AD4 Seal

Supreme Court of the State of New York
APPELLATE DIVISION
Fourth Judicial Department

Decisions - March 25, 2011

A-N., AKYRA, MTR. OF353CAF 10-01392(B-05623-09)
AHERN, CAROL A. v SIROTA, RONALD H.340CA 10-02263(2010-000703)
ASH, KENNETH v WINDOW SPECIALIST, INC.,387CA 10-01205(I118235)
ASH, KENNETH v WINDOW SPECIALIST, INC.,386CA 10-01204(I118235)
AULETA, FRANCIS v BERBARY, JAMES L.286KAH 10-00417(I-2009-12546)
B., JULIANI, MTR. OF265CAF 10-00295(NN-13516-09)
BAKER, TREVIS D., PEOPLE v328KA 07-00931(I06-368)
BAKER, TREVIS D., PEOPLE v323KA 07-00930(I06-409)
BANAH, JUNIOR A., PEOPLE v345KA 07-00949(I2004-0097-1)
BARROW, DEWEY R. v DUBOIS, D.L. GORDON384CA 10-01140(CA-2006-001367)
BARROW, DEWEY R. v DUBOIS, D.L. GORDON385CA 10-01142(CA-2006-001367)
BELL, MICHAEL STEVEN, PEOPLE v305KA 07-02434(I2006-0945)
BETETTE, JR., VINCENT B. v COUNTY OF MONROE,1600CA 10-01608(06-2361)
BOARDMAN, HARRIET C. v CHURCH OF THE TRANSFIGURATION,410CA 10-00842(2004-14049)
BOARDMAN, HARRIET C. v CHURCH OF THE TRANSFIGURATION,411CA 10-00843(2004-14049)
BOARDMAN, HARRIET C. v CHURCH OF THE TRANSFIGURATION,409CA 10-00841(2004-14049)
BOSLEY, BRIAN, PEOPLE v402KA 10-00081(I2008-2808)
BROWN, DANA P., PEOPLE v1511KA 09-02220(I5986)
C., KAYLIN, MTR. OF287CAF 10-01090(B-00495-09, B-00496-09)
C., LOKI, MTR. OF308CAF 10-00832(NN-1565 TO 1570-08;)
C., MICHAEL, MTR. OF306CAF 10-00620(B379-09, B380-09)
CAMHI, EMILY v RUCKERT, DDS, ERIC W.363CA 10-01847(11140-08)
CAMPOPIANO, LAURA L. v VOLCKO, PAUL J.96CA 08-01720(2005/6834)
CASTILLO, RAPHAEL, PEOPLE v240KA 07-00717(I93-0594)
CHAPPELL, RUTH M. v DIBBLE, BRUCE C.354CAF 09-02015(V-01072-08/08A)
CLARK, GARY B., PEOPLE v367KA 10-00085(09-33)
CLEAR SKIES OVER ORANGEVILLE, v TOWN BOARD OF TOWN OF ORANGEVILLE,293CA 10-01650(42273)
COLEMAN, RICHARD L., PEOPLE v107KA 10-00152(I2000-143)
COLEMAN, JR., ALTON J. v COLEMAN, JOANNE272CA 10-01891(1542-2007)
COMMISSO, ANTHONY v GREENLEAF, LYNDA383CA 10-02185(2008-1583)
CONIBER, JEFF v CENTER POINT TRANSFER STATION, INC.,254CA 10-02125(41453)
CONTI, JAMES v CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS WATER BOARD,270CA 10-02238(133666)
COSTANTINO, JOSEPH V., PEOPLE v264KA 10-01364(I2009-2254A)
COUNTY OF ERIE, v AFSCME, LOCAL 1000,269CA 10-02252(I-2009-12193)
CURRY, BRIAN, PEOPLE v304KA 09-00286(I2007-19091)
DEAN, ANTHONY, PEOPLE v324KA 10-00026(I2009-0052)
DEGRAFINREID, TERRY v KHAHAIFA, S.284KAH 10-00656(09-36762)
DEKDEBRUN, GREGORY A. v KANE, CHERYL294CA 10-02149(76442)
DEMUS, JOHN P., PEOPLE v350KA 08-01688(I07C-134)
DIOGUARDI, ANTHONY P., PEOPLE v280KA 10-00812(S07-070 (VOP))
DUNBAR, TIMOTHY L., PEOPLE v400KA 06-03712(I2005-0926-1)
E., HASSAN, MTR. OF309CAF 09-02111(B-00978-06, B-00979-06)
ELAMIN, ROBERT, PEOPLE v346KA 09-01893(I2008-0600)
EVERETT, DAVID, PEOPLE v349KA 07-02580(I2007-0114)
FASO, JEFFREY F., PEOPLE v80KA 10-00244(I06-120)
FERENCHAK, RALPH P., PEOPLE v397KA 09-00595(IDV-07-0028)
FS KIDS, LLC, v COMPENSATION RISK MANAGERS, LLC,257CA 10-01068(I2008-11268)
FS KIDS, LLC, v COMPENSATION RISK MANAGERS, LLC,258CA 10-01069(I2008-11268)
GALLEY, LINDA v CLARK, GARY311CA 10-02142(136968)
GALLUP, WILLIAM v SUMMERSET HOMES, LLC,334CA 10-02242(2002-7155)
GAYTON, SERRELL, PEOPLE v129KA 09-01818(I2007-0398A)
GENERAL STAR NATIONAL INSURANCE COM, v NIAGARA FRONTIER TRANSIT METRO SYST,252CA 10-01675(2004-7982)
GIGLIOTTI, VINCENT F. v BIANCO, CYNTHIA A.275CA 10-01198(I2009014458)
GILMORE, GABRIEL, PEOPLE v243KA 08-00867(S2008-3071)
GONYOU, CRYSTAL M. v MCLAUGHLIN, ROBERTA D.251CA 10-01700(2006-366)
GRESS, MARLINO v BROWN, BYRON313CA 10-01673(I-2008-0601)
GRIECO, CAROL H. v KALEIDA HEALTH,358CA 10-02232(I 2007-10724)
HALL, WILLIE, PEOPLE v239KA 10-00023(I2009-0034-1)
HAMPTON, JR., FRANKLIN v KIRKPATRICK, ROBERT A.283TP 10-00458(2009-14627)
HAYMON, JOAN v PETTIT, DONALD J.344CA 10-01730(01-834)
HILL, ERIC D., PEOPLE v1608KA 07-01907(I2006-0984)
HINES, TERRANCE B., PEOPLE v399KA 09-02164(I2009-090)
HIRT, SEAN v MANCUSO, PAUL298CA 10-02237(CA2010-000126)
HOWARD, DARNELL, PEOPLE v244KA 08-01807(II07-375)
HUDSON, JAMES E., PEOPLE v326KA 10-00502(I09-469-07)
JACOBS, LISANN v TILE SHOPPE ENTERPRISES, INC.,366CA 10-02054(I2008-10574)
JOHNSON, JAQUAWN O., PEOPLE v246KA 08-00223(I2007-0166B)
JONES, CYRESS, PEOPLE v74KA 09-01202(I2008-2526)
KAPUSCINSKI, MICHAEL v JELLETT, GISELLE310CAF 10-01172(V-1170-99/08M, 08N)
KING, KEVIN M. v D.R. CHAMBERLAIN CORPORATION,40CA 10-00050(I2002-1123) & (I2004-3633)
KING, KEVIN M. v D.R. CHAMBERLAIN CORPORATION,47CA 10-01740(I2002-1123)
KIRSHTEIN, MURRAY J.S. v AMERICU CREDIT UNION,339CA 10-01686(CA2004-000757)
KIRSHTEIN, MURRAY J.S. v AMERICU CREDIT UNION,338CA 10-01313(02-00824A)
KNIGHT, ODIS, PEOPLE v396KA 09-02476(I08-165A)
KOONCE, RONNIE A., PEOPLE v370KA 10-01055(S2009-267A)
KOSTYO, STEVEN v SCHMITT AND BEHLING, LLC,21CA 10-01279(2006-2151)
KUHN, JAMES C. v CAMELOT ASSOCIATION, INC.,1528CA 10-00907(K1-2007-720)
KUHN, JAMES C. v CAMELOT ASSOCIATION, INC.,1529CA 10-01057(K1-2007-720)
LADELFA, JON M., MTR. OF382CA 10-00906(2004-184B)
LEHIGH CONSTRUCTION GROUP, INC., SHERK, JOHN R. v1070CA 10-00873(I2007-0161)
LEWANDOWSKI, ARRON W., PEOPLE v177KA 10-00022(I09-44)
LIGGINS, WILLIAM, PEOPLE v248KA 09-01869(I98-436)
LIN, KAI v STRONG HEALTH, DEPARTMENT OF DENTIS,87CA 10-01474(9125/07) & (1511/08)
LIN, KAI v STRONG HEALTH, DEPARTMENT OF DENTIS,87.1CA 09-02432(9125-07) & (08-1511)
MARITA CAR RENTALS, INC., v GENERAL STAR MANAGEMENT COMPANY,255CA 10-01149(I-2007/7321)
MAYS, CHARLES E., PEOPLE v101KA 09-01783(I2008-0980D)
MCALLISTER, CHARLES v LECONEY, PATRICIA261TP 10-01476(10-1149)
MCCULLOUGH, DAVID v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF PAROLE,285KAH 10-00654(09-37108)
MCLELLAN, JOHN R., PEOPLE v351KA 09-01060(I08-67)
MCMANUS, JAMES E. v COUNTY OF ONONDAGA,290CA 10-02048(2004-1539)
MITCHELL, VARRELL v BERBARY, JAMES L.371TP 10-02127(2010-430)
MONROE, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v368KA 10-00061(I08-169)
MURRAY, WILLIAM F., PEOPLE v242KA 09-02146(II08-362)
NEUMAN, DAVID v FRANK, STUART A.291CA 10-00933(2006-7466)
NEW YORK SCHOOLS INSURANCE RECIP, MTR. OF253CA 10-02172(I2009-12594)
NGUYEN, LAI v KIRALY, WILLIAM E.42CA 10-00315(I-2007-4717)
NGUYEN, LAI v KIRALY, WILLIAM E.43CA 10-01445(I-2007-4717)
NIAGARA COUNTY, v POWER AUTHORITY OF THE STATE OF NEW, YORK134CA 10-00262(137244)
OBOT, OTU A. v MEDAILLE COLLEGE,256CA 10-02260(2009-2266)
OLIN, DAVID J. v STATE OF NEW YORK,379CA 10-02009
OLIVER, RAHEEM v FISCHER, BRIAN299TP 10-02236(20979-10)
P., III, LEOPOLIAN, MTR. OF376CAF 10-00488(B-264-09, B-265-09)
PARKS, MARQUIS, PEOPLE v329KA 10-00245(I2008-1750)
PIRON, ZACHARIAH, PEOPLE v303KA 10-02030(08-1441) & (2008-1274-1)
POPAL, FARID v SLOVIS, ESQ., HARVEY J.356CA 10-00731(I-2009-6524)
REBON, LAURIE v YORK, DONNA428CA 10-01696(2006/6113) & (2006/6113 TP1)
REEB, GARY, PEOPLE v241KA 10-01094(I01177-2004)
REED, EARL J., PEOPLE v263KA 05-00837(I04/00244)
REINHARDT, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v105KA 09-02119(I08-C-237)
RIPKA, JOANN v RIPKA, ROBBIE296CA 10-01693(2006-0089)
RIVERA, BENJAMIN, PEOPLE v104KA 08-00201(I687/88)
RIVERA, BENJAMIN, PEOPLE v103KA 07-00779(I0687/88)
RIVERS, NATALIE, PEOPLE v245KA 07-01060(I06-636)
ROACH, THERESA v MARRA, JOSEPH V.381CA 10-01909(I2008-7174)
ROBINSON, EDDIE M. v FISCHER, BRIAN259TP 10-02012(44240)
RODGERS, SIR RAVEN, PEOPLE v327KA 10-01050(I2009-3287)
RODRIGUEZ, EMMANUEL, PEOPLE v202KA 10-01100(I02733-2009)
SCHREINER, TIMOTHY M., PEOPLE v419KA 10-01175(I2005-39)
SHERROD, ANTHONY, PEOPLE v247KA 99-02223(97-1426-001)
SIWULA, JOHN T. v TOWN OF HORNELLSVILLE,337CA 10-01572(92322)
SMALLEY, DAVID v HARLEY DAVIDSON MOTOR COMPANY, INC,344.1CA 10-02022(4847/07)
SMIKLE, MAJERE, PEOPLE v1487KA 09-01463(I2008-0776)
SNYDER, DANIEL v SNYDER, DAWN295CA 10-02095(SF 2003-902603)
SPRAGUE, ALVIS D., PEOPLE v301KA 08-01759(I2007-0965)
STATE OF NEW YORK, VANILLE, JOHN D. v78KAH 09-00972(09-36338)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v KALCHTHALER, CHARLES359CA 10-00205(09C14)
STATE OF NEW YORK, VANILLE, JOHN D. v79KAH 09-01010(09-36338)
STEUBEN COUNTY SUPPORT COLLECTION U, v KELLY, NEIL T.288CAF 10-00644(F-02223-06/09D)
STEVER, DAVID F. v HSBC BANK USA, N.A.,378CA 10-01589(2005-6100)
STOCKER, KEVIN T. v 2900 TRANSIT ROAD LLC,380CA 10-01581(08-6585)
SZMANIA, DEBORAH v STATE OF NEW YORK,389CA 10-00989(111595) & (111596)
SZMANIA, DEBORAH v STATE OF NEW YORK,388CA 10-00987(111595)
THOMAS, DEREK G., PEOPLE v300KA 10-00052(S09-027)
TOLIVER, SAMUEL T., PEOPLE v72KA 09-01374(I2007-1196)
TSOULIS, ALEXANDER v ABBOTT BROS. II STEAK OUT, INC.,183CA 10-01721(103322)
VENKATARAMAN, SRINIVASAN v ORTMAN-NABI, M.D., JUDITH297CA 10-02104(I2001-521)
W., IMANI D., MTR. OF374CAF 10-00078(B-07514-07)
WALDEN, CRYSTAL M., PEOPLE v373KA 10-00183(S08-067)
WASHINGTON, THOMAS, PEOPLE v398KA 10-00819(I2008-1407)
WASHINGTON, III, RICHARD J., PEOPLE v369KA 09-00403(II06-217)
WATTS, PEREZ, PEOPLE v262KA 09-02437(I2008-363-2)
WELLBORN, MICHAEL L., PEOPLE v332KA 08-00650(I2007-0187B)
WESTER, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v372KA 08-00122(I06/0195C)
WILJEFF, LLC, v UNITED REALTY MANAGEMENT CORP.,230CA 10-01922(08-16439)
WILJEFF, LLC, v UNITED REALTY MANAGEMENT CORP.,229CA 10-01879(08-16439)
WILLIAMS, GABRIEL M., PEOPLE v33KA 09-01489(I2001-0911)
WINTERS, RICKY L., PEOPLE v390KA 10-00665(I2007-134)
YELTON, JR., RICHARD v FROELICH, BRANDIE L.375CAF 10-00743(V-05275-07/09C,/09E)
ZANE, FLORINE v CORBETT, MARK S.182CA 10-00691(CA2004-001476)
ZULEY, M.D., MARGARITA v ELIZABETH WENDE BREAST CARE, LLC,365CA 10-02091(09/12624)
    
Motions and Crawfords