AD4 Seal

Supreme Court of the State of New York
APPELLATE DIVISION
Fourth Judicial Department

Decisions - April 30, 2010

1093 GROUP, INC., v CANALE, MARY JANE476CA 09-02411(2008-6263)
A., DEMARIAH, MTR. OF538CAF 09-00688(B-18842-07, B-18853-07)
ALEKSANDROWICZ, PETER v CANTELLA & COMPANY, INC.,516CA 09-02528(05-008289)
ALLICK, IMRAN A., PEOPLE v602KA 07-01768(I2006-195B)
ALLISON, KYLE, PEOPLE v506KA 08-01761(I2007-0935)
AYALA, ANDRES, PEOPLE v508KA 08-01055(I84-1726-2)
BALLS, BRITTANY LOUISA v DOLLIVER, RYAN607CAF 09-01947(V-04892-08)
BARNISH, THOMAS, PEOPLE v439KA 06-01347(I2005-0405-1)
BENSON, SHELIA v LILLIE, TREVOR M.611CA 09-02366(I 2007-1557)
BOBAK, ADAM, MTR. OF1331CA 09-00404(I2008-11187)
BOUSE, JOSEPH, PEOPLE v556KA 09-02064(II05-008)
BOYZUCK, TRACI, PEOPLE v376KA 09-00947(I08-29)
BRADLEY, FELDER, PEOPLE v639KA 06-02980(I0466/05)
BROWN, NADIRAH, PEOPLE v461KA 09-01460(I2007-2646)
BRUNSON, MICKEY v STRONG, LONNELL649CA 09-02572(2136/08)
BURNS, PATRICK E. v KROENING, LEE A.499CA 09-01074(116058)
BURRIS, GENEVA L. v LOVING, ROBERT J.K.626CAF 09-00887(F-15238-08/08A)
BUTLER, TRACI v STAGECOACH GROUP, PLC,519CA 09-01532(1541-2008)
BUTLER, TRACI v STAGECOACH GROUP, PLC,518CA 09-01531(1541-2008)
BUTLER, TRACI v STAGECOACH GROUP, PLC,524CA 09-01533(1541-2008)
C., ERIC v NEW YORK STATE POLICE,389CA 09-01880(I-2008-10654)
CALDERON, JR., JOHN v WALGREEN CO.,386CA 09-01623(07/1779)
CALEB, BRENT C. v SEVENSON ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES,324CA 09-01997(22723)
CHACON-CHAVEZ, HARRY v CITY OF ROCHESTER,652CA 09-02067(06-1175)
CHIPLEY, MORGAN L. v STEPHENSON, M.D., GRANT W.436CA 09-00059(2004-1410)
CITY OF ROME, v RAILROAD PROPERTY DEVELOPMENT CORP.,475CA 09-00897(2004-1051)
CLYBURN, ATO v KADIEN, GREGORY J.480TP 09-02471(2009-11096)
CLYDE, RAYMOND, PEOPLE v404KA 08-00850(I2007-021)
CLYDE, RAYMOND, PEOPLE v405KA 08-00851(I2007-021)
COBB, CHARLES S., PEOPLE v484KA 07-00255(I04-0264A)
COLTON, JUDY v TOWN BOARD OF TOWN OF AMHERST,658CA 09-02348(2008-2482)
CONNOLLY, JONATHAN, PEOPLE v555KA 09-01025(I5191)
COOPER, SHARON v NEW YORK CENTRAL MUTUAL FIRE INSUR.,454CA 09-02108(2008/9343)
COOPER, BRIAN, PEOPLE v444KA 08-01771(I2008-0276)
COUNTY OF ONTARIO, v HELSER, SUSAN M.653CA 09-01879(100140)
COWAN, COURTNEY v STAGECOACH GROUP, PLC,520CA 09-01534(1541-2008)
COWAN, COURTNEY v STAGECOACH GROUP, PLC,521CA 09-01535(1541-2008)
COWAN, COURTNEY v STAGECOACH GROUP, PLC,525CA 09-01536(1539-2008)
DAIL, BERTHA v MERCHANTS MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY,390CA 09-02231(2008007755)
E., ANDREA, MTR. OF605CAF 09-00708(B01171-08)
EDGETT, MICHELLE v NORTH FORK BANK,650CA 09-02526(2002-77997)
EDWARDS, SHEILA ELIZABETH v ERIE COACH LINES COMPANY,529CA 09-01549(1452-2005)
EDWARDS, SHEILA ELIZABETH v ERIE COACH LINES COMPANY,528CA 09-01548(1452-2005)
EDWARDS, SHEILA ELIZABETH v ERIE COACH LINES COMPANY,527CA 09-01547(1452-2005)
EDWARDS, CARMELLA v ST. ELIZABETH MEDICAL CENTER,548CA 09-02605(CA2006-5757)
ERIE COUNTY SHERIFF'S POLICE BENEVO, LENT ASSOCIATION v COUNTY OF ERIE,657CA 09-02152(2008-4274)
FARNETI, ALDO v AT&T,589CA 09-02525(2009-5133)
FARNHAM, MITCHELL v MEDER, BRIAN J.501CA 09-02169(K1-2003-639)
FEDESON, RUTH v HOWARD JOHNSON TIKI RESORT INN,632CA 09-02383(135107)
FIGGINS, ANDREW, PEOPLE v554KA 08-01018(I5043)
FIOCCO, MARLE M. v DOYLE, SHANNON M.281CA 09-01617(130393)
FOSTER, MICHIAL E., PEOPLE v1517KA 08-02523(I434-97)
FOTI, ANTHONY v NOFTSIER, JR., ROBERT ROMEYN575CA 09-02549(CA2007-00422)
FRACCOLA, JR., ALBERT G. v FRACCOLA, PHYLLIS545CA 09-02308(2008-000430)
FRANCIS, JUSTIN W. v FRANCIS, SUZANNE547CA 09-02327(2008-900248)
FULTON, DERRICK R., PEOPLE v579KA 08-01906(II08-078)
GAFFNEY, THOMAS J. v CHIACCHIA & FLEMING LLP,171CA 09-01528(2007-07938)
GAMLEN, CLINTON B., PEOPLE v603KA 09-00508(S2008-208)
GARZONE, EMANUEL, PEOPLE v535KA 07-01050(S05/9000)
GAYLE, JUNIOR, PEOPLE v533KA 09-00181(I5164)
GIACOMETTI, AMY G. v DOYLE, SHANNON M.280CA 09-01618(127487)
GINTHER, GEORGE EAGAN v CRAWFORD, JR., ROBERT A.608CA 09-00915(2005-11539)
GLACIAL AGGREGATES, LLC, v TOWN OF YORKSHIRE,1116CA 07-02611(69015)
GLANTON, ROMARIS, PEOPLE v397KA 09-00581(I07-127)
GLANTON, ROMARIS, PEOPLE v398KA 09-00582(I08-11)
GLENN, LEE A., PEOPLE v485KA 08-01015(I2005-1558)
GLOVER, TINA, BERLING, KIMBERLY v537CAF 08-02592(V-16-07/07B,)
GODWIN, MEAGAN v STAGECOACH GROUP, PLC,526CA 09-01539(53-2007)
GODWIN, MEAGAN v STAGECOACH GROUP, PLC,523CA 09-01538(53-2007)
GODWIN, MEAGAN v STAGECOACH GROUP, PLC,522CA 09-01537(53-2007)
GOLLEL, MAUREEN ANN v GOLLEL, RICHARD MICHAEL680CA 09-02321(2009-09031)
GOLLEL, MAUREEN ANN v GOLLEL, RICHARD MICHAEL681CA 09-02322(2009-09031)
GOODRUM, BRUCE, PEOPLE v659KA 09-00509(I2008-0718)
GOOSSEN, KAREN v GOOSSEN, JOHN541CAF 09-01176(O-1266-08)
GOOSSEN, JOHN R. v GOOSSEN, KAREN536CAF 09-00998(V-11824/11829-07)
GREEN, CHAZARAY A., PEOPLE v560KA 07-01136(I06/306)
GREGORY, DYANI A., PEOPLE v357KA 07-00824(I2006-0504)
GRIFFIN, DAVON M., PEOPLE v251KA 03-02629(I2003-0103-1)
GROSS, SUZANN v HERTZ LOCAL EDITION CORP.,340CA 09-01622(I2005-10493)
GUINYARD, LAWRENCE, PEOPLE v423.1KA 10-00730(I2007-1004)
GUINYARD, LAWRENCE, PEOPLE v423KA 08-02394(I2007-1004)
H., AARON, MTR. OF563CAF 09-00129(NA-02428-07, NA-02429-07
H., JANE, MTR. OF625CAF 09-00889(NN-8114-08)
HANCOCK, ALVIN, PEOPLE v481KA 08-00120(I06-471)
HANCOCK, ALVIN, PEOPLE v486KA 07-01649(I07/207)
HARRIS, ANTWOIN, PEOPLE v227KA 08-02547(I2008-0714A)
HARRIS, ANTWOIN, PEOPLE v226KA 08-02549(I2008-0877I)
HARRIS, ANTWOIN, PEOPLE v228KA 08-02548(I2008-0714I)
HARRIS, JR., VARNER, PEOPLE v624KA 08-02379(I2006-2937)
HAWKINS, BRYAN R. v FISCHER, BRIAN306TP 09-02172(43183)
HEARD, ALEX J., PEOPLE v641KA 07-02556(I2006-0557)
HSBC BANK USA, NA, MTR. OF323CA 09-02136(2002-0295)
HUCKS, MARQUIS C., PEOPLE v578KA 08-02401(1993/2394) & (I93-W0165)
HUNT, CARL B., LEWIS, RYDELLE v643KAH 08-02094(1193-2008)
HUNTER, IAN, PEOPLE v394KA 07-02497(I2007-046A)
INGERSOLL, HEATHER A. v PLATT, LONNIE S.470CAF 09-00248(V-04310/11-06/07C)
J., DONATAE, MTR. OF469CAF 09-01184(NN-04916-08)
J.-M., ROMANYA, MTR. OF627CAF 09-00542(NN-8145-07)
JOHNSON, BRYANT, PEOPLE v665KA 07-01061(I06/575)
JONES, DAVON, PEOPLE v600KA 09-00918(I2008-2158)
K., KYLE, MTR. OF540CAF 09-00875(B-4327,8-06)
KALB, SHANE P., PEOPLE v598KA 08-02643(S07-011)
KALWASINSKI, MITCHELL v FISCHER, BRIAN517CA 09-01444(20.643-08)
KAMGUIA, M.D., PIERRE v MCWAYNE, FREDERICK573CA 09-02466(2005-2388)
KHEEL, THOMAS H. v KHEEL, JULIAN MARK411CA 09-02252(12689/08)
KIM, CHANG HAN v CLYMER CENTRAL SCHOOL,433CA 09-01999(200/775)
KLOCK, EDWARD v KLOCK, MAUREEN668CAF 09-00426(F-0012-08/08A)
KNAUBER, DEBRA, PEOPLE v601KA 07-02650(I4949)
KNUTH, JENNIFER R. v WESTFALL, TROY J.669CAF 09-00622(V-01187-03/09H)
KOZIOL, LEON R. v WALSH-HOOD, MARTHA648OP 09-02550
KRAFT, LISA A. v ROUSSEAU, CANDICE671CAF 09-01164(V-04086-08/08A)
LEMPKE, JOHN, ROBINSON, EDDIE M. v463TP 09-02606(43248)
LEVEILLE, II, FRANK, PEOPLE v482KA 09-01252(S2008-421)
LEVEILLE, II, FRANK, PEOPLE v487KA 09-01251(S2008-206)
LEWIS, WINFORD H. v LEWIS, MARY ELIZABETH491CA 09-01013(06/7444)
LEWIS, WINFORD H. v LEWIS, MARY ELIZABETH492CA 09-01015(06-7444)
LEWIS, JOAN M. v LUSTAN, FRANK148CA 09-01645(i2007/1795)
LEWIS, TRAVIS, PEOPLE v577KA 08-00859(I2007-0828A)
LIFSON, ALEXANDER v CITY OF SYRACUSE,364CA 08-02666(01-0877)
LIFSON, ALEXANDER v CITY OF SYRACUSE,365CA 09-01739(01-0877)
LIVERPOOL PUBLIC LIBRARY, MTR. OF596CA 09-02604(2009-3048)
MANUFACTURERS AND TRADERS TRUST COM, MTR. OF498CA 09-01787(00-02357)
MATTHEWS, GUADALUPE v MATTHEWS, EDWARD644CAF 06-01035
MAYBACK, JR., JONATHAN, PEOPLE v557KA 09-00300(S29986)
MCLAUGHLIN, SAMUEL A., PEOPLE v562KA 09-01373(S2009-038)
MISLIN, BARBARA A. v CITY OF TONAWANDA SCHOOL DISTRICT,633CA 08-02568(I2007-4040)
MM 1, LLC, v LAVANCHER, SHERRY254CA 09-02043(2008-6211)
MORGAN, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v137KA 06-03804(I023/06)
MUNDRICK, DEBORAH PATRICIA v MUNDRICK, RICHARD THOMAS237CA 09-00613(99/6856)
MURPHY, BRADLEY W. v PEACE, REA M.628CAF 09-02467(V-1591-06/09D,)
NASH, REESEIE, PEOPLE v509KA 08-02186(I2006-1732)
NEW HAMPSHIRE INSURANCE COMPANY, MTR. OF1330CA 09-00333(I2008-7414)
NEW YORK MUNICIPAL INSURANCE RECIP, v W.P. MAHONEY ENTERPRISES, INC.,569CA 09-01657(60149/07)
NEWBERN, JAMAICA, PEOPLE v530KA 09-00937(I2008-1322)
NEWBERN, JAMAICA, PEOPLE v531KA 09-00938(I2008-1681)
NICHOLS, STEPHEN v XEROX CORPORATION,277CA 09-01916(03-8370)
NICHOLS, TERESA v VANAMERONGEN, DEBORAH262TP 09-02063(58711)
ONEIDA INDIAN NATION, v HUNT CONSTRUCTION GROUP, INC.,496CA 09-01346(2008-5453)
PARKER, JAMES A., PEOPLE v314KA 08-00305(I2006-0502)
PARKWAY PEDIATRIC AND ADOLESCENT ME, v VITULLO, M.D., BENEDETTO284CA 09-02291(2006-1585)
POBLACKI, ARTHUR R., PEOPLE v664KA 09-02358(00988-2008)
POULSEN, BRIAN v LIGHTHOUSE ASSEMBLY AT HIGH FALLS,543CA 09-02393(2008-011156)
PRINGLE, BRYAN D., PEOPLE v640KA 09-00815(S06C-167)
PROGRESSIVE HALCYON INSURANCE, COMPANY v GIACOMETTI, AMY G.279CA 09-01619(128231)
PROKOPIENKO, MICHAEL A., PEOPLE v372KA 09-00950(IIDV2007-5013)
PROKOPIENKO, MICHAEL A., PEOPLE v373KA 09-00958(IIDV2007-5042-V)
QUINN, NAPOLEON v MORRISSEY, J.P.642KAH 09-00211(08-WRIT-11)
R., EDUARDO, MTR. OF165CAF 09-01563(D-17329-08)
R., EDUARDO, MTR. OF490CAF 09-02454(D-17329-08)
R., JAVIER, MTR. OF449CAF 09-02234(D-04994-08)
RAMOS, GABRIEL L. v RAMOS, DARCY A.585CAF 09-00425(V-00404-01/08Q)
RICHARDSON, RAJSHEEM L., PEOPLE v510KA 08-01188(I230-07)
RIOS, ELVIN, PEOPLE v197KA 08-02141(I2008-0357)
RIOS, ELVIN, PEOPLE v198KA 09-01198(I2008-001094)
RIVENBURG, JANICE v HIGHLAND HOSPITAL OF ROCHESTER, INC,495CA 09-01848(03-11694)
RIVENBURG, JANICE v HIGHLAND HOSPITAL OF ROCH.,494CA 09-00913(11694-03)
ROBLES, LUIS R., PEOPLE v354KA 06-00792(I2005-0383)
ROUSSEAU, CANDICE v KRAFT, LISA A.670CAF 09-01163(V-04086-08/09B,)
S., DONELL, MTR. OF586CAF 09-00079(NN-8659-8660-07)
SAUNDERS, WILLIAM P. v ROCHESTER CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT,636CA 09-01994(06/7020)
SHUBBUCK, JUSTIN M. v CONNERS, SEAN W.450CA 09-01104
SHUGATS, JOSEPH A. v ERIE COUNTY MEDICAL CENTER CORPORAT,513CA 09-02331(2009-3505)
SICOLI, BENJAMIN M., PEOPLE v619KA 09-01126(I2007-437)
SMITH, MELVIN v WILLIAMS, MELVIN584KAH 09-01462(42372)
SORRENTO LACTALIS, INC., v POLANSKI, JR., NORMAN L.609CA 09-01345(I2009-6546)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v FARNSWORTH, DANIEL387CA 09-01424(MH K1/2008-943)
STEPHENS, BRUCE C., PEOPLE v534KA 05-02423(I2004-0418-1)
STEWART, DALE M., PEOPLE v466KA 09-01284(I2008-129)
STODDARD, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v576KA 09-00933(S08-098)
STODOLKA, CHARLES K. v STARPOINT CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,647TP 09-02312(137420)
STOUGHTENGER, LISA v CARRIONS, GLADYS140TP 09-01423(2008-3051)
SYRELL, BRIAN J., PEOPLE v580KA 09-00511(S2008-106)
T., ROYSTAR, MTR. OF488CAF 09-00834(B-064-08)
TARANTINO, STEPHEN, PEOPLE v505KA 09-02574(5839)
THIELE, KENNETH, PEOPLE v504KA 09-00156(I99-183SCI)
THOMAS, STEVEN D., PEOPLE v139KA 08-02246(S08-105)
TOOLEY, MARK, PEOPLE v558KA 09-00315(S07-040)
TURNER, STEPHEN v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,1248CA 09-00073(I2004-2110)
TURNER, STEPHEN v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,553CA 09-01614(I2004-2110)
TURNER, STEPHEN v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,551CA 09-01612(I2004-2110)
TURNER, STEPHEN v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,550CA 09-00759(2004-2110)
TURNER, STEPHEN v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,552CA 09-01613(I2004-2110)
TYSZKA, SHAWN v MAKE AND TAKE HOLDING, LLC,612CA 09-01876(5064/08)
VANGORDER, FRED, PEOPLE v597KA 08-01065(98-3568) & (I98-0207)
WAHRENDORF, DAVID v CITY OF OSWEGO,574CA 09-02032(2008-1111)
WHITFIELD, AHKEEM, PEOPLE v582KA 08-01035(I07-07-088)
WILDER, SHANNON v WILDER, THOMAS489CAF 09-00478(V-1209, 1210-05)
WILSON, CHRIS T., PEOPLE v465KA 07-01270(I2006-0418)
WOOD, LAURIE v LYNCHESKY, ROBERT606CAF 09-01275(V-00060-01/07C)
WOODS, RONNIE, PEOPLE v483KA 09-00206(I2006-1635)
WORKMAN, JAMES, PEOPLE v663KA 08-02016(I95-0417-001)
ZAFUTO, BRENT, PEOPLE v620KA 09-00736(I2008-0488)
ZANGHI, DANIEL, PEOPLE v623KA 09-00406(S00-DI-038)
    
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS