Welcome
Home
THE COURT
    Overview of the Appellate Division
    Justices of the Court
    The Courthouse
DECISIONS
    Latest Decisions
    Decision Release Dates
    Search
CLERKS OFFICE
    Clerk and Deputy Clerk of the Court
    Contact Information
    Terms of the Court
    Court Calendars
    Rules of Practice
    Frequently Asked Questions
    Forms and Practice Aids
    Latest Court News
    Employment Opportunities
ATTORNEY MATTERS
    Admission to the Bar
    Attorney Discipline
    Attorney Registration Delinquency
    Registration as In-House Counsel
    Retirement
    Voluntary Resignation
PROGRAMS & AUXILIARY AGENCIES
    Assigned Counsel Program
    Attorneys for Children Program
    Attorney Grievance Committees
    Court Examiners
    Indep. Judicial Election Qual. Comm.
    Law Library
    Mental Hygiene Legal Service
    Pro Bono Policy and Program
RELATED LINKS
   Court sites
   Legal sites




Decisions - June 8, 2012

ABREU, CARLOS v FISCHER, BRIAN626TP 11-01936(45397)
A., AUBREY, MTR. OF713CAF 11-00619(B-11481-09)
AGARWAL, PRASHANT, PEOPLE v701KA 12-00141(2010-5044)
ALEXANDER, HAROLD v NEW YORK CENTRAL MUTUAL,711CA 11-01520(09/15867)
ALLEN, MICAIAH v GRAHAM, HAROLD D.600TP 11-02389(2011-0472)
ALSTON, JESSE, PEOPLE v681KA 11-00543(I2011-7001)
ANDERSON, BARBARA v JUSTICE, RAY694CA 12-00183(1416-2009)
ANDREWS, RICHARD T. v COUNTY OF CAYUGA,746CA 12-00103(2009-1448)
BARNES, JESSIE J. v HARLING, RONALD624TP 11-00161(2009/06325)
BASSET GROUP, INC., v TOWN OF GREECE TOWN BOARD,648CA 11-02279(10/13415)
BIGBY, KHALLIN D., PEOPLE v654KA 11-01322(I2010-070B)
BLOOM, JR., NORMAN M., PEOPLE v608KA 11-00792(I10-33)
BLUEROCK ENERGY HOLDINGS, INC., v CHAMBRONE, ANGELO F.664CA 11-02434(2011-1145)
BLUEROCK ENERGY HOLDINGS, INC., v CHAMBRONE, ANGELO F.665CA 11-02435(2011-1145)
BUTLER, CALVIN, PEOPLE v484KA 09-02374(I09-01-009)
C., ALBERTO, MTR. OF758CAF 11-00433(B-16960-09)
CAMARDO, JR., JOSEPH A. v CITY OF AUBURN,670CA 11-01200(2011-0259)
CARRASQUILLO, LUIS F., PEOPLE v487KA 10-01400(I2007-1123-1)
CENTERPOINTE CORPORATE PARK, v MONY,598CA 11-02408(I2004-6531)
CHAVIS, ANTHONY v SYRACUSE COMMUNITY HEALTH CENTER, I, NC.761CA 11-02292(2008-8753)
CHECKSFIELD, TERRY v SIEDLICKI, SR., JOHN C.790CA 11-02594(2008-2885)
CITY OF BUFFALO, MTR. OF668CA 11-02021(2011-000814)
CITY OF SYRACUSE, v CENTRAL NEW YORK ASSN. OF DELTA,697CA 11-02503(2009-4467)
CLARK, JEREMY, PEOPLE v650KA 10-02500(S34284)
CLOSE, DAWN M. v DARIEN LAKE THEME PARK AND CAMPING, RESORT, INC.691CA 11-02220(2007/11293)
COBLE, DONTAE, PEOPLE v702KA 10-02442(I2010-0571)
COLEMAN, KERRY A., PEOPLE v754KA 10-00286(S2009-03090A (VOP))
CONSILIO, CARYN A. v TERRIGINO, CHRISTOPHER641CAF 11-00869(V01488-10/10D)
CONTI, CAROL D. v TOWN OF CONSTANTIA,718CA 11-02554(08-2093)
COUNTY OF ERIE, v DAINES, RICHARD F.661CA 12-00134(2010-12362)
COUNTY OF NIAGARA, v DAINES, RICHARD F.667CA 11-02505(142572)
DEPONCEAU, VICTOR A., PEOPLE v200KA 08-00634(I2005-0962B)
DUDEK, EDWARD, CONNIFF, JAMES v643CA 11-02459(2009-3895)
DUKE, MICHELLE L. v DUKE, BRIAN A.762CA 10-01871(SF 2008-902270)
ENGLERT, LEONARD M. v SCHAFFER, JR., ESQ., GERALD W.783CA 12-00064(2006/12365)
ERIE COUNTY S.P.C.A., v HOSKINS, BETH642CA 11-02239(I2010-5704)
FFT SENIOR COMMUNITIES, INC., v TOWN OF CANANDAIGUA,572.1CA 11-02058(099643)
FINCH, BENJAMIN, PEOPLE v756KA 10-02502(S10-114)
FOSTER, ANDREW J. v FOSTER, CANDIE A.778CAF 11-00382(V-02225-04/10F)
FRACCOLA, ALAN P., FRACCOLA, PROVIDENZA M. v646CA 12-00165(93021)
G., DREVONNE, MTR. OF232CAF 11-00084(B-20755-57-08)
GARDNER, DALE M. v STIVERS SENECA MARINE, INC.,162CA 11-01783(I2007-97662)
GERMAIN, BARBARA v KOHL'S CORPORATION,734CA 11-02540(2010-0642)
GRAVES, JULIUS, PEOPLE v722KA 11-00153(I2009-1339)
GRIBBINS, JAMES v RUSHFORD LAKE RECREATION DISTRICT,496CA 10-02432(38434)
GUILFORD, JAMES E., PEOPLE v552KA 08-01674(I2007-0874-1)
GUTIERREZ, ANDRES P., PEOPLE v708KA 10-01794(I08-306)
GUZMAN, EVAN P., PEOPLE v680KA 11-00401(I2009-3406)
HAMM, DARYL, PEOPLE v752KA 10-01591(I2008-3123)
HANN, RICHARD v BLACK, STEPHEN R.1388CA 11-01042(102608/08)
HARRIS, RUTH S. v STOELZEL, WILLIAM716CA 12-00021(2009-0117)
HASLEY, JEREMY, PEOPLE v704KA 11-00194(I2006-0049X)
HAYWOOD, TAUREAN v KIRKPATRICK, ROBERT A.599TP 11-01702(I-2011-02346)
HAYWOOD, SR., LAMONT v ANZALONE, MELISSA662CAF 08-01780(V00472/73-08)
HOLMES, TERRY L., PEOPLE v633KA 08-02353(I2007-1049)
HOWINGTON, JAMELL, PEOPLE v679KA 11-02514(10-0746)
HUMPHREY, DONOVAN v CAMPANY, EDWARD804CA 11-02005(2009-9679)
HUNTSMAN, CRAIG A., PEOPLE v556KA 08-02239(I08-01-024)
HUNTSMAN, CRAIG, PEOPLE v557KA 11-00567(I08-01-024)
IRVIN, PLIEKOU, PEOPLE v705KA 11-00062(I02-01-046)
J., TIOSHA, MTR. OF779CAF 11-00022(B-7173-2007, B-7174-2007
JACKSON, II, LOUIS v BEACH, DEBBRA612CAF 10-02472(V-78-00/09AC)
JAMES, LEONARD, PEOPLE v676KA 11-00544(I2010-7240)
JELKS, MELVIN M. v WRIGHT, KIM759CAF 11-01599(F-06586-09/10C)
JIMENEZ, EDUARDO, PEOPLE v605KA 09-02644(I2004-0073-1)
JOE, QUINTRELL L., PEOPLE v859KA 08-00219(I2007-0390-2)
JOHNSON, TIMOTHY T. v GENESEE MANAGEMENT, INC.,784CA 11-02510(2007/12234)
K., VIOLETTE, MTR. OF780CAF 11-01673(NN-02269-10)
KIRK, SR., RICHARD, PEOPLE v403KA 08-01439(I07C-122)
KNIGHT, MARY J. v REALTY USA.COM, INC.,690CA 12-00089(143001)
KYLER, BRADLEY I., PEOPLE v656KA 10-01006(I09-101)
L., ALEXIA, MTR. OF637CAF 11-01028(B-1637-10)
L., BRANDON, MTR. OF638CAF 11-01029(B-1638-10)
LANE, GERTRUDE A. v TEXAS ROADHOUSE HOLDINGS, LLC,423CA 11-02265(07-7908)
LEWIS, NATHAN v GRAHAM, HAROLD D.634KAH 11-00852(2010-1140)
LIAROS, THEODORE S. v TED'S JUMBO RED HOTS, INC.,721CA 11-02520(I2011-846)
LICARI, SALVATORE J. v NEW YORK CENTRAL MUTUAL INSURANCE,671CA 12-00131(2010-1394)
LINER, JOSHUA v FISCHER, BRIAN627TP 12-00223(21,081-11)
LONG, WILLIAM, PEOPLE v770KA 10-02077(I2009-0016)
LOWTHER, NICOLE L. v EASTMAN, CHRISTOPHER A.811.1CAF 12-00468(V-02280-04/11F)
M., AUSTIN, MTR. OF635CAF 11-01521(AS-09097-07)
M., AUSTIN, MTR. OF636CAF 11-01522(AS-09097-07)
MASTERSON, JEFFREY, PEOPLE v769KA 11-00399(I96-0124)
MCCRAY, WENFORD N., PEOPLE v749KA 11-01022(I2008-168)
MCINTOSH, II, EVERETT C., PEOPLE v607KA 11-00677(I2010-025)
MCLAUGHLIN, ANN L., MTR. OF747CA 11-01131(2008-1960/E)
MCLAUGHLIN, ANN L., MTR. OF748CA 11-01132(2008-1960/E)
MEDEN, JASON M., PEOPLE v773KA 11-00975(ST09-131)
MILLER, VINCENT, PEOPLE v703KA 10-02512(II10-109)
MITCHELL, DONTIE S. v FISCHER, BRIAN743CA 11-00383(2010-7531)
MONTAGUE, KIM v BROOKS, JASON A.685CAF 11-01129(V-02201-10, V-03488-10)
MORGAN, NICHOLAS J., PEOPLE v628KA 07-01252(I2005-0783B)
MURPHY, SUSAN v STATE OF NEW YORK,785CA 12-00104(115287)
MURRAY, WILLIAM M. v STATE OF NEW YORK,764CA 11-01856(M-79011)
NASTRI REAL ESTATE, LLC, v BEBLO, DOLORES744CA 11-02506(2011-4260)
NASTRI REAL ESTATE, LLC, v BEBLO, DOLORES745CA 11-02511(2011-4260)
NEW YORK CENTRAL MUTUAL FIRE INSURA, v NUGENT PANEPINTO, J.S.C., CATHERINE645OP 12-00096
NICHOLSON, CHRISTOPHER A. v NICHOLSON, DONNA M.710CAF 10-01623(V-00211-08/09A)
NIKOLOV, NIKOLA K. v TOWN OF CHEEKTOWAGA,524CA 11-01871(I-2008-2914)
P., NOAH VINCENT, MTR. OF733CAF 11-00442(B-04511-10)
PALMS, CURTIS, PEOPLE v772KA 09-01943(I2007-0927-13)
PATRICK PROPERTIES, LLC, v STOCKER, KEVIN766CA 10-02509(09-13243)
PECK, JAY, PEOPLE v727KA 11-00376(I2010-0906-1)
PETRONE, MICHAEL R. v ARGENTO, VICTORIA M.625OP 11-02595
POLONCARZ, MARK C. v COLLINS, CHRISTOPHER C.1209CA 11-00918(2010/011796)
PRACHEL, KATHLEEN v TOWN OF WEBSTER,450CA 11-02197(6502-07)
REEVES, MAURICE v ERIE COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL SE, RVICES731CAF 11-01515(NN-12864-10/10A)
RIVERA, ANTHONY, PEOPLE v723KA 11-01263(I2010-02509)
RLI INSURANCE COMPANY, v SMIEDALA, LESLIE616CA 12-00261(2007-130744)
RODRIGUEZ, ALBERTO v FISCHER, BRIAN526TP 11-01795(21067-11)
ROTTERMAN, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v726KA 11-01340(I01-198)
ROUTE 104 & ROUTE 21 DEVELOPMENT, v CHEVRON U.S.A., INC.,768CA 11-02518(55873)
RUPERT, JR., PHILIP D. v GATES & ADAMS, P.C.,692CA 11-02098(04/2692)
RUPERT, JR., PHILIP D. v GATES & ADAMS, P.C.,693CA 11-02099(04/2692)
RUSS, SR., BRYON K. v FISCHER, BRIAN739CA 11-00260(2010-0704)
S., ANASTASHIA, MTR. OF684CAF 11-01814(B-12-10)
S., SAMED, MTR. OF611CAF 10-02034(NA-12674-06)
SALIM, RAFIQ, PEOPLE v755KA 10-01173(I2009-1771I)
SANTIAGO, JR., CARLOS, PEOPLE v775KA 08-01881(I2007-0885)
SCHREIER, DAVID W., PEOPLE v707KA 11-02547(2009-0418)
SCOTT, LASHAWN J., PEOPLE v655KA 11-00404(I2004-0883C)
SEGUIN, LAWRENCE D. v LANDFRIED, M.D., MATTHEW J.666CA 11-02552(2007-012874)
SELECT FABRICATORS, INC., v HOGE, WILLIAM594CA 11-01299(98614)
SELECT FABRICATORS, INC., v HOGE, WILLIAM593CA 11-01298(98614)
SERVEY, TRAVIS, PEOPLE v651KA 10-02302(S10-333)
SHAFF, LAUREN, MTR. OF732CAF 12-00118(D-105-11)
SHUTE, JR., STEWART M. v MCLUSKY, ROBERT415CA 11-00944(08-5190)
SHUTE, JR., STEWART M. v MCLUSKY, ROBERT416CA 11-00945(08-5190)
SHUTE, JR., STEWART M. v MCCLUSKY, ROBERT421CA 11-02575(08-5190)
SHUTE, JR., STEWART M. v MCCLUSKY, ROBERT422CA 11-02596(08-5190)
SIMMONS, JR., RICHARD A., PEOPLE v652KA 11-01084(I2010-188)
SMITH, ELEANOR M. v CORNELL, CRYSTAL M.720CA 11-02592(168/06)
SOLOMON, JOEQUELL E., PEOPLE v574KA 10-01960(I10-01-026)
SPRATLEY, KENT D., PEOPLE v631KA 11-00486(II10-097)
SQUIRES, GEORGE P., PEOPLE v675KA 11-01490(I2011-5012)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v HALL, JOHN717CA 11-01437(59893)
STOCK, LYNN v DALY, M.D., DENNIS400CA 11-01973(06-2709)
STUBBS, JASON MARCELLUS, PEOPLE v699KA 06-03122(I114/06)
STUBBS, JASON MARCELLUS, PEOPLE v700KA 06-03701(I114/06)
SURF CITY ENTERPRISES OF SYRACUSE,, v NEW YORK STATE LIQUOR AUTHORITY,712TP 12-00139(2011-6895)
TARO, JASON, PEOPLE v507KA 08-02457(I2008-0015-1)
TENNEY, PAUL R., PEOPLE v601KA 10-00661(S09-108)
TENNEY, PAUL R., PEOPLE v602KA 11-01305(S09-108)
THOMAS, TOM v BOHEEN DAVIS, CYNTHIA L.617CA 11-02181(30975/2005)
THOMPSON, KENNETH L., PEOPLE v753KA 10-01781(I09-85)
THOUSAND, ROBERT J., PEOPLE v678KA 11-00249(I2009-283-1)
TINCH-MCNEILL, SANDRA v ALCOHOL AND DRUG DEPENDENCY SERVICE,613CA 11-00681(2003-7789)
TUPER, PATRICIA P. v TUPER, KENNETH E.446CA 11-02168(105925)
TURNER, JESSIE A., PEOPLE v560KA 07-00633(I2006-0737-2 & 0679-1)
TYSON, MICHEL v NAZARIAN, LAWRENCE294CA 11-02068(2008-06560)
VAN BROCKLEN, RUSSEL v ERIE COUNTY MEDICAL CENTER,571CA 11-02199(2010-8697)
VANBUREN, ALEXANDRA v WILLIAMSVILLE CENTRAL SCHOOL DIST.,686CA 12-00138(2011-410)
WALKER, BENNY L., PEOPLE v750KA 09-00282(I2007-0106)
WEIR, TRACI L., PEOPLE v757KA 07-02335(SI-05-515A-04)
WILSON, HARRY, PEOPLE v728KA 11-01163(I10-04-085)