skip to main content
Law Reporting
Bureau Thomas J.K. Smith, State Reporter

Appellate Division, First Department Decisions

Current Month Archived Cases Motions

January 2005 Archive

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

Cases Decided January 27, 2005
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
Cordula Bartha v Nicholas Bartha 4601 2005 NY Slip Op 00450
People v Victor Holman 4358 2005 NY Slip Op 00451
Frank Schneider v Mohamed Diallo 5075 2005 NY Slip Op 00452
People v Omar Radwan 5189 2005 NY Slip Op 00453
People v Oscar Ferrero 5191 2005 NY Slip Op 00454
People v Richard Weir 5194 2005 NY Slip Op 00455
Frank DeRosa v Ann Valentino 5195 2005 NY Slip Op 00456
People v Essie Grant 5197 2005 NY Slip Op 00457
People v Deloris Williams 5200 2005 NY Slip Op 00458
People v Victor Delgado 5201 2005 NY Slip Op 00459
Madison Hudson Associates, LLC v Joseph Neumann 5203 2005 NY Slip Op 00460
David Realty and Funding, LLC v Second Avenue Realty Co. 5204N 2005 NY Slip Op 00461
Lisa Lippiello v Benjamin D. Fein 3729 2005 NY Slip Op 00462
Bernadette Gotay v David Breitbart 4003 2005 NY Slip Op 00463
Matter of Letisha D. 4339 2005 NY Slip Op 00464
Sharon Bowie v 2377 Creston Realty, LLC 4404 2005 NY Slip Op 00465
Matter of Constantinos Papaioannou v Raymond Kelly 4408 2005 NY Slip Op 00466
People v Daniel Johnson 4496 2005 NY Slip Op 00467
Brian Bellamy v City of New York 4936 2005 NY Slip Op 00468
HSD/Horton Associates v United States Fire Insurance Company 5147 2005 NY Slip Op 00469
People v Dukieen Wilson 5205 2005 NY Slip Op 00470
Alberto Gonzalez v 310 West 38th, L.L.C. 5206 2005 NY Slip Op 00471
People v John Red 5207 2005 NY Slip Op 00472
Matter of Saqib A. 5208 2005 NY Slip Op 00473
Eutelia Corina Cortez v Manhattan Bible Church 5209 2005 NY Slip Op 00474
People v Anthony Blackman 5211 2005 NY Slip Op 00475
Matter of Lashawn Shanteal R. v Lisa Ann W. 5212 2005 NY Slip Op 00476
Sean Schron v New York University 5214 2005 NY Slip Op 00477
People v Mauro Menard 5215 2005 NY Slip Op 00478
People v Anonymous 5217 2005 NY Slip Op 00479
Alex Bistricer v Singer, Bienenstock, Zamansky, Ogele & Selengut, LLP 5218 2005 NY Slip Op 00480
Cordula Bartha v Nicholas Bartha Saxe 4601 2005 NY Slip Op 00481
Cases Decided January 25, 2005
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
Kenneth Memminger v Nelson Gardens, Inc. 5188N 2005 NY Slip Op 00337
Edwin George v New York City Health and Hospitals Corporation 5077 2005 NY Slip Op 00338
David Diaz v Elrac, Inc. 4184 2005 NY Slip Op 00339
Tony Silvester v Time-Warner, Inc. 4546 2005 NY Slip Op 00340
Donna Lippett v Education Alliance 4733 2005 NY Slip Op 00341
Clive Medland v Third Avenue Cosmetics, Inc. 4895 2005 NY Slip Op 00342
Jorge Luis Cruz v Board of Managers of 140 West End Avenue Condominium 5105 2005 NY Slip Op 00343
Sarah Thorne v Elizabeth S. Grubman 5117N 2005 NY Slip Op 00344
People v Nathan Williams 5155 2005 NY Slip Op 00345
People v Charles Johnson 5156 2005 NY Slip Op 00346
Elliott Associates, L.P. v Dennis C. Hayes 5157 2005 NY Slip Op 00347
Leida Cruz v Isabella Geriatric Center, Inc. 5159 2005 NY Slip Op 00348
Matter of Crystal Antoinette C. v Eric L. 5160 2005 NY Slip Op 00349
Mona Demo v James Badie 5161 2005 NY Slip Op 00350
People v Joseph Oliver 5167 2005 NY Slip Op 00351
Matter of Keith Budd v Raymond W. Kelly 5169 2005 NY Slip Op 00352
People v Jerrold Dowdey 5173 2005 NY Slip Op 00353
Matter of Cecile Schoberle v New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal 5174 2005 NY Slip Op 00354
People v Gregory Kellam 5175 2005 NY Slip Op 00355
People v John Vasquez 5177 2005 NY Slip Op 00356
Robin Mitnick v Jesse Rosenthal 5182 2005 NY Slip Op 00357
People v Tariq Wyatt 5183 2005 NY Slip Op 00358
People v Alex Arrington 5186 2005 NY Slip Op 00359
Cases Decided January 20, 2005
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Lydia Wagner v Walter Drobenko 5154N 2005 NY Slip Op 00316
Matter of Taisha R. v Nancy J. 5118 2005 NY Slip Op 00317
People v Lloyd Fishman 5119 2005 NY Slip Op 00318
People v Nestor Santos 5120 2005 NY Slip Op 00319
People v Darnell Macon 5121 2005 NY Slip Op 00320
People v Peter Melendez 5124 2005 NY Slip Op 00321
Creditanstalt Investment Bank AG v Chadbourne & Parke LLP 5125 2005 NY Slip Op 00322
Mark Finkelstein v Warner Music Group Inc. 5127 2005 NY Slip Op 00323
Abdul Karim v Pervaiz Malik 5128 2005 NY Slip Op 00324
Micah Goldberg v Enterprise Rent-A-Car Company 5130 2005 NY Slip Op 00325
Shirley A. Brown v Aames Capital Corporation 5131 2005 NY Slip Op 00326
Matter of Phoenix Insurance Company v Chris Kantlis 5134N 2005 NY Slip Op 00327
People v Andre Walton 5140 2005 NY Slip Op 00328
People v Gregory Galberth 5141 2005 NY Slip Op 00329
People v Jesse Green 5142 2005 NY Slip Op 00330
People v Frederick Robinson 5143 2005 NY Slip Op 00331
Matter of John Albert Steel v Department for the Aging of the City of New York 5145 2005 NY Slip Op 00332
Ivan Jarvis v Crotona Associates, LLC 5146 2005 NY Slip Op 00333
Federal Express Corporation v Federal Jeans, Inc. 5148 2005 NY Slip Op 00334
Philip Spages v Gary Null Associates, Inc. 5149 2005 NY Slip Op 00335
Kien Gian-Nguyen v Sy Jimmy-Nguyen 5153N 2005 NY Slip Op 00336
Cases Decided January 18, 2005
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
Michael Melnitzky v Elizabeth Besobrasow 5113 2005 NY Slip Op 00218
Lori Brandwein v New York City Transit Authority 4924 2005 NY Slip Op 00219
Jose Fonseca v Manhattan and Bronx Surface Transit Operating Authority 4838 2005 NY Slip Op 00220
Joseph B. Zinn v Jefferson Towers, Inc. 4938 2005 NY Slip Op 00221
Elizabeth Martinez v "John" Tsung 4960N 2005 NY Slip Op 00222
Matter of Michael V. Blumenthal v Daniel Kingsford 5026N 2005 NY Slip Op 00223
Enrique Torres v Morse Diesel International, Inc. 5048 2005 NY Slip Op 00224
People v Darryl Whitley 5102 2005 NY Slip Op 00225
People v Anthony Patrick 5103 2005 NY Slip Op 00226
Matter of Adrienne Sumowicz v Raymond Kelly 5104 2005 NY Slip Op 00227
Matter of Jordane John C. v John W. 5106 2005 NY Slip Op 00228
People v Ravi Chankar 5108 2005 NY Slip Op 00229
People v Jenny Marte 5111 2005 NY Slip Op 00230
John Mascola v City University of New York 5112 2005 NY Slip Op 00231
Cases Decided January 13, 2005
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
Travelers Insurance Company v Rita Abelow 5099N 2005 NY Slip Op 00201
American Transit Insurance Company v Lincoln Hinds 4447 2005 NY Slip Op 00202
Elvetta Fulton v Allstate Insurance Company 4616 2005 NY Slip Op 00203
Martha Nunez v Teresa Fernandez 4919 2005 NY Slip Op 00204
1199 Housing Corporation v International Fidelity Insurance Company 4552 2005 NY Slip Op 00205
Transportation Consultants of America, Inc. v American Home Assurance Company 4586 2005 NY Slip Op 00206
41 Fifth Owners Corp. v 41 Fifth Equities Corp. 4807 2005 NY Slip Op 00207
Iris Ahmed v City of New York 4837 2005 NY Slip Op 00208
People v Agim Mulosmanaj 5081 2005 NY Slip Op 00209
People v Elvis Castillo 5082 2005 NY Slip Op 00210
People v Salvatore DiBenedetto 5084 2005 NY Slip Op 00211
People v Wesley Kelly 5086 2005 NY Slip Op 00212
Elvin Vincenty v Cincinnati Incorporated 5089 2005 NY Slip Op 00213
People v Tyrone Carmichael 5091 2005 NY Slip Op 00214
Matter of "Baby Girl" Q. v Damaira Q. 5092 2005 NY Slip Op 00215
Matter of Steven Truglio v Raymond W. Kelly 5093 2005 NY Slip Op 00216
Matter of Lawana Robinson v Richard T. Roberts 5094 2005 NY Slip Op 00217
Cases Decided January 11, 2005
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
Estelle Gilson v Metropolitan Opera 4346 2005 NY Slip Op 00099
Liliane Unanue v Ira Leon Rennert 4652 2005 NY Slip Op 00100
Matthew Ocasio v New York City Health and Hospitals Corporation (Morrisania Neighborhood Family Care Center) 4766N 2005 NY Slip Op 00101
People v Joseph Hernandez 5060 2005 NY Slip Op 00102
People v Rodney Bailey 2005 NY Slip Op 00103
People v Todd Griffin 5063 2005 NY Slip Op 00104
People v Ronald Scrima 5064 2005 NY Slip Op 00105
Jay H. Schafrann v N.V. Famka, Inc. 5068 2005 NY Slip Op 00106
People v Willie Dunn 5070 2005 NY Slip Op 00107
Pennsylvania Building Company v Raymond A. Schaub 5073 2005 NY Slip Op 00108
LaSalle Bank National Association v Nomura Asset Capital Corporation 5074 2005 NY Slip Op 00109
Matter of David Bernfeld 5076 2005 NY Slip Op 00110
Jarmin Wilson v Sherman Terrace Cooperative, Inc. 5078N 2005 NY Slip Op 00111
Roger Miller v Ian Polow 3039 2005 NY Slip Op 00112
People v James Barrett 4457 2005 NY Slip Op 00113
Matter of Michael Cambridge v Commissioner of the New York City Department of Buildings 4472 2005 NY Slip Op 00114
Anthony Bonanno v Port Authority of New York and New Jersey 4945 2005 NY Slip Op 00115
Estelle Gilson v Metropolitan Opera Saxe 4346 2005 NY Slip Op 00116
Cases Decided January 6, 2005
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Barry W. Horowitz Per Curiam M-4891 2005 NY Slip Op 00073
Wanda Irizarry v Ashar Realty Corp. 4615 2005 NY Slip Op 00074
Edward Bazinet v Galina Kluge 4647 2005 NY Slip Op 00075
Albert Stephenson v Hotel Employees and Restaurant Employees Union Local 100 of the AFL-CIO 2640 2005 NY Slip Op 00076
Jaime Harlock v Scott Kay, Inc. 4663 2005 NY Slip Op 00077
Colgate Scaffolding & Equipment Corp. v York Hunter City Services, Inc. 4808N 2005 NY Slip Op 00078
