Appellate Division, Third Department Decisions

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

**Cases Decided November 26, 2003**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Francis J. Burdo		11606	2003 NYSlipOp 18927
People v Salaudeen A. Roots		12952	2003 NYSlipOp 18928
People v James T. Nelson		13988	2003 NYSlipOp 18929
People v Craig D. Neu		14109	2003 NYSlipOp 18930
People v Sean M. McCafferty		14164	2003 NYSlipOp 18931
People v David M. Donaldson		14166	2003 NYSlipOp 18932
People v James Lane		14210	2003 NYSlipOp 18933
People v Brandon W. Vedder		14255	2003 NYSlipOp 18934
People v Robert Williams		14285	2003 NYSlipOp 18935
People v Napoleon N. Tetreault		14364	2003 NYSlipOp 18936
People v Allen W. Plaisted		14547	2003 NYSlipOp 18937
People v Lisa Fezza		14601	2003 NYSlipOp 18938
Matter of Elizabeth Mcdevitt v Ernest Stimpson		91846	2003 NYSlipOp 18939
Matter of James W. Donlin v West Babylon Fire District		92140	2003 NYSlipOp 18940
Matter of Robert C. Lee v Paula L. Stark		92256	2003 NYSlipOp 18941
Matter of Michael Lynch v Ellen J. Tambascio		92257	2003 NYSlipOp 18942
Antonino Cassara v Maria Cassara		92269	2003 NYSlipOp 18943
Matter of Arlene McArdle v Pamela McArdle		92506	2003 NYSlipOp 18944
Matter of Douglas H. v Catherine H.		92648	2003 NYSlipOp 18945
Matter of Doreen Stitzel v Mark Brown		92701	2003 NYSlipOp 18946
Matter of Theodore N.		92910	2003 NYSlipOp 18947
Matter of Jean Somers Miller v Clayton Waters		92913	2003 NYSlipOp 18948
Matter of Evan P.		93006	2003 NYSlipOp 18949
Matter of Russell B. v Carol C.		93019	2003 NYSlipOp 18950
Matter of Patrick Coleman v Cheryl Coleman		93081	2003 NYSlipOp 18951
Matter of Kerrianne AA. v Linda AA.		93101	2003 NYSlipOp 18952
Matter of Nancy Crane v Julio Lopez-Arias		93194	2003 NYSlipOp 18953
Matter of Alan Ritchie v Renee Waters		93210	2003 NYSlipOp 18954
Matter of Kathy Messer v Commissioner of Labor		93233	2003 NYSlipOp 18955
Matter of Antonia QQ. v Lance RR.		93254	2003 NYSlipOp 18956
Matter of Thelonious Ragin v Glenn S. Goord		93358	2003 NYSlipOp 18957
Matter of Howard Freire v Glenn S. Goord		93384	2003 NYSlipOp 18958
Matter of Daniel Mercado v Glenn S. Goord		93422	2003 NYSlipOp 18959
Matter of James Patterson v Glenn S. Goord		93512	2003 NYSlipOp 18960
Matter of Rushawn Young v Floyd Bennett		93575	2003 NYSlipOp 18961
Matter of Luis Morales v Donald Selsky		93628	2003 NYSlipOp 18962
Matter of Karl Ahlers v New York State Division of Parole		93677	2003 NYSlipOp 18963
Matter of Linda Angello v National Finance Corporation		93710	2003 NYSlipOp 18964
Matter of Frank Engler v United Parcel Service		93810	2003 NYSlipOp 18965
Battenkill Veterinary Equine v Amy Cangelosi		93875	2003 NYSlipOp 18966
Matter of Louie Angel v Brion D. Travis		93904	2003 NYSlipOp 18967
Edward M. Smith v Lone Star Industries		93957	2003 NYSlipOp 18968
Albert Zanger v Margaret Zanger		93960	2003 NYSlipOp 18969
Matter of Erich D.		93991	2003 NYSlipOp 18970
Matter of Charlene E. Emeterio v Commissioner of Labor		93994	2003 NYSlipOp 18971
Matter of Timothy Parkhurst v Angela McFall	Crew III	93995	2003 NYSlipOp 18972
Paul D. Smith v Lori A. Smith		94010	2003 NYSlipOp 18973
Matter of Raul E. Burgos v David L. Miller		94100	2003 NYSlipOp 18974
Daniel Pinkowski v All-States Sawing & Trenching		94122	2003 NYSlipOp 18975
John H. Shultis v Lorna E. Reichel-Shultis		94190	2003 NYSlipOp 18976
Matter of Michele Cieslewicz v Commissioner of Labor		94259	2003 NYSlipOp 18977

**Cases Decided November 18, 2003**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Fidencio Rosario v Brion D. Travis		93932	2003 NYSlipOp 18421

**Cases Decided November 17, 2003**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Harry R. Hayes			2003 NYSlipOp 18978
Matter of Graeme Wood			2003 NYSlipOp 18979
Barbara H. Russell v Kimberly M. Perrone			2003 NYSlipOp 18373

**Cases Decided November 13, 2003**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Mark Rivenburgh	12315	2003 NYSlipOp 18274
People v Robert L. Robinson	12439	2003 NYSlipOp 18275
People v Ronald Grier	13192	2003 NYSlipOp 18276
People v Richard J. Barclay	13666	2003 NYSlipOp 18277
People v Omar Wright	13752	2003 NYSlipOp 18278
People v Kenneth Spencer	13971	2003 NYSlipOp 18279
People v Damion V. Frierson	14046	2003 NYSlipOp 18280
People v Joseph G. Hoppe	14201	2003 NYSlipOp 18281
People v Ronald L. Amato	14254	2003 NYSlipOp 18282
People v Louis Urbina	14322	2003 NYSlipOp 18283
People v Eric Howard	14370	2003 NYSlipOp 18284
People v James A. Schehr	14551	2003 NYSlipOp 18285
People v Marc A. Meyer	14720	2003 NYSlipOp 18286
Matter of Moran Towing Corporation v Michael H. Urbach	87765	2003 NYSlipOp 18287
Matter of Laurie Barager-Dieter v Kelly Temporary Services	91327	2003 NYSlipOp 18288
Matter of William Sohmer v Arben Construction Company	91558	2003 NYSlipOp 18289
Matter of Elizabeth Wyman v Maidas Floral Shop	92747	2003 NYSlipOp 18290
Matter of Taub's Carpet and Tile Corporation v Kenneth J. Ringler	92783	2003 NYSlipOp 18291
Michael Randolph v Mathew P. Warnecke	92983	2003 NYSlipOp 18292
County of Nassau v State of New York	92989	2003 NYSlipOp 18293
Matter of Barbara J. Brown v Clifton Recycling	93004	2003 NYSlipOp 18294
Matter of Harvey Evans v Jewish Home and Hospital	93106	2003 NYSlipOp 18295
Matter of John C. Scott v City of Albany	93122	2003 NYSlipOp 18296
Matter of Marilyn Conway v CBI Services, Inc.	93123	2003 NYSlipOp 18297
Matter of Joyce M. Holmes v Kelly Farm & Garden	93135	2003 NYSlipOp 18298
Matter of Green Harbour Homeowners' Association v Town of Lake George Planning Board	93432	2003 NYSlipOp 18299
Alex Cruz v State of New York	93440	2003 NYSlipOp 18300
Frederick E. Heidelmark v State of New York	93454	2003 NYSlipOp 18301
Matter of Jimmie J. Powell v Commissioner of Labor	93551	2003 NYSlipOp 18302
Matter of Interstate Industrial Corporation v Thomas K. Murphy	93670	2003 NYSlipOp 18303
Delphine W. Knight Brown v Arcady Realty Corporation	93687	2003 NYSlipOp 18304
Matter of Steven Kaiser v H. Carl Mccall	93689	2003 NYSlipOp 18305
Carol Burnell v Stephen J. Huneau	93716	2003 NYSlipOp 18306
Matter of Association of Cable Access Producers v Public Service Commission of State of New York	93721	2003 NYSlipOp 18307
Matter of Michael Katzer v County of Rensselaer	93765	2003 NYSlipOp 18308
Emaly Vasquez v George McGeever	93783	2003 NYSlipOp 18309
Matter of David R. Sachs v New York State Racing and Wagering Board, Division of Harness Racing	93784	2003 NYSlipOp 18310
Mortgage Money Unlimited v Walter J. Schaffer	93785	2003 NYSlipOp 18311
Mary M. McDonald v Josephine Lengel	93787	2003 NYSlipOp 18312
Matter of Colleen K. Brennan v Faith Broadcasting	93796	2003 NYSlipOp 18313
Theodore Bigelow v Dick's Sporting Goods	93919	2003 NYSlipOp 18314
Eleanor S. Harrington v Estate of Lawrence Crouse	93936	2003 NYSlipOp 18315
Jordan Adams v Todd Pagano	93938	2003 NYSlipOp 18316
Matter of Dale Malone v Bob Bernhardt Paving	93950	2003 NYSlipOp 18317
Matter of Steven G. Lynch v Commissioner of Labor	94005	2003 NYSlipOp 18318
Matter of Wan Zhang v Robert J. Murphy	94008	2003 NYSlipOp 18319
Matter of Joseph Raub v Cutler Hammer	94120	2003 NYSlipOp 18320
Gail A. Weiglhofer v Frederick L. Weiglhofer	94311	2003 NYSlipOp 18321

