Appellate Division, Third Department Decisions

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

**Cases Decided December 31, 2003**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Steven R. Mason	11878	2003 NYSlipOp 19899
People v Jesse D. Boyce	13623	2003 NYSlipOp 19900
People v Rafael Vinals	13791	2003 NYSlipOp 19901
People v Toyan A. Grose	13964	2003 NYSlipOp 19902
People v Hal La Valley	13985	2003 NYSlipOp 19903
People v Craig A. Leabo	14161	2003 NYSlipOp 19904
People v Terry D. Gannon	14176	2003 NYSlipOp 19905
People v Mark T. Thomson	14432	2003 NYSlipOp 19906
People v Michael Brown	14474	2003 NYSlipOp 19907
People v Clifford J. Ward	14549	2003 NYSlipOp 19908
People v Richard S. Loudenslager	14678	2003 NYSlipOp 19909
People v Timothy J. Nolan	14864	2003 NYSlipOp 19910
People v Todd O'Brien	14865	2003 NYSlipOp 19911
Matter of Susan Morrow v Loren Morrow	86918	2003 NYSlipOp 19912
Matter of Barney C. Custer v Paula N. Slater	92024	2003 NYSlipOp 19913
Matter of Paul Mitchell v J. Hessell	92823	2003 NYSlipOp 19914
Matter of Stephen L. v June L.	92842	2003 NYSlipOp 19915
Matter of Stoney Harrison v Donald Selsky	93116	2003 NYSlipOp 19916
Matter of Katlyn GG. v Christine GG.	93163	2003 NYSlipOp 19917
Matter of David P. Anderson v Lydall Manning	93239	2003 NYSlipOp 19918
Matter of Trisha M. Ortiz v Wilson Ortiz	93310	2003 NYSlipOp 19919
Matter of Peter WW. v Marilee YY.	93327	2003 NYSlipOp 19920
Matter of Douglas Knipple v Mildred Jackson	93348	2003 NYSlipOp 19921
Matter of Rafael Almonte v New York State Division of Parole	93442	2003 NYSlipOp 19922
Matter of Madison-Oneida Board of Cooperative Educational Services v Richard P. Mills	93661	2003 NYSlipOp 19923
Matter of Oni B. Cole v Commissioner of Labor	93701	2003 NYSlipOp 19924
Matter of Henry Marcial v Glenn S. Goord	93853	2003 NYSlipOp 19925
M.d. Morris v Cutting Motors	93935	2003 NYSlipOp 19926
Matter of Richard Reimers v American Axle Manufacturing	93946	2003 NYSlipOp 19927
Bettina Broer v William Hellermann	94016	2003 NYSlipOp 19928
Matter of Todd Dowdy v Glenn S. Goord	94130	2003 NYSlipOp 19929
Matter of Teresa E. Myers v H. Carl McCall	94182	2003 NYSlipOp 19930
Matter of John P. West v Commissioner of Labor	94254	2003 NYSlipOp 19931
Stephen A. Munson v Bambi M. Lippman	94280	2003 NYSlipOp 19932
Matter of Bonnie Jean Smyth v Thomas E. Flanigan	94281	2003 NYSlipOp 19933
Matter of Charles M.R. Hutchinson	94289	2003 NYSlipOp 19934
Dan R. Enterprises v Kuglers Service Station	94299	2003 NYSlipOp 19935
Matter of Annette M. Adams v Commissioner of Labor	94332	2003 NYSlipOp 19936
Patricia Hendrix v Royal F. Hendrix	94358	2003 NYSlipOp 19937
Matter of Rosemary A. Izzo v Commissioner of Labor	94369	2003 NYSlipOp 19938
Charles G. Smith v Augustin J. Delago	94430	2003 NYSlipOp 19939
Matter of Jeannette LL. v John A. Johnson	94436	2003 NYSlipOp 19940
Matter of Irving Rothe v United Medical Associates	94439	2003 NYSlipOp 19941

**Cases Decided December 29, 2003**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Roger L. Dworsky			2003 NYSlipOp 19943

