AD4 Seal

Supreme Court of the State of New York
APPELLATE DIVISION
Fourth Judicial Department

Decisions - June 7, 2013

 
Allegany
VENNARD, CHARLES J. v HAUN, SANDRA L.649CAF 12-00439(V-00925-04/10B)
 
Cayuga
CRENSHAW, WILLIAM v GRAHAM, HAROLD573KAH 12-00566(2011-1064)
TARO, AUSTIN J., PEOPLE v615KA 12-00820(I2011-089)
 
Chautauqua
NORSE PIPELINE, LLC, v TOWN OF BUSTI,601CA 12-02380(K1-2009-1284)
NORSE PIPELINE, LLC, v TOWN OF BUSTI,606CA 12-02381(K1-2009-1284)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v FARNSWORTH, DANIEL530CA 12-00257(MH K1-2008-943)
 
Erie
A., ROMAN E., MTR. OF553CAF 11-02466(B-02826-11)
A., ROMAN E., MTR. OF554CAF 12-00301(B-02826-11)
ARIA CONTRACTING CORPORATION, v HISCOCK & BARCLAY, LLP,622CA 12-01611(2009-011449)
BADDING, JR., ROBERT E., PEOPLE v550KA 11-01642(I2010-01870)
BENKLEMAN, MARIE T. v KOLB, MARCIA A.722CA 12-02376(2011-655)
BIANCHINE, JENNIFER v NYS OFFICE OF CHILDREN AND FAMILY S,728.1TP 12-01781(2012-000356)
BOROWSKI, MARK W. v PTAK, JEREMY J.1315CA 12-00965(I2010-0185)
BUFFALO UNITED CHARTER SCHOOL, v NEW YORK STATE PERB, RELATIONS BOARD515CA 12-02092(2011-1248)
BUYER'S FIRST CHOICE, INC., v SIMME, JOANNE272CA 12-01178(I-2010-12324)
BUYER'S FIRST CHOICE, INC., v SIMME, JOANNE271CA 12-01177(I-2010-12324)
CURTO, PATRICIA v NYS COLLEGE OF VETERINARY MEDICINE,725CA 12-02209(2011-4197)
CURTO, PATRICIA v NYS COLLEGE OF VETERINARY MEDICINE,724CA 12-02207(2011-4197)
DANDRIDGE, TERRY L., PEOPLE v594KA 11-01155(I98-2785)
DEXTER, DOMINIQUE v KOERNTGEN, ROBERT512CA 12-01902(09-0542)
DUSZYNSKI, ANN v ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY,538CA 12-02075(10/12426)
FLATTS, ALICIA M. v RODRIGUEZ, VIRGINIA D.718CA 12-02400(I2010-1072)
GWYNN, JR., ROBERT, PEOPLE v637KA 12-01107(I2006-2956)
HOYT, MICHAEL R., PEOPLE v463KA 11-01480(S34818)
JASCO, JANIE v ALVIRA, DAVID579CAF 12-01027(F-00049-00/11E)
LANE, MARCUS, PEOPLE v593KA 12-00215(S35826)
MELSKI, SOPHIA v FITZPATRICK & WELLER, INC.,537CA 12-01545(2009009909)
NOAH, STEPHEN J., PEOPLE v414KA 12-01879(2010-00103)
NWAWKA, NANCY CHINEZE v YAMUTUALE, DESIRE BADIBADY555CAF 11-01564(V-07779-10/10A)
PAYTON, ROBERT M. v 5391 TRANSIT ROAD, LLC,585CA 13-00013(2010-3189)
PORTERFIELD, CHARLES, PEOPLE v715KA 11-01985(I2009-02085)
STEPHENSON, LINDSEY v FLEMING, ANDREW P.677CA 12-02039(2011/2960)
SUTTLES, TRUMAINE, PEOPLE v614KA 11-01629(I2010-1223)
TORRES, ARMANDO v STATE OF NEW YORK,658CA 11-02472(118610)
V., DESTINY, MTR. OF620CAF 12-01136(B-15226-11)
WHALEN, SHAWN, PEOPLE v709KA 12-00383(I2011-0479)
WILK, JOANNE v JAMES, M.D., DAVID M.914CA 12-00577(2005-8135)
WRIGHT, LUKE J., PEOPLE v369KA 11-01117(I2010-00197)
 
Genesee
ALLARD, RAYMOND E., PEOPLE v201KA 11-01989(I5439)
MILLER, II, RICKY L., PEOPLE v684KA 12-00405(I5452)
MILLER, II, RICKY L., PEOPLE v689KA 12-00407(I5454)
PREEDOM, CHRISTOPHER B., PEOPLE v641KA 12-02247(11-97)
STROLLO, ROBERT C., PEOPLE v591KA 12-00357(S11-084)
 
Herkimer
IOCOVOZZI, VINCENT D. v IOCOVOZZI, BONNETTE516CA 12-01970(94735)
 
Jefferson
DELSOL, OROSMAN v FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF NEW YORK, I,514CA 12-01375(2009-0332)
 
Lewis
ELLIOTT, SHAUN K., PEOPLE v597KA 10-02122(I2010-011)
 
Livingston
DRUMM, CARL v SHAH, NIRAV R.707TP 12-02375(857-2012)
K., JULIE, MTR. OF621CAF 12-00092(B-00007-99/11C)
 
Monroe
ALEXIS, DAMIAN R., PEOPLE v568KA 09-01186(I2008-0445)
ARENA, SANDRA M., PEOPLE v526KA 09-02147(I2008-0696)
ATKINS, UKIAH R., PEOPLE v595KA 09-01138(I2003-0146)
BROWN, CRAIG D., PEOPLE v714KA 09-01085(I2008-0370)
GAYDEN, JR., JOHN, PEOPLE v508KA 07-01185(I06/714)
JEFFERSON, DONNELL v STUBBE, ESQ., JOSHUA446CA 11-02452(2011/06590)
MCCOY, JAMES A., PEOPLE v551KA 10-01753(S2010-3377)
TAYLOR, FREDERICK D. v DANRICH HOMES, INC.,680CA 12-02001(11/1497)
VINCENT AUTOMOTIVE, INC., v CHEVRON U.S.A., INC.,517CA 12-02006(2006-11150)
 
Niagara
BOWMAN, SANDRA v CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS,429CA 12-01495(145107/2011)
PRESNELL, CHASTITY N. v NEW YORK CENTRAL MUTUAL INSURANCE,624CA 13-00018(139505)
REYNOLDS, ROBERT A. v FERRANTE, D.C., CHRISTOPHER S.457CA 12-01546(145190)
RIOS, JOHN E., PEOPLE v223KA 11-01825(I2009-421)
WESTGATE, RICHARD v BRODERICK, DAVID S.333CA 12-01631(133864)
 
Oneida
CUDA, GARY D. v DWYER, HON. MICHAEL L.404OP 12-01976
HOBIN, TODD M. v HOBIN, CANDICE L.774CA 12-00674(D2009-044730)
ROMAN, WALTER, PEOPLE v528KA 11-01080(II09-317)
SANBORN, JAMISON C., PEOPLE v569KA 12-02354(2012-40)
 
Onondaga
BATTLE, MARQUES, PEOPLE v613KA 10-01097(I2009-0990-1)
DOE, JANE v NORTH MEDICAL, P.C.,610.1CA 12-01944(2011C7CP)
GRAHAM, CLIFFORD, PEOPLE v442KA 10-00532(I2009-0615-1)
GREEN THUMB LAWN CARE, INC., v NEW YORK STATET DEPARTMENT OF ENVIR, ONMENTAL CONSERVATION373CA 12-01133(2011-5764)
GREEN THUMB LAWN CARE, INC., v IWANOWICZ, PETER M.372CA 12-01132(2011-0062)
HOTALING, RICHARD v SPROCK, ESQ., CHARLES M.532CA 12-01221(2002-5939)
HOTALING, RICHARD v SPROCK, ESQ., CHARLES M.533CA 12-01222(2002-5939)
LOSTUMBO, STANLEY, PEOPLE v343KA 12-00106(I2011-0160-1)
MCNEILL, EFFRIN, PEOPLE v509KA 11-02365(I2011-0705-1)
PAULK, MARTIN S., PEOPLE v416KA 09-01790(I2008-0024-1)
PAULK, MARTIN S., PEOPLE v415KA 09-01789(I2008-0785-1)
SAFFOLD, ROBERT, PEOPLE v666KA 10-00398(I2003-0395-1)
SPOSSEY, DEBRA, PEOPLE v439KA 10-01153(SI-2009-1051-1)
TRINIDAD, EDUARDO, PEOPLE v511KA 10-01206(I2009-1130-2)
WILLIAMS, PAUL, PEOPLE v340KA 09-01766(I2009-0237-1)
 
Ontario
BARR, JOEY D., PEOPLE v570KA 11-02324(I10-10-221)
DEWITT, MICHAEL P., PEOPLE v549KA 12-01438(11-4-085)
 
Orleans
ORLEANS COMMUNITY HEALTH, MTR. OF513CA 12-01777(12-39842)
W., DAMIEN, MTR. OF578CAF 11-02546(NN-00212-11)
 
Oswego
BUTCHINO, DUSTIN L., PEOPLE v669KA 11-02491(I11C-77)
CORMIER, MICHELLE v CLARKE, ROXANNE409CAF 11-02304(V-829-10/10A)
LUKENS, JACK, PEOPLE v393KA 10-01086(I09C-076)
THOMPSON, WILLIAM R. v SITHE/INDEPENDENCE LLC,289CA 12-01647(08-1655)
 
Seneca
GEORGE, LUCINDA, MTR. OF235CA 12-01498(2007/22189A)
WEST, JAMES v SHEAHAN, MICHAEL590TP 12-02305(46567)
 
Steuben
VAUGHN, DARRYL R. v MAHON, STEPHANIE M.697CA 12-02221(2012-0205CV)
 
Wayne
FAETH, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v505KA 12-00896(I99-95)
WATKINS, GREGORY, PEOPLE v420KA 12-00716(I10-86)
 
Wyoming
BRIECKE, STEPHAN v NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF, CORRECTIONAL SERVICES574KAH 12-00657(21,140-11)
BROWNLEE, BENJAMIN v FISCHER, BRIAN661TP 12-02249(21,230 -12)
DELACRUZ, GENARO v FISCHER, BRIAN664TP 12-02210(21233-12)
GEORGE, PATRICK v REISDORF BROS., INC.,586CA 13-00027(44005)
GREGG, NOAH, PEOPLE v548KA 12-00277(S6505)
GUTIERREZ, OMAN v FISCHER, BRIAN589TP 12-02389(21203-12)
MOTZER, ERIC J., PEOPLE v546KA 12-00838(I6361)
REDMOND, DAVID v FISCHER, BRIAN662TP 12-02388(21210-12)
WELCH, TIMOTHY, PEOPLE v710KA 12-01483(I6544)
 
Yates
DAVIDSON, WAYNE v VILLAGE OF PENN YAN,449CA 12-01960(2012-0092)
DAVIDSON, WAYNE v VILLAGE OF PENN YAN,443CA 12-01959(2012-91)
EASLING, LI HSIEN v HENDERSON, STEPHEN R.700CA 12-02005(2009-0562)
      
      
      
Motions & Crawfords