Appellate Division, First Department Decisions

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

**Cases Decided May 31, 2024**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Davis v Clennon		Index No. 153378/24 Appeal No. 2542 Case No. 2024-03120	2024 NY Slip Op 03004

**Cases Decided May 30, 2024**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Citibank, N.A. v N/A	Index No. 652233/22 Appeal No. 2392 Case No. 2023-01432	2024 NY Slip Op 02975
Albert M. Watson Photography Inc. v Kartheiser	Index No. 155000/16 Appeal No. 2384 Case No. 2023-05062	2024 NY Slip Op 03003
Trump v Trump	Index No. 453299/21 Appeal No. 2394 Case No. 2023-03021	2024 NY Slip Op 03002
Torres v Levy	Index No. 32953/18 Appeal No. 2413-2414 Case No. 2023-04228, 2023-04229	2024 NY Slip Op 03001
Matter of Yakov T. v Tracy S.	Docket No. U-15558-19 Appeal No. 2385 Case No. 2023-01801	2024 NY Slip Op 03000
Starr Indem. & Liab. Co. v Monte Carlo, LLC	Index No. 651045/13 Appeal No. 2204 Case No. 2024-00144	2024 NY Slip Op 02999
Sire Spirits, LLC v Beam Suntory, Inc.	Index No. 650799/23 Appeal No. 2410-2411 Case No. 2023-04891, 2023-04892	2024 NY Slip Op 02998
Rosenberg v Wilson	Index No. 804948/21 Appeal No. 2399 Case No. 2023-04941	2024 NY Slip Op 02997
Pursuit Credit Special Opportunity Fund, L.P. v Krunchcash, LLC	Index No. 651070/22 Appeal No. 2386-2387 Case No. 2023-04998, 2023-06254	2024 NY Slip Op 02996
Matter of People of the State of New York ex rel. Tobias v Martuscello	Index No. 810784/23 Appeal No. 2405 Case No. 2024-00921	2024 NY Slip Op 02995
People v Noboa	Ind. No. 567/18 Appeal No. 2400 Case No. 2019-05292	2024 NY Slip Op 02994
People v S.J.	Ind. No. 1987/21, 1491/21, SCI No. 72001/22 Appeal No. 2391-2391A Case No. 2022-05138	2024 NY Slip Op 02993
People v Busgith	Ind. No. 1434/14 Appeal No. 2383 Case No. 2017-02501	2024 NY Slip Op 02992
People v Park	Ind. No. 493/17 Appeal No. 2406 Case No. 2024-00380	2024 NY Slip Op 02991
Paleja v KP NY Operations LLC	Index No. 651826/20 Appeal No. 2408 Case No. 2022-04182	2024 NY Slip Op 02990
Manhattan Chrystie St. Dev. Fund, LLC v 215 Chrystie Invs. LLC	Index No. 651148/21 Appeal No. 2388 Case No. 2023-03970	2024 NY Slip Op 02989
Matter of Trina M. v Bryant P.	Index No. V-08834/18 Appeal No. 2393 Case No. 2020-01740	2024 NY Slip Op 02988
Licurgo-Villar v Samouha	Index No. 161930/18 Appeal No. 2397-2398 Case No. 2023-03749, 2023-03750	2024 NY Slip Op 02987
JTED46, Inc. v Espresso Dream, LLC	Index No. 652332/19 Appeal No. 2407 Case No. 2023-04787	2024 NY Slip Op 02986
Matter of Joseph v Sewell	Index No. 159873/22 Appeal No. 1987 & M-2024-01240 Case No. 2023-05198	2024 NY Slip Op 02985
Matter of Henn v Sewell	Index No. 152739/23 Appeal No. 2401 Case No. 2023-05125	2024 NY Slip Op 02984
Matter of GSB Gold Std. Corp. AG v Google LLC	Index No. 160880/22 Appeal No. 2396 Case No. 2023-05565	2024 NY Slip Op 02983
Matter of Good Lawgic, LLC v Merchan	Index No. 71543/23 Appeal No. 2486 & M-1928 Case No. 2024-02457	2024 NY Slip Op 02982
Glebow Realty Assoc. v Dietrich	Index No. 158123/21 Appeal No. 2440 Case No. 2022-05235	2024 NY Slip Op 02981
Dowlah v Professional Staff Congress	Index No. 151561/22 Appeal No. 2412 Case No. 2023-06121	2024 NY Slip Op 02980
Doherty v 730 Fifth Upper, LLC	Index No. 158538/18 Appeal No. 947 Case No. 2023-00233	2024 NY Slip Op 02979
Matter of Parvati D. (Roman D.)	Docket No. NN-12883-21 Appeal No. 2409 Case No. 2023-05793	2024 NY Slip Op 02978
Matter of Brandon D. v Emely A.	Docket No. V-01400/21, V-04475/21 Appeal No. 2402-2403 Case No. 2023-02208, 2023-02209	2024 NY Slip Op 02977
Matter of Under 21 v Drysdale	Case No. 2024-00942 Appeal No. 2416 Case No. 2024-00942	2024 NY Slip Op 02976
110 NC LLC v Bank of Am., N.A.	Index No. 652635/23 Appeal No. 2404 Case No. 2023-06614	2024 NY Slip Op 02974

**Cases Decided May 28, 2024**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of G.B. (Gary B.)	Docket No. NN-15312/22, NN-15313/22 Appeal No. 2369 Case No. 2023-02734	2024 NY Slip Op 02884
Zhang v Mastercard Inc.	Index No. 195529/22 Appeal No. 2372 Case No. 2023-04692	2024 NY Slip Op 02898
Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. v All Respondents for this Special Proceeding	Index No. 154984/21 Appeal No. 2375-2376&M-2040 Case No. 2023-05665, 2023-06440	2024 NY Slip Op 02897
Matter of N.R. (D.W.)	Docket No. N5005/22, N5006/22 Appeal No. 2377 Case No. 2023-03641, 2023-03642	2024 NY Slip Op 02896
Matter of Sea Ltd. Sec. Litig.	Index No. 151344/22 Appeal No. 2371 Case No. 2023-03081	2024 NY Slip Op 02895
People v Griffin	Ind. No. 1748/17 Appeal No. 2316 Case No. 2019-03551	2024 NY Slip Op 02894
People v Hidalgo	Ind. No. 1819/18 Appeal No. 2367 Case No. 2022-03702	2024 NY Slip Op 02893
Melgarejo v City of New York	Index No. 153534/21 Appeal No. 2380 Case No. 2023-05159	2024 NY Slip Op 02892
Kwan v HFZ Capital Group, LLC	Index No. 651518/23 Appeal No. 2381 Case No. 2023-04697	2024 NY Slip Op 02891
Intelli v New York City Dept. of Transp.	Index No. 162060/19 Appeal No. 2368 Case No. 2023-03275	2024 NY Slip Op 02890
Hall v Middleton	Index No. 655003/19 Appeal No. 2275 Case No. 2023-01330	2024 NY Slip Op 02889
Cimen v HQ Capital Real Estate L.P.	Index No. 656205/20 Appeal No. 2378 Case No. 2023-05068	2024 NY Slip Op 02888
Chongqing Huansong Indus. (Group) Co. Ltd. v Kinderhook Indus. LLC	Index No. 154507/23 Appeal No. 2370&M-1474&M-1188 Case No. 2023-05382	2024 NY Slip Op 02887
Matter of Bonifacio v Sewell	Index No. 152332/22 Appeal No. 2379 Case No. 2022-05305	2024 NY Slip Op 02886
Baxter v LPI, Inc.	Index No. 652844/22 Appeal No. 2373 Case No. 2023-03377	2024 NY Slip Op 02885

**Cases Decided May 23, 2024**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Bello v New York City Health & Hosps. Corp.		Index No. 305687/10, 43061/17 Appeal No. 2359 Case No. 2023-01439	2024 NY Slip Op 02864
Sternkopf v 395 Hudson N.Y., LLC		Index No. 160764/18, 595983/19, 595370/20, 595415/20, 595490/20 595578/20, 595579/20, 595612/20 Appeal No. 2355-2356 Case No. 2023-04465, 2023-04467	2024 NY Slip Op 02883
Smartmatic USA Corp. v Fox Corp.		Index No. 151136/21 Appeal No. 2353 Case No. 2023-06372	2024 NY Slip Op 02882
SanMiguel v Grimaldi	Rodriguez, J.	Index No. 24515/13 Appeal No. 1420 Case No. 2020-03823	2024 NY Slip Op 02881
Matter of L.M.R. (Kareem R.--Ashley P.E.)		Docket No. 11315-18/19 Appeal No. 2352 Case No. 2023-00128	2024 NY Slip Op 02880
People v Alam		Ind No. 5170/14 Appeal No. 2350 Case No. 2021-04508	2024 NY Slip Op 02879
People v Roland R.		Ind No. 1671/18 Appeal No. 2364 Case No. 2023-01420	2024 NY Slip Op 02878
People v Rivas-Grullon		Ind No. 2185/19 Appeal No. 2307 Case No. 2023-00965	2024 NY Slip Op 02877
People v Stricklin		Ind No. 73847/22 Appeal No. 2357 Case No. 2022-05176	2024 NY Slip Op 02876
Nassar v Macy's Inc.		Index No. 161207/14 Appeal No. 2362-2363 Case No. 2023-03590 2024-01126	2024 NY Slip Op 02875
MREF REIT Lender 2 LLC v FPG Maiden Holdings, LLC		Index No. 653189/22 Appeal No. 2354 Case No. 2023-03861	2024 NY Slip Op 02874
Matter of Trump v Merchan		Index No. 71543/23 Appeal No. 2457M-1953 Case No. 2024-02413	2024 NY Slip Op 02873
Matter of McIlwain	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2023-05302 Case No. 2023-06177	2024 NY Slip Op 02872
Matter of Hooker	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2024-00297 Case No. 2024-00390	2024 NY Slip Op 02871
Matter of Dancy	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2023-05705 Case No. 2023-06716	2024 NY Slip Op 02870
Kataman Metals LLC v Macquarie Futures USA, LLC		Index No. 651882/23 Appeal No. 2351 Case No. 2023-05079	2024 NY Slip Op 02869
Flowers v 73rd Townhouse, LLC		Index No. 651036/10 Appeal No. 2366 Case No. 2023-00819	2024 NY Slip Op 02868
First Commerce, LLC v St. Mark's Prop. Acquisition LLC		Index No. 850205/22 Appeal No. 2365 Case No. 2023-05501	2024 NY Slip Op 02867
Matter of Desis Rising Up & Moving v New York City Districting Commn.		Index No. 151762/23 Appeal No. 2358 Case No. 2023-03051	2024 NY Slip Op 02866
Board of Mgrs. of the 432 Park Condominium v 56th & Park (NY) Owner, LLC		Index No. 655617/21 595204/22 Appeal No. 2361 Case No. 2023-03510	2024 NY Slip Op 02865

**Cases Decided May 21, 2024**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Anandaraja v Icahn Sch. of Medicine at Mount Sinai		Index No. 159045/22 Appeal No. 2332 Case No. 2023-04160	2024 NY Slip Op 02769
Matter of Yedid v Sorkin		Index No. 161033/21, 152809/23 Appeal No. 2335-2336 Case No. 2023-05148, 2023-05106	2024 NY Slip Op 02791
Wilmington Sav. Fund Socy., FSB v Lau		Index No. 104792/09 Appeal No. 2339 Case No. 2022-05487	2024 NY Slip Op 02790
Umeh v New York City Health & Hosps. Corp.		Index No. 29886/20 Appeal No. 2340 Case No. 2023-03578	2024 NY Slip Op 02789
Matter of New York City Asbestos Litig.		Index No. 190225/18 Appeal No. 1944-1945 Case No. 2023-01490, 2023-06327	2024 NY Slip Op 02788
Rodriguez v Tri-Borough Certified Home Care, Ltd.		Index No. 152047/18 Appeal No. 2329 Case No. 2023-02569	2024 NY Slip Op 02787
Matter of New York City Asbestos Litig.		Index No. 190346/18 Appeal No. 2317 Case No. 2023-05032	2024 NY Slip Op 02786
People v Ivezic		Ind. No. 760/20 Appeal No. 2331 Case No. 2022-00563	2024 NY Slip Op 02785
People v Marten		Ind. No. 4196/13 Appeal No. 2327 Case No. 2018-2648	2024 NY Slip Op 02784
People v Mora		SCI No. 92/19, 93/19 Appeal No. 2345 Case No. 2019-2573	2024 NY Slip Op 02783
Matter of Patel v Macy's Inc.		Index No. 650755/22 Appeal No. 2326 Case No. 2022-05009	2024 NY Slip Op 02782
Matter of D.P. (L.C.)		Docket No. NN-09787/22 Appeal No. 2318 Case No. 2023-01233	2024 NY Slip Op 02781
Myzak v Rosania		Index No. 654542/22 Appeal No. 2320-2322 Case No. 2023-06150, 2024-00078, 2024-00088	2024 NY Slip Op 02780
Munoz v JDS Seagirt LLC		Index No. 154427/17 Appeal No. 2323 Case No. 2022-05372	2024 NY Slip Op 02779
Medallion Fin. Corp. v Nelsk Taxi Inc.		Index No. 650367/19 Appeal No. 2349 Case No. 2023-04224	2024 NY Slip Op 02778
Goldman v Abraham Heschel Sch.		Index No. 158209/21 Appeal No. 2338 Case No. 2023-04691	2024 NY Slip Op 02777
Fifth Partners LLC v Foley		Index No. 161105/21 Appeal No. 2341-2342-2343-2344 Case No. 2023-04898, 2023-04899, 2023-04901, 2023-05556	2024 NY Slip Op 02776
De Los Santos v Carlyle House Inc.		Index No. 28573/17 Appeal No. 2319 Case No. 2023-01686	2024 NY Slip Op 02775
Clover Private Credit Opportunities Origination (Levered) II, L.P. v Sanberg		Index No. 652063/23 Appeal No. 2346 Case No. 2024-00912	2024 NY Slip Op 02774
Cedar Grove Capital Partners v Ehrlich		Index No. 654986/22 Appeal No. 2328 Case No. 2023-02726	2024 NY Slip Op 02773
Campbell v City of New York		Index No. 20810/19 Appeal No. 2334 Case No. 2023-04532	2024 NY Slip Op 02772
Matter of Bentkowski v City of New York	Gesmer, J.	Index No. 154962/23, Motion No. 2024-1452 Appeal No. 2038 Case No. 2023-04716	2024 NY Slip Op 02771
B King Chick LLC v Organization for Defense of Four Freedoms for Ukraine, Inc.		Index No. 850122/22 Appeal No. 2330 Case No. 2023-04846	2024 NY Slip Op 02770

**Cases Decided May 16, 2024**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Bradley v St. Barnabas Hosp.	Index No. 26673/18 Appeal No. 2310 Case No. 2022-02868	2024 NY Slip Op 02751
Matter of Toussie v City of New York	Index No. 161114/22 Appeal No. 2306 Case No. 2023-03628	2024 NY Slip Op 02761
Taxi Tours Inc. v Go N.Y. Tours Inc.	Index No. 653012/19 Appeal No. 2315 Case No. 2023-05944	2024 NY Slip Op 02760
Matter of T.R. (Jaquasia G.)	Docket No. NN-05575/21, NN-05574/21 Appeal No. 2302 Case No. 2023-01526	2024 NY Slip Op 02759
People v Elliot	Ind. No. 5465/10 Appeal No. 2301 Case No. 2019-4541	2024 NY Slip Op 02758
Naramore v Mount Sinai Health Sys., Inc.	Index No. 152989/20 Appeal No. 2314 Case No. 2023-03748	2024 NY Slip Op 02757
Matter of Irani v City of New York	Index No. 153096/22 Appeal No. 2312-2313 Case No. 2023-03549, 2023-03551	2024 NY Slip Op 02756
Ho v Star Contrs., Inc.	Index No. 652769/22 Appeal No. 2308 Case No. 2023-04986	2024 NY Slip Op 02755
Glen Oaks Vil. Owners, Inc. v City of New York	Index No. 154327/22 Appeal No. 2309 Case No. 2024-00134	2024 NY Slip Op 02754
Feehan v Consolidated Edison Co. of N.Y., Inc.	Index No. 154755/22 Appeal No. 2303 Case No. 2023-04590	2024 NY Slip Op 02753
Entech Eng'g, P.C. v Dewberry Engrs. Inc.	Index No. 653172/15 Appeal No. 2304-2305 Case No. 2023-04003, 2023-04004	2024 NY Slip Op 02752

**Cases Decided May 14, 2024**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of 350 Cent. Park W. Assoc. LLC v New York State Div. of Hous. & Community Renewal		Index No. 155601/22 Appeal No. 2282 Case No. 2023-01015	2024 NY Slip Op 02656
Matter of Trump v Merchan		Ind. No. 71543/23 Appeal No. 2382&M-2024-01976 Case No. 2024-02369	2024 NY Slip Op 02680
T.J. v Parpia		Index No. 160808/20 Appeal No. 2300 Case No. 2023-03697	2024 NY Slip Op 02679
Siegel v Delta Airlines, Inc.		Index No. 161354/15 Appeal No. 2267 Case No. 2023-05388	2024 NY Slip Op 02678
Scaccia v Brookfield Props. One WFC Co., LLC		Index No. 159389/18 Appeal No. 2299 Case No. 2022-05603	2024 NY Slip Op 02677
Matter of Tashenea J.S. (Donald R.)		Docket No. B-29494/13 Appeal No. 2283 Case No. 2023-03146	2024 NY Slip Op 02676
People v Edwards		Ind. No. 1794/14 Appeal No. 2281 Case No. 2019-4407	2024 NY Slip Op 02675
People v Gilberto D.		Ind. No. 453/11 Appeal No. 2268 Case No. 2017-2439	2024 NY Slip Op 02674
People v Calderon		Ind. No. 472/18, 2222/18 Appeal No. 2264-2264A Case No. 2019-05368	2024 NY Slip Op 02673
People v D.T.		Ind. No. 1311/13 Appeal No. 2274 Case No. 2021-03097	2024 NY Slip Op 02672
People v Newsom		Ind. No. 4582/02 Appeal No. 2296-2296A-2296B Case No. 2005-280, 2023-02805	2024 NY Slip Op 02671
Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler LLP v Marcus & Cinelli LLP		Index No. 652711/22 Appeal No. 2276 Case No. 2023-02219	2024 NY Slip Op 02670
Noel v 336 E 95th Realty LLC		Index No. 156177/21 Appeal No. 2297 Case No. 2023-02980	2024 NY Slip Op 02669
Matter of Cane	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2023-04005 Case No. 2023-04550	2024 NY Slip Op 02668
Massoumi v Ganju		Index No. 654289/20 Appeal No. 2269-2270 Case No. 2023-01513, 2023-01514	2024 NY Slip Op 02667
Maldonado v Hines 1045 Ave. of the Ams. Invs. LLC		Index No. 152214/15 Appeal No. 1546 Case No. 2023-00135	2024 NY Slip Op 02666
Matter of N.L. v J.H.		Docket No. V12966-19, V-12966-19A, V-12966-19B Appeal No. 2266 Case No. 2023-00256	2024 NY Slip Op 02665
Kravitz v Chicken Soup for the Soul, LLC		Index No. 155469/21 Appeal No. 2272 Case No. 2023-04000	2024 NY Slip Op 02664
Harleysville Ins. Co. v United Fire Protection, Inc.		Index No. 652621/17 Appeal No. 2289 Case No. 2023-03566	2024 NY Slip Op 02663
Greenwich Ins. Co. v City of New York		Index No. 154552/12 Appeal No. 2280 Case No. 2023-04407	2024 NY Slip Op 02662
Goris v New York City Hous. Auth.		Index No. 155362/18, 595936/18 Appeal No. 2284 Case No. 2023-04718	2024 NY Slip Op 02661
Foxx v Berrosa Auto Corp.		Index No. 27481/18 Appeal No. 2298 Case No. 2023-03790	2024 NY Slip Op 02660
Dan v City of New York		Index No. 21313/16 Appeal No. 2265 Case No. 2023-03010	2024 NY Slip Op 02659
CoreSite 32 Ave. of the Ams., L.L.C. v 32 Sixth Ave. Co. LLC		Index No. 652792/19 Appeal No. 2290-2291-2292-2293-2294-2295 Case No. 2023-05349, 2023-05351, 2023-03975	2024 NY Slip Op 02658
Aronson Mayefsky & Sloan, LLP v Praeger	Kern, J.P.	Index No. 153999/23 Appeal No. 1881 Case No. 2023-04617	2024 NY Slip Op 02657

**Cases Decided May 10, 2024**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Davis v Schley		Index No. 153380/24 Appeal No. 2415 Case No. 2024-02974	2024 NY Slip Op 02614

**Cases Decided May 9, 2024**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
20 Broad St. Owner LLC v Sonder USA, Inc.	Index No. 653493/20 Appeal No. 2232 Case No. 2023-06145	2024 NY Slip Op 02580
Matter of Grandsard v Hutchison	Index No. 153605/24 Appeal No. 2395 Case No. 2024-02950	2024 NY Slip Op 02613
Weiss v Park Towers S. Co., LLC	Index No. 161545/15 Appeal No. 2255 Case No. 2023-04926	2024 NY Slip Op 02612
US Bank N.A. v Narain	Index No. 35570/14 Appeal No. 2236 Case No. 2023-03499	2024 NY Slip Op 02611
Teshabaeva v Family Home Care Servs. of Brooklyn & Queens, Inc.	Index No. 158949/17 Appeal No. 2259 Case No. 2023-00511	2024 NY Slip Op 02610
Simpertegui v Carlyle House Inc.	Index No. 27911/17 Appeal No. 2233 Case No. 2023-02362	2024 NY Slip Op 02609
Rodriguez v Isabella Geriatric Ctr. Inc.	Index No. 152618/17 Appeal No. 2247-2248 Case No. 2023-01631, 2023-02144	2024 NY Slip Op 02608
Rabich v City of New York	Index No. 159567/16 Appeal No. 2190 Case No. 2022-05326	2024 NY Slip Op 02607
People v Mateo	Ind No. 2038/19 Appeal No. 2227 Case No. 2023-00460	2024 NY Slip Op 02606
People v Adames	Ind No. 1190/17 Appeal No. 2241 Case No. 2019-3212	2024 NY Slip Op 02605
People v Tolliver	Ind No. 1653/18 Appeal No. 2254 Case No. 2020-02214	2024 NY Slip Op 02604
People v Rodriguez	Ind No. 1091/07 Appeal No. 2235 Case No. 2019-4155	2024 NY Slip Op 02603
People v Dozier	Ind No. 4451/18 Appeal No. 2252 Case No. 2019-04637	2024 NY Slip Op 02602
People v Williams	Ind No. 73540/22 Appeal No. 2243 Case No. 2023-02892	2024 NY Slip Op 02601
Peart v Carreras	Index No. 802259/21 Appeal No. 2230 Case No. 2023-05026	2024 NY Slip Op 02600
Needham & Co., LLC v UpHealth Holdings, Inc.	Index No. 655331/21 Appeal No. 2253 Case No. 2023-06591	2024 NY Slip Op 02599
Martinez v Urban Renaissance Collaboration Ltd. Partnership	Index No. 33400/20 Appeal No. 2261-2262 Case No. 2023-00413 2023-03715	2024 NY Slip Op 02598
Matter of Trina L. v Michelene M.	Docket No. V-14889/23 V-896/20 V-12857-61/21 Appeal No. 2245 Case No. 2023-03273	2024 NY Slip Op 02597
Matter of Kimberly J. v Benjamin G.	Index No. V-4909/22 Case No. 2023-04491 Appeal No. 2229	2024 NY Slip Op 02596
Hilton Wiener LLC v Zenk	Index No. 657440/19 Appeal No. 2237 Case No. 2023-05960	2024 NY Slip Op 02595
Matter of Liet Han v J.P. Morgan Sec., LLC	Index No. 653456/23 Appeal No. 2249-2250 Case No. 2023-05480, 2023-06156	2024 NY Slip Op 02594
Guerra v 100 Stevens Ave. LLC	Index No. 153998/17 Appeal No. 2246 Case No. 2023-00662	2024 NY Slip Op 02593
Gopstein v Bellinson Law, LLC	Index No. 159060/22 Appeal No. 2228 Case No. 2023-05770	2024 NY Slip Op 02592
Gobind v Nercessian	Index No. 25769/14 Appeal No. 2257 Case No. 2023-03025	2024 NY Slip Op 02591
Flatiron 30 LLC v Continuum Co. LLC	Index No. 653355/21 Appeal No. 2258 Case No. 2023-04040	2024 NY Slip Op 02590
Matter of Espinoza v Motor Veh. Acc. Indem. Corp.	Index No. 802084/23 Appeal No. 2242 Case No. 2023-04805	2024 NY Slip Op 02589
Diamond Realty Mgt., LLC v Yakub Gold Inc	Index No. 159522/20 Appeal No. 2240 Case No. 2023-01301	2024 NY Slip Op 02588
Desosa v Ortiz-Osorio	Index No. 26241/18 Appeal No. 2231 Case No. 2023-03378	2024 NY Slip Op 02587
Cline v Grodin	Index No. 654095/22 Appeal No. 2234 Case No. 2023-05525	2024 NY Slip Op 02586
Caras v George Comfort & Sons, Inc.	Index No. 152645/15 Appeal No. 2238-2239 Case No. 2023-05405, 2023-06799	2024 NY Slip Op 02585
Matter of Bohm v Wan	Index No. 884/23 Appeal No. 2263 Case No. 2024-01543	2024 NY Slip Op 02584
Board of Mgrs. of the 100 W. 93 Condominium v 660 Columbus Retail Owner	Index No. 155851/22 Appeal No. 2244 Case No. 2023-02860	2024 NY Slip Op 02583
A.J.D. Bldg. LLC v Ben-Harush	Index No. 157386/21 Appeal No. 2260 Case No. 2023-03825	2024 NY Slip Op 02582
Matter of 5400 Co. v New York State Div. of Hous. & Community Renewal	Index No. 800315/23 Appeal No. 2256 Case No. 2023-04702	2024 NY Slip Op 02581

**Cases Decided May 7, 2024**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Beadell v Eros Mgt. Reality, LLC	Pitt-Burke, J.	Index No. 159152/17 Appeal No. 1354-1355 Case No. 2022-03454, 2023-03683	2024 NY Slip Op 02496
Matter of Rijos v New York City Tr. Auth.		Index No. 152047/23 Appeal No. 2220 Case No. 2023-06721	2024 NY Slip Op 02510
PV Holding Corp. v Fernandez		Index No. 160035/20 Appeal No. 2213 Case No. 2023-00761	2024 NY Slip Op 02509
People v Crawford		Ind. No. 2131/19 Appeal No. 2218 Case No. 2023-01001	2024 NY Slip Op 02508
People v Guzman		Ind. No. 4450/15, 2832/16, 1846/16 Appeal No. 2208 Case No. 2018-272, 2017-2380	2024 NY Slip Op 02507
People v Shuler		Ind. No. 3073/15 Appeal No. 2224 Case No. 2019-2016	2024 NY Slip Op 02506
New York City Hous. Auth. v Admiral Ins. Co.		Index No. 451444/20 Appeal No. 2212 Case No. 2023-00733	2024 NY Slip Op 02505
Loja v 133 Lincoln LLC		Index No. 812401/22 Appeal No. 2211 Case No. 2023-03372	2024 NY Slip Op 02504
Kidron v Suris & Assoc., P.C.		Index No. 33992/19 Appeal No. 2221-2222 Case No. 2023-02233, 2023-02235	2024 NY Slip Op 02503
Jones Law Firm, P.C. v Peck		Index No. 651700/20 Appeal No. 2225 Case No. 2023-03594	2024 NY Slip Op 02502
Matter of J.J.D. v M.D.		Docket No. NN-08656-8/22 Appeal No. 2149 Case No. 2023-04962	2024 NY Slip Op 02501
Gonzalez v Cruz		Index No. 27185/20 Appeal No. 2209 Case No. 2023-06368	2024 NY Slip Op 02500
Matter of Paul D. v Margarita O.		Docket No. V-8426/21, V-8426-21/22A, V-8246-23/22B Appeal No. 2210 Case No. 2023-04395	2024 NY Slip Op 02499
Commissioners of the State Ins. Fund v Call-A-Head Corp.		Index No. 450810/21 Appeal No. 2223 Case No. 2023-05887	2024 NY Slip Op 02498
Britt v Levgar Equities Corp.		Index No. 30587/19 Appeal No. 2216 Case No. 2023-04136	2024 NY Slip Op 02497
841-853 Fee Owner, LLC v Space Initiatives LLC		Index No. 650542/21 Appeal No. 2214-2215 Case No. 2023-06233, 2023-06234	2024 NY Slip Op 02494
979 Second Ave. LLC v Yue Wah Chao		Index No. 654145/21 Appeal No. 2226 Case No. 2023-03611	2024 NY Slip Op 02495

**Cases Decided May 2, 2024**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
RDF Agent, LLC v Electric Red Ventures, LLC		Index No. 656537/22 Appeal No. 2173-2174 Case No. 2022-03619, 2023-04647	2024 NY Slip Op 02384
Wolinsky v Berkowitz		Index No. 365303/22 Appeal No. 2189 Case No. 2023-02781	2024 NY Slip Op 02389
Wilmington Trust N.A. v Nelson		Index No. 654750/21 Appeal No. 2184 Case No. 2022-05378	2024 NY Slip Op 02388
West 125th St. Realty LLC v Chosen Realty Corp		Index No. 152859/21 Appeal No. 2181-2182 & M-1201 M-1427 Case No. 2023-04634, 2023-04638	2024 NY Slip Op 02387
U.S. Bank N.A. v 1226 Evergreen Bapaz LLC		Index No. 802559/21 Appeal No. 2169-2170 Case No. 2023-06397, 2023-06413	2024 NY Slip Op 02386
Matter of Rivera v Sewell		Index No. 151813/22 Appeal No. 2175 Case No. 2023-02460	2024 NY Slip Op 02385
People v Pisano		Ind. No. 72767/22 Appeal No. 2178 Case No. 2023-03003	2024 NY Slip Op 02379
Matter of People of the State of New York v VDARE Found., Inc.		Index No. 453196/22 Appeal No. 2185 Case No. 2024-00015	2024 NY Slip Op 02383
People v Middleton		Ind. No. 3049/19 Appeal No. 2176 Case No. 2023-02475	2024 NY Slip Op 02382
People v Pitts		Ind. No. 1614/20 Appeal No. 2195-2195A Case No. 2022-01617, 2023-04854	2024 NY Slip Op 02381
People v R.B.		Ind. No. 3432/14 Appeal No. 2186 Case No. 2017-2400	2024 NY Slip Op 02380
IntegrateNYC, Inc. v State of New York	Moulton, J.	Index No. 152743/21 Appeal No. 1230 Case No. 2022-02719	2024 NY Slip Op 02369
People v Campbell		Ind. No. 306/18 Appeal No. 2180 Case No. 2020-04372	2024 NY Slip Op 02378
People v Vasquez		Ind. No. 3264-17 Appeal No. 2203 Case No. 2019-03516	2024 NY Slip Op 02377
People v Jesurum		Ind. No. 3593/18 Appeal No. 2197 Case No. 2022-04700	2024 NY Slip Op 02376
People v Rosario		SCI No. 4633/09 Appeal No. 2168 Case No. 2018-03184	2024 NY Slip Op 02375
People v Rojas		Ind. No. 792/16 Appeal No. 2171 Case No. 2019-3644	2024 NY Slip Op 02374
Operr Plaza, LLC v Wang		Index No. 654192/21 Appeal No. 2202 Case No. 2022-00695	2024 NY Slip Op 02373
Morris-Perry v Morris-Perry		Index No. 301256/22 Appeal No. 2206 Case No. 2023-04737	2024 NY Slip Op 02372
Millenium Consol. Holdings, LLC v Bluefin Capital Mgt., LLC		Index No. 656387/22 Appeal No. 2179 Case No. 2023-02397	2024 NY Slip Op 02371
Tao Liu v Sobin Chang		Index No. 656209/20 Appeal No. 2205 Case No. 2023-04132	2024 NY Slip Op 02370
Matter of 900 Eight Ave. Condo LLC v New York State Div. of Hous. & Community Renewal		Index No. 157101/22 Appeal No. 2196 Case No. 2023-03712	2024 NY Slip Op 02361
Haskins v Metropolitan Transp. Auth.		Index No. 151643/20 Appeal No. 2172 Case No. 2023-01037	2024 NY Slip Op 02368
DIG SSOF Evanston Lender, LLC v Su-Mei Yen		Index No. 653060/22 Appeal No. 2177 Case No. 2023-05155	2024 NY Slip Op 02367
Matter of Carlson v New York City Council		Index No. 5648/22 Appeal No. 2187 Case No. 2023-05566	2024 NY Slip Op 02366
AIG Prop. Cas. Co. v Arista A.C. Corp.		Index No. 160669/16, 595386/19 Appeal No. 2183 Case No. 2023-02018	2024 NY Slip Op 02365
Agard v Port Auth. of N.Y. & N.J.		Index No. 152913/19, 595959/19 Appeal No. 2191-2192-2193 & M-1279 Case No. 2022-04966, 2022-05746, 2023-00346	2024 NY Slip Op 02364
Matter of Abrams v Abrams		Index No. 658845/21 Appeal No. 2207 Case No. 2023-03426	2024 NY Slip Op 02363
Matter of O.B.A. (Eleiona J.)		Docket No. NN-05455/22 Appeal No. 2188 Case No. 2022-03615	2024 NY Slip Op 02362