Welcome
Home
THE COURT
    Overview of the Appellate Division
    Justices of the Court
    The Courthouse
DECISIONS
    Latest Decisions
    Decision Release Dates
    Search
CLERKS OFFICE
    Clerk and Deputy Clerk of the Court
    Contact Information
    Terms of the Court
    Court Calendars
    Rules of Practice
    Frequently Asked Questions
    Forms and Practice Aids
    Latest Court News
    Employment Opportunities
ATTORNEY MATTERS
    Admission to the Bar
    Attorney Discipline
    Attorney Registration Delinquency
    Registration as In-House Counsel
    Retirement
    Voluntary Resignation
PROGRAMS & AUXILIARY AGENCIES
    Assigned Counsel Program
    Attorneys for Children Program
    Attorney Grievance Committees
    Court Examiners
    Indep. Judicial Election Qual. Comm.
    Law Library
    Mental Hygiene Legal Service
    Pro Bono Policy and Program
RELATED LINKS
   Court sites
   Legal sites




Decisions - November 12, 2010

 
Allegany
HADSELL, MARK K., PEOPLE v1295KA 09-01145(S08-107-V)
 
Cattaraugus
ALOI, STEVEN, PEOPLE v1220KA 09-01255(I08-017)
ALOI, STEVEN, PEOPLE v1221KA 10-00165(I08-017)
B., ROSEMARIE v C., CAROL1278CAF 09-01656(V-01009-09)
C., ANNASTASIA, CATTARAUGUS COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF, SOCIAL SERVICES v1284CAF 09-01567(NN-1565-08)
C., LOKI, MTR. OF1285CAF 09-01568(NA-1567, 1568-08)
C., ANNASTASIA, MTR. OF1290CAF 09-01566(NN-1566-08; NA-1569,)
REED, CYRUS Y., PEOPLE v982KA 09-00284(I08-082)
 
Cayuga
ARCHIE, DEREK L., PEOPLE v1247KA 09-02640(I2009-042)
CLARKSON, DOUGLAS, PEOPLE v1276KA 09-01276(I2007-108)
KENNEDY, TROY L., PEOPLE v959KA 09-01166(I2008-087)
STILES, RONALD K., PEOPLE v1272KA 09-02088(S2009-156)
VANANTWERP, JONATHON A., PEOPLE v1197KA 09-02278(S2009-162)
 
Chautauqua
BOND, GEOFFREY v TURNER, THOMAS A.1045CA 10-00746(K1-2008-889)
JACKSON, LOUIS J. v BEACH, DEBBRA K.1226CAF 09-00991(V-78-00/08Y, V-78-00/08Z
 
