AD4 Seal

Supreme Court of the State of New York
APPELLATE DIVISION
Fourth Judicial Department

Decisions - September 27, 2013

 
Allegany
RHODES, BRENDAN J., PEOPLE v847KA 12-00847(SSCI10-042)
 
Cattaraugus
WEEKLEY, KEITH A. v WEEKLEY, SARAH A.952CAF 12-01023(V-1396-07/10D and 11E)
 
Cayuga
ALVARADO, HECTOR, PEOPLE v961KA 12-00992(I2001-058)
SMITH, JAMES v GRAHAM, HAROLD D.854KAH 12-00565(2011-0861)
STOUDYMIRE, ANITA v NYS DIVISION OF HUMAN RIGHTS,842CA 13-00248(2012-0256)
TOWN OF THROOP, v CORDWAY, CHRISTINE997CA 13-00108(2011-0915)
WALKER, LAMONT v FISCHER, BRIAN891TP 13-00295(2012-252)
 
Chautauqua
PANZICA, RUTH ANN v FANTAUZZI, MICHAEL R.863CA 13-00217(K1-2011-181)
 
Erie
BAKER HALL, v CITY OF LACKAWANNA ZONING BOARD OF,845CA 12-01990(2012-1448)
BENNEFIELD, ADAM, PEOPLE v919KA 11-02104(I2000-0435)
BENNEFIELD, ADAM, PEOPLE v920KA 12-01043(I2000-0435)
BENZIN, DAWN v KUTY, TIMOTHY949CAF 12-01770(V-14061-03/11D, V-14061-
BOLDEN, WILLIAM, PEOPLE v944KA 10-02194(I2009-3214)
BRITT, CARMEN v BUFFALO MUNICIPAL HOUSING AUTHORITY,971CA 12-00173(I2004-9897)
BRITT, CARMEN v BUFFALO MUNICIPAL HOUSING AUTHORITY,977CA 13-00146(I2004-9897)
CHANDLER, SAMUEL, PEOPLE v985KA 11-02160(I2010-1494)
CURTO, PATRICIA v NATIONAL FUEL CORPORATION,973CA 12-01850(I2011-4626)
CURTO, PATRICIA v NATIONAL FUEL CORPORATION,972CA 12-01849(I2011-4626)
DUNLOP, EVA E. v SAINT LEO THE GREAT R.C. CHURCH,865CA 13-00129(I 2011-4361)
ENVIRONMENTAL TESTING & CONSULTING, v CITY OF BUFFALO,954CA 13-00331(2006-10375)
EPPS, BILLIE, PEOPLE v850KA 12-00899(S33266)
FRASCELLA, KATHERINE v HAMBURG CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,1018CA 13-00128(2011-4426)
GAFFNEY, PATRICK v NORAMPAC INDUSTRIES, INC.,992CA 13-00339(2010-2140)
HSBC BANK USA, MTR. OF860CA 13-00332(22-9710/A)
J., KADYN, ERIE COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL, SERVICES v929CAF 12-01287(NN-18086-11, NN-18087-11
JOHNSON, CLAUDIA S. v JOHNSON, LARRY C.933CA 12-01749(SF2006-902415)
JOHNSON, CLAUDIA S. v JOHNSON, LARRY C.934CA 12-01751(SF2006-902415)
KNIGHTON, ROBERT, PEOPLE v988KA 11-01850(I2010-02943D)
MANISCALCO, MELISSA v MANISCALCO, PHILIP879CA 12-01237(SF 2010-901282)
MANISCALCO, MELISSA v MANISCALCO, PHILIP880CA 12-01238(SF2010/901282)
MCCUTCHEON, JUSTIN, PEOPLE v829KA 11-02358(I2010-2602I)
MICRO-LINK, LLC, v TOWN OF AMHERST,881CA 12-02346(7983/07)
MICRO-LINK, LLC, v TOWN OF AMHERST,882CA 12-02347(7983/07)
NEWBURY PLACE REO II, LLC, v ZAHRAN, ALI A.960CA 13-00296(2009-9931)
O'BRIEN, COLLEEN v BAINBRIDGE, LARRY J.990CA 13-00453(I2005-7382)
PEMBERTON, ROY T. v KALEIDA HEALTH,913CA 12-02162(2011-458)
PHILLIPS, HENDELL, PEOPLE v872KA 09-00579(I2007-0188R)
PITTMAN, MARIO, PEOPLE v826KA 11-02124(I2005-00887)
PRICE, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v966KA 11-01766(I2010-02624)
RAMOS, BURT G. v HUGHES, TIMOTHY P.866CA 12-02275(I 2010-11584)
RESZKA, ELIZABETH v COLLINS, COUNCILMAN JOSEPH A.885OP 13-00321(123270)
SIGNS, ROBIN A. v CRAWFORD, DAVID D.938CA 12-02306(2009 010244)
SUMMERS, GLENN B. v SPADA, PETER A.969CA 13-00238(I2009-5625)
SUNICK, ALBERT R. v WADSWORTH, JOHN M.981CA 13-00276(I2012-1442)
SWAIN, ELISHA R., PEOPLE v833KA 11-01826(I2009-03317)
WIND, SUSAN P. v MCNEIL, TIMOTHY J.935CA 12-02188(I-2009-11843)
WORTHY, DEVINE, PEOPLE v893KA 11-02264(I2010-01371D)
WORTHY, DEVINE, PEOPLE v894KA 11-02118(I2011-00236D)
 
Genesee
ETTLEMAN, PATRICK J., PEOPLE v874KA 12-00279(I5447)
FEIDNER, CHRISTOPHER J., PEOPLE v828KA 12-00501(S11-069)
SHUMWAY, DAVID v KELLEY, JUSTIN838CA 12-02159(51805)
SHUMWAY, DAVID v KELLEY, JUSTIN839CA 12-02160(51805)
WALRADT, APRIL v BATAVIA FAMILY DENTAL,834CA 13-00382(59161)
 
Herkimer
CHILDS, CHARLIE v CITY OF LITTLE FALLS,916TP 13-00235(96898)
COUNTY OF HERKIMER, v VILLAGE OF HERKIMER,937CA 12-02254(95576)
 
Jefferson
B., ALAZAYA I., MTR. OF908CAF 12-01141(NA-03821-10)
B., ALAZAYA I., MTR. OF900CAF 12-01218(NA-03821-10)
B., KAYDEN M., MTR. OF909CAF 12-01142(NN-01234-11)
B., KAYDEN M., MTR. OF901CAF 12-01271(NN-01234-11)
NORTZ, SCOTT R. v MICHIGAN MILLERS MUTUAL INSURANCE C,995CA 13-00014(2009-00002730)
 
Monroe
BRUMFIELD, MICHAEL S., PEOPLE v851KA 09-01582(I2008-0896)
CAMPBELL, JASPER, PEOPLE v896KA 10-00720(I2007-0993B)
CAPPON, CHRISTOPHER v CARBALLADA, CARLOS858CA 13-00081(2010-12487)
CARTER, TARRELL J., PEOPLE v965KA 09-00854(I2008-0199)
CLARKE, JAMES B. v DANGELO, CAROL975CA 13-00397(5335-08)
CONEY, MARK D., PEOPLE v925KA 08-02110(I2007-1032)
COTTON, STEVEN L., PEOPLE v989KA 08-02485(I2008-0249)
CUFFIE, VICTOR, PEOPLE v983KA 09-00497(I2008-0305)
DASHER, BERNARD, PEOPLE v873KA 09-00175(I2008-0455)
FLYNN, PATRICIA v HADDAD, MIKHAEL N.991CA 13-00413(78-2010)
GLOVER, CAROLYN v BOTSFORD, DAVID959CA 13-00394(2010-6415)
GLOVER, WARREN J., PEOPLE v986KA 10-00503(I2008-0780)
H., JAMAL, PEOPLE v831KA 11-01483(I2010-0882A)
H., JAMAL, PEOPLE v830KA 11-01482(I2010-0773A)
HUMPHREY, DONOVAN, PEOPLE v947KA 09-01395(I2008-0083)
J., ISAAC, MTR. OF950CAF 12-02037(D-3014-11)
JONES, CLEMON, PEOPLE v853KA 09-02028(I2006-0711)
MILTON, HAROLD v JOYCE, LINDA889TP 12-01227(2337/2012)
THOUSAND, KIMBERLY, PEOPLE v917KA 12-00607(I2008-0294)
UTICA NATIONAL INSURANCE GROUP, v OUR TOUCH, INC.,957CA 13-00191(09-16634)
VAN SHARMA, INC., v CHAMBERLAIN, GEORGE A.840CA 12-01794(2009/3992)
VARGAS, DARIANA, PEOPLE v899KA 09-01313(I2008-0942)
 
Niagara
CIRIFALCO, JUDITH M. v U.S.I. BUILDING SERVICES, INC.,843CA 13-00299(132655)
FARINELLA, GUS MICHAEL v STATE OF NEW YORK,1016CA 13-00418(116051)
MCCALL, JOE ANN v SANDERS, JOYCE A.976CA 12-02091(145283)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v MATTER, MICHAEL955CA 12-01123(7317)
 
Oneida
ALEXANDER, TYREE, PEOPLE v827KA 08-00648(II05-153)
BOSCO, MAUREEN, MTR. OF878CA 12-01550(CA2010-001192)
CONLEY & TIBBITTS PROPERTIES, LLC, v LEATHERSTOCKING COOPERATIVE INSURAN, CE COMPANY980CA 13-00372(CA2011-002318)
SOWICH, CHRISTINA v COUNTY OF ONEIDA,939CA 12-02339(CA2011-000494)
THEALL, ADAM, PEOPLE v852KA 11-00684(II10-294)
UTICA CUTLERY COMPANY, v HISCOCK & BARCLAY, LLP,930CA 13-00377(2009-1804)
ZOECKLER, SR., DAVID D. v STATE OF NEW YORK,883CA 13-00148(118689)
 
Onondaga
ABBOTT, JONATHAN v LUCCHETTI, JR., VITO WILLIAM835CA 12-02371(2011-3001)
ABBOTT, JONATHAN v LUCCHETTI, JR., VITO WILLIAM841CA 12-02372(2011-3001)
ABBOTT, JONATHAN v CROWN MILL RESTORATION DEVELOPMENT,846CA 12-02373(06-0442)
CARTER, DEBBIE v SYRACUSE UNIVERSITY CARRIER DOME,998CA 13-00294(6279/10)
IMANVERDI, ATASH v POPOVICI, DPM, BRYAN G.953CA 12-00885(2007-7750)
JOHNSON, STEPHON, PEOPLE v967KA 12-01162(I2009-1104-2)
JOHNSON, GREGORY, PEOPLE v964KA 09-02542(I2009-0036-1)
LOPEZ, ROBERTO R., PEOPLE v848KA 12-00428(I2009-0503-1)
MAZELLA, JANICE v BEALS, M.D., WILLIAM931CA 12-01864(2010-3387)
SMITH, BARTHOLOMEW, PEOPLE v918KA 09-02651(I2009-0240-1)
STEVENS, CLAYTON H., PEOPLE v987KA 09-02539(I2009-0512-1)
SYSCO SYRACUSE, LLC, v EGAN, III, STUART1001CA 12-02121(2012-EF56)
VARANO, KELLY v FORBA HOLDINGS, LLC,996CA 12-01911(2011-2128) & (I11-7011)
WILLIAMS, KENNETH E. v WILLIAMS, MIKI M.1015CAF 12-01557(F-06231-11/11A)
 
Ontario
BATTLE, STARLET, PEOPLE v926KA 12-00546(I11-01-054)
BROWN, CHRISTY M. v WOLFGRAM, RAYMOND902CAF 12-01216(V-00213-08/09A-F)
HAWKINS, JOHN J., PEOPLE v892KA 11-02361(I10-10-224)
PARE, TERESA M. v WHITE, JR., RICHARD W.904CAF 12-01419(G-00907-09/11J)
VANALST, FRANK, PEOPLE v890.1KA 12-01643(I11-10-197)
WHITE, JR., RICHARD W. v WILCOX, AMANDA903CAF 12-01205(P-00528-11)
WHITE, JR., RICHARD W. v WILCOX, AMANDA905CAF 12-01421(G-00907-09/11G)
 
Orleans
DUDLEY, FRANK v KHAHAIFA, SIBATU897KAH 11-02615(11-39200)
SOIS, DEBBIE v FISCHER, BRIAN825TP 13-00333(12-40487)
 
Oswego
KAMINSKI, STANLEY A., PEOPLE v962KA 11-01660(I10C-145)
SWANK, STEVEN M., PEOPLE v832KA 11-01558(I10C-70)
 
Steuben
BUTTON, CHRISTAL L., ALLEN, RICHARD J. v927CAF 12-00627(V-000421-11/11A)
GALLAGHER, LISA A. v GALLAGHER, MICHAEL T.951CAF 13-00206(F-00608-10/10A)
 
Wayne
BROWNELL, CASEY, PEOPLE v946KA 13-00053(I 11-13)
GUNTER, SABRINA, PEOPLE v982KA 12-00715(I11-05)
VANDERBROOK, GAIL v EMERALD SPRINGS RANCH,855CA 12-01981(62589/2007)
 
Wyoming
DUBOIS, HARLEY D., PEOPLE v869KA 12-01954(I6653)
FAIELLO, DEAN v FISCHER, BRIAN978CA 11-02248(20,931-10)
STEWART, RANDLOPH v FISCHER, BRIAN867TP 13-00379(21,276-12)
ZUFALL, KATHERINE v ZUFALL, KARL887CA 12-01799(42832)
ZUFALL, KATHERINE v ZUFALL, KARL888CA 12-01800(42832)
    
 MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS