skip to main content
Law Reporting
Bureau Thomas J.K. Smith, State Reporter

Appellate Division, First Department Decisions

Current Month Archived Cases Motions

May 2004 Archive

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

Cases Decided May 27, 2004
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Huma H. Kamgar Per Curiam M-5738 2004 NYSlipOp 04228
Matter of Tockwotten Associates v New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal 2943 2004 NYSlipOp 04229
Suminatra Raghu v 24 Realty Co. 3415 2004 NYSlipOp 04230
Diane Cummin v Arch Cummin 3043 2004 NYSlipOp 04231
City of New York v Phoenix Sound 3120N 2004 NYSlipOp 04232
People v Peter Arzu 3473 2004 NYSlipOp 04233
NYCTL 1998-1 Trust and Bank of New York v Jacob Rabinowitz 3513N 2004 NYSlipOp 04234
Michael S. Horwitz v 1025 Fifth Avenue 3546 2004 NYSlipOp 04235
People v Anthony Downing 3740 2004 NYSlipOp 04236
People v Anthony Calabrese 3741 2004 NYSlipOp 04237
Daniel Pelli v William A. Connors 3742 2004 NYSlipOp 04238
Peggy Randall v Montefiore Medical Center 3743 2004 NYSlipOp 04239
People v Kenneth Schnabel 3746 2004 NYSlipOp 04240
People v Gil Lewis 3747 2004 NYSlipOp 04241
People v Ramon Antegua 3750 2004 NYSlipOp 04242
Eleanor S. Martin v Marsha Feltingoff 3751N 2004 NYSlipOp 04243
Matter of Elvin Lebron v Hon. Joan Madden 3752 2004 NYSlipOp 04244
People v Petros Babi 3753 2004 NYSlipOp 04245
People v Anthony Beaker 3754 2004 NYSlipOp 04246
Jose L. DeJesus v Henry Todaro 3758 2004 NYSlipOp 04247
Yvette Medley v Simon B. Lopez 3759 2004 NYSlipOp 04248
Home Insurance Company v Leprino Foods Company 3760 2004 NYSlipOp 04249
Stevan Barbul v Mahrokh Songhorian 3761 2004 NYSlipOp 04250
People v Michael Rivera 3764 2004 NYSlipOp 04251
People v Devrol Palmer 3765 2004 NYSlipOp 04252
People v Shelton Forbes 3766 2004 NYSlipOp 04253
Frances Hotkins v New York City Transit Authority 3767 2004 NYSlipOp 04254
John Timmins v Tishman Construction Corp. Sullivan 2004 NYSlipOp 04255
John Timmins v Tishman Construction Corp. 2864 2004 NYSlipOp 04256
Cases Decided May 25, 2004
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Frederick C. Hayes Per Curiam M-34 2004 NYSlipOp 04109
Mary McGarvey v Bank of New York 3221 2004 NYSlipOp 04110
Trocom Construction Corp. v Consolidated Edison Company of New York 3233 2004 NYSlipOp 04111
Coty Inc. v Anchor Construction 2772 2004 NYSlipOp 04112
Putman High Yield Trust v Bank of New York 2991 2004 NYSlipOp 04113
Russell C. Clark v New York City Housing Authority 3049 2004 NYSlipOp 04114
Becker Parkin Dental Supply Company v 450 Westside Partners 3384 2004 NYSlipOp 04115
People v Daniel Griffen 3709 2004 NYSlipOp 04116
Matter of Stefan Papasoff v Elizabeth C. Cockrell 3713 2004 NYSlipOp 04117
People v Charles Sanders 3716 2004 NYSlipOp 04118
Tereze Marku v Moore Capital Management 3719 2004 NYSlipOp 04119
People v Milton Powell 3720 2004 NYSlipOp 04120
People v Uranius Torrence 3721 2004 NYSlipOp 04121
Henry Galloway v New York City Police Department 3723N 2004 NYSlipOp 04122
People v Jerrold Schwartz 3724 2004 NYSlipOp 04123
People v Shaun Harris 3725 2004 NYSlipOp 04124
People v Tarelle Davis 3726 2004 NYSlipOp 04125
George Billis v Leighton, Leighton & Leighton 3727 2004 NYSlipOp 04126
People v Javier Rodriguez 3728 2004 NYSlipOp 04127
Noemi Velazquez v State of New York 3730 2004 NYSlipOp 04128
Matter of Sergio Schwartzman v Tax Appeals Tribunal of the City of New York 3731 2004 NYSlipOp 04129
Susana Parra v 167 Allison Meat Corp. 3733 2004 NYSlipOp 04130
Elias Rasabi v Shlomo Rasabi 3734 2004 NYSlipOp 04131
People v Danny Ramos 3737 2004 NYSlipOp 04132
Ira E. Garr v Sara Kinberg 3739 2004 NYSlipOp 04133
1029 Sixth, LLC v Riniv Corporation Saxe 31843185 2004 NYSlipOp 04134
1029 Sixth, LLC v Riniv Corporation 3182 2004 NYSlipOp 04135
Cases Decided May 20, 2004
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Wilens and Baker Per Curiam. M-5132 2004 NYSlipOp 04077
People v Persio Marte 3679 2004 NYSlipOp 04078
Tower Building Restoration v 20 East 9th Street Apartment Corp. 3680 2004 NYSlipOp 04079
Juan Garcia v Tribeca Broadway Associates 3685 2004 NYSlipOp 04080
Raymond Lanzot v Ivy Kenneth Blecher 3686 2004 NYSlipOp 04081
People v Tony Campbell 3688 2004 NYSlipOp 04082
People v Kim Jaime 3689 2004 NYSlipOp 04083
People v Jose Rivera 3690 2004 NYSlipOp 04084
Broadwell America v Bram Will El LLC 3692 2004 NYSlipOp 04085
West Gate House v 860-870 Realty 3694N 2004 NYSlipOp 04086
Ergonomic Systems Philippines v CCS International 2015 2004 NYSlipOp 04087
People v Joseph Bentley 2539 2004 NYSlipOp 04088
Richard Laecca v New York University 2642 2004 NYSlipOp 04089
Consumers Union of U.S. v State of New York 2925 2004 NYSlipOp 04090
EBC I, Inc. v Goldman Sachs & Co. 3308 2004 NYSlipOp 04091
Sarasota, Inc. v Tina Finkel 3318 2004 NYSlipOp 04092
Public Service Mutual Insurance Company v Harlen Housing Associates 3443 2004 NYSlipOp 04093
Matter of Alfreida B. Kenny 3500 2004 NYSlipOp 04094
Matter of Curtis Phillips v Steven Barrett 3662 2004 NYSlipOp 04095
ASKL Enterprises v NYNEX Long Distance Company 3695 2004 NYSlipOp 04096
People v William Pastranos 3697 2004 NYSlipOp 04097
Josef Fried v Marcello Valenzano 3698 2004 NYSlipOp 04098
HSA Residential Mortgage Services of Texas v Stewart Title Guaranty Co. 3699 2004 NYSlipOp 04099
People v Ranier Velasquez 3700 2004 NYSlipOp 04100
Commissioners of the State Insurance Fund v Fortune Interior Dismantling Corp 3702 2004 NYSlipOp 04101
People v Lorenzo Saldana 3703 2004 NYSlipOp 04102
People v Stephen Roberts 3704 2004 NYSlipOp 04103
Matter of Constance Saddlier v Teachers' Retirement System of the City of New York 3706 2004 NYSlipOp 04104
People v Gerald Charles 3707 2004 NYSlipOp 04105
Alfredo Colon Aviles v San Rafael Cooperativa de Ahorro y Credito 3708N 2004 NYSlipOp 04106
Siobhan McDermott v Coffee Beanery Nardelli 2004 NYSlipOp 04107
Siobhan McDermott v Coffee Beanery 2982 2004 NYSlipOp 04108
Cases Decided May 18, 2004
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Michael L. Goldman Per Curiam M-51 2004 NYSlipOp 03930
Matthew Iacobazzo v Saeed Asad 3368 2004 NYSlipOp 03931
Matter of Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corporation v Stanley M. Chesley 1284N 2004 NYSlipOp 03932
Cointech, Inc. v Masaryk Towers Corporation 2749 2004 NYSlipOp 03933
Lynda Mandell v Jerome Karr 2963 2004 NYSlipOp 03934
Matter of Shelton Johnson v New York City Department of Environmental Protection 3073 2004 NYSlipOp 03935
Matter of Louis Maldarelli v John Doherty 3074 2004 NYSlipOp 03936
Abraham Berkowitz v Fischbein, Badillo, Wagner & Harding 3192 2004 NYSlipOp 03937
Matter of Commissioner of Social Services v Luis Alonso G. 3292 2004 NYSlipOp 03938
People v Darren Carter 3647 2004 NYSlipOp 03939
Chelsea Piers Management v Diana Chapin 3648 2004 NYSlipOp 03940
Matter of Matthew D. v Yolanda M. 3649 2004 NYSlipOp 03941
Matter of Gabriel Acosta v Raymond Kelly 3650 2004 NYSlipOp 03942
People v Anthony Costanzo 3651 2004 NYSlipOp 03943
New York City Housing Authority v United States Underwriters Insurance Company 3654 2004 NYSlipOp 03944
Darwein Cruz v City of New York 3656 2004 NYSlipOp 03945
People v Miguel Pizzaro 3657 2004 NYSlipOp 03946
People v Stanley Johnson 3661 2004 NYSlipOp 03947
People v Fred Charlemagne 3663 2004 NYSlipOp 03948
Bakerhood, Inc. v S.E.&K. Corp. 3664 2004 NYSlipOp 03949
People v John Rogoski 3665 2004 NYSlipOp 03950
V.C. Vitanza Sons v New York City Housing Authority 3666 2004 NYSlipOp 03951
Matter of Antoine M. v Antoine Latief M. 3667 2004 NYSlipOp 03952
Franklin High Income Trust v APP Global 3668 2004 NYSlipOp 03953
Mark A. Taylor v New York University Medical Center 3671 2004 NYSlipOp 03954
Woodhaven Associates v Public Service Mutual Insurance Company 3672 2004 NYSlipOp 03955
Ernest Dickens v New York City Transit Authority 3673 2004 NYSlipOp 03956
People v Raju Katharu 3676 2004 NYSlipOp 03957
Martin Jackson v JoAnn Jackson 3678N 2004 NYSlipOp 03958
Shin-Etsu Chemical Co. v ICICI Bank Limited Sullivan 3033 2004 NYSlipOp 03959
Shin-Etsu Chemical Co. v ICICI Bank Limited 3033 2004 NYSlipOp 03960
Cases Decided May 13, 2004
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Ronald F. Harnisch Per Curiam M-5323 2004 NYSlipOp 03895
Matter of John Creegan v Board of Trustees of the New York City Police Pension Fund Article II 2607 2004 NYSlipOp 03896
People v Albert Cruz 2770 2004 NYSlipOp 03897
Matter of Jemrock Realty Company v New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal 2773 2004 NYSlipOp 03898
Fanny Grullon v Edric M. Henry 3288N 2004 NYSlipOp 03899
Daisy Torres v Prime Realty Services 3614 2004 NYSlipOp 03900
People v Carl Williams 3615 2004 NYSlipOp 03901
Washington Leon v Ione Mendonca 3616 2004 NYSlipOp 03902
Steven Boulukos v 213 P.A.S. 3617 2004 NYSlipOp 03903
Matter of Dameon M. 3621 2004 NYSlipOp 03904
Miriam Marrero v Ryder Truck Rental 3622 2004 NYSlipOp 03905
People v Anonymous 3623 2004 NYSlipOp 03906
Gloria Perez v Martha Lochard 3624 2004 NYSlipOp 03907
People v Robert Lopez 3626 2004 NYSlipOp 03908
People v Kevin Smith 3627 2004 NYSlipOp 03909
Lucia Warck-Meister v Diana Lowenstein Fine Arts 3628 2004 NYSlipOp 03910
SNS Bank v Citibank 3629 2004 NYSlipOp 03911
Elizabeth Jackson v Bronx Lebanon Hospital Center 3630N 2004 NYSlipOp 03912
People v Richie Rivera 3631 2004 NYSlipOp 03913
People v Richie Rivera 3632 2004 NYSlipOp 03914
Matter of Alexis S.D. v Wanda C. 3634 2004 NYSlipOp 03915
Roundabout Theatre Company v Continental Casualty Company 3635 2004 NYSlipOp 03916
People v Joe Jones 3636 2004 NYSlipOp 03917
Janet Callaghan v Susan Goldsweig 3637 2004 NYSlipOp 03918
1205-15 First Avenue Associates v Daniel McDonough 3638 2004 NYSlipOp 03919
Paul M. Deutschman v First Manufacturing Co. 3639 2004 NYSlipOp 03920
Thomas Hassett v Celtic Holdings 3640 2004 NYSlipOp 03921
People v Rolando Segarra 3641 2004 NYSlipOp 03922
People v Alberto Benvenutti 3643 2004 NYSlipOp 03923
Michael Small v Brodsky 42 3645N 2004 NYSlipOp 03924
EMC Iron Works v Regal Construction Corp. 3646N 2004 NYSlipOp 03925
David Solomon v Bell Atlantic Corporation Ellerin 2949 2004 NYSlipOp 03926
David Solomon v Bell Atlantic Corporation 2949 2004 NYSlipOp 03927
Cases Decided May 11, 2004
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
Patrick Cavanaugh v 4518 Associates 1864 2004 NYSlipOp 03721
Matter of Allstate Insurance Company v Henry Rapp 3430N 2004 NYSlipOp 03722
Ricky Barnes v New York Mercantile Exchange 1961 2004 NYSlipOp 03723
Henry Rosario v Universal Truck & Trailer Service 2243 2004 NYSlipOp 03724
People v Anonymous 3445 2004 NYSlipOp 03725
Wazir Khan v Duane Reade 3496 2004 NYSlipOp 03726
Cynthia Jacobs v Continuum Health Partners 3562 2004 NYSlipOp 03727
People v Melvin Howard 3579 2004 NYSlipOp 03728
People v Eduardo Glenn 3580 2004 NYSlipOp 03729
MJM Advertising v Panasonic Industrial Company 3581 2004 NYSlipOp 03730
180 Water Street Associates v Lehman Brothers Holdings 3583 2004 NYSlipOp 03731
Matter of 442 West 45th Street v New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal 3584 2004 NYSlipOp 03732
Barbara A. Simon v 160 West End Avenue Corporation 3585 2004 NYSlipOp 03733
Hawthorne Group v RRE Ventures 3587 2004 NYSlipOp 03734
People v Julio Almonte 3590 2004 NYSlipOp 03735
People v Victor Aguilar 3591 2004 NYSlipOp 03736
Madelaine Stein v Gary Steven Stein 3593N 2004 NYSlipOp 03737
Matter of Amstel Recycling & Concrete Corp. v City of New York 3597 2004 NYSlipOp 03738
People v Francisco Urena 3598 2004 NYSlipOp 03739
People v Rosheen Gill 3599 2004 NYSlipOp 03740
People v Rosheen Gill 3600 2004 NYSlipOp 03741
Ronald Holmes v New York City Housing Authority 3601 2004 NYSlipOp 03742
Patricia A. Hutchinson v Zurich Scudder Investments 3603 2004 NYSlipOp 03743
Matter of Warner Bros. Records v PPX Enterprises 3605 2004 NYSlipOp 03744
American Building Maintenance Co. of New York v Solow Management Corporation 3607 2004 NYSlipOp 03745
People v Lonell Logan 3609 2004 NYSlipOp 03746
People v William Franklin 3610 2004 NYSlipOp 03747
Gina P. v Stephen S. 3612N 2004 NYSlipOp 03748
Matter of Zaffar Bugtti Per Curiam M-106 2004 NYSlipOp 03749
Patrick Cavanaugh v 4518 Associates Sullivan 1865 2004 NYSlipOp 03750
Cases Decided May 6, 2004
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
Carolyn Brown v C. Francois Jean Achy 839 2004 NYSlipOp 03666
People v Ladale Kennedy 2617 2004 NYSlipOp 03667
Cherell Taylor v Gin Cabel Trucking 3419 2004 NYSlipOp 03668
People v Robert Lee Blaine 1756 2004 NYSlipOp 03669
Stapleton Studios v City of New York 2202 2004 NYSlipOp 03670
People v John Valentine 3291 2004 NYSlipOp 03671
MTB Bank-in-Liquidation v Lloyd's Underwriters of Directors, Officers and Company Liability Policy #FD024940O 3300 2004 NYSlipOp 03672
Gregory V. Serio v Public Service Mutual Insurance Company 3301 2004 NYSlipOp 03673
Mercedes Arjona v Jose L. Calcano 3461 2004 NYSlipOp 03674
People v Woodrow Wheeler 3539 2004 NYSlipOp 03675
People v Ronald Mask 3540 2004 NYSlipOp 03676
Matter of 301 West 111th Owners v Division of Housing and Community Renewal 3541 2004 NYSlipOp 03677
Big Apple Ice Cream v City of New York 3542 2004 NYSlipOp 03678
Kelly Krechmer v Mark Mintzer 3545 2004 NYSlipOp 03679
Matter of New York City Asbestos Litigation 3547 2004 NYSlipOp 03680
People v Aziz Harden 3549 2004 NYSlipOp 03681
People v Damien Gilbert 3550 2004 NYSlipOp 03682
People v Deshawn Sealy 3551 2004 NYSlipOp 03683
People v Pedro Santiago 3552 2004 NYSlipOp 03684
Leila Green v New York City Housing Authority 3553 2004 NYSlipOp 03685
George Noroian v Steven E. Cohen 3555 2004 NYSlipOp 03686
Sea Trade Maritime Corporation v Hellenic Mutual War Risks Association (Bermuda) Limited 3556N 2004 NYSlipOp 03687
People v Marvin Gray 3558 2004 NYSlipOp 03688
Jennifer Taveras v City of New York 3559 2004 NYSlipOp 03689
People v Robert Williams 3560 2004 NYSlipOp 03690
Matter of Alberto DeP. v Enriqueta DeP. 3561 2004 NYSlipOp 03691
Greater New York Mutual Insurance Company v White Knight Restoration 3563 2004 NYSlipOp 03692
Rosemary Kindelan v Society of the New York Hospital 3566 2004 NYSlipOp 03693
Xao He Lu v Steven B. Ross 3567 2004 NYSlipOp 03694
Rosar Realty Corporation v Paul E. Leavin 3568 2004 NYSlipOp 03695
People v Robert Searcy 3569 2004 NYSlipOp 03696
Matter of Tiffany R. v Olga Iris C. 3570N 2004 NYSlipOp 03697
People v Jamal Jordan 3571 2004 NYSlipOp 03698
People v Vladimir Nunez 3572 2004 NYSlipOp 03699
People v Dennis Coleman 3573 2004 NYSlipOp 03700
Matter of Stacey P. 3574 2004 NYSlipOp 03701
Lana & Samer, Inc. v Eric Goldfine 3576 2004 NYSlipOp 03702
Carolyn Brown v C. Francois Jean Achy Marlow 2004 NYSlipOp 03703
Cases Decided May 4, 2004
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
Ruby Emanuel v Sheridan Transportation Corp. 2598 2004 NYSlipOp 03604
Allison Clifford v Marion Turkel 1522 2004 NYSlipOp 03605
Phyllis Toote v Canada Dry Bottling Company of New York 1414 2004 NYSlipOp 03606
Matter of Eileen Consilvio v Alan L. 3058 2004 NYSlipOp 03607
People v Felipe Ortiz 3199 2004 NYSlipOp 03608
David Z. Inc. v Timur on Fifth Avenue 3386N 2004 NYSlipOp 03609
Edwin Padilla v Avrum A. Freelund 3397 2004 NYSlipOp 03610
People v Ramon Nunez-Garcia 3515 2004 NYSlipOp 03611
People v Edmond Pena 3519 2004 NYSlipOp 03612
Matter of Dumaka Hershey Jones D. v Dawn J. 3520 2004 NYSlipOp 03613
1711 LLC v 231 West 54th Corp. 3521 2004 NYSlipOp 03614
Rogelio Lopez v Mendon Leasing Corporation 3523 2004 NYSlipOp 03615
Norman Annenberg v Antonio Calvo 3525 2004 NYSlipOp 03616
Kenneth Thompson v Mount Sinai Hospital 3526 2004 NYSlipOp 03617
People v Miguel Valderas 3527 2004 NYSlipOp 03618
People v Jerome Smith 3528 2004 NYSlipOp 03619
James Wilson v City of New York 3529 2004 NYSlipOp 03620
People v Patricia Feerick 3533 2004 NYSlipOp 03621
Ana Jiminez v City of New York 3534 2004 NYSlipOp 03622
Ira Blutreich v Amalgamated Dwellings 3536N 2004 NYSlipOp 03623
S.M. Pires v Frota Oceanica Brasileira, S.A. 3537N 2004 NYSlipOp 03624
Matter of Michael Goodson v Hon. Charles Solomon 3595 2004 NYSlipOp 03625
Matter of Downtown Enterprise v Hon. Herman Cahn 3596 2004 NYSlipOp 03626
Ruby Emanuel v Sheridan Transportation Corp. Tom 2004 NYSlipOp 03627

Links to or from other sites do not signify endorsement or relationship with them.