March 15, 2017
PERSONAL & CONFIDENTIAL
This responds to your inquiry (16-174) asking 1) whether you may preside in matters involving a local probation officer who has been recently appointed to serve on the village board in the same village where you serve as part-time justice; 2) whether you may preside in matters involving the probation officer’s subordinates and their probationers; and 3) whether you may preside in matters involving the probation officer who will be running for election on the same slate as you.
A part-time village justice is disqualified subject to remittal in any matter where a village board member is involved in a matter pending before the judge. Remittal is unavailable in any case where a party is self-represented. If other probation officers or probationers appear, the part-time judge need not recuse, unless the probation officer/village board member is involved in the matter either directly or in a supervisory capacity.
The fact that you and the probation officer/village board member will be running on the same slate does not create a reasonable basis to question your impartiality and, therefore, does not alter the analysis concerning disqualification.
As a reminder, when running on the same slate, a judicial candidate must refrain from endorsing another candidate but may otherwise participate in activities involving the slate of candidates, subject to the Rules Governing Judicial Conduct (see e.g. 22 NYCRR 100.5 [political activity]). If you have any questions about your judicial campaign, you may contact the Judicial Campaign Ethics Center (http://www.nycourts.gov/ip/jcec/) for guidance.
Enclosed, for your convenience, are Opinions 16-21; 15-121; 14-84; and 09-16 which address this issue.
Very truly yours,
George D. Marlow, Assoc. Justice
Appellate Div., First Dep’t (Ret.)
Hon. Margaret T. Walsh
Family Court Judge
Acting Justice, Supreme Court