Appellate Division, First Department Decisions

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

**Cases Decided October 31, 2024**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Adebanjo v Johnson	Index No. 451868/20 Appeal No. 2929 Case No. 2024-00027	2024 NY Slip Op 05395
Williams v Mount Sinai Health Sys., Inc.	Index No. 160367/19 Appeal No. 2933 Case No. 2023-06575	2024 NY Slip Op 05424
Matter of Wasserstein	File No. 3927/09/O, 3927/09/P, 3927/09/Q, 3927/09/R, 3927/09S, 3927/09Tm 3927/09U Appeal No. 2960 Case No. 2024-03826	2024 NY Slip Op 05423
Vaccaro v ESRT Empire State Bldg., L.L.C.	Index No. 154556/19 Appeal No. 2959 Case No. 2023-03651	2024 NY Slip Op 05422
Snazzi Reporting, Inc. v Veritext, LLC	Index No. 650680/22 Appeal No. 2957 Case No. 2023-04022	2024 NY Slip Op 05421
Guzman-Saquisili v Harlem Urban Dev. Corp.	Index No. 156061/19, 595074/20 Appeal No. 2945 Case No. 2023-04935	2024 NY Slip Op 05420
Ruiz v BOP 245 Park LLC	Index No. 159255/19 Appeal No. 2952 Case No. 2024-03815	2024 NY Slip Op 05419
People v Cruceta-Castillo	SCI No. 3752/18 Appeal No. 2944 Case No. 2019-3962	2024 NY Slip Op 05418
People v Garcia	Ind No. 71218/22 Appeal No. 2931 Case No. 2023-00163	2024 NY Slip Op 05417
People v Smith	Ind No. 5257/11 Appeal No. 2958 Case No. 2018-3135	2024 NY Slip Op 05416
People v Kayumov	Ind No. 1451/17 Appeal No. 2936 Case No. 2018-2387	2024 NY Slip Op 05415
People v Johnson	SCI No. 73990/23 Appeal No. 2941 Case No. 2023-04477	2024 NY Slip Op 05414
People v Kirlew	Ind No. 1310/21 Appeal No. 2949 Case No. 2023-03771	2024 NY Slip Op 05413
People v Hernandez	Ind No. 72707/22 Appeal No. 2953 Case No. 2023-04857	2024 NY Slip Op 05412
Ortiz v Country Beer Distrib. Inc.	Index No. 26727/17 Appeal No. 2948 Case No. 2023-02172	2024 NY Slip Op 05411
OH 126th St. Hous. Dev. Fund Corp. v Berkley Ins. Co.	Index No. 652824/22 Appeal No. 2934 Case No. 2024-03079	2024 NY Slip Op 05410
Melikov v 66 Overlook Terrace Corp.	Index No. 153504/18 Appeal No. 2935 Case No. 2023-03946	2024 NY Slip Op 05409
Matter of Denim M.	Docket No. D-00333-22 Appeal No. 2946 Case No. 2023-01803	2024 NY Slip Op 05408
Jara-Salazar v 250 Park, L.L.C.	Index No. 152788/19, 595822/19, 596157/19, 595128/21, 595566/21 Appeal No. 2930 Case No. 2023-06237	2024 NY Slip Op 05407
Ingram Yuzek Gainen Carroll & Bertolotti, LLP v McCullar	Index No. 655386/21 Appeal No. 2937 Case No. 2023-02984	2024 NY Slip Op 05406
Matter of H.W. v New York City Dept. of Hous. Preserv. & Dev.	Index No. Index No. 153647/22 Appeal No. 2947 Case No. 2023-03728	2024 NY Slip Op 05405
Good Gateway, LLC v Thakkar	Index No. 160660/16 Appeal No. 2927 Case No. 2024-00105	2024 NY Slip Op 05404
Fouad v Milton Hershey Sch. & Sch. Trust	Index No. 155743/18 Appeal No. 2939 Case No. 2024-02729	2024 NY Slip Op 05403
Farrell Limousine Serv. LLC v Macro Consultants LLC	Index No. 653863/19 Appeal No. 2943 Case No. 2023-02865	2024 NY Slip Op 05402
Delcid v Park Ave. Christian Church	Index No. 30463/18 Appeal No. 2951 Case No. 2023-02419	2024 NY Slip Op 05401
Celestine v Bonte	Index No. 24190/20 Appeal No. 2955 Case No. 2023-04712	2024 NY Slip Op 05400
Matter of Stephanie C. v Ricardo E.	Index No. V-21452/18 V-35210/18 Appeal No. 2928 Case No. 2022-04782	2024 NY Slip Op 05399
Aristocrat Plastic Surgery P.C. v Silva	Index No. 153200/21 Appeal No. 2942 Case No. 2023-05414	2024 NY Slip Op 05398
ARCPE1, LLC v Public Serv. Mut. Ins. Co.	Index No. 161751/14 Appeal No. 2940 Case No. 2023-05010	2024 NY Slip Op 05397
Adler Windows, Inc. v Freidheim	Index No. 650194/21 Appeal No. 2956 Case No. 2023-05700	2024 NY Slip Op 05396

**Cases Decided October 29, 2024**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Anonymous v Anonymous	Index No. 101183/20 Appeal No. 2907 Case No. 2023-03150	2024 NY Slip Op 05303
Wykstra v 304-36 E. 83rd Realty LLC	Index No. 158326/20 Appeal No. 2921 Case No. 2023-02802	2024 NY Slip Op 05319
Starnella v Ganti	Index No. 23624/17 Appeal No. 2912 Case No. 2023-04432	2024 NY Slip Op 05318
Protetch v Jocar Realty Co., Inc.	Index No. 656111/21 Appeal No. 2911 Case No. 2023-04115	2024 NY Slip Op 05317
People v Wilkins	Ind. No. 72943/22 Appeal No. 2913 Case No. 2023-00448	2024 NY Slip Op 05316
People v Curtis	Ind. No. 71122/21 Appeal No. 2906 Case No. 2022-05122	2024 NY Slip Op 05315
People v Guerrero	Ind. No. 4501/16 Appeal No. 2910 Case No. 2018-2149	2024 NY Slip Op 05314
People v Johnson	Ind. No. 1376/20 Appeal No. 2917 Case No. 2022-02008	2024 NY Slip Op 05313
Pena v Rhodes 2 L.L.C.	Index No. 155145/19 Appeal No. 2920 Case No. 2024-00743	2024 NY Slip Op 05312
Orellana v 115 Enters. Group LLC	Index No. 34897/20 Appeal No. 2923 Case No. 2024-01005	2024 NY Slip Op 05311
Matter of Olivia O.	Docket No. D-06752/23 Appeal No. 2908 Case No. 2023-06072	2024 NY Slip Op 05310
Messer v Hughes	Index No. 23891/20 Appeal No. 2922 Case No. 2023-04804	2024 NY Slip Op 05309
Innovative Sec. Ltd. v OBEX Sec. LLC	Index No. 650685/23 Appeal No. 2916 Case No. 2024-02447	2024 NY Slip Op 05308
Gilchrist v Your First Home, LLC	Index No. 307878/11 Appeal No. 2914-2915 Case No. 2023-06390, 2023-06398	2024 NY Slip Op 05307
DeOleo v 90 Fifth Owner, LLC	Index No. 30885/17, 43376/18, 43169/19 Appeal No. 2909 Case No. 2024-01465	2024 NY Slip Op 05306
Commissioners of the State Ins. Fund v Z Bldrs. Assoc. LLC	Index No. 452265/18 Appeal No. 2919 Case No. 2023-06456	2024 NY Slip Op 05305
Antoniello v Faustina Corp.	Index No. 604511/05 Appeal No. 2924-2925 Case No. 2024-00869, 2024-03175,	2024 NY Slip Op 05304

**Cases Decided October 24, 2024**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of K. A. v Rayfie T.	Docket No. N6541/22 Appeal No. 2876 Case No. 2024-00920	2024 NY Slip Op 05271
Matter of Barons Media, LLC v Shapiro Legal Group, PLLC	Index No. 152278/221 Appeal No. 2889-2890 Case No. 2023-06019 2024-00657	2024 NY Slip Op 05301
Zhong Lun Law Firm LLC v Zhong Lun Law Firm	Index No. 657018/22 Appeal No. 2899 Case No. 2023-05274	2024 NY Slip Op 05300
Matter of Yarusso v Sewell	Index No. 151578/23 Appeal No. 2901 Case No. 2023-04867	2024 NY Slip Op 05299
Spicer v Garda World Consulting (UK) Ltd.	Index No. 655352/23 Appeal No. 2882 Case No. 2024-01110	2024 NY Slip Op 05298
Rivera v F&S Contr., LLC	Index No. 157618/19 Appeal No. 2903 Case No. 2024-02610	2024 NY Slip Op 05297
Perez v City of New York	Index No. 152638/23 Appeal No. 2887 Case No. 2023-06521	2024 NY Slip Op 05296
People v Lockett	Ind No. 74312/22 Appeal No. 2900 Case No. 2023-04499	2024 NY Slip Op 05295
People v Colin	Ind No. 423/20 Appeal No. 2879 Case No. 2022-03365	2024 NY Slip Op 05294
People v Bah	Ind No. 3304/17, 59/18 Appeal No. 2896 Case No. 2019-5232	2024 NY Slip Op 05293
People v Zimmerman	Ind No. 3301/84 4293/84 Appeal No. 2891 Case No. 2019-2561	2024 NY Slip Op 05292
People v Rivera	Ind No. 70841/21 Appeal No. 2874 Case No. 2022-01872	2024 NY Slip Op 05291
People v Calhoun	Ind No. 73868/22 Appeal No. 2884 Case No. 2023-04475	2024 NY Slip Op 05290
Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler LLP v HoganWillig, PLLC	Index No. . 655006/22 Appeal No. 2880 Case No. 2023-04487	2024 NY Slip Op 05289
Parker v Trustees of the Spence Sch., Inc.	Index No. 155427/19 Appeal No. 2904 Case No. 2023-05368	2024 NY Slip Op 05288
Orenstein v 301 E. 78 St. Owners Corp.	Index No. 152869/20 Appeal No. 2894 Case No. 2023-02724	2024 NY Slip Op 05287
Noyack Med. Partners LLC v OSK IX, LLC	Index No. 654665/21 Appeal No. 2902 Case No. 2024-01881	2024 NY Slip Op 05286
Mehmeti v Karlin	Index No. 100122/23 Appeal No. 2875 Case No. 2024-01577	2024 NY Slip Op 05285
Macaulay v New Line Structures & Dev. LLC	Index No. 154509/21 Appeal No. 2898 Case No. 2024-02787	2024 NY Slip Op 05284
Matter of Tashawnda L. v Ladarius M. P.	O-01926/22 V-01928/22 Appeal No. 2892-2893 Case No. 2023-04544 2023-04511	2024 NY Slip Op 05283
Krohn v Reyes	Index No. 156385/19 Appeal No. 2895 Case No. 2023-03676	2024 NY Slip Op 05282
Juman v Cape Church Assoc., LLC	Index No. 153080/23 595618/23 Appeal No. 2877 Case No. 2024-01853	2024 NY Slip Op 05281
