ARIEL, JR., DONALD1021CAF 09-01877(V-20745-08/08A)
CARUANA, MARY v PADMANABHA, M.S., BHAVANSA953CA 10-00787(I2008/6426)
CHATT, LEON, PEOPLE v926KA 08-01135(I2006-1940)
COOPER, CARL M., PEOPLE v1101KA 08-02522(I2008-0239)
COOPER, CARL M., PEOPLE v1102KA 08-02521(I2008-0792)
CRAVATTA, MICHAEL J. v NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF TRANSP, ORTATION1078CA 10-00770(13429-08)
CURELLA, DOUGLAS J. v TOWN OF AMHERST,944CA 10-00614(2008-3209)
D'ANGELO, STEPHANIE v LITTERER, ANDREA S.1034CA 10-00709(2008-5890)
DINATALE, ROBIN v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN,1003TP 09-01922(007734/2009)
EBERLE, JAN v HUGHES, III, M.D., THOMAS F.1076CA 09-01908(I 2007-554)
GALLO, PAULINE v RIESKE, MELINDA1004CA 10-00391(2006-8778)
GIARDINA, SHARON J. v LIPPES, RICHARD J.929CA 09-02251(2003-8028)
GRAHAM, DARRELL, PEOPLE v1123KA 09-00320(I2007-1641)
GRAHAM, DARRELL, PEOPLE v1124KA 09-00577(I2007-2735)
HARRIS, GEORGE L., PEOPLE v940KA 08-02540(I2008-0381)
HARRIS, JR., FRED, PEOPLE v979KA 09-01483(S31665)
J., ALEXANDRA, MTR. OF942CAF 09-00874(NN-15539-08, NN-15540-08
JOHNSON, DARRELL, PEOPLE v1126KA 08-02228(I2006-2843)
K., GEORGE, MTR. OF941CAF 09-01595(NN-15606-15611-2008)
KIDDER, MARY v MOORE, LARRY947CA 10-00445(I2008-003378)
LAIDLAW ENERGY AND ENVIRONMENTAL, v TOWN OF ELLICOTTVILLE,1053CA 10-00136(2007-6628)
LAPE, HOLLY v WILLIAM GOLDBACH, ROLLINS, INC.,950CA 09-01673(I2008-3876)
LAVANN, IVOIRE v BELL, JACOB1106CAF 09-00890(O-14709-08)
LEONE, DONALD v BRASON, DAVID1069CA 10-00651(2009-040)
M., DEONDRE, MTR. OF1020CAF 09-01735(B-10735-08)
MATTAR, LAWRENCE JOSEPH v HECKL, ROSANNA E.1061CA 10-00206(SF 2006-902242)
MAY, LEE O., PEOPLE v1057KA 09-00601(I1628-2005)
MCDUFFIE, JAMAR, PEOPLE v1018KA 09-01917(I2008-0502)
MORGAN, LOUIS, PEOPLE v1103KA 09-00604(I2007-2648)
NEW YORK STATE NURSES ASSOCIATION,, v COUNTY OF ERIE,1079CA 10-00094(11671/2008)
NIXON, WINNIE, PEOPLE v1128KA 08-02273(I2007-2076)
OWENS, LARRY, PEOPLE v1059KA 09-00720(I2008-01300R)
PAGE, FRANCIS v PAGE, JEAN ELLEN1110CAF 10-00297(F-16926-08/08B)
PINO ALTO PARTNERS, v ERIE COUNTY WATER AUTHORITY,946CA 09-02596(I2006-11957)
POLIZZI, DDS, GAETANO J. v IPPOLITO, MS, DDS, ANTHONY J.1072CA 10-00227(I2007-011026)
R., EDUARDO, MTR. OF983CAF 10-00735(D-10215-09)
R., ELEYDIE, ERIE COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL, SERVICES v1107CAF 09-01596(B-15445-08,)
ROBINSON, DAVID U. v BROADSPIRE SERVICES, INC.,936CA 09-02510(I2005-10829)
SCHENK, JEFFREY, PEOPLE v1100KA 09-00495(I2005-2310)
SEMRAU, RICHARD, PEOPLE v1122KA 07-01855(I02368-2006)
SHIRE, SHARMARKE, PEOPLE v1017KA 09-00740(I2008-0718)
SMIELECKI, WILLIAM J., PEOPLE v1104KA 08-02355(I00026-2008)
SMOLINSKI, THOMAS J. v SMOLINSKI, MATTHEW A.994CA 10-00714(5874/01)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v WILKES, HAROLD1143CA 09-01474(M 543,946-08)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v WILKES, HAROLD1141CA 09-01471(M 543,946-08)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v WILKES, HAROLD1142CA 09-01472(M 543,946-08)
TIRADO, KANDIS v KORITZ, SARA H.1029CA 10-00511(I-2008/6198)
TRZASKA, THOMAS J. v ALLIED FROZEN STORAGE, INC.,935CA 09-02509(2007-000871)
TRZASKA, THOMAS J. v ALLIED FROZEN STORAGE, INC.,930CA 10-00760(2007-0871)
TURNER, STEPHEN v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,1133CA 09-02575(2004-2110)
TURNER, STEPHEN v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,1132CA 09-02429(I2004-2110)
VAILLANT, ALEXANDER, PEOPLE v1060KA 09-02414(S31563)
VELOCITY INVESTMENTS, LLC, v COCINA, EVE MARIE952CA 09-02514(I-2007-1915)
WACHOVIA DEALER SERVICES, INC., v HARDEE, JAMES L.934CA 10-00472(2009-931)
WISNIEWSKI, STEVEN, PEOPLE v975KA 09-02569(I2007-0931)
WISNIEWSKI, STEVEN, PEOPLE v981KA 09-02570(S30465)
 
