AD4 Seal

Supreme Court of the State of New York
APPELLATE DIVISION
Fourth Judicial Department

Decisions - February 10, 2011

 
Allegany
MOORE, RICHARD M., PEOPLE v216KA 09-01458(S08-044)
 
Cattaraugus
CATTARAUGUS COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF SO, v ROBERTS, NICCOLE161CAF 09-02619(F-851-08)
 
Cayuga
ARCHIE, DEREK L. v STALLONE, DAVID71OP 10-01878
SWAN, TROY E., PEOPLE v55KA 09-02349(I2006-076)
VAN NORSTRAND, GLENN E. v GRAHAM, HAROLD D.9.1KAH 11-00136(2009-0108)
VAN NORSTRAND, GLENN E. v GRAHAM, HAROLD D.9KAH 10-00037(2009-0108)
 
Erie
10 ELLICOTT SQUARE COURT CORPORATIO, v VIOLET REALTY, INC.,1526CA 10-00992(20085-7591)
ANDERSON, TRACY v RONCONE, SARAH39CAF 10-00293(V-00267-08/08A,)
ANDERSON, TERRY R., PEOPLE v126KA 10-00247(I2009-0049)
BEST, RANDALL K. v SWAN GROUP LIMITED PARTNERSHIP,1483CA 10-01300(I2007-010859)
CIVIL SERVICE EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION, COUNTY OF ERIE, v146TP 10-01869(2010/5226)
COLON, BRYAN, PEOPLE v35KA 09-01788(I2007-2040)
CUSTODI, ROBIN v TOWN OF AMHERST,1484CA 10-01081(2008-9556)
CUSTOM TOPSOIL, INC., v CITY OF BUFFALO,1523CA 10-01320(I-2009-10979)
DAVIS, CHARLES L. v FIRMAN, M.D., RUSSELL168CA 10-01354(12004/03)
DAVIS, AARON, PEOPLE v175KA 10-00154(I2008-2238)
DIPIZIO, BERNARD v DIPIZIO, DOROTHY1527CA 10-00368(I-2008-9607)
DONAHUE, DENNIS, PEOPLE v1494KA 08-01563(I2007-2222)
F., JALEEL E., MTR. OF113CAF 10-00512(B-17588-2006)
G., VONDAJIA P., MTR. OF158CAF 10-00390(B-10032-2008)
GELSTER, DALE R. v JAOUDE, MARIA L.88CA 10-01970(2008-6947)
GIWA, JERELENE v BUFFALO MUNICIPAL HOUSING AUTHORITY,46TP 10-01806(2010-3978)
GREEN, ROBERT v C.O. FALTER CONSTRUCTION CORP.,1395CA 10-00442(2005-132)
HUARD, SHANNON v LUGO, JOSE36CAF 09-02492(F-10435-03/09B)
HUMPHREY, KENT G. v GARDNER, M.D., SHEILA F.20CA 10-01950(2007-4285)
JENKINS, ALICIA v SHAW, MICHAEL P.223CAF 10-00965(F-13253-09/09A)
JONES, TY, PEOPLE v149KA 09-01481(S31519)
KILEY, III, FRANK W. v GREENFIELD MANOR, INC.,120CA 10-01717(I2007-012415)
LAWRENCE, ROBERT, PEOPLE v218KA 09-01206(I2007-1194)
MCCRIMAGER, JERMAINE, PEOPLE v213KA 09-01304(I2006-2531)
NIAGARA FRONTIER TRANSPORTATION AUT, BURTON, IRIC v48CA 10-00928(I-2009-000777)
NIAGARA FRONTIER TRANSPORTATION AUT, MTR. OF114CA 10-01969(2010001479)
OBOT, OTU A. v NATIONAL FUEL GAS DIST. CORP.,14CA 10-00481(I-2009008211)
OBOT, OTU A. v NATIONAL FUEL GAS DISTRIBUTION, CORPORATION15CA 10-00895(I-2009-008211)
P., DANTE, MTR. OF37CAF 10-01639(D-00177-10)
PIECZYNSKI, III, EDMUND, PEOPLE v102KA 09-02647(S32486)
PISKORZ, EDWARD A. v PISKORZ, MARILYN1502CA 10-01598(SF 2004/901269)
RAULS, BRIAN v DIRECTV, INC.,13CA 09-02486(2007-2770)
REYNOLDS, III, WALTER F. v KREBS, WILLIAM41CA 10-01442(2007-3762)
S., SHANIA, MTR. OF1594CAF 09-02209(NN-11655-08)
SCOTT, JR., RICHARD v BERBARY, JAMES L.1TP 10-01788(10-5629)
SENIOR, JERMAINE O., PEOPLE v76KA 10-00150(S32374)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v ALI, JAMAAL16CA 09-02522(MH 543, 665-2007)
TORRO-TORRES, MIGUEL, PEOPLE v75KA 10-00285(I2009-0045)
WILLIAMS, ANTHONY GRILL, PEOPLE v51KA 09-02279(I2009-1747X)
ZOSH, ELIZABETH A. v SMITH, THOMAS110CAF 09-02495(F-05349-03/07B)
 