French v NYS Dept. of Labor	Index No. 653626/23 Appeal No. 2897 Case No. 2024-00950	2024 NY Slip Op 05280
Espinal v MPI Mgt. LLC	Index No. 161177/22 Appeal No. 2885 Case No. 2024-00335	2024 NY Slip Op 05279
Matter of Employers Ins. Co. of Wausau v Dominion Ins. Receivable LLC	Index No. 653628/22 Appeal No. 2878 Case No. 2023-03690	2024 NY Slip Op 05278
Dziura v Human Dev. Assn., Inc.	Index No. 159998/18 Appeal No. 2888 Case No. 2023-02379	2024 NY Slip Op 05277
De Souza v Hudson Yards Constr. II LLC	Index No. 157354/19 Appeal No. 2883 Case No. 2023-03854	2024 NY Slip Op 05276
CSN Realty Corp v 2252 Third Ave. LLC	Index No. 657221/21 Appeal No. 3005-3006 Case No. 2023-04957, 2023-04958	2024 NY Slip Op 05275
Bey v City of New York	Index No. 24662/16 Appeal No. 2905 Case No. 2024-00710	2024 NY Slip Op 05274
Matter of Bertram v Metropolitan Transp. Auth.	Index No. 150357/23 Appeal No. 2886 Case No. 2023-04912	2024 NY Slip Op 05273
ACP Hous. Assoc., L.P. v ABJ Milano, LLC	Index No. 156320/19 Appeal No. 2881 Case No. 2023-05417	2024 NY Slip Op 05272

**Cases Decided October 22, 2024**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
U.S. Bank N.A. v Mave Hotel Invs. LLC	Index No. 850280/21 Appeal No. 2869-2870 Case No. 2024-00370, 2024-03404	2024 NY Slip Op 05195
Timoyanis v Zhongmeng (U.S.A.) Co. Ltd.	Index No. 151444/22 Appeal No. 2872 Case No. 2023-03967	2024 NY Slip Op 05194
State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v Equinox Physical Therapy, P.C.	Index No. 160355/20 Appeal No. 2863 Case No. 2023-03172	2024 NY Slip Op 05193
Rodriguez v Riverside Ctr. Site 5 Owner LLC	Index No. 157144/17 Appeal No. 2860 Case No. 2023-03425	2024 NY Slip Op 05192
Porter v Bachner	Index No. 100351/19 Appeal No. 2868 Case No. 2024-03704	2024 NY Slip Op 05191
People v Hanemann	Ind. No. 3332/18 Appeal No. 2856 Case No. 2019-05417	2024 NY Slip Op 05190
Matter of 609 Realty LLC v New York State Div. of Hous. & Community Renewal	Index No. 151598/23 Appeal No. 2871 Case No. 2023-05605	2024 NY Slip Op 05179
People v Wallace	Ind. No. 24451C/18, 4316/18 Appeal No. 2374 Case No. 2020-03255	2024 NY Slip Op 05189
People v Perez	Ind. No. 72528/22 Appeal No. 2862 Case No. 2022-05792	2024 NY Slip Op 05188
People v Ramos	Ind. No. 798/17 Appeal No. 2865 Case No. 2019-05058	2024 NY Slip Op 05187
Landa v Friedman	Index No. 657198/21, 595676/22 Appeal No. 2864 Case No. 2023-03968	2024 NY Slip Op 05186
Koretz v 363 E. 76th St. Corp.	Index No. 656255/17 Appeal No. 2861 Case No. 2023-05024	2024 NY Slip Op 05185
Matter of Tyra H. v Tariq M.	Docket No. V-04698/21, V-04871/21 Appeal No. 2858 Case No. 2023-05645	2024 NY Slip Op 05184
Giuffre v Oh	Index No. 150002/23 Appeal No. 2859 Case No. 2023-06793	2024 NY Slip Op 05183
Bapaz NYC W. 46 St Group LLC v Assa	Index No. 652456/18 Appeal No. 2866-2867 Case No. 2024-02623, 2024-03151	2024 NY Slip Op 05182
AIG Prop. Cas. Co. v MTS Power Sys.	Index No. 150455/20 Appeal No. 2857 Case No. 2024-02941	2024 NY Slip Op 05181
Acosta-Romero v Suiyeng Hung Fong	Index No. 812904/22 Appeal No. 2873 Case No. 2024-00408	2024 NY Slip Op 05180

**Cases Decided October 17, 2024**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
A.N.L.Y.H. Invs. LP v JDS Principal Highline LLC		Index No. 651757/22 Appeal No. 2843 Case No. 2024-01886	2024 NY Slip Op 05133
United Hay, LLC v Harounian		Index No. 657310/17 Appeal No. 2846-2846A Case No. 2023-06320	2024 NY Slip Op 05151
U.S. Bank Trust, N.A. v Stewart		Index No. 850292/17 Appeal No. 2851 Case No. 2023-06343	2024 NY Slip Op 05150
Matter of Sanitation Salvage Corp. v City of New York		Index No. 157928/18 Appeal No. 2855 Case No. 2023-04161	2024 NY Slip Op 05149
People v Artist		Ind No. 1116/16 Appeal No. 2852 Case No. 2023-01992	2024 NY Slip Op 05148
People v Herbin		Ind No. 1048/21 Appeal No. 2837 Case No. 2022-02291	2024 NY Slip Op 05147
People v Stone		Ind No. 3145/19 Appeal No. 2849 Case No. 2022-05805	2024 NY Slip Op 05146
People v McKenzie		Ind No. 3505/15 Appeal No. 2844 Case No. 2019-5867	2024 NY Slip Op 05145
People v Santana		Ind No. 3272N/19 Appeal No. 2848 Case No. 2021-00346	2024 NY Slip Op 05144
Payne v Rosenberg, Minc, Falkoff & Wolff, LLP		Index No. 151952/22 Appeal No. 2853 Case No. 2023-04615	2024 NY Slip Op 05143
Matter of Oved & Oved LLP v Google, LLC		Index No. 161870/23 Appeal No. 2845 Case No. 2024-02095	2024 NY Slip Op 05142
O'Connor v Society Pass Inc.	Oing, J.	Index No. 656938/19 Appeal No. 2494 Case No. 2023-03020	2024 NY Slip Op 05141
Minahan v New York City Tr. Auth.		Index No. 162252/19 Appeal No. 2838 Case No. 2023-06178	2024 NY Slip Op 05140
M13 & M15 Holdings, LLC v Athanson		Index No. 151634/21 Appeal No. 2854 Case No. 2024-00151	2024 NY Slip Op 05139
Kerr v Garcia		Index No. 155973/16 Appeal No. 2841 Case No. 2023-04139	2024 NY Slip Op 05138
Karanevich-Dono v Haas		Index No. 805377/18 Appeal No. 2751 Case No. 2023-04754	2024 NY Slip Op 05137
Matter of Pandora S.D. (Isabelle D.)		Docket No. B-07951/20 Appeal No. 2839 Case No. 2023-04568	2024 NY Slip Op 05136
Coyle v Dos-Santos		Index No. 24279/17E Appeal No. 2850 Case No. 2023-04878	2024 NY Slip Op 05135
Atlantic Mut. Ins. Co. v Greater N.Y. Mut. Ins. Co.		Index No. 113846/06 Appeal No. 2842 Case No. 2023-05633	2024 NY Slip Op 05134

**Cases Decided October 15, 2024**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Walton v Perez	Index No. 812171/21 Appeal No. 2808 Case No. 2024-01528	2024 NY Slip Op 05081
Urquia v Deegan 135 Realty LLC	Index No. 22340/19 Appeal No. 2817 Case No. 2023-05286	2024 NY Slip Op 05080
Ullah v Ullah	Index No. 301223/00 Appeal No. 2815 Case No. 2023-02212	2024 NY Slip Op 05079
People v Franco	SCI No. 1327/19 Appeal No. 2818 Case No. 2020-00570	2024 NY Slip Op 05078
Tapia v Bravo	Index No. 300900/17 Appeal No. 2799-2800 Case No. 2023-02845, 2024-00915	2024 NY Slip Op 05077
Spiegel v 226 Realty LLC	Index No. 150371/13 Appeal No. 2805 Case No. 2023-03102	2024 NY Slip Op 05076
Matter of Scarola v Malone	Index No. 652186/17 Appeal No. 2823 Case No. 2023-06263	2024 NY Slip Op 05075
People v Rivera-Santana	Ind. No. 1250/18 Appeal No. 733 Case No. 2019-04016	2024 NY Slip Op 05074
People v Gurley	Ind. No. 1428/13 Appeal No. 2816, 2816A, M-2024-04165 Case No. 2017-368, 2023-003272	2024 NY Slip Op 05073
People v Saxton	SCI No. 400/10 Appeal No. 2801 Case No. 2017-1325	2024 NY Slip Op 05072
People v Martinez	Ind. No. 363/19, 600/20, 71233/22 Appeal No. 2797-2798 Case No. 2023-03191, 2023-03200, 2023-03201	2024 NY Slip Op 05071
People v Gadsden	Ind. No. 1235/17 Appeal No. 2819 Case No. 2018-1526	2024 NY Slip Op 05070
People v Champion	Ind. No. 1037-20 Appeal No. 2788 Case No. 2022-02043	2024 NY Slip Op 05069
People v Young	Ind. No. 1524/20 Appeal No. 2829 Case No. 2021-04147	2024 NY Slip Op 05068
People v Salgado	Ind. No. 2564/19 Appeal No. 2807 Case No. 2019-05289	2024 NY Slip Op 05067
People v Morris	Ind. No. 2098/14, 3583/15 Appeal No. 2793-2794 Case No. 2017-599, 2018-292, 2022-03468	2024 NY Slip Op 05066
People v Matos	Ind. No. 3662/19 Appeal No. 2811 Case No. 2021-01719	2024 NY Slip Op 05065
Panasia Estate, Inc. v Glazer	Index No. 150764/23 Appeal No. 2828, M-4073 Case No. 2024-03213	2024 NY Slip Op 05064
Matter of New York Civ. Liberties Union v New York State Off. of Ct. Admin.	Index No. 154792/22 Appeal No. 2832 Case No. 2023-06069	2024 NY Slip Op 05063
Matter of Neumann	File No. 4105/16 Appeal No. 2826 Case No. 2023-02876	2024 NY Slip Op 05062
Nath v Chemtob Moss Forman & Beyda, LLP	Index No. 160711/22 Appeal No. 2796 Case No. 2024-01391	2024 NY Slip Op 05061
Matter of Jermaine N. v Tatiana T.	Case No. 2023-06419 Docket No. V-08110-21, V-08111-21 Appeal No. 2822	2024 NY Slip Op 05060
MTGLQ Invs., L.P. v Vazquez	Index No. 810148/12 Appeal No. 2820, M-04289 Case No. 2023-06758	2024 NY Slip Op 05059
Molina v 114 Fifth Ave. Assoc., LLC	Index No. 156349/16 Appeal No. 2824 Case No. 2022-01708	2024 NY Slip Op 05058
Matter of McKenzie v Mennin	Appeal No. 2833, M-2024-03193 Case No. 2024-04077	2024 NY Slip Op 05057
Marisol Holdings LLC v Imagine Airport Ventures, LLC	Index No. 654908/19 Appeal No. 2795 Case No. 2023-04621	2024 NY Slip Op 05056
Matter of Michael L. v Lillian G.	Docket No. V09509/20, V04484/21 Appeal No. 2790 Case No. 2023-04453	2024 NY Slip Op 05055
Kanuteh v New York City Tr. Auth.	Index No. 450458/19 Appeal No. 2821 Case No. 2023-04483	2024 NY Slip Op 05054
Matter of Jones Law Firm, P.C. v J. Synergy Green, Inc.	Index No. 651857/23 Appeal No. 2810 Case No. 2023-04067	2024 NY Slip Op 05053
Hasnat v ADP Realty Ltd.	Index No. 809691/21 Appeal No. 2830 Case No. 2024-02458	2024 NY Slip Op 05052
Gomez v Mount Sinai Hosp.	Index No. 805113/20 Appeal No. 2812-2813 Case No. 2023-04835, 2023-04836	2024 NY Slip Op 05051
Gerasimowicz v Delis	Index No. 654322/13 Appeal No. 2831 Case No. 2024-01104	2024 NY Slip Op 05050
Frances v Klein	Index No. 151000/20 Appeal No. 2806 Case No. 2024-02347	2024 NY Slip Op 05049
de Luca v de Luca	Index No. 365505/23 Appeal No. 2792 Case No. 2023-05587	2024 NY Slip Op 05048
Cooper v Bldg 7th St. LLC	Index No. 153479/18, 595699/18 Appeal No. 2791 Case No. 2023-05055	2024 NY Slip Op 05047
Campagna v New York City Police Dept..	Index No. 151512/23 Appeal No. 2827 Case No. 2023-04557	2024 NY Slip Op 05046
Burgos v Diamond Bricks Inc.	Index No. 452125/16 Appeal No. 2789 Case No. 2022-04988	2024 NY Slip Op 05045
Basturan v New York City Tr. Auth.	Index No. 151270/17 Appeal No. 2802-2803 Case No. 2023-05492, 2024-2532	2024 NY Slip Op 05044
Matter of V.B. v Nicole A.	Docket No. N11704/20 Appeal No. 2814, 2814A Case No. 2023-03548	2024 NY Slip Op 05043
Allied World Natl. Assur. Co. v AIG Specialty Ins. Co.	Index No. 654162/21 Appeal No. 2809 Case No. 2024-01691	2024 NY Slip Op 05042

**Cases Decided October 10, 2024**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Board of Mgrs. of the St. Tropez Condominium v JMA Consultants, Inc.	Index No. 656079/18 Appeal No. 2779 Case No. 2023-06136	2024 NY Slip Op 05019
People v Checo	Ind. No. 71844/23 Appeal No. 2773 Case No. 2023-05540	2024 NY Slip Op 05037
People v Thomas	Ind. No. 3123/19 Appeal No. 2784 Case No. 2021-01223	2024 NY Slip Op 05036
People v Santiago	Ind. No. 1302/18 Appeal No. 2782 Case No. 2023-02117	2024 NY Slip Op 05035
People v Rios	SCI No. 3612N/17 Appeal No. 2778 Case No. 2018-1949	2024 NY Slip Op 05034
People v Mobley	Ind. No. 1342/21 Appeal No. 2767 Case No. 2023-00844	2024 NY Slip Op 05033
People v Blanding	Ind. No. 5085/15 Appeal No. 2780 Case No. 2018-571	2024 NY Slip Op 05032
People v Higgs	Ind. No. 364/17 Appeal No. 2772 Case No. 2019-3243	2024 NY Slip Op 05031
Matter of Mingo v Records Access Officer of the N.Y. County Dist. Attorney's Off.	Index No. 100371/22 Appeal No. 2785 Case No. 2022-04890	2024 NY Slip Op 05030
Mercer Sq., LLC v Namdor, Inc.	Index No. 652272/19 Appeal No. 2774 Case No. 2023-04528	2024 NY Slip Op 05029
Mascia v Pinar	Index No. 22716/20 Appeal No. 2781 Case No. 2023-04315	2024 NY Slip Op 05028
Matter of Sheila M. v Jodeci S.	O-11743/21 Docket No. O-11743/21 Appeal No. 2770 Case No. 2023-06514	2024 NY Slip Op 05027
LW Holdco V LLC v Puls	Index No. 654747/21 Appeal No. 2776 Case No. 2023-04363	2024 NY Slip Op 05026
Leffler v Kotick	Index No. 155820/18 Appeal No. 2787 Case No. 2024-02364	2024 NY Slip Op 05025
Joseph v Morsali	Index No. 365092/23 365092/23 Appeal No. 2783 Case No. 2023-05101	2024 NY Slip Op 05024
Janet Transit, Inc. v Mott Haven Improvement Group LP	Index No. 804743/23 Appeal No. 2786 Case No. 2023-02473	2024 NY Slip Op 05023
Matter of Hefti v New York State Div. of Hous. & Community Renewal	Index No. 158290/22 Appeal No. 2768-2769 Case No. 2023-04790, 2024-00198	2024 NY Slip Op 05022
Matter of Demar Plumbing Corp. v City of New York	Index No. 160544/22 Appeal No. 2775-2775A Case No. 2023-01651	2024 NY Slip Op 05021
Matter of Citibank, N.A. v N/A	Index No. 652233/22 Appeal No. 2392 Case No. 2023-1432	2024 NY Slip Op 05020

**Cases Decided October 8, 2024**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Aidekman v State of N.Y. Div. of Hous. & Community Renewal		Index No. 154361/21 Appeal No. 2745 Case No. 2023-04877	2024 NY Slip Op 04896
Tuckahoe Realty LLC v 241 E. 76 Tenants Corp.		Index No. 656414/19 Appeal No. 2730 Case No. 2023-03295	2024 NY Slip Op 04937
Matter of Lillette T. v Simone G.		Index No. V-03172/21, V-03465/21, V-03173/21, V-03439/21, V-03468/21 Appeal No. 2753 Case No. 2023-06674	2024 NY Slip Op 04936
Matter of Sullivan v Uber Tech. Inc.		Index No. 653207/22 Appeal No. 2747 Case No. 2023-05229	2024 NY Slip Op 04935
Shendelman v Shendelman		Index No. 365842/23 Appeal No. 2760-2761 Case No. 2024-03249, 2024-04004	2024 NY Slip Op 04934
Sandoval-Morales v 164-20 N. Blvd., LLC		Index No. 158954/17 Appeal No. 2731 Case No. 2023-03024	2024 NY Slip Op 04933
Sandoval v 201 W. 16 Owners Corp.		Index No. 31594/18, 43154/19, 43417/19, 43422/19 Appeal No. 2736 Case No. 2023-03560	2024 NY Slip Op 04932
Sagoe v Danella Constr. of NY, Inc.		Index No. 20689/16 Appeal No. 2746 Case No. 2023-02814	2024 NY Slip Op 04931
Matter of Regal Cinemas, Inc. v Atom Tickets, LLC		Index No. 652782/21 Appeal No. 2725-2726 Case No. 2022-00908, 2022-00909	2024 NY Slip Op 04930
Matter of Portocarrero v Poole		Index No. 452958/22 Appeal No. 2724 Case No. 2023-02757	2024 NY Slip Op 04929
Pleskun v Rogova		Index No. 150768/18 Appeal No. 2718 Case No. 2023-04106	2024 NY Slip Op 04928
People v Guillen-Beltre		Ind. No. 0384/15 Appeal No. 2749 Case No. 2022-03448	2024 NY Slip Op 04927
People v Pichardo		Ind. No. 2748/11 Appeal No. 2748 Case No. 2013-01589	2024 NY Slip Op 04926
People v McDaniels		Ind. No. 2330/17 Appeal No. 2732 Case No. 2019-04056	2024 NY Slip Op 04925
People v Rodriguez		Ind. No. 4412/18 Appeal No. 2755 Case No. 2019-03778	2024 NY Slip Op 04924
People v Soberanis		Ind. No. 1539/19 Appeal No. 2762 Case No. 2019-04784	2024 NY Slip Op 04923
People v Barksdale		Ind. No. 1457/18 Appeal No. 2733 Case No. 2024-00580	2024 NY Slip Op 04922
People v Barlow		SCI No. 3745/18 Appeal No. 2757 Case No. 2019-2332	2024 NY Slip Op 04921
People v Perry		Ind. No.1389/21 Appeal No. 2723, M-4242 Case No. 2023-02647	2024 NY Slip Op 04920
People v Roper		Docket No. 32282/11 Appeal No. 2737 Case No. 2018-464	2024 NY Slip Op 04919
People v Gerson		Ind. No. 427/18, 1141/18 Appeal No. 2715 Case No. 2022-01519	2024 NY Slip Op 04918
People v Galantter		Ind. No. 3103/15 Appeal No. 2728 Case No. 2018-2548	2024 NY Slip Op 04917
People v Gantt		Ind. No. 993/18 Appeal No. 2752 Case No. Case No. 2019-03404	2024 NY Slip Op 04916
Payano v Proto Prop. Servs. LLC		Index No. 22996/20 Appeal No. 2750 Case No. 2024-00939	2024 NY Slip Op 04915
Owens v Braun		Index No. 100405/22 Appeal No. 2756-2756A Case No. 2023-04904	2024 NY Slip Op 04914
Nadler v Carmine Ltd.		Index No. 155461/22 Appeal No. 2754 Case No. 2023-06192	2024 NY Slip Op 04913
Molner v Molner		Index No. 301261/12 Appeal No. 2738, M-4082 Case No. 2024-01055	2024 NY Slip Op 04912
Matter of Mariana Trading Inc. v Amazon.Com Servs., LLC		Index No. 651075/23 Appeal No. 2765 Case No. 2023-06547	2024 NY Slip Op 04911
Lev v Eataly USA LLC		Index No. 154470/20 Appeal No. 2763 Case No. 2024-02764	2024 NY Slip Op 04910
Matter of Johnson & Johnson v Northwell Health Inc.		Index No. 153527/24, 153220/24 Appeal No. 2739-2740 Case No. 2024-03951, 2024-03913	2024 NY Slip Op 04909
Matter of Howard v New York City Police Dept.		Index No. 156621/22 Appeal No. 2716 Case No. 2023-06223	2024 NY Slip Op 04908
Matter of Jaiden H. v Jeanette H.		Docket No. NA-1969/23, NA-1970/23 Appeal No. 2744 Case No. 2023-03644	2024 NY Slip Op 04907
Matter of Fein v Langer	Oing, J.	Index No. 651198/23 Appeal No. 2198-2201 Case No. 2023-01660, 2023-03490, 2023-03491, 2023-03492	2024 NY Slip Op 04906
Matter of S.F. v Navasia A.J.		Docket No. 07508-9/21, 09602/22 Appeal No. 2717 Case No. 2023-05790	2024 NY Slip Op 04905
Matter of R.F. (Robert F.)		Docket No. B-00561/15 Appeal No. 2729 Case No. 2023-03646	2024 NY Slip Op 04904
