Appellate Division, First Department Decisions

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

**Cases Decided September 26, 2024**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
20 Broad St. Owner LLC v Sonder USA, Inc.		Index No. 653493/20 Appeal No. 2232 Case No. 2023-06145	2024 NY Slip Op 04591
Solo Group LLC, Series 9 v Dunia		Index No. 381387/08 Appeal No. 2616[M-4104] Case No. 2024-00608	2024 NY Slip Op 04633
Matter of Wythe Berry LLC v Goldman		Index No. 655683/23 Appeal No. 2615 Case No. 2023-06011	2024 NY Slip Op 04632
V.Z. v Roman Catholic Diocese of Burlington		Index No. 950164/19 Appeal No. 2619 Case No. 2023-02044	2024 NY Slip Op 04631
TH Fashion Ltd. v Vince Holding Corp.		Index No. 159241/23 Appeal No. 2618 Case No. 2024-02233	2024 NY Slip Op 04630
Swallows v W N.Y. Times Sq.		Index No. 153537/22 Appeal No. 2635 Case No. 2024-00313	2024 NY Slip Op 04629
Matter of Aminata S. v Ndongo D.		Docket No. V01882/23 V01883/23 Appeal No. 2608 Case No. 2023-06816	2024 NY Slip Op 04628
Rabinowitz v Clarke		Index No. 807713/21 Appeal No. 2645 Case No. 2023-06056	2024 NY Slip Op 04627
Matter of Cherie D. R. (Keith M. R.)		Docket No. B-7446/22 V-8750/23 Appeal No. 2628 Case No. 2024-00592	2024 NY Slip Op 04626
People v Paulino	SHULMAN, J.	Index No. 1656/17 Appeal No. 1955 Case No. 2018-2414	2024 NY Slip Op 04625
People v Norman		Ind No. 2782/15 Appeal No. 2644 Case No. 2019-5228	2024 NY Slip Op 04624
People v Harris		Ind No. 928N/17 Appeal No. 2614 Case No. 2018-1964	2024 NY Slip Op 04623
People v Kuchma		Ind No. 4410/15 91/16 Appeal No. 2626-2626A Case No. 2017-1445	2024 NY Slip Op 04622
People v Perez		Ind No. 3196/15 Appeal No. 2609 Case No. 2018-1235	2024 NY Slip Op 04621
People v Lopez		Ind No. 99014/20 Appeal No. 2643 Case No. 2022-02438	2024 NY Slip Op 04620
People v Lucas		Ind No. 596/21 Appeal No. 2606 Case No. 2023-00615	2024 NY Slip Op 04619
People v Brown		Ind No. 3268/18 Appeal No. 2617 Case No. 2022-01893	2024 NY Slip Op 04618
People v Johnson		Ind No. 1180/21 Appeal No. 2610 Case No. 2022-04878	2024 NY Slip Op 04617
People v Allen		Ind No. 3808/18 Appeal No. 2632 Case No. 2020-00233	2024 NY Slip Op 04616
People v Maldonado		Ind No. 71803/22 Appeal No. 2636 Case No. 2022-04337	2024 NY Slip Op 04615
People v Orenstein		Ind No. 211/19 2303/19 SCI No. 1605/19 Appeal No. 2621-2622 Case No. 2020-00558 2021-03492	2024 NY Slip Op 04614
People v Carey		SCI No. 167/19 Appeal No. 2633 Case No. 2019-3991	2024 NY Slip Op 04613
People v Jones		Ind No. 71847/23 Appeal No. 2637 Case No. 2023-05319	2024 NY Slip Op 04612
Murray v Stone		Index No. 157220/21 Appeal No. 2641-2642 Case No. 2023-04404 2023-05603	2024 NY Slip Op 04611
Mosquera v TF Cornerstone Inc.		Index No. 23663/16 Appeal No. 2629 Case No. 2023-01706	2024 NY Slip Op 04610
Molina v Loft 124 Condominium		Index No. 150937/17 Appeal No. 2611 Case No. 2023-05954	2024 NY Slip Op 04609
Matter of Smith	PER CURIAM	Motion No. 2024-02770 Case No. 2024-03669	2024 NY Slip Op 04608
Matter of Orochena	P E R C U R I A M	Motion No. 2024-03288 Case No. 2024-04172	2024 NY Slip Op 04607
Matter of McNary	P E R C U R I A M	Motion No. 2024-03719 Case No. 2024-03289	2024 NY Slip Op 04606
Madison Hospitality Mgt. LLC v Acacia Network Hous., Inc.		Index No. 656639/20, 595806/21 Appeal No. 2634 Case No. 2023-04995	2024 NY Slip Op 04605
Hernandez v Samouha		Index No. 153558/18 Appeal No. 2625 Case No. 2024-03060	2024 NY Slip Op 04604
Galarza v City of New York		Index No. 28727/17 Appeal No. 2613 Case No. 2023-00810	2024 NY Slip Op 04603
Friedman v Bloomberg, L.P.		Index No. 152952/21 Appeal No. 2639 Case No. 2023-06013	2024 NY Slip Op 04602
Envision Healthcare Corp. v XL Ins. Am., Inc.		Index No. 651163/22 Appeal No. 2631 Case No. 2023-02825	2024 NY Slip Op 04601
Matter of Davenport v New York State Dept. of Fin. Servs.		Index No. 160242/21 Appeal No. 2612 Case No. 2023-06472	2024 NY Slip Op 04600
Casiano v Riverdale SNF, LLC		Index No. 801306/21 Appeal No. 2640 Case No. 2023-04008	2024 NY Slip Op 04599
Bortugno v New York State Urban Dev. Corp.		Index No. 150623/13 590330/13 590151/14 Appeal No. 2607-2607A Case No. 2023-06186	2024 NY Slip Op 04598
Board of Mgrs. of Cipriani Club Residences at 55 Wall Condominium v Howard L. Zimmerman Architects & Engrs. DPC		Index No. 650480/22 Appeal No. 2638 Case No. 2023-04627	2024 NY Slip Op 04597
Matter of Berkley Ins. Co. v Schnall		Index No. 654949/22 Appeal No. 2624 Case No. 2023-04219	2024 NY Slip Op 04596
Aponte v Uber Tech., Inc.		Index No. 153629/22 Appeal No. 2630 Case No. 2023-05722	2024 NY Slip Op 04595
American Pipe & Tank Lining Co., Inc. v National Union Fire Ins. Co. of Pittsburgh, PA		Index No. 152057/22 595624/22 Appeal No. 2620 Case No. 2023-05169	2024 NY Slip Op 04594
6 W. 20th St. Tenants Corp. v Dezer Props. LLC		Index No. 158046/21 Appeal No. 2623 Case No. 2024-01058N	2024 NY Slip Op 04593
558 Seventh Ave. Corp. v PKNY IV, LLC		Index No. 160550/20 Appeal No. 2627 Case No. 2024-2710	2024 NY Slip Op 04592

**Cases Decided September 24, 2024**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
4CS Ltd v Kahiri Diamonds Ltd		Index No. 650976/20 Appeal No. 2605 Case No. 2023-06790	2024 NY Slip Op 04513
Matter of M.V.		Docket No. D-14854/23 Appeal No. 2585 Case No. 2023-05000	2024 NY Slip Op 04535
Umeh v New York City Health & Hosps. Corp.		Index No. 29886/20 Appeal No. 2340 Case No. 2023-03578	2024 NY Slip Op 04534
Smith v Extell W. 45th LLC		Index No. 160712/13 Appeal No. 2597 Case No. 2023-05265	2024 NY Slip Op 04533
Reid v City of New York		Index No. 400032/14 Appeal No. 2595 Case No. 2024-00661	2024 NY Slip Op 04532
Matter of Police Benevolent Assn. of the City of N.Y., Inc. v New York City Civilian Complaint Review Bd.		Index No. 150441/23 Appeal No. 2594&M-2024-04178 Case No. 2024-01130	2024 NY Slip Op 04531
People v Arthur		Ind. No. 489/21, 2196/21 Appeal No. 2587-2588 Case No. 2022-04142, 2022-04144	2024 NY Slip Op 04530
People v Feldmeth		Ind. No. 2754/18 Appeal No. 2591 Case No. 2020-01095	2024 NY Slip Op 04529
People v McPhaul		Ind. No. 71352/23 Appeal No. 2600 Case No. 2023-05483	2024 NY Slip Op 04528
People v Gray		Ind No. 1213/21 Appeal No. 2586 Case No. 2023-01749	2024 NY Slip Op 04527
People v Batista		Ind. No. 4279/17 Appeal No. 2583 Case No. 2020-00618	2024 NY Slip Op 04526
People v White		Ind. No. 498/18 Appeal No. 2596 Case No. 2020-02459	2024 NY Slip Op 04525
People v D.S.		Ind. No. 3252/19 Appeal No. 2603 Case No. 2021-04355	2024 NY Slip Op 04524
Oliveira v Top Shelf Elec. Corp.		Index No. 153436/20 Appeal No. 2601 Case No. 2023-03316	2024 NY Slip Op 04523
Odom v Williams		Index No. 12875/16 Appeal No. 2604 Case No. 2023-01255	2024 NY Slip Op 04522
Matter of Luna v Motor Veh. Acc. Indem. Corp.		Index No. 815058/23 Appeal No. 2584 Case No. 2024-00645	2024 NY Slip Op 04521
Matter of Kunz (F.H.)		Index No. 530880/23 Appeal No. 2602 Case No. 2024-01956	2024 NY Slip Op 04520
Hernandez v Opera Owners, Inc.		Index No. 32526/19 Appeal No. 2590 Case No. 2023-04393	2024 NY Slip Op 04519
Haim v 875 Park Ave. Corp.		Index No. 653123/23 Appeal No. 2589 Case No. 2024-01228	2024 NY Slip Op 04518
Gulf LNG Energy, LLC v Eni S.p.A.	Oing, J.,	Index No. 654819/18, 653520/20 Appeal No. 2101-02 Case No. 2023-04872, 2023-04874	2024 NY Slip Op 04517
Enchante Accessories, Inc. v Navigators Ins. Co.		Index No. 653403/22 Appeal No. 2592-2593 Case No. 2023-05457, 2023-05697	2024 NY Slip Op 04516
Matter of Dubuche v New York City Tr. Auth.		Index No. 151849/23 Appeal No. 2598-2599 Case No. 2023-04911, 2024-02167	2024 NY Slip Op 04515
Alfani v Rivercross Tenants Corp.		Index No. 160032/15 Appeal No. 2217 Case No. 2023-03043	2024 NY Slip Op 04514

**Cases Decided September 19, 2024**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Emmanuel C.F. (Patrice M. D. F.)		Docket No. NA-35058/23, NA-35059/23 Appeal No. 264 9 &M-4079 Case No. 2024-02338	2024 NY Slip Op 04482
Solidx Mgt. LLC v Vaneck Sec. Corp.		Index No. 650223/21 Appeal No. 2549 Case No. 2024-00538	2024 NY Slip Op 04489
People v Sparks	Gesmer, J.	Index No. 4231/19 Appeal No. 2505 Case No. 2022-01821	2024 NY Slip Op 04488
People v Tapia		Ind. No. 3500/16 Appeal No. 2076 Case No. 2018-04329	2024 NY Slip Op 04487
Matter of Ruby	PER CURIAM	Motion No. 2024-03093 Case No. 2024-01180	2024 NY Slip Op 04486
Matter of Gessen	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2024-03085 Case No. 2024-03991	2024 NY Slip Op 04485
Matter of Mantilla v New York City Dept. of Hous. Preserv. & Dev.		Index No. 153475/22 Appeal No. 2219 Case No. 2022-03774	2024 NY Slip Op 04484
Matter of Freedom Found. v New York City Dept. of Citywide Admin. Servs.		Index No. 152725/22 Appeal No. 2576 Case No. 2023-01154	2024 NY Slip Op 04483

**Cases Decided September 12, 2024**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of 18 W. 55th St. LLC v Pleiades House LLC		Index No. 154692/22 Appeal No. 2529 Case No. 2022-05676	2024 NY Slip Op 04437
People v Torres	RODRIGUEZ, J.	Index No. 4909/13 Appeal No. 1793 Case No. 2015-2283	2024 NY Slip Op 04442
People v Sanchez		Ind No. 73955/22 Appeal No. 2006 Case No. 2023-05014	2024 NY Slip Op 04441
Matter of Chism	PER CURIAM	Motion No. 2024-02148 Case No. 2023-01532	2024 NY Slip Op 04440
Mandracchia v Renovate-Create Sourcing & Procurement Corp.		Index No. 653953/19 Appeal No. 2438-2439 Case No. 2023-01377, 2023-05829	2024 NY Slip Op 04439
Matter of David E.		Index No. 500012/23, 500013/23 Appeal No. 2007-2008 Case No. 2023-05330, 2023-05331	2024 NY Slip Op 04438

**Cases Decided September 5, 2024**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
GCA Advisors, LLC v Intersections, Inc.		Index No. 656893/19 Appeal No. 2003-2004 Case No. 2023-03449, 2023-04530	2024 NY Slip Op 04359
Ria R Squared, Inc. v DW Partners, LP		Index No. 651101/22 Appeal No. 1757 Case No. 2023-03028	2024 NY Slip Op 04363
Picchioni v Sabur	ROSADO, J.	Index No. 21790/14 Appeal No. 2325 Case No. 2023-02240	2024 NY Slip Op 04362
People v Perkins		SCI No. 385/17 Appeal No. 2288 Case No. 2019-2046	2024 NY Slip Op 04361
People v Leslie		Ind. No. 99051/15 Appeal No. 1131 Case No. 2019-1672	2024 NY Slip Op 04360