AD4 Seal

Supreme Court of the State of New York
APPELLATE DIVISION
Fourth Judicial Department

Decisions - December 30,2010

 
ALLEGANY
DOMBROWSKI, THOMAS E. v BULSON, RAYMOND W.1130CA 10-00097(36448)
 
Cattaraugus
CAPPIELLO, DOMINIC v CAPPIELLO, LAURIE1521CAF 10-00003(V-1290-04/09 H,I,J,K,L)
WARRIOR, NORMA v BEATMAN, SR., ROBERT E.1522CAF 10-00198(V-03208-02/09U)
WILSON, CLIFTON J. v LINN, TAMERA K.1518CAF 10-00255(V-01203-06/09J)
 
Cayuga
CULLEN, JOHN, PEOPLE v1428KA 10-00180(I2006-5030)
GILFUS, JOSEPH B. v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,1422CA 10-01606(2004-1057)
SCHOONMAKER, MARY ELIZABETH, PEOPLE v1449KA 10-01605(10-0156)
SMALL, JR., III, JOHN P., PEOPLE v1588KA 10-00466(I2008-192)
 
Chautauqua
MOON, MICHAEL A. v VILLAGE OF BROCTON ZBA,1579CA 10-01376(K1-2009-1378)
 
Erie
ACTIVE WORKFORCE, INC., v CRYAN, MICHAEL1479CA 10-01290(I2006-3659)
AFRIKA, NACHE, PEOPLE v1429KA 08-01266(I98-2639-001)
ANDERSON, KEVIN, PEOPLE v1468KA 09-01468(I2007-0310)
B., JULIANI, MTR. OF1474CAF 10-00254(NN-13516-09)
BELSTADT, ROBERT G. v BELSTADT, LISA A.1302CA 10-01238(SF2003-902143)
BISSELL, PETER v TOWN OF AMHERST,1371CA 10-00580(2009-10257)
BOIVIN, WAYNE v MARRANO/MARC EQUITY CORP.,1480CA 10-01568(2007-6331)
BONNER, JR., DARIN, PEOPLE v1567KA 09-02048(I2008-2850)
BOYLAND, TOBIAS, PEOPLE v1412KA 10-00774(09/1672)
BRYNDLE, DANIEL v SAFETY KLEEN SYSTEMS, INC.,1423CA 10-00611(I2003-9689)
BUFFALO PROFESSIONAL FIREFIGHTERS, MTR. OF1464CA 10-01450(2009-5156)
CASCIO, THOMAS, PEOPLE v1590KA 10-00330(I2009-0182S)
DAHAR, MICHAEL v HOLLAND LADDER & MANUFACTURING CO.,1307CA 10-00546(I2007-4427)
DAHAR, MICHAEL v HOLLAND LADDER & MANUFACTURING CO.,1308CA 10-00839(I2007-4427)
DUBUQUE, STEVEN v BREMILLER, SHAWNA M.1472CAF 09-02262(V-02982-09)
DUPLEASIS, HILLERY M., PEOPLE v1547KA 09-00200(I2005-2508)
ERON, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v1543KA 09-00548(I2008-0005)
FERRARO, JERROLD v TOWN BOARD OF TOWN OF AMHERST,1439CA 09-02565(2008-7696)
FLOOD, DIANE v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,1419CA 10-00444(2008-1318)
GAMBLE, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v1466KA 09-01956(I2009-0047)
GARLAND, ARLENE S. v RLI INSURANCE COMPANY,1077CA 10-00534(2007-989)
GEORGE, CHARLES v HEALTHNOW NEW YORK, INC.,1477CA 10-01487(I-2004-4661)
GRIECO, CAROL H. v KALEIDA HEALTH,1508CA 10-01071(10724-2007)
GRIECO, CAROL H. v KALEIDA HEALTH,1507CA 10-01188(I2007-10724)
HIGHSMITH, ROY, PEOPLE v1470KA 09-00832(I93-1483-001)
ISKALO ELECTRIC TOWER LLC, v STANTEC CONSULTING SERVICES, INC.,1164CA 10-00777(2006/4223)
JENKINS, TERRY, PEOPLE v1517KA 09-01367(I2008-1877)
JONES, NAKIESHA, PEOPLE v1417KA 09-02370(I03008-2008)