Genesee
TOWNSEND OIL CORPORATION, v MARINI, ANTHONY L.1099CA 10-00868(56071)
 
Herkimer
PETT, VICTOR, PEOPLE v921KA 08-01665(II08-007)
PLUNKETT, DAVID, PEOPLE v1127KA 09-01437(I06-063)
 
Jefferson
CRUMP, JR., RICHARD A., PEOPLE v997KA 09-01820(I08-358-08)
ROGERS, PENNY v SHERMAN, WILLIAM1114CA 10-00397(2006-1535)
SHAMPINE, NORMAN, PEOPLE v923KA 07-00810(03-0983) & (I694-02)
WEBB, JOHN v BOCK, CHARLES A.1097CA 09-02159(07-183)
WINDSONG LANE FARMS, v TELMARK, LLC,1073CA 09-01685(2004-2341)
WINDSONG LANE FARMS, v TELMARK, LLC,1074CA 09-01972(2004-2341)
WINDSONG LANE FARMS, v TELMARK, LLC,1075CA 09-01973(2004-2341)
 
Lewis
MARRIOTT, ALFRED F. v TOWN AND VILLAGE OF LOWVILLE ZONING,1091CA 10-00354(CA2009-000212)
 
Livingston
MILLER, ANDREW J., PEOPLE v1056KA 07-02427(I95-116)
NICHOLS, JUSTIN, PEOPLE v1000KA 09-00003(I2007-120A)
SNYDER, MARGARET v PLANK, DONALD991CA 10-00510(360-2009)
 
Monroe
B., WHYTNEI, MTR. OF1001CAF 09-00699(B-7436-07, B-1279/80-07)
BATCHATEU, BEST v PETERS, DAVID R.1025TP 09-02097(2009/5932)
BATJER, SCOTT, PEOPLE v920KA 10-00875(0398/07)
BERMUDEZ, VINCENT, PEOPLE v925KA 07-01379(I438/06)
BREAN, RENEE L. v LOVE, RICK D.1033CA 10-00564(15421-07)
CANNON, GEOFF v COR RIDGE ROAD COMPANY, LLC,1096CA 09-01527(2006/9286)
DAVIS, BRANDON L., PEOPLE v927KA 07-01265(I2006-0395)
EASTMAN KODAK COMPANY, v CARMOSINO, ROBERT1121.1CA 10-01062(2010/02022)
FANTIGROSSI, JR., JAMES F. v BRANNON HOMES, INC.,1094CA 10-00414(2007/8118)
GRAY, STEVE J., PEOPLE v955KA 10-00748(331/08)
HENDERSON, LYNN, PEOPLE v958KA 07-01866(I2007-0078)
KALKMAN, LAURIE, COULTER, GEOFFREY R. v928CA 09-02444(1994 DT 00316/B)
KNOPE, OLGA v KNOPE, GERARD S.968CA 10-00342(2007-13482)
M., JUSTYCE, MTR. OF1085CAF 09-01777(NN-05050-09, NN-05054-09
MACON, MARCUS M., PEOPLE v939KA 07-01633(I2006-0954C)
MARGOLIS, JANE L. v VOLKSWAGEN OF AMERICA, INC.,967CA 10-00049(4089/02)
MARGOLIS, JANE L. v VOLKSWAGEN OF AMERICA, INC.,972CA 08-02012(2002-4089)
MCDONELL, KYLE P. v NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF MOTOR, VEHICLES1043TP 10-00878(2867-2010)
MCFARLEY, JR., JAMES, PEOPLE v922KA 07-01489(I2000-0455)
MCMILLON, JR., ANDRE M., PEOPLE v1038KA 09-00533(I502/2008)
MENDEZ, JOSE, PEOPLE v960KA 07-00416(I0442/06)
MILLER, BRIAN v MILLER, JENNIFER1084CAF 09-02613(F-04420-06A-D)
MIRANDA, ISRAEL, PEOPLE v974KA 05-00500(I2003-0354)
MITCHELL, LATEIK, PEOPLE v1039KA 05-00257(I559/2003)
MUDHOLKAR, GOVIND S. v THE UNIVERSITY OF ROCHESTER,1027CA 10-00761(09-05950)
RADKO, MARIE v BANWAR, M.D., NITIN S.948CA 10-00516(6755-03)
RUSH, EUGENE, PEOPLE v1019KA 07-01909(I2006-0686)
SELTZER, LAWRENCE v CITY OF ROCHESTER,943TP 10-00789(2009-2093)
SHROUT, KIMBERLY A. v ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC CORPORATIO, N1032CA 09-02560(2003/7032)
SIMPSON, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v963KA 06-03432(I44/06)
VICENS, ORLANDO, PEOPLE v1058KA 09-00496(I1993-W-0064)
 
Niagara
BOWLER, SANDRA v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HU,1044TP 10-00767(136596)
KABALAN, GABRIELE v HOGHOOGHI, DDS, ALEXANDER1009CA 09-02247(125851)
KARCZ, JR., JOHN W. v KLEWIN BUILDING COMPANY, INC.,1026CA 10-00858(123582)
PAYNE, ALMA D. v R-D MAINTENANCE UNLIMITED, INC.,937CA 09-02103(122247)
RLI INSURANCE COMPANY, v SMIEDALA, LESLIE931CA 09-02296(130744/07)
SCHRADER, DENITA v SCHRADER, DANIEL1111CA 10-00576(103660)
TRANE, MARK v HASTEE, JAMES R.1030CA 10-00874(I28055)
 
Oneida
ANGELICOLA, ROBERTO v PATRICK HEATING OF MOHAWK,973CA 09-01405(2005-001312)
BORK, MARGUERITE D., PEOPLE v919KA 07-01565(II06-335)
CAPODIFERRO, NICOLE M. v CAPODIFERRO, ROBERT A.1136CA 09-02453(D2006-42923)
CARPENTER, ROBERT M. v NY ADVANCE ELECTRIC, INC.,1005CA 10-00497(I300030/2009)
CHUCK TOMASELLI, DOING BUSINESS AS, v ONEIDA COUNTY INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMEN,964CA 10-00396(2008 -410)
ROY, DONNA L., PEOPLE v957KA 08-02546(II07-450)
SHARLOW, JAMIE WURZ v SHARLOW, JR., ROBERT1118CA 10-00526(2006-042976)
SINGH, PAUL D., PEOPLE v980KA 10-00711(I-08-152)
TODD, CAROL ANN v MORRISON, ALISTAIR CHARLES1105CAF 10-00864(F-06037-08)
V., ALEXIS, VANDUSEN, WILLIAM v1014.2CAF 10-00115(V-10569-09/09BN)
VANDUSEN, WILLIAM v RIGGS, MELISSA L.1014.1CAF 09-01397(V-10569-99/08BM)
WATKINS, JAMES, PEOPLE v1081KA 09-00349(II08-275)
 
Onondaga
BANK OF UTICA, v CITY OF SYRACUSE,993CA 10-00603(09-1939)
BRADBURY, GREGORY v MONAGHAN, GENEVA1108CAF 10-00128(V-08013-08, V-08014-08)
BRADBURY, GREGORY v MONAGHAN, GENEVA1109CAF 10-00129(V-08013-08/09A,)
CRANE-HOGAN STRUCTURAL SYSTEMS, INC, v ESLS DEVELOPMENT, LLC,945CA 10-00527(3728/08)
DOSANJH, HARWANT, MTR. OF1010CA 10-00433(08-0896)
DRURY, PHILLIP v VILLAGE OF NORTH SYRACUSE,1064TP 10-00459(2010-0027)
GUERESCHI, DANIEL v FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF NEW YORK,1046CA 09-02586(2007-8699)
H., ALFONSO, MTR. OF1089CAF 09-01293(NN-00063-09)
HAYES, KELLY v NORSTAR APARTMENTS, LLC,987CA 10-00643(2008-4007)
JAMES SYRACUSE LLC, v GAMAGE, JOHN C.1014CA 10-00584(2006-2552)
JAMES SYRACUSE LLC, v GAMAGE, JOHN C.1013CA 10-00583(2006-2551)
JAMES SYRACUSE LLC, v GAMAGE, JOHN C.1012CA 10-00582(2005-2338)
JONES, JR., DENNIS D., PEOPLE v961KA 06-02499(I2006-0498-1)
MEDLER, PATRICK, PEOPLE v1082KA 09-00698(I2008-0787-1)
OGDEN, PHYLLIS G. v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF,1065TP 10-00363(2009-6615)
PETERSON, HELEN v DAINES, M.D., RICHARD F.1063TP 10-00736(2010-0031)
PURCELL, JULIE v JEFFERSON COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY,986CA 10-00710(07-6925)
RAUCH, SAHRINA H. v KELLER, BRIAN W.1087CAF 09-02190(V-04744-05/09C)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v FLAGG, DANIEL1079.1CA 10-00776(08C0001)
TAG MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, INC., v V.I.P. STRUCTURES, INC.,965CA 10-00649(2004-2520)
 
Ontario
CHILBERT, MICHELE S. v SOLER, ARCHANGEL L.1083CAF 09-01914(V00521-09)
CHILBERT, MICHELE S. v SOLER, ARCHANGEL L.1088CAF 09-01915(O-00418-09)
GENEVA CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT, v ANONYMOUS, A TENURED TEACHER,1024CA 10-00465(101900)
INNTEL MANAGEMENT CORPORATION, v CITY OF CANANDAIGUA,984OP 10-00167
LYON, BRIAN P., PEOPLE v999KA 08-01365(I07-10-115)
MATEO, DAMIAN J., PEOPLE v1037KA 09-00921(I04-10-105)
PEAY, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v956KA 08-01670(I07-01-006)
SCHAEFER, BETTY v TOWN OF VICTOR,1007CA 10-00074(99549)
STEARNS, ADAM R. v O'BRIEN, IRENE1049CA 10-00352(100093)
 
Orleans
RICHARDSON, JAMES E. v MURRAY TOWN COURT,969CA 09-02266(09-36574)
TESMER, MONICA v COLONNA, DAVID951CA 10-00708(07-33761)
 
Oswego
BAKER, ROBERT v COUNTY OF OSWEGO,1008CA 10-00507(06-0285)
CARSON, JEFFREY M. v TOWN OF OSWEGO,970CA 09-02320(2008-0539)
COUNCIL, NAHSHON AARON v UTICA FIRST INSURANCE COMPANY,1119CA 10-00775(08-8191)
FUREY, SCOTT, PEOPLE v1016KA 10-00766(08c-138)
GRAHAM, RICHARD L., PEOPLE v1145KA 10-01008(I 10C-12)
GRAHAM, KATHERINE A., PEOPLE v1144KA 10-01007(I 10C-13)
LEWIS, SUE Y. v TOWN OF RICHLAND,1098CA 10-00395(08-2267)
MONSAY, EVELYN H. v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN,1042TP 10-00790(10-276)
RIPKA, JOANN v RIPKA, ROBBIE1051CA 09-01605(2006-0089)
THOMAS, BRETT H., PEOPLE v976KA 08-02001(S07C-214)
TRACY, DALE R., PEOPLE v1080KA 09-01502(I08C-111)
 
Seneca
CARSON, GENERAL v WILLIAMS, MELVIN1041KAH 10-00166(42,602)
NICHOLSON, DAMON v A. ANASTASIO & SONS TRUCKING CO., I,988CA 10-00093(40650)
RODRIGUEZ, ALBERTO v FISCHER, BRIAN918TP 10-00042(43396)
 
Steuben
ANDRUS, EDWARD, PEOPLE v924KA 09-01246(I2007-341)
BROWN, TRISHA v ARNOT MEDICAL CENTER,1050CA 10-00225(96518)
E., ZANNA, MTR. OF1022CAF 09-00541(NA03057-07, NA03056-07)
ROLL, GARY S. v GAVITT, ASHLEIGH A.1092CA 10-00099(101646)
 
Wayne
COLLIER, WILLIAM, PEOPLE v954KA 09-01283(I08-157)
HOUSE, MARLIN, PEOPLE v996KA 09-01554(I08-88)
LOVELESS FAMILY TRUST, v KOENIG, PAUL1135CA 10-00249(57585) & (65785)
TONZI, CAROL A. v NICHOLS, RICHARD H.1140CA 10-00408(59082)
TONZI, CAROL A., MTR. OF1139CA 10-00407(59082)
VANLARE, KENNETH, PEOPLE v962KA 09-01048(I08-120)
 
Wyoming
DIAZ, JUAN, PEOPLE v1125KA 09-02345(I6046)
SIMMONS, ERIK, PEOPLE v1015KA 09-02346(I5959)
 
Yates
PRATT, COLLEEN, PEOPLE v998KA 09-01887(S09-20)
    
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS