skip to main content
Law Reporting
Bureau Thomas J.K. Smith, State Reporter

Appellate Division, Second Department Decisions

Current Month Archived Cases Motions

January 2005 Archive

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

Cases Decided January 31, 2005
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
Olga Arguinzoni v Parkway Hospital 2004-02261 2005 NY Slip Op 00507
Annette Aryeh v Nathaniel Aryeh 2004-07208 2005 NY Slip Op 00508
Eva Avezzano v Alberto Savoretti 2003-05391 2005 NY Slip Op 00509
Michael Baione v Central Suffolk Hospital 2003-03406 2005 NY Slip Op 00510
Jacqueline Beaton v Transit Facility Corp. 2004-05513 2005 NY Slip Op 00511
Yoram Ben-Amram v Miriam Hershowitz 2004-03297 2005 NY Slip Op 00512
Paul Brennan v R.C. Dolner, Inc. 2003-09015 2005 NY Slip Op 00513
CAB Associates v State of New York 2003-06069 2005 NY Slip Op 00514
Victoria Cally v New York Hospital Medical Center of Queens 2004-06456 2005 NY Slip Op 00515
Adam Capowski v Arlington Central School District 2004-02567 2005 NY Slip Op 00516
Casa Redimix Concrete Corp. v MacQuesten General Contracting, Inc. 2003-07710 2005 NY Slip Op 00517
City of New York v Long Island Power Authority 2003-07708 2005 NY Slip Op 00518
City of Peekskill v Timothy Schurr 2004-03180 2005 NY Slip Op 00519
Cooper, Bamundo, Hecht & Longworth, LLP v Gregory Kuczinski 2003-11151 2005 NY Slip Op 00520
John J. Curry v Patricia Curry 2003-08594 2005 NY Slip Op 00521
Susan Dahlin v Sarah J. Paladino 2004-03063 2005 NY Slip Op 00522
Melvyn DeVore v Gilbert S. Lederman 2004-02127 2005 NY Slip Op 00523
Timothy Edwards v United States Liability Insurance Company 2003-05424 2005 NY Slip Op 00524
Donald G. Gore v Giuseppe Cambareri 2004-01268 2005 NY Slip Op 00525
Dexter Greenwood v Charles W. Tuzzolo 2004-04608 2005 NY Slip Op 00526
Abraham C. Grossman v Team Care Home Care Agency, Inc. 2003-06189 2005 NY Slip Op 00527
Joseph Guarino v 233 East 69th Street Owners Corp. 2003-07685 2005 NY Slip Op 00528
Ira Hochman v Robert LaRea 2003-06713 2005 NY Slip Op 00529
Jordan Construction Products Corporation v Travelers Indemnity Company of America 2003-08657 2005 NY Slip Op 00530
Cheryl Kearse v New York City Transit Authority Crane 2002-10935 2005 NY Slip Op 00531
Key Bank National Association v Harry L. Stern 2003-06022 2005 NY Slip Op 00532
Daniel Kreiner v Mather Memorial Hospital 2004-02954 2005 NY Slip Op 00533
Robin Levenherz v Lee Povinelli 2003-07731 2005 NY Slip Op 00534
Robin Levenherz v Lee Povinelli 2003-10778 2005 NY Slip Op 00535
David Levy v Cheryl H. Grandone 2004-08714 2005 NY Slip Op 00536
Carlos A. Liaros v City of New York 2004-02480 2005 NY Slip Op 00537
Matthieu Maceno v Franklin Hospital Medical Center 2003-11172 2005 NY Slip Op 00538
Jaimie Magee v County of Suffolk 2004-03859 2005 NY Slip Op 00539
Silas Mancia v Metropolitan Transit Authority Long Island Bus 2003-08849 2005 NY Slip Op 00540
Hope Mangia v Minchew Santner & Brenner, LLP 2004-02950 2005 NY Slip Op 00541
Manna Fuel Oil Corp. v Paul R. Ades 2003-05911 2005 NY Slip Op 00542
Rosa Marquez v Juan Oballe 2004-01985 2005 NY Slip Op 00543
Peter Marren v William Ludlam 2003-07062 2005 NY Slip Op 00544
Mark Meely v 4 G's Truck Renting Co., Inc. Crane 2003-02933 2005 NY Slip Op 00545
Mi Ja Lee v Paul K. Glicksman 2004-02676 2005 NY Slip Op 00546
Vincent Richard Morgan v John McCaffrey 2003-07022 2005 NY Slip Op 00547
Agnes Jean Murphy v Kulka Construction Corp. 2002-11423 2005 NY Slip Op 00548
Aleksandr Naydis v LA Transportation Corp. 2004-01934 2005 NY Slip Op 00549
Juan Negron v JP Morgan Chase/Chase Manhattan Bank 2004-02316 2005 NY Slip Op 00550
Eliezer Tibor Neuhauser v Antonio Polanco 2003-08945 2005 NY Slip Op 00551
New York State Electric & Gas Corporation v State of New York 2003-06423 2005 NY Slip Op 00552
Jeanette O'Connor v Circuit City Stores, Inc. 2003-09216 2005 NY Slip Op 00553
Edward O'Neill v New York City Housing Authority 2003-07930 2005 NY Slip Op 00554
Old Republic National Title Insurance Company v Cardinal Abstract Corp. 2003-07003 2005 NY Slip Op 00555
Albert J. Perri v Gilbert Johnson Enterprises, Ltd. 2003-01732 2005 NY Slip Op 00556
Wanda Piatek v New York City Transit Authority 2003-03890 2005 NY Slip Op 00557
Antonia Rios v Johnson V.B.C. 2003-07880 2005 NY Slip Op 00558
Jovan Rodriguez v Booth Memorial Medical Center 2003-10615 2005 NY Slip Op 00559
Ramesh Sarva v Amitava Chakravorty 2004-00325 2005 NY Slip Op 00560
Wayne Small v New York City Transit Authority 2004-02814 2005 NY Slip Op 00561
Harold Sommers v Robert Cohen 2004-03359 2005 NY Slip Op 00562
Richard A. Spuhler v Mohammad R. Khan 2003-08793 2005 NY Slip Op 00563
Vincent Starnella v Burke Heat 2003-08310 2005 NY Slip Op 00564
Peter Stassou v Casini & Huang Construction, Inc. 2003-07702 2005 NY Slip Op 00565
Sakina Willis v New York City Transit Authority 2003-09427 2005 NY Slip Op 00566
David Winiarski v Duryea Associates, LLC 2003-09661 2005 NY Slip Op 00567
Matter of Allstate Insurance Company v Fidel R. Calderon 2004-00249 2005 NY Slip Op 00568
Matter of City of New York v Jamaica Arms Hotel, Inc. 2003-06854 2005 NY Slip Op 00569
Matter of Natale D'Altilio v Joy I. D'Altilio 2004-01917 2005 NY Slip Op 00570
Matter of Estate of Barbara W. Boothe v Alpha Development Corp. 2003-09046 2005 NY Slip Op 00571
Matter of Chester Flanders v New York State Division of Parole 2003-10752 2005 NY Slip Op 00572
Matter of Sam Mealie v Board of Zoning Appeals of Town of Brookhaven 2003-06310 2005 NY Slip Op 00573
Matter of New York Central Mutual Fire Insurance Company v Alfred L. Dukes 2003-08077 2005 NY Slip Op 00574
Matter of Erin Olsen v County of Nassau 2004-01660 2005 NY Slip Op 00575
Matter of Anthony R. v Elliot R. 2003-00493 2005 NY Slip Op 00576
Matter of Abraham Retek v City of New York 2003-09636 2005 NY Slip Op 00577
Matter of Travelers Indemnity Company v Safie Mohammed 2004-01544 2005 NY Slip Op 00578
Matter of Curtis Vann v Jennifer Vann 2004-01019 2005 NY Slip Op 00579
People v Ahmed Abdelghany 2003-01290 2005 NY Slip Op 00580
People v Wayne Brown 2001-10428 2005 NY Slip Op 00581
People v Carlyle Dale 2000-03862 2005 NY Slip Op 00582
People v Stuart Friedman 2002-11478 2005 NY Slip Op 00583
People v Beresford Hall 2004-00216 2005 NY Slip Op 00584
People v Kenneth Henderson 2003-04112 2005 NY Slip Op 00585
People v Kenroy Jackson 2002-08679 2005 NY Slip Op 00586
People v Gilbert Loo 2003-03777 2005 NY Slip Op 00587
People v Brian A. Manzullo 2004-03325 2005 NY Slip Op 00588
People v Trisha McPherson 2001-05785 2005 NY Slip Op 00589
People v Trisha McPherson 2004-01734 2005 NY Slip Op 00590
People v Steven Price 2001-01586 2005 NY Slip Op 00591
People v Raymond Rodriguez 2003-00342 2005 NY Slip Op 00592
People v Sameh Shaaban 2003-04952 2005 NY Slip Op 00593
People v Ralph S. Taufman 2003-11041 2005 NY Slip Op 00594
People v Cleon Watson 2002-04657 2005 NY Slip Op 00595
People v Robert A. Williams 2002-10945 2005 NY Slip Op 00596
People v Daniel Woodberry 1990-02656 2005 NY Slip Op 00597
Cases Decided January 24, 2005
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
Jamir Ali v Anani Agboglo 2003-08832 2005 NY Slip Op 00361
Linda Banuchis v Government Employees Insurance Co. 2004-01240 2005 NY Slip Op 00362
Nicole Bynum v Willie Salter 2004-02200 2005 NY Slip Op 00363
Jose Antonio Calix v New York City Transit Authority 2004-02371 2005 NY Slip Op 00364
Stephanie Casella v New York City Transit Authority 2004-01105 2005 NY Slip Op 00365
Andrew E. Check v Adnan Gacevk 2004-04467 2005 NY Slip Op 00366
Mary Crosson v Jamaica Hospital Medical Center 2003-08530 2005 NY Slip Op 00367
Antoneth Dawkins v Otis Stone 2004-05129 2005 NY Slip Op 00368
Nathaniel DelGadillo v City of New York 2004-05416 2005 NY Slip Op 00369
Wallace Dillon v Valco American Corp. 2004-00772 2005 NY Slip Op 00370
Dunkin Donuts of New York, Inc. v Mid-Valley Oil Company, Inc. 2003-03467 2005 NY Slip Op 00371
Gail S. Fanelli v George C. Fanelli 2003-07614 2005 NY Slip Op 00372
Elizabeth Freulich-Woodruff v B.A. Auto Repair, Inc. 2004-01960 2005 NY Slip Op 00373
Robert Hothan v Metropolitan Suburban Bus Authority 2003-04069 2005 NY Slip Op 00374
Sakyna Hunter v India Young 2004-01247 2005 NY Slip Op 00375
Icy Splash Food & Beverage, Inc. v Felix Henckel 2003-03390 2005 NY Slip Op 00376
Thomas P. Jedlicka v Gary Field 2004-02562 2005 NY Slip Op 00377
Eduardo Labarca v Abdul Rauf 2004-00912 2005 NY Slip Op 00378
Leon Petroleum, LLC v Tartan Corp. 2003-01526 2005 NY Slip Op 00379
John Livingston v City of New York 2004-00375 2005 NY Slip Op 00380
Florin C. Papa v 24 Caryl Avenue Realty Co. 2003-09151 2005 NY Slip Op 00381
Savitri I. Poliah v Westchester County Country Club, Inc. 2004-02403 2005 NY Slip Op 00382
Dorothea Richter v Hunter's Run Homeowners Association, Inc. 2004-00467 2005 NY Slip Op 00383
Martin Ross v Lan Chile Airlines 2004-01819 2005 NY Slip Op 00384
Milette Shanon v Jerome D. Patterson 2003-06675 2005 NY Slip Op 00385
Patricia Sherin v Amy Louise Roda 2004-01385 2005 NY Slip Op 00386
Jaroslaw Sierzputowski v City of New York 2004-02566 2005 NY Slip Op 00387
Georges Y. Takle v New York City Transit Authority 2004-01499 2005 NY Slip Op 00388
Workers' Compensation Board of State of New York v Joseph Rizzi 2004-03386 2005 NY Slip Op 00389
Robert J. Zysk v Fidelity Title Ins. Co. of New York 2004-00242 2005 NY Slip Op 00390
Matter of Allstate Insurance Company v Arlene S. Massre 2004-04342 2005 NY Slip Op 00391
Matter of Joseph Bruno v Lorraine Kerr 2003-10441 2005 NY Slip Op 00392
Matter of Colin Clarke v Raymond P. Martinez 2004-03443 2005 NY Slip Op 00393
Matter of DSMG Corp. v State of New York Division of Housing and Community Renewal 2003-07633 2005 NY Slip Op 00394
Matter of Newark Insurance Company v Jacqueline Caruso 2004-00101 2005 NY Slip Op 00395
Matter of Adonis Earl S. v Earl S. 2003-09664 2005 NY Slip Op 00396
Matter of Irving Schachter v State of New York Division of Housing and Community Renewal 2003-03985 2005 NY Slip Op 00397
Matter of Philip E. Sicks Per Curiam 2003-09487 2005 NY Slip Op 00398
Matter of 21 Lizensk Corporation v Yeshaiya Benyamin Spillman 2004-00166 2005 NY Slip Op 00399
People v Tislam Allah 1990-06100 2005 NY Slip Op 00400
People v David B. 2001-10648 2005 NY Slip Op 00401
People v Andrew Brunjes 2002-09619 2005 NY Slip Op 00402
People v Archie Chatman 2002-00623 2005 NY Slip Op 00403
People v Richenel Clark 2003-02357 2005 NY Slip Op 00404
People v Ayinde Fair 2001-05977 2005 NY Slip Op 00405
People v Khaliq Harris 2003-11313 2005 NY Slip Op 00406
People v Glenda Herring 2002-10082 2005 NY Slip Op 00407
People v Rasun King 2002-10707 2005 NY Slip Op 00408
People v Marvin Mack 2002-10081 2005 NY Slip Op 00409
People v Issac Mizrahi 2002-10164 2005 NY Slip Op 00410
People v Anthony Oldham 2004-03261 2005 NY Slip Op 00411
People v Dimas Perez 1999-11047 2005 NY Slip Op 00412
People v Jose Soto 2003-01942 2005 NY Slip Op 00413
People v David Talbert 2000-10850 2005 NY Slip Op 00414
People v Danette Vargas 2002-11009 2005 NY Slip Op 00415
Cases Decided January 25, 2005
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Rosemarie Panio v Carolee Sunderland 2004-11251 2005 NY Slip Op 00360
Cases Decided January 18, 2005
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
Michael Anderson v Olympia & York Tower B Company 2003-06193 2005 NY Slip Op 00233
P. Gerald Barbato v Hollow Hills Country Club 2004-06830 2005 NY Slip Op 00234
Arlee Boggin v Anna M. Wilson 2003-04905 2005 NY Slip Op 00235
Brennan Bros. Co., Inc. v Lumbermens Mutual Casualty Company 2003-10404 2005 NY Slip Op 00236
Ernesto Carballo v 444 East 87th Street Owners Corp. 2003-08073 2005 NY Slip Op 00237
Dartha Cunningham v Adam E. Diers 2003-04225 2005 NY Slip Op 00238
Dartha Cunningham v Adam E. Diers 2003-08502 2005 NY Slip Op 00239
Daniel Estrada v Berkel Incorporated 2003-03080 2005 NY Slip Op 00240
F.A.S.A. Construction Corporation v Village of Monroe 2003-05007 2005 NY Slip Op 00241
First Data Merchant Services Corp. v One Solution Corporation 2003-08586 2005 NY Slip Op 00242
442 Decatur Street, LLC v Spheres Realty, Inc. 2003-11381 2005 NY Slip Op 00243
Peter Hemingway v Pelham Country Club 2003-07730 2005 NY Slip Op 00244
J. Sackaris & Sons, Inc. v Terra Firma Construction Management & General Contracting, LLC 2002-11181 2005 NY Slip Op 00245
J. Sackaris & Sons, Inc. v Firma Construction Management & General Contracting, LLC 2003-04876 2005 NY Slip Op 00246
Lawrence Kaufman v Steven C. Kunis 2003-04843 2005 NY Slip Op 00247
Nissequogue Boat Club v State of New York 2003-03358 2005 NY Slip Op 00248
Robert Pacella v Whiteman Osterman & Hanna 2003-05888 2005 NY Slip Op 00249
Tomo Razmilovic v Thomas Dowd 2004-01618 2005 NY Slip Op 00250
Nicholas Sabbatini v Benito Galati 2004-04419 2005 NY Slip Op 00251
Jill Shuler v Larry Dupree 2003-07001 2005 NY Slip Op 00252
Anthony Sirico v Nancy L. Beukelaer 2004-06721 2005 NY Slip Op 00253
34-35 Corporation v Industry City Associates 2003-04593 2005 NY Slip Op 00254
Bertha Vera v Michael Fishman 2004-00202 2005 NY Slip Op 00255
Kenneth Whitfield v Board of Education of the City of Mount Vernon 2004-00318 2005 NY Slip Op 00256
Kenneth Whitfield v Board of Education of the City of Mount Vernon 2004-03118 2005 NY Slip Op 00257
Matter of Priscilla Abrams v Larry D. Martin 2004-06081 2005 NY Slip Op 00258
Matter of Astoria Gas Turbine Power, LLC v Tax Commission of City of New York 2003-04017 2005 NY Slip Op 00259
Matter of Hilary A. Best v State of New York 2004-10923 2005 NY Slip Op 00260
Matter of Carla Biundo v New York Central Mutual 2004-05898 2005 NY Slip Op 00261
Matter of Mildred Jeraldine C. v Elaine C. 2003-06446 2005 NY Slip Op 00262
Matter of Chubb Group of Insurance Companies v Beverly Williams 2003-10126 2005 NY Slip Op 00263
Matter of Charles Franklin Davis Per Curiam 2004-08671 2005 NY Slip Op 00264
Matter of Imperia Bros. Inc. v Raymond P. Martinez 2003-08930 2005 NY Slip Op 00265
Matter of Margaret Mateer v Peter Field 2002-10576 2005 NY Slip Op 00266
Matter of Alexa Miranda v Moses Vasquez 2004-01294 2005 NY Slip Op 00267
Matter of Ronald N. v Verna Eggleston 2003-10356 2005 NY Slip Op 00268
Matter of Mark Neuman 2003-10438 2005 NY Slip Op 00269
Matter of Cleveland R. 2003-07280 2005 NY Slip Op 00270
Matter of Kevin Smith v Supreme Court, Kings County 2003-08126 2005 NY Slip Op 00271
Matter of Village of Port Chester v Fabio Sorto 2003-10555 2005 NY Slip Op 00272
Matter of Susan L. Walberg v Edward A. Rudden 2003-04868 2005 NY Slip Op 00273
Matter of Raymond P. Wirth 2003-02506 2005 NY Slip Op 00274
People v John B. 2000-09074 2005 NY Slip Op 00275
People v Frederick Bembury 2000-09074 2005 NY Slip Op 00276
People v Jermaine Boykin 2003-04308 2005 NY Slip Op 00277
People v James R. Eaton 2003-00941 2005 NY Slip Op 00278
People v Courtney Green 2002-02838 2005 NY Slip Op 00279
People v Barry Mitchell 2003-07092 2005 NY Slip Op 00280
Cases Decided January 10, 2005
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
Julio Abreu v City of New York 2003-07517 2005 NY Slip Op 00117
Muhammed Anwar v Hellman Management 2003-09134 2005 NY Slip Op 00118
BDG Oceanside, LLC v RAD Terminal Corp. 2003-02886 2005 NY Slip Op 00119
William Capozzi v Robert Huhne 2004-03735 2005 NY Slip Op 00120
John Cotter v Summit Security Services, Inc. 2004-01333 2005 NY Slip Op 00121
Barbara Hoppmann D'Angelo v Ronald D'Angelo 2003-05057 2005 NY Slip Op 00122
Jack D'Elia v Joanne D'Elia 2003-02121 2005 NY Slip Op 00123
Maureen Dunleavy v Hilton Hall Apartments Co., LLC 2002-11400 2005 NY Slip Op 00124
405 44th Street Realty Co. v 168 Fortune Realty, Inc. 2003-04344 2005 NY Slip Op 00125
Justina Ganda v Deborah Cardinale 2003-08105 2005 NY Slip Op 00126
Leonora Gangi v DaimlerChrysler Corporation 2004-04117 2005 NY Slip Op 00127
J-Mar Service Center, Inc. v Mahoney, Connor & Hussey 2003-05910 2005 NY Slip Op 00128
Stephen T.B. Jablonski v Carolyn A. Rapalje 2003-04412 2005 NY Slip Op 00129
Annie Jagmohan v City of New York 2004-01136 2005 NY Slip Op 00130
Erein Justin v Steven Orshan 2003-05395 2005 NY Slip Op 00131
Lemonia Kolivas v Maureen D. Kirchoff 2003-08729 2005 NY Slip Op 00132
Vinod Kumar v Yonkers Contracting Company, Inc. 2003-04036 2005 NY Slip Op 00133
Martin Iron & Construction Co. v Grace Industries, Inc. 2003-06556 2005 NY Slip Op 00134
Candy Medina v City of New York 2003-04363 2005 NY Slip Op 00135
Midwest First Financial Limited Partership III v First American Title Insurance Company of New York 2003-06286 2005 NY Slip Op 00136
Eileen O'Connor v Marc C. Kuzmicki 2004-06018 2005 NY Slip Op 00137
Estrella Ocasio v Panagiota Zorbas 2003-03294 2005 NY Slip Op 00138
Joseph Orlando v Audax Construction Corp. 2003-08206 2005 NY Slip Op 00139
San Sung Korean Methodist Church of New York v Professional USA Construction Corp 2004-02852 2005 NY Slip Op 00140
John J. Schurmacher v Goran Djordjevski 2004-03905 2005 NY Slip Op 00141
2001 Commerce Street Corp. v Star Enterprise 2003-06156 2005 NY Slip Op 00142
Toni Wright v Evanston Insurance Company 2003-09064 2005 NY Slip Op 00143
Matter of AIU Insurance Company v Mimose Henry 2003-10634 2005 NY Slip Op 00144
Matter of Ebony Starr B. v Ebony B. 2004-01831 2005 NY Slip Op 00145
Matter of John Barbalious v Exterior Wall Systems, Inc. 2004-02062 2005 NY Slip Op 00146
Matter of County of Nassau v Civil Service Employees Association, Inc. 2004-01380 2005 NY Slip Op 00147
Matter of Scott D'Esposito v Noel Francine Kepler 2003-06816 2005 NY Slip Op 00148
Matter of Canvas H. 2004-01193 2005 NY Slip Op 00149
Matter of Susan Huddleston v Norman Huddleston 2003-11006 2005 NY Slip Op 00150
Matter of William K. 2003-06478 2005 NY Slip Op 00151
Matter of Madhu S. v Taijwaite S. 2003-09317 2005 NY Slip Op 00152
Matter of Susan Winkler v Michael Nussenblatt 2003-10222 2005 NY Slip Op 00153
People v Manolo Abreu 2000-01416 2005 NY Slip Op 00154
People v Angelo Espinal 2000-04687 2005 NY Slip Op 00155
People v Alvin Hudson 2000-06878 2005 NY Slip Op 00156
People v Michael Mack 2000-06878 2005 NY Slip Op 00157
People v David Thigpen 2001-03535 2005 NY Slip Op 00158
People v Michael Williams 2003-02980 2005 NY Slip Op 00159
People v Patrick Williams 2002-05820 2005 NY Slip Op 00160
People ex rel. Alvin L. Spitzer v William Clarke 2004-11276 2005 NY Slip Op 00161

Links to or from other sites do not signify endorsement or relationship with them.