Welcome
Home
THE COURT
    Overview of the Appellate Division
    Justices of the Court
    The Courthouse
DECISIONS
    Latest Decisions
    Decision Release Dates
    Search
CLERKS OFFICE
    Clerk and Deputy Clerk of the Court
    Contact Information
    Terms of the Court
    Court Calendars
    Rules of Practice
    Frequently Asked Questions
    Forms and Practice Aids
    Latest Court News
    Employment Opportunities
ATTORNEY MATTERS
    Admission to the Bar
    Attorney Discipline
    Attorney Registration Delinquency
    Registration as In-House Counsel
    Retirement
    Voluntary Resignation
PROGRAMS & AUXILIARY AGENCIES
    Assigned Counsel Program
    Attorneys for Children Program
    Attorney Grievance Committees
    Court Examiners
    Indep. Judicial Election Qual. Comm.
    Law Library
    Mental Hygiene Legal Service
    Pro Bono Policy and Program
RELATED LINKS
   Court sites
   Legal sites




Decisions - December 30, 2010

AFRIKA, NACHE, PEOPLE v1429KA 08-01266(I98-2639-001)
ALVARADO, ENRICO, PEOPLE v1450KA 09-00745(2004/04157) & (I2004-3339)
ALVERSON, MELISSA J., PEOPLE v1563KA 08-02673(I2007-235)
ANDERSON, MICHAEL v LADUE, JOSEPH1524CA 10-01339(2009-000438)
ANDERSON, KEVIN, PEOPLE v1468KA 09-01468(I2007-0310)
AQUAVELLA, M.D., P.C., JAMES V. v VIOLA, M.D., RALPH S.1158CA 10-01201(2002/06929)
ARK PATENT INTERNATIONAL, L.L.C., v TARKSOL INTERNATIONAL, L.L.C.,1459CA 10-01569(2007/11921)
ARKPORT STAFF UNITED, v ARKPORT CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,1501CA 10-01525(103719)
AROESTY, ROBERT v FARASH CORPORATION,1506CA 10-01552(I2009-007652)
BARNES, DEBORAH J. v EVANS, JIMMIE L.1454CAF 09-01672(V-06765-04,)
BEACH, HARRY J. v VILLAGE OF WOLCOTT,1618CA 10-00267(63237)
BELSTADT, ROBERT G. v BELSTADT, LISA A.1302CA 10-01238(SF2003-902143)
BENESH, MARK L. v COURTNEY, KAREN A.1465CA 10-01464(04-10479)
BENSHOFF, ALEXANDRA v RAKOCZY, ADAM R.1463CA 10-01412(2007-3837)
BISSELL, PETER v TOWN OF AMHERST,1371CA 10-00580(2009-10257)
BOIVIN, WAYNE v MARRANO/MARC EQUITY CORP.,1480CA 10-01568(2007-6331)
BONNER, JR., DARIN, PEOPLE v1567KA 09-02048(I2008-2850)
BOURCY, WESLEY A. v BOURCY, MARY LOU1551CA 09-02470(2005-2534)
BOYLAND, TOBIAS, PEOPLE v1412KA 10-00774(09/1672)
B., JULIANI, MTR. OF1474CAF 10-00254(NN-13516-09)
BRANTLEY, DAMIAN, PEOPLE v1586KA 10-00122(I09-107)
BRISSON, ALLEN, PEOPLE v1540KA 08-02414(I2007-1323-1)
BRONSON, TRUDI L. v HANSEL, ALLEN J.1159CA 10-00565(08-35425)
BROWN, LINDA M. v STATE OF NEW YORK,1115CA 09-00990(110037/108961)
