AD4 Seal

Supreme Court of the State of New York
APPELLATE DIVISION
Fourth Judicial Department

Decisions - March 21, 2014

 
Allegany
DROUIN, ROBIN, PEOPLE v27KA 12-01343(I11-043)
JOHNSON, PAULA J. v AYYUB, M.D., MOHAMMAD121CA 13-00510(35834)
 
Cattaraugus
ALLEGANY WIND LLC, v PLANNING BOARD OF TOWN OF ALLEGANY,1324CA 13-00795(80852)
 
Cayuga
BATES, GREGORY, PEOPLE v231KA 12-02107(I2011-205B)
DALE, ALAN v STALLONE, ET. AL.,, DAVID215KAH 12-00747(2011-0658)
PLAZA DRIVE GROUP OF CNY, LLC, v TOWN OF SENNETT,65CA 13-00405(2012-0902)
RUSS, SR., BRYON K. v FISCHER, BRIAN186TP 13-01389(2013-00000666)
RUSSELL, FRANK v FISCHER, BRIAN224CA 12-01642(2011-1257)
 
Chautauqua
GIVAN, ROBERT v MAKIN, ROBERT A.216CA 13-01407(2011-75866)
HOLST, WILLIAM M. v LIBERATORE, VICTOR198CA 13-01644(k1 2008-1096)
 
Erie
BRITT, CARMEN v BUFFALO MUNICIPAL HOUSING AUTHORITY,349CA 13-01393(I-2004-9897)
CANDINO, JR., JOSEPH D. v STARPOINT CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,83CA 13-01241(2012-03166)
DAVIS, LAMAR, PEOPLE v289KA 12-00707(I2007-00260)
HARVEY, MERLE A. v AGLE, RANDY142CA 13-01350(2012-605680)
HENSLER, CARL v GALASSO, DOMINIC A.143CA 13-01239(2010-10344)
HOUSTON, LUZ M. v MCNEILUS TRUCK & MANUFACTURING, INC,103CA 13-01249(2010-006374)
LOZINAK, SUZANNE v BOARD OF EDUCATION OF WILLIAMSV,197CA 13-00984(2013-0037)
M&T BANK, v CHOICE GRANITE PRODUCTS LTD.,57CA 13-00837(I2009-10153)
M&T BANK, v CHOICE GRANITE PRODUCTS LTD.,58CA 13-00838(I2009-10153)
MARRERO, NANCY v GANDOLFO, PAUL FREDERICK307CA 13-01656(2011-4346)
MERRITT, STEPHAN, PEOPLE v331KA 12-01249(I2011-0836)
MOHAMUD, ALI-MOHAMAD, PEOPLE v232KA 12-02273(I2012-00771)
MORROW, TEVIN, PEOPLE v292KA 12-01482(I2012-0082)
PULVINO, BRANDON M., PEOPLE v212KA 12-00794(I2008-2350X)
REID, JUSTIN, PEOPLE v312KA 12-01054(I2011-1239)
RIDGE, STEVEN C. v GOLD, ALICE1300CA 13-00908(I2010/9890)
RODRIGUEZ, OFELIA v COLON, MARIA I.101CA 13-00293(I 2009-002762)
RUNDLE-KRZYZANIAK, ROBIN E. v BAIN, JUSTIN A.204CA 13-01500(2012-1595)
SOUTH BUFFALO DEVELOPMENT, LLC, v PVS CHEMICAL SOLUTIONS, INC.,20.1CA 13-00791(2011-603609)
SUTTNER, JOANNE v A.W. CHESTERTON COMPANY,206CA 13-01373(I2010-12499)
TEXIDOR, III, ROBERTO, PEOPLE v190KA 12-01346(S36464)
THOMAS, CLEVELAND L. v HUH, JACOB K.226CA 13-01040(I2010-011926)
TROST, CARL v ROCKINGHAM ESTATES, LLC,246CA 13-01157(2011-1191)
WILSON, NJERA A., PEOPLE v234KA 11-02057(I2009-2937D)
 
Genesee
CARNEY, NORMAN J. v PAVILION DRAINAGE SUPPLY CO., INC.,261CA 13-01532(61219)
 
Herkimer
WORDEN, STEPHANIE L. v SIMPSON, TONI844CA 13-00288(94898)
 
Jefferson
WHITFIELD, RHASHAY R., PEOPLE v99KA 11-00098(I10-191-10)
 
Lewis
LEWIS COUNTY, v NIAGARA MOHAWK POWER CORPORATION,220CA 13-01412(CA2010-000556)
WILLIAMS, GRAYLON K. v WILLIAMS, MERIAH L.278CAF 13-00115(V-00626-00627-12/12AB)
 
Livingston
BOYKIN, JERMAIN v FISCHER, BRIAN227TP 13-01359(502-2013)
 
Monroe
BERNARD, GREGORY, PEOPLE v193KA 09-02219(I2007-0876A)
BERNARD, GREGORY, PEOPLE v194KA 12-01386(I2007-0876A)
BISHOP, LANCE R., PEOPLE v311KA 10-00521(I2008-0813)
BRIGGS, LATASHA D., PEOPLE v316KA 10-01030(W2010-3052)
HOLMES, MICHAEL A., PEOPLE v95KA 12-00870(I2011-0688A)
MANN, FRANCINE v WEGMANS FOOD MARKETS, INC.,330CA 13-01668(2011-13797)
MCCALLA, KARL, PEOPLE v294KA 10-00701(I95-0744)
PITTS, BERNARD, PEOPLE v192KA 12-01929(I95-0283)
SYLAR, ROBERT, PEOPLE v267KA 13-00124(I2000-0333)
VROOMAN, RONALD L., PEOPLE v114KA 08-02354(I2007-0851)
WRIGHT, HOWARD S., PEOPLE v1247KA 07-01841(I2006-0799)
 
Niagara
BOWER, CHRISTOPHER M. v CITY OF LOCKPORT,159CA 13-01309(133225)
CASSATA, HONORABLE JOSEPH J. v STATE OF NEW YORK,183CA 13-00640(143688)
FELVUS, ROBERT M., PEOPLE v209KA 13-00153(I2012-073)
GROSSKOPF, MARC A., PEOPLE v271KA 12-02154(IID10-0011-V)
SONNELITTER, GARY v WHITE, JOSEPH39CA 12-00175(123270)
SONNELITTER, GARY v WHITE, JOSEPH40CA 12-00176(123270)
 
Oneida
BROWN, IKIKO K., PEOPLE v167KA 12-01098(II10-329)
C., TREYVONE, MTR. OF319CAF 12-01103(B-01397-11/12B)
COLON, MIGUEL, STATE OF NEW YORK, v306CA 13-00005(CA2011-001828)
DEGROAT, RICHARD v KELLY, CHARLES275KAH 13-00535(CA2012-002545)
HENSEL, ANTHONY J. v CITY OF UTICA,203TP 13-01575(2013-001219)
LOPEZ, WILFREDO v LUGO, JENNIFER277CAF 13-00215(V-1230-(1231)-12)
PATTERSON, CHRISTIAN M., PEOPLE v87KA 12-01049(II11-322)
REYNOLDS, SHARELLE v KELLY, RICHARD328CA 13-01390(2009-002331)
RITZEL, SR., RONALD v CARRION, DENNIS1272CA 12-00845(2006-001320)
SEFERAGIC, ESAD v HANNAFORD BROS CO.,244CA 13-00691(CA2010-002450)
VENETTOZZI, ANTHONY J. v MANTELLI, HEIDI L.152CAF 13-00661(V-00475-06/11Q)
WARE, MARK A., PEOPLE v270KA 10-00732(II08-442)
 
Onondaga
BUFF, PHILIP v VILLAGE OF MANLIUS,37CA 13-01118(2012-5341)
DAVIS, JABRE, PEOPLE v73KA 11-01291(I2009-0738-1)
EAST2WEST CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, LLC, v THE FIRST REPUBLIC CORPORATION OF A,179CA 13-00749(2012-1555)
EAST2WEST CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, LLC, v QUINLIVAN, PIERIK & KRAUSE,180CA 13-00755(2012-1555)
EMERALD EQUIPMENT SYSTEMS, INC., v GEARHART BROTHERS SERVICES, LLC,104CA 13-01266(2012-4075)
GRIMES, LOUIS, PEOPLE v131KA 13-00330(I2012-0640-1)
MYLES, ANTWAN, PEOPLE v250KA 11-01070(I2010-0092-1)
QUILTY, PAMELA J. v CORMIER, DANIELLE J.242CA 13-01666(2012-1676)
QUINONES, GILBERT v LEONARD, SIOBHAN367CAF 12-01509(V-0176-10/11A)
RAIMONDO, ROBERT C. v DOUGLAS, THOMAS345CA 13-00354(CA2011-7513)
STATE FARM FIRE & CASUALTY COMPANY, v NATIONAL GRID POWER CORPORATION,329CA 13-01560(2917/2011)
TRAVET, HELEN, PEOPLE v268KA 11-00479(I2010-1115-1)
WILLIAMS, HENRY, PEOPLE v313KA 11-01295(I2010-0686-1)
 
Ontario
AHLERS, DAVID M. v ECOVATION, INC.,324CA 13-01364(101573)
 
Orleans
C., MARCO A., PEOPLE v210KA 12-01242(I11-51)
POWELL, JOYCE E., PEOPLE v1198KA 11-01585(I09-87)
ROBLES, NICHOLAS v STATE PRISON, WARDEN ORLEANS189KAH 12-02327(12-40186)
RUSSELL, JIMMY DEAN, PEOPLE v273KA 12-00926(I05-27)
 
Oswego
HARGRAVE, GARRETT v LECHASE CONSTRUCTION SERVICES, LLC,1373CA 13-00925(10-2012)
 
Steuben
NORTON, GREGORY W. v CITY OF HORNELL,256CA 13-01523(2012-1579)
ROCHE, PHILIP J. v BAKER, BROOKS T.282CA 13-01682(2012-1446CV)
S., MAKAYLA, MTR. OF321CAF 12-01823(B-02184/02185-11)
 
Wayne
BEYRAU, JAMES, PEOPLE v290KA 12-01863(I11-144)
BEYRAU, JAMES, PEOPLE v291KA 12-01900(S12-W10)
LAWLER, MICHAEL A. v KST HOLDINGS CORPORATION,136CA 13-00839(64725)
 
Wyoming
BARNES, ARRELLO v FISCHER, BRIAN208TP 13-01474(21,341-13)
BOTTOM, ANTHONY v ANNUCCI, ANTHONY228TP 13-01661(21370-13)
CARDEW, ROBERT v FISCHER, BRIAN127CA 13-00176(21,188-12)
ELDER, JARVIS v FISCHER, BRIAN90TP 13-01112(21,303-12)
FLOYD, DENNIS v FISCHER, BRIAN187TP 13-01635(21,340-13)
HOWARD, VINCENT v FISCHER, BRIAN248TP 13-01472(21,312-13)
ROSS-SIMMONS, AHJEMIN v FISCHER, BRIAN265CA 13-00261(21,247-12)
TYES, RICHARD v FISCHER, BRIAN188TP 13-01475(21,311-13)
WAPNIEWSKI, STEPHEN M., PEOPLE v335KA 12-01520(I6613)
     
 MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS