AD4 Seal

Supreme Court of the State of New York
APPELLATE DIVISION
Fourth Judicial Department

Decisions - February 6, 2009

ADAMS, RODNEY, PEOPLE v11KA 07-01627(I2003-5336)
ALLAH, WAHEEM v HODSON, TIM48TP 08-01457(40993)
ALLPORT, BRIAN L., PEOPLE v212KA 07-01644(I06-62)
ANDERSON, THOMAS v TOWN OF CHILI PLANNING BOARD,1360CA 08-00311(5930-07)
ARNOLD, JANET v ERIE COUNTY MEDICAL CENTER, CORPORATION1640CA 08-00743(I2007-2871)
B., CLARK C. v FULLER, II, NEIL1466CA 07-01831(03-1985)
BARON, RICHARD v KLEWIN BUILDING COMPANY, INC.,251CA 08-02156(2003-12753)
BELILE, THOMAS J., PEOPLE v214KA 08-00018(I05-64)
BETSY ROSS REHABILITATION CENTER,, INC. v BIRNBAUM, MICHAEL J.1489CA 08-00507(01-00995)
BLACK, GORDON S. v DOLIN, LONNY H.156CA 08-01088(13648/02)
BLACK, DARRYL, PEOPLE v1563KA 08-00676(2007-0815)
BLOOM, ROBERT W. v HENSEL, ESQ., RENE F.1419CA 08-01064(2005-8014)
BOYD, PATRICK, PEOPLE v213KA 06-02298(II05-226)
BRITO, WILFREDO, PEOPLE v211KA 06-02286(I2005-1165-1)
BROOKS, KIMBERLY, PEOPLE v210KA 07-00151(I06C-050)
BROWN, HOMER, PEOPLE v32KA 05-02601(I2005-314)
BROWN, LAMAR, PEOPLE v1606KA 06-02121(S21871)
BRYANT, THOMAS v FISCHER, BRIAN47TP 08-01530(20613-08)
BUNNELL, GERRI L., PEOPLE v55KA 06-03548(I4701)
BURSHTYNSKY, LOMA, PEOPLE v231KA 08-00628(S07-73)
BUTCHER, ORLANDO, PEOPLE v2KA 07-01725(II07-170)
C.,  MADISON, MTR. OF61CAF 07-01094(NA-03975-05, NA-03976-05
CANNON, TYRONE, PEOPLE v103KA 06-03543(I-2005-0377-1)
CARABALLO, FRANSISCO, PEOPLE v123KA 03-02272(I631/02)
CARDINELL, JACK A. v CHERUNDOLO, BOTTAR & LEONE, P.C.,155CA 08-01631(2005-4040)
CARR, ERIC D., PEOPLE v58KA 07-01927(I01872-2006)
CARTER, DAMARIUS, PEOPLE v82KA 03-01746(02-937-1)
CATARACT SPORTS & ENTERTAINMENT, GROUP, LLC v ESSEX INSURANCE COMPANY,1658CA 08-01419(11491)
CHABOT, JASON A. v CHABOT, LISA177CAF 07-01801(V-00178-98/06M)
CLAPP, DOLLY, PEOPLE v4KA 07-02430(I00575-2006)
CLIFFORD, SEAN D., PEOPLE v187KA 07-02424(SID07-0024)
CONKLIN, EDWIN v BONGIOVANNI, MICHAEL160CA 08-01841(2005--524)
COOPER, JESSIE JAMES, PEOPLE v1566KA 03-02013(I122/03)
COOPER, JESSIE JAMES, PEOPLE v1567KA 03-02014(I066/03)
COR ROUTE 5 COMPANY, LLC, v SARACENE, ALFRED226CA 08-01645(2007-5158)
COUNTY OF ONTARIO, v MIDDLEBROOK, BRUCE EDWIN1621CA 08-01073(98384)
COWARD, BOBBY M., PEOPLE v166KA 06-02819(I2005-1414-1)
CRANDALL, ERIK v WRIGHT WISNER DISTRIBUTING CORP.,1615CA 08-01166(2005-2143)
CUNNINGHAM, ARLENE K. v JACKSON, II, LOUIS J.174CAF 07-01578(V-78-00/06V)
DALEY, PATRICK L. v COUNTY OF ERIE,1661CA 08-00606(2007-7962)
DANIELS, DAMIEN, PEOPLE v56KA 07-02197(I2006-2892)
DARTNELL ENTERPRISES, INC., v HEWLETT-PACKARD COMPANY,1532CA 08-00746(2006/02709)
DECAPUA, ROCKY, PEOPLE v233KA 07-00952(I17/03)
DOZIER, TIMOTHY, PEOPLE v165KA 07-02563(I02185-2006)
DRECHSEL, CHERI ANN v NARBY, GEORGE M.1683CA 08-00167(I2001-10053)
DUDLEY, JUDITH E. v TOWN BOARD OF TOWN OF PRATTSBURGH,1708OP 08-01586
DUNBAR, JESSIE M. v ORTON, WILLIAM G.113CA 08-01223(04-1852)
DUNBAR, JESSIE M. v ORTON, WILLIAM G.115CA 08-01847(04-1852)
E., ANTHONY, MTR. OF13CAF 08-00720(B-1960-06, B-1961-06)
EBLING, STEPHEN v TOWN OF EDEN,134TP 08-01582(2008-4256)
EDWARDS, KEVIN M., PEOPLE v145KA 07-02487(S28859)
ELDERWOOD HEALTH CARE CENTER, v NOVELLO, M.D., ANTONIA C.18CA 08-01547(2006-7928)
ELLSWORTH, ROBERT W., PEOPLE v170KA 07-02648(I06-481)
ERB, RUDY E., PEOPLE v1369KA 07-02140(CR 04-687) & (I2004-447)
EVOLUTION IMPRESSIONS, INC., v LEWANDOWSKI, JAMES D.1531CA 08-00297(2005/06051)
F., MARIA, MTR. OF83CAF 08-00595(B-00575-07, B-00577-07)
FARROW, THOMAS, PEOPLE v25KA 06-01033(SI-2004-0965-1)
FASANO, VIRGINIA v J.C. PENNEY CORPORATION,1698CA 08-00093(14213-06)
FASANO, VIRGINIA v J.C. PENNEY CORPORATION,1699CA 08-00094(14213-06)
FLAGG, JAUQERE, PEOPLE v218KA 06-01497(I2005-0895-1)
FLEMMING, RICKY, PEOPLE v219KA 06-01620(I2006-020)
FOSTER, TIMOTHY v BARTLETT, BARBARA131CAF 07-01913(V-01242-03/07C, V-01242-
FOSTER, ANTHONY, PEOPLE v238KA 05-01036(I04-856)
FRIEDHABER, KENNETH H. v TOWN BOARD OF TOWN OF SHELDON,228CA 07-02495(38491)
GAGNE, STEPHEN v FISCHER, BRIAN72TP 08-01529(20605-08)
GAGNER, JOHN D., PEOPLE v106KA 07-00814(I06-07-078)
GARCIA, EDWIN v BARIE, NORA1676CAF 07-00708(F-01034-96/06B)
GARDNER, MATTHEW, PEOPLE v239KA 06-01216(I05-0815-1)
GARDNER, JACOB, PEOPLE v186KA 06-02853(I464/02)
GIMENEZ, EDWIN, PEOPLE v1666KA 07-01385(I2005-2028-001)
GONYOU, CRYSTAL M. v SANMARTIN, JUSTIN M.21CA 08-01715(2006-366)
GOUGH, JAMES R. v SCHILD, JEAN G.202CA 08-01460(07/06383)
GRACE, ELEANOR B. v GRACE, DANIEL W.60CAF 07-02450(V-00910-03/07C, V-00911-
GRACE, DANIEL W. v GRACE, ELEANOR B.59CAF 07-02449(V-00910-03/07B, V-00911-
GRAY, JOSEPH v KIRKPATRICK, ROBERT A.1680CA 07-01353(I2006-10116)
GREEN, DEMAR, PEOPLE v232KA 08-00373(I2007-1454)
GROTH, RICHARD N. v BJ'S WHOLESALE CLUB, INC.,1660CA 08-00072(05-4197)
GUTZMER, CARL A. v SANTINI, MYRIAM L.1526CAF 07-02724(V-00039-98/07S, V-00039-
HAMILTON, THERESA, PEOPLE v125KA 05-02437(I2004-816)
HAMPTON, JR., FRANKLIN JOEL THOMAS v DENNISON, ROBERT80KAH 07-02532(07-Writ-6)
HANSON, PAUL v LABRIOLA, A.162.1TP 08-01484(08-34708)
HARRIS, WILLETTE v JACKSON, EILEEN70CA 08-01056(1-2004-589)
HERRING, CLAYTON E., PEOPLE v144KA 07-02328(I2006-558)
HINCKLEY, LISA v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,117CA 08-01401(I2003-7777)
HINKSON, WAYNE R., PEOPLE v24KA 07-01827(I06-10-134)
HINKSON, WAYNE, PEOPLE v49KA 07-01825(S05-DI-237)
HOLLINS, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v163KA 05-02671(I2005-45)
HOME INSULATION & SUPPLY, INC., v BUCHHEIT, JR., GERALD A.1642CA 08-01428(2004-11838)
HUNT, ROBERT L., PEOPLE v28KA 08-00008(I2002-158)
IGLESIAS, TAMMY v BROWN, ANNE183CA 08-01627(2005-5035)
IOCOVOZZI, VINCENT D. v GETNICK LIVINGSTON ATKINSON GIGLIOT,89CA 08-01663(2380/04)
IVEYS, III, RAYMOND M., PEOPLE v73KA 08-00158(S2006-484)
J., KASEEM, MTR. OF201CAF 07-01072(B-03088-06, B-03089-06)
JACKSON, ANTHONY v GRAHAM, HAROLD1KAH 08-00495(2007-0695)
JACKSON, CONSTANTINE, PEOPLE v124KA 06-03044(I2004-0231-1-V)
JACKSON, ISAAC, PEOPLE v27KA 07-02668(II07-100)
JAMES, WILLIAM, PEOPLE v50KA 07-01947(S2004-4191)
JOHNSON, DARRELL v ALEXANDER, GEORGE133TP 08-01531(20619-08)
JONES, DANIEL v CITY OF BUFFALO,71CA 07-01836(I2007-1272)
JUHASZ, DANA v JUHASZ, STEPHEN1418CA 08-00284(SF900151/2004)
K., BRITTANY, MTR. OF85CAF 07-01606(B-00437,B-00438, B-00439
K., SAMANTHA, MTR. OF246CAF 08-00290(B-06344-06)
KAPP, JOSHUA, PEOPLE v128KA 06-03797(I2006-0774-4)
KERNAHAN, HASHIM, PEOPLE v51KA 07-02661(I2006-1137)
KERNAHAN, HASHIM, PEOPLE v52KA 07-02662(I2006-1952)
KNIERY, PATRICIA v COTTRELL, INC.,1618CA 08-01388(I2007-5120)
LAIDLAW ENERGY & ENVIRONMENTAL, INC, v TOWN OF ELLICOTTVILLE,1659CA 08-01183(I-2007-11259)
LAKE, DALE v KALEIDA HEALTH,109CA 08-01658(I2003-9117)
LANZARA, KEVIN R., PEOPLE v29KA 07-01247(I2006-102(1))
LEBARON, DENNIS v ERIE INSURANCE COMPANY,43CA 08-01444(96663)
LEE, MILTON, PEOPLE v193KA 07-00774(I00-457)
LEGGIO, JOHN v HOGAN, DANIEL D.111TP 08-01711(I2007-4663)
LIGHTHOUSE POINTE PROPERTY, ASSOCIATES LLC. v NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF, ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATI1330CA 08-00835(2007/9731)
LONG, KEITH v CELLINO & BARNES, P.C.,1620CA 07-01737(2005-7708)
LORD, MICHAELJON H., PEOPLE v240KA 07-01767(I06-035)
LOREE, PHILIP J. v BARNES, JAMES G.108CA 08-01697(98846)
LOWERY, MARIANNE v COLE, ONI176CAF 08-00692(F-2846-00/07D)
LUNDY, GEORGE v CITY OF OSWEGO,87TP 08-01579(07-1512)
LUPPINO, JAMES v O'BRIEN, WILLIAM E.181CA 08-00776(I2004-3571)
LUPPINO, JAMES v O'BRIEN, WILLIAM E.180CA 07-02704(I2004-3571)
LUTHRINGER, KEVIN v LUTHRINGER, GREGORY1423CA 08-00716(I2006-007833)
M., JOSHUA, MTR. OF1633CAF 08-01257(D-233-07/07A)
M., SHAHIDA, MTR. OF130CAF 08-00458(B-15154-55-07)
MAGUIRE, KEITH v CORCORAN, MICHAEL23KAH 08-01196(2007-1153)
MAKARCHUK, ARDA v MAKARCHUK, EDWARD1681CA 08-01118(CA2006-2081)
MALLABER, JOSEPH K., PEOPLE v173KA 07-02185(96355) & (S2007-67W)
MARTIN-GRANDE, DIANE M. v GRANDE, PAUL J.135CA 08-01743(84742)
MARTINEZ, LUIS, PEOPLE v1632KA 04-00585(I2003/0278)
MATTHEWS, CYNTHIA J. v SMALLRIDGE, KEVIN T.1641CA 08-01110(2005/8151)
MAXON, JOSEPH P. v WOODS OVIATT GILMAN LLP,107CA 08-01842(05-13220)
MAYNARD, KAREN, PEOPLE v1485KA 07-02198(I06-78)
MCCALL, JAMAR, PEOPLE v75KA 07-02562(I2006-2215)
MCENNIS, JONATHAN, PEOPLE v189KA 07-02655(I2007-1466)
MCLEOD, LYSA L. v MCLEOD, JAMAR A.241CAF 07-02573(O-821-07, V-00860-71. V-
MCNALLY, PETER R., PEOPLE v98KA 04-02819(S2004-3975)
MCNAUGHTON, RYAN A., PEOPLE v57KA 07-01499(I2006-204)
MCPHEE, JEREMY M. v JOHN D. BRUSH, INC.,22CA 08-01003(2006/9347)
MOORE, WILLIAM, PEOPLE v152KA 07-01083(I01772-2005)
MOORE, MATTHEW, PEOPLE v215KA 07-00825(I0012-2005)
MOORE, RICHARD, PEOPLE v3KA 08-00137(I2006-2800)
MORGAN, GERALD L., PEOPLE v78KA 08-00637(I07-173)
MORRIS, MARLENE v SCHEPP, CHRISTOPHER J.19CA 08-01174(52390)
MOSKAL, IRENE v UTICA COLLEGE,90CA 08-01391(CA2006-002747)
MOSLEY, CHARNELL, PEOPLE v102KA 07-00892(I2004-0306)
MOSLEY, CHARNELL, PEOPLE v101KA 05-00310(I306/04)
MOTHERSELL, ROBERT, PEOPLE v188KA 06-03549(I2006-0433-1)
NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN RI, v VILLAGE PLAZA FAMILY RESTAURANT,1523TP 08-01413(008884/2007)
NEWTON, JR., RAYMOND F., PEOPLE v150KA 07-00719(I06C-091)
O'BRIEN, DANIEL E., PEOPLE v121KA 08-00246(I2002-075-V)
OLIPHANT FINANCIAL CORPORATION, v ANGELO, JAMES T.138CA 08-01587(96171/05)
OUCHIE, CARLA, PEOPLE v6KA 07-00846(I2006-0919A)
PARRIS, YUSEFF v GOORD, GLENN S.230TP 08-01592(CA2007-1827)
PENNINGTON, JAMES E. v WOYTASH, JAMES1513CA 07-01431(2006/7722)
PETERS, DAVID, PEOPLE v10KA 06-03779(I2006-0774-3)
PETTIGREW, SR., DAVID C., PEOPLE v95KA 08-00245(I2007-320)
PIERCE, THERESA, PEOPLE v237KA 08-00686(ILC-15192)
POREDA, HELGA v KROFSSIK, AIMEE222CA 08-01363(2005/306)
RAFI, MIAN v RUTGERS CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY,1601CA 08-00800(68813)
RAMSEY, KAREEM, PEOPLE v1546KA 06-00067(I2003-0385-1)
RAPLEY, KENYATTA L., PEOPLE v7KA 05-01491(I2004-0642)
RAPLEY, KENYATTA L., PEOPLE v8KA 05-01492(I2004-0675)
RATEAU, NATHALIE v DAPA COMMUNICATIONS, INC.,1519CA 08-00574(2005/70626)
RAUX, JR., RONALD J. v CITY OF UTICA,157CA 08-01546(CA2004-1370)
REASIN, MATTHEW K., PEOPLE v100KA 07-00757(S06-DI-055)
RHODES, DAVID v LEMPKE, JOHN185TP 08-00759(40735)
RICHMOND, TIMOTHY C. v ORTON, WILLIAM G.114CA 08-01224(04-1987)
ROBINSON, BRIAN, PEOPLE v252KA 08-01262(S28297)
RODRIGUEZ, ROBERT v FISCHER, BRIAN119TP 08-01730(CA2008-001552)
ROGERS, SPENCER, PEOPLE v1564KA 08-01159(2007-0815)
ROSPIERSKI, LEONARD v HAAR, D.D.S., M.D., JEAN G.1554CA 08-01067(I2003-4830)
ROYCE, FREDERICK K., PEOPLE v167KA 07-02684(I07-26)
RUGGIO, KATHLEEN v PCCB, INC.,206CA 08-01755(07-1365)
SANTIAGO, RENEE S. v SPINUZZA, WENDY A.44CA 08-01291(K1-2004-576)
SANTIAGO, JOSE, PEOPLE v96KA 02-02514(I671/01)
SAUNDERS, JR., JAMES M. v AIELLO, DONNA M.1677CAF 08-00991(F-07934-02/07B)
SCALA, FELICE v SCALA, VENERA1534CA 07-02361(06-3150)
SCERBO, ALBERT, PEOPLE v1629KA 08-00198(I2007-383-1)
SCERBO, ALBERT, PEOPLE v1630KA 08-00199(I2007-383-1)
SCHENA, DEBORAH, PEOPLE v164KA 08-00687(I5054)
SCHULTZ, HENRY V. v LYNESS, STEPHANIE200CAF 08-00535(V-02471-07)
SHAPARD, CHRISTOPHER M., PEOPLE v1573KA 07-01566(I00178-2006)
SHORT, JOY, PEOPLE v120KA 08-00119(I2006-1801)
SIMMONS, JR., LEROY v STATE OF NEW YORK,247CA 07-01936(113313)
SMITH, ANTWON, PEOPLE v127KA 07-01151(4839/04) & (I04-318)
SMITH, TRAVIOUS JUAN, PEOPLE v146KA 05-00426(I35/04)
SOULIER, CHARLES v RADIATOR SPECIALTY COMPANY,1619CA 08-01163(2006-2184)
SPERDUTI, ROSE v NEW YORK STATE EXECUTIVE,42CA 07-02498(2007-4389)
STERN, VIVIAN v THE CHARTER OAK FIRE INSURANCE COMP,16CA 08-01630(2002-5595)
STROMAN, STEVE, PEOPLE v1648KA 99-02082(I97-118A)
SWAN, JR., RAYMOND S. v INGERSOLL, ANDREW J.1686.2CA 08-01105(I 2006-10721)
SWEENEY, KATHLEEN M. v LINDE, JOAN M.65CA 08-00494(I2004-1562)
SWEENEY, KATHLEEN M. v LINDE, JOAN M.66CA 08-00496(I2004-1562)
T., CORY, PEOPLE v1621.1KA 08-00498(SCI 26707)
TABB, CHRISTIAN, PEOPLE v1647KA 06-00771(I01979-2004)
TABONE, SAMUEL L. v LEE, M.D., KEUN Y.1415CA 08-01085(129947)
TANTAO, ENRIQUE v BERBARY, JAMES L.118TP 08-01798(i2007-12403)
TANTILLO, R. MICHAEL, MTR. OF1643KA 08-01441(40713(A))
TARTAN TEXTILE SERVICES, INC., v ST. JOSEPH'S HOSPITAL HEALTH CENTER,88CA 08-00529(01-02761)
TAYLOR, RONALD, PEOPLE v126KA 07-02660(I2006-227)
TELFER, WALTER K. v PICKARD, NICOLE L.86CAF 08-00612(V-00119-06/07B)
TELFER, WALTER, PEOPLE v99KA 07-00627(I2006-1270-1)
THE LINKS AT BLACK CREEK, LLC, v BALLANTYNE DEVELOPMENT, LLC,17CA 08-00820(2007/03035)
THOMPSON, SARAH B., MTR. OF1711CAF 08-00599(F-00198-01/07E)
TORRES, III, GUILLERMO, PEOPLE v151KA 05-02578(I04-968)
TOWN OF CHEEKTOWAGA, MTR. OF184CA 08-01595(I-2008-873)
TRALA, TIMOTHY C. v AFIF, HUSSEIN1686CA 08-01406(2005/11254)
TRENCA, PAULETTE v CULETON, ROBERT1694CA 08-01376(2004-1231)
TRUPO, FRANCIS v PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY,1535CA 08-00833(10661-04)
TYGER, ALICIA, PEOPLE v149KA 08-00485(I07-080-1)
UTICA CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT, v FEHLHABER, CRAIG S.91CA 08-01578(CA2007-1911)
VIRELLA, III, CONCEPCION v ALLSTATE HOME CARE OF BUFFALO, INC.,1696CA 08-01099(I-2006-000520)
VIRELLA, III, CONCEPCION v ALLSTATE HOME CARE OF BUFFALO, INC.,1697CA 08-01100(2006-520)
WALLACE, JOSEPH, PEOPLE v1631KA 08-01305(93-2030)
WARD, GEORGE v CORCORAN, MICHAEL1674KAH 07-02096(2007-0696)
WATSON, KURT W. v WATSON LANDSCAPING, INC.,116CA 08-00992(2001-6852)
WEBSTER, STEPHEN E. v TOTAL IDENTITY CORP.,110CA 08-01066(2005/00211)
WESTFIELD FAMILY PHYSICIANS, PC, v HEALTHNOW NEW YORK, INC.,1359CA 08-01079(K1-2003-459)
WHEELER, MATTHEW, PEOPLE v236KA 08-01597(2006-372)
WHITLOCK, JONATHAN, PEOPLE v143KA 07-02091(I2006-1190)
WILLIAMS, CASSANDRA v CLINTON CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,40CA 08-01596(CA2005-2617)
WILLIAMS, DEQUAN, PEOPLE v97KA 06-03803(I2003-1147-2)
WILSON, ANTWON R., PEOPLE v147KA 08-00161(I2006-592)
WILSON, KIM MATTHEW, PEOPLE v129KA 06-01046(I2005-0402)
WINDSONG LANE FARMS, v TELMARK, LLC,158CA 07-02244(2004-2341)
WINKLER, ELIZABETH L. v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN RI,1584TP 08-01313(2008-5789)
WURTHMANN, DENNIS v KIRKPATRICK, ROBERT A.1653KAH 07-02186(I-2007-3730)
    
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS