Appellate Division, First Department Decisions

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

**Cases Decided March 30, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Morgan Barrington Financial Services v Juana M. Roman		7920	2006 NY Slip Op 02432
Matter of Samuel Tiggs v Hon. Daniel P. FitzGerald		8217	2006 NY Slip Op 02433
People v Miguel Guerrero		6899	2006 NY Slip Op 02434
People v Willis White		6987	2006 NY Slip Op 02435
Matter of Michelle Verdell v Lincoln Amsterdam House, Inc.		7445	2006 NY Slip Op 02436
Shinko Foods, Inc. v 483 Columbus L&M Corp.		7541	2006 NY Slip Op 02437
JRK Franklin, LLC v 164 East 87th Street LLC		7571	2006 NY Slip Op 02438
Rosemarie Aronitz v PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP		7614	2006 NY Slip Op 02439
Phillip Gayle v Port Authority of New York and New Jersey		7847	2006 NY Slip Op 02440
Clifford Aymes v City of New York		7880	2006 NY Slip Op 02441
Delia Reyes v La Ronda Cocktail Lounge		8005	2006 NY Slip Op 02442
Matter of Ann De Jong v Kings County Hospital Center		8099	2006 NY Slip Op 02443
People v Jose Garcia		8181	2006 NY Slip Op 02444
People v Isaac O. McLaurin		8182	2006 NY Slip Op 02445
People of the State of New York ex rel. Robert Nieves v Warden, Rikers Island Correctional Facility		8185	2006 NY Slip Op 02446
People v Christopher McCoy		8187	2006 NY Slip Op 02447
William E. Garner v Francis Tong		8188	2006 NY Slip Op 02448
People v Phillip Peyton		8190	2006 NY Slip Op 02449
Matter of Stefanie Judith N. v Melissa N.		8191	2006 NY Slip Op 02450
State of New York ex rel. Stephen J. Harkavy v Eileen Consilvio	Malone	7675	2006 NY Slip Op 02451
Matter of Erik Veski	Per Curiam	M-3810	2006 NY Slip Op 02452

**Cases Decided March 28, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Cyril Kendall		6885	2006 NY Slip Op 02292
45 East 89th Street Condominium v Arrow Restoration, Inc.		7792	2006 NY Slip Op 02293
Anonymous v Anonymous		6874N	2006 NY Slip Op 02294
Luis Rivera v JRJ Land Property Corp.		6923	2006 NY Slip Op 02295
People v Peter Butler		7286	2006 NY Slip Op 02296
People v Demetrius Davis		8156	2006 NY Slip Op 02297
Matter of 160 Bleecker Street Owners, Inc. v Division of Housing and Community Renewal		8157	2006 NY Slip Op 02298
Donna Davin v JMAM, LLC		8158	2006 NY Slip Op 02299
People v Rafael Delossantos		8159	2006 NY Slip Op 02300
People v Samuel Jenkins		8160	2006 NY Slip Op 02301
Holy Cross Polish National Catholic Church of New York, Inc. v Louis T. Milazzo		8163	2006 NY Slip Op 02302
People v Edward Wilkins		8164	2006 NY Slip Op 02303
Sylvia Mendel v Henry Phipps Plaza West, Inc.		8165	2006 NY Slip Op 02304
Matter of Darnell J.		8166	2006 NY Slip Op 02305
Rafael Diaz Gutierrez v L. Raul Bernard		8168N	2006 NY Slip Op 02306
People v William Escalera		8169	2006 NY Slip Op 02307
People v Curtis Jackson		8172	2006 NY Slip Op 02308
People v Andy Saenz		8173	2006 NY Slip Op 02309
Matter of Patrolmen's Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc. v City of New York		8174	2006 NY Slip Op 02310
People v Robert Lynn		8176	2006 NY Slip Op 02311
Matter of Sammie C.		8178	2006 NY Slip Op 02312
People v James Kirk		8179	2006 NY Slip Op 02313
Elizabeth Hazlett v Massud Rahbar		8180N	2006 NY Slip Op 02314
People v Michael Garcia	Catterson	7863	2006 NY Slip Op 02315

**Cases Decided March 23, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
West 111th Street Rehab Associates v Jonathan Poole		7861	2006 NY Slip Op 02271
Marcus Telesford v Raymond W. Patterson		7911	2006 NY Slip Op 02272
Matter of Carroll E. Haynes v New York City Department of Homeless Services		7922	2006 NY Slip Op 02273
Seong Sil Kim v New York City Transit Authority		6303	2006 NY Slip Op 02274
People v Beato Ozuna		6986	2006 NY Slip Op 02275
Matter of Mark Diefenthaler v Joel I. Klein		7935	2006 NY Slip Op 02276
People v Joseph Trilli		8141	2006 NY Slip Op 02277
People v Mayra Collado		8143	2006 NY Slip Op 02278
Diana Brown v Transcare New York, Inc.		8145	2006 NY Slip Op 02279
Donald Orenstein v Irvin Brum		8146	2006 NY Slip Op 02280
People v Amaury Caseresherrera		8147	2006 NY Slip Op 02281
Valentina Gafner v Chelsea Piers, L.P.		8149	2006 NY Slip Op 02282
People v Claude Danton		8154	2006 NY Slip Op 02283
Campaign for Fiscal Equity, Inc. v State of New York	Buckley	6915	2006 NY Slip Op 02284
Matter of Israel G. Grossman	Per Curiam	M-198	2006 NY Slip Op 02285
Matter of Steven A. Kirschenbaum	Per Curiam	M-1125	2006 NY Slip Op 02286
Matter of Joseph J. Pierini	Per Curiam	M-81	2006 NY Slip Op 02287

**Cases Decided March 21, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Herbert Moskowitz v Lorraine Jorden		7989	2006 NY Slip Op 02124
People v Jose Garcia		8125	2006 NY Slip Op 02125
Tadeusz Olszewski v Park Terrace Gardens, Inc.		8126	2006 NY Slip Op 02126
People v Diego Santana		8129	2006 NY Slip Op 02127
Matter of Carlos Ortiz v Manhattan Psychiatric Center		8130	2006 NY Slip Op 02128
Matter of Billy G.		8131	2006 NY Slip Op 02129
People v Luis Rivera		8132	2006 NY Slip Op 02130
People v Ameil Alston		8138	2006 NY Slip Op 02131
People v Simon Jimenez		8139	2006 NY Slip Op 02132
Harold R. Eskenazi v Jules W. Schapiro		6734	2006 NY Slip Op 02133
Bessie Taylor v Nicholas Terrigno		7757	2006 NY Slip Op 02134
Kory Kleinberg v City of New York		7950	2006 NY Slip Op 02135
People v Kamran Feili		8113	2006 NY Slip Op 02136
Jermeal Escourse v City of New York		8115	2006 NY Slip Op 02137
Matter of Antonio G.		8118	2006 NY Slip Op 02138
Henry Fajemirokun v Dresdner Kleinwort Wasserstein Limited		8119	2006 NY Slip Op 02139
People v William Johnson		8120	2006 NY Slip Op 02140
Manhattan Real Estate Equities Group LLC v Pine Equity NY, Inc.		8121	2006 NY Slip Op 02141
People v Jose Marrero		8122	2006 NY Slip Op 02142
Juanita Rojas v City of New York		8123N	2006 NY Slip Op 02143
Anna Pezhman v City of New York	Saxe	7766	2006 NY Slip Op 02144

**Cases Decided March 16, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Ann Styles v General Motors Corporation		4070	2006 NY Slip Op 01889
People v Albert Jonson		7487	2006 NY Slip Op 01890
Matter of Felix Santiago v Glenn S. Goord		7914	2006 NY Slip Op 01891
Debbie Mostel v Bennett Mostel		7923	2006 NY Slip Op 01892
CLP Leasing Company, LP v Maurice N. Nessen		7555	2006 NY Slip Op 01893
People v Miguelito Hernandez		8084	2006 NY Slip Op 01894
People v Alan Thomas		8087	2006 NY Slip Op 01895
People v Benjamin Thomas		8088	2006 NY Slip Op 01896
Matter of Vivian Pena v New York City Civil Service Commission		8089	2006 NY Slip Op 01897
Matter of Vincent Leone v Raymond W. Kelly		8091	2006 NY Slip Op 01898
People v Melvin McMillian		8092	2006 NY Slip Op 01899
Matter of Yoshita Lazelle Childress v Augustin Winston Samuel		8094	2006 NY Slip Op 01900
Matter of United Services Automobile Association v Asiclo Joseph Melendez		8095N	2006 NY Slip Op 01901
People v Anthony Reid		8098	2006 NY Slip Op 01902
Matter of Jo-Fra Properties, Inc.		8100	2006 NY Slip Op 01903
People v Raul Garcia		8101	2006 NY Slip Op 01904
Mue Maksuti v Best Italian Pizza		8103	2006 NY Slip Op 01905
People v Ian Abelson		8104	2006 NY Slip Op 01906
Matter of Gary Williams v New York City Transit Authority		8106	2006 NY Slip Op 01907
People v Herbert Long		8107	2006 NY Slip Op 01908
Lucille Altschuler v Gramatan Management, Inc.		8109	2006 NY Slip Op 01909
Monserrate Soto v Trinity Morris Corp.		8110N	2006 NY Slip Op 01910
Sonia Pimentel v Citibank, N.A.	Catterson	6244	2006 NY Slip Op 01911
Matter of James P. Cornelio	Per Curiam	M-77	2006 NY Slip Op 01912
Matter of Michael L. Marley	Per Curiam	M-3028	2006 NY Slip Op 01913

