Appellate Division, First Department Decisions

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

**Cases Decided October 31, 2023**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
829 Greenwich St., LLC v Slorer	Index No. 654937/21 Appeal No. 932 Case No. 2023-02843	2023 NY Slip Op 05458
Zeitlin v Cohan	Index No. 156829/21 Appeal No. 927 Case No. 2022-04173	2023 NY Slip Op 05484
Watts v American BD Co.	Index No. 159621/19 Appeal No. 950 Case No. 2023-03358	2023 NY Slip Op 05483
Pinpoint Bldrs., Inc. v Golden Ins. Co.	Index No. 653864/16, 595955/16 Appeal No. 943 Case No. 2022-01002	2023 NY Slip Op 05482
Pietroforte v Belle Harbor Home of the Sages, Inc.	Index No. 805149/14 Appeal No. 948 Case No. 2022-02701	2023 NY Slip Op 05481
People v Martin	Ind. No. 206/21 Appeal No. 944 Case No. 2022-00141	2023 NY Slip Op 05480
People v Jones	Ind. Nos. 1232/18, 1311/18 Appeal No. 934-934A Case No. 2020-00629	2023 NY Slip Op 05479
People v Bueno	Ind. No. 2223/17, SCI No. 1532/18 Appeal No. 929 Case No. 2018-04067	2023 NY Slip Op 05478
People v Gamarra-Mendoza	Ind. No. 502/19 Appeal No. 924 Case No. 2022-02735	2023 NY Slip Op 05477
People v Hodgson	Ind. No. 185/15 Appeal No. 919 Case No. 2017-2188	2023 NY Slip Op 05476
People v Davis	Ind. No. 8310/96 Appeal No. 937 Case No. 2022-02742	2023 NY Slip Op 05475
People v Randolph	Ind Nos. 3466/17, 3466/17 Appeal No. 942-942A Case No. 2019-04570, 2019-2028	2023 NY Slip Op 05474
O'Shea v Procida Constr. Corp.	Index No. 32582/18E Appeal No. 928 Case No. 2022-05421	2023 NY Slip Op 05473
Matter of Mamatkulov v CUNY, the City Univ. of N.Y.	Index No. 100566/22 Appeal No. 949 Case No. 2023-00308	2023 NY Slip Op 05472
Matter of Community Church of N.Y. v Duckett	Index No. 154733/22 Appeal No. 923 Case No. 2022-04831	2023 NY Slip Op 05471
Gleitman v Kushner	Index No. 153660/19 Appeal No. 951 Case No. 2022-05534	2023 NY Slip Op 05470
Five Star Elec. Corp. v A.J. Pegno Constr. Co., Inc./Tully Constr. Co., Inc.	Index No. 400897/11 Appeal No. 939-940 Case No. 2023-02148, 2023-03044	2023 NY Slip Op 05469
Matter of Fisher v City of N.Y. Off. of the Mayor	Index No. 157755/21 Appeal No. 920 Case No. 2023-00339	2023 NY Slip Op 05468
Ferreira v E-J Elec. Installation Co.	Index No. 30856/19E Appeal No. 922 Case No. 2022-03096	2023 NY Slip Op 05467
Matter of Elizabeth F. v Wilfredo F.	Docket No. O-04933-21 Appeal No. 938 Case No. 2023-01022	2023 NY Slip Op 05466
Cicardo Natl., Inc. v Loeb	Index No. 650737/20 Appeal No. 946 Case No. 2023-00345	2023 NY Slip Op 05465
Children's Magical Garden, Inc. v Marom	Index No. 654960/19 Appeal No. 925 Case No. 2022-04750	2023 NY Slip Op 05464
Cardenas v State of New York	Claim No. 97094 Appeal No. 935 Case No. 2023-00468	2023 NY Slip Op 05463
Matter of Jorge R.C. v Julieta A.C.	Docket No. V20935-36-12/18E, V-20935-36-12/19F Appeal No. 921 Case No. 2022-01394	2023 NY Slip Op 05462
Broome Lender LLC v Empire Broome LLC	Index No. 850198/21 Appeal No. 933 Case No. 2022-05190	2023 NY Slip Op 05461
Matter of Berisha v 4042 E. Tremont Café Corp.	Index No. 260677/16E Appeal No. 941 Case No. 2023-00978	2023 NY Slip Op 05460
Matter of Aron Law PLLC v New York City Police Dept.	Index No. 155529/22 Appeal No. 930 Case No. 2023-00187	2023 NY Slip Op 05459

**Cases Decided October 26, 2023**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
75 St. Servicing LLC v CLST Enters. LLC	Index No. 850001/21 Appeal No. 914 Case No. 2022-04757	2023 NY Slip Op 05441
Wansi v Wansi	Index No. 3755/05 Appeal No. 918 Case No. 2023-03357	2023 NY Slip Op 05457
Matter of B. V. (Jacquella W.)	Docket No. N-02472/21 N-02473/21 N-02474/21 N-02475/21 Appeal No. 903 Case No. 2023-00129	2023 NY Slip Op 05456
Suzuki v Greenberg	Index No. 159360/21 Appeal No. 913 Case No. 2023-02300	2023 NY Slip Op 05455
Rosenbaum v Myers	Index No. 652971/19 Appeal No. 908-909 Case No. 2022-05726, 2022-05727	2023 NY Slip Op 05454
Rodriguez v Trinity Evangelical Lutheran Church	Index No. 28132/20 Appeal No. 907 Case No. 2022-04652	2023 NY Slip Op 05453
People v Savage	Ind No. 1726/16 Appeal No. 681 Case No. 2019-3213	2023 NY Slip Op 05452
People v DeSilva	Ind No. 4480/17 Appeal No. 905 Case No. 2019-03707	2023 NY Slip Op 05451
People v Rosario	SCI No. 3100/11 Appeal No. 916 Case No. 2018-769	2023 NY Slip Op 05450
People v Nunez	Ind No. 181/19 Appeal No. 911 Case No. 2020-01199	2023 NY Slip Op 05449
Pacelli v Peter L. Cedeno & Assoc., PC	Index No. 158224/16 Appeal No. 902 Case No. 2023-01445	2023 NY Slip Op 05448
Nash v Walker Mem. Baptist Church, Inc.	Index No. 28989/17 43139/18 43273/18 Appeal No. 904 Case No. 2023-00023	2023 NY Slip Op 05447
Lantern Endowment Partners, LP v Bluefin Servicing Ltd.	Index No. 654002/19 Appeal No. 912 Case No. 2022-3323	2023 NY Slip Op 05446
Jorge v City of New York	Index No. 300803/12 Appeal No. 915 Case No. 2022-01874	2023 NY Slip Op 05445
Dynamic Event Group, Inc. v Penske Truck Leasing Co., L.P.	Index No. 652160/21 Appeal No. 906 Case No. 2022-03916	2023 NY Slip Op 05444
Carboni v Alfa Romeo USA	Index No. 190328/19 Appeal No. 917 Case No. 2023-00781	2023 NY Slip Op 05443
AIG Prop. Cas. Co. v SF Constr. Servs., Inc.	Index No. 150165/17 Appeal No. 910-910A Case No. 2022-03712	2023 NY Slip Op 05442

**Cases Decided October 24, 2023**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
35th St. Assoc. v Sasson	Index No. 652839/21 Appeal No. 870 Case No. 2022-03786	2023 NY Slip Op 05353
Unlimited Assets, Inc. v PennyMac Corp.	Index No. 31371/18 Appeal No. 890 Case No. 2022-03457	2023 NY Slip Op 05385
U.S. Bank N.A. v Barker Project LLC	Index No. 809792/21 Appeal No. 868 Case No. 2023-00738	2023 NY Slip Op 05384
Sharp v Ferrante Law Firm	Index No. 155297/22 Appeal No. 887 Case No. 2023-01745	2023 NY Slip Op 05383
Matter of Schulte	File No. 4582/05 Appeal No. 898 Case No. 2023-00272	2023 NY Slip Op 05382
Sanli Oriental Rugs Corp. v S&S Realty Corp.	Index No. 157787/18 Appeal No. 873 Case No. 2022-04665	2023 NY Slip Op 05381
Rubin v Di Dimatteo	Index No. 154295/20 Appeal No. 896 Case No. 2023-01608	2023 NY Slip Op 05380
Matter of Rivera v Board of Trustees of N.Y. Fire Dept.	Index No. 156115/21 Appeal No. 678 Case No. 2022-04201	2023 NY Slip Op 05379
Prendergast v New York City Tr. Auth.	Index No. 150778/20 Appeal No. 897 Case No. 2022-05826	2023 NY Slip Op 05378
People v Torres	Ind No. 946/20 Appeal No. 884 Case No. 2022-04346	2023 NY Slip Op 05377
People v Castillo	Ind No. 936/14, 2948/15 Appeal No. 889-889A Case No. 2017-808	2023 NY Slip Op 05376
People v Thomas	Ind No. 1072/18 Dkt. No. 11178/18 Appeal No. 899-899A Case No. 2019-862	2023 NY Slip Op 05375
People v Jackson	Index No. 4517/14 Appeal No. 894 Case No. 2017-1284	2023 NY Slip Op 05374
People v Njie	Ind No. 1319/17 Appeal No. 869 Case No. 2019-3445	2023 NY Slip Op 05373
People v Salvador	SCI No. 2236/17 Appeal No. 864 Case No. 2019-04906	2023 NY Slip Op 05372
People v Melbourne	Ind No. 317/21 Appeal No. 881 Case No. 2022-00839	2023 NY Slip Op 05371
People v Vallejo	Ind No. 2533/10 Appeal No. 874 Case No. 2022-02754	2023 NY Slip Op 05370
Matter of New Millennium Pain & Spine Medicine, P.C. v Progressive Cas. Ins. Co.	Index No. 654892/22 Appeal No. 879 Case No. 2023-03262	2023 NY Slip Op 05369
McDowell v Rodriguez	Index No. 152151/17 Appeal No. 885 Case No. 2022-05638	2023 NY Slip Op 05368
Marquez v 171 Tenants Corp.	Index No. 106616/11 Appeal No. 867 Case No. 2022-04586	2023 NY Slip Op 05367
Matter of Living Real Estate Group, LLC v Douglas Elliman, LLC	Index No. 653959/22 654722/22 Appeal No. 891-892 Case No. 2023-01561 2023-01734	2023 NY Slip Op 05366
Matter of Jablecki v Board of Mgrs. of Harborview Condominium	Index No. 152072/23 Appeal No. 882 Case No. 2023-02030	2023 NY Slip Op 05365
Good Gateway, LLC v Thakkar	Index No. 160660/16 Appeal No. 901 Case No. 2023-02617	2023 NY Slip Op 05364
Gilat v Sutton	Index No. 651038/22 Appeal No. 883 Case No. 2023-01919	2023 NY Slip Op 05363
Matter of Baby Girl G. (Curtis M. R.)	Docket No. NN-13983-21 Appeal No. 886-886A Case No. 2022-01274	2023 NY Slip Op 05362
Firescu v Diamond	Index No. 650301/21 Appeal No. 895 Case No. 2022-03769	2023 NY Slip Op 05361
Matter of Farca v Board of Educ. of the City Sch. Dist. of the City of N.Y.	Index No. 155911/22 Appeal No. 865 Case No. 2023-00313	2023 NY Slip Op 05360
Chelsea 8th Ave. LLC v Chelseamilk LLC	Index No. 158387/22 Appeal No. 880 Case No. 2023-02095	2023 NY Slip Op 05359
Matter of Cameron v Shea	Index No. 151741/20 Appeal No. 900 Case No. 2023-00569	2023 NY Slip Op 05358
Calderoni v 260 Park Ave. S. Condominium	Index No. 152050/22 Appeal No. 876-877 Case No. 2022-03926 2022-04140	2023 NY Slip Op 05357
Matter of Pedro C. v Michelle R.	Docket No. V-12449-50-17/19A V-12449-50-17/21B Appeal No. 866 Case No. 2022-05390	2023 NY Slip Op 05356
Bauseman v Pamdh Enters. Inc.	Index No. 26314/16 Appeal No. 878 Case No. 2022-02429	2023 NY Slip Op 05355
Archives, L.L.C. v Volpe	Index No. 152158/21 Appeal No. 871-872 Case No. 2023-01016 2023-03468	2023 NY Slip Op 05354

**Cases Decided October 19, 2023**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
325 Mgt. Corp. v Statuto	Index No. 157359/21 Appeal No. 819 Case No. 2022-04712	2023 NY Slip Op 05307
Westman Realty Co., LLC v Nettles	Index No. 159605/20 Appeal No. 849 Case No. 2023-02325	2023 NY Slip Op 05346
Warburg Realty Partnership, Ltd. v Aschheim	Index No. 651948/22 Appeal No. 859 Case No. 2022-05539	2023 NY Slip Op 05345
Walker v Triborough Bridge & Tunnel Auth.	Index No. 160839/21 Appeal No. 825 Case No. 2022-04246	2023 NY Slip Op 05344
Sickinger v Sickinger	Index No. 305619/17 Appeal No. 831 Case No. 2023-01113	2023 NY Slip Op 05343
Satterifield v Vstock Transfer, LLC	Index No. 650311/19 Appeal No. 858 Case No. 2022-02839	2023 NY Slip Op 05342
People v Felix	Ind No. 70747/22 Appeal No. 828 Case No. 2022-03701	2023 NY Slip Op 05341
People v Patrick	Ind No. 4074/19 Appeal No. 853 Case No. 2020-04113	2023 NY Slip Op 05340
People v Torres	Ind No. 243/16 Appeal No. 834 Case No. 2019-2471	2023 NY Slip Op 05339
People v Forman	Ind No. 855/15 Appeal No. 847 Case No. 2018-2024	2023 NY Slip Op 05338
People v Luis R.	Ind No. 617/14 Appeal No. 838 Case No. 2017-1373	2023 NY Slip Op 05337
People v Mills	Ind No. 2984/11 Appeal No. 824 Case No. 2019-1872	2023 NY Slip Op 05336
People v Scotland	Ind No. 873/10 Appeal No. 829 Case No. 2021-04625	2023 NY Slip Op 05335
People v Santos	Ind No. 4581/18 Appeal No. 860 Case No. 2021-04084	2023 NY Slip Op 05334
People v Ortiz	Ind No. 1457/20 Appeal No. 823 Case No. 2022-02026	2023 NY Slip Op 05333
People v Simmons	Ind No. 501/15 Appeal No. 857 Case No. 2018-3052	2023 NY Slip Op 05332
People v Rochford	Ind No. 2395/09 Appeal No. 861 Case No. 2022-01623	2023 NY Slip Op 05331
People v Chapman	Ind No. 896/17 Appeal No. 841 Case No. 2019-05183	2023 NY Slip Op 05330
People v Sanchez	Ind No. 2810/14 Appeal No. 852 Case No. 2017-1020 2020-00388	2023 NY Slip Op 05329
People v Salas	Ind No. 3471/07 Appeal No. 832-833 Case No. 2016-00862 2022-02977	2023 NY Slip Op 05328
People v Gonzalez	Ind No. 834/16 Appeal No. 846 Case No. 2016-01846	2023 NY Slip Op 05327
People v Wilson	Ind No. 866/16 Appeal No. 851 Case No. 2017-1039	2023 NY Slip Op 05326
People v Cherif	Ind No. 974/21 Appeal No. 818 Case No. 2022-03302	2023 NY Slip Op 05325
People v Frazier	Ind No. 3391/15 Appeal No. 836 Case No. 2018-1737	2023 NY Slip Op 05324
Owens v STD Trucking Corp.	Index No. 23076/19E Appeal No. 862-863 Case No. 2022-00787 2022-03460	2023 NY Slip Op 05323
Osario v NYSandy4 NBP19 LLC	Index No. 34317/19E Appeal No. 835 Case No. 2022-03641	2023 NY Slip Op 05322
Murphy v Chinatown Cardiology, P.C.	Index No. 805038/16 Appeal No. 854 Case No. 2022-04998	2023 NY Slip Op 05321
Magna Equities II, LLC v Writ Media Group Inc.	Index No. 653808/16 Appeal No. 839-840 Case No. 2020-03794 2022-01540	2023 NY Slip Op 05320
Matter of Lebowitz v Board of Educ. of the City Sch. Dist. of the City of N.Y.	Index No. 154876/22 Appeal No. 821 Case No. 2022-04896	2023 NY Slip Op 05319
Matter of Dionisio L. v Albania L.	Docket No. V-43310- 14/16A&B V-43487-14/16A&B Appeal No. 843 Case No. 2020-00460	2023 NY Slip Op 05318
Kushner v Carter Ledyard & Milburn LLP	Index No. 654432/21 Appeal No. 827 Case No. 2023-00953	2023 NY Slip Op 05317
Matter of J.M. (Luis E.)	Docket No. NA-15172/19 Appeal No. 820 Case No. 2022-02210	2023 NY Slip Op 05316
IBT Media Inc. v Pragad	Index No. 652277/22 Appeal No. 848 Case No. 2023-00650	2023 NY Slip Op 05315
Matter of Knapp	File No. 2019/20 Appeal No. 822 Case No. 2023-01527	2023 NY Slip Op 05314
Harsanyi v Extell 4110 LLC	Index No. 157170/15 Appeal No. 850 Case No. 2023-00363	2023 NY Slip Op 05313
Gill v Bk Bryant Ave. HDFC., Inc.	Index No. 33960/18E Appeal No. 844 Case No. 2023-01352	2023 NY Slip Op 05312
Escobar v New York City Tr. Auth.	Index No. 153360/17 Appeal No. 842 Case No. 2023-01709	2023 NY Slip Op 05311
Davis v Brookfield Props. Mgt., LLC	Index No. 158492/17 Appeal No. 837 Case No. 2022-05275	2023 NY Slip Op 05310
Barone v Clopton	Index No. 303097/16 Appeal No. 855-856 Case No. 2021-04727, 2021-04746	2023 NY Slip Op 05309
513 W. 26th Realty LLC v George Billis Galleries, Inc.	Index No. 160266/20 Appeal No. 845 Case No. 2021-03203	2023 NY Slip Op 05308

**Cases Decided October 17, 2023**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Alberico v Riverside Unit C, LLC	Index No. 154621/16 Appeal No. 799 Case No. 2022-02343	2023 NY Slip Op 05220
Wong v Wong	Index No. 158126/17 Appeal No. 809 Case No. 2022-05463	2023 NY Slip Op 05239
Velin M. v Bermet T.	Index No. 300797/16 Appeal No. 797 Case No. 2023-00751	2023 NY Slip Op 05238
Teshabaeva v Family Home Care Servs. of Brooklyn & Queens, Inc.	Index No. 158949/17 Appeal No. 816 Case No. 2022-05482	2023 NY Slip Op 05237
Shane v Rosenwaks	Index No. 152545/19 Appeal No. 804 Case No. 2022-03572	2023 NY Slip Op 05236
People v Rosas	SCI. No. 1873/19 Appeal No. 814 Case No. 2020-00900	2023 NY Slip Op 05235
People v McNeill	Ind. No. 3359/16 Appeal No. 815 Case No. 2021-03907	2023 NY Slip Op 05234
People v Krull	Ind. No. 831/15 Appeal No. 802 Case No. 2018-1350	2023 NY Slip Op 05233
People v Ayala	Ind. No. 1408/16 Docket No. 2015 NY 078097, 2015 NY 076767 Appeal No. 813 Case No. 2017-01543	2023 NY Slip Op 05232
People v Hampton	Ind. No. 1426/19 Appeal No. 801 Case No. 2022-00888	2023 NY Slip Op 05231
People v Torres	Ind. No. 4626/16 Appeal No. 807 Case No. 2019-4202	2023 NY Slip Op 05230
People v Burgos	Ind. No. 3831/16 Appeal No. 796 Case No. 2019-5268	2023 NY Slip Op 05229
People v Williams	Ind. No. 3658/16 Appeal No. 811 Case No. 2021-04137	2023 NY Slip Op 05228
Neuwelt v 33072 Owners Corp.	Index No. 655265/21 Appeal No. 808 Case No. 2023-03001	2023 NY Slip Op 05227
Lowman v Consolidated Edison Co. of N.Y., Inc.	Index No. 158715/17, 595442/18 Appeal No. 812 Case No. 2022-04296	2023 NY Slip Op 05226
Matter of Marlene H. v Loren D.	Docket No. O-11070/21 Appeal No. 798 Case No. 2022-03156	2023 NY Slip Op 05225
Five Star Elec. Corp. v Silverite Constr. Co., Inc.	Index No. 652495/20 Appeal No. 810 Case No. 2022-04840	2023 NY Slip Op 05224
Matter of C.F. (Carlos F.)	Docket No. NA-16419/21 Appeal No. 806 Case No. 2022-05346	2023 NY Slip Op 05223
Chopra v Gyu-Kaku Japanese BBQ	Index No. 153741/20 Appeal No. 800 Case No. 2022-05521	2023 NY Slip Op 05222
Burnes v City of New York	Index No. 161477/21 Appeal No. 817 Case No. 2022-04292	2023 NY Slip Op 05221

**Cases Decided October 12, 2023**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
45-47-49 Eighth Ave. LLC v Conti	Index No. 654033/20 Appeal No. 764 Case No. 2021-02743	2023 NY Slip Op 05180
Matter of Edward C. Y. v Jessica E. H.	Docket No. O-8240/20 Appeal No. 776 Case No. 2022-04845	2023 NY Slip Op 05215
Wagman v Morgan Stanley Children's Hosp. of N.Y. Presbyt.	Index No. 160709/21 Appeal No. 771[M-3778] Case No. 2022-05622	2023 NY Slip Op 05214
Matter of Matthew P. v Linnea W.	Docket No. O-04643/20, O-02893/20, O-015691/20, V-02893/20;21A;21B, V-03036/20;21A Appeal No. 753 Case No. 2022-02782	2023 NY Slip Op 05213
Van Horne v Ben-Dov	Index No. 652444/20 Appeal No. 759-760 Case No. 2021-02156 2023-00252	2023 NY Slip Op 05212
Shapiro v 89th St. Dev. Co. LLC	Index No. 153428/18 Appeal No. 789 Case No. 2023-01830	2023 NY Slip Op 05211
Matter of Robert S. v Norma C.	Docket Nos. V-06262/19, V-13581/19 Appeal No. 785 Case No. 2022-04388	2023 NY Slip Op 05210
Matter of Maria D.S. v Andrei S.	Index No. O-07168/22 Appeal No. 763 Case No. 2022-04979	2023 NY Slip Op 05209
People v Floyd	Ind No. 1367/15 Appeal No. 786 Case No. 2018-364	2023 NY Slip Op 05208
People v Cosme	Ind No. 747/15 Appeal No. 15175 Case No. 2018-5425	2023 NY Slip Op 05207
People v Robinson	Ind No. 954/18 Appeal No. 751 Case No. 2021-2280	2023 NY Slip Op 05206
People v Wilson	Ind No. 1234/17 Appeal No. 791 Case No. 2019-5163	2023 NY Slip Op 05205
People v Jordan	Ind No. 1723/17 Appeal No. 765 Case No. 2018-2283	2023 NY Slip Op 05204
People v Robbins	Ind No. 2199/18 Appeal No. 782 Case No. 2021-02597	2023 NY Slip Op 05203
People v Seales	Ind No. 1140/16 Appeal No. 770 Case No. 2019-05435	2023 NY Slip Op 05202
People v Badillo	Ind No. 79/13 Appeal No. 790 Case No. 2015-1696	2023 NY Slip Op 05201
People v Calderon	Ind No. 1557/16 Appeal No. 758 Case No. 2018-2400	2023 NY Slip Op 05200
People v Jacob M.	Ind No. 4417/17 Appeal No. 766 Case No. 2020-00220	2023 NY Slip Op 05199
People v Vargas	Ind No. 497/15 1119N/15 1053/16 Appeal No. 793-793A Case No. 2019-5834	2023 NY Slip Op 05198
People v Jenkins	Ind No. 4019/17 Appeal No. 773-773A Case No. 2019-03624 2022-03507	2023 NY Slip Op 05197
People v Guzman	Ind No. 71914/22 Appeal No. 779 Case No. 2022-05310	2023 NY Slip Op 05196
People v Williams	Ind No. 221/20 Appeal No. 767 Case No. 2021-04599	2023 NY Slip Op 05195
People v Echeverria	Ind No. 2356/18 Appeal No. 755 Case No. 2019-03705	2023 NY Slip Op 05194
Matter of NYP Holdings, Inc. v New York City Police Dept.	Index No. 159132/21 Appeal No. 788 Case No. 2023-00242	2023 NY Slip Op 05193
Newell v Javier	Index No. 302650/15 Appeal No. 754 Case No. 2022-03964	2023 NY Slip Op 05192
Nava v Franklin	Index No. 30312/17 Appeal No. 781 Case No. 2023-00624	2023 NY Slip Op 05191
Lucas v Verizon Communications, Inc.	Index No. 652529/20 Appeal No. 761 Case No. 2023-02043	2023 NY Slip Op 05190
Matter of Lopez v New York State Off. of Children & Family Servs.	Index No. 150924/22 Appeal No. 762 Case No. 2023-00910	2023 NY Slip Op 05189
Johnson v Johnson	Index No. 812848/22 Appeal No. 795 Case No. 2023-00200	2023 NY Slip Op 05188
Fifth Ave. 25G LLC v Sambar	Index No. 150021/22 Appeal No. 772 Case No. 2022-05311	2023 NY Slip Op 05187
Engholm v AIMCO 240 W. 73rd St., LLC	Index No. 155328/20 Appeal No. 752 Case No. 2023-01197	2023 NY Slip Op 05186
Diaz v State of New York	Appeal No. 768-769 Case No. 2022-03897, 2022-03898	2023 NY Slip Op 05185
Chaar v Arab Bank P.L.C.	Index No. 651780/22 Appeal No. 794-794A Case No. 2022-04975	2023 NY Slip Op 05184
Carey v Carey	Index No. 152192/21 Appeal No. 783 Case No. 2022-01053	2023 NY Slip Op 05183
Beer v Beer	Index No. 308103/19 Appeal No. 756-757 Case No. 2022-05301 2023-01133	2023 NY Slip Op 05182
Advanced Alternative Media, Inc. v Hindlin	Index No. 655916/18 Appeal No. 780 Case No. 2022-04939	2023 NY Slip Op 05181

**Cases Decided October 10, 2023**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Geraldine H.T. B. v Guillaume A. P. M. J.	Docket No. V-14694/19 Appeal No. 732 Case No. 2022-05815	2023 NY Slip Op 05091
Velasquez v 94 E. 208 St. Partners LLC	Index No. 31258/19 Appeal No. 745 Case No. 2022-04473	2023 NY Slip Op 05110
Shabtai v HFZ Capital Group, LLC	Index No. 653453/21 Appeal No. 735-735A Case No. 2022-03558	2023 NY Slip Op 05109
People v Chodakowski	Ind. No. 2930/15 Appeal No. 14522 Case No. 2021-00327	2023 NY Slip Op 05108
People v Gamble	Ind. No. 3464/16 Appeal No. 734 Case No. 2019-816	2023 NY Slip Op 05107
People v Guzman-Caba	SCI No. 348/14 Appeal No. 16903 Case No. 2015-2126, 2014-02382	2023 NY Slip Op 05106
People v Brown	Ind. No. 6292/06 Appeal No. 730 Case No. 2018-2157	2023 NY Slip Op 05105
People v Stocks	Ind. No. 1511/17 Appeal No. 743 Case No. 2018-04226	2023 NY Slip Op 05104
People v Jackson	Ind. No. 1226/16, 817/17 Appeal No. 739 Case No. 2018-4908, 2019-4489	2023 NY Slip Op 05103
People v Qadir Y.	Ind. No. 4082/17, 1477/17, 1635/17 Appeal No. 747-748 Case No. 2019-5358, 2018-03318	2023 NY Slip Op 05102
People v Rivera-Santana	Ind. No. 1250/18 Appeal No. 733 Case No. 2019-04016	2023 NY Slip Op 05101
People v Diaz	Ind. No. 1867/17 Appeal No. 746 Case No. 2019-03478	2023 NY Slip Op 05100
Matter of McMikle v Department of Educ. of the City of N.Y.	Index No. 150697/22 Appeal No. 731 Case No. 2022-03082	2023 NY Slip Op 05099
Matter of Jewish Press Inc. v New York City Police Dept.	Index No. 155798/21 Appeal No. 742 Case No. 2022-04285	2023 NY Slip Op 05098
Goldberg v Torim	Index No. 151425/18 Appeal No. 738 Case No. 2023-01475	2023 NY Slip Op 05097
Garcia v 122-130 E. 23rd St. LLC	Index No. 153179/19, 595901/19 Appeal No. 736 Case No. 2022-01004	2023 NY Slip Op 05096
Febres v Metropolitan Transp. Auth.	Index No. 28870/17 Appeal No. 737 Case No. 2022-04183	2023 NY Slip Op 05095
Matter of Country-Wide Ins. Co. v Bay Needle Care Acupuncture, P.C.	Index No. 650424/16 Appeal No. 749 Case No. 2022-03570	2023 NY Slip Op 05094
Caldwell v 4 NYP Ventures	Index No. 157607/16, 595007/18 Appeal No. 744M-3782 Case No. 2022-04625	2023 NY Slip Op 05093
Matter of Benavides v New York City Health & Hosps. Corp.	Index No. 801170/22 Appeal No. 750 Case No. 2022-03204	2023 NY Slip Op 05092

**Cases Decided October 5, 2023**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
111 W. 57th Inv. LLC v 111 W57 Mezz Inv. LLC	Index No. 655031/17 Appeal No. 718 Case No. 2023-00158	2023 NY Slip Op 05029
Matter of Ward v New York Police Dept. Headquarters License Div.	Index No. 100881/21 Appeal No. 716 Case No. 2022-04125	2023 NY Slip Op 05051
Vallone v Vulcano	Index No. 8051638/19 Appeal No. 711 Case No. 2023-00382	2023 NY Slip Op 05050
Salcedo v Strathmore Constr. Mgt., LLC	Index No. 306568/13E Appeal No. 710 Case No. 2023-00113	2023 NY Slip Op 05049
Matter of C. S. (Donte S.)	Docket No. NA-08296/20, NA-08297-20 Appeal No. 709-709A Case No. 2022-04859	2023 NY Slip Op 05048
Matter of N.R. (Delilah W.)	Docket No. NN-5005/22, NN-5006/22 Appeal No. 717 Case No. 2023-00027	2023 NY Slip Op 05047
People v Bacon	Ind. No. 806/18 Appeal No. 722 Case No. 2019-3512	2023 NY Slip Op 05046
People v Rodriguez	SCI No. 790/19 Appeal No. 715 Case No. 2019-03479	2023 NY Slip Op 05045
People v Galarza	SCI No. 2437/18 Appeal No. 707 Case No. 2021-01263	2023 NY Slip Op 05044
People v Jackson	Ind. No. 5625/12 Appeal No. 712 Case No. 2021-04347	2023 NY Slip Op 05043
People v Davis	Ind. No. 122/21 Appeal No. 720 Case No. 2022-01742	2023 NY Slip Op 05042
People v Alexander R.	Ind. No. 1444/18 Appeal No. 727 Case No. 2020-02154	2023 NY Slip Op 05041
People v Negron	Ind. No. 1125/21 Appeal No. 724 Case No. 2021-03714	2023 NY Slip Op 05040
Matter of Oversight Mgt. Servs., LLC v Soliman	Index No. 159791/21 Appeal No. 723 Case No. 2023-00127	2023 NY Slip Op 05039
IO Experience Design LLC v C & A Mktg. Inc.	Index No. 655660/18 Appeal No. 714 Case No. 2023-02908	2023 NY Slip Op 05038
Iaccarino v Koenig	Index No. 162121/18 Appeal No. 725-726 Case No. 2022-02572, 2023-00443	2023 NY Slip Op 05037
Hylton v WTC Tower 1 LLC	Index No. 156171/19 Appeal No. 721 Case No. 2022-04359	2023 NY Slip Op 05036
Gupta v YM Pro Corp	Index No. 153384/20 Appeal No. 719 Case No. 2022-04706	2023 NY Slip Op 05035
Carver v Artiles	Index No. 34934/19E Appeal No. 713 Case No. 2023-02130	2023 NY Slip Op 05034
Carrasquillo v New York City Tr. Auth.	Index No. 25579/14E Appeal No. 708 Case No. 2023-01021	2023 NY Slip Op 05033
Bronx Car Park Sys., Inc. v Fordham Hill Owners' Corp.	Index No. 651147/22 Appeal No. 729 Case No. 2023-01182	2023 NY Slip Op 05032
Bldg ABI Enters., LLC v 711 Second Ave. Corp.	Index No. 110703/11 Appeal No. 728 Case No. 2022-01599	2023 NY Slip Op 05031
Artemiou v City of New York	Index No. 805202/15 Appeal No. 830 Case No. 2022-02142	2023 NY Slip Op 05030

**Cases Decided October 3, 2023**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Aras v B-U Realty Corp.	Kennedy	Index No. 161448/14 Appeal No. 16846 Case No. 2022-01126	2023 NY Slip Op 04917
Upfront Megatainment, Inc. v Thiam		Index No. 652156/21 Appeal No. 704&M-03759 Case No. 2022-05221	2023 NY Slip Op 04954
Subway Real Estate Corp. v Jahedi		Index No. 652369/17 Appeal No. 668 Case No. 2022-04186	2023 NY Slip Op 04953
Smith, Gambrell & Russell, LLP v 3 W. 16th St., LLC		Index No. 654238/21 Appeal No. 677 Case No. 2023-00730	2023 NY Slip Op 04952
Matter of Sami v Rosado		Index No. 151262/19 Appeal No. 706 Case No. 2023-02124	2023 NY Slip Op 04951
Matter of Richardson v Motor Veh. Acc. Indem. Corp.		Index No. 800088/22E Appeal No. 679 Case No. 2023-00603	2023 NY Slip Op 04950
RCI Hosp.ity Holdings, Inc. v White		Index No. 161752/19 Appeal No. 689 Case No. 2022-00810	2023 NY Slip Op 04949
Matter of Alexandra R.R. v Doris H.		Docket No. V-02372/22 V-02373/22 V-02374/22 Appeal No. 695 Case No. 2022-03178	2023 NY Slip Op 04948
People v Norwood		Ind. No. 647/15 Appeal No. 671 Case No. 2018-02469	2023 NY Slip Op 04947
People v Collins		Ind. No. 3587/14 Appeal No. 673 Case No. 2017-1061	2023 NY Slip Op 04946
People v Wright		Ind. No. 74567/22 Appeal No. 701 Case No. 2023-00079	2023 NY Slip Op 04945
People v Murtha		Ind. No. 0038/19, 0372/19 Appeal No. 667 Case No. 2020-00522	2023 NY Slip Op 04944
People v Santos		Ind. No. 03935/19 Appeal No. 676 Case No. 2022-04958	2023 NY Slip Op 04943
People v Hayes		Ind. No. 3574/18 Appeal No. 693 Case No. 2020-01514	2023 NY Slip Op 04942
People v Muhamed G.		Ind. No. 3225/16 Appeal No. 680 Case No. 2019-1455	2023 NY Slip Op 04941
People v Marywal G.		Ind. No. 3735/16 Appeal No. 703 Case No. 2019-5641	2023 NY Slip Op 04940
People v Colon		Ind. No. 2198/17 Appeal No. 690 Case No. 2018-04321	2023 NY Slip Op 04939
People v Berrocal		Ind. No. 346/12 Appeal No. 685 Case No. 2014-2526	2023 NY Slip Op 04938
People v Stallings		Ind. No. 1273/17 Appeal No. 696 Case No. 2019-04541	2023 NY Slip Op 04937
People v Bookman		Docket No. 20133/18, 20044/19 Appeal No. 662 Case No. 2019-5887	2023 NY Slip Op 04936
Matter of Paul v City of New York		Index No. 154728/22 Appeal No. 688 Case No. 2023-00290	2023 NY Slip Op 04935
Newby v Morales		Index No. 25491/20E Appeal No. 675 Case No. 2023-00003	2023 NY Slip Op 04934
Morini v Thurman		Index No. 159159/21 Appeal No. 682 Case No. 2022-03778	2023 NY Slip Op 04933
Matter of Lajuan M. v Administration for Children's Servs.		Docket No. G-17307-22 Appeal No. 687 Case No. 2022-04932	2023 NY Slip Op 04932
Matter of Kaylie v Kaylie		Index No. 151662/22 Appeal No. 663 Case No. 2023-02864	2023 NY Slip Op 04931
Matter of C'D. K.J. (Kamesha D.L.)		Docket No. N-30754/19, N-30755/19, N-30756/19, NN-08548/20 Appeal No. 672-672A Case No. 2022-01691	2023 NY Slip Op 04930
Matter of Katherine J. v Everlene S.		Docket No. O-02956/22 Appeal No. 664 Case No. 2022-05391	2023 NY Slip Op 04929
Invictus Global Mgt. LLC v GE Engine Servs., LLC		Index No. 652103/22 Appeal No. 692 Case No. 2023-00258	2023 NY Slip Op 04928
Matter of Hogue v Board of Educ. of the City Sch. Dist. of the City of N.Y.		Index No. 155400/22 Appeal No. 670 Case No. 2022-04898	2023 NY Slip Op 04927
Heykal Props., LLC v 450 W. 31st St. Owners Corp.		Index No. 653641/18 Appeal No. 694 Case No. 2022-04476	2023 NY Slip Op 04926
Franklin v Franklin		Index No. 310534/19 Appeal No. 698 Case No. 2023-00243	2023 NY Slip Op 04925
Fishbein v Goldman		Index No. 150975/18 Appeal No. 702 Case No. 2022-04085	2023 NY Slip Op 04924
Dille v Zoelle LLC		Index No. 157435/2022 Appeal No. 697 Case No. 2023-00519	2023 NY Slip Op 04923
Coon v WFP Tower B Co. L.P.		Index No. 151837/16 Appeal No. 691 Case No. 2022-01413	2023 NY Slip Op 04922
Castaneda v Amsterco 67, LLC		Index No. 30981/19E Appeal No. 665 Case No. 2022-03262	2023 NY Slip Op 04921
Board of Mgrs. of the 15 Union Sq. W. Condominium v Azogui		Index No. 162500/15 Appeal No. 669 Case No. 2022-03233	2023 NY Slip Op 04920
Bizounouya v CNA Ins. Co.		Index No. 300082/19 Appeal No. 705&M-3854 Case No. 2022/05399	2023 NY Slip Op 04919
Bich v Bich		Index No. 652092/20 Appeal No. 674 Case No. 2022-01083	2023 NY Slip Op 04918
1591 Second Ave. LLC v Metropolitan Transp. Auth.		Index No. 161539/15 Appeal No. 683-684 Case No. 2022-02279, 2022-04177	2023 NY Slip Op 04916