Erie
ALESSIO, JENNIFER v BURCH, HAROLD1368CAF 09-02494(O-13555-09)
A., AKEIRA, MTR. OF1363CAF 09-02493(NN-03857-09)
A., BABY GIRL, MTR. OF1227CAF 09-01388(NA-02470-09)
AYLSWORTH, DONNA M. v KOWALCZYK, GREGORY1160CA 10-00542(SF-1999-901097)
BENTON, JONATHAN, PEOPLE v1219KA 10-00605(I02002-2008)
BOIVIN, WAYNE A. v THE MARRANO/MARC EQUITY GROUP,1265CA 10-01186(2007-6331)
CARRASQUILLO, CHRISTOPHER v SEB DEVELOPMENT, LLC,1331CA 10-01009(2006-8329)
CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC., MURPHY, JOHN v1213CA 09-02450(I2004-680)
DRAMAN, SHANE M. v NEW YORK STATE OFFICE OF CHILDREN A,1333TP 10-01166(2010/2888)
DRENNEN, MICHAEL, MTR. OF1185CA 10-00950(2009-1093)
ENDRES, EUGENE v MOSEY, ACEY M.1310CA 10-00901(2006-011/A)
FAC CONTINENTAL LLC, v YICKJING567 LLC,1156CA 10-00268(I2007-12419)
FAC CONTINENTAL LLC, v YICKJING567 LLC,1157CA 10-00269(I2007-12419)
GILBERT, NATHANIEL, PEOPLE v1293KA 09-00596(I0540-S01)
HARNANTO, JOSHUA M. v GANDASAPUTRA, YVONNE1186CAF 09-02255(V-04710-09/09B,)
H., MIKIA, MTR. OF1279CAF 09-01726(B-124-127-2008)
IPPOLITO, MS, DDS, ANTHONY J. v POLIZZI, DDS, GAETANO J.1322CA 10-00318(I2009-008315)
JOHNSON, CHARLES T., PEOPLE v1224KA 09-00860(I2007-0966)
K., NOREON, MTR. OF1280CAF 09-01675(B-00126-08, V-03001-08)
LAURICELLA, JR., SALVATORE v LAURICELLA, SAMANTHA1367CAF 10-00835(F-06602-09)
L., STEVEN, MTR. OF1366CAF 09-02183(AS-19939-05/08A,)
MCCANN, KARA R. v HARLEYSVILLE INSURANCE COMPANY OF N,1179CA 10-00612(I2007-10372)
MCCANN, KARA R. v HARLEYSVILLE INSURANCE COMPANY OF N,1180CA 10-00613(I2007-10372)
MCCORMICK, TIMOTHY P. v 257 W. GENESEE, LLC,1291CA 10-00437(I-2007-1539)
MORRIS, ANTHONY, PEOPLE v1356KA 08-02630(I2007-2798D)
MURPHY, JOHN v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,1214CA 09-02452(I2004-680)
NEW YORK STATE THRUWAY AUTHORITY, v KTA-TATOR ENGINEERING SERVICES,1257CA 10-00474(I-2004-11115TP1)
PFAFFENBACH, NATHAN v NEMEC, DOUGLAS J.1031CA 10-00749(I2008-6645)
PICCIONE, GEORGE, PEOPLE v1173KA 09-00173(I00158-2008-S01)
PONHOLZER, DONNA v SIMMONS, EDWARD1071CA 10-00740(I2004/5867)
R.-A., JEZEKIAH, ERIE COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL, SERVICES v1228CAF 09-01389(NA-11876-77-08)
RICHEY, CHANELLE C. v HAMM, MARY LOU1332CA 10-00194(2009005005)
ROMANELLO, ANNE M. v FINLAY, KENNETH S.1349CA 10-00411(2008-7356)
RUFFINS, AARON L., PEOPLE v1382KA 09-02019(0036-2008)
SMITH, DAMION, PEOPLE v1292KA 07-00800(I99-2384-001)
SWARTZ, DERRICK A. v KALSON, VICTOR F.1232CA 10-01003(I 2008-2846)
WASHINGTON, DENNIS, PEOPLE v1195KA 09-00856(I2008-1432)
W., SYIRA, MTR. OF1231CAF 09-01862(NN-09776-78-2008)
WILLIAMS, LUSHAWN A., PEOPLE v1151KA 09-01577(I2007-1951)
WINIARSKI, RICHARD v HARRIS, M.D., LINDA1239CA 10-00490(2007/3375)
WINIARSKI, RICHARD v HARRIS, M.D., LINDA1240CA 10-00585(2007/3375)
WINIARSKI, RICHARD v HARRIS, M.D., LINDA1238CA 10-00374(2007/3375)
W., AUDRIANNA, MTR. OF1277CAF 09-02035(NN-02173-08, NN-02174-08
YOONESSI, MAHMOOD v GIVENS, DEBRA L.1373CA 10-00578(I2003/9143)
 
Genesee
CHRISTOPHER, STEVEN v STATE OF NEW YORK,1209CA 09-01780(108185)
DANIELS, BURNIE, PEOPLE v1316KA 09-00726(I5107)
LONGHINE, JEFFREY, PEOPLE v1171KA 09-02052(T-5768)
MOORE, JOSHUA C. v MOORE, DESIREE1385CAF 09-01265(V-00559-08,)
PALASZYNSKI, PAMELA v MATTICE, BEVERLY J.1189CA 10-00722(56825)
PALASZYNSKI, PAMELA v MATTICE, BEVERLY J.1188CA 10-00639(56825)
 