**Cases Decided March 14, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Frontier Insurance Company		7916	2006 NY Slip Op 01729
Patricia E. Soviero v Carroll Group International, Inc.		7984	2006 NY Slip Op 01730
People v Ramon Grullon		8071	2006 NY Slip Op 01731
Josephine Estey-Dorsa v Teodoro Chavez		8072	2006 NY Slip Op 01732
People v Carlos Rodriguez		8075	2006 NY Slip Op 01733
People v Antonio Stump		8076	2006 NY Slip Op 01734
Kaback Enterprises, Inc. v Time, Inc.		8077	2006 NY Slip Op 01735
Sharon D. Levy v Deer Trans. Corp.		8079	2006 NY Slip Op 01736
People v Jamel Winston		8080	2006 NY Slip Op 01737
Jacquelyn Wolfer v 184 Fifth Ave. LLC		8082N	2006 NY Slip Op 01738
Louis C. Fiabane v Ryan S. Goldstein		8083N	2006 NY Slip Op 01739
Beatrice Morris v State of New York		7354N	2006 NY Slip Op 01740
Jose Offman v Harjinder Singh		7732	2006 NY Slip Op 01741
People v George Gonzalez		8061	2006 NY Slip Op 01742
Sharipzhan Mukhutdinov v Edward R. Finch		8063	2006 NY Slip Op 01743
People v Leighton Nelson		8065	2006 NY Slip Op 01744
Borress & Borress LLC v CSJ LLC		8070N	2006 NY Slip Op 01745
Matter of Thomas A. Bolan	Per Curiam	M-5196	2006 NY Slip Op 01746
Madison Avenue Leasehold, LLC v Madison Bentley Associates LLC	Tom	6902	2006 NY Slip Op 01747
Matter of Anthony J. Fauci	Per Curiam	M-1277	2006 NY Slip Op 01748

**Cases Decided March 9, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Lloyd Putter v City of New York		7871N	2006 NY Slip Op 01704
Credit Suisse First Boston v Utrecht-America Finance Co.		7924N	2006 NY Slip Op 01705
People v Elaine Marchetti		8030	2006 NY Slip Op 01706
People v Eulogio Ortiz		8033	2006 NY Slip Op 01707
People v Alexy Rosario		8034	2006 NY Slip Op 01708
Matter of Bethelite Community Church v Department of Environmental Protection of the City of New York		8036	2006 NY Slip Op 01709
People v Woodrow Flemming		8037	2006 NY Slip Op 01710
Homeside Development Corp. v Dassa Brill LLC		8038	2006 NY Slip Op 01711
John Bowman v George Di Placidi		8040	2006 NY Slip Op 01712
Esther Krivda v Liberty Lines Express, Inc.		8042N	2006 NY Slip Op 01713
Edward S. Freiman v Sheila E. Horn		8043N	2006 NY Slip Op 01714
Carey & Associates v Rudi Ernst		6296	2006 NY Slip Op 01715
Irene B. Smith v IG Second Generation Partners, L.P.		7803	2006 NY Slip Op 01716
Matter of Lovely Uddin v New York City Transit Authority		7833N	2006 NY Slip Op 01717
Patria Lantigua v 700 W. 178th Street Associates, LLC		7886	2006 NY Slip Op 01718
People v Caesar Friendly		8044	2006 NY Slip Op 01719
Dianne Delia v 1586 Northern Blvd. Co., LLC		8045	2006 NY Slip Op 01720
People v Karl Pennington		8046	2006 NY Slip Op 01721
Matter of Lorraine Folks v New York City Housing Authority		8047	2006 NY Slip Op 01722
People v Mitchell Overton		8049	2006 NY Slip Op 01723
Rizwan Gondal v New York Stock Exchange		8051	2006 NY Slip Op 01724
Vincent P. Iannazzo v Milton E. Stanson		8052	2006 NY Slip Op 01725
Victor Alexander v State of New York		8055	2006 NY Slip Op 01726
Devendra Kumar Jain v New York City Transit Authority		8056N	2006 NY Slip Op 01727
Matter of Bobby Tran v Kwok Bun Lee	Nardelli		2006 NY Slip Op 01728

**Cases Decided March 7, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Lylene Flores v Dezreen Leslie		6656	2006 NY Slip Op 01534
Bertone Commissioning v City of New York		7377N	2006 NY Slip Op 01535
Bluebird Partners, L.P. v First Fidelity Bank, N.A.		7041	2006 NY Slip Op 01536
CitiFinancial Company (DE) v Sidney C. McKinney		7631	2006 NY Slip Op 01537
Alfreda Mazurek v Metropolitan Museum of Art		7698	2006 NY Slip Op 01538
People v Juan Hernandez		7998	2006 NY Slip Op 01539
People v Morris Evans		7999	2006 NY Slip Op 01540
A.J. Clarke Real Estate Corp. v Milton Meyers		8000	2006 NY Slip Op 01541
Baystone Equities, Inc. v Jacqueline Handel-Harbour		8001	2006 NY Slip Op 01542
People v Robert Miles		8002	2006 NY Slip Op 01543
People v Claudius Green		8003	2006 NY Slip Op 01544
Ira Rogovin v Philomena Rogovin		8007	2006 NY Slip Op 01545
Matter of June W.		8008	2006 NY Slip Op 01546
Ruta & Soulios, LLP v Litman & Litman, P.C.		8013N	2006 NY Slip Op 01547
People v Christopher Ellis		8014	2006 NY Slip Op 01548
Dean Ross v Sam Wu		8015	2006 NY Slip Op 01549
People v Freddie Johnson		8016	2006 NY Slip Op 01550
Evelyn Castillo v Kittatinny Canoes Corp.		8017	2006 NY Slip Op 01551
Matter of Car Barn Flats Residents Association v New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal		8018	2006 NY Slip Op 01552
Perry Blackmon v Charles M. Dinstuhl		8019	2006 NY Slip Op 01553
People v Michael Smith		8020	2006 NY Slip Op 01554
Afua Afriye Opetubo v Ahmed A. Opetubo		8022	2006 NY Slip Op 01555
Frances Ferrara v JetBlue Airways Corporation		8023	2006 NY Slip Op 01556
People v Deszon Moore		8024	2006 NY Slip Op 01557
People v Carlos Lemus		8025	2006 NY Slip Op 01558
Matter of Ericka Stacey B. v Mary B.		8026	2006 NY Slip Op 01559
Countrywide Home Loans, Inc. v Debrah Keys		8027N	2006 NY Slip Op 01560
Carlton Long v Beverly Folasade Sowande		8028N	2006 NY Slip Op 01561
RBP of 400 W42 St., Inc. v 400 West 42nd Street Realty Associates		8029N	2006 NY Slip Op 01562
Matter of Eric A. Klein	Per Curiam	M-6559	2006 NY Slip Op 01563

**Cases Decided March 2, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Jaydee White		6553	2006 NY Slip Op 01509
People v DeJuan Berry		7980	2006 NY Slip Op 01510
People v Felix Mozo		7982	2006 NY Slip Op 01511
Michael Edelstein v Sheldon Farber		7983	2006 NY Slip Op 01512
People v Hassan Kemp		7985	2006 NY Slip Op 01513
Matter of Marshall H.		7986	2006 NY Slip Op 01514
People v Christopher Ramos		7987	2006 NY Slip Op 01515
Hambrecht & Quist Guaranty Finance, LLC v El Coronado Holdings, LLC		7988	2006 NY Slip Op 01516
People v Jeffrey Jiminez		7990	2006 NY Slip Op 01517
Juan Quezada v Jose G. Luque		7991	2006 NY Slip Op 01518
Norma McCown Bullard v St. Barnabas Hospital		7992	2006 NY Slip Op 01519
Decana Inc. v Spyro C. Contogouris		7995N	2006 NY Slip Op 01520
Antwerpse Diamantbank N.V. v Neal J. Nissel		7996N	2006 NY Slip Op 01521
Eugene F. Scherrer v Time Equities, Inc.		7997N	2006 NY Slip Op 01522
John Perez v Dhan Paul Singh		4689	2006 NY Slip Op 01523
Gap, Inc. v Fisher Development, Inc.		6682	2006 NY Slip Op 01524
Philippine American Lace Corp. v 236 West 40th Street Corp.		7079N	2006 NY Slip Op 01525
Thomas Nelson v Bryant Park Hotel		7254	2006 NY Slip Op 01526
People v Rene Lisojo		7502	2006 NY Slip Op 01527
Theatre Row Phase II Associates v H&I, Inc.		7545	2006 NY Slip Op 01528
Pier 59 Studios L.P. v Chelsea Piers L.P.		7581	2006 NY Slip Op 01529
Classic Leather, Inc. v Taylor & Katz Properties Ltd.		7673N	2006 NY Slip Op 01530
Milady Gomez v Kilsy Delacruz		7849	2006 NY Slip Op 01531
Nicholas Koechlin v Phillip J. Weintraub		7885	2006 NY Slip Op 01532
Matter of Edmund D. Kahn	Per Curiam	M-3135-A	2006 NY Slip Op 01533