Appellate Division, Third Department Decisions

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

**Cases Decided April 29, 2004**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Luis Santiago	12127	2004 NYSlipOp 03175
People v Michael L. Hamilton	13648	2004 NYSlipOp 03176
People v Ronald J. Caruso	14619	2004 NYSlipOp 03177
People v Anthony Casey	14690	2004 NYSlipOp 03178
People v Katherine Wagoner	14743	2004 NYSlipOp 03179
People v Thomas P. Kane	14769	2004 NYSlipOp 03180
People v Henry J. Harden	15074	2004 NYSlipOp 03181
Matter of Thomas L. Huckaby v New York State Division of Tax Appeals, Tax Appeals Tribunal	92539	2004 NYSlipOp 03182
Matter of John I. v Lisa J.	92718	2004 NYSlipOp 03183
Matter of Jeffrey A. Rutz v Sandra L. Carinci	92917	2004 NYSlipOp 03184
Matter of Jeran PP. v Joanne PP.	93213	2004 NYSlipOp 03185
Matter of Elvin Lebron v Glenn S. Goord	93864	2004 NYSlipOp 03186
Matter of Vito Sale v Helmsley-Spear	93915	2004 NYSlipOp 03187
Matter of Bryan Woodall v Glenn S. Goord	94105	2004 NYSlipOp 03188
Matter of Sherman Terry v Denise Borggreen	94194	2004 NYSlipOp 03189
Matter of John B. DeCarlo v Commissioner of Labor	94296	2004 NYSlipOp 03190
Matter of Darrell Isereau v Brushton-moira School District	94310	2004 NYSlipOp 03191
Matter of Donald L. Hassig v New York State Department of Environmental Conservation	94403	2004 NYSlipOp 03192
Kristina L. Nichols v Elizabeth B. Turner	94524	2004 NYSlipOp 03193
Matter of Larry Porter v Glenn S. Goord	94608	2004 NYSlipOp 03194
Ronald G. Hiatt v Susan M. Tremper-Hiatt	94611	2004 NYSlipOp 03195
Matter of Nathaniel Jackson v Joseph Smith	94755	2004 NYSlipOp 03196
Matter of Marilyn A. Mallimo v Commissioner of Labor	94791	2004 NYSlipOp 03197
Matter of Carrie Haddad v City of Hudson	94797	2004 NYSlipOp 03198
Matter of Margaret Van Haneghan v New York State Teachers' Retirement System	94814	2004 NYSlipOp 03199
Matter of Cheryl A. Dickson v Commissioner of Labor	94840	2004 NYSlipOp 03200
Matter of Edwin F. Diaz v Commissioner of Labor	94842	2004 NYSlipOp 03201
Matter of John Weiss v Commissioner of Labor	94937	2004 NYSlipOp 03202
Matter of Shirley Pommerville v H. Carl McCall	94962	2004 NYSlipOp 03203
Matter of Robert L. Ellenbogen v Lisa B. Ellenbogen	94989	2004 NYSlipOp 03204
Matter of State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company v Shannon Jackson	95019	2004 NYSlipOp 03205
Julian Bergman v Laurie C. Feinberg	95035	2004 NYSlipOp 03206
Matter of Cristina Cedeno v Commissioner of Labor	95036	2004 NYSlipOp 03207
Matter of Kathleen FF. v Patricia D. Lockhart	95045	2004 NYSlipOp 03208
Cornelio R. Catena v Amsterdam Memorial Hospital	95056	2004 NYSlipOp 03209
Matter of Richard S.	95071	2004 NYSlipOp 03210
John F. Zelber v Anthony Lewoc	95108	2004 NYSlipOp 03211
Rosalie Dennebaum v Rotterdam Square	95109	2004 NYSlipOp 03212

**Cases Decided April 22, 2004**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Shereem Burch		14621	2004 NYSlipOp 02976
People v James D. Perron		14717	2004 NYSlipOp 02977
People v Donald F. Durant		14760	2004 NYSlipOp 02978
People v Adam K. Roberts		15077	2004 NYSlipOp 02979
George E. Pataki v New York State Assembly	Lahtinen	91757	2004 NYSlipOp 02980
Barbara Dongelewic v Jolene Marcus		93944	2004 NYSlipOp 02981
Matter of John Yannucci v Consolidated Freightways		93988	2004 NYSlipOp 02982
Matter of Susan Hart v Pageprint/dekalb		94339	2004 NYSlipOp 02983
Matter of Thomas J. Liber v H. Carl McCall		94575	2004 NYSlipOp 02984
Matter of Robert W. Rose v Commissioner of Labor		94615	2004 NYSlipOp 02985
Matter of Steven B. Mokszycki v James W. McMahon		94623	2004 NYSlipOp 02986
Matter of Myron Hunt/Shaker Loudon Associates v Board of Assessment Review for Town of Colonie		94634	2004 NYSlipOp 02987
Kenneth M. Ahigian v Kaitlin Davis		94663	2004 NYSlipOp 02988
Michael V. Thoma v Town of Schodack		94754	2004 NYSlipOp 02989
Matter of Gwendolyn Graham v Commissioner of Labor		94766	2004 NYSlipOp 02990
Anthony L. Venditti v Liberty Mutual Insurance Company		94782	2004 NYSlipOp 02991
Joseph F. Gagen v Kipany Productions		94783	2004 NYSlipOp 02992
Matter of Toni Walker v Greene Central School District		94798	2004 NYSlipOp 02993
Matter of Linda Donato v Richard P. Mills		94841	2004 NYSlipOp 02994
Matter of County of Clinton v Gary A. Drollette		94851	2004 NYSlipOp 02995
Matter of Leslie Eberhard v Elmira City School District		94913	2004 NYSlipOp 02996
Federico Cuevas v Quandt's Foodservice Distributors		94919	2004 NYSlipOp 02997
Jodie Skibinsky v State Farm Fire and Casualty Company		94954	2004 NYSlipOp 02998
Brenda K. Greene v Jerry J. Wood		94956	2004 NYSlipOp 02999
80 State Street v Allwen, Inc.		94964	2004 NYSlipOp 03000

**Cases Decided April 20, 2004**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Richard A. Gross v William M. Hoblock		95579	2004 NYSlipOp 02888

**Cases Decided April 15, 2004**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Phyllis R. Comfort	10214	2004 NYSlipOp 02789
People v Lewis Beverly	13939	2004 NYSlipOp 02790
People v Kevin M. Kane	14475	2004 NYSlipOp 02791
People v Alvin M. Hogencamp	14682	2004 NYSlipOp 02792
People v Anthony Casey	14689	2004 NYSlipOp 02793
People v Brian Marmulstein	15041	2004 NYSlipOp 02794
Hydro Investors v Trafalgar Power	90020	2004 NYSlipOp 02795
Matter of Dawn J. Banks v John T. Hairston	91714	2004 NYSlipOp 02796
Elizabeth F. Hoffman v Valmore A. Pelletier	93227	2004 NYSlipOp 02797
Matter of Anne Y. Auclair v George A. Bolderson	93349	2004 NYSlipOp 02798
Calvin W. Gong v Daut S. Gjoni	94110	2004 NYSlipOp 02799
Matter of Daniel T. Fronczak v Commissioner of Labor	94125	2004 NYSlipOp 02800
Matter of Deborah Ann Crisman v Marsh & Mclennan Companies	94227	2004 NYSlipOp 02801
Matter of Shawn G. Granger v Glenn S. Goord	94274	2004 NYSlipOp 02802
Denise Trionfero v John H. Vanderhorn	94491	2004 NYSlipOp 02803
Matter of Kristin M. Bickerton v Commissioner of Labor	94625	2004 NYSlipOp 02804
Matter of Jonathan J. Fowler v Commissioner of Labor	94631	2004 NYSlipOp 02805
Matter of George K. Dzaba v Commissioner of Labor	94657	2004 NYSlipOp 02806
Matter of Mojan M. Ghoulian v Commissioner of Labor	94661	2004 NYSlipOp 02807
Matter of Margaret E. Nicotra v Commissioner of Labor	94676	2004 NYSlipOp 02808
Matter of Byron Orane v Commissioner of Labor	94682	2004 NYSlipOp 02809
John Turner v Sano-Rubin Construction Company	94715	2004 NYSlipOp 02810
Matter of Isabel C. Arcila v Commissioner of Labor	94723	2004 NYSlipOp 02811
Matter of David H. Grunkorn v Commissioner of Labor	94736	2004 NYSlipOp 02812
Matter of Rolando Rodriguez v Commissioner of Labor	94738	2004 NYSlipOp 02813
C.R.A. Inc. of Northern New York v J & K Plumbing and Heating Company	94761	2004 NYSlipOp 02814
Matter of Erika L. Turner v Commissioner of Labor	94789	2004 NYSlipOp 02815
Matter of Robert B. Lohmann v Commissioner of Labor	94816	2004 NYSlipOp 02816
Matter of Joseph S. Bucolo v Commissioner of Labor	94822	2004 NYSlipOp 02817
Matter of Patricia E. Chapin v Alan G. Hevesi	94923	2004 NYSlipOp 02818
Albany Electrical Contractors Association v Linda Angello	94927	2004 NYSlipOp 02819
Matter of Jennifer Fergus v Alan G. Hevesi	95044	2004 NYSlipOp 02820
Matter of Bart English v H. Carl Mccall	95053	2004 NYSlipOp 02821
Matter of Wayne Mcmorrow v Alan Hevesi	95088	2004 NYSlipOp 02822
Matter of Robert Feeney v Island Cable Construction	95106	2004 NYSlipOp 02823
Matter of Robert M. Winn v Rensselaer County Conditional Release Commission	95322	2004 NYSlipOp 02824