BROWN, DARIUS, PEOPLE v1513KA 09-02098(I08-162)
BROWN, DARIUS, PEOPLE v1512KA 09-02095(I08-126B)
BROWN, DWAYNE, PEOPLE v1591KA 09-01500(09-36143)
BROWN, DARIUS, PEOPLE v1514KA 09-02099(I09-04)
BRYNDLE, DANIEL v SAFETY KLEEN SYSTEMS, INC.,1423CA 10-00611(I2003-9689)
BUFFALO PROFESSIONAL FIREFIGHTERS, MTR. OF1464CA 10-01450(2009-5156)
BURGIO, JAMES v INCE, BRANDON1462CA 09-02198(06-11892)
BURNS, DEBORAH v CARBALLADA, CARLOS1558TP 10-01593(I
C., ADREONA, MTR. OF1519CAF 09-01955(A-3631-08)
CALDWELL, DANIEL P. v WARD, RHONDA D.1620CA 10-00844(62056)
CAPPIELLO, DOMINIC v CAPPIELLO, LAURIE1521CAF 10-00003(V-1290-04/09 H,I,J,K,L)
CARDIFF, DONALD v CARRIER, ROBERT M.1283CA 10-01234(03742)
CARR, JR., JARVIS v COUNTY OF NIAGARA,1619CA 10-01426(130492)
CASCIO, THOMAS, PEOPLE v1590KA 10-00330(I2009-0182S)
COOPER, ATOO V., PEOPLE v1434KA 09-01002(SI08-408-08)
COUNTY OF NIAGARA, v DAINES, RICHARD F.1440CA 10-00847(137680)
CULLEN, JOHN, PEOPLE v1428KA 10-00180(I2006-5030)
CURTIN, PAULA J. v J.B. HUNT TRANSPORT, INC.,1182CA 09-02201(1701/04)
CURTIN, PAULA J. v J.B. HUNT TRANSPORT, INC.,1183CA 10-00540(2004-001701)
DAHAR, MICHAEL v HOLLAND LADDER & MANUFACTURING CO.,1308CA 10-00839(I2007-4427)
DAHAR, MICHAEL v HOLLAND LADDER & MANUFACTURING CO.,1307CA 10-00546(I2007-4427)
DAVIS-WRIGHT, MARK, PEOPLE v1425KA 08-00028(I339/07)
DAWSON, DANIEL N., PEOPLE v1222KA 08-01551(I5112)
DELEE, MAURICE, PEOPLE v1416KA 07-01179(I2006-330-1)
DEMJANENKO, VICTOR v DEMJANENKO, VIRGINIA L.1485CA 10-01624(129630)
DEMPSEY, AARON J., PEOPLE v1546KA 07-02343(I2007-0118A)
DOMBROWSKI, THOMAS E. v BULSON, RAYMOND W.1130CA 10-00097(36448)
DUBUQUE, STEVEN v BREMILLER, SHAWNA M.1472CAF 09-02262(V-02982-09)
DUFFY, MICHAEL J., STONE, GILBERT H. v1460CA 10-01341(2001DT01229/a)
DUPLEASIS, HILLERY M., PEOPLE v1547KA 09-00200(I2005-2508)
EATON, FAYE M. v WAYNE TEACHERS ASSOCIATION,1301CA 10-00422(07/04487)
EATON, FAYE M. v HUNGERFORD, SYLVIA1300CA 10-00421(07/04487)
ERON, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v1543KA 09-00548(I2008-0005)
F., KHALIL O., MTR. OF1549CAF 09-01565(NN-2233-08)
FARRELL, TIMOTHY P. v STATE OF NEW YORK,1437CA 09-01927(106918)
FERRARO, JERROLD v TOWN BOARD OF TOWN OF AMHERST,1439CA 09-02565(2008-7696)
FINGER LAKES RACING ASSOCIATION, IN, v TOWN OF FARMINGTON,1601CA 10-01625(09-103279)
FLOOD, DIANE v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,1419CA 10-00444(2008-1318)
FRAZIER, WILLIAM F. v FRAZIER, KIMBERLY A.1475CAF 09-02182(V-00994-09/09A)