Matter of Curry v Hagler		Index No. 570224/11 Appeal No. 2766 Case No. 2024-05230	2024 NY Slip Op 04903
Crandall v Equinox Holdings, Inc.		Index No. 157373/18 Appeal No. 2758-2759 Case No. 2023-04948	2024 NY Slip Op 04902
Matter of Cooper v Best		Appeal No. 2741 Case No. 2024-03074	2024 NY Slip Op 04901
Coney Is. Auto Holdings, Corp. v Parts Auth., LLC		Index No. 656816/22 Appeal No. 2764 Case No. 2024-00255	2024 NY Slip Op 04900
Cain v 42 W. 65th LLC		Index No. 155713/22 Appeal No. 2743 Case No. 2023-03390	2024 NY Slip Op 04899
Borek v Seidman		Index No. 805351/21 Appeal No. 2719-2722 Case No. 2023-01118, 2023-01272, 2023-02051, 2023-02052	2024 NY Slip Op 04898
Ashekian v Cresco Labs LLC		Index No. 656112/21 Appeal No. 2734-2735 Case No. 2023-02994, 2023-03005	2024 NY Slip Op 04897

**Cases Decided October 3, 2024**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Ace Am. Ins. Co. v Consolidated Edison Co. of N.Y., Inc.		Index No. 153899/16, 595491/17 Appeal No. 2706 Case No. 2023-03284	2024 NY Slip Op 04800
Matter of Windermere Props., LLC v City of New York		Index No. 151908/22 Appeal No. 2687 Case No. 2023-03306	2024 NY Slip Op 04842
Sweetpea Ventures Inc. v Belmamoun		Index No. 650812/22 Appeal No. 2677 Case No. 2023-01901	2024 NY Slip Op 04841
Stafford v EV Transp. Servs., Inc.		Index No. 652390/23 Appeal No. 2712-2712A Case No. 2024-00418 2024-03689	2024 NY Slip Op 04840
Schneider v 254 PAS Prop. LLC		Index No. 109136/09 Appeal No. 2690 Case No. 2024-02305	2024 NY Slip Op 04839
Rockefeller Univ. v Aetna Cas. & Sur. Co.		Index No. 654425/19 Appeal No. 2686 Case No. 2024-00112	2024 NY Slip Op 04838
People v Seabrook		Ind No. 4750/17 Appeal No. 2697 Case No. 2019-05090	2024 NY Slip Op 04837
People v Underwood		Ind No. 75339/22 Appeal No. 2705 Case No. 2023-06285	2024 NY Slip Op 04836
People v Clark		Ind No. 74965/22 Appeal No. 2685 Case No. 2023-05126	2024 NY Slip Op 04835
People v Aguilar		Ind No. 2408/17 Appeal No. 2684 Case No. 2020-01033	2024 NY Slip Op 04834
People v Powell		Ind No. 889/21 Appeal No. 2704 Case No. 2023-00126	2024 NY Slip Op 04833
People v Rivera		Ind No. 1453/18 Appeal No. 2688-2689 Case No. 2019-05303 2020-00574	2024 NY Slip Op 04832
People v Bah		Ind No. 1474/18 Appeal No. 2711 Case No. 2020-00217	2024 NY Slip Op 04831
People v Svendsen		Ind No. 514/20 Appeal No. 2670 Case No. 2022-03839	2024 NY Slip Op 04830
People v Alsina		Ind No. 4394/15 Appeal No. 2693 Case No. 2017-03428	2024 NY Slip Op 04829
People v Haskins		SCI No. 0046/20 Appeal No. 2682 Case No. 2022-01049	2024 NY Slip Op 04828
People v Martinez		Ind No. 2116/18 72909/22 Appeal No. 2679-2679A Case No. 2022-02020 2022-05010	2024 NY Slip Op 04827
People v Gordon		Ind No. 1288/18 Appeal No. 2701 Case No. 2022-04961	2024 NY Slip Op 04826
People v Mulero		Ind No. 419/13 Appeal No. 2678 Case No. 2019-5766	2024 NY Slip Op 04825
People v Zubidi	O'Neill Levy, J.	Index No. 1731/19 Appeal No. 2534 Case No. 2022-02960	2024 NY Slip Op 04824
People v Suber		Ind No. 889/20 Appeal No. 2709 Case No. 2022-03061	2024 NY Slip Op 04823
People v Ceesay		Index No. 1641/17 Appeal No. 2699 Case No. Case No. 2018-03040	2024 NY Slip Op 04822
Padilla v Estate of James Clayton Larmett		File No. 1152B/21 Appeal No. 2700 Case No. 2023-05763	2024 NY Slip Op 04821
Newman v New York City Hous. Auth.		Index No. 152547/18, 595593/18 Appeal No. 2683 Case No. 2023-03384	2024 NY Slip Op 04820
Matter of Michalow v D.E. Shaw & Co., L.P.		Index No. 653480/22 Appeal No. 2708 Case No. 2023-02951	2024 NY Slip Op 04819
Matter of Naccarato	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2024-03548 Case No. 2023-04735	2024 NY Slip Op 04818
Matter of 197 Madison Holdings LLC v NYS Div. of Hous. & Community Renewal		Index No. 154462/22, 154402/22 Appeal No. 2675-2576 Case No. 2023-05628, 2023-05625	2024 NY Slip Op 04817
Lamerique v Columbia Univ.		Index No. 161478/21 Appeal No. 2691 Case No. 2024-01570	2024 NY Slip Op 04816
Kolodziejski v Jen-Mar Elec. Serv. Corp.		Index No. 105627/11 Appeal No. 2713-2713A Case No. 2024-02552	2024 NY Slip Op 04815
John Doe XIII v Archdiocese of N.Y.		Index No. 950065/20 Appeal No. 2692 Case No. 2024-02043	2024 NY Slip Op 04814
Jane Doe v Blackrabbit 19		Index No. 153384/18 34452/20 Appeal No. 2696 Case No. 2023-05702	2024 NY Slip Op 04813
Haart v Scaglia		Index No. 652373/22 Appeal No. 2710 Case No. 2023-01943	2024 NY Slip Op 04812
Furman v Lexington Ave. Hotel		Index No. 157175/14 595418/15 595070/16 595516/18 Appeal No. 2707 Case No. 2023-03283	2024 NY Slip Op 04811
Fields v General Conference of the United Methodist Church		Index No. 950932/21 Appeal No. 2702 Case No. 2023-05925	2024 NY Slip Op 04810
Fernandez v Suffolk County Pub. Admr.		Index No. 155629/22 Appeal No. 2714 Case No. 2023-01075	2024 NY Slip Op 04809
Matter of Dana F. v Derek A.		Docket No. F-05504-04/21E Appeal No. 2695 Case No. 2023-01843	2024 NY Slip Op 04808
Duran v East 185th St. Realty Corp.		Index No. 27791/19E Appeal No. 2698 Case No. 2024-00899	2024 NY Slip Op 04807
Cox v Seniorcare Emergency Med. Servs., Inc.		Index No. 808307/21 Appeal No. 2680 Case No. 2024-02072	2024 NY Slip Op 04806
Matter of Chloe F.C. v Steven J.C.		G-04903/21 Case No. 2023-05575 Docket No. G-04903/21 Appeal No. 2672 Case No. 2023-05575	2024 NY Slip Op 04805
Board of Mgrs. of 570 Broome Condominium v Soho Broome Condos LLC		Index No. 650950/23 Appeal No. 2681 Case No. 2023-05814	2024 NY Slip Op 04804
Betancourt v Burnside Mews Assoc., L.P.		Index No. 21290/18E Appeal No. 2694 Case No. 2023-04527	2024 NY Slip Op 04803
Alevy v Herz		Index No. 158691/21 Appeal No. 2673-2674 Case No. 2023-03053 2023-04581	2024 NY Slip Op 04802
Adams v Legacy Carting Corp.		Index No. 25033/17E Appeal No. 2671 Case No. 2023-03810	2024 NY Slip Op 04801

**Cases Decided October 1, 2024**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of 174th TIC Owner LLC v Niblack	Index No. 161172/22 Appeal No. 2658 Case No. 2023-03127	2024 NY Slip Op 04734
Tower Natl. Ins. Co. v Lugo	Index No. 160305/18 Appeal No. 2650 Case No. 2023-04325	2024 NY Slip Op 04753
Tejada-Rodriguez v 76 Eleventh Ave. Prop. Owner LLC.	Index No. 29502/18 Appeal No. 2663 Case No. 2023-03709	2024 NY Slip Op 04752
Strout v CF E 88 LLC	Index No. 161439/19 Appeal No. 2667 Case No. 2024-01945	2024 NY Slip Op 04751
Schwartz v Mount Sinai Hosp.	Index No. 805218/21 Appeal No. 2666 Case No. 2023-06366	2024 NY Slip Op 04750
Pitang v Beacon Broadway Co., LLC	Index No. 27350/17 Appeal No. 2654 Case No. 2023-00996	2024 NY Slip Op 04749
People v Humphrey	Ind. No. 4032/14 Appeal No. 2647 Case No. 2018-2140	2024 NY Slip Op 04748
People v Rosa	Ind. No. 854/2017 Appeal No. 2664 Case No. 2019-3977	2024 NY Slip Op 04747
People v Williams	Ind. No. 0066/13 Appeal No. 2656 Case No. 2019-1814	2024 NY Slip Op 04746
People v Jones	Ind. No. 4877/04 Appeal No. 2665 Case No. 2021-04780	2024 NY Slip Op 04745
People v Ruiz	Ind. No. 591/20 Appeal No. 2657 Case No. 2024-01634	2024 NY Slip Op 04744
People v Martinez	Ind. No. 70130/23, 74765/22 Appeal No. 2652-2653 Case No. 2023-05113, 2024-00738	2024 NY Slip Op 04743
People v Parker	Ind. No. 1052/17 Appeal No. 2661 Case No. 2019-2292	2024 NY Slip Op 04742
Kapitus Servicing, Inc. v Epazz, Inc.	Index No. 651031/20 Appeal No. 2651 Case No. 2023-03227	2024 NY Slip Op 04741
Diaz v City of New York	Index No. 301016/10 Appeal No. 2668-2669 Case No. 2023-04777, 2024-00733	2024 NY Slip Op 04740
De Vito v Yeh	Index No. 152393/23 Appeal No. 2660 Case No. 2023-05336	2024 NY Slip Op 04739
Matter of Chef Tang LLC v Orchard Hospitality Corp.	Index No. 650501/24 Appeal No. 2662 Case No. 2024-01712	2024 NY Slip Op 04738
Matter of Browning v DM Tellock & Assoc., PLLC	Index No. 652528/23 Appeal No. 2655 Case No. 2023-06426	2024 NY Slip Op 04737
Matter of Aflalo	Index No. 3950/19 Appeal No. 2648 Case No. 2023-03937	2024 NY Slip Op 04736
A&D Family Homes, LLC v Herz	Index No. 154298/21 Appeal No. 2659 Case No. 2023-02163, 2023-04770	2024 NY Slip Op 04735