Jefferson
CONSUMER SOLUTIONS REO, LLC, v GIGLIO, JOHN A.1344CA 10-00005(2008-1827)
DEVANE, TRAVIS V., PEOPLE v1298KA 09-01511(I276-08)
MADILL, JAMES W., PEOPLE v1338KA 09-00822(I03-500-03-V)
SYMONDS, JR., HAROLD D. v BERLIN, BETH1354TP 10-01194(2010-566)
 
Livingston
BETTS, CYNTHIA A. v TOWN OF MOUNT MORRIS,1328CA 10-01176(452-2007)
CASE, THOMAS V. v CASE, ANTONE R.1348CA 10-00567(297-2003)
MACWILLIAMS, MARGUERITE v MACWILLIAMS, ROBERT1205CAF 09-02496(F-01145-04/09E)
 
Monroe
ALLEN, BRANDON O., PEOPLE v1176KA 07-01843(I2006-0769A)
BROWN, MARY v MONROE COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL, SERVICES971CA 10-00501(2004-2039/A)
CALDWELL, MICHAEL D., PEOPLE v1248KA 08-02470(I2006-0966A)
CASELLA, ROBERT v CITY OF ROCHESTER,1327CA 10-01269(09-16229)
COX, HENRY, PEOPLE v1274KA 09-00201(I2007-0925A)
DEAN, LAMARCUS, PEOPLE v1271KA 08-00030(I416/07)
DONALD, RONALDO M., PEOPLE v1273KA 09-00939(I2008-0568)
EATON, FAYE M. v WAYNE TEACHERS ASSOCIATION,1306CA 10-00528(2009-6118)
EXTALE, JAMES, PEOPLE v1174KA 08-00786(I2004-1076)
FISHER, AARON RICHARD, PEOPLE v1339KA 06-03538(I303/06)
HEATON, LISA v MONROE COUNTY,1093CA 10-00591(2009-01213)
KHUNS, SUSAN C. v BAY STATE INSURANCE COMPANY,1090CA 10-00231(04/11301)
LASTER, KEITH, PEOPLE v977KA 06-00672(I2000-466)
LASTER, KEITH, PEOPLE v978KA 06-00673(I2005-622)
MORRISON, PATRICK, PEOPLE v1359KA 07-01486(I2006-970)
MURCH, SCOTT v FIRST UNITED METHODIST CHURCH OF CA, NANDAIGUA1305CA 10-00321(07/00180)
NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN, v INDEPENDENT AUTO APPRAISERS, INC.,1212TP 10-00994(09/10545)
OWENS, ANTWON, PEOPLE v1154KA 07-00578(I2006-235)
PORCELLI, SUSAN, MTR. OF1323CA 09-01969(2006-1840)
POVOSKI, JR., FRANK J., PEOPLE v1198KA 07-01225(I2005-0040)
REED, CHARLES, PEOPLE v1194KA 07-02558(I2007-0415B)
REED, CHARLES, PEOPLE v1199KA 07-01033(I06-123)
RIVERA, HECTOR L., PEOPLE v1379KA 09-00493(I1995-W-0012)
SANTIAGO, JOSE J., PEOPLE v1216KA 07-02349(I210/99)
SAWYER, NICHOLAS, PEOPLE v1172KA 08-02464(2007-012295) & (I2007-0780)
SCOTT, CHARLIE J., PEOPLE v1196KA 08-00136(I2006-0913)
SNOW, BERNARD, PEOPLE v1362KA 07-01925(I2006-0969)
SUBURBAN TOOL & DIE CO., INC., v CENTURY MOLD COMPANY, INC.,1192.1CA 10-00785(2008/15399)
SULLIVAN, SHAWN v RGS ENERGY GROUP, INC.,1095CA 10-00682(2007/12462)
VELEZ, LUIS A., PEOPLE v1177KA 04-01659(I2003-0094C)
WASHINGTON, JR., JAMES E., PEOPLE v1299KA 06-03139(I2004-1148B)
WEST, RANDALL v FORTEQ NORTH AMERICA, INC.,1267CA 10-00347(2007/5931)
WEST, RANDALL, MTR. OF1266CA 10-00345(2007/05931)
WEST, RANDALL v FORTEQ NORTH AMERICA, INC.,1268CA 10-00348(2007/05931)
WHITED, ANDREW N., PEOPLE v1384KA 08-00155(I2006-0188)
 
Niagara
COPP, FLORENCE, PEOPLE v1225KA 09-01516(I2008-491-1)
DAVIS, MARLIN v HOSPITALITY MOTELS USA, INC.,1288CA 10-01263(2006-128110)
DYE, JR., MARVIN, PEOPLE v1340KA 09-01555(2003-253)
HOWARD, KEIKO v ROBB, PATRICK J.1309CA 10-00964(132037)
LORENTI, MARK v STICKL CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC.,1329CA 10-01185(134438)
MATT, RICHARD W., PEOPLE v1360KA 08-01373(I1998-012)
MELLON, DEBORAH v CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS,1236CA 10-01235(139321)
NATIONAL URBAN VENTURES, INC., v CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS,1190CA 10-00675(134497)
NATIONAL URBAN VENTURES, INC., v CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS,1184CA 10-00673(134497)
ONE NIAGARA LLC, v CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS,1237CA 10-01283(137559)
VERIZON NEW YORK, INC., v STATE OF NEW YORK,1324CA 09-01684(112333)
WATTS, PEREZ, PEOPLE v1317KA 09-02436(I2008-533)
WILLIS, ERIC, PEOPLE v1335KA 09-02303(I2009-101)
 
Oneida
ABBUHL, HOWARD A. v AMERICU CREDIT UNION,1208CA 10-01182(CA2009-000914)
FRANCIS, STEPHEN P., PEOPLE v1246KA 08-02679(II08-090)
HULIHAN, WILLIAM, ROLF, DONALD v1148TP 10-00888(CA2009-003463)
LUTZ, BETSY v STERLING, JASON1207CAF 09-02307(V-05909-95/09H)
MARTIN LUTHER NURSING HOME, INC., v DOWLING, MICHAEL J.1374CA 10-01013(94-10581)
MOHAWK VALLEY WATER AUTHORITY, v STATE OF NEW YORK,1165CA 10-00688(2005-928)
MOHAWK VALLEY WATER AUTHORITY, v STATE OF NEW YORK,1166CA 10-00689(CA2005-000928)
RIDER, HAROLD L. v CORRIGAN, KAREN1396CAF 10-00980(F-01378-09/09)
RIGGS, MELISSA L. v VANDUSEN, WILLIAM1282CAF 10-00114(F-04587-07/08C)
SCHNEIDER, JEFFREY M., LOMANTO, LISA L. v1204CAF 09-01782(F-03814-08/08B)
SCHNEIDER, JEFFREY M., LOMANTO, LISA L. v1203CAF 09-01781(F-03814-08/08B)
STANISTREET, BRADLEY R., PEOPLE v1296KA 09-00616(II07-366)
UTICA MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY, v MCATEER & FITZGERALD, INC.,1354.1CA 09-02448(2002-000808)
UTICA MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY, v MCATEER & FITZGERALD, INC.,1354.2CA 09-02449(2002-000808)
ZENZILLO, JANINE v UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYD'S LONDON,1211CA 10-00886(CA000535/06)
 
Onondaga
CHIARAPPA, WILLIAM, PEOPLE v1357KA 09-00507(SI-2007-0442-V-1)
CITY OF SYRACUSE INDUSTRIAL, DEVELOPMENT AGENCY v HESS CORPORATION,1178CA 09-00624(2008-4242)
COR BROKERAGE, INC., v NEW HARTFORD SHOPPING CENTER TRUST,1350CA 10-01167(2009-66844)
COUNTY OF ONONDAGA, v MAYOCK, BRIAN1397TP 10-01168(2010-1733)
FREEMAN, MATTHEW, PEOPLE v1149KA 07-00535(I2006-0765-2)
HANSEN, JAMES B. v CAROUSEL CENTER COMPANY, L.P.,1256CA 10-00065(2004-4764) & (2004-4764A)
HENDERSON, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v1150KA 07-00132(I2006-0237-1)
JONES, WILLIE J., PEOPLE v1319KA 07-00402(I2005-0769-1)
KING, CHRISTINE L. v FOSTER, WILLIAM P.1251CAF 10-00890(V-04232-04233-07/09B)
MARGETIN, RUSSELL v JEWETT, JR., ROBERT T.1011CA 10-00782(2003-6628)
O'CONNOR, LYNDA, PEOPLE v1244KA 08-00491(I2007-0312-5, SCI
ROTH, NORMAN E. v CITY OF SYRACUSE,1311CA 09-02503(2001-2698) & (2002-3223)
SPARCINO, JOSEPH G., PEOPLE v1153KA 10-01128(08-1429)
TOWN OF ONONDAGA, v RITTER, DIANA JONES1168TP 10-01232(2010-1909)
 
Ontario
BARNES, MONTRELL A., PEOPLE v1275KA 09-01765(I08-DI-027)
BOWERS, NATHANIEL B., PEOPLE v1218KA 09-00159(S08-DI-169)
BRINK, RONALD, PEOPLE v995KA 08-02649(I08-01-022)
GARTH, LEONID G. v BENET, LISA1286CA 10-00586(101451)
KINNEAR, LLOYD F., PEOPLE v1318KA 10-00929(08-10-119)
MORRICE, KEVIN R., PEOPLE v1200KA 10-01195(07-04-070)
SINGLETON, WILLIE J., PEOPLE v1036KA 08-02018(I07-10-118)
WALTZ, JAMES T. v VINK, MARY S.1372CA 10-01091(101007/08)
 
Orleans
BUNTING, JOHNNY v GOORD, GLENN S.1146TP 09-01446(0936335)
K., CODY, MTR. OF1387CAF 09-02080(A-136-09)
MCCRAY, JR., BRYANT C., PEOPLE v1321KA 09-02188(I09-23)
MCKEON, JR., RICHARD J., PEOPLE v1361KA 09-00580(I08-23)
 
Oswego
BRAY, KIMBERLY v DESTEVENS, ROBERT1253CAF 09-01767(V-00249-98/09T)
SALSBERY, SHAUN M., PEOPLE v1377KA 09-01795(I08C-202)
SHERMAN, DAVID D., PEOPLE v1355KA 10-00788(09C-101)
 
Seneca
BONILLA, MIGUEL v NASH, MICHAEL1334KAH 10-01002(43045)
LANCASTER, JASON v NASH, MICHAEL1315KAH 10-01010(43046)
OZOLINS, REBECCA E. v NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF CORREC,1313TP 10-00364(43602/2009)
 
Steuben
GRANDALL, ROBERT v FETHERS, TRACY1255CAF 09-02187(V00802/803-09)
SILLS, ROBERT v ROYSTON, JOAN1369CA 10-00577(86951/79987)
SILLS, ROBERT v ROYSTON, JOAN1370CA 10-01098(86951/79987)
W., AYODEJI, MTR. OF1252CAF 09-02045(B00583-09)
 
Wayne
T.-L., SHARDANAE, MTR. OF1386CAF 09-01634(NA-1546-08)
WAHL, GARY A. v COUNTY OF WAYNE,1343CA 10-00974(68382)
 
Wyoming
CALLENDER, AARON v FISCHER, BRIAN1169TP 10-01277(20910-10)
HAYES, LEROY v NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF CORREC,1314KAH 10-00951(20,859-09)
LYONS, PHILIP J. v STATE OF NEW YORK,1330CA 09-02343(113617)
SOLER, FRANCISCO v FISCHER, BRIAN1147TP 10-01276(20907-09)
WARE, ELLIS LEE v EVANS, ANDREA1210TP 10-00958(20921-10)
    
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS