AD4 Seal

Supreme Court of the State of New York
APPELLATE DIVISION
Fourth Judicial Department

Decisions - December 30, 2009

 
Allegany
C., ASHLEY L., MTR. OF1549CAF 08-01180(NN-22-24-07, NN-80-82-07
 
Cattaraugus
ERON, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v1472KA 08-01890(I03-191)
KRAFT, SHIRLEY, MTR. OF1558CA 07-02154(2006-32387)
LINN, TAMERA v WILSON, CLIFTON1591CAF 08-01927(V-1203-06/08 D, E & F)
WALSH, JOHN v ASSESSOR OF THE TOWN OF ALLEGANY,1477CA 09-00590(74412/72847)
ZULIANI, ROGER P., PEOPLE v1520KA 08-02221(I07-188)
 
Cayuga
HANNIG, MICHAEL E., PEOPLE v1627KA 08-02187(S2008-093)
HENRY, GENE D., PEOPLE v1605KA 09-00078(S2008-154)
LANGLER, JAMES v COUNTY OF CAYUGA,1601TP 09-01267(08-451)
PREDMORE, JR., RICKY, PEOPLE v1560KA 08-02229(I2008-040A)
ROBINSON, MICHAEL v GRAHAM, HAROLD1474KAH 09-00208(2008-0644)
TOWN OF SENNETT TOWN BOARD, v RYBACH & RIG PROPERTIES, LLC,1673CA 08-01865(2008-1114)
WILKINSON, JESSICA v STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INS.,1653CA 09-00755(2007-01094)
 
Chautauqua
BIGELOW, DANIEL D. v ZIELINSKI, RACHEL L.1555CA 08-02500(K1-2007-286)
BLAIR, BEVERLY A. v KELLY, DONNA S.1662CA 09-01218(K1-2008-746)
C., LASHANTA M. R., MTR. OF1547CAF 08-02475(B-1431-08)
FINCH, JR., FRANCIS G. v RYDER TRUCK RENTAL, INC.,1557CA 09-01224(K1-2007-252)
MORRISON, GREGG W., PEOPLE v1650KA 07-00916(I06-399)
PLP, II LP, v NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRO,1482CA 09-01183(132001)
TESTERMAN, ROBERT C. v ZIELINSKI, RACHEL L.1553CA 08-02423(K1-2007-286)
TESTERMAN, ROBERT C. v ZIELINSKI, RACHEL L.1554CA 08-02498(K1-2006-1334)
TOWN, TODD A. v SIDIYAHYA, NINA C.1497CA 09-00669(K1-2006-568)
TOWN, TODD A. v SIDIYAHYA, NINA C.1498CA 09-00670(K1-2006-568)
 
Erie
ADAMS, GILBERT, PEOPLE v1536KA 08-00655(I2004-2488)
ADNEY, FRANCES v MORTON, III, HERBERT J.1548CAF 08-02189(V2182/V2183/06/08C)
AQUINO, MICHAEL v HIGGINS, MICHAEL1249CA 09-00847(2007-2709)
AURORA MEDICAL GROUP, P.C., v GENEWICK, M.D., TIFFANY1595CA 09-01393(2009-2199)
B.R., JUSTIN, PEOPLE v1490KA 08-01979(S27997)
BERMUDEZ, JASON v BERBARY, JAMES L.1510TP 09-01247(2009-2020)
BORZILLIERI, MICHAEL v JONES, DOUGLAS G.1355CA 08-01317(I2006/5775)
BRODERICK, DAVID S. v TRIVEDI, M.D., JAGDISH M.1550CA 09-01521(116466)
CARUSO, MICHAEL G. v VILLAGE OF KENMORE,1556CA 09-01433(2008/9738)
COLE, AHMIR, PEOPLE v1585KA 07-02429(I2006-0952)
DANIELS, MARK, PEOPLE v1489KA 08-02217(I2007-1327)
DEGEORGE, JOANNE M. v BAUMAN, MATTHEW F.1486CA 09-01351(2007-89)
DUQUIN, ROBERT v CHAMELI, ANDREW1661CA 09-01130(2006-2005)
GINTHER, GEORGE EAGAN v PHOTIADIS, GREGORY P.1500CA 08-02389(2005-6054)
GUSTAFSON, WILLIAM v STANSBERRY, R.P.A., ANDREW J.1398.1CA 09-01543(I2004/566)
GUSTAFSON, WILLIAM v DIPPERT, D.O., PAUL C.1398CA 08-02596(I2004/566)
GUSTAFSON, WILLIAM v DIPPERT, D.O., PAUL C.1397CA 08-02595(I2004/566)
HALLING, CHRISTOPHER v STATE OF NEW YORK,1639CA 08-02035(107751)
HARTLOFF, NORMAN G. v LORIGO, LLC,1310CA 09-01008(I2007-3553)
HARTRICH, DANIEL, PEOPLE v1540KA 09-00840(I2007-0222)
HARTRICH, DANIEL, PEOPLE v1539KA 08-01430(I2007-1469)
HERDZIK, ALAN J. v CHOJNACKI, TOM1104CA 08-02182(2006-2961)
HERDZIK, ALAN J. v LOMMER, SR., JAMES1105CA 08-02183(I2006-2961)
HILL, GREGORY v KAIDEN, GREGORY J.1545KAH 09-00235(2008-6880)
HOME THERAPY EQUIPMENT, INC., v HART, BRENDA LEE1506CA 09-01354(2009-3867)
HUGHES, LAKICIA M. v DAVIS, LIONEL L.1387CAF 08-01244(V-20788-06/07A)
HUNTER, EPHRIAM, PEOPLE v1469KA 08-01886(S28882)
HUNTER, EPHRIAM, PEOPLE v1468KA 08-01887(I2007-0773)
JOHNSON, CLAUDIA S. v JOHNSON, LARRY1440CA 08-02618(SF2006-902415)
JOHNSON, CLAUDIA S. v JOHNSON, LARRY C.1441CA 08-02619(902415/06)
KANE, ROBERTA A. v UTICA FIRST INSURANCE COMPANY,1350CA 09-00306(I2002-7500)
KIRKLAND, WESLEY, PEOPLE v1646KA 08-01038(I2007-0950)
LE, STEPHEN, PEOPLE v1564KA 08-01370(I2007-0935)
LONG, KEITH, MTR. OF1476CA 08-02191(I2005-7708)
M., DEON, MTR. OF1546CAF 08-02154(B-7310-07)
M&T BANK CORPORATION, v GEMSTONE CDO VII, LTD,1552CA 09-01402(2008-7064)
MCCLINTIC, DOUGLAS P. v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,1601.1CA 09-00775(2006-006083)
MONILE, MICHAEL J. v NEW YORK STATE LIQUOR AUTHORITY,1575CA 09-01197(2008-13354)
MULDOWNEY, KELLY M. v ROGOWSKI, JEFFREY J.1698CA 09-01228(I2007-11657)
O'DONNELL, JOHN v FERGUSON, ROBERT1416CA 09-00221(I1999/9634)
PATTON, JONATHON, PEOPLE v1492KA 08-01894(S30016)
PAYNE, BASIL S., PEOPLE v1651KA 08-01366(I2006-2189)
PELC, ROBERT J. v BERG, F. STEVEN1368CA 09-00523(I 2005/3007)
POKORSKI, KENNETH v GANNETT CO., INC.,1619CA 09-00826(08-000995)
POKORSKI, KENNETH v GANNETT CO., INC.,1620CA 09-00956(08-000995)
RADDER, DENNIS v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,1551CA 09-00415(I2005-8536)
READING, BEVERLY J., PEOPLE v1537KA 08-02014(S00632-2008)
ROBINSON, ANDREW v FISCHER, BRIAN1444CA 08-01930(I-2007-12364)
ROSWELL PARK CANCER INSTITUTE CORP, v SODEXO AMERICA, LLC,1501CA 09-01222(TPI-2007/2862)
S., RICHELIS, MTR. OF1228.2CAF 09-00117(B-15013-06)
SAWICKI, MARGARET ANN v SPAICH, TIMOTHY1674CA 09-00843(2005-10457)
SCHIENER, JOHN R. v TOWN OF SARDINIA,1244CA 08-02551(2006-008945)
STABLEY, DAVID L. v CACI-STABLEY, PHYLLIS A.1435CAF 09-00872(F-13659-07/07A)
STORY, THOMAS W., PEOPLE v1542KA 08-02011(I2007-2123)
SYKES, ERIC T., PEOPLE v1541KA 08-02108(I00658-2008)
TAFELSKI, PHILIP v THE BUFFALO CITY CEMETERY, INC.,1654CA 09-01220(I2005-8552)
THE PARK COUNTRY CLUB OF BUFFALO,, INC. v TOWER INSURANCE COMPANY OF, NEW YORK1599CA 09-00808(2007-6450)
VILLAGE OF LANCASTER, v COUNTY OF ERIE,1672CA 09-01360(2008-5304)
 
Genesee
CUNNINGHAM, JONATHAN A., PEOPLE v1648KA 08-02074(IFile No. I08-2008)
GUEVARA, CARLOS, PEOPLE v1544KA 08-00536(I5059)
GUTZMER, CARL A. v SANTINI, MYRIAM L.1691CAF 09-00572(O-00508-08)
KLINE, ROBERTA E., PEOPLE v1581KA 09-00174(S08-24)
SCROGER, LISA A. v SCROGER, JERRY K.1612CAF 09-00313(O-01041-08)
 
Herkimer
DIGEORGIO, MICHAEL, MTR. OF1642CA 09-01127(08-88606)
FIA CARD SERVICES, N.A., MTR. OF1571CA 09-01290(88718/2008)
 
Jefferson
GOSIER, GUY E. v AUBERTINE, SCOTT G.1659CA 08-01932(2008-1823)
SMITH, ANDREA M. v NATALI, SR., JACK B.1593CAF 09-00621(V-01308-06/08 I)
 
Livingston
SZCZESNIAK, STEPHEN v WHITFORD, MARK1457CA 09-00329(497-2005)
 
Monroe
AIR CHARTER TEAM, INC., v CATERING SPECIALISTS LLC,1700CA 09-01553(7775-09)
ARIENO, JOSEPH J. v SWB FUNERAL SERVICES, INC.,1531CA 08-01916(07/07084)
BRAULT, BARBARA A. v SMUGORZEWSKI, DEBORAH K.1692CAF 08-02192(V-12789-04)
CARMICHAEL, ROYAL, PEOPLE v1473KA 06-03284(I550/2005)
CHASE MANHATTAN BANK, v UNIVERSITY OF ROCHESTER,1364CA 09-00836(1956TT00443)
CLARK, JEFFREY W., PEOPLE v1583KA 07-00622(S2001-9077)
COAN, MARY LOUISE v THOMPSON, THOMAS N.1279CAF 08-01933(F-12998-03)
EMERGENCY ENCLOSURES, INC., v NATIONAL FIRE ADJUSTMENT CO., INC.,1333CA 09-00311(08-2041)
EMERGENCY ENCLOSURES, INC., v NATIONAL FIRE ADJUSTMENT CO., INC.,1332CA 09-00309(08-2041)
FILIACI, THOMAS v FILIACI, JERI-LYNN1660CA 08-02613(2006-14326)
GEE, LENO W. v M & T BANK,1679CA 08-01973(2007/11090)
GOFF, GLEN M., PEOPLE v1649KA 09-01289(06/516)
GREEN, DAVID K., PEOPLE v1628KA 05-01294(I359A/2004)
GREEN, STEVEN, PEOPLE v1632KA 07-00129(I0373/06)
GRIFFITH OIL COMPANY, INC., v NATIONAL FIRE INSURANCE, COMPANY OF PITTSBURG, PA996CA 08-02656(01/03787)
GRIFFITH OIL COMPANY, INC., v NATIONAL UNION FIRE INSURANCE CO.,995CA 08-00930(3787/01)
HALLER, THERESA v GACIOCH, M.D., GERALD M.1570CA 08-02612(7653-04)
HALLER, THERESA v GACIOCH, GERALD M.1569CA 08-02127(7653/04)
HAMMONS, JR., THOMAS L., PEOPLE v1652KA 06-00040(I1156/04)
HOUSEHOLD FINANCE REALTY CORPORATIO, v ROBINSON, DAVID W.1505CA 09-01221(2003-13364)
HUTCHERSON, BRYANT v ROCHESTER CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT,1574CA 09-01306(8718/08)
KABIR, YASMIN v COUNTY OF MONROE,1086CA 09-00017(05-11613)
KALEN, CHRISTOPHER M., PEOPLE v1345KA 06-03244(I2005-818)
KEENAN, LAURENCE L. v APPEALS BOARD OF ADMINISTRATIVE ADJ,1487TP 09-01362(2009-4980)
KHAMMONIVANG, VANG, PEOPLE v1512KA 07-00826(I45/06)
KHAMMONIVANG, VANG, PEOPLE v1519KA 07-00828(I791/05)
KLIM, RICHARD, MTR. OF1509TP 09-01111(2007-11664)
LAMPLEY, JR., LESTER L., PEOPLE v1584KA 07-01330(I2005-0905)
LUPIEN, KRISTIN v LUPIEN, JR., GORDON1657CA 09-01356(5861/08)
MARTINEZ, JESUS, PEOPLE v1565KA 05-01871(I310/04)
MUTO, ELEANORE v ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH OF ST. JOHN T,1636CA 09-01131(2007-5810)
NATHAN, DARYL v ROCHESTER HOUSING AUTHORITY,1697CA 09-01400(2006-9163)
ROCHESTER EQUIPMENT & MAINTENANCE, v ROXBURY MOUNTAIN SERVICE, INC.,1655CA 09-01292(2006-5341)
ROWLAND, PAUL v WILMORITE, INC.,1596CA 09-01403(10148/06)
SCHMITZ, DONNA LEE v CALDWELL & COOK, INC.,1038CA 09-00355(2007-2151)
SEARLEY, STEVEN v WEGMANS FOOD MARKETS, INC.,1635CA 09-01133(2004-7026)
SWANK, KELLY, PEOPLE v1666KA 06-03138(I0920/05)
TAYLOR, EUGENE D., PEOPLE v1513KA 06-01615(I2005-0545)
WEAVER, GERALD F. v TOWN OF PENFIELD,1633CA 09-01491(10205/02)
 
Niagara
BRADBERRY, DARREN, PEOPLE v1445KA 07-02326(I2006-109)
BREWER, TOMELL T., PEOPLE v1604KA 08-02674(IT06-2257)
BREWER, TOMELL T., PEOPLE v1603KA 08-02675(S2008-237)
DABROWSKI, JR., WALTER T., PEOPLE v1538KA 08-02080(I2001-385-V)
DEMMIN, TRACY v SMIECH, STANLEY1313CA 09-00966(2005-123038)
MANGUS, RHONDA, MTR. OF1600TP 09-01245(136504)
MATTESON, MARK A. v NEWFANE CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT BOA,1365CA 09-00977(129915)
TOWNSEND, RAYMOND T., PEOPLE v1630KA 07-02570(I2006-104)
 
Oneida
BENDERSON DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, LLC., v ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS,1663CA 09-01457(CA2008-001381)
BILLINS, JEFFREY C., PEOPLE v1645KA 07-01495(II07-063)
BROWN, MICHAEL v ROME UP & RUNNING, INC.,1479CA 09-01116(2007-00018)
DAVIS, TOUSSAINT, PEOPLE v1256KA 07-01886(I06-113)
DISCHIAVI, GARY M. v CALLI, WILLIAM S.1453CA 09-00801(2007-1283)
DISCHIAVI, GARY M. v CALLI, WILLIAM S.1452CA 09-00798(2007-1283)
DISCHIAVI, GARY M. v CALLI, WILLIAM S.1456CA 09-00804(2007-1283)
DISCHIAVI, GARY M. v CALLI, WILLIAM S.1455CA 09-00803(2007-1283)
DISCHIAVI, GARY M. v CALLI, WILLIAM S.1454CA 09-00802(2007-1283)
DRAKE, JR., THOMAS J., PEOPLE v1625KA 08-01207(I07-322)
K., GIOVANNI, MTR. OF1590CAF 08-02593(B-04046-05/08C)
KESSEL BRENT CORPORATION, v BENDERSON PROPERTY DEVELOPMENT, INC,1481CA 09-00357(2005-001511)
MADDOX, COLLIS B., PEOPLE v1470KA 08-01112(II07-078)
MCLIESH, JR., ALBERT P. v TOWN OF WESTERN,1389CA 09-00879(ca 2008 -2348)
PERKINS, NATASHA L. v WATSON, SR., CURTIS1592CAF 08-02590(O-04452-08)
PROCANICK, WILLIAM M., PEOPLE v1562KA 09-01355(07-278)
SAWYER, DONALD, MTR. OF1530CA 09-00439(CA 2008-003161)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v MUENCH, KARL1394CA 08-01301(CA2007-3337)
SUMTER, IBRIEL, PEOPLE v1467KA 08-01123(II07-272)
TAMBURRINO, JAMES T., PEOPLE v1587KA 08-00997(2005-394)
TAMBURRINO, JAMES T., PEOPLE v1586KA 06-02628(2005-394)
 
Onondaga
ATWATER, BRIAN R. v THUNDER BAY HOMES,1644CA 09-00618(2005-0219)
BERSANI, M.D., FRANK A. v TEXACO, INC.,1504CA 09-01270(2007-0115)
CITY OF SYRACUSE INDUSTRIAL, DEVELOPMENT AGENCY v KAUFMANN'S CAROUSEL CENTER, INC.,1461CA 09-00001(05-7106)
DART, JAMES R. v WOOLMAN, MARION G.1527CAF 09-00238(V-07172-06/08b)
DECICCO, DOMINIC v CITY OF SYRACUSE,1597CA 09-00549(2008-2288)
DICKINSON, VIOLA v DAINES, M.D., RICHARD F.1246CA 09-00711(2008-4831)
DYKES, PHILLIP K., PEOPLE v1626KA 07-00033(I2005-0224-2)
H., IRIS L. v ONONDAGA COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF, SOCIAL SERVICES1521CAF 08-02240(V-01566-08)
LAHEY, JAMES R. v LAHEY, KATHRYN E.1287CA 09-01005(M-0904-97)
LT PROPCO, LLC, v CAROUSEL CENTER COMPANY LP,1460CA 09-00002(07-3883)
LT PROPCO, LLC, v CAROUSEL CENTER COMPANY LP,1458CA 08-02265(07-3883)
LT PROPCO, LLC, v CAROUSEL CENTER COMPANY LP,1459CA 08-02266(07-3883)
NICOL, SHAWN, PEOPLE v1493KA 08-00979(I2004-0404-1)
O., NESTOR H., MTR. OF1522CAF 08-02195(B-4858-07)
PALMER, MORGAN T. v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,1057CA 09-00148(2005-1727)
PALMER, MORGAN T. v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,1056CA 09-00035(2005-1727)
R., JR., RAUL, MTR. OF1693CAF 08-00899(B-792-07/07A)
RAWSON, DAWN v STATE OF NEW YORK,1534CA 08-01706(105379)
SALISBURY, JR., STEPHEN D. v CHRISTIAN, JONELLE K.1335CA 08-00939(2004-6424)
SALISBURY, JR., STEPHEN D. v CHRISTIAN, JONELLE K.1336CA 09-00438(2004-6424)
SMITH, ANTHONY v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF PAROLE,1589KAH 08-01858(2008-3243)
SMITH, VIRGIL v SHERWOOD, HAZEL E.1634CA 09-01333(2003-6210)
TOWN OF ONONDAGA, v GRIMM, MICHAEL1694CA 09-01110(2007-0078)
 
Ontario
LAGASSE, PRESTON M., PEOPLE v1495KA 08-01046(S07-DI-136)
LOMBARDI, JOSEPH T., PEOPLE v1588KA 08-00862(I07-07-077)
MARVIN, JR., KENNETH J., PEOPLE v1514KA 08-00326(I06-04-052)
MARVIN, JR., KENNETH J., PEOPLE v1515KA 08-00327(I06-04-050)
MARVIN, JR., KENNETH J., PEOPLE v1516KA 08-00328(I06-04-049)
MASSA CONSTRUCTION, INC., v GEORGE M. BUNK, P.E., P.C.,1507CA 09-01377(97022)
MURPHY, JR., PHILIP L., PEOPLE v1518KA 08-00342(I07-10-121)
RUSS, BRYON K., PEOPLE v1471KA 08-02635(I00-04-102B)
SCHMIDT, CHARLES R., PEOPLE v1647KA 08-02077(I99-01-062)
STATE FARM FIRE & CASUALTY COMPANY, v GRIFFITH ENERGY, INC.,1594CA 09-00867(94450/04)
 
Orleans
HARVEY, SCOTT M. v GAULIN, NICOLE1637CA 09-00973(07-33818)
HARVEY, SCOTT M. v GAULIN, NICOLE1638CA 09-00974(07-33818)
JOCK, DEVIN M., PEOPLE v1665KA 08-02482(I08-39)
NAVAREZ, JOHN, MTR. OF1511TP 09-00013(08-35697)
SANDERSON, JOSEPH F., PEOPLE v1494KA 07-02178(I06-59 and 07-25)
 
Oswego
PHILIPS, JR., CLIFFORD B. v ELLSWORTH, DAVID C.1220CA 09-00696(06-1796)
 
Seneca
MAZZONI, PATRICIA A. v VILLAGE OF SENECA FALLS,1656CA 08-02179(36715)
 
Steuben
GREENE, TERRANCE D. v AVOCA CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,1640CA 09-01132(94967)
 
Wayne
CONNORS, DAVID v GRAY, JON E.1484CA 09-01477(63093)
TAILLIE, EUGENE v ROCHESTER GAS AND ELECTRIC CORP.,1658CA 09-00534(55381)
WEAVER, TONY, PEOPLE v1631KA 09-00392(I08-80)
YOUNG, MATTHEW, PEOPLE v1582KA 08-02126(I07-23)
 
Wyoming
ADELINE, SCOTT v UNGER, DAVID1559TP 09-01009(20794-09)
BRAMER, II, JAMES F. v UTICA MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY,1643CA 09-01336(39613)
DUDAS, DAVID v FISCHER, BRIAN1598CA 09-00557(20,716-08)
KALWASINSKI, MITCHELL v FISCHER, BRIAN1502CA 08-00789(20,419-07)
KALWASINSKI, MITCHELL v FISCHER, BRIAN1503CA 09-00965(20,419-07)
KALWASINSKI, MITCHELL, MTR. OF1508CA 08-00785(20,589-07)
 
Yates
KEARNS, JEFFREY M., PEOPLE v1491KA 08-02002(I06-27)
    
    
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS