Appellate Division, First Department Decisions

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

**Cases Decided February 26, 2004**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Matthew Weissman	Per Curiam	M-5649	2004 NYSlipOp 01309
David L. Thornton v Shlomo Baron		404	2004 NYSlipOp 01233
Michael P. McGorry v Madison Square Garden Corporation		586	2004 NYSlipOp 01234
Diane Bennett v New York City Transit Authority		1852	2004 NYSlipOp 01235
Mariano Mendoza v Grace Industries		2256	2004 NYSlipOp 01236
People v Carlos Caban		1340	2004 NYSlipOp 01237
Carlos Suarez v Shigeo Abe		1641	2004 NYSlipOp 01238
Oil Heat Institute of Long Island Insurance Trust v RMTS Associates		1675N	2004 NYSlipOp 01239
Matter of Thomas L.		2286	2004 NYSlipOp 01240
Matter of Christopher Grimm v State of New York Division of Housing and Community Renewal		2576	2004 NYSlipOp 01241
Nationwide Registry & Security v B&R Consultants		2587	2004 NYSlipOp 01242
People v Miguel Rodriguez		2948	2004 NYSlipOp 01243
People v Mark Beckford		2950	2004 NYSlipOp 01244
People v Encilio Salcedo		2952	2004 NYSlipOp 01245
People v Robert Anderson			2004 NYSlipOp 01246
Matter of Erron M.		2955	2004 NYSlipOp 01247
Tahseen H. Syed v Normel Construction Corp.		2957	2004 NYSlipOp 01248
Matter of Kevin Hogan v Raymond Kelly		2958	2004 NYSlipOp 01249
Carriage Development v U.S. Underwriters Insurance Company		2959	2004 NYSlipOp 01250
HSBC Bank USA v 85th Estates Company		2960	2004 NYSlipOp 01251
Andrew Mundo Inc. v Liberty Mutual Group		2961	2004 NYSlipOp 01252
People v Tonya Jenkins		2968	2004 NYSlipOp 01253
Pari Dulac v Robert Dabrowski		2969	2004 NYSlipOp 01254
Hon Fui Hui v East Broadway Mall		2972	2004 NYSlipOp 01255
People v Umar Delgado		2973	2004 NYSlipOp 01256
Matter of Xavier Jamal C. v Sherley C.		2974	2004 NYSlipOp 01257
People v Miriam Barona		2976	2004 NYSlipOp 01258
Rosa J. Moreira v City of New York		2977	2004 NYSlipOp 01259
Matter of Joanne Telleria v New York City Housing Authority		2978	2004 NYSlipOp 01260
Jay Fox v Carmen Fusco		2980	2004 NYSlipOp 01261
William L. Kollbeck v 417 FS Realty		2981	2004 NYSlipOp 01262
Matter of KSLM-Columbus Apartments v New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal	Nardelli		2004 NYSlipOp 01263
Matter of KSLM-Columbus Apartments v New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal		2080	2004 NYSlipOp 01264

**Cases Decided February 24, 2004**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Ray Smith v John S. Girolamo		2265N	2004 NYSlipOp 01196
Earl Brustowsky v Abraham Herbst		2714	2004 NYSlipOp 01197
People v Francisco Batista		2931	2004 NYSlipOp 01198
Edward J. Ryan v Alex R. Sobolevsky		2932	2004 NYSlipOp 01199
People v Mitchell Sullivan		2933	2004 NYSlipOp 01200
Matter of Michelle T.S. v Andrea S.		2934	2004 NYSlipOp 01201
People v Michael Graham		2936	2004 NYSlipOp 01202
People v Lamont White		2937	2004 NYSlipOp 01203
Rafael Chevere v Hyundai Motor Company		2938	2004 NYSlipOp 01204
Matter of Jericho Pub v New York State Liquor Authority		2940	2004 NYSlipOp 01205
Matter of Allan H. Hoehl v Raymond W. Kelly		2941	2004 NYSlipOp 01206
Karen Henry v Leeds & Morelli		2945	2004 NYSlipOp 01207
George Novo v William H. Roth		2947N	2004 NYSlipOp 01208
Russ DiBello v Joel Salkowitz		2028N	2004 NYSlipOp 01209
Cindy Adams v Hilton Hotels		2296	2004 NYSlipOp 01210
People v Marquis Phillips		2409	2004 NYSlipOp 01211
People v Thomas Downey		2414	2004 NYSlipOp 01212
Timothy Cahill v Triborough Bridge and Tunnel Authority		2470	2004 NYSlipOp 01213
Mary Oliver Warden v Dr. Robert Orlandi		2524	2004 NYSlipOp 01214
Ernest Riddick v City of New York		2596	2004 NYSlipOp 01215
Guillermo Orellano v 29 East 37th Street Realty Corp.		2661	2004 NYSlipOp 01216
J.A. v S.A.		2666N	2004 NYSlipOp 01217
People v Malik Flye		2911	2004 NYSlipOp 01218
People v Walter Atkins		2913	2004 NYSlipOp 01219
People v Ray Walters		2915	2004 NYSlipOp 01220
People v Jose Morel		2916	2004 NYSlipOp 01221
People v Darnell Price		2917	2004 NYSlipOp 01222
Edward Arthur Nieman v Sears, Roebuck and Co.		2919	2004 NYSlipOp 01223
Rachel Bridge Corp. v Avi Dishi		2923	2004 NYSlipOp 01224
Madison Hudson Associates v Joseph Neumann		2928	2004 NYSlipOp 01225
Lisa Marcus v Barry Marcus		2929N	2004 NYSlipOp 01226
Matter of Calvin Burnett v Hon. Bernard J. Fried		3037	2004 NYSlipOp 01227
Leonard J. Levenson v Jonathan Lippman	Rosenberger		2004 NYSlipOp 01228
Leonard J. Levenson v Jonathan Lippman		2465	2004 NYSlipOp 01229
Matter of Anand M.S. Gujral	Per Curiam	M-5370	2004 NYSlipOp 01230

**Cases Decided February 19, 2004**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Jonathan A. Weinstein	Per Curiam	M-3614	2004 NYSlipOp 01231

**Cases Decided February 19, 2004**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Andrew S. Marks	Per Curiam	M-5280	2004 NYSlipOp 01100
Carlingford Center Point Associates v MR Realty Associates		588	2004 NYSlipOp 01101
People v Derek Andrades		1948	2004 NYSlipOp 01102
Matter of Venus Melody R.-W. v Amy W.		2670	2004 NYSlipOp 01103
People v Kurtis Tyler		2854	2004 NYSlipOp 01104
People v Ariel Nazario		1592	2004 NYSlipOp 01105
243-249 Holding Co. v Felipe Infante		1898	2004 NYSlipOp 01106
Matter of 427 West 51st Street Owners Corp. v Division of Housing and Community Renewal		2082	2004 NYSlipOp 01107
Wells Fargo Bank Minnesota v Mark F. Cohn		2209	2004 NYSlipOp 01108
Sybil Kane v Estia Greek Restaurant		2609	2004 NYSlipOp 01109
Elba Ramirez v Ryer Ave		2759	2004 NYSlipOp 01110
New Street Ice Company v New York City Department of Business Services		2771	2004 NYSlipOp 01111
People v Troy Steinbergin		2869	2004 NYSlipOp 01112
Dani Michaels, Inc. v Design 2000, N.Y.		2870	2004 NYSlipOp 01113
People v Michael Parker		2871	2004 NYSlipOp 01114
Bobby Bradley v Soundview Healthcenter		2872	2004 NYSlipOp 01115
People v Meshach Valladi		2874	2004 NYSlipOp 01116
People v Eddie Guzman		2875	2004 NYSlipOp 01117
People v Anthony Valez		2877	2004 NYSlipOp 01118
Million Gold Realty Co. v S.E. & K. Corp.		2879	2004 NYSlipOp 01119
Express Industries Group v City of New York		2881	2004 NYSlipOp 01120
PM Contracting Company v 32 AA Associates		2882	2004 NYSlipOp 01121
Warren Murphy v Columbia University		2883	2004 NYSlipOp 01122
Carmen Garcia v Delgado Travel Agency		2884	2004 NYSlipOp 01123
Ledya Rosado v Home Depot		2886	2004 NYSlipOp 01124
Matter of Tyrone G. v Lucretia S.		2889	2004 NYSlipOp 01125
People v Trevis Funches		2891	2004 NYSlipOp 01126
Joseph Iocovello v Weingrad & Weingrad		2893	2004 NYSlipOp 01127
Matter of Tyreese H.		2894	2004 NYSlipOp 01128
People v Anthony Jones		2895	2004 NYSlipOp 01129
Teresa Esteva v John Catsimatidis		2896	2004 NYSlipOp 01130
Coney Island Resorts v City of New York		2897	2004 NYSlipOp 01131
People v Robert Perez		2899	2004 NYSlipOp 01132
Matter of Melvyn Kaufman v Tudor Realty Services Corp.		2900	2004 NYSlipOp 01133
Matter of Roderick T. v Sheryl Robin J.		2901	2004 NYSlipOp 01134
Antonio Fernandes v Equitable Life Assurance Society of the United States		2902	2004 NYSlipOp 01135
Luis Carmo v Clifford Lazzaro		2903	2004 NYSlipOp 01136
Matter of Jose Miguel Olivido Rodriguez v Robert T. Johnson		2904	2004 NYSlipOp 01137
Matter of Accessible Development Corp. v Ocean House Center		2906	2004 NYSlipOp 01138
People v Phil Vincente		2909	2004 NYSlipOp 01139
Monique Finn v City of New York		2910N	2004 NYSlipOp 01140
J.P. Doumak, Inc. v Westgate Financial Corp.	Friedman	97-98	2004 NYSlipOp 01141
J.P. Doumak, Inc. v Westgate Financial Corp.		97	2004 NYSlipOp 01142

**Cases Decided February 17, 2004**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Joseph Burden	Per Curiam	M-4577	2004 NYSlipOp 00965
Tamika Ortiz v Abdul Momin Biswas		2506	2004 NYSlipOp 00966
George Pampafikos v Harpreet K. Wander		2513N	2004 NYSlipOp 00967
Matter of Maurier M.		2787	2004 NYSlipOp 00968
People v Isaac Torres		2852	2004 NYSlipOp 00969
Andres Heredia v Two Kings, Inc.		2853	2004 NYSlipOp 00970
People v Donette Mathews		2855	2004 NYSlipOp 00971
Matter of Jonathan M.		2856	2004 NYSlipOp 00972
People v Andy Bradley		2857	2004 NYSlipOp 00973
People v Jamel Brown		2858	2004 NYSlipOp 00974
People v Jose Gonzalez		2859	2004 NYSlipOp 00975
Matter of Eliazar G.		2860	2004 NYSlipOp 00976
Barbara Grant v City of New York		2861	2004 NYSlipOp 00977
Matter of Mark Weir v William Bratton		2862	2004 NYSlipOp 00978
John Buric v Howard Safir		2865	2004 NYSlipOp 00979
Lula Williams v White Castle Systems		2867	2004 NYSlipOp 00980
Matter of Newsday, Inc. v Robert D. Morgenthau		2868N	2004 NYSlipOp 00981
People v Leon Smith		1270	2004 NYSlipOp 00982
27th Street Associates v Richard Lehrer		1933	2004 NYSlipOp 00983
Cavit Sarigul v New York Telephone Company		2086	2004 NYSlipOp 00984
People v Mark Watson		2370	2004 NYSlipOp 00985
Rachell M. Gober v Ira L. Gober		2486	2004 NYSlipOp 00986
Matter of Gregory Hopp v Raymond Kelly		2767	2004 NYSlipOp 00987
M.L. Weiner & Associates v S.I.K. Sales Corp.		2807	2004 NYSlipOp 00988
Paul Katsehtes v Nora G. Braunstein		2820	2004 NYSlipOp 00989
Deborah Buchholz v Trump 767 Fifth Avenue		2824	2004 NYSlipOp 00990
Matter of Gilbert Lau v Hon. William J. Davis		2930	2004 NYSlipOp 00991