**Cases Decided December 24, 2003**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Steven Jones		12921	2003 NYSlipOp 19828
People v Richard Almarez		13073	2003 NYSlipOp 19829
People v Marianne L. Perry		13594	2003 NYSlipOp 19830
People v Wilfredo Polanco		14170	2003 NYSlipOp 19831
People v Tesfay Abera		14209	2003 NYSlipOp 19832
People v Cyril Marshall		14323	2003 NYSlipOp 19833
People v Michael D. York		14451	2003 NYSlipOp 19834
People v Patrick S. Murray		14801	2003 NYSlipOp 19835
Matter of Jerrica J. v Catherine J.		91712	2003 NYSlipOp 19836
Matter of Donald E. Nye v IBM Corporation		92061	2003 NYSlipOp 19837
Gregory Cendales v State of New York		92984	2003 NYSlipOp 19838
Matter of Alison J. Manzano v Robert A. Manzano		93253	2003 NYSlipOp 19839
Matter of Margaret J. Winn v Wayne D. Baker		93365	2003 NYSlipOp 19840
Albert F. Holly v Betty S. Morgan		93477	2003 NYSlipOp 19841
Matter of Debbie Pastore v Commissioner of Labor		93649	2003 NYSlipOp 19842
Matter of Eddie Gonzalez v Glenn S. Goord		93655	2003 NYSlipOp 19843
Matter of Orlando Nieves v Glenn S. Goord		93866	2003 NYSlipOp 19844
Matter of Martha Palka v Union Endicott Central School District		93879	2003 NYSlipOp 19845
Clifford E. Relyea v Elaine K. Relyea		93926	2003 NYSlipOp 19846
Matter of Charles D. Henness v Price Chopper/Golub Corporation		93945	2003 NYSlipOp 19847
Matter of Yvonne Remillard v Marcellus W. Luck		93964	2003 NYSlipOp 19848
Matter of James E. v Rose E.		93993	2003 NYSlipOp 19849
Elizabeth McDonald v Josephine Lengel		94123	2003 NYSlipOp 19850
North4ore Realty v Dexter Bishop		94165	2003 NYSlipOp 19851
Matter of Rodney Rush v Glenn S. Goord		94184	2003 NYSlipOp 19852
Eden Park Health Services v Robert Estes		94219	2003 NYSlipOp 19853
Matter of Joann Skrandel v Richard Haese		94223	2003 NYSlipOp 19854
Matter of Vestal Central School District v Vestal Teachers Association		94258	2003 NYSlipOp 19855
Integrated Book Technology v T/R Systems		94300	2003 NYSlipOp 19856
Matter of John R. Dyer v Indium Corporation of America		94316	2003 NYSlipOp 19857
Naomi Jones v Robert M. Armstrong		94362	2003 NYSlipOp 19858
Matter of County of Orange v New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services	Mercure	94365	2003 NYSlipOp 19859
Matter of Civil Service Employees Association, Inc., Local 1000, Afscme, Afl-cio v New York State Public Employment Relations Board		94407	2003 NYSlipOp 19860
Matter of Marcy RR. v Carolyn SS.		94500	2003 NYSlipOp 19861
Juliette A. Guasconi v Thomas L. Pohl		94504	2003 NYSlipOp 19862
Matter of Jun Cao v Ping Zhao		94595	2003 NYSlipOp 19863

**Cases Decided December 23, 2003**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of William S. La Bahn			2003 NYSlipOp 19942