**Cases Decided November 6, 2003**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Raymond Taylor	11573	2003 NYSlipOp 18089
People v Preston A. Lawrence	12174	2003 NYSlipOp 18090
People v Hasheem Alston	12234	2003 NYSlipOp 18091
People v Daniel T. Chaires, Jr.	12241	2003 NYSlipOp 18092
People v David J. Obert	13312	2003 NYSlipOp 18093
People v Nate Beander	13943	2003 NYSlipOp 18094
People v Everett R. Whalen	14000	2003 NYSlipOp 18095
People v Frank Lerario	14203	2003 NYSlipOp 18096
People v Joshua L. Meyer	14219	2003 NYSlipOp 18097
People v James A. Peltier	14284	2003 NYSlipOp 18098
People v Donnell Lewis	14507	2003 NYSlipOp 18099
People v Michael N. Moorehead	14680	2003 NYSlipOp 18100
People v Richard D. Johnson	78646	2003 NYSlipOp 18101
Andre T. McCants v State of New York	91054	2003 NYSlipOp 18102
Matter of Edward Stromski v Jefferson Auto Body	91149	2003 NYSlipOp 18103
Matter of Nancy Steen v Governor's Office of Employee Relations	91566	2003 NYSlipOp 18104
Matter of Ronald Citrin v Harry Merkle	92357	2003 NYSlipOp 18105
Matter of Jerald Miller v Glenn S. Goord	92406	2003 NYSlipOp 18106
Matter of Chaka Mosi Kamau Zulu v Thomas J. Egan	92698	2003 NYSlipOp 18107
Steven Sweeney v Jeremy Peterson	92905	2003 NYSlipOp 18108
Matter of Vladimir Keselman v New York City Transit Authority	92915	2003 NYSlipOp 18109
Thomas Sharpe v Charles A. Gardner	93151	2003 NYSlipOp 18110
Matter of Androme Leather Corporation v City of Gloversville	93154	2003 NYSlipOp 18111
Matter of Harold Allen v Brentwood Fire District	93157	2003 NYSlipOp 18112
Gail D. Buster v Stacey L. Parker	93222	2003 NYSlipOp 18113
Matter of Alexander Ricciardi v Johnstown Leather	93280	2003 NYSlipOp 18114
Matter of Johnny Couser v Glenn S. Goord	93302	2003 NYSlipOp 18115
Matter of Erry Rosas v Shirley Baker	93329	2003 NYSlipOp 18116
Matter of C.j. Scott v Daniel Senkowski	93344	2003 NYSlipOp 18117
Matter of Frank Sepe v Glenn S. Goord	93351	2003 NYSlipOp 18118
Matter of Mark Gantt v Roy Girdich	93360	2003 NYSlipOp 18119
Matter of Winston Edwards v Neponsit Health Care Center	93393	2003 NYSlipOp 18120
Matter of Reginald McFadden v David Armmitage	93542	2003 NYSlipOp 18121
Matter of Fernando Ferrar v Donald Selsky	93577	2003 NYSlipOp 18122
Matter of Richard J. Finchum, Jr. v Frank Colaiacomo	93592	2003 NYSlipOp 18123
Carol Rosati v Kohl's Department Stores	93681	2003 NYSlipOp 18124
Concourse Nursing Home v State of New York	93682	2003 NYSlipOp 18125
Edward Fazzone, Jr. v George G. Gourlay	93714	2003 NYSlipOp 18126
Matter of Jimmy L. Edwards v New York City Police Department	93734	2003 NYSlipOp 18127
Wendy L. Harjes v Paul C. Parisio	93764	2003 NYSlipOp 18128
Matter of Linda L. Gorton v Genesee County Chapter Nysarc	93777	2003 NYSlipOp 18129
Matter of Tawana M. Kendricks v Commissioner of Labor	93805	2003 NYSlipOp 18130
Matter of Daphne Buffaloe v Commissioner of Labor	93848	2003 NYSlipOp 18131
Matter of Frank W. Oku v Commissioner of Labor	93849	2003 NYSlipOp 18132
Matter of Derius Brown v Glenn S. Goord	93852	2003 NYSlipOp 18133
Matter of Felix Concepcion v Donald Selsky	93867	2003 NYSlipOp 18134
Matter of Michael Flynn v H. Carl McCall	93889	2003 NYSlipOp 18135
Matter of Maria Lazar v Commissioner of Labor	93890	2003 NYSlipOp 18136
Matter of Edward Sylcox v Antonia C. Novello	93894	2003 NYSlipOp 18137
Matter of Debra Miller v North Syracuse Central School District	93941	2003 NYSlipOp 18138
Matter of Betty A. Engle v Reale Construction Company	94114	2003 NYSlipOp 18139
Matter of Anthony Tompkins v Morgan Stanley Dean Witter	94115	2003 NYSlipOp 18140