KEMPA, ANTHONY P. v TOWN OF BOSTON,1478CA 10-01295(2007-1305)
LEE, TYMONN, PEOPLE v1378KA 09-00936(I2008-2345)
MALBURG, GREGG A. v KELLER, JOSEPH G.1424CA 10-00671(I2007-003097)
MARTINEZ, DIANE v DUNKEL, CHARLES D.1557CA 10-00370(2009-08937)
MCCABE, AMY v ST. PAUL FIRE & MARINE INSURANCE CO,1235CA 10-00091(I-2008-6553)
MCCABE, AMY v ST. PAUL FIRE & MARINE INSURANCE CO,1234CA 10-00090(2008/6553)
MCDONALD, MICHAEL v TAYLOR, JUSTIN1616CA 10-01610(I-2009-7022)
MOTT, JR., THOMAS G. v STRONGBUILT, INC.,1503CA 10-01609(2006-10194)
NICHOLS, DEBORAH v BDS LANDSCAPE DESIGN,1438CA 10-01377(I2009-11422)
P., YASIEL, MTR. OF1473CAF 09-02270(B-01425-08)
PERRY, NORMAN M. v EDWARDS, JAMES1304CA 10-00879(2007-6469)
POMMERENCK, BRIGID v NASON, SR., GERALD R.1445CA 10-01118(2008-3381)
PRALLE, ARND v PETRIE, CHRISTOPHER S.1578CA 10-00672(I2009-011222)
ROGERS, NICHOLAS W. v ANDERSON, KRISTI L.1575CAF 09-01358(V-18074-08)
ROLLO, GENEVIEVE v SERVICO NEW YORK, INC.,1577CA 10-00781(I2007/4978)
SCHERR, DAVID v CITY OF LACKAWANA,1559CA 10-00910(I-2007-000782)
SCHLEY, JERALYN v STEFFANS, RYEN1482CA 10-00938(2007-4913)
SCOTT, LAMAR, PEOPLE v1562KA 10-00335(I2008-0645)
SMITH, MARY BETH v SCHULTZ, II, PAUL F.1602CA 10-01427(2007-5604)
SMITH, JONATHAN, PEOPLE v1446KA 09-01192(S31281)
SPRINGS, JR., ARTHUR J. v CITY OF BUFFALO,1393CA 09-02534(2006/8186)
STANLEY, DIANE R. v MATTAR, ESQ., LAWRENCE J.1263CA 10-00047(2003/1004) & (2003/1564)
STANLEY, DIANE R. v MATTAR, ESQ., LAWRENCE J.1260CA 10-00043(2003/1004) & (2003/1564)
STANLEY, DIANE R. v MATTAR, ESQ., LAWRENCE J.1261CA 10-00045(2003/1004) & (2003/1564)
STANLEY, DIANE R. v MATTAR, ESQ., LAWRENCE J.1262CA 10-00046(2003/1004) & (2003/1564)
STANLEY, DIANE R. v MATTAR, ESQ., LAWRENCE J.1259CA 09-01756(2003/1004) & (2003/1564)
STEELE, DALE R. v LAFFERTY, TIMOTHY1582CA 10-00477(I08-03051)
STROUD, LAVERN, PEOPLE v1564KA 09-01051(S28533)
SWAN, JR., RAYMOND S. v INGERSOLL, ANDREW J.1068CA 10-00041(2006/010721)
SWAN, JR., RAYMOND S. v INGERSOLL, ANDREW J.1066CA 09-02227(2006/010721)
SWAN, JR., RAYMOND S. v INGERSOLL, ANDREW J.1067CA 10-00040(2006/010721)
SWEENEY, MICHAEL J., PEOPLE v1565KA 09-01884(S31831)
TADUSZ, LAURA, MTR. OF1574CAF 09-02261(V-19620-07)
THOMAS, JURI P., PEOPLE v1589KA 09-00766(I2007-01659)
THREET, MARK S. v THREET, REGINA M.1471CAF 09-02459(O-565-09, O-565-09/09A&B
THREET, REGINA M. v THREET, MARK S.1476CAF 09-02371(V-16436-09/09A)
THURMAN, MAURICE L., PEOPLE v1415KA 09-00871(I2008-0719)
TODIE, EUGENE, PEOPLE v1561KA 09-01193(S31230)
VANYO, RONALD v VANYO, ANN1481CA 09-02377(SF2007-900958)
WEBB, DELORES M. v AARON, MAURICE1498CAF 10-01424(V-18477-08/09)
ZILLIOX, MARK P. v WESTERN NEW YORK SNOWMOBILE CLUB OF,1552CA 10-01322(I2007-5075)
 
Genesee
DAWSON, DANIEL N., PEOPLE v1222KA 08-01551(I5112)
SHEPHERD, JR., DONALD, PEOPLE v1560KA 09-02051(S09-86)
SHUMWAY, DAVID v KELLEY, JUSTIN1441CA 10-01396(51805)
 
Jefferson
BOURCY, WESLEY A. v BOURCY, MARY LOU1551CA 09-02470(2005-2534)
C., ADREONA, MTR. OF1519CAF 09-01955(A-3631-08)
COOPER, ATOO V., PEOPLE v1434KA 09-01002(SI08-408-08)
F., KHALIL O., MTR. OF1549CAF 09-01565(NN-2233-08)
 
Lewis
STATE OF NEW YORK, v PIERCE, MICHAEL1550CA 09-00466(CA2008-000348)
 
Livingston
ALVERSON, MELISSA J., PEOPLE v1563KA 08-02673(I2007-235)
NIEDERMAIER, JASON v TOWN OF CONESUS,1603CA 09-02199(787-2007)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v SHAW, DUANE1461CA 09-01443(1296-2008)
WILLIS, RANDY, PEOPLE v1469KA 08-02362(I2008-077)
 
Monroe
ALVARADO, ENRICO, PEOPLE v1450KA 09-00745(2004/04157) & (I2004-3339)
AQUAVELLA, M.D., P.C., JAMES V. v VIOLA, M.D., RALPH S.1158CA 10-01201(2002/06929)
ARK PATENT INTERNATIONAL, L.L.C., v TARKSOL INTERNATIONAL, L.L.C.,1459CA 10-01569(2007/11921)
AROESTY, ROBERT v FARASH CORPORATION,1506CA 10-01552(I2009-007652)
BARNES, DEBORAH J. v EVANS, JIMMIE L.1454CAF 09-01672(V-06765-04,)
BENESH, MARK L. v COURTNEY, KAREN A.1465CA 10-01464(04-10479)
BURGIO, JAMES v INCE, BRANDON1462CA 09-02198(06-11892)
BURNS, DEBORAH v CARBALLADA, CARLOS1558TP 10-01593(I
DAVIS-WRIGHT, MARK, PEOPLE v1425KA 08-00028(I339/07)
DEMPSEY, AARON J., PEOPLE v1546KA 07-02343(I2007-0118A)
DUFFY, MICHAEL J., STONE, GILBERT H. v1460CA 10-01341(2001DT01229/a)
EATON, FAYE M. v HUNGERFORD, SYLVIA1300CA 10-00421(07/04487)
EATON, FAYE M. v WAYNE TEACHERS ASSOCIATION,1301CA 10-00422(07/04487)
GIFFORD, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v1413KA 07-01560(I2006-0799A)
H., JERMAINE, MTR. OF1451CAF 10-01565(NN-7779-08)
HARNISCHFEGER, OTTO v MOORE, DAVID1442CA 10-01075(07-07664)
HARRIS, HOWARD, PEOPLE v1548KA 04-02941(I2003-0582)
HELLMAN, GLENN M. v HELLMAN, BRUCE1595CA 10-00983(2005-9695)
HILLARD, ANTONIO, PEOPLE v1488KA 06-03491(I2006-0515)
HOLMES, JR., WILLIE, PEOPLE v1431KA 08-00029(I2006-0916)
HORTON, DARIUS L., PEOPLE v1250KA 06-02317(I2005-0663)
KNAPP, KIRSSY, PEOPLE v1587KA 09-01704(I2007-0398)
KRAMER, LISA v BERARDICURTI, KEN1570CAF 10-01342(V-04353-02/07F)
KRIEGER, DORIS v MCDONALD'S RESTAURANT OF NEW YORK,,1628CA 10-00570(I2007/7063)
LAWRENCE, ESQ., C. BRUCE v GUARDSMARK, LLC,1580CA 10-01340(2009/10913)
LOWE, PATRICK D., PEOPLE v1427KA 05-00922(I2004-0059C)
LYONS, LISA v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN,1627TP 10-01595(I
MALDONADO, ROBERTO, PEOPLE v1585KA 09-00491(I1993-0581)
MARTIN, THERESA E. v 21 GOODWAY DRIVE, INC.,1621CA 10-01331(2007-3634)
MONROE COUNTY SHERIFF, MTR. OF1576CA 10-01338(2009/7252)
NELSON, MALIKA F. v NOH, THOMAS1421CA 10-01310(06/5903)
NELSON, FLORINE v STANDER, THOMAS A.1391OP 10-01251
NILSEN, PATRICK R., PEOPLE v1493KA 07-00917(I06-346)
PALERMO, THOMAS v TACCONE, ANTHONY1258CA 10-00640(2008-5342)
PICHARDO, CARLOS, PEOPLE v1408KA 07-01506(94/03)
POVOSKI, JR., FRANK J., PEOPLE v1410KA 07-00962(I2005-0962A)
POWELL, JOYCE, PEOPLE v1568KA 07-01269(I0899/2006)
RAJAB, RAMADHAN, PEOPLE v1448KA 08-01800(I2007-0073)
RESTO, ROSA, PEOPLE v1432KA 08-00378(I2006-0792A)
RUCKER, MICHAEL v MCDONALD'S RESTAURANT OF NEW YORK,,1629CA 10-00571(I2007/7064)
STUART, GARY, PEOPLE v1426KA 07-02653(S2006/3931)
W., IMANI D., MTR. OF1452CAF 09-01798(B-07514-07)
WILLIAMS, MARCELLE E., PEOPLE v1411KA 08-02409(I2005-0879)
WILLIAMS, MARCELLE E., PEOPLE v1406KA 07-00903(I2006-0367)
 
Niagara
CARR, JR., JARVIS v COUNTY OF NIAGARA,1619CA 10-01426(130492)
COUNTY OF NIAGARA, v DAINES, RICHARD F.1440CA 10-00847(137680)
DEMJANENKO, VICTOR v DEMJANENKO, VIRGINIA L.1485CA 10-01624(129630)
FRAZIER, WILLIAM F. v FRAZIER, KIMBERLY A.1475CAF 09-02182(V-00994-09/09A)
HANNAH B. ACRES, LLC, v HOWE, MARTHA A.1598CA 10-01184(124507)
JORDAN, TREMELL R., PEOPLE v1447KA 10-00471(I2009-171)
P., MYA V., MTR. OF1571CAF 09-01905(AS-00533-07/08A)
ROGERS, NICHOLAS J. v NIAGARA FALLS BRIDGE COMMISSION,1353CA 10-00406(134034)
SALVAGNI, SANDRA, PEOPLE v1405KA 10-00394(I2008-513)
SHAW, JOHN W., PEOPLE v1467KA 09-02283(I2008-504-1)
SMITH, SANDRA J. v SMITH, CHARLES D.1390CA 10-00615(125630)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v MOTZER, MICHAEL1436CA 09-02318(MH7283)
SWEET, JACK Z., PEOPLE v1537KA 09-00188(2001-490)
T., DEVONTE M., MTR. OF1609CAF 09-02006(B-00847-08)
T., SHENI A., MTR. OF1610CAF 09-02007(B-00848-08)
T., SHIAH A.-R., MTR. OF1611CAF 09-02008(B-00849-08)
T., SYANNE L., MTR. OF1612CAF 09-02009(B-00850-08)
T., TOYIN S., MTR. OF1613CAF 09-02010(B-00851-08)
 
Oneida
ANDERSON, MICHAEL v LADUE, JOSEPH1524CA 10-01339(2009-000438)
CARDIFF, DONALD v CARRIER, ROBERT M.1283CA 10-01234(03742)
CURTIN, PAULA J. v J.B. HUNT TRANSPORT, INC.,1182CA 09-02201(1701/04)
CURTIN, PAULA J. v J.B. HUNT TRANSPORT, INC.,1183CA 10-00540(2004-001701)
HERNANDEZ, DANNY, PEOPLE v1433KA 08-00336(I2007-199)
KELLY, SHAWN A., PEOPLE v1383KA 08-02676(II07-077)
PRATT, ANDREW v HOGAN, MICHAEL1420CA 10-00669(CA2008-2289)
S., SEAN, MTR. OF1495CAF 09-02434(B-05297-08)
 
Onondaga
BENSHOFF, ALEXANDRA v RAKOCZY, ADAM R.1463CA 10-01412(2007-3837)
BRISSON, ALLEN, PEOPLE v1540KA 08-02414(I2007-1323-1)
DELEE, MAURICE, PEOPLE v1416KA 07-01179(I2006-330-1)
FARRELL, TIMOTHY P. v STATE OF NEW YORK,1437CA 09-01927(106918)
GARDNER, BRANDON WILLIAM v STATE OF NEW YORK,1345CA 10-00892(109520)
GROSS, GORDON, PEOPLE v1409KA 10-01349(2008-1017-1)
LEIER, KENNETH, PEOPLE v1536KA 09-01751(I80-0594-1)
LYNCH, DONNA PRINCE v WATERS, MIKE1443CA 10-00945(2003-6853)
LYNCH, DONNA PRINCE v WATERS, MIKE1444CA 10-00947(2003-6853)
MARTINSEN, ALIX v CAMPERLINO, W. JAMES1556CA 10-01065(2008-8391)
MCKENZIE BANKING COMPANY, v BILLINSON, CRAIG J.1457CA 10-01417(2008-2787)
ONONDAGA COMMUNITY COLLEGE, MTR. OF1623CA 10-01440(2009-7865)
RICKERT, KRISTEN v COUNTY OF ONONDAGA,1614CA 10-01539(2008-2219)
SHANNE, VALERIE v CENTRAL NEW YORK REGIONAL TRANSPORT,1615CA 10-00897(2009-7034)
SMITH, ELAINE v CROUSE HEALTH HOSPITAL, INC.,1597CA 10-01611(2005-4791)
T., ALFONZO, MTR. OF1455CAF 10-00105(NN-4295-09)
THE PENN TRAFFIC COMPANY, v NATIONAL UNION FIRE INSURANCE CO.,1458CA 10-01530(2008-8869)
W., CHARITY, MTR. OF1453CAF 09-01953(B-8825-08)
WATKINS, JUDSON, PEOPLE v1407KA 07-00077(I01-0727-1)
ZELIE, KEVIN M. v TOWN OF VAN BUREN,1581CA 10-01302(08-4589)
 
Ontario
FINGER LAKES RACING ASSOCIATION, IN, v TOWN OF FARMINGTON,1601CA 10-01625(09-103279)
GILLETTE, SUMMER v GEDNEY, JEREMY1496CAF 09-02264(V-01160/61-02U&V)
HANSEN, TRAVIS E., PEOPLE v1538KA 09-00287(I08-07-079)
JONES, ROBERT E. v LAIRD, THERESA1520CAF 09-01728(DV-2008-003)
JONES, KUMAR S., PEOPLE v1542KA 09-01050(I08-10-131)
OSBORN, TRISHIA v GEDNEY, JEREMY1497CAF 09-02265(V-1242-08)
ROSSO, DANIEL H. v GEROUW-ROSSO, ANDREA M.1456CAF 09-01668(V-1808-06/08A)
 
Orleans
BRONSON, TRUDI L. v HANSEL, ALLEN J.1159CA 10-00565(08-35425)
BROWN, DWAYNE, PEOPLE v1591KA 09-01500(09-36143)
POOLE, COLLEN T., PEOPLE v1435KA 09-02415(I09-25)
 
Oswego
JACQUES, JR., DELBERT J., PEOPLE v1593KA 09-02218(I08C-213)
LANDO, JR., TIMOTHY E. v LANDO, JESSICA J.1572CAF 09-02391(V-1459 & 1460-08)
RYAN, THOMAS C. v PORT OF OSWEGO AUTHORITY, ALSO KNOW,1554CA 10-01287(2006-0319)
WALLIS, MARY W. v SANDY CREEK CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,1596TP 10-01362(2009-1710)
 
Seneca
MARTIN, NATHANIEL, PEOPLE v1569KA 09-02313(I09-016)
SHARPE, TIMOTHY v FISCHER, BRIAN1622TP 10-01577(44089)
SHEPHERD, EON v FISCHER, BRIAN1489TP 10-01576(44016)
TUMMINIA, ROBERT W. v LEMKE, JOHN B.1490TP 10-01553(43858)
 
Steuben
ARKPORT STAFF UNITED, v ARKPORT CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,1501CA 10-01525(103719)
MACKEY, JR., JOE, PEOPLE v1430KA 09-01964(I2007-323)
MAKIN, LEON v VANTREESE, CAROL1389CA 10-01233(98040)
MCPHERSON, DARCY, PEOPLE v1486KA 08-02123(I2006-193A)
 
Wayne
BEACH, HARRY J. v VILLAGE OF WOLCOTT,1618CA 10-00267(63237)
BRANTLEY, DAMIAN, PEOPLE v1586KA 10-00122(I09-107)
BROWN, LINDA M. v STATE OF NEW YORK,1115CA 09-00990(110037/108961)
BROWN, DARIUS, PEOPLE v1514KA 09-02099(I09-04)
BROWN, DARIUS, PEOPLE v1512KA 09-02095(I08-126B)
BROWN, DARIUS, PEOPLE v1513KA 09-02098(I08-162)
CALDWELL, DANIEL P. v WARD, RHONDA D.1620CA 10-00844(62056)
GROSS, GORDON B., PEOPLE v1414KA 10-01570(08-113)
MANUEL, KEVIN, PEOPLE v1607KA 09-02222(I09-59)
ROGERS, AUTUMN D. v EDELMAN, JANNA K.1584CA 10-00721(64068)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v FOX, ERSKINE1553CA 09-02057(CONF1346)
TARVER, WILLIE, PEOPLE v1510KA 10-00506(I09-140)
WRIGHT, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v1566KA 09-02175(I09-75)
 
Wyoming
MEYER, WILLIAM T. v STOUT, DONALD L.1418CA 09-02580(36050)
SIMMONS, ALPHONSO v FISCHER, BRIAN1617CA 09-01615(20,698-08)
THOMAS, JASON v THOMAS, JAMIE1630CAF 10-01237(V-00100-10/10A,)
WISNIEWSKI, FRANK, PEOPLE v1544KA 09-01364(I5915)
WOODWARD, SHAWN, PEOPLE v1545KA 09-01844(I5971)
 ; ; ; ;
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS ;  ; ;