AD4 Seal

Supreme Court of the State of New York
APPELLATE DIVISION
Fourth Judicial Department

Decisions - June 8, 2012

ABREU, CARLOS v FISCHER, BRIAN626TP 11-01936(45397)
A., AUBREY, MTR. OF713CAF 11-00619(B-11481-09)
AGARWAL, PRASHANT, PEOPLE v701KA 12-00141(2010-5044)
ALEXANDER, HAROLD v NEW YORK CENTRAL MUTUAL,711CA 11-01520(09/15867)
ALLEN, MICAIAH v GRAHAM, HAROLD D.600TP 11-02389(2011-0472)
ALSTON, JESSE, PEOPLE v681KA 11-00543(I2011-7001)
ANDERSON, BARBARA v JUSTICE, RAY694CA 12-00183(1416-2009)
ANDREWS, RICHARD T. v COUNTY OF CAYUGA,746CA 12-00103(2009-1448)
BARNES, JESSIE J. v HARLING, RONALD624TP 11-00161(2009/06325)
BASSET GROUP, INC., v TOWN OF GREECE TOWN BOARD,648CA 11-02279(10/13415)
BIGBY, KHALLIN D., PEOPLE v654KA 11-01322(I2010-070B)
BLOOM, JR., NORMAN M., PEOPLE v608KA 11-00792(I10-33)
BLUEROCK ENERGY HOLDINGS, INC., v CHAMBRONE, ANGELO F.664CA 11-02434(2011-1145)
BLUEROCK ENERGY HOLDINGS, INC., v CHAMBRONE, ANGELO F.665CA 11-02435(2011-1145)
BUTLER, CALVIN, PEOPLE v484KA 09-02374(I09-01-009)
C., ALBERTO, MTR. OF758CAF 11-00433(B-16960-09)
CAMARDO, JR., JOSEPH A. v CITY OF AUBURN,670CA 11-01200(2011-0259)
CARRASQUILLO, LUIS F., PEOPLE v487KA 10-01400(I2007-1123-1)
CENTERPOINTE CORPORATE PARK, v MONY,598CA 11-02408(I2004-6531)
CHAVIS, ANTHONY v SYRACUSE COMMUNITY HEALTH CENTER, I, NC.761CA 11-02292(2008-8753)
CHECKSFIELD, TERRY v SIEDLICKI, SR., JOHN C.790CA 11-02594(2008-2885)
CITY OF BUFFALO, MTR. OF668CA 11-02021(2011-000814)
CITY OF SYRACUSE, v CENTRAL NEW YORK ASSN. OF DELTA,697CA 11-02503(2009-4467)
CLARK, JEREMY, PEOPLE v650KA 10-02500(S34284)
CLOSE, DAWN M. v DARIEN LAKE THEME PARK AND CAMPING, RESORT, INC.691CA 11-02220(2007/11293)
COBLE, DONTAE, PEOPLE v702KA 10-02442(I2010-0571)
COLEMAN, KERRY A., PEOPLE v754KA 10-00286(S2009-03090A (VOP))
CONSILIO, CARYN A. v TERRIGINO, CHRISTOPHER641CAF 11-00869(V01488-10/10D)
CONTI, CAROL D. v TOWN OF CONSTANTIA,718CA 11-02554(08-2093)
COUNTY OF ERIE, v DAINES, RICHARD F.661CA 12-00134(2010-12362)
COUNTY OF NIAGARA, v DAINES, RICHARD F.667CA 11-02505(142572)
DEPONCEAU, VICTOR A., PEOPLE v200KA 08-00634(I2005-0962B)
DUDEK, EDWARD, CONNIFF, JAMES v643CA 11-02459(2009-3895)
DUKE, MICHELLE L. v DUKE, BRIAN A.762CA 10-01871(SF 2008-902270)
ENGLERT, LEONARD M. v SCHAFFER, JR., ESQ., GERALD W.783CA 12-00064(2006/12365)
ERIE COUNTY S.P.C.A., v HOSKINS, BETH642CA 11-02239(I2010-5704)
FFT SENIOR COMMUNITIES, INC., v TOWN OF CANANDAIGUA,572.1CA 11-02058(099643)
FINCH, BENJAMIN, PEOPLE v756KA 10-02502(S10-114)
FOSTER, ANDREW J. v FOSTER, CANDIE A.778CAF 11-00382(V-02225-04/10F)
FRACCOLA, ALAN P., FRACCOLA, PROVIDENZA M. v646CA 12-00165(93021)
G., DREVONNE, MTR. OF232CAF 11-00084(B-20755-57-08)
GARDNER, DALE M. v STIVERS SENECA MARINE, INC.,162CA 11-01783(I2007-97662)
GERMAIN, BARBARA v KOHL'S CORPORATION,734CA 11-02540(2010-0642)
GRAVES, JULIUS, PEOPLE v722KA 11-00153(I2009-1339)
GRIBBINS, JAMES v RUSHFORD LAKE RECREATION DISTRICT,496CA 10-02432(38434)
GUILFORD, JAMES E., PEOPLE v552KA 08-01674(I2007-0874-1)
GUTIERREZ, ANDRES P., PEOPLE v708KA 10-01794(I08-306)
GUZMAN, EVAN P., PEOPLE v680KA 11-00401(I2009-3406)
HAMM, DARYL, PEOPLE v752KA 10-01591(I2008-3123)
HANN, RICHARD v BLACK, STEPHEN R.1388CA 11-01042(102608/08)
HARRIS, RUTH S. v STOELZEL, WILLIAM716CA 12-00021(2009-0117)
HASLEY, JEREMY, PEOPLE v704KA 11-00194(I2006-0049X)
HAYWOOD, TAUREAN v KIRKPATRICK, ROBERT A.599TP 11-01702(I-2011-02346)
HAYWOOD, SR., LAMONT v ANZALONE, MELISSA662CAF 08-01780(V00472/73-08)
HOLMES, TERRY L., PEOPLE v633KA 08-02353(I2007-1049)
HOWINGTON, JAMELL, PEOPLE v679KA 11-02514(10-0746)
HUMPHREY, DONOVAN v CAMPANY, EDWARD804CA 11-02005(2009-9679)
HUNTSMAN, CRAIG A., PEOPLE v556KA 08-02239(I08-01-024)
HUNTSMAN, CRAIG, PEOPLE v557KA 11-00567(I08-01-024)
IRVIN, PLIEKOU, PEOPLE v705KA 11-00062(I02-01-046)
J., TIOSHA, MTR. OF779CAF 11-00022(B-7173-2007, B-7174-2007
JACKSON, II, LOUIS v BEACH, DEBBRA612CAF 10-02472(V-78-00/09AC)
JAMES, LEONARD, PEOPLE v676KA 11-00544(I2010-7240)
JELKS, MELVIN M. v WRIGHT, KIM759CAF 11-01599(F-06586-09/10C)
JIMENEZ, EDUARDO, PEOPLE v605KA 09-02644(I2004-0073-1)
JOE, QUINTRELL L., PEOPLE v859KA 08-00219(I2007-0390-2)
JOHNSON, TIMOTHY T. v GENESEE MANAGEMENT, INC.,784CA 11-02510(2007/12234)
K., VIOLETTE, MTR. OF780CAF 11-01673(NN-02269-10)
KIRK, SR., RICHARD, PEOPLE v403KA 08-01439(I07C-122)
KNIGHT, MARY J. v REALTY USA.COM, INC.,690CA 12-00089(143001)
KYLER, BRADLEY I., PEOPLE v656KA 10-01006(I09-101)
L., ALEXIA, MTR. OF637CAF 11-01028(B-1637-10)
L., BRANDON, MTR. OF638CAF 11-01029(B-1638-10)
LANE, GERTRUDE A. v TEXAS ROADHOUSE HOLDINGS, LLC,423CA 11-02265(07-7908)
LEWIS, NATHAN v GRAHAM, HAROLD D.634KAH 11-00852(2010-1140)
LIAROS, THEODORE S. v TED'S JUMBO RED HOTS, INC.,721CA 11-02520(I2011-846)
LICARI, SALVATORE J. v NEW YORK CENTRAL MUTUAL INSURANCE,671CA 12-00131(2010-1394)
LINER, JOSHUA v FISCHER, BRIAN627TP 12-00223(21,081-11)
LONG, WILLIAM, PEOPLE v770KA 10-02077(I2009-0016)
LOWTHER, NICOLE L. v EASTMAN, CHRISTOPHER A.811.1CAF 12-00468(V-02280-04/11F)
M., AUSTIN, MTR. OF635CAF 11-01521(AS-09097-07)
M., AUSTIN, MTR. OF636CAF 11-01522(AS-09097-07)
MASTERSON, JEFFREY, PEOPLE v769KA 11-00399(I96-0124)
MCCRAY, WENFORD N., PEOPLE v749KA 11-01022(I2008-168)
MCINTOSH, II, EVERETT C., PEOPLE v607KA 11-00677(I2010-025)
MCLAUGHLIN, ANN L., MTR. OF747CA 11-01131(2008-1960/E)
MCLAUGHLIN, ANN L., MTR. OF748CA 11-01132(2008-1960/E)
MEDEN, JASON M., PEOPLE v773KA 11-00975(ST09-131)
MILLER, VINCENT, PEOPLE v703KA 10-02512(II10-109)
MITCHELL, DONTIE S. v FISCHER, BRIAN743CA 11-00383(2010-7531)
MONTAGUE, KIM v BROOKS, JASON A.685CAF 11-01129(V-02201-10, V-03488-10)
MORGAN, NICHOLAS J., PEOPLE v628KA 07-01252(I2005-0783B)
MURPHY, SUSAN v STATE OF NEW YORK,785CA 12-00104(115287)
MURRAY, WILLIAM M. v STATE OF NEW YORK,764CA 11-01856(M-79011)
NASTRI REAL ESTATE, LLC, v BEBLO, DOLORES744CA 11-02506(2011-4260)
NASTRI REAL ESTATE, LLC, v BEBLO, DOLORES745CA 11-02511(2011-4260)
NEW YORK CENTRAL MUTUAL FIRE INSURA, v NUGENT PANEPINTO, J.S.C., CATHERINE645OP 12-00096
NICHOLSON, CHRISTOPHER A. v NICHOLSON, DONNA M.710CAF 10-01623(V-00211-08/09A)
NIKOLOV, NIKOLA K. v TOWN OF CHEEKTOWAGA,524CA 11-01871(I-2008-2914)
P., NOAH VINCENT, MTR. OF733CAF 11-00442(B-04511-10)
PALMS, CURTIS, PEOPLE v772KA 09-01943(I2007-0927-13)
PATRICK PROPERTIES, LLC, v STOCKER, KEVIN766CA 10-02509(09-13243)
PECK, JAY, PEOPLE v727KA 11-00376(I2010-0906-1)
PETRONE, MICHAEL R. v ARGENTO, VICTORIA M.625OP 11-02595
POLONCARZ, MARK C. v COLLINS, CHRISTOPHER C.1209CA 11-00918(2010/011796)
PRACHEL, KATHLEEN v TOWN OF WEBSTER,450CA 11-02197(6502-07)
REEVES, MAURICE v ERIE COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL SE, RVICES731CAF 11-01515(NN-12864-10/10A)
RIVERA, ANTHONY, PEOPLE v723KA 11-01263(I2010-02509)
RLI INSURANCE COMPANY, v SMIEDALA, LESLIE616CA 12-00261(2007-130744)
RODRIGUEZ, ALBERTO v FISCHER, BRIAN526TP 11-01795(21067-11)
ROTTERMAN, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v726KA 11-01340(I01-198)
ROUTE 104 & ROUTE 21 DEVELOPMENT, v CHEVRON U.S.A., INC.,768CA 11-02518(55873)
RUPERT, JR., PHILIP D. v GATES & ADAMS, P.C.,692CA 11-02098(04/2692)
RUPERT, JR., PHILIP D. v GATES & ADAMS, P.C.,693CA 11-02099(04/2692)
RUSS, SR., BRYON K. v FISCHER, BRIAN739CA 11-00260(2010-0704)
S., ANASTASHIA, MTR. OF684CAF 11-01814(B-12-10)
S., SAMED, MTR. OF611CAF 10-02034(NA-12674-06)
SALIM, RAFIQ, PEOPLE v755KA 10-01173(I2009-1771I)
SANTIAGO, JR., CARLOS, PEOPLE v775KA 08-01881(I2007-0885)
SCHREIER, DAVID W., PEOPLE v707KA 11-02547(2009-0418)
SCOTT, LASHAWN J., PEOPLE v655KA 11-00404(I2004-0883C)
SEGUIN, LAWRENCE D. v LANDFRIED, M.D., MATTHEW J.666CA 11-02552(2007-012874)
SELECT FABRICATORS, INC., v HOGE, WILLIAM594CA 11-01299(98614)
SELECT FABRICATORS, INC., v HOGE, WILLIAM593CA 11-01298(98614)
SERVEY, TRAVIS, PEOPLE v651KA 10-02302(S10-333)
SHAFF, LAUREN, MTR. OF732CAF 12-00118(D-105-11)
SHUTE, JR., STEWART M. v MCLUSKY, ROBERT415CA 11-00944(08-5190)
SHUTE, JR., STEWART M. v MCLUSKY, ROBERT416CA 11-00945(08-5190)
SHUTE, JR., STEWART M. v MCCLUSKY, ROBERT421CA 11-02575(08-5190)
SHUTE, JR., STEWART M. v MCCLUSKY, ROBERT422CA 11-02596(08-5190)
SIMMONS, JR., RICHARD A., PEOPLE v652KA 11-01084(I2010-188)
SMITH, ELEANOR M. v CORNELL, CRYSTAL M.720CA 11-02592(168/06)
SOLOMON, JOEQUELL E., PEOPLE v574KA 10-01960(I10-01-026)
SPRATLEY, KENT D., PEOPLE v631KA 11-00486(II10-097)
SQUIRES, GEORGE P., PEOPLE v675KA 11-01490(I2011-5012)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v HALL, JOHN717CA 11-01437(59893)
STOCK, LYNN v DALY, M.D., DENNIS400CA 11-01973(06-2709)
STUBBS, JASON MARCELLUS, PEOPLE v699KA 06-03122(I114/06)
STUBBS, JASON MARCELLUS, PEOPLE v700KA 06-03701(I114/06)
SURF CITY ENTERPRISES OF SYRACUSE,, v NEW YORK STATE LIQUOR AUTHORITY,712TP 12-00139(2011-6895)
TARO, JASON, PEOPLE v507KA 08-02457(I2008-0015-1)
TENNEY, PAUL R., PEOPLE v601KA 10-00661(S09-108)
TENNEY, PAUL R., PEOPLE v602KA 11-01305(S09-108)
THOMAS, TOM v BOHEEN DAVIS, CYNTHIA L.617CA 11-02181(30975/2005)
THOMPSON, KENNETH L., PEOPLE v753KA 10-01781(I09-85)
THOUSAND, ROBERT J., PEOPLE v678KA 11-00249(I2009-283-1)
TINCH-MCNEILL, SANDRA v ALCOHOL AND DRUG DEPENDENCY SERVICE,613CA 11-00681(2003-7789)
TUPER, PATRICIA P. v TUPER, KENNETH E.446CA 11-02168(105925)
TURNER, JESSIE A., PEOPLE v560KA 07-00633(I2006-0737-2 & 0679-1)
TYSON, MICHEL v NAZARIAN, LAWRENCE294CA 11-02068(2008-06560)
VAN BROCKLEN, RUSSEL v ERIE COUNTY MEDICAL CENTER,571CA 11-02199(2010-8697)
VANBUREN, ALEXANDRA v WILLIAMSVILLE CENTRAL SCHOOL DIST.,686CA 12-00138(2011-410)
WALKER, BENNY L., PEOPLE v750KA 09-00282(I2007-0106)
WEIR, TRACI L., PEOPLE v757KA 07-02335(SI-05-515A-04)
WILSON, HARRY, PEOPLE v728KA 11-01163(I10-04-085)