**Cases Decided December 18, 2003**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Ebin A. Coleman	12607	2003 NYSlipOp 19581
People v David Delosh	12640	2003 NYSlipOp 19582
People v Courtney B. Douglas	13013	2003 NYSlipOp 19583
People v Aaron Umber	13320	2003 NYSlipOp 19584
People v Charles W. Toland		2003 NYSlipOp 19585
People v Courtney B. Douglas	13801	2003 NYSlipOp 19586
People v Latrevette Smith	14057	2003 NYSlipOp 19587
People v Christopher Vandunk	14137	2003 NYSlipOp 19588
People v Dewitt Henry	14158	2003 NYSlipOp 19589
People v Rashad Reid	14221	2003 NYSlipOp 19590
People v Larry D. Kirkland	14366	2003 NYSlipOp 19591
People v Brandon M. Kinch	14492	2003 NYSlipOp 19592
People v Joseph R. Trathen	14599	2003 NYSlipOp 19593
People v Carrie L. Gambaccini	14711	2003 NYSlipOp 19594
People ex rel. Burt v James L. Campbell	91956	2003 NYSlipOp 19595
Matter of James S. Hollenbeck v Hollenbeck & Dailey	91994	2003 NYSlipOp 19596
Matter of Mahmood Yoonessi v State Board for Professional Medical Conduct	92009	2003 NYSlipOp 19597
Diane Pentony v Elena Saxe	92211	2003 NYSlipOp 19598
Matter of Robert E. McKee v Commissioner of Taxation and Finance	92650	2003 NYSlipOp 19599
James C. Douglas v Kingston Income Partners '87	93072	2003 NYSlipOp 19600
Matter of Sawhorse Lumber and More v Ray Amell	93212	2003 NYSlipOp 19601
Matter of Connie Rote v Lexington Center	93229	2003 NYSlipOp 19602
John B. Turner v Douglas R. Caesar	93252	2003 NYSlipOp 19603
Ish Chopra v Pella Window Corporation	93298	2003 NYSlipOp 19604
Matter of Friar Tuck Inn of Catskills v Town of Catskill	93300	2003 NYSlipOp 19605
Matter of Ralph B. Post	93334	2003 NYSlipOp 19606
Matter of Katya Schreiber v Peter Schreiber	93400	2003 NYSlipOp 19607
Matter of Robert C. Buckles v County of Sullivan	93409	2003 NYSlipOp 19608
Matter of Dylan Taylor v Robert E. Kranichfeld	93494	2003 NYSlipOp 19609
Michael Aldrich v Vera L. Sampier	93578	2003 NYSlipOp 19610
Cynthia Jackson v Gas Company	93690	2003 NYSlipOp 19611
Matter of Steven J. Bond v Village of Potsdam	93693	2003 NYSlipOp 19612
Robin J. Yarinsky v Steven Yarinsky	93709	2003 NYSlipOp 19613
Susan E. Moffitt v Kenneth R. Murray	93754	2003 NYSlipOp 19614
Matter of Olean City School District v New York State Education Department	93782	2003 NYSlipOp 19615
Charles W. Durham v New York East Travel	93799	2003 NYSlipOp 19616
Matter of Thomas L. Spinosa	93857	2003 NYSlipOp 19617
Matter of Tony Starks v Glenn S. Goord	93865	2003 NYSlipOp 19618
Matter of John Corona v New York State Department of Correctional Services	93870	2003 NYSlipOp 19619
Matter of Donald L. Hassig v Eugene L. Nicandri	93953	2003 NYSlipOp 19620
Matter of Mahlon Burroughs v Empire State Agricultural Compensation Trust	93974	2003 NYSlipOp 19621
Stanley F. Nourse v Fulton County Community Heritage Corporation	93992	2003 NYSlipOp 19622
Matter of Mary Palmer v New York State Division for Youth	94006	2003 NYSlipOp 19623
Matter of Steve Zakheim v Town of Fallsburg	94042	2003 NYSlipOp 19624
William Schwinghammer v Sullivan West Central School District	94045	2003 NYSlipOp 19625
Matter of Richard Sush v New York State Teachers' Retirement System	94092	2003 NYSlipOp 19626
Matter of Jeannie M. Fredenburg v Emerson Power Transmission	94116	2003 NYSlipOp 19627
Matter of Joanne Amadio v H. Carl McCall	94163	2003 NYSlipOp 19628
Matter of Norma M. Ford v Commissioner of Labor	94166	2003 NYSlipOp 19629
Matter of Hector Spinel v Commissioner of Labor	94179	2003 NYSlipOp 19630
Aaron Trudeau v Jon A. Cooke	94191	2003 NYSlipOp 19631
Matter of Site Acquisitions v Town of New Scotland	94211	2003 NYSlipOp 19632
Josephine Hayes v City of Amsterdam	94240	2003 NYSlipOp 19633
David Wells v British American Development Corporation	94255	2003 NYSlipOp 19634
Stacey Casey v Ridge Associates	94266	2003 NYSlipOp 19635
Matter of Yitka Kozak v Suny At Old Westbury	94268	2003 NYSlipOp 19636
Matter of Jan Millner v Cablevision	94303	2003 NYSlipOp 19637
Matter of Evelyn Francis v Delia A. Palombo	94988	2003 NYSlipOp 19638

**Cases Decided December 11, 2003**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Bernard Alston	12602	2003 NYSlipOp 19339
People v William P. Kalteux	12839	2003 NYSlipOp 19340
People v Kiermer Tarver	13261	2003 NYSlipOp 19341
People v Dewitt Gibson	13264	2003 NYSlipOp 19342
People v Joshua Shaw	13583	2003 NYSlipOp 19343
People v Scott R. Martin	13793	2003 NYSlipOp 19344
People v Ward J. Arnold	13815	2003 NYSlipOp 19345
People v Duncan Terry	14134	2003 NYSlipOp 19346
People v Shawn Henning	14171	2003 NYSlipOp 19347
People v Calvin Smith	14374	2003 NYSlipOp 19348
People v Joel Harris	14447	2003 NYSlipOp 19349
People v Kevin L. Thomas	14498	2003 NYSlipOp 19350
People v Tyler J. Boyce	14539	2003 NYSlipOp 19351
People v Nikolaus Koufomichalis	75687	2003 NYSlipOp 19352
George W. Chase v Cayuga Medical Center At Ithaca	91966	2003 NYSlipOp 19353
Jorge M. Pardo v Antonio C. Novello	92005	2003 NYSlipOp 19354
Matter of Gary Thompson v Saucke Brothers Construction Company	92186	2003 NYSlipOp 19355
Matter of Andrew Anowai v Holiday Inn	92480	2003 NYSlipOp 19356
Matter of Kathleen A. Curley v Allstate Insurance Company	92484	2003 NYSlipOp 19357
Matter of Consolidated Masonry Contractors v Linda Angello	92559	2003 NYSlipOp 19358
Chase Manhattan Bank v Joan Harris	92766	2003 NYSlipOp 19359
Matter of Fred Mateo v Alpha Mechanical Corporation	92836	2003 NYSlipOp 19360
Matter of Ronald Lynch v State of New York	92889	2003 NYSlipOp 19361
Matter of Harold Rosenberg v New York State Board of Regents	92904	2003 NYSlipOp 19362
Matter of Robert Wilson v Chicago Bridge & Iron	93321	2003 NYSlipOp 19363
Matter of John Zippo v Glenn S. Goord	93375	2003 NYSlipOp 19364
Matter of Eduard Aminov v New York Black Car Operators Injury Compensation Fund	93515	2003 NYSlipOp 19365
Matter of Henrietta Rodken v Dorothy Gordon	93555	2003 NYSlipOp 19366
Matter of John A. Johnson v Shelmar Corporation	93612	2003 NYSlipOp 19367
Matter of Pinkie Anderson v Central New York DDSO	93619	2003 NYSlipOp 19368
Matter of Rex O. Depew v Lancet Arch	93653	2003 NYSlipOp 19369
Daniel E. Gillespie v Flight Line Pub	93706	2003 NYSlipOp 19370
Matter of Dorothy Gennes v Longwood Central School District	93707	2003 NYSlipOp 19371
Nadine Lemoine v Cornell University	93723	2003 NYSlipOp 19372
Darryl Dunham v Broome County	93724	2003 NYSlipOp 19373
Matter of Donald W. La Rock v Commissioner of Labor	93733	2003 NYSlipOp 19374
W. Park Allen v Joseph E. Mastrianni	93735	2003 NYSlipOp 19375
Matter of Robert M. Cooney v Commissioner of Labor	93788	2003 NYSlipOp 19376
Matter of Jimmie W. Hall v H. Carl McCall	93873	2003 NYSlipOp 19377
Jeffrey John v John Engel	93925	2003 NYSlipOp 19378
Joseph D. Tatko v Sheldon Slate Products Company	93986	2003 NYSlipOp 19379
Henri Janian v John R. Barnes	94055	2003 NYSlipOp 19380
Matter of Jose Felton v Donald Selsky	94076	2003 NYSlipOp 19381
April M. Kappes v Cohoes Bowling Arena	94083	2003 NYSlipOp 19382
Matter of Peter A. Blake v Commissioner of Labor	94140	2003 NYSlipOp 19383
Matter of Ralph Esposito v Commissioner of Labor	94141	2003 NYSlipOp 19384
Matter of Saramma A. Joseph v H. Carl McCall	94174	2003 NYSlipOp 19385
Sean P. Canavan v David Galuski	94195	2003 NYSlipOp 19386
Shoaollah Farhadi-Jou v Key Bank of New York	94213	2003 NYSlipOp 19387
Andrew Greenberg, Inc. v Sir-tech Software	94215	2003 NYSlipOp 19388
Matter of Veronica Parsons-Zieba v Cornell University	94342	2003 NYSlipOp 19389

**Cases Decided December 4, 2003**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v David Stephens	12850	2003 NYSlipOp 19028
People v Robert Gaddy	13000	2003 NYSlipOp 19029
People v Gregory Lake	13361	2003 NYSlipOp 19030
People v Gregory Jackson	13471	2003 NYSlipOp 19031
People v Freddie Lee Toms	13965	2003 NYSlipOp 19032
People v Mark E. Cannon	14131	2003 NYSlipOp 19033
People v Douglas Lopez	14274	2003 NYSlipOp 19034
People v Michael Deperna	14283	2003 NYSlipOp 19035
People v John Dominy	14348	2003 NYSlipOp 19036
People v Mary T. Kalenak	14460	2003 NYSlipOp 19037
People v Bret D. McClean	14484	2003 NYSlipOp 19038
People v Christopher Saunders	14501	2003 NYSlipOp 19039
People v Allen W. Plaisted	14544	2003 NYSlipOp 19040
Matter of Bonnalee Vann v Christopher Herson	90044	2003 NYSlipOp 19041
Anita Morand v Michael Morand	92016	2003 NYSlipOp 19042
Matter of Radu Lupascu v Utog 2-Way Radio	92663	2003 NYSlipOp 19043
Gregory F. Ireland v Geico Corporation	92671	2003 NYSlipOp 19044
Matter of Evangelos A. Catsoulis v New York State Department of Health	92918	2003 NYSlipOp 19045
Matter of Rafael Rivera v Glenn S. Goord	93172	2003 NYSlipOp 19046
Lorentz W. Hansen v Kathleen L. Werther	93241	2003 NYSlipOp 19047
Christopher A. Kerr v Louisville Housing	93267	2003 NYSlipOp 19048
Matter of Alah Adams v Glenn S. Goord	93367	2003 NYSlipOp 19049
Matter of Jerald Miller v Glenn S. Goord	93419	2003 NYSlipOp 19050
Matter of Harvey Marcelin v Donald Selsky	93518	2003 NYSlipOp 19051
Matter of Jewel Restaneo v Commissioner of Labor	93538	2003 NYSlipOp 19052
People ex rel. Bernabe Encarnacion v Michael McGinnis	93638	2003 NYSlipOp 19053
Matter of Diallo R. A. Madison v Donald Selsky	93667	2003 NYSlipOp 19054
Richard J. Fortin v Hill & Markes, Inc.	93686	2003 NYSlipOp 19055
Matter of Chauncy Ramos v New York State Division of Parole	93772	2003 NYSlipOp 19056
Matter of Charles Hogencamp v AMSCAM	93801	2003 NYSlipOp 19057
Jo Ann Martin v Wilson Memorial Hospital	93830	2003 NYSlipOp 19058
Dana Grzelecki v Stephen F. Sipperly	93907	2003 NYSlipOp 19059
Lillian Aaron v Steven L. Aaron	93952	2003 NYSlipOp 19060
Matter of Langford P. Byron v State of New York, Civil Service Commission	93973	2003 NYSlipOp 19061
Matter of William H. Jones v Commissioner of Labor	93996	2003 NYSlipOp 19062
Matter of Jerome J. Petrillo v Commissioner of Labor	93999	2003 NYSlipOp 19063
Matter of Mary L. Culp v Commissioner of Labor	94004	2003 NYSlipOp 19064
Matter of Ann M. Early v Commissioner of Labor	94030	2003 NYSlipOp 19065
Matter of Walter L. Allen v Commissioner of Labor	94039	2003 NYSlipOp 19066
Matter of Mary Figueroa v Commissioner of Labor	94043	2003 NYSlipOp 19067
Matter of Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation v City of Saratoga Springs Assessor	94072	2003 NYSlipOp 19068
Matter of Alex A. Yanulavich v Appeals Board of Administrative Adjudication Bureau of New York State Department of Motor Vehicles	94081	2003 NYSlipOp 19069
Matter of Malta Town Centre I v Town of Malta Board of Assessment Review	94084	2003 NYSlipOp 19070
Robert J. Trentini v Metropolitan Property and Casualty Insurance Company	94099	2003 NYSlipOp 19071
Matter of Carl Johnson v Donald Selsky	94129	2003 NYSlipOp 19072
Matter of Phyllis Maldarelli v Commissioner of Labor	94146	2003 NYSlipOp 19073
Matter of William O. Alfaro v Commissioner of Labor	94168	2003 NYSlipOp 19074
Matter of Charles Place v Ryder	94202	2003 NYSlipOp 19075
Matter of Carol Perez v Victory Motor Inn	94264	2003 NYSlipOp 19076
Lori Gravelle v Nelson G. Dunster	94291	2003 NYSlipOp 19077

**Cases Decided December 3, 2003**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Joseph J. Balok			2003 NYSlipOp 19390