Welcome
Home
THE COURT
    Overview of the Appellate Division
    Justices of the Court
    The Courthouse
DECISIONS
    Latest Decisions
    Decision Release Dates
    Search
CLERKS OFFICE
    Clerk and Deputy Clerk of the Court
    Contact Information
    Terms of the Court
    Court Calendars
    Rules of Practice
    Frequently Asked Questions
    Forms and Practice Aids
    Latest Court News
    Employment Opportunities
ATTORNEY MATTERS
    Admission to the Bar
    Attorney Discipline
    Attorney Registration Delinquency
    Registration as In-House Counsel
    Retirement
    Voluntary Resignation
PROGRAMS & AUXILIARY AGENCIES
    Assigned Counsel Program
    Attorneys for Children Program
    Attorney Grievance Committees
    Court Examiners
    Indep. Judicial Election Qual. Comm.
    Law Library
    Mental Hygiene Legal Service
    Pro Bono Policy and Program
RELATED LINKS
   Court sites
   Legal sites




Decisions - March 20, 2009

 
Allegany
B., BOBBIE S, MTR. OF350CAF 08-00967(NN-0726-07)
B., BOBBIE S, MTR. OF354CAF 08-00695(NN-0726-07)
HIXSON, MICHAEL A. v COTTON-HANLON, INC.,67CA 08-01864(32555)
 
Cattaraugus
BONAFEDE, DANIEL J. v STATE OF NEW YORK,362CA 08-01399(110353)
BOWEN, DONALD, PEOPLE v171KA 07-02095(I06-176)
GREY, JOHN v FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH OF OLEAN,431CA 08-01668(67998)
GREY, JOHN S. v FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH OF OLEAN, YORK432CA 08-01636(67998)
HOWELL, RAHEIM, PEOPLE v262KA 08-00236(I07-73)
LAFFERTY, ROBERT A., PEOPLE v169KA 06-01553(I05-008)
RICKICKI, DAVID P. v BORDEN CHEMICAL DIVISION OF BORDEN,22.2CA 07-01668(53395)
RICKICKI, DAVID P. v BORDEN CHEMICAL DIVISION OF BORDEN,22.1CA 07-02552(53395)
SAMPSON, P. MARC v RAINBOW FORD LINCOLN MERCURY, INC.,315CA 08-01956(66281)
WAGNER, WILLIAM G., PEOPLE v331KA 07-01782(I04-037)
 
Cayuga
CASE, ROBERT VERLE v CAYUGA COUNTY,1598CA 07-01351(06-867)
COYNE, SEAN P. v FISHER, BRIAN283TP 08-02113(2008-0489)
HOLBERT, STEPHEN M., PEOPLE v463KA 08-01127(I2006-147)
LANFAIR, GERALD v CORCORAN, MICHAEL268KAH 08-00831(2007-0918)
RAYMOND, ELWOOD L., PEOPLE v415KA 08-00516(I2007-059)
RICHARDS, MAGDALEN v BARTHOLOMEW, ANGELA481CA 06-02384(03-719)
 
Erie
A., SARAH, MTR. OF62CAF 08-00265(B-21281-06)
ABUHAMRA, IBITSAM TAHER v NEW YORK CENTRAL MUTUAL FIRE, INSURANCE COMPANY1514CA 08-01178(2006/9242)
ALEJANDRO, JASON J., PEOPLE v391KA 08-00346(I2006-1820)
APPLETON, ROOSEVELT, PEOPLE v399KA 07-02352(I2006-1284)
B., LUCAS, MTR. OF271CAF 08-00181(B-02507-07)
BUSCH, JR., JAMES E., PEOPLE v438KA 07-01045(I02017-2006)
C., ELEGANT R., MTR. OF402CAF 08-00990(B-15613-07)
CARVALHO, ANTONIO R., PEOPLE v439KA 07-01683(I2005-2772)
D.R. WATSON HOLDINGS, LLC, CB RICHARD ELLIS, BUFFALO, LLC, v1357CA 08-01022(10299/2005)
DIPASQUALE, JACK L. v M.J. OGIONY BUILDERS, INC.,227CA 08-01642(I2006-2716)
FOXWORTH, MARGARETTA v JENKINS, JOHN112CA 08-01177(I2005-10751)
GOODMAN, COLLYER v BERBARY, JAMES L.284TP 08-02052(2007-11976)
GORDON, EBONY, PEOPLE v305KA 06-03028(I2005-1312)
GREEN, DARNELL, PEOPLE v172KA 07-01166(I2006-1052)
HAY, GERALD v JAY, GORDON360CA 08-01115(2002/253)
HORTON, ROBERT, PEOPLE v414KA 07-00239(S26747)
HUNT, DAVON, PEOPLE v329KA 08-00126(I2007-0122)
HUNT, DAVON, PEOPLE v328KA 08-00125(I2006-2816)
HYLANT, JOSEPH P. v MANUFACTURERS AND TRADERS TRUST, COMPANY335CA 08-00918(2003-2536)
JOHNSON, TERRANCE, PEOPLE v441KA 07-02677(I00031-2007)
JONES, DEVON, PEOPLE v467KA 08-00381(I2007-1466)
KMIOTEK, DEANNA M. v CHABA, GENE M.64CA 07-02403(2005-5030)
KONOPCZYNSKI, TODD v ADF CONSTRUCTION CORP.,161CA 08-01124(2004 9115)
L., JEFFREY, PEOPLE v325KA 07-02486(S28843)
LAIDLAW ENERGY & ENVIRONMENTAL, INC, v TOWN OF ELLICOTTVILLE,41CA 08-01624(2007-6628)
LEDWIN, ROY v AUMAN, JEFFREY182CA 08-01754(I-2002-9477)
MROZ, KENNETH, PEOPLE v324KA 08-00418(S28334)
O'CONNELL MACHINERY CO., INC., v CITY OF BUFFALO ZONING BOARD OF, APPEALS274CA 08-01281(I2007/10168)
P., MORGAN, MTR. OF314CAF 07-02411(NN-15576-06, O-14821/22-
POTTER, MARGARET M. v TOWN BOARD OF THE TOWN OF, AURORA209.2CA 08-01967(I2008-9036)
POTTER, MARGARET M. v TOWN BOARD OF THE TOWN OF AURORA,209.1CA 08-01727(I2008-2099)
RAAB, JAMIE v KALEIDA HEALTH,384CA 08-01352(2006-004013)
RAK, CAROLYN v COUNTRY FAIR, INC.,132CA 08-01656(2003-7234)
RAMOS, JUAN, PEOPLE v168KA 07-02190(I2006-1492)
RAULS, BRIAN v DIRECTV, INC.,224CA 08-01814(I2007-2770)
RICHMOND FARMS DAIRY, LLC, v NATIONAL GRANGE MUTUAL INSURANCE, COMPANY1556CA 08-01150(2006-2625)
RITE AID OF NEW YORK, INC., v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN,1602TP 08-01106(I 2007-4597)
S., EDDIE, MTR. OF492CAF 08-00038(B-3684-07, B-3685-07)
S., ISIS, MTR. OF401CAF 08-00251(B-02347-07)
SCISSION, RASHAD, PEOPLE v427KA 08-00124(I2006-2630)
SCOTT, GREG, PEOPLE v444KA 08-00792(I2006-1215)
VASQUEZ, JUSTIN, PEOPLE v488KA 08-00857(S26980)
VAZQUEZ, BILLY, PEOPLE v348KA 06-03657(I2005-2311-SAG)
VIBO CORPORATION, v WHITE, ERIC R.279CA 08-02177(2005/2478)
WEBB, LEON, PEOPLE v54KA 07-01914(I01901-2006)
WINTERS, JAKE, PEOPLE v423KA 08-00639(I2007-0935)
 
Genesee
GLADDING, NOAH, PEOPLE v469KA 07-00692(I4816)
GUTZMER, CARL A. v SANTINI, MYRIAM L.63CAF 08-00771(V-00039-98/07U,)
HARDY, JR., EDWARD W., PEOPLE v309KA 07-01890(S04-78)
OBERLANDER, ALEXIS, PEOPLE v53KA 07-01035(I4933)
W., DAKOTA, MTR. OF493CAF 07-02493(B-114-07)
 
Jefferson
ESTRELLITA LLC, v TOWN BOARD OF TOWN OF ALEXANDRIA,317CA 08-01948(2007-2022)
FLINN, GUNTHER J., PEOPLE v104KA 08-00440(I06-434-06)
MILLER, JOHN E. v LARGETT, JOHN J.480CA 08-00295(05-2377)
WIND POWER ETHICS GROUP, v ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS OF TOWN OF,34CA 07-01995(07-789)
WIND POWER ETHICS GROUP, v ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS,35CA 08-01409(07-0789)
 
Lewis
HEARTWOOD FORESTLAND FUND, III, LP, v CROOKED LAKE PRESERVE, LLC,1684CA 08-01307(CA2006-00010)
 
Livingston
CLOUTIER, PAUL G. v GENESEO COLLISION SERVICES, LLC,294CA 08-01992(9732003)
CRUZ, MARIA L. v CRUZ, SR., PEDRO L.311CAF 07-01584(V-00558-05/06A, V-00558-
MULHOLLAND, ATHENA v BOSS, TODD A.490CAF 08-01279(V-00343-02/06,)
NEVAREZ, JOHN v HUNT, CARL B.282TP 08-01569(77-2008)
WOOD, SCOTT M., PEOPLE v266KA 07-02337(I2002-049)
 
Monroe
1440 EMPIRE BOULEVARD DEVELOPMENT, CORP. v LAWYERS TITLE INSURANCE CORPORATION,275CA 08-01390(2006/06967)
ALLEN, CARLTON, PEOPLE v345KA 06-03416(W3615/06)
B., MAKAIO L., MTR. OF352CAF 07-02292(B-3882/83-07)
CHESHER, DARRELL J., PEOPLE v370KA 06-02854(W2006/3048)
CHILDRES, MIA CARL, PEOPLE v31KA 03-02632(I466/03)
CLOSURE, CURTIS, PEOPLE v390KA 07-00621(S2006/4187)
CLOSURE, CURTIS, PEOPLE v389KA 07-00620(S2006/4188)
CONLEY, KEVIN v NEVISON, MARLENE272CAF 08-01094(V-7524-07)
COTTO, EFRAIN, PEOPLE v153KA 05-02215(I484/05)
DOUGLAS, GOLDDE, PEOPLE v377KA 05-01759(I2004-0254)
FAIRPORT BAPTIST HOMES, v DAINES, M.D., RICHARD F.280TP 08-01974(07-5592)
GARCIA-SANTIAGO, JERRY L., PEOPLE v398KA 06-02142(I2005-0116)
HOYTE, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v306KA 06-01051(W2006-3014)
JOHNSON, DAVID M. v EBIDENERGY, INC.,1578CA 08-01455(2003-3167)
JONES, TIMOTHY, PEOPLE v105KA 05-00667(I8/04)
JONES, TIM, PEOPLE v261KA 08-00801(S2006-3473)
KUNSMAN, EILEEN v BAROODY, RONALD343CA 08-02040(2006-0253)
MARTINEZ, ANGEL, PEOPLE v260KA 06-00121(I95-609)
NORTHERN TRUST, NA, v DELLEY, PATRICIA A.250CA 07-02360(07/2083)
OSBORNE, CHRISTOPHER H., PEOPLE v148KA 07-02262(I2004-1037)
PULLUAIM, WILLIAM, PEOPLE v369KA 06-02487(I650/05)
RESIDENTS AGAINST WAL-MART, v PLANNING BOARD OF TOWN OF, GREECE248CA 08-01662(07-13449)
RIVERA, ORLANDO, PEOPLE v425KA 05-02505(I198/05)
ROMAN, JOSE, PEOPLE v1561KA 03-01577(I561/02)
ROMAN, JOSE, PEOPLE v1560KA 03-01576(I514/02)
SANTOS, PEDRO M., PEOPLE v307KA 06-02806(S2005-3960)
SAPP, JEFFERY C., PEOPLE v349KA 06-00550(I539/05)
SHUFELT, JEANINE M. v DICE AMERICA, INC.,276CA 08-01721(2005/05359)
SIMMONS, JUACQUIS, PEOPLE v347KA 07-02287(I2004-197)
SMITH, JOB, PEOPLE v332KA 05-02007(I810/04)
SUMMERS, JOHN M. v CITY OF ROCHESTER,14CA 08-01032(2007-10556)
SUMMERS, JOHN M. v CITY OF ROCHESTER,15CA 08-01048(2007-10556)
WALLACE, KENNETH, PEOPLE v12KA 05-01408(I2004-1017)
YOUNG, BRANDON D., PEOPLE v466KA 07-00907(I2006-4125)
 
Niagara
BRADIGAN, WILLIAM M., PEOPLE v346KA 08-00517(I2006-589)
BRAND, SHAWN, PEOPLE v396KA 08-00146(I2005-526)
BUTLER, CHRISTIAN M., PEOPLE v483KA 08-00828(I2004-279)
MARACLE, TRACY, PEOPLE v209.4KA 07-02636(I2004-310)
MARACLE, TRACY, PEOPLE v209.3KA 07-00835(I2004-310)
RICKARD, IDA, PEOPLE v326KA 08-00846(I2004-419-V)
RODGERS, ANA v CITY OF NORTH TONAWANDA,383CA 08-02104(131393)
SOFIEN, LILLIAN v NOEL, CHARLES PHILIP410CA 08-01485(119720)
T.L.C. WEST, LLC, v FASHION OUTLETS OF NIAGARA, LLC,1597CA 08-01222(128572)
 
Oneida
BENNETT, BARBARA v DELIA, ELIS J.477CA 08-01626(CA2006-2308)
BERRY, ARTHUR v UTICA NATIONAL INSURANCE GROUP,476CA 08-01946(CA2007-1405)
CAPOCCETTA, LUIGI, PEOPLE v394KA 08-00680(II07-197)
G., IYONA, MTR. OF474CAF 08-01710(D-02803-07)
GARRETT, WILLIE, PEOPLE v416KA 07-00455(I05-226)
KOZIOL, LEON R. v KOZIOL, KELLY HAWSE1706CA 08-00165(D-42102)
KOZIOL, LEON R. v KOZIOL, KELLY HAWSE1705CA 08-00164(D-42102)
KOZIOL, LEON R. v KOZIOL, KELLY HAWSE1704CA 08-00163(D-42102)
KOZIOL, LEON R. v KOZIOL, KELLY HAWSE1703CA 07-02530(D-42102)
P., AMONI, MTR. OF491CAF 07-01826(NN-00616-07, NN-00617-07
ROACHE, WALTER J. v CONNELL, S.A.333KAH 08-00685(CA2004-749)
SULLIVAN CONTRACTING, INC., v TURNER CONSTRUCTION CO.,162CA 08-01729(CA 2005 - 2489)
 
Onondaga
BALL, LARRY v CITY OF SYRACUSE,154CA 08-00707(07-7610)
BISHOP, ANDREW E., PEOPLE v397KA 08-00657(I2008-69-1)
COBAUGH, SUSAN M., PEOPLE v263KA 04-01490(I2004-0348-2)
COMFORT, JAMES E., PEOPLE v81KA 05-00820(I2003-0325-1)
COMFORT, JAMES, PEOPLE v76KA 03-02311(I2003-0325-1)
GUIFFRIDA, MICHAEL v STORICO DEVELOPMENT, LLC,46CA 08-01310(05-3142)
HALLSTON MANOR FARM, LLC, v ANDREW, JULIE LYNN203CA 08-01090(2007-1740)
HOTALING, MICHAEL v EXCELLUS HEALTH PLAN, INC.,340CA 08-01445(2005-0596)
LEONARD, MARY E. v THOMPSON & JOHNSON EQUIPMENT CO.,, INC.93CA 08-01609(2005-3163)
LEONARD, MARY E. v THOMPSON & JOHNSON EQUIPMENT CO.,, INC.94CA 08-01610(2005-3163)
LEONARD, MARY E. v THOMPSON & JOHNSON EQUIPMENT CO.,, INC.92CA 07-01802(I2005-3163)
LUCIANO, JUAN CARLOS, PEOPLE v192KA 06-03438(I2005-0993-2-V)
MCCURTY, AARON, PEOPLE v486KA 06-01927(I2004-0730-2)
MCCURTY, AARON, PEOPLE v485KA 06-01926(I2005-0013-1)
MILEA, THERESA v CITY OF SYRACUSE,404CA 08-00663(99-1111)
MILEA, THERESA v CITY OF SYRACUSE,403CA 08-00662(99-1111)
OUTLEY, JOANNE v UPSTATE MEDICAL UNIVERSITY,450CA 08-01452(2006-7881)
PETTY, MICHAEL D., PEOPLE v265KA 07-00264(I2005-1369-1)
SWAN, GEORGE, PEOPLE v440KA 07-02334(I2005-1144-1)
TAG MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, INC., v P.S. GRISWOLD CO., INC.,339CA 08-00927(2002-1821)
THOMAS, RONALD, PEOPLE v235KA 06-01214(I2005-0419-1)
WILLIAMS, TIMOTHY, PEOPLE v371KA 06-00555(I2005-0518-1)
YOUNIS, DAVID A. v MARTIN, NORMAN J.356CA 08-02071(2007-8151)
 
Ontario
ARMITAGE, PETER A., PEOPLE v465KA 08-01047(I05-DI-036)
BECKER, SEAN, PEOPLE v327KA 06-01606(S06-DI-070)
BELANGER, MICHAEL PAUL, PEOPLE v445KA 08-00337(I07-SORA-004)
COLLIER, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v304KA 07-02421(I07-01-031)
JACOBSON, RYAN W., PEOPLE v190KA 06-02985(I06-01-020)
MCKOY, LAMON, PEOPLE v368KA 05-00425(I04-04-065)
RANDLEMAN, TROY F., PEOPLE v288KA 07-01928(S06-DI-196)
SCHIPPER, JOSHUA D., PEOPLE v373KA 06-01602(I05-07-073)
SCHROM, WALLACE R., PEOPLE v378KA 08-00375(I06-10-135)
VIEIRA, LIONEL T. v HUFF, DIANE P.470CAF 08-00309(V-02718-02/07K)
 
Orleans
EWING, SR., HAROLD E. v BRUNNER INTERNATIONAL, INC.,179CA 08-01846(30948/05)
PITTS, BERNARD v UNGER, DAVID290KAH 08-00395(07-33920)
SANTORO, JOSEPH M., PEOPLE v464KA 08-00444(S05-S-02)
 
Oswego
CAPPETTA, THOMAS C. v MALDONADO, JASMINE310CAF 08-00760(2006ID000003)
J., III, CHRISTOPHER, MTR. OF471CAF 08-01322(B-619-621-06/07B)
JOHNSON, LAURIE v DELTA INTERNATIONAL MACHINERY CORP.,137CA 08-01176(2002-2185)
MALISZEWSKI, PETER J., PEOPLE v1712KA 08-01555(I06C-33)
 
Seneca
FIRST NAMED PUBLIC OFFICIAL, MTR. OF437KA 08-02070(40718A)
IFILL, RICHARD SUNDAY v FISCHER, BRIAN303TP 08-01201(40955)
ZONA, JOSHUA, PEOPLE v33KA 08-01462(I07-068)
 
Steuben
CANTINERI, MICHAEL v CARRERE, FREDERIC205CA 08-00204(92154)
GIARDINA, TERESA A. v CAMPBELL, TERRY L.334CAF 08-00280(O-2034-07)
 
Wayne
COMPTON, DANIEL P. v FREYN, MAUREEN B.312CAF 08-00770(V0977-05/07B)
MERRILL, ROBERT J., PEOPLE v374KA 07-02431(I07-09)
SHORT, KATHLEEN B. v SHORT, RONALD A.140CA 08-01125(00856)
 
Wyoming
CONTI, DANIEL M. v WYOMING COUNTY,433CA 08-01008(39260)
HIZBULLAHANKHAMON, QABAIL v FISCHER, BRIAN229TP 08-01532(20602-08)
MARKOWITZ, ELLIOT v STATE OF NEW YORK,277CA 07-01977(105735)
MCILROY, JAMES v MUSKOKA TRANSPORT, LTD.,381CA 08-00304(35205/2004)
 
Yates
KLEM, JOHN, PEOPLE v379KA 08-01045(S06-69)
PETERSEN, ROBERT, PEOPLE v330KA 08-00482(S07-33)
    
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS