Appellate Division, First Department Decisions

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

**Cases Decided January 30, 2024**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
245 E. 19 Realty LLC v 245 E. 19th St. Parking LLC		Index No. 651004/22 Appeal No. 1547 Case No. 2023-04598	2024 NY Slip Op 00368
Dong v GTV Media Group., Inc.		Index No. 652190/21 Appeal No. 1552 Case No. 2023-00202	2024 NY Slip Op 00399
Yang v Knights Genesis Group		Index No. 651118/21 Appeal No. 1568 Case No. 2023-00649	2024 NY Slip Op 00398
Estate of Tawil v Sutton		Index No. 653633/15 Appeal No. 1560 Case No. 2022-05752	2024 NY Slip Op 00397
Sylvan Hosp.ity Group, Inc. v St. Giles Hotel, LLC		Index No. 150582/22 Appeal No. 1563 Case No. 2023-00653	2024 NY Slip Op 00396
Rodriguez v Miller Plumbing & Heating, Inc.		Index No. 452253/16, 595080/19 Appeal No. 1561 Case No. 2022-05005	2024 NY Slip Op 00395
Rivas v Restaurant Assoc., Inc.		Index No. 151379/18 Appeal No. 1554 Case No. 2023-03362	2024 NY Slip Op 00394
Pujols v Pros on the Move, LLC		Index No. 29855/20 Appeal No. 1540 Case No. 2023-01937	2024 NY Slip Op 00393
Perkins Eastman Architects, D.P.C. v White Plains Hosp. Med. Ctr., Inc.		Index No. 653890/22 Appeal No. 1551 Case No. 2023-03738	2024 NY Slip Op 00392
People v Osbourne		Ind. No. 1420/02 Appeal No. 1548 Case No. 2021-04400	2024 NY Slip Op 00391
People v Ramirez	MENDEZ, J.	Ind. No. 5809/13 Appeal No. 1093 Case No. 2019-05011	2024 NY Slip Op 00390
People v National Rifle Assn. of Am.		Index No. 451625/20 Appeal No. 1558 Case No. 2022-05432	2024 NY Slip Op 00389
People v Herrera		Ind. No. 949/15 Appeal No. 1566 Case No. 2017-2154	2024 NY Slip Op 00388
People v Holt		Ind. No. 2830/14 Appeal No. 1559 Case No. 2016-2637	2024 NY Slip Op 00387
People v Williams		Ind. No. 1500/18 Appeal No. 1537 Case No. 2021-04543	2024 NY Slip Op 00386
People v Abreu		Ind. No. 1318/19 Appeal No. 1535 Case No. 2022-04735	2024 NY Slip Op 00385
People v Benbow		Ind. No. 01418/21 Appeal No. 1553 Case No. 2023-02912	2024 NY Slip Op 00384
People v Scott		Ind. No. 3639/16 Appeal No. 1556 Case No. 2018-4540	2024 NY Slip Op 00383
People v Flores		Ind. No. 2243/19 Appeal No. 1539 Case No. 2020-04117	2024 NY Slip Op 00382
Mora v Branker		Index No. 150816/18 Appeal No. 1557 Case No. 2023-01126	2024 NY Slip Op 00381
Mercedes v Cool Wind Ventilation Corp.		Index No. 151002/22 Appeal No. 1550 Case No. 2023-02516	2024 NY Slip Op 00380
Maldonado v Hines 1045 Ave. of the Ams. Invs. LLC		Index No. 152214/15 Appeal No. 1546 Case No. 2023-00135	2024 NY Slip Op 00379
Leili v Romanello		Index No. 159603/16 Appeal No. 1536 Case No. 2023-01597	2024 NY Slip Op 00378
Hribovsek v United Cerebral Palsy of N.Y. City		Index No. 152849/17 Appeal No. 1463 Case No. 2022-05615	2024 NY Slip Op 00377
Hardy Way, LLC v Yap		Index No. 653101/17 Appeal No. 1541-1545 Case No. 2022-03645, 2022-05042, 2022-05043, 2022-05234, 2022-05471	2024 NY Slip Op 00376
Gavrielov v Unger Consulting Group Ltd.		Index No. 157950/21 Appeal No. 1549 Case No. 2023-01114	2024 NY Slip Op 00375
Ferreyra v Wayne		Index No. 805173/16 Appeal No. 1538 Case No. 2022-03654	2024 NY Slip Op 00374
Fernandez v Hoke		Index No. 805052/19 Appeal No. 1431-1432 Case No. 2022-05533, 2023-01438	2024 NY Slip Op 00373
Etienne v MTA N.Y. City Tr. Auth.		Index No. 155727/22 Appeal No. 1567 Case No. 2023-02797	2024 NY Slip Op 00372
DB 232 Seigel Mezz LLC v Moskovits		Index No. 652080/22 Appeal No. 1564-1565 Case No. 2022-04306, 2022-04820	2024 NY Slip Op 00371
CitiMortgage, Inc. v Pantoja		Index No. 13637/06 Appeal No. 1555 Case No. 2023-03041	2024 NY Slip Op 00370
Chazen v Ma		Index No. 656954/22 Appeal No. 1562 Case No. 2023-01141	2024 NY Slip Op 00369

**Cases Decided January 25, 2024**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Rey Ramon J.L. (Yesenia D.L.)		Index No. B-11108/20 Appeal No. 1521 Case No. 2023-00798	2024 NY Slip Op 00357
Werner v Jag 1st Ave Realty LLC		Index No. 150013/20 Appeal No. 1527 Case No. 2023-03657	2024 NY Slip Op 00366
Vasquez v Manhattan Coll.		Index No. 28636/19 Appeal No. 1523 Case No. 2023-01676	2024 NY Slip Op 00365
People v Dyer		Ind. No. 4974/11 Appeal No. 118 Case No. 2017-2250	2024 NY Slip Op 00364
People v Guity		Ind. No. 3452/18 Appeal No. 991 Case No. 2020-03501	2024 NY Slip Op 00363
People v Leighton R.		Ind. No. 1885/14 Appeal No. 1519 Case No. 2017-03013	2024 NY Slip Op 00362
People v Alfonso		Ind. No. 2853/10 Appeal No. 1528 Case No. 2013-02331	2024 NY Slip Op 00361
People v Garcia		SCI No. 2758/15 Appeal No. 1533 Case No. 2019-1187	2024 NY Slip Op 00360
Matter of Sang Seok Na v Cohen		Index No. 42042/22 Appeal No. 1532 Case No. 2023-03625	2024 NY Slip Op 00359
McGovern v St. Luke's-Roosevelt Hosp. Ctr.		Index No. 150602/20 Appeal No. 1530 Case No. 2023-01773	2024 NY Slip Op 00358
Carboni v Alfa Romeo USA		Index No. 190328/19 Appeal No. 1520 Case No. 2023-00777	2024 NY Slip Op 00351
KSP Constr., LLC v LV Prop. Two, LLC	Higgitt, J.,	Index No. 656646/19 Appeal No. 1056 Case No. 2022-02921	2024 NY Slip Op 00356
Khurdayan v Kassir		Index No. 159480/17 Appeal No. 1529 Case No. 2023-01250	2024 NY Slip Op 00355
Matter of Khorassani v Financial Indus. Regulatory Auth.		Index No. 153819/23 Appeal No. 1534 Case No. 2023-03770	2024 NY Slip Op 00354
JDS Constr. Group LLC v Copper Servs., LLC		Index No. 656912/20 Appeal No. 1524-1525 Case No. 2023-03014, 2023-03015	2024 NY Slip Op 00353
Cropper v New York City Tr. Auth.		Index No. 154550/21 Appeal No. 1526 Case No. 2023-02261	2024 NY Slip Op 00352

**Cases Decided January 23, 2024**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of 3061-63 Third Ave. LLC v Soliman		Index No. 817589/21 Appeal No. 1507 Case No. 2023-03511	2024 NY Slip Op 00256
Wagner Assoc. LLC v PFNY, LLC		Index No. 150583/18, 650426/18 Appeal No. 1493-1494 Case No. 2023-00170, 2023-00167	2024 NY Slip Op 00288
Thomas v Triboro Maintenance Corp.		Index No. 31033/17 Appeal No. 1499 Case No. 2022-04807	2024 NY Slip Op 00287
Stevens v Skolnik		Index No. 101498/19 Appeal No. 1504 Case No. 2022-03183	2024 NY Slip Op 00286
SHC-MG-25 Doe v Archdiocese of N.Y.		Index No. 950743/20 Appeal No. 1237 Case No. 2023-00736	2024 NY Slip Op 00285
Reyes v Perez		Index No. 21863/18, 27203/18 Appeal No. 1513 Case No. 2023-00882	2024 NY Slip Op 00284
Pitter-Green v NYU Langone Med. Ctr.		Index No. 155386/21 Appeal No. 1385 Case No. 2023-00123	2024 NY Slip Op 00283
People v McFarlane		Ind. No. 71936/22 Appeal No. 1510 Case No. 2023-01436	2024 NY Slip Op 00282
People v Tully		Ind. No. 879/17 Appeal No. 1503 Case No. 2019-05339	2024 NY Slip Op 00281
People v Smith		Ind. No. 416/17 Appeal No. 1488 Case No. 2021-02061	2024 NY Slip Op 00280
People v Jolivert		Ind. No. 1231/15 Appeal No. 1517 Case No. 2018-4786	2024 NY Slip Op 00279
People v Brickhouse		Ind. No. 195/18 Appeal No. 1501 Case No. 2019-1146	2024 NY Slip Op 00278
People v Johnson		Ind. No. 277/20, SCI No. 1440/20 Appeal No. 1495-1495A Case No. 2021-00095	2024 NY Slip Op 00277
Meyer v Cabot Lodge Sec. LLC		Index No. 653746/22 Appeal No. 1515 Case No. 2023-03243	2024 NY Slip Op 00276
Maurizaca v 201 Water St., LLC		Index No. 159770/15, 595628/17, 595162/18 Appeal No. 1492 Case No. 2023-02178	2024 NY Slip Op 00275
Matter of Lilly	PER CURIAM	Motion No. 2023-04850 Case No. 2023-03062	2024 NY Slip Op 00274
Matter of Kort	PER CURIAM	Motion No. 2023-04516 Case No. 2023-05153	2024 NY Slip Op 00273
Landis v 383 Realty Corp.		File No. 2017-1388/B, Index No. 653847/15 Appeal No. 1506 Case No. 2023-01239	2024 NY Slip Op 00272
Matter of K.A.M. (Rayshawn H.--Niteskia B.)		Docket No. NN-12701/21, NN-12702/21 Appeal No. 1505 Case No. 2023-02540	2024 NY Slip Op 00271
J.K. v City of New York		Index No. 950684/20 Appeal No. 1500 Case No. 2023-01101	2024 NY Slip Op 00270
Gilliard v Manhattan Nuvo LLC		Index No. 29967/18 Appeal No. 1514 Case No. 2023-00454	2024 NY Slip Op 00269
Eastern Effects, Inc. v 3911 Lemmon Ave. Assoc., LLC		Index No. 652152/22 Appeal No. 1509 Case No. 2023-00137	2024 NY Slip Op 00268
E.S. v Windsor Owners Corp.	OING, J.	Index No. 159133/17 Appeal No. 778 Case No. 2022-04295	2024 NY Slip Op 00267
E.D. v Intercontinental Hotels Group		Index No. 159963/17 Appeal No. 1518 Case No. 2022-02144	2024 NY Slip Op 00266
Degraffe v City of New York		Index No. 451555/18 Appeal No. 1516 Case No. 2023-05005	2024 NY Slip Op 00265
Cosme v City of New York		Index No. 30370/17 Appeal No. 1412 Case No. 2022-05732	2024 NY Slip Op 00264
Churchill Owners Corp. v Kent		Index No. 650052/22 Appeal No. 1497-1498 Case No. 2023-03027, 2023-03037	2024 NY Slip Op 00263
Matter of Bautista v New York City Hous. Auth.		Index No. 812977/21 Appeal No. 1502 Case No. 2023-01065	2024 NY Slip Op 00262
Matter of Bajraktari Realty Corp. v Soliman		Index No. 806662/21 Appeal No. 1508 Case No. 2022-02151	2024 NY Slip Op 00261
Matter of Atreyu L.B. v Chyann R.		Docket No. O-23721-22/23A, O-23722-22/23A, O-23721-22, O-23722-22 Appeal No. 1490-1490A-1490B Case No. 2023-02120, 2023-02121, 2023-02122	2024 NY Slip Op 00260
Allied World Assur. Co. (U.S.) Inc. v Greater N.Y. Mut. Ins. Co.		Index No. 651635/21 Appeal No. 1511-1512 Case No. 2023-03085, 2023-03668	2024 NY Slip Op 00259
Abdulfattaah v Riverbay Corp.		Index No. 300164/14 Appeal No. 1496 Case No. 2023-00343	2024 NY Slip Op 00258
5AIF Sycamore 2, LLC v 201 EB Dev. III		Index No. 850190/21 Appeal No. 1489 Case No. 2023-00472	2024 NY Slip Op 00257

**Cases Decided January 18, 2024**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Andino v Wizards Studios N. Inc.		Index No. 161437/18 Appeal No. 1476 Case No. 2022-05029	2024 NY Slip Op 00220
Wright v City of New York		Index No. 805963/21 Appeal No. 1453 Case No. 2023-03221	2024 NY Slip Op 00253
Tour Cent. Park Inc. v Thor 38 Park Row LLC		Index No. 651406/21 Appeal No. 1449 Case No. 2022-05773	2024 NY Slip Op 00252
Matter of Sidy T.		Docket No. D3571/22 Appeal No. 1468 Case No. 2022-04847	2024 NY Slip Op 00251
Richardson v Garely		Index No. 805308/17 Appeal No. 1465 Case No. 2022-04692	2024 NY Slip Op 00250
Matter of PricewaterhouseCoopers, LLP v Cahill		Index No. 653664/20 Appeal No. 1486-1487 Case No. 2022-1850 2022-02277	2024 NY Slip Op 00249
People v Lewis	PITT-BURKE, J.	Index No. 72876/22 Appeal No. 1054 Case No. 2023-02116	2024 NY Slip Op 00248
People v Radesco		Ind No. 3086/15 Appeal No. 1475 Case No. 2019-3842	2024 NY Slip Op 00247
People v Collier		Ind No. 24421C/09 Appeal No. 1483 Case No. 2015-1913	2024 NY Slip Op 00246
People v Ortiz		Ind No. 3147/17 Appeal No. 1471 Case No. 2019-3886	2024 NY Slip Op 00245
People v Talavera		Ind No. 39-2017 Appeal No. 1459M-4960 Case No. 2022-03928	2024 NY Slip Op 00244
People v Parrilla		Ind No. 72831/22 Appeal No. 1466 Case No. 2023-02118	2024 NY Slip Op 00243
People v Marquise M.		Ind No. 802/17 Appeal No. 1448 Case No. 2019-1839	2024 NY Slip Op 00242
People v Coulibaly		Ind No. 1973/16 Appeal No. 1452 Case No. 2017-3061	2024 NY Slip Op 00241
People v Unger		Ind No. 3153/16 Appeal No. 1482 Case No. 2019-810	2024 NY Slip Op 00240
People v Tolbert		ndex No. 71416/22 Appeal No. 1480M-4329 Case No. 2022-02823	2024 NY Slip Op 00239
People v Ikpemgbe		Ind No. 70236/22 Appeal No. 1444 Case No. 2022-04141	2024 NY Slip Op 00238
People v Santiago		Ind No. 2938/18 Appeal No. 1450 Case No. 2019-03549	2024 NY Slip Op 00237
People v Ufret		Ind No. 932/21, 1089/21 Appeal No. 1462 Case No. 2022-05001, 2022-05053	2024 NY Slip Op 00236
Parada v Herron		Index No. 306831/14 Appeal No. 1484-1485 Case No. 2022-05384 2023-01720	2024 NY Slip Op 00235
Merrick v Macerich Co.		Index No. 158681/16 Appeal No. 1478-1479 Case No. 2023-02175	2024 NY Slip Op 00234
Mensah v New York Inst. of Tech.		Index No. 100068/23 Appeal No. 1460-1461 Case No. 2023-02744 2023-02745	2024 NY Slip Op 00233
Matter of Tessler	PER CURIAM	Motion No. 2023-04832 Case No. 2023-00890	2024 NY Slip Op 00232
Marte v Tishman Constr. Corp.		Index No. 154819/17 Appeal No. 1477 Case No. 2022-05303	2024 NY Slip Op 00231
Louis v City of New York		Index No. 30357/18 Appeal No. 1447 Case No. 2022-01756	2024 NY Slip Op 00230
Janet Transit, Inc. v Mott Haven Improvement Group LP.		Index No. 809181/22 Appeal No. 1470M-3962 Case No. 2022-04962	2024 NY Slip Op 00229
J.T. Magen & Co. Inc. v Nissan N. Am., Inc.		Index No. 160497/17 Appeal No. 1451 Case No. 2023-00124	2024 NY Slip Op 00228
Fifth & Fifty-Fifth Residence Club Assn., Inc. v Vistana Signature Experiences, Inc.		Index No. 151907/19 Appeal No. 1464 Case No. 2022-05747	2024 NY Slip Op 00227
Fata v Heskel's Riverdale, LLC		Index No. 34350/20 Appeal No. 1445-1446 Case No. 2023-04379 2023-04779	2024 NY Slip Op 00226
PC-16 Doe v Hill Regional Career High Sch.		Index No. 950364/20 Appeal No. 1172 Case No. 2022-04637	2024 NY Slip Op 00225
Diaz v New York City Health & Hosps. Corp.		Index No. 27388/17 Appeal No. 1481 Case No. 2021-03855	2024 NY Slip Op 00224
CMB Export Infrastructure Inv. Group 48, LP v Motcomb Estates, Ltd.		Index No. 653821/22 Appeal No. 1472-1473-1474-1474A Case No. 2023-01142, 2023-01955, 2023-01979 2023-03818	2024 NY Slip Op 00223
Casiano v City of New York		Index No. 157840/17 Appeal No. 1467 Case No. 2022-03777	2024 NY Slip Op 00222
Bradley v NYU Langone Hosps.		Index No. 161006/18 595521/19 Appeal No. 1454 Case No. 2023-00378	2024 NY Slip Op 00221

**Cases Decided January 16, 2024**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
3rd & 60th Assoc. Sub LLC v Zavolunov		Index No. 152736/22 Appeal No. 893 Case No. 2023-03208	2024 NY Slip Op 00160
Woods v Harris-Camden Terminal Equip. Inc.		Index No. 28993/18 Appeal No. 1435 Case No. 2023-00901	2024 NY Slip Op 00177
Verna v Little Richie Bus Serv. Inc.		Index No. 156195/19 Appeal No. 1437 Case No. 2023-01290	2024 NY Slip Op 00176
Matter of Annette R. v Dakiem E.D.		Dkt No. V-0274-17/18A, V-0274-17/21B Appeal No. 1424 Case No. 2022-01138	2024 NY Slip Op 00175
Matter of Lam Quan, MD, PC v GEICO Gen. Ins. Co.		Index No. 651286/23 Appeal No. 1423 Case No. 2023-03165	2024 NY Slip Op 00174
People v Smith		Ind No. 4352/09, 0036/10 Appeal No. 1429-1429A Case No. 2016-2629	2024 NY Slip Op 00173
People v Bryant		Ind. No. 480-19 Appeal No. 1436 Case No. 2022-01446	2024 NY Slip Op 00172
People v Murphy		Ind. No. 1674/19 Appeal No. 1426 Case No. 2022-04731	2024 NY Slip Op 00171
People v Robert M.		Ind. No. 1031/16 Appeal No. 1433 Case No. 2018-3292	2024 NY Slip Op 00170
People v Rivera		Ind. No. 3492/18 Appeal No. 1422 Case No. 2019-04907	2024 NY Slip Op 00169
Murray v Consolidated Edison of N.Y., Inc.		Index No. 34175/18 Appeal No. 1427-1428 Case No. 2022-05623, 2022-05596	2024 NY Slip Op 00168
Matter of Medallion Fin. Corp. v Rucker		Index No. 812275/21 Appeal No. 1430 Case No. 2022-05532	2024 NY Slip Op 00167
Long v Cushman & Wakefield, Inc.		Index No. 153118/18, 595049/21, 595152/21 Appeal No. 627 Case No. 2022-03997	2024 NY Slip Op 00166
Matter of Chiu Wing Kwok v City of N.Y. Off. of Admin. Trials & Hearings (OATH)		Index No. 153712/22 Appeal No. 1208 Case No. 2022-05262	2024 NY Slip Op 00165
IHG Harlem I LLC v 406 Manhattan LLC	KAPNICK, J.	Index No. 161863/15 Appeal No. 774-775 Case No. 2022-05636, 2022-05637	2024 NY Slip Op 00164
Hotel 237, LLC v G.M. Canmar Residence Corp.		Index No. 657772/19 Appeal No. 1441-1442 Case No. 2022-02270, 2022-02278	2024 NY Slip Op 00163
Bunjaj v 37 W. 20 Co.		Index No. 33160/19, 43085/20 Appeal No. 1425 Case No. 2022-05439	2024 NY Slip Op 00162
75 First Ave. Club LLC v United Glass Sys. Corp.		Index No. 652658/22 Appeal No. 1434 Case No. 2023-03185	2024 NY Slip Op 00161

**Cases Decided January 11, 2024**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
63rd & 3rd NYC LLC v Advanced Contr. Solutions, LLC	Index No. 656164/19 Appeal No. 1387 Case No. 2022-02104	2024 NY Slip Op 00120
Matter of Williams v New York City Hous. Auth.	Index No. 100176/19 Appeal No. 1325 Case No. 2023-00480	2024 NY Slip Op 00156
S.M. v Madura	Index No. 815695/21 Appeal No. 1404 Case No. 2022-03589	2024 NY Slip Op 00155
Rosario v Cao	Index No. 24404/19 Appeal No. 1405 Case No. 2022-05313	2024 NY Slip Op 00154
Rivera v Bhuiyan	Index No. 25912/15 Appeal No. 1408-1409 Case No. 2023-01433, 2023-02132	2024 NY Slip Op 00153
Port Morris Distillery, Inc. v Global Estate LLC	Index No. 28397/18 Appeal No. 1402 Case No. 2023-02363	2024 NY Slip Op 00152
People v Davis	Ind. No. 73413/22 Appeal No. 1406 Case No. 2023-00957	2024 NY Slip Op 00151
People v Sanchez	Ind. No. 876/18 Appeal No. 1414 Case No. 2020-00461	2024 NY Slip Op 00150
People v Aviles	Ind. No. 99001/18 Appeal No. 1380 Case No. 2018-03253	2024 NY Slip Op 00149
People v Williams	Ind. No. 14/15 Appeal No. 1399 Case No. 2018/5393	2024 NY Slip Op 00148
People v Swinton	Ind. No. 721/19 Appeal No. 1393 Case No. 2019-04882	2024 NY Slip Op 00147
People v Jaquan K.	Ind. No. 233/20, 2281/19 Appeal No. 1419-1419A Case No. 2023-00036	2024 NY Slip Op 00146
People v Collazo	Ind. No. 1501/17 Appeal No. 1401 Case No. 2018-04046	2024 NY Slip Op 00145
People v Samuel	Ind. No. 3402/16 Appeal No. 1390-1390A Case No. 2018-1885, 2022-02520	2024 NY Slip Op 00144
People v Martinez	Ind. No. 763/16 Appeal No. 1386-1386A Case No. 2019-1830, 2022-03761	2024 NY Slip Op 00143
People v Stepney	Ind. No. 848/21 Appeal No. 1411 Case No. 2023-01000	2024 NY Slip Op 00142
OKL Holdings, Inc v Abercrombie & Fitch Stores Inc.	Index No. 651061/23 Appeal No. 1389 Case No. 2023-03183	2024 NY Slip Op 00141
Matthew v DeRose	Index No. 31141/17 Appeal No. 1383-1384 Case No. 2023-00490, 2023-03229	2024 NY Slip Op 00140
Manson-Frempong v Forbes	Index No. 29389/18 Appeal No. 1397 Case No. 2022-05168	2024 NY Slip Op 00139
Matter of Victor M., III v Adriana Y.	V-20932/18 V-25505/18 Docket No. V-20932/18, V-25505/18 Appeal No. 1382-1382A Case No. 2022-02835, 2023-01176	2024 NY Slip Op 00138
Matter of Ethan M. (Miguel M.)	Docket No. NN-08085/21 Appeal No. 1403-1403A Case No. 2023-00220	2024 NY Slip Op 00137
Matter of Lamar v Nigro	Index No. 151535/22 Appeal No. 1392 Case No. 2022-03629	2024 NY Slip Op 00136
Matter of Kralik v New York City Dept. of Hous. Preserv. & Dev.	Index No. 154431/22 Appeal No. 1394 Case No. 2023-01324	2024 NY Slip Op 00135
Jones v Vornado N.Y. RR One L.L.C.	Index No. 159102/15 Appeal No. 1398 Case No. 2022-05650	2024 NY Slip Op 00134
Hunte v Cubesmart Self Stor.	Index No. 2713/22 Appeal No. 1396 Case No. 2022-05380	2024 NY Slip Op 00133
Hockaday v Hessel	Index No. 813356/21 Appeal No. 1388 Case No. 2023-01642	2024 NY Slip Op 00132
Ferrer v Williams	Index No. 21955/17 Appeal No. 1421 Case No. 2023-00237	2024 NY Slip Op 00131
Xuezhen Dong v Cruz-Marte	Index No. 23584/17 Appeal No. 1395 Case No. 2023-02016	2024 NY Slip Op 00130
De Diaz v Klausner	Index No. 30368/19 Appeal No. 1418 Case No. 2023-01429	2024 NY Slip Op 00129
Deprospo v Nixon-Cochran	Index No. 350720/09 Appeal No. 1417 Case No. 2023-00087	2024 NY Slip Op 00128
Chalas v Grass Roots Kitchen, LLC	Index No. 24402/20 Appeal No. 1415 Case No. 2023-02500	2024 NY Slip Op 00127
Castillo v TRM Contr. 626, LLC	Index No. 23185/19 Appeal No. 1413 Case No. 2023-01201	2024 NY Slip Op 00126
Candelario v MJHS Hospice & Palliative Care, Inc.	Index No. 25246/16 Appeal No. 1381 Case No. 2023-00954	2024 NY Slip Op 00125
Bucci v City of New York	Index No. 34069/19 Appeal No. 1407 Case No. 2022-04531	2024 NY Slip Op 00124
Baymen Indus., Ltd. v Empire City Subway Co. (Ltd.)	Index No. 650743/20 Appeal No. 1391 Case No. 2022-05492	2024 NY Slip Op 00123
Ardel Constr. & Design Group, Inc. v VBG 990 AOA, LLC	Index No. 654671/21 Appeal No. 1400 Case No. 2023-00837	2024 NY Slip Op 00122
Alexi Home Design, Inc. v Union Mut. Fire Ins. Co.	Index No. 21042/19 Appeal No. 1416 Case No. 2023-01891	2024 NY Slip Op 00121

**Cases Decided January 9, 2024**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Shawmut Woodworking & Supply, Inc. v Cord Contr. Co. Inc.	Index No. 154088/16 Appeal No. 1365 Case No. 2022-03996	2024 NY Slip Op 00044
Wojcik Law Firm, P.C. v Mull	Index No. 650071/19 Appeal No. 1367 Case No. 2022-01674	2024 NY Slip Op 00060
Tadco Constr. Corp. v General Contrs. Assn. of N.Y., Inc.	Index No. 656320/20 Appeal No. 1378 Case No. 2023-01834	2024 NY Slip Op 00059
Supply Co., LLC v Hardy Way, LLC	Index No. 652885/16 Appeal No. 1370-1371-1372-1373 Case No. 2022-03647, 2022-04137, 2022-05141, 2022-05297	2024 NY Slip Op 00058
Sinera v Embassy House Eat LLC	Index No. 24647/13 Appeal No. 1359 Case No. 2023-00743	2024 NY Slip Op 00057
People v McPherson	SCI No. 1056/19 Appeal No. 1366 Case No. 2019-03820	2024 NY Slip Op 00056
People v Williams	Ind. No. 2551/19 Appeal No. 1374 Case No. 2020-03661	2024 NY Slip Op 00055
People v Gray	Ind. No. 2948/19 Appeal No. 1363 Case No. 2022-02340	2024 NY Slip Op 00054
People v Beard	Ind. No. 4661/17 Appeal No. 1356 Case No. 2020-04927	2024 NY Slip Op 00053
People v Rucker	SCI No. 2673/17 Appeal No. 1377 Case No. 2019-3010	2024 NY Slip Op 00052
Matter of Ortiz v New York State Dept. of Motor Vehs.	Index No. 814921/22E Appeal No. 1369 Case No. 2023-03787	2024 NY Slip Op 00051
Mironov v Memorial Hosp. for Cancer & Allied Disease	Index No. 155433/17 Appeal No. 1375 Case No. 2023-04164	2024 NY Slip Op 00050
Matter of Marcie A.M. v Joseph A.C.	Docket No. F-45145-15/19A Appeal No. 1358 Case No. 2023-03617	2024 NY Slip Op 00049
Maldonado v Young & Booby Realty Corp.	Index No. 21196/15 Appeal No. 1362 Case No. 2022-04486	2024 NY Slip Op 00048
Lindemann v VNO 100 W. 33rd St. LLC	Index No. 159374/15, 595849/15, 595864/18 Appeal No. 1376 Case No. 2022-03138	2024 NY Slip Op 00047
Keri v Beye	Index No. 27076/19E Appeal No. 1360-1361 Case No. 2022-04335, 2023-01882	2024 NY Slip Op 00046
Castellotti v Free	Index No. 158162/12 Appeal No. 1379 Case No. 2023-03279	2024 NY Slip Op 00045

**Cases Decided January 4, 2024**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Amelia A. (Saul A.)		Docket No. N7289/20 Appeal No. 1338 Case No. 2023-00543	2024 NY Slip Op 00018
Titan Indus. Servs. Corp. v Navigators Ins. Co.		Index No. 653882/19 Appeal No. 1351 Case No. 2022-05718	2024 NY Slip Op 00041
Teixeira v Teixeira		Index No. 320063/21 Appeal No. 1339 Case No. 2022-05555	2024 NY Slip Op 00040
Tamar Equities Corp. v Signature Barbershop 33 Inc.		Index No. 152046/22 Appeal No. 1153 Case No. 2023-03999	2024 NY Slip Op 00039
SRS Enters., Inc. v Rosemex, Inc.		Index No. 653924/21 Appeal No. 1348 Case No. 2022-05294	2024 NY Slip Op 00038
Shineco, Inc. v Lei Zhang		Index No. 160669/21 Appeal No. 1344 Case No. 2022-04509	2024 NY Slip Op 00037
Richardson v New York City Hous. Auth.		Index No. 153556/22 Appeal No. 1352 Case No. 2023-00041	2024 NY Slip Op 00036
People v Foreman		Ind No. 488/17 SCI No. 377/16 Appeal No. 1336 Case No. 2019-4383	2024 NY Slip Op 00035
People v Story		Ind No. 6605/96 Appeal No. 1341 Case No. 2021-03099	2024 NY Slip Op 00034
People v Esquilin		Ind No. 3109/14, 9784/98 Appeal No. 1353-1353A Case No. 2022-00427	2024 NY Slip Op 00033
People v Hoover		Ind No. 151/18 2640/18 Appeal No. 1350-1350A Case No. 2019-784, 2019-800	2024 NY Slip Op 00032
People v Robbins		Ind No. 2199/18 Appeal No. 782 Case No. 2021-02597	2024 NY Slip Op 00031
People v Reyes		Ind No. 4400/15 Appeal No. 1345 Case No. 2018-4617	2024 NY Slip Op 00030
Matter of Pawel v Justice Ctr. for the Protection of People with Special Needs		Index No. 157542/21 Appeal No. 1263 Case No. 2023-02408	2024 NY Slip Op 00029
Nationwide Gen. Ins. Co. v South		Index No. 154533/21 Appeal No. 1337 Case No. 2023-02237	2024 NY Slip Op 00028
Matter of Melville	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2023-04377 Case No. 2022-05820	2024 NY Slip Op 00027
Matter of Grant	PER CURIAM	Motion No. 2023-04521 Case No. 2023-05157	2024 NY Slip Op 00026
Kramer v Bailey Rest. Group. Inc.		Index No. 157987/17 Appeal No. 1349 Case No. 2023-01791	2024 NY Slip Op 00025
Fuschi v JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.		Index No. 802907/22 Appeal No. 1346 Case No. 2022-03586	2024 NY Slip Op 00024
East 54th Operating LLC v Brevard Owners, Inc.		Index No. 154045/23 Appeal No. 1343 Case No. 2023-03242	2024 NY Slip Op 00023
Continuum Energy Tech., LLC v Iron Oak, Inc. (USA)		Index No. 657219/21, 595270/22 Appeal No. 1347 Case No. 2022-05628	2024 NY Slip Op 00022
Coffman v A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co.		Index No. 190137/16 Appeal No. 1340 Case No. 2022-03091	2024 NY Slip Op 00021
Chan v Havemeyer Holdings LLC		Index No. 652359/22 Appeal No. 1233 Case No. 2023-02683	2024 NY Slip Op 00020
Matter of Barton LLP v Maybank		Index No. 654372/22 Appeal No. 1342 Case No. 2023-02968	2024 NY Slip Op 00019