Appellate Division, Third Department Decisions

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

**Cases Decided July 29, 2004**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Mohammed X. Poquee		12752	2004 NYSlipOp 06222
People v William Richardson		14262	2004 NYSlipOp 06223
People v Batista Carralero		14502	2004 NYSlipOp 06224
People v Tony Jordan		14659	2004 NYSlipOp 06225
Matter of Anita Gropper v Tax Appeals Tribunal of State of New York		93698	2004 NYSlipOp 06226
Priscilla V. Schantz v Jean F. O'Sullivan	Mercure	94288	2004 NYSlipOp 06227
Rosen Auto Leasing, Inc. v Marc D. Jacobs		94412	2004 NYSlipOp 06228
Matter of John L. Lewis v Brion D. Travis		94897	2004 NYSlipOp 06229
Matter of Clear Channel Outdoor, Inc. v Town Board of Town of Windham		95057	2004 NYSlipOp 06230
SCOTT, STACKROW & COMPANY, C.P.A.'s, P.C. v Maryanne Skavina		95222	2004 NYSlipOp 06231
Matter of Jane Freed v New York State Racing and Wagering Board		95340	2004 NYSlipOp 06232
SCC Associates v Manufacturers and Traders Trust Company		95360	2004 NYSlipOp 06233
State Farm Fire and Casualty Company v Sally Firmstone		95366	2004 NYSlipOp 06234
Matter of Deborah Kantor v Ed Olsen		95372	2004 NYSlipOp 06235
Marietta Corporation v Pacific Direct, Inc.		95430	2004 NYSlipOp 06236
Jerid Reilly v Marvin Fulmer		95466	2004 NYSlipOp 06237
Matter of David Beneke v Town of Santa Clara		95469	2004 NYSlipOp 06238
Mark Hausman v C.P. Hoffman		95477	2004 NYSlipOp 06239
Raymond A. Carney v Allied Craftsman General Contractors, Inc.		95558	2004 NYSlipOp 06240

**Cases Decided July 19, 2004**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Attorneys In Violation of Judiciary Law . 468-a. v David I. Channing			2004 NYSlipOp 06174

**Cases Decided July 15, 2004**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of R. Stephen Reilly			2004 NYSlipOp 06173

**Cases Decided July 22, 2004**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Thomas H. Stabb	14130	2004 NYSlipOp 06138
People v David J. Santalucia	14640	2004 NYSlipOp 06139
People v William L. Coss	14746	2004 NYSlipOp 06140
People v Adam D. Norton	14921	2004 NYSlipOp 06141
People v Janet Seavey	14963	2004 NYSlipOp 06142
People v Rrustem Muriqi	14990	2004 NYSlipOp 06143
People v Douglas A. Romeo	15232	2004 NYSlipOp 06144
People v Mark E. Smith	15246	2004 NYSlipOp 06145
Matter of Eduardo Eusebio v Verizon New York, Inc.	93725	2004 NYSlipOp 06146
Matter of Edward Koehl v Daniel Senkowski	94218	2004 NYSlipOp 06147
Matter of Eric Thomas v Donald Selsky	94555	2004 NYSlipOp 06148
Matter of Peter Graziano v Donald Selsky	94565	2004 NYSlipOp 06149
Matter of Sandra L. Moss v Commissioner of Labor	94570	2004 NYSlipOp 06150
E.W. Tompkins Company, Inc. v State of New York	94624	2004 NYSlipOp 06151
State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company v Nathaniel C. Glinbizzi	94868	2004 NYSlipOp 06152
Diane L. Atkins v Exxon Mobil Corporation	95024	2004 NYSlipOp 06153
Matter of Anja Limperis v Commissioner of Labor	95026	2004 NYSlipOp 06154
Matter of Louis Tatta v Brion Travis	95084	2004 NYSlipOp 06155
Matter of Bernard Cooper v Donald Selsky	95174	2004 NYSlipOp 06156
Matter of Samuel Landy v Commissioner of Labor	95190	2004 NYSlipOp 06157
Fallsburg Fishing & Boating Club, Inc. v Philip Spiegel	95230	2004 NYSlipOp 06158
Matter of Robert Mellis v New York State Department of Corrections	95279	2004 NYSlipOp 06159
Matter of Wilfredo Polanco v Donald Selsky	95292	2004 NYSlipOp 06160
Melissa Chiarini v County of Ulster	95348	2004 NYSlipOp 06161
Matter of Patricia A. Jeffares v Commissioner of Labor	95370	2004 NYSlipOp 06162
Matter of Ephrem J. Pilon	95384	2004 NYSlipOp 06163
Roger L. Jennings v City of Glens Falls Industrial Development Agency	95386	2004 NYSlipOp 06164
Matter of Denise Fox v Commissioner of Labor	95423	2004 NYSlipOp 06165
Matter of Dolores Rosen v Commissioner of Labor	95453	2004 NYSlipOp 06166
Matter of Jaime Zevallos v Commissioner of Labor	95465	2004 NYSlipOp 06167
Matter of Sheila Jones v Commissioner of Labor	95482	2004 NYSlipOp 06168
Matter of Michael Howard v Glenn S. Goord	95509	2004 NYSlipOp 06169
Matter of William G. Peak v Commissioner of Labor	95514	2004 NYSlipOp 06170
Matter of Kevin A. Robinson v Commissioner of Labor	95516	2004 NYSlipOp 06171
Matter of Thomas M. Lassen v Alan G. Hevesi	95580	2004 NYSlipOp 06172

**Cases Decided July 13, 2004**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Mark J. Gaylord			2004 NYSlipOp 06089
Matter of Michael B. Mendelson			2004 NYSlipOp 06090

**Cases Decided July 8, 2004**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Matthew J. Mann			2004 NYSlipOp 06088

**Cases Decided July 15, 2004**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Jorge Martinez	12976	2004 NYSlipOp 06051
People v Stanley Butterfield	13230	2004 NYSlipOp 06052
People v Walter R. Thatcher	13674	2004 NYSlipOp 06053
People v James Schwing	13848	2004 NYSlipOp 06054
People v Anthony Jones	14334	2004 NYSlipOp 06055
People v Clifford A. Roberts	14554	2004 NYSlipOp 06056
People v Demetrios D. Green	14563	2004 NYSlipOp 06057
People v Furman Henry	14625	2004 NYSlipOp 06058
People v James W. Hanrahan	14739	2004 NYSlipOp 06059
People v Jermaine Holmes	14763	2004 NYSlipOp 06060
People v Jose C. Lopez	78725	2004 NYSlipOp 06061
Matter of Eric Harris v Donald Selsky	94453	2004 NYSlipOp 06062
Kingsley Arms, Inc. v Copake-Taconic Hills Central School District	94499	2004 NYSlipOp 06063
Thomas J. Minotti v Daniel J. Larkin	94722	2004 NYSlipOp 06064
Matter of David G. Katsaris v Lockheed Martin Federal Systems	94732	2004 NYSlipOp 06065
Matter of Aaron Callender v Donald Selsky	94821	2004 NYSlipOp 06066
Matter of Harry A. Conners v Commissioner of Labor	94905	2004 NYSlipOp 06067
Bertil Schou v Luba B. Whiteley	94909	2004 NYSlipOp 06068
Matter of Robert Reed v Donald Selsky	94974	2004 NYSlipOp 06069
Laverne J. Anderson Marszal v Lloyd K. Anderson	95073	2004 NYSlipOp 06070
National Interstate v A.J. Murphy Company, Inc.	95124	2004 NYSlipOp 06071
Matter of Jesus Martinez v Glenn S. Goord	95131	2004 NYSlipOp 06072
Matter of Selvin Paiz v Coastal Pipeline Products Corporation	95147	2004 NYSlipOp 06073
Matter of Michael B. Valenti v Penn Plax Plastics	95162	2004 NYSlipOp 06074
Matter of Joseph S. Goncalves v Edward R. Donnelly	95169	2004 NYSlipOp 06075
Matter of Carlos Campoverde v Donald Selsky	95175	2004 NYSlipOp 06076
Matter of Nicholas R. Sarubbi v Commissioner of Labor	95287	2004 NYSlipOp 06077
Matter of Michael McCloud v Gary Amell	95296	2004 NYSlipOp 06078
Diedre L. Welch v Carmelo De Cicco	95347	2004 NYSlipOp 06079
Matter of Richard A. McGloin v Commissioner of Labor	95349	2004 NYSlipOp 06080
Matter of William J. Chrysler v Commissioner of Labor	95359	2004 NYSlipOp 06081
Matter of Kathleen A. Pfohl v Hunter's Hope Foundation, Inc.	95368	2004 NYSlipOp 06082
Matter of Armida M. Garcia-Primer v Commissioner of Labor	95373	2004 NYSlipOp 06083
Matter of Dan D. Rolfe v Commissioner of Labor	95376	2004 NYSlipOp 06084
Matter of Kristin L. De Marco v Commissioner of Labor	95382	2004 NYSlipOp 06085
Matter of Tom P. Michaels v Towne Ford	95390	2004 NYSlipOp 06086
Matter of Lamar Advertising of Penn, Llc v John Pitman	95529	2004 NYSlipOp 06087

**Cases Decided July 8, 2004**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Albert Daley	11544	2004 NYSlipOp 05805
People v Robert J. Bower	14753	2004 NYSlipOp 05806
People v Edward Warner	14766	2004 NYSlipOp 05807
Matter of Arlene M. Carella v Cary G. Ferrara	88776	2004 NYSlipOp 05808
John W. Tabner v Ralph H. Drake		2004 NYSlipOp 05809
Matter of Damion Frierson v Shirley Goldston	92115	2004 NYSlipOp 05810
Daniel S. Pfoltzer v Gloria J. Morris-Pfoltzer	92557	2004 NYSlipOp 05811
Matter of Joshua M. v Dimari N.	93335	2004 NYSlipOp 05812
Matter of Kathleen M. Anderson v William H. Anderson	93837	2004 NYSlipOp 05813
Matter of Vilhjal Campbell v Urice Brewster	93928	2004 NYSlipOp 05814
Shawn Stocklas v Auto Solutions of Glenville, Inc.	94262	2004 NYSlipOp 05815
Matter of Rachel R. Armstrong v Heath A. Belrose	94301	2004 NYSlipOp 05816
Matter of Ariel PP. v Theresa QQ.	94497	2004 NYSlipOp 05817
Matter of Lamont D.	94546	2004 NYSlipOp 05818
Matter of Richard Otero v Donald Selsky	94559	2004 NYSlipOp 05819
Matter of Patrick Mathieu v Michael T. Giambruno	94693	2004 NYSlipOp 05820
Matter of Otis P. Jenkins v Judy A. Jenkins	94770	2004 NYSlipOp 05821
Matter of Bronsky-Graff Orthodontics, P.C.	94911	2004 NYSlipOp 05822
Matter of Deborah A. Kelly v Andrew Bovee	95079	2004 NYSlipOp 05823
Thomas J. Gilbert v Albany Medical Center	95140	2004 NYSlipOp 05824
Matter of Jamel Brown v Glenn S. Goord	95179	2004 NYSlipOp 05825
Matter of Jack Schulman v Commissioner of Labor	95302	2004 NYSlipOp 05826
Matter of Dennis C. Lang v Commissioner of Labor	95303	2004 NYSlipOp 05827
Dennis Foote v Traditional Builders, Ltd.	95361	2004 NYSlipOp 05828
Matter of Center Square Association, Inc. v City of Albany Board of Zoning Appeals	95362	2004 NYSlipOp 05829
Sandra Pechtel v Lee P. Gould	95369	2004 NYSlipOp 05830
CV Holdings, LLC v Artisan Advisors, LLC	95389	2004 NYSlipOp 05831
Matter of Georgia Taylor v Continental Insurance Company	95421	2004 NYSlipOp 05832
John W. Valachovic v Mary Susan Valachovic	95444	2004 NYSlipOp 05833
Mary A. Dunne v David W. Dunne	95474	2004 NYSlipOp 05834
Matter of Adrian Hernandez v Donald Selsky	95498	2004 NYSlipOp 05835
Lori K. Cerasaro v Victor J. Cerasaro	95519	2004 NYSlipOp 05836
Matter of Robert Escalera v Alan G. Hevesi		2004 NYSlipOp 05837
William E. Huffner v Arnot Ogden Medical Center	95555	2004 NYSlipOp 05838
James Herzog v Louis M. Schroeder	95563	2004 NYSlipOp 05839
Robert Parker v Rust Plant Services, Inc.	95571	2004 NYSlipOp 05840
Davis M. Etkin v Capital District Regional Off-track Betting Corporation	95581	2004 NYSlipOp 05841

**Cases Decided July 7, 2004**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Joseph Dalton v George Pataki	Mercure	94493	2004 NYSlipOp 05769

**Cases Decided July 1, 2004**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v James L. Long		11984	2004 NYSlipOp 05684
People v Robert H. Stone		12781	2004 NYSlipOp 05685
People v Kie M. Washington		14357	2004 NYSlipOp 05686
People v Michael Horton		14367	2004 NYSlipOp 05687
People v Anthony M. Garraway		14529	2004 NYSlipOp 05688
People v Daniel T. Hines		14867	2004 NYSlipOp 05689
People v Karen E. Atwood		15100	2004 NYSlipOp 05690
Matter of Matthew RR. v Helen A. Carson		90173	2004 NYSlipOp 05691
Matter of Milton S. Birch v Jackie Sayegh		92774	2004 NYSlipOp 05692
Matter of Bruce D. Baker v Orange Heating and Cooling		92879	2004 NYSlipOp 05693
Matter of Nelson Escoto v Glenn S. Goord		93341	2004 NYSlipOp 05694
Matter of Dominick H.		93453	2004 NYSlipOp 05695
Matter of Paul L. Maglione v New York State Department of Health		93529	2004 NYSlipOp 05696
Matter of Christina Herman v Ismael Villafane		93766	2004 NYSlipOp 05697
Matter of Robert Russo v New York City Department of Correction		93916	2004 NYSlipOp 05698
Matter of Randal Swearingen v Waste Stream Environmental, Inc.		94148	2004 NYSlipOp 05699
Eric M. Steinborn v Jeffrey M. Himmel			2004 NYSlipOp 05700
Matter of Matthew Crippen v Mandy Keator		94396	2004 NYSlipOp 05701
Matter of Donald NN.		94470	2004 NYSlipOp 05702
Matter of John R. Falatyn		94542	2004 NYSlipOp 05703
Matter of Erie Boulevard Hydropower, L.P. v Town of Ephratah Board of Assessors		94621	2004 NYSlipOp 05704
Matter of Thomas W. Adams v Kathryn E. Franklin		94667	2004 NYSlipOp 05705
Matter of Shawn P. Dudla v Bronwyn S. Dudla		94709	2004 NYSlipOp 05706
Mary J. Fox v Thomas H. Fox		94733	2004 NYSlipOp 05707
Matter of Mary Cina v Clark Waters		94762	2004 NYSlipOp 05708
Matter of City of Albany		94836	2004 NYSlipOp 05709
Matter of Mega Personal Lines, Inc. v Dianne Halton		94908	2004 NYSlipOp 05710
Matter of James Oefelein v Town of Thompson Planning Board		94910	2004 NYSlipOp 05711
Matter of Briding Newell v Commissioner of Labor		94934	2004 NYSlipOp 05712
Keith Sills v Patrick Dellavalle		94939	2004 NYSlipOp 05713
Matter of Newsday, Inc. v State Department of Transportation	Mercure	94959	2004 NYSlipOp 05714
Matter of Sean U.		94981	2004 NYSlipOp 05715
Richard E. Hitchcock v Gerald Abbott		94993	2004 NYSlipOp 05716
Matter of Darren R. Miller v Commissioner of Labor		95009	2004 NYSlipOp 05717
Matter of Patricia T. Henderson v James P. Henderson		95061	2004 NYSlipOp 05718
Matter of Marc Mosher v New York State Racing and Wagering Board, Division of Harness Racing		95096	2004 NYSlipOp 05719
Matter of Willie Robinson v New Venture Gear		95123	2004 NYSlipOp 05720
Dylan Cohen v Scott Bernstein		95149	2004 NYSlipOp 05721
Darlene M. Blandin v Marathon Equipment Company		95158	2004 NYSlipOp 05722
Gary Appler v Riverview Obstetrics & Gynecology, P.C.		95181	2004 NYSlipOp 05723
Matter of Howard J. Fairbairn		95217	2004 NYSlipOp 05724
Raymond W. Heslin v Metropolitan Life Insurance Company		95218	2004 NYSlipOp 05725
Matter of Harold F. Wagner v Arthur J. Roth		95231	2004 NYSlipOp 05726
Matter of James E. Morgan v New York State Department of Environmental Conservation		95232	2004 NYSlipOp 05727
Jane Doe v Board of Education of Morris Central School		95235	2004 NYSlipOp 05728
Matter of Feliciana Umanzor v General Telecom		95239	2004 NYSlipOp 05729
Matter of Holden's Haulers v Madison County Department of Solid Waste and Sanitation		95255	2004 NYSlipOp 05730
Matter of Angel Jiminez v Waldbaums	Mugglin	95257	2004 NYSlipOp 05731
Archie Sanders v Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.		95266	2004 NYSlipOp 05732
E. Susan De Sanna v Rockefeller Center, Inc.		95286	2004 NYSlipOp 05733
Tracy Stickles v James Fuller		95451	2004 NYSlipOp 05734