GAMBLE, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v1466KA 09-01956(I2009-0047)
GARDNER, BRANDON WILLIAM v STATE OF NEW YORK,1345CA 10-00892(109520)
GARLAND, ARLENE S. v RLI INSURANCE COMPANY,1077CA 10-00534(2007-989)
GEORGE, CHARLES v HEALTHNOW NEW YORK, INC.,1477CA 10-01487(I-2004-4661)
GIFFORD, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v1413KA 07-01560(I2006-0799A)
GILFUS, JOSEPH B. v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,1422CA 10-01606(2004-1057)
GILLETTE, SUMMER v GEDNEY, JEREMY1496CAF 09-02264(V-01160/61-02U&V)
GRIECO, CAROL H. v KALEIDA HEALTH,1507CA 10-01188(I2007-10724)
GRIECO, CAROL H. v KALEIDA HEALTH,1508CA 10-01071(10724-2007)
GROSS, GORDON, PEOPLE v1409KA 10-01349(2008-1017-1)
GROSS, GORDON B., PEOPLE v1414KA 10-01570(08-113)
H., JERMAINE, MTR. OF1451CAF 10-01565(NN-7779-08)
HANNAH B. ACRES, LLC, v HOWE, MARTHA A.1598CA 10-01184(124507)
HANSEN, TRAVIS E., PEOPLE v1538KA 09-00287(I08-07-079)
HARNISCHFEGER, OTTO v MOORE, DAVID1442CA 10-01075(07-07664)
HARRIS, HOWARD, PEOPLE v1548KA 04-02941(I2003-0582)
HELLMAN, GLENN M. v HELLMAN, BRUCE1595CA 10-00983(2005-9695)
HERNANDEZ, DANNY, PEOPLE v1433KA 08-00336(I2007-199)
HIGHSMITH, ROY, PEOPLE v1470KA 09-00832(I93-1483-001)
HILLARD, ANTONIO, PEOPLE v1488KA 06-03491(I2006-0515)
HOLMES, JR., WILLIE, PEOPLE v1431KA 08-00029(I2006-0916)
HORTON, DARIUS L., PEOPLE v1250KA 06-02317(I2005-0663)
ISKALO ELECTRIC TOWER LLC, v STANTEC CONSULTING SERVICES, INC.,1164CA 10-00777(2006/4223)
JACQUES, JR., DELBERT J., PEOPLE v1593KA 09-02218(I08C-213)
JENKINS, TERRY, PEOPLE v1517KA 09-01367(I2008-1877)
JONES, ROBERT E. v LAIRD, THERESA1520CAF 09-01728(DV-2008-003)
JONES, KUMAR S., PEOPLE v1542KA 09-01050(I08-10-131)
JONES, NAKIESHA, PEOPLE v1417KA 09-02370(I03008-2008)
JORDAN, TREMELL R., PEOPLE v1447KA 10-00471(I2009-171)
KELLY, SHAWN A., PEOPLE v1383KA 08-02676(II07-077)
KEMPA, ANTHONY P. v TOWN OF BOSTON,1478CA 10-01295(2007-1305)
KNAPP, KIRSSY, PEOPLE v1587KA 09-01704(I2007-0398)
KRAMER, LISA v BERARDICURTI, KEN1570CAF 10-01342(V-04353-02/07F)
KRIEGER, DORIS v MCDONALD'S RESTAURANT OF NEW YORK,,1628CA 10-00570(I2007/7063)
LANDO, JR., TIMOTHY E. v LANDO, JESSICA J.1572CAF 09-02391(V-1459 & 1460-08)
LAWRENCE, ESQ., C. BRUCE v GUARDSMARK, LLC,1580CA 10-01340(2009/10913)
LEE, TYMONN, PEOPLE v1378KA 09-00936(I2008-2345)
LEIER, KENNETH, PEOPLE v1536KA 09-01751(I80-0594-1)
LOWE, PATRICK D., PEOPLE v1427KA 05-00922(I2004-0059C)
