Appellate Division, First Department Decisions

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

**Cases Decided February 28, 2023**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of 81st Realty Corp. v New York State Div. of Hous. & Community Renewal		Index No. 152358/22 Appeal No. 17409 Case No. 2022-04585	2023 NY Slip Op 01058
Resorts Group, Inc. v Cerberus Capital Mgt., L.P.		Index No. 653777/20 Appeal No. 17415 Case No. 2022-02152	2023 NY Slip Op 01071
Matter of Salton v Mazur		Index No. 100008/20 Appeal No. 17407 Case No. 2022-00750	2023 NY Slip Op 01070
S. G. v Harlem Vil. Academy Charter Sch.		Index No. 161238/17 Appeal No. 16959 Case No. 2022-02478	2023 NY Slip Op 01069
People v Cummings		Ind No. 1077/19 Appeal No. 17406 Case No. 2020-00805	2023 NY Slip Op 01068
People v Hernandez		Ind No. 939/16 Appeal No. 17413 Case No. 2018-1414	2023 NY Slip Op 01067
Oscar Blandi Salon, Inc. v Joseph E. Marx Co., Inc.		Index No. 153590/22 Appeal No. 17417 Case No. 2022-04919	2023 NY Slip Op 01066
NYCTL 1998-2 Trust v Bronx County Pub. Admr.		Index No. 300547/12E Appeal No. 17416 Case No. 2022-04164	2023 NY Slip Op 01065
My Size, Inc. v North Empire LLC		Index No. 653901/18 Appeal No. 17410 Case No. 2022-00707	2023 NY Slip Op 01064
Muslar v Hall	MENDEZ, J.	Index No. 160598/20 Appeal No. 17168 Case No. 2022-02128	2023 NY Slip Op 01063
Matter of Strage	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2022-04713 Case No. 2022-02056	2023 NY Slip Op 01062
Matter of Samuel J. J. v Sofia L. S.		Docket No. O-10959-19/19A Appeal No. 17408-17408A-17408B Case No. 2022-02828 2022-02830 2022-03788	2023 NY Slip Op 01061
Gomez v Cypser		Index No. 800366/22E Appeal No. 17419 Case No. 2022-04328	2023 NY Slip Op 01060
Applehole v Wyeth Ayerst Labs.		Index No. 105122/09 Appeal No. 17418 Case No. 2022-00788	2023 NY Slip Op 01059
228 W 72 LLC v 228A W. 72 LLC		Index No. 652601/21 Appeal No. 17411-17412 Case No. 2022-01655 2022-01657	2023 NY Slip Op 01057

**Cases Decided February 23, 2023**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of 2010 Powell, LLC v New York State Div. of Hous. & Community Renewal	Index No. 802395/21E Appeal No. 17263 Case No. 2022-00302	2023 NY Slip Op 01043
Solo Group LLC, Series 9 v Harris	Index No. 381387/08E Appeal No. 17395 Case No. 2022-03979	2023 NY Slip Op 01056
Webb v New York City Tr. Auth.	Index No. 27683/16E Appeal No. 17399 Case No. 2021-02147	2023 NY Slip Op 01055
People v Lopez	Ind. No. 2330/17 Appeal No. 17391 Case No. 2019-3579	2023 NY Slip Op 01054
People v Anderson	Ind. No. 3461/02, 2349/02, 2769/02 Appeal No. 17396 Case No. 2012-02056	2023 NY Slip Op 01053
Mendonca v Plaza Constr. LLC	Index No. 155011/19 Appeal No. 17277 Case No. 2021-02307	2023 NY Slip Op 01052
Lindsay v CG Maiden Member, LLC	Index No. 159454/17 Appeal No. 17392 Case No. 2022-03455	2023 NY Slip Op 01051
Franpo Realty, LLC v Power Furniture Inc.	Index No. 651022/20 Appeal No. 17405 Case No. 2022-01659	2023 NY Slip Op 01050
Fernandez v Bright Leasing Corp.	Index No. 26090-18E Appeal No. 17402-17403 Case No. 2022-02586, 2022-02770	2023 NY Slip Op 01049
Matter of Zion Zahmar Z.K.F. (Katrina F.)	Docket No. B-19301/18 Appeal No. 17393 Case No. 2022-02393	2023 NY Slip Op 01048
Contreras v Mall 1-Bay Plaza, LLC	Index No. 34407/20E Appeal No. 17398 Case No. 2022-03032	2023 NY Slip Op 01047
Matter of Bellet Constr. Co., Inc. v LaRocca	Index No. 152529/21 Appeal No. 17400-17401 Case No. 2022-00892, 2022-02196	2023 NY Slip Op 01046
Bax v InterEnergy Holdings	Index No. 650499/18 Appeal No. 17394 Case No. 2022-00107	2023 NY Slip Op 01045
Art Capital Bermuda Ltd. v Bank of N.T. Butterfield & Sons Ltd.	Index No. 650082/17 Appeal No. 17397 Case No. 2022-03147	2023 NY Slip Op 01044

**Cases Decided February 21, 2023**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
195E76 LLC v 197 E. 76th St., LLC		Index No. 152131/21 Appeal No. 17376 Case No. 2022-02120	2023 NY Slip Op 00940
Zucker Real Estate Corp. v Old Republic Natl. Tit. Ins. Co.		Index No. 657701/19 Appeal No. 17387 Case No. 2022-04880	2023 NY Slip Op 00973
Matter of Susan W. v Darren K.		Docket No. F-994-20/20A, F-994-20/20B Appeal No. 17361-17361A Case No. 2022-02308	2023 NY Slip Op 00972
True Gate Holding, Ltd. v Baroukhian		Index No. 850142/12 Appeal No. 17360 Case No. 2022-02377	2023 NY Slip Op 00971
Tower 570 Co., L.P. v Miller & Wrubel P.C.		Index No. 654658/18 Appeal No. 17384 Case No. 2022-02975	2023 NY Slip Op 00970
Strout v CF E 88 LLC		Index No. 161439/19 Appeal No. 17373 Case No. 2022-03107	2023 NY Slip Op 00969
Saporito v Branda		Index No. 155838/20 Appeal No. 17386 Case No. 2021-03724	2023 NY Slip Op 00968
Salvo v Greater N.Y. Mut. Ins. Co.		Index No. 657025/20 Appeal No. 17370-17371 Case No. 2021-03996, 2021-04713	2023 NY Slip Op 00967
Matter of Ryan v City of New York		Index No. 159251/21 Appeal No. 17365 Case No. 2022-04675	2023 NY Slip Op 00966
People v Johnson		Ind. No. 3380/16 Appeal No. 10156 Case No. 2022-00647	2023 NY Slip Op 00965
People v Requena		SCI No. 4126/19 Appeal No. 17383 Case No. 2020-01716	2023 NY Slip Op 00964
People v Aguirre		Ind. No. 351/18 Appeal No. 17366 Case No. 2019-2562	2023 NY Slip Op 00963
People v Anonymous		Ind. No. 4414/11 Appeal No. 17209 Case No. 2019-3419	2023 NY Slip Op 00962
People v Jones		Ind. No. 1129/18 Appeal No. 17359 Case No. 2019-05438	2023 NY Slip Op 00961
People v Bonilla		Ind. No. 832/15 Appeal No. 17375 Case No. 2018-2753	2023 NY Slip Op 00960
Partow v Van Owners Purch. Bur., Inc.		Index No. 29770/17E Appeal No. 17389 Case No. 2022-04599	2023 NY Slip Op 00959
Matter of Parking Expert, Inc. v City of New York		Index No. 157979/21 Appeal No. 17369 Case No. 2022-02564	2023 NY Slip Op 00958
Matter of O'Reilly v Board of Educ. of the City Sch. Dist. of the City of N.Y.		Index No. 161040/21, 160017/21, 160353/21, 161076/21 Appeal No. 16688-16689-16690-16691 Case No. 2022-00684, 2022-00949, 2022-01398, 2022-01703	2023 NY Slip Op 00957
Matter of Moreno	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2022-04475 Case No. 2016-00141	2023 NY Slip Op 00956
Matter of Lopez v New York State Off. of Children & Family Servs.		Index No. 150882/22 Appeal No. 17388 Case No. 2022-03070	2023 NY Slip Op 00955
Matter of LL 410 E. 78th St. LLC v Division of Hous. & Community Renewal		Index No. 159153/21 Appeal No. 17382 Case No. 2022-01875	2023 NY Slip Op 00954
Kramer-Wilson Co., Inc. v National Gen. Mgt. Corp.		Index No. 655243/21 Appeal No. 17368 Case No. 2022-02414	2023 NY Slip Op 00953
Matter of Maria G.T. (Maria T.)		Docket No. B-07680-19 Appeal No. 17377 Case No. 2022-00721	2023 NY Slip Op 00952
Francis v 3475 Third Ave. Owner Realty, LLC		Index No. 21991/18E Appeal No. 17385 Case No. 2022-03273	2023 NY Slip Op 00951
Florsheim v Marriott Intl., Inc.		Index No. 150063/20 Appeal No. 17372 Case No. 2022-04596	2023 NY Slip Op 00950
Booston LLC v 35 W. Realty Co., LLC		Index No. 654308/19 Appeal No. 17380-17381 Case No. 2022-03792, 2022-03794	2023 NY Slip Op 00949
DeJesus v 935 Bronx Riv. Ave., LLC		Index No. 23807/15E Appeal No. 17379 Case No. 2022-02590	2023 NY Slip Op 00948
De Paz v 4221 Broadway Owner LLC		Index No. 159720/19 Appeal No. 17367 Case No. 2022-02272	2023 NY Slip Op 00947
Matter of New York City Asbestos Litig.		Index No. 190190/19 Appeal No. 17378 Case No. 2022-02391	2023 NY Slip Op 00946
Matter of Clarke v Board of Educ. of the City Sch.		Index No. 160787/21, 160829/21, 160725/21, 160821/21 Appeal No. 16710-16711-16712-16713 Case No. 2022-01699, 2022-01700, 2022-01701, 2022-01702	2023 NY Slip Op 00945
Bossert v New York Univ. Langone Med. Ctr. Tisch Hosp.		Index No. 154578/16 Appeal No. 17364 Case No. 2022-03267	2023 NY Slip Op 00944
Matter of A.C. v New York State Div. of Hous. & Community Renewal		Index No. 150114/22 Appeal No. 17390 Case No. 2022-03853	2023 NY Slip Op 00943
50 E. 126th St. Realty LLC v Allard		Index No. 109284/05 Appeal No. 17362-17363 Case No. 2022-01062, 2022-01063	2023 NY Slip Op 00942
354 Chauncey Realty, LLC v Brownstone Agency, Inc.		Index No. 650202/20 Appeal No. 17374 Case No. 2022-01521	2023 NY Slip Op 00941

**Cases Decided February 16, 2023**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of 156 W. 15th St. Chelsea L.L.C. v City of New York	Index No. 153126/19 Appeal No. 17353 Case No. 2020-03263	2023 NY Slip Op 00923
Malan v FSJ Realty Group II LLC	Index No. 26484/15 Appeal No. 17346-17347 Case No. 2021-04057 2022-01492	2023 NY Slip Op 00939
Tycoon Constr. Corp. v New York City Hous. Auth.	Index No. 651471/18 Appeal No. 17352 Case No. 2022-00003	2023 NY Slip Op 00938
Summit Dev. Corp. v Hudson Meridian Constr. Group LLC	Index No. 650172/09 650755/09 650239/09 Appeal No. 17351 Case No. 2022-01277	2023 NY Slip Op 00937
Reape v NCRNC, LLC	Index No. 805403/16 Appeal No. 17225 Case No. 2022-03101	2023 NY Slip Op 00936
Prechtl v Trane U.S., Inc.	Index No. 159325/21 Appeal No. 17357 Case No. 2022-02285	2023 NY Slip Op 00935
People v Sainkitts	Ind No. 4432/18 5097/15 SCI No. 744/17 Appeal No. 17344 Case No. 2019-3861 2019-2569	2023 NY Slip Op 00934
People v Wisdom	Index No. 4884/15 Appeal No. 17350 Case No. 2019-2515	2023 NY Slip Op 00933
People v Bundy	Ind No. 4977/12 Appeal No. 17342 Case No. 2017-1550	2023 NY Slip Op 00932
People v Mason	Ind No. 4884/15 Appeal No. 17348-17349 Case No. 2018-2734 2018-02946	2023 NY Slip Op 00931
Matter of New York Civ. Liberties Union v New York City Dept. of Corr.	Index No. 159851/21 Appeal No. 17358 Case No. 2022-02467	2023 NY Slip Op 00930
Mesquite Cr. Wind LLC v Mars Wind, Inc.	Index No. 655535/21 Appeal No. 17355 Case No. 2022-04294	2023 NY Slip Op 00929
HAI-2, LLC v BlackRock Fin. Mgt., Inc.	Index No. 655756/18 Appeal No. 17356 Case No. 2022-04360	2023 NY Slip Op 00928
Matter of Nathaniel H. (Nathaniel H.--Dayalyn G.)	Docket No. NN3266/21 Appeal No. 17215-17215A Case No. 2022-00796	2023 NY Slip Op 00927
Giovacco v Graham	Index No. 156895/19 Appeal No. 17343 Case No. 2022-02536	2023 NY Slip Op 00926
Choudhry v Starbucks Corp.	Index No. 20393/16 Appeal No. 17354 Case No. 2021-04188	2023 NY Slip Op 00925
Burgos Caba v 587-91 Third Owner, LLC	Index No. 160171/18 595211/19 Appeal No. 17345 Case No. 2022-01557	2023 NY Slip Op 00924

**Cases Decided February 14, 2023**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Bigio v Gooding	Index No. 28327/20E Appeal No. 17319 Case No. 2021-03947	2023 NY Slip Op 00806
Zanani v Scott Seidler Family Trust	Index No. 156268/21 Appeal No. 17332 Case No. 2022-00388	2023 NY Slip Op 00836
Matter of Haoxuan X. (Chen X.)	Docket No. NN-03353/19 Appeal No. 17307 Case No. 2022-03200	2023 NY Slip Op 00835
SSP Springs, LLC v First Speciality Ins. Corp.	Index No. 652453/20 Appeal No. 17331 Case No. 2021-04060	2023 NY Slip Op 00834
Srivatsa v Rosetta Holdings LLC	Index No. 651476/21 Appeal No. 17308-17309 Case No. 2021-04106 2021-04107	2023 NY Slip Op 00833
Smartmatic USA Corp. v Fox Corp.	151136/21 Index No. 151136/21 Appeal No. 17049 Case No. 2022-01291	2023 NY Slip Op 00832
RTW Retailwinds, Inc. v Colucci & Umans	Index No. 150794/20 Appeal No. 17034 Case No. 2021-03076	2023 NY Slip Op 00831
Romano v New York City Tr. Auth.	Index No. 153015/14 Appeal No. 17310-17311-17312-17313-17314 Case No. 2022-02936, 2022-00023, 2022-00089, 2022-00087 2022-00074	2023 NY Slip Op 00830
Philips RS N. Am., LLC v Savara, Inc	Index No. 650269/21 Appeal No. 17317 Case No. 2022-03713	2023 NY Slip Op 00829
People v Simpson	Ind No. 2122/14 Appeal No. 16440 Case No. 2016-718	2023 NY Slip Op 00828
People v Johnson	Ind No. 856/16 Appeal No. 17147 Case No. 2019-1843	2023 NY Slip Op 00827
People v Soto	Ind No. 3975/19 Appeal No. 17327 Case No. 2022-02298	2023 NY Slip Op 00826
Matter of People of the State of New York v Trump	Index No. 451685/20 Appeal No. 17340 Case No. 2022-01812	2023 NY Slip Op 00825
People v Cruz	Ind No. 3387/18 Appeal No. 17316 Case No. 2020-01783	2023 NY Slip Op 00824
People v Reid	Ind No. 3884/14 0438/15 Appeal No. 17315 Case No. 2016-2618	2023 NY Slip Op 00823
People v Bailey	Ind No. 4485/16 Appeal No. 17305 Case No. 2019/04567	2023 NY Slip Op 00822
People v Soto	Ind No. 30117/15 Appeal No. 17333 Case No. 2018-565	2023 NY Slip Op 00821
People v Brown	Ind No. 994/18 Appeal No. 17322 Case No. 2021-01713	2023 NY Slip Op 00820
PCT Contr., LLC v Riggs Distler & Co., Inc.	Index No. 655278/18 Appeal No. 17335-17336-17337-17338 Case No. 2022-02280, 2022-02616, 2022-03259, 2022-04026	2023 NY Slip Op 00819
Odigie v Gateway Sec. Guard Servs., Inc.	Index No. 158218/18 Appeal No. 17321 Case No. 2022-01412	2023 NY Slip Op 00818
Menlo Energy Fla., LLC v Certain Underwriters at Lloyds London	Index No. 650271/14 Appeal No. 17326 Case No. 2022-01081	2023 NY Slip Op 00817
Maldonado v Liberty El. Corp.	Index No. 152395/17 595773/17 595370/18 595300/20 Appeal No. 17334 Case No. 2021-03160	2023 NY Slip Op 00816
Matter of Malia A. (Dwayne T. M.--Shaguira M. B.)	Docket No. NN-17856/17 NN-17857/17 Appeal No. 17325-17325A Case No. 2021-03766	2023 NY Slip Op 00815
Lazar v Mor	Index No. 654538/19 Appeal No. 17318 Case No. 2022-00503	2023 NY Slip Op 00814
Jonke v Foot Locker, Inc.	Index No. 111794/99 Appeal No. 17329 Case No. 2022-00567	2023 NY Slip Op 00813
Day v Serenity Pharms., LLC	Index No. 657373/19 Appeal No. 17341 Case No. 2022-04196	2023 NY Slip Op 00812
Ellis v JPMorgan Chase Bank N.A.	Index No. 156426/17 Appeal No. 17339 Case No. 2022-04107	2023 NY Slip Op 00811
Doumbia v Bamba	Index No. 4487/21 Appeal No. 17330 Case No. 2022-00981	2023 NY Slip Op 00810
Cordero v Kacinskis	Index No. 153843-16 Appeal No. 17306 Case No. 2022-00199	2023 NY Slip Op 00809
Connor v AMA Consulting Engrs. PC	Index No. 162524/14 595879/15 Appeal No. 17328 Case No. 2021-03038	2023 NY Slip Op 00808
Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's, London v Forty Seventh Fifth Co. LLC	Index No. 156417/18 Appeal No. 17323-17324 Case No. 2021-04300 2022-02816	2023 NY Slip Op 00807

**Cases Decided February 9, 2023**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Watkins	Ind. No. 2233/13 Appeal No. 16761 Case No. 2019-2535	2023 NY Slip Op 00742
Gjurashaj v ABM Indus. Groups, LLC	Index No. 153290/21 Appeal No. 17287 Case No. 2022-04463	2023 NY Slip Op 00753
Williams v Citigroup, Inc.	Index No. 650481/10 Appeal No. 17290 Case No. 2021-04291	2023 NY Slip Op 00752
Voss v City of New York	Index No. 156741/17 Appeal No. 17268 Case No. 2022-01070	2023 NY Slip Op 00751
T.W. v Phillip Bus Serv.	Index No. 28978/17E Appeal No. 17285 Case No. 2022-02058	2023 NY Slip Op 00750
Small v City of New York	Index No. 23325/03 Appeal No. 17296 Case No. 2021-00539	2023 NY Slip Op 00749
Scevola v New York Sports & Joints Orthopaedic Specialists PLLC	Index No. 154788/18 Appeal No. 17280 Case No. 2021-03994	2023 NY Slip Op 00748
Ralph Lauren Retail, Inc. v 888 Madison LLC	Index No. 652718/21 Appeal No. 17276 Case No. 2022-02382	2023 NY Slip Op 00747
People v Hamilton	Ind. No. 2684/14, 682/16 Appeal No. 17286 Case No. 2020-01840	2023 NY Slip Op 00746
People v Parker	Ind. No. 99034/15 Appeal No. 17292 Case No. 2018-1550	2023 NY Slip Op 00745
People v Diallo	Ind. No. 598/21 Appeal No. 17279 & M-4615 Case No. 2022-01361	2023 NY Slip Op 00744
People v Sharma	Ind. No. 2421/16, 2839/16 Appeal No. 17273-17274 Case No. 2019-05422	2023 NY Slip Op 00743
Matter of 495 Estates v New York State Div. of Hous. & Community Renewal	Index No. 158723/20 Appeal No. 17269 Case No. 2022-00264	2023 NY Slip Op 00720
People v Weathers	Ind. No. 4843/16 Appeal No. 17278 Case No. 2019-1141	2023 NY Slip Op 00741
People v Richardson	Ind. No. 4317/16 Appeal No. 17298 Case No. 2018-592	2023 NY Slip Op 00740
People v Cruz	Ind. No. 2301/17 Appeal No. 17289 Case No. 2019-03806	2023 NY Slip Op 00739
People v Shipman	Ind. No. 2661/17 Appeal No. 17267 Case No. 2019-4024	2023 NY Slip Op 00738
People v Coleman	Ind. No. 2994/18 Appeal No. 17301 Case No. 2019-04483	2023 NY Slip Op 00737
People v Alan L.	Ind. No. 2130/16 Appeal No. 17270 Case No. 2018-1989	2023 NY Slip Op 00736
Matter of Kylie P. (Carlos P.)	V-21839-40/16/20A Docket No. V-21839-40/16/20A Appeal No. 17288 Case No. 2022-02693	2023 NY Slip Op 00735
New York Mar. & Gen. Ins. Co. v Wesco Ins. Co.	Index No. 814326/21E Appeal No. 17291 Case No. 2022-02670	2023 NY Slip Op 00734
Matter of Noe v Local 983	Index No. 154208/22 Appeal No. 17304 Case No. 2022-02598	2023 NY Slip Op 00733
Madison Sq. Garden Sports Corp. v Factory Mut. Ins. Co.	Index No. 651521/21 Appeal No. 17281 Case No. 2022-02068	2023 NY Slip Op 00732
Liberty Mut. Ins. Co. v Bonilla	Index No. 657190/21 Appeal No. 17302 Case No. 2022-04270	2023 NY Slip Op 00731
Matter of Tak Yuet Kong v Commissioner of Labor	Index No. 158074/20 Appeal No. 17271 Case No. 2021-03811	2023 NY Slip Op 00730
Herrera v Highgate Hotels, L.P.	Index No. 151096/18E Appeal No. 17300 Case No. 2022-01750	2023 NY Slip Op 00729
Hua Jun "Coco" Han v Chen	Index No. 651073/18 Appeal No. 17275 Case No. 2022-02354	2023 NY Slip Op 00728
Gulf LNG Energy, LLC v Eni S.P.A.	Index No. 654819/18 Appeal No. 17299 Case No. 2022-00602	2023 NY Slip Op 00727
Goldberger v Magid	Index No. 652404/14 Appeal No. 17272 Case No. 2022-00252	2023 NY Slip Op 00726
Dabrowski v ABAX Inc.	Index No. 106778/07 Appeal No. 16980 Case No. 2022-00441	2023 NY Slip Op 00725
Continental Cas. Co. v KB Ins. Co., Ltd.	Index No. 652103/18 Appeal No. 17293-17294-17295 Case No. 2021-04128, 2021-04129, 2021-04130	2023 NY Slip Op 00724
Concepcion v Lessel Transp. Corp.	Index No. 452219/18, 150590/22 Appeal No. 17282-17283-17284 Case No. 2022-02843, 2022-01905, 2022-01985	2023 NY Slip Op 00723
Brook v Peconic Bay Med. Ctr.	Index No. 650921/12 Appeal No. 16983 Case No. 2021-04613	2023 NY Slip Op 00722
Matter of Board of Mgrs. of Franklin Place Condominium v New York City Fire Dept.	Index No. 161047/20 Appeal No. 17297 Case No. 2021-03533	2023 NY Slip Op 00721

**Cases Decided February 7, 2023**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
CORE Group Mkt.ing LLC v MIP One Wall St. Acquisition LLC		Index No. 654409/21 Appeal No. 17262 Case No. 2022-03816	2023 NY Slip Op 00643
Bersin Props., LLC v Nomura Credit & Capital, Inc.		Index No. 452630/14 Appeal No. 17264 Case No. 2022-01153	2023 NY Slip Op 00628
United Hay, LLC v Harounian		Index No. 657310/17 Appeal No. 17255-17256 Case No. 2022-01139, 2022-02074	2023 NY Slip Op 00642
Scottsdale Ins. Co. v Mt. Hawley Ins. Co.		Index No. 650998/19 Appeal No. 17259 Case No. 2021-03723	2023 NY Slip Op 00641
Matter of S.L. v A.V.		Index No. 304798/19 Appeal No. 17025 Case No. 2022-03002	2023 NY Slip Op 00640
People v Jones		Ind. No. 2139/14 Appeal No. 17260 Case No. 2016-977	2023 NY Slip Op 00639
People v Littlejohn		Ind. No. 4759/14 Appeal No. 17251 Case No. 2017-149	2023 NY Slip Op 00638
People v Okoduwa		Ind. No. 659/13 Appeal No. 17249 Case No. 2019-05141	2023 NY Slip Op 00637
People v DeLeon		Ind. No. 709/19 Appeal No. 17258 Case No. 2019-03964	2023 NY Slip Op 00636
People v Brown		Ind. No. 7282/03 Appeal No. 17254 Case No. 2017-2953	2023 NY Slip Op 00635
Padilla v Labow		Index No. 805098/18 Appeal No. 17257 Case No. 2022-02069	2023 NY Slip Op 00634
Horn v Nestor		Index No. 810002/13 Appeal No. 17253 Case No. 2022-04462	2023 NY Slip Op 00633
Ganz v Florman		Index No. 805177/19 Appeal No. 17252 Case No. 2022-02278	2023 NY Slip Op 00632
Elite Wine & Spirit LLC v Michelangelo Preserv. LLC	GONZÁLEZ, J.	Index No. 29527/19E Appeal No. 17138 Case No. 2022-00579	2023 NY Slip Op 00631
De La Cruz v Evers Mar. & Seaplane Base		Index No. 32797/20 Appeal No. 17250 Case No. 2022-02738	2023 NY Slip Op 00630
Condor Capital Corp. v CALS Invs., LLC		Index No. 652639/21 Appeal No. 17261 Case No. 2022-01052	2023 NY Slip Op 00629

**Cases Decided February 2, 2023**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Nancy A. v Juan A. B.		Docket No. V-4069-13/21C V-4069-13/21D V-4291-13/21C V-4291-13/21D Appeal No. 17234-17234A Case No. 2022-00417	2023 NY Slip Op 00479
Williams v Bronx Harbor Health Care Complex, Inc.		Index No. 32712/18E Appeal No. 17247 Case No. 2021-03914	2023 NY Slip Op 00508
Villanueva v National Frgt., Inc.		Index No. 36262/17 Appeal No. 17230 Case No. 2022-03401	2023 NY Slip Op 00507
Schoolfield v Services for the Underserved, Inc.		Index No. 27123/15E Appeal No. 17239 Case No. 2021-03678	2023 NY Slip Op 00506
Sayreville Seaport Assoc. Urban Renewal, L.P. v Indian Harbor Ins. Co.		Index No. 651626/21 Appeal No. 17222 Case No. 2022-02167	2023 NY Slip Op 00505
People v Naquan H.		Ind No. 3769/16 Appeal No. 17240 Case No. 2019-1634	2023 NY Slip Op 00504
People v Hernandez		Ind No. 3793/15 Appeal No. 17243 Case No. 2019-391	2023 NY Slip Op 00503
People v McCray		Ind No. 3920/08 Appeal No. 12241-12241A Case No. 2016-2146	2023 NY Slip Op 00502
People v Guillory		Ind No. 3176/16 Appeal No. 17224 Case No. 2020-01000	2023 NY Slip Op 00501
People v Green		Ind Nos. 0118/16 2003/16 Appeal No. 17228 Case No. 2018-2249	2023 NY Slip Op 00500
People v Rivera		Ind No. 3540/15 Appeal No. 17220 Case No. 2019-1482	2023 NY Slip Op 00499
People v Colon		Ind No. 6022/09 Appeal No. 17237 Case No. 2018-2677	2023 NY Slip Op 00498
People v Greene		Ind No. 1570/17 3724/17 Appeal No. 17232 Case No. 2018-03037	2023 NY Slip Op 00497
People v Allen	RENWICK, J.	Index No. 1178/16 2604/16 Appeal No. 16179 Case No. 2019-2895	2023 NY Slip Op 00496
People v Malloy		Ind No. 4299/08 Appeal No. 17246 Case No. 2015-720	2023 NY Slip Op 00495
People v Charles		SCI No. 2036/01 Appeal No. 17229 Case No. 2020-04091	2023 NY Slip Op 00494
People v Jones		00109C/11 58689C/11 00109C/11 58689C/11 Docket No. 00109C/11 58689C/11 Appeal No. 17213-17213A Case No. 2015-925	2023 NY Slip Op 00493
Pacheco v Trustees of Columbia Univ. in the City of N.Y.		Index No. 34248/19E Appeal No. 17236 Case No. 2022-01987	2023 NY Slip Op 00492
Martinez v Ravi		Index No. 21744/17 Appeal No. 17217 Case No. 2021-02845	2023 NY Slip Op 00491
Mariette v Amber Ct. of Pelham Gardens LHCSA, LLC		Index No. 24983/19E Appeal No. 17235 Case No. 2022-00127	2023 NY Slip Op 00490
J.G. v St. Luke's-Roosevelt Hosp. Ctr.		Index No. 805126/13 Appeal No. 17216 Case No. 2022-01695	2023 NY Slip Op 00489
Hayden v Mandelsberg		Index No. 161147/20 Appeal No. 17233 Case No. 2022-01455	2023 NY Slip Op 00488
Matter of Harris v Bronx County Dist. Attorney		Index No. 260395/19 Appeal No. 17223[M-05113] Case No. 2022-00028	2023 NY Slip Op 00487
Gedula 26, LLC v Lightstone Acquisitions III LLC		Index No. 653977/14 Appeal No. 17241 Case No. 2022-00975	2023 NY Slip Op 00486
Fawer v Shipkevich PLLC		Index No. 651056/22 Appeal No. 17244-17245 Case No. 2022-02352 2022-02373	2023 NY Slip Op 00485
Cisse v New York City Health & Hosps. Corp.		Index No. 805006/19 Appeal No. 17231 Case No. 2021-03819	2023 NY Slip Op 00484
Bldg 44 Devs. LLC v Pace Cos. N.Y., LLC		Index No. 595631/20 650390/20 Appeal No. 17238 Case No. 2022-00476	2023 NY Slip Op 00483
Arch Specialty Ins. Co. v Nautilus Ins. Co.		Index No. 651364/21 Appeal No. 17221 Case No. 2022-01211	2023 NY Slip Op 00482
Andes Petroleum Ecuador Ltd. v Occidental Petroleum Co.		Index No. 655072/21 Appeal No. 17242 Case No. 2022-02965	2023 NY Slip Op 00481
Ader v Ader		Index No. 35006/20 Appeal No. 17248 Case No. 2022-01014	2023 NY Slip Op 00480