People v Ricardo Ford 4831 2005 NY Slip Op 00079
Lawrence J. Lynch, Jr. v City of New York 4833 2005 NY Slip Op 00080
Gloria Chandler Ramsey v New York University Hospital Center 4954N 2005 NY Slip Op 00081
People v Harby Mayor 5043 2005 NY Slip Op 00082
Matter of William Tizer 5044 2005 NY Slip Op 00083
People v Elvert Kitching 5045 2005 NY Slip Op 00084
People v Augustin Flores 5046 2005 NY Slip Op 00085
Wujin Nanxiashu Secant Factory v Ti-Well International Corporation 5047 2005 NY Slip Op 00086
Juan Gorbea v Eli Uriel 5049 2005 NY Slip Op 00087
People v Legrand Jones 5050 2005 NY Slip Op 00088
Matter of Chyna J. 5051 2005 NY Slip Op 00089
Leonard Weitz v Thomas Bruderman 5052 2005 NY Slip Op 00090
Michael F. Zinn v Salomon, Smith Barney, Inc. 5053 2005 NY Slip Op 00091
People v Dwayne Brown 5055 2005 NY Slip Op 00092
Geraldine Pauling v Orentreich Medical Group 5057 2005 NY Slip Op 00093
Matter of Bombardier Transportation (Holdings) USA, Inc. v Telephonics Corporation 5058N 2005 NY Slip Op 00094
Lisa Marcus v Barry Marcus 5059N 2005 NY Slip Op 00095
Barry & Sons, Inc. v Instinct Productions LLC Sullivan 4714 2005 NY Slip Op 00096
Barry & Sons, Inc. v Instinct Productions LLC 4714 2005 NY Slip Op 00097
Matter of Karene A. Freeman Per Curiam M-4339 2005 NY Slip Op 00098
Cases Decided January 4, 2005
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Michael S. Wantuck Per Curiam M-4149 2005 NY Slip Op 00001
Tomasz Bielecki v City of New York 3982 2005 NY Slip Op 00002
Peter J. DaPuzzo v Reznick Fedder & Silverman 4062 2005 NY Slip Op 00003
Christina Aguinaga v 342 East 72nd Street Corporation 4444 2005 NY Slip Op 00004
Cellular Telephone Company v 210 East 86th Street Corp. 4402 2005 NY Slip Op 00005
Heskel's West 38th Street Corp. v Gotham Construction Company LLC 4418N 2005 NY Slip Op 00006
People v Carmen Feliciano 4459 2005 NY Slip Op 00007
3405 Putnam Realty Corp. v Chubb Custom Insurance Company 4595 2005 NY Slip Op 00008
Gary Fragin v Fleet Bank 4610 2005 NY Slip Op 00009
Jamaica Recycling Corp. v City of New York 4795 2005 NY Slip Op 00010
People v Angel Santos 4951 2005 NY Slip Op 00011
People v Amin Kallamni 5028 2005 NY Slip Op 00012
People v Anthony Brown 5029 2005 NY Slip Op 00013
People v Shadee Sheppard 5031 2005 NY Slip Op 00014
People v Miguel Ramirez 5032 2005 NY Slip Op 00015
Matter of New York Foundation for Senior Citizens, Guardian Services, Inc. v Ronald Schoon 5033 2005 NY Slip Op 00016
Matter of Dominique P. v Leonard P. 5034 2005 NY Slip Op 00017
Scott D. Quinlan v New York City Fire Department 5035 2005 NY Slip Op 00018
People v Terence Wells 5037 2005 NY Slip Op 00019
Eleanor L. Simms v APA Truck Leasing Corporation 5038 2005 NY Slip Op 00020
Matter of Ricardo Copello v Raymond W. Kelly 5040 2005 NY Slip Op 00021
Audley Bent v Albert S. Jackson Marlow 3935 2005 NY Slip Op 00022
Audley Bent v Albert S. Jackson 3935 2005 NY Slip Op 00023
Samuel Thompson v Naimatullah Abbasi Marlow 4505 2005 NY Slip Op 00024
Samuel Thompson v Naimatullah Abbasi 4505 2005 NY Slip Op 00025

Links to or from other sites do not signify endorsement or relationship with them.