Genesee
CONIBER, MARGARET A. v UNITED MEMORIAL MEDICAL CENTER,228CA 10-02001(58735)
EASTERLING, DEREK, PEOPLE v122KA 09-00718(S08-082)
HOOTEN, ROY, PEOPLE v1606KA 09-00321(S08-091)
HOOTEN, ROY, PEOPLE v1605KA 09-02125(S08-091 (restitution onl
MULLINGS, KEVIN L., PEOPLE v1515KA 08-01950(S07-023)
SMITH, RONALD A., PEOPLE v151KA 10-00702(S08-08)
 
Herkimer
LAYMON, ELIZABETH v ALLEN, JAMES F.95CA 10-01971(2004-80855)
 
Livingston
ENGLERT, RONALD v ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS OF TOWN OF,17CA 09-02610(872-2009)
 
Monroe
BAKER, THOMAS M., PEOPLE v174KA 07-00753(I06/509)
BENNETT, GARTH, PEOPLE v125KA 08-00544(I871/07)
BOWEN, DONNY, PEOPLE v108KA 08-00480(I2007-0887)
BUSSEY, HARVEY, PEOPLE v53KA 07-01490(I06/625)
CAMACCHO, ULYSSES, PEOPLE v28KA 08-02115(I2004-0123)
CHICHESTER, THOMAS, MTR. OF1531CA 10-00164(2008/1333)
CHICHESTER, THOMAS, MTR. OF1530CA 09-02324(2008-1333)
CHOMIK, CATHERINE v SYPNIAK, JAROSLAW25CAF 09-00701(F-3238-01/08C,D)
CRISLER, MARQUES, PEOPLE v130KA 08-00621(I2007-0479)
DITUCCI, DAVID, PEOPLE v11KA 10-01943(986/2007)
DITUCCI, DAVID, PEOPLE v10KA 10-01941(986/2007)
ESPOSITO, JOSEPH P. v CITY OF ROCHESTER,1599CA 10-01309(2009-10761)
G., VINCENT E. D., MTR. OF64CAF 09-01797(B-14069-08)
GANO, JASON, PEOPLE v1592KA 09-00429(2007-0398C)
GAUSE, DERRICK, PEOPLE v82KA 08-01878(I2002-0183)
GIBLIN, DENISE v WEST IRONDEQUOIT CENTRAL SCHOOL DIS,191CA 10-01688(2008-2750)
GREEN, PRESTON, PEOPLE v5KA 08-02368(S2008-3469)
HAHN AUTOMOTIVE WAREHOUSE, INC., v AMERICAN ZURICH INSURANCE COMPANY,1287CA 10-00545(2006/5800)
JACKSON, DOLPHUS L., PEOPLE v171KA 08-01234(I2006-0778)
JOHNSON, TERRENCE L., PEOPLE v4KA 08-01331(I2007-0760)
L., DONALD L. v MICELI, ROBERT J.1532CA 09-00631(2007/13233)
L., DONALD L., MTR. OF1533CA 09-00632(2007/13233)
L., DONALD L., MTR. OF1534CA 09-00633(08-13278)
LARKIN, LILY v ROCHESTER HOUSING AUTHORITY,1504CA 10-01567(09/9006)
LYNCH, ROBERT A., PEOPLE v77KA 06-02430(I989-04)
MARTZLOFF, SCOTT v RUSH-HENRIETTA CENTRAL SCHOOL,70CA 10-01073(04-10259)
MCKENZIE, DONYELL, PEOPLE v1541KA 07-01840(I2007/16)
PARKER, CHESTER, PEOPLE v124KA 09-00734(I89-0281)
PETERKIN, RASHAD, PEOPLE v1509KA 07-00393(I2006-0312)
POOLE, C.W., PEOPLE v155KA 08-01558(I2006-0996)
SULLI, PAUL, PEOPLE v131KA 07-00936(I582/06)
WEBB, LATISHA, PEOPLE v98KA 08-00347(I2006/839)
WHITMORE, MARLENE v FEDERATED RETAIL HOLDING, INC.,181CA 10-01720(2006-4625)
WILLIAMS, ALFONSO D., PEOPLE v73KA 08-02584(I2008-0426)
 
Niagara
BENTLEY, BONNIE P. v RIDGE ROAD EXPRESS INCORPORATED,163CA 10-01695(125626)
COKE, WILLIAM J., PEOPLE v29KA 09-01440(S2002-021)
COLDALLAH, RAKEM T., PEOPLE v3KA 09-02178(S2009-316)
COLDALLAH, RAKEM T., PEOPLE v8KA 09-02181(I2008-563)
COULDERY, PAMELA v COULDERY, ROBERT162CAF 10-01751(V-03044-07/08C)
FOSS, III, COLBY, PEOPLE v1539KA 09-02127(I2004-306)
MULLANEY, JAN v ROYALTY PROPERTIES, LLC,145CA 10-01526(133143)
ROGERS, ZACHERY A., PEOPLE v170KA 10-00719(I2009-238)
SCHAFER, FRANKLIN D., PEOPLE v1516KA 10-01301(2009-026)
TABB, MICHAEL A., PEOPLE v180KA 09-00724(I2007-513)
WHITE, DEQUANA M., PEOPLE v27KA 09-02217(I2008-431A)
WHITE, DEQUANA M., PEOPLE v32KA 10-00718(S2008-157)
 
Oneida
BLACK, DONNA v WATSON, JOHN PAUL157CAF 10-00589(V-00298-98/09)
BRYANT, RICKY v FISCHER, BRIAN97TP 10-01653(CA2010-000395)
FIEBIGER, HENRY v JAY-K LUMBER, INC.,136CA 10-01333(CA2006-000860)
GONZALEZ, GLORIA T., PEOPLE v1535KA 08-02118(I07-067)
TOLEDO, JAVIS v FISCHER, BRIAN2TP 10-01923(2009-3247)
TRIFICANA, RICHARD v CARRIER, ROBERT M.1289CA 10-00539(CA2008-003741/32-09-0069
 
Onondaga
ASD SPECIALTY HEALTHCARE, INC., v HIMPLER, BENJAMIN S.94CA 10-01145(2009-5665)
C., THOMAS, ONONDAGA COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF, SOCIAL SERVICES v112CAF 10-00169(NN-8255-8256-08)
COSBY, PIERRE D., PEOPLE v1491KA 06-03311(I2006-0150-1)
COSBY, PIERRE, PEOPLE v1492KA 09-01036(I2006-0150)
CURRY, JASON, PEOPLE v156KA 07-02678(I2007-0689-1)
GILBERT, DOROTHY v SUTKOWY, DAVID164CA 10-00378(2009-3853)
INGRAM, TECOY, PEOPLE v54KA 09-02382(I0808-1108-1)
JELFO, THERESA ANNE v JELFO, JR., JOHN MICHAEL18CA 09-00081(2006-M-0589)
JELFO, THERESA ANNE v JELFO, JR., JOHN MICHAEL19CA 10-01542(2006-M-0589)
MCMANUS, JAMES E. v COUNTY OF ONONDAGA,188CA 10-01334(2004-1539) & (2004-1539A)
MORAN, WILLIAM v CITY OF SYRACUSE,1392CA 10-01223(2289-06)
PROGRESSIVE NORTHEASTERN INSURANCE, CO. v STATE FARM INSURANCE COMPANIES,1583CA 10-00264(05-5781)
RICKERT, KRISTEN v COUNTY OF ONONDAGA,69CA 10-01992(2008-2219)
S., NICHOLAS, MTR. OF227CAF 10-01096(B-5513-09)
SLATTERY, COREY, PEOPLE v148KA 09-00774(I2008-0405-1)
VERIZON NEW YORK, INC., v LA BARGE COMPANIES,84CA 10-01101(2003-1894)
VERIZON NEW YORK, INC., v LABARGE BROTHERS COMPANY, INC.,89CA 10-01102(2003-1891)
VERIZON NEW YORK, INC., v LABARGE BROTHERS COMPANY, INC.,90CA 10-01103(2003-1891)
VERIZON NEW YORK, INC., v LABARGE BROTHERS COMPANY, INC.,83CA 10-01099(2003-1894)
WALESKI, JEAN M. v CITY OF SYRACUSE,1048CA 10-00137(06-0117)
WALESKI, JEAN M. v CITY OF SYRACUSE,169CA 10-01818(056-0117)
WALLEY, TAJOURA v BIVINS, ASHLEY66CA 10-01860(2006-3935)
WILLIAMS, CAL, PEOPLE v59KA 07-00754(I2006-0737-1, 2006-679-2
 
Ontario
ARNOLD, RICHARD BENJAMIN B., PEOPLE v50KA 09-01277(S09-DI-075)
BROWN, DAVID A., PEOPLE v127KA 09-02337(I09-01-003)
CRUZ, HECTOR R., PEOPLE v109KA 09-00835(I08-10-126)
HAMMOND, DAVID v BAKER, GORDON67CA 10-01805(101247)
JONES, ROBERT E. v LAIRD, THERESA159CAF 09-01920(V-01535-07/08P,Q,R,T,U)
LAIRD, THERESA M. v JONES, ROBERT E.160CAF 09-02014(V-01535-07/09 V,W,S,AA)
ZECK, JR., CHARLES J. v GASPAR, VICTOR68CA 10-01977(102312)
 
Orleans
MCCLAIN, HUSSAYN v NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF CORREC, TIONAL SERVICES211CA 10-00854(09-36974)
SANDS, MARK D., PEOPLE v34KA 08-00379(I07-20)
 
Oswego
FAUL, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v6KA 10-00176(S08C-0206)
K., PAIGE, OSWEGO COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL, v61CAF 10-00475(NA-2254-2255-08)
MILLER, MARCUS, PEOPLE v60KA 09-01503(I08C-169)
POWELL, TROY, PEOPLE v128KA 10-00024(I08C-092)
 
Seneca
PHILLIPS, JASON v HENRY B'S INC.,135CA 10-00448(40169)
 
Steuben
CAMPBELL, SHAWN, PEOPLE v12KA 08-02049(I2004-314)
TERWILLIGER, DONNA v KNICKERBOCKER, CHRISTINA L.1499CA 10-01199(I100021)
 
Wayne
BURKHART, JR., WILLIAM E. v MODICA, STEVEN V.1505CA 10-00401(66936)
DRENNAN, BRYON, PEOPLE v56KA 09-02148(I08-172)
VILLAGE OF PALMYRA, v HUB LANGIE PAVING, INC.,1500CA 10-01449(58637)
WILSON, JR., WILBERT, PEOPLE v30KA 10-00288(I09-06)
 
Wyoming
CUMMINGS, DOUGLAS, PEOPLE v31KA 10-01402(I4316)
JEFFREY, MIGUEL v FISCHER, BRIAN26TP 10-01991(21,005)
    
Motions and Crawfords