**Cases Decided April 13, 2004**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Patrick J. Cannon			2004 NYSlipOp 02825

**Cases Decided April 8, 2004**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Joaquin Duran		2004 NYSlipOp 02616
People v Elija Merritt		2004 NYSlipOp 02617
People v Charles L. Chrysler		2004 NYSlipOp 02618
People v James M. Potter		2004 NYSlipOp 02619
People v Daniel Rodriguez	13967	2004 NYSlipOp 02620
People v Sylvester Stroman	15042	2004 NYSlipOp 02621
Matter of Wanda Shambo v Orkin Pest Control		2004 NYSlipOp 02622
Matter of Samuel Winbush v Glenn S. Goord	93074	2004 NYSlipOp 02623
Matter of Andrea Peterson v Suffolk County Police Department	93247	2004 NYSlipOp 02624
Matter of Safwat Attia Youssef v State Board for Professional Medical Conduct	93250	2004 NYSlipOp 02625
Matter of Joseph A. Mosso v Raquel C. Mosso	93331	2004 NYSlipOp 02626
Matter of Charles McAllister v Glenn S. Goord	93527	2004 NYSlipOp 02627
Matter of Adrian Hernandez v Donald Selsky	93762	2004 NYSlipOp 02628
Matter of Robert Howard v Donald Selsky		2004 NYSlipOp 02629
Matter of Jason Pabon v Glenn S. Goord		2004 NYSlipOp 02630
Christopher M. Preston v State of New York		2004 NYSlipOp 02631
Matter of Rodolfo Taylor v Lieutenant Katz	94175	2004 NYSlipOp 02632
Lynne Lewis v Raymond Lewis		2004 NYSlipOp 02633
Matter of John Worthy v Donald Selsky	94217	2004 NYSlipOp 02634
People ex rel.. David Burr v John Smith	94272	2004 NYSlipOp 02635
Nancy E. Hewitt v County of Rensselaer	94337	2004 NYSlipOp 02636
Matter of John Dalton v Donald Selsky	94361	2004 NYSlipOp 02637
Matter of George Colon v Superintendent of Franklin Correctional Facility	94446	2004 NYSlipOp 02638
Matter of Wilfredo Polanco v Floyd G. Bennett, Jr.	94457	2004 NYSlipOp 02639
Matter of Frank Alba v Glenn S. Goord	94462	2004 NYSlipOp 02640
Matter of Kahill Berry v Leonard Portuondo	94464	2004 NYSlipOp 02641
Venture Manufacturing (Singapore) Ltd. v Matco Group	94480	2004 NYSlipOp 02642
Matter of Steven S. Mounnarat v Commissioner of Labor	94518	2004 NYSlipOp 02643
Matter of Ethel Laracy	94519	2004 NYSlipOp 02644
Matter of Geraldo J. Barcene v Commissioner of Labor	94599	2004 NYSlipOp 02645
Matter of Linda Adams v Commissioner of Labor	94613	2004 NYSlipOp 02646
Matter of Eleggua Osun Elufe v Michael G. Parrott	94639	2004 NYSlipOp 02647
Matter of Elsworth L. Weaver v Commissioner of Labor	94639	2004 NYSlipOp 02648
Matter of Mikhail Grushko v Commissioner of Labor	94717	2004 NYSlipOp 02649
Matter of Floyd W. Johnson	94746	2004 NYSlipOp 02650
Matter of Williamsville Clare Bridge Operator v Antonia C. Novello	94806	2004 NYSlipOp 02651
Sherrilynn Edick v Paul De Lima Company	94807	2004 NYSlipOp 02652
Robert F. Agars, Jr. v Mary Theresa Agars	94961	2004 NYSlipOp 02653
Matter of Bettina Jennings	94983	2004 NYSlipOp 02654
Kool-Temp Heating & Cooling v Dennis Ruzika	94997	2004 NYSlipOp 02655

**Cases Decided April 1, 2004**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Deb Ireland		2004 NYSlipOp 02656
People v Tasheem A. Goldston	12653	2004 NYSlipOp 02430
People v Vincent L. O'Connor	12665	2004 NYSlipOp 02431
People v J'Min Ward	13665	2004 NYSlipOp 02432
People v Wayne Calkins	13968	2004 NYSlipOp 02433
People v Leodis M. Williams	14157	2004 NYSlipOp 02434
People v Furman Gilmore	14165	2004 NYSlipOp 02435
People v Lonnie Spears	14288	2004 NYSlipOp 02436
People v Dominique Baker	14503	2004 NYSlipOp 02437
People v Tyrone Lee	14602	2004 NYSlipOp 02438
People v Kevin L. Thomas	14709	2004 NYSlipOp 02439
People v Joshua Lemons	14712	2004 NYSlipOp 02440
Matter of Isaiah Brown v State of New York	93049	2004 NYSlipOp 02441
Matter of Arthur R. Clarke v Michelle Clarke	93195	2004 NYSlipOp 02442
Matter of Sabrina M. v Richard N.	93496	2004 NYSlipOp 02443
Matter of Elsie Caldwell v Alliance Consulting Group	93704	2004 NYSlipOp 02444
Stephanie L. Corbett v John J. Corbett	93738	2004 NYSlipOp 02445
Matter of Sammy Feliciano v Glenn S. Goord	93753	2004 NYSlipOp 02446
Matter of Yvonne N. v Furman N.	94019	2004 NYSlipOp 02447
Matter of Deborah I. v April I.	94023	2004 NYSlipOp 02448
Matter of Rafael Perez v Glenn S. Goord	94086	2004 NYSlipOp 02449
Judith L. Starr v County of Cortland	94087	2004 NYSlipOp 02450
Matter of Stephanie X. v Valerie X.	94235	2004 NYSlipOp 02451
Matter of Wilberto Reyes v Glenn S. Goord	94271	2004 NYSlipOp 02452
Matter of Stacia D. Heyn v Timothy T. Burr	94320	2004 NYSlipOp 02453
Matter of Luis Velez v Donald Selsky	94451	2004 NYSlipOp 02454
Brian Dearden v Tompkins County	94485	2004 NYSlipOp 02455
Daniel Murtagh v John J. Beachy	94532	2004 NYSlipOp 02456
Raymond Corporation v National Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburg, Pa	94552	2004 NYSlipOp 02457
Matter of Leo B. McKinney v H. Carl McCall	94644	2004 NYSlipOp 02458
Matter of Maria E. McColl v James J. McColl	94680	2004 NYSlipOp 02459
Bonnie Sue Moon v Francis Moon	94741	2004 NYSlipOp 02460
Sharon C. Harrington v Leigh E. Harrington	94785	2004 NYSlipOp 02461
Diane Wilson v Time Warner Cable	94818	2004 NYSlipOp 02462
Matter of Joseph T. Bojarczuk v Richard P. Mills	94837	2004 NYSlipOp 02463
Judith Suib v Michael Keller	94893	2004 NYSlipOp 02464
Manchester Technologies v Brian Hansen	95122	2004 NYSlipOp 02465