LYNCH, DONNA PRINCE v WATERS, MIKE1443CA 10-00945(2003-6853)
LYNCH, DONNA PRINCE v WATERS, MIKE1444CA 10-00947(2003-6853)
LYONS, LISA v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN,1627TP 10-01595(I
MACKEY, JR., JOE, PEOPLE v1430KA 09-01964(I2007-323)
MAKIN, LEON v VANTREESE, CAROL1389CA 10-01233(98040)
MALBURG, GREGG A. v KELLER, JOSEPH G.1424CA 10-00671(I2007-003097)
MALDONADO, ROBERTO, PEOPLE v1585KA 09-00491(I1993-0581)
MANUEL, KEVIN, PEOPLE v1607KA 09-02222(I09-59)
MARTIN, THERESA E. v 21 GOODWAY DRIVE, INC.,1621CA 10-01331(2007-3634)
MARTIN, NATHANIEL, PEOPLE v1569KA 09-02313(I09-016)
MARTINEZ, DIANE v DUNKEL, CHARLES D.1557CA 10-00370(2009-08937)
MARTINSEN, ALIX v CAMPERLINO, W. JAMES1556CA 10-01065(2008-8391)
MCCABE, AMY v ST. PAUL FIRE & MARINE INSURANCE CO,1235CA 10-00091(I-2008-6553)
MCCABE, AMY v ST. PAUL FIRE & MARINE INSURANCE CO,1234CA 10-00090(2008/6553)
MCDONALD, MICHAEL v TAYLOR, JUSTIN1616CA 10-01610(I-2009-7022)
MCKENZIE BANKING COMPANY, v BILLINSON, CRAIG J.1457CA 10-01417(2008-2787)
MCPHERSON, DARCY, PEOPLE v1486KA 08-02123(I2006-193A)
MEYER, WILLIAM T. v STOUT, DONALD L.1418CA 09-02580(36050)
MONROE COUNTY SHERIFF, MTR. OF1576CA 10-01338(2009/7252)
MOON, MICHAEL A. v VILLAGE OF BROCTON ZBA,1579CA 10-01376(K1-2009-1378)
MOTT, JR., THOMAS G. v STRONGBUILT, INC.,1503CA 10-01609(2006-10194)
NELSON, FLORINE v STANDER, THOMAS A.1391OP 10-01251
NELSON, MALIKA F. v NOH, THOMAS1421CA 10-01310(06/5903)
NICHOLS, DEBORAH v BDS LANDSCAPE DESIGN,1438CA 10-01377(I2009-11422)
NIEDERMAIER, JASON v TOWN OF CONESUS,1603CA 09-02199(787-2007)
NILSEN, PATRICK R., PEOPLE v1493KA 07-00917(I06-346)
ONONDAGA COMMUNITY COLLEGE, MTR. OF1623CA 10-01440(2009-7865)
OSBORN, TRISHIA v GEDNEY, JEREMY1497CAF 09-02265(V-1242-08)
P., MYA V., MTR. OF1571CAF 09-01905(AS-00533-07/08A)
P., YASIEL, MTR. OF1473CAF 09-02270(B-01425-08)
PALERMO, THOMAS v TACCONE, ANTHONY1258CA 10-00640(2008-5342)
PERRY, NORMAN M. v EDWARDS, JAMES1304CA 10-00879(2007-6469)
PICHARDO, CARLOS, PEOPLE v1408KA 07-01506(94/03)
POMMERENCK, BRIGID v NASON, SR., GERALD R.1445CA 10-01118(2008-3381)
POOLE, COLLEN T., PEOPLE v1435KA 09-02415(I09-25)
POVOSKI, JR., FRANK J., PEOPLE v1410KA 07-00962(I2005-0962A)
POWELL, JOYCE, PEOPLE v1568KA 07-01269(I0899/2006)
PRALLE, ARND v PETRIE, CHRISTOPHER S.1578CA 10-00672(I2009-011222)
PRATT, ANDREW v HOGAN, MICHAEL1420CA 10-00669(CA2008-2289)
RAJAB, RAMADHAN, PEOPLE v1448KA 08-01800(I2007-0073)
RESTO, ROSA, PEOPLE v1432KA 08-00378(I2006-0792A)
RICKERT, KRISTEN v COUNTY OF ONONDAGA,1614CA 10-01539(2008-2219)
ROGERS, NICHOLAS W. v ANDERSON, KRISTI L.1575CAF 09-01358(V-18074-08)
ROGERS, AUTUMN D. v EDELMAN, JANNA K.1584CA 10-00721(64068)
ROGERS, NICHOLAS J. v NIAGARA FALLS BRIDGE COMMISSION,1353CA 10-00406(134034)
ROLLO, GENEVIEVE v SERVICO NEW YORK, INC.,1577CA 10-00781(I2007/4978)
ROSSO, DANIEL H. v GEROUW-ROSSO, ANDREA M.1456CAF 09-01668(V-1808-06/08A)
RUCKER, MICHAEL v MCDONALD'S RESTAURANT OF NEW YORK,,1629CA 10-00571(I2007/7064)
RYAN, THOMAS C. v PORT OF OSWEGO AUTHORITY, ALSO KNOW,1554CA 10-01287(2006-0319)
SALVAGNI, SANDRA, PEOPLE v1405KA 10-00394(I2008-513)
SCHERR, DAVID v CITY OF LACKAWANA,1559CA 10-00910(I-2007-000782)
SCHLEY, JERALYN v STEFFANS, RYEN1482CA 10-00938(2007-4913)
SCHOONMAKER, MARY ELIZABETH, PEOPLE v1449KA 10-01605(10-0156)
SCOTT, LAMAR, PEOPLE v1562KA 10-00335(I2008-0645)
SHANNE, VALERIE v CENTRAL NEW YORK REGIONAL TRANSPORT,1615CA 10-00897(2009-7034)
SHARPE, TIMOTHY v FISCHER, BRIAN1622TP 10-01577(44089)
S., SEAN, MTR. OF1495CAF 09-02434(B-05297-08)
SHAW, JOHN W., PEOPLE v1467KA 09-02283(I2008-504-1)
SHEPHERD, EON v FISCHER, BRIAN1489TP 10-01576(44016)
SHEPHERD, JR., DONALD, PEOPLE v1560KA 09-02051(S09-86)
SHUMWAY, DAVID v KELLEY, JUSTIN1441CA 10-01396(51805)
SIMMONS, ALPHONSO v FISCHER, BRIAN1617CA 09-01615(20,698-08)
SMALL, JR., III, JOHN P., PEOPLE v1588KA 10-00466(I2008-192)
SMITH, ELAINE v CROUSE HEALTH HOSPITAL, INC.,1597CA 10-01611(2005-4791)
SMITH, SANDRA J. v SMITH, CHARLES D.1390CA 10-00615(125630)
SMITH, MARY BETH v SCHULTZ, II, PAUL F.1602CA 10-01427(2007-5604)
SMITH, JONATHAN, PEOPLE v1446KA 09-01192(S31281)
SPRINGS, JR., ARTHUR J. v CITY OF BUFFALO,1393CA 09-02534(2006/8186)
STANLEY, DIANE R. v MATTAR, ESQ., LAWRENCE J.1259CA 09-01756(2003/1004) & (2003/1564)
STANLEY, DIANE R. v MATTAR, ESQ., LAWRENCE J.1262CA 10-00046(2003/1004) & (2003/1564)
STANLEY, DIANE R. v MATTAR, ESQ., LAWRENCE J.1263CA 10-00047(2003/1004) & (2003/1564)
STANLEY, DIANE R. v MATTAR, ESQ., LAWRENCE J.1261CA 10-00045(2003/1004) & (2003/1564)
STANLEY, DIANE R. v MATTAR, ESQ., LAWRENCE J.1260CA 10-00043(2003/1004) &(2003/1564)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v FOX, ERSKINE1553CA 09-02057(CONF1346)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v SHAW, DUANE1461CA 09-01443(1296-2008)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v PIERCE, MICHAEL1550CA 09-00466(CA2008-000348)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v MOTZER, MICHAEL1436CA 09-02318(MH7283)
STEELE, DALE R. v LAFFERTY, TIMOTHY1582CA 10-00477(I08-03051)
STROUD, LAVERN, PEOPLE v1564KA 09-01051(S28533)
STUART, GARY, PEOPLE v1426KA 07-02653(S2006/3931)
SWAN, JR., RAYMOND S. v INGERSOLL, ANDREW J.1068CA 10-00041(2006/010721)
SWAN, JR., RAYMOND S. v INGERSOLL, ANDREW J.1067CA 10-00040(2006/010721)
SWAN, JR., RAYMOND S. v INGERSOLL, ANDREW J.1066CA 09-02227(2006/010721)
SWEENEY, MICHAEL J., PEOPLE v1565KA 09-01884(S31831)
SWEET, JACK Z., PEOPLE v1537KA 09-00188(2001-490)
TADUSZ, LAURA, MTR. OF1574CAF 09-02261(V-19620-07)
TARVER, WILLIE, PEOPLE v1510KA 10-00506(I09-140)
THE PENN TRAFFIC COMPANY, v NATIONAL UNION FIRE INSURANCE CO.,1458CA 10-01530(2008-8869)
T., ALFONZO, MTR. OF1455CAF 10-00105(NN-4295-09)
T., DEVONTE M., MTR. OF1609CAF 09-02006(B-00847-08)
T., SHENI A., MTR. OF1610CAF 09-02007(B-00848-08)
T., SHIAH A.-R., MTR. OF1611CAF 09-02008(B-00849-08)
T., SYANNE L., MTR. OF1612CAF 09-02009(B-00850-08)
T., TOYIN S., MTR. OF1613CAF 09-02010(B-00851-08)
THOMAS, JASON v THOMAS, JAMIE1630CAF 10-01237(V-00100-10/10A,)
THOMAS, JURI P., PEOPLE v1589KA 09-00766(I2007-01659)
THREET, MARK S. v THREET, REGINA M.1471CAF 09-02459(O-565-09, O-565-09/09A&B
THREET, REGINA M. v THREET, MARK S.1476CAF 09-02371(V-16436-09/09A)
THURMAN, MAURICE L., PEOPLE v1415KA 09-00871(I2008-0719)
TODIE, EUGENE, PEOPLE v1561KA 09-01193(S31230)
TUMMINIA, ROBERT W. v LEMKE, JOHN B.1490TP 10-01553(43858)
VANYO, RONALD v VANYO, ANN1481CA 09-02377(SF2007-900958)
W., CHARITY, MTR. OF1453CAF 09-01953(B-8825-08)
W., IMANI D., MTR. OF1452CAF 09-01798(B-07514-07)
WALLIS, MARY W. v SANDY CREEK CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,1596TP 10-01362(2009-1710)
WARRIOR, NORMA v BEATMAN, SR., ROBERT E.1522CAF 10-00198(V-03208-02/09U)
WATKINS, JUDSON, PEOPLE v1407KA 07-00077(I01-0727-1)
WEBB, DELORES M. v AARON, MAURICE1498CAF 10-01424(V-18477-08/09)
WILLIAMS, MARCELLE E., PEOPLE v1406KA 07-00903(I2006-0367)
WILLIAMS, MARCELLE E., PEOPLE v1411KA 08-02409(I2005-0879)
WILLIS, RANDY, PEOPLE v1469KA 08-02362(I2008-077)
WILSON, CLIFTON J. v LINN, TAMERA K.1518CAF 10-00255(V-01203-06/09J)
WISNIEWSKI, FRANK, PEOPLE v1544KA 09-01364(I5915)
WOODWARD, SHAWN, PEOPLE v1545KA 09-01844(I5971)
WRIGHT, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v1566KA 09-02175(I09-75)
ZELIE, KEVIN M. v TOWN OF VAN BUREN,1581CA 10-01302(08-4589)
ZILLIOX, MARK P. v WESTERN NEW YORK SNOWMOBILE CLUB OF,1552CA 10-01322(I2007-5075)
    
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS