[*1]
Sullivan v 40/40 Club
2011 NY Slip Op 52566(U)
Decided on December 30, 2011
Appellate Term, Second Department
Published by New York State Law Reporting Bureau pursuant to Judiciary Law § 431.
As corrected in part through February 25, 2015; it will not be published in the printed Official Reports.


Decided on December 30, 2011
SUPREME COURT, APPELLATE TERM, SECOND DEPARTMENT, 2d, 11th and 13th JUDICIAL DISTRICTS

PRESENT: : PESCE, P.J., RIOS and STEINHARDT, JJ.
2010-1266 Q C

Gwendolyn Sullivan and CARL SULLIVAN, Appellants, -against

against

40/40 Club, Desiree Gonzalez, CLAIRE F. PERLMAN, c/o ADAMS & COMPANY, LLC, TONI P. YOUNG c/o YOUNG CONWAY STARGATT & TAYLOR, LLP, as Trustee of the Trust Under the Last Will and Testament of HELEN FIELD, ROBERT M. BELSON, NANCY S. MARX, ELIAS SAVADA, ANDREW J. TUNICK, Trustee U/W of HELENE ROSENTHAL, JEAN RUTH Also Known as JEAN F. RUTH, TONI P. YOUNG As Known as TONI E. PERLMAN YOUNG, BARBARA R. KURTIN, RICHARD LIPPNER, PHILIP RUTH, JANET BIRNBAUM, ELLEN SIEV, as Trustee U/D/T for JOSEPH E. BELSON, ELLEN SIEV, as Trustee U/D/T for LAURA T. BELSON, MORTON SAVADA and ERNEST ADLER, as Trustees under the last will and testament of GERTRUDE LEIGHT, deceased, for JANET BIRNBAUM, ROBERT BELSON, ELIAS SAVADA, ALAN J. SAVADA, NANCY MARX, DANIEL SAVADA and SHIRA SAVADA, RICHARD S. BIRNBAUM, as Trustee for the benefit of RONALD AARON BIRNBAUM, ALAN J. SAVADA, DANIEL SAVADA, SHIRA SAVADA, JOSEPH E. BELSON, LAURA T. BELSON, RONALD AARON BIRNBAUM, THOA, LLC, c/o TONI YOUNG, SITORI, LLC, c/o Corporation Service Company, SK 1115 BROADWAY, LLC, c/o ROBERT HORAN, JP 1115 BROADWAY, LLC, c/o ADAMS & COMPANY, LLC, PERLMAN FAMILY PARTNERS, LLC, c/o ADAMS & CO., REAL ESTATE, TPY 1115 BROADWAY, LLC, c/o STARGATT & YOUNG CONWAY TAYLOR, LLP, DP 1115 BROADWAY, LLC, c/o DIANE PACHETTI, THE ALAN J. SAVADA REVOCABLE TRUST c/o CASA BOCCA DI LEONE, JOHN "DOE", "JANE DOE" and OTHER UNKNOWN, UNNAMED EMPLOYEES OF 40/40 CLUB, Respondents. 40/40 CLUB and DESIREE GONZALEZ, Third-Party Plaintiffs, ALL SEASON PROTECTION SERVICES, INC., Third-Party Defendant.




Opinion withdrawn from publication by the State Reporter because it duplicates the opinion published at 2011 NY Slip Op 52419(U).