**Cases Decided February 10, 2004**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Karene A. Freeman	Per Curiam	M-5131	2004 NYSlipOp 00590
M&R Construction Corp. v IDI Construction Company		2178	2004 NYSlipOp 00591
People v Eveth Rivera		2669	2004 NYSlipOp 00592
People v Esteban Perez		2811	2004 NYSlipOp 00593
People v Jody Parrella		2812	2004 NYSlipOp 00594
People v John Russo		2814	2004 NYSlipOp 00595
People v Noah Formey		2815	2004 NYSlipOp 00596
People v Dorian Diaz		2816	2004 NYSlipOp 00597
Matter of Aristotle G v Francisco G.		2817	2004 NYSlipOp 00598
Matter of Hawthorne Gardens v State of New York Division of Housing and Community Renewal		2818	2004 NYSlipOp 00599
Carlos Elias v Albert J. Linder		2821	2004 NYSlipOp 00600
Matter of Donelle Thomas M. v Linda Ann M.		2825	2004 NYSlipOp 00601
Carmen Guttierez v Lenox Hill Neighborhood House		2827	2004 NYSlipOp 00602
People v Terence Vaughn		2828	2004 NYSlipOp 00603
Lillian Herrera v David Matlin		2829N	2004 NYSlipOp 00604
People v Adolphus Cooper		2830	2004 NYSlipOp 00605
TOA Construction Co. v Michael Tsitsires		2831	2004 NYSlipOp 00606
People v Efran George		2832	2004 NYSlipOp 00607
Fazel Rahman v City of New York		2833	2004 NYSlipOp 00608
People v Reginald Fayton		2835	2004 NYSlipOp 00609
People v Hiussam Gauthier		2836	2004 NYSlipOp 00610
People v Hector Resto		2837	2004 NYSlipOp 00611
George Kralik v 239 East 79th Street Owners Corp.		2839	2004 NYSlipOp 00612
Matter of Robert Ripp v Raymond W. Kelly		2840	2004 NYSlipOp 00613
Claudia Zeitz Poster v Harold S. Poster		2841	2004 NYSlipOp 00614
Yunus Zaveri v Rosy Blue, Inc.		2843	2004 NYSlipOp 00615
Carlos Rodriguez v Terence Cardinal Cooke Health Care Center		2844	2004 NYSlipOp 00616
RST Corporation v Eva Meyerhoff		2846	2004 NYSlipOp 00617
Louis Dreyfus Energy Corp. v MG Refining and Marketing		2847	2004 NYSlipOp 00618
Arelis Guzman v Schiavone Construction Co.		2850	2004 NYSlipOp 00619
Lehman Brothers Holdings v Andrew Penson		2851N	2004 NYSlipOp 00620
Leonia Bank v Pentti J.K. Kouri	Sullivan	1608	2004 NYSlipOp 00621
Leonia Bank v Pentti J.K. Kouri		1608	2004 NYSlipOp 00622

**Cases Decided February 5, 2004**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Simon Haberman v David S. Singer	Ellerin	2262	2004 NYSlipOp 00586
People v Dwaine Gilley		2803	2004 NYSlipOp 00587
People v Maurice Mayo		2789	2004 NYSlipOp 00588
Simon Haberman v David S. Singer		2262	2004 NYSlipOp 00589

**Cases Decided February 5, 2004**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Cecilio Figueroa	2780	2004 NYSlipOp 00571
Avery B. Seavey v James Kendrick Trucking	2781	2004 NYSlipOp 00572
People v Robert Delgado	2783	2004 NYSlipOp 00573
People v Jack Retkinski	2785	2004 NYSlipOp 00574
Matter of Gustavo C.	2786	2004 NYSlipOp 00575
People v Robert Reed	2788	2004 NYSlipOp 00576
Matter of Ali S. Kandemir v New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal	2790	2004 NYSlipOp 00577
3636 Greystone Owners v Greystone Building	2794N	2004 NYSlipOp 00578
People v Anthony Forte	2795	2004 NYSlipOp 00579
City of New York v Seabury Construction Corporation	2796	2004 NYSlipOp 00580
People v Jerome Mack	2799	2004 NYSlipOp 00581
People v Juan Nunez	2800	2004 NYSlipOp 00582
People v Judi Olivo	2801	2004 NYSlipOp 00583
Rudy Markard v Lawrence H. Bloom	2805	2004 NYSlipOp 00584
Aurele Henry, Jr. v Con Edison	2806	2004 NYSlipOp 00585

**Cases Decided February 3, 2004**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Jose Fernandez v Otis Elevator Company		2174	2004 NYSlipOp 00468
Anthony Pommells v Francisco R. Perez		1624	2004 NYSlipOp 00469
Lawrence A. Omansky v Robert Gurland		1725	2004 NYSlipOp 00470
Richard Ogust v 451 Broome Street Corp		1442	2004 NYSlipOp 00471
Sheila Leopold Hooke v Speedy Auto Center		1815	2004 NYSlipOp 00472
Matter of Bank of New York v UBS Warburg LLC		2381N	2004 NYSlipOp 00473
People v Jack Morris		2766	2004 NYSlipOp 00474
People v Christian Rosario		2768	2004 NYSlipOp 00475
People v Roy Clendinen		2769	2004 NYSlipOp 00476
Matter of Theodore Guzy v Tino Hernandez		2774	2004 NYSlipOp 00477
Matter of Angel G.		2775	2004 NYSlipOp 00478
Matter of Robert M. Morgenthau v Hon. John A.K. Bradley		2779	2004 NYSlipOp 00479
Jose Fernandez v Otis Elevator Company	Mazzarelli	2174	2004 NYSlipOp 00480