Appellate Division, Third Department Decisions

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

**Cases Decided November 24, 2004**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Warren E. Powell	10010	2004 NYSlipOp 08727
People v Willie J. Thigpen	13644	2004 NYSlipOp 08728
People v Ida L. Thomas	14147	2004 NYSlipOp 08729
People v Jonathan D. Muniz	14279	2004 NYSlipOp 08730
People v Charles M. Knowles	14465	2004 NYSlipOp 08731
People v Jeremiah P. Johnson	14749	2004 NYSlipOp 08732
People v Hyo Park	14762	2004 NYSlipOp 08733
People v Jeffrey C. Grune	14826	2004 NYSlipOp 08734
People v Rodney Smith	14869	2004 NYSlipOp 08735
People v Debra J. Swenson	14883	2004 NYSlipOp 08736
People v Jonathan Cherry	14950	2004 NYSlipOp 08737
People v Gary F. Seeber	14954	2004 NYSlipOp 08738
People v Telly Tabb	14955	2004 NYSlipOp 08739
People v Chad D. Walters	15276	2004 NYSlipOp 08740
Matter of Karen K. Ford v Commissioner of Labor	85962	2004 NYSlipOp 08741
Jeffrey R. Kaczor v Lori M. Kaczor	92410	2004 NYSlipOp 08742
Matter of Carolyn Adenaike v David Adenaike	93021	2004 NYSlipOp 08743
Matter of Michael Tavernia v Kathalina Bouvia	93403	2004 NYSlipOp 08744
Matter of John W. Folsom v Khalida Folsom	93659	2004 NYSlipOp 08745
People ex rel. David v New York State Division of Parole	93760	2004 NYSlipOp 08746
Matter of Jemila PP. v Manny PP.	93847	2004 NYSlipOp 08747
People ex rel. Turner v Hembrooke	93934	2004 NYSlipOp 08748
Matter of Lillian R.	94155	2004 NYSlipOp 08749
Matter of Paul U. v Heather T.	94203	2004 NYSlipOp 08750
Matter of Whitney Z.	94285	2004 NYSlipOp 08751
Matter of Anton Hagans v Laura Harden	94433	2004 NYSlipOp 08752
Matter of Theodore D. Fraczek v Monique Syczyk	94476	2004 NYSlipOp 08753
Matter of Alan J. Brisson v County of Onondaga	94529	2004 NYSlipOp 08754
Matter of Shirley Kargoe v Dennis Mitchell	94589	2004 NYSlipOp 08755
Matter of Edward G. Hill v Melinda Hillenbrand	94688	2004 NYSlipOp 08756
Genevieve L. Wheeler v Howard R. Wheeler	94721	2004 NYSlipOp 08757
Matter of Tara V. v County of Otsego	94963	2004 NYSlipOp 08758
Matter of Richard T. v Carol T.	94966	2004 NYSlipOp 08759
Matter of Huang Sheng Ku v Dana Alexander, Inc.	95001	2004 NYSlipOp 08760
Roger Steen v Quaker State Corporation	95168	2004 NYSlipOp 08761
Matter of Andrea A. v William B.	95354	2004 NYSlipOp 08762
Matter of Coleman Nathaniel Bennett Altheim	95371	2004 NYSlipOp 08763
Matter of Roger Simmonds v James Walsh	95642	2004 NYSlipOp 08764
Matter of Heriberto Palacio v New York State Department of Correctional Services	95648	2004 NYSlipOp 08765
Thomas Chiotti v Susan Chiotti	95706	2004 NYSlipOp 08766
Nicholas Daisernia v Michelle E. Thomas	95725	2004 NYSlipOp 08767
Nancy R. Commins v Raymond A. Couture	95733	2004 NYSlipOp 08768
Matter of William Edwards v Glenn S. Goord	95802	2004 NYSlipOp 08769
Matter of Charles Debose v Donald Selsky	95810	2004 NYSlipOp 08770
Matter of Kenneth Spulka v Glenn S. Goord	95937	2004 NYSlipOp 08771
Matter of Theodore Black v Glenn S. Goord	95944	2004 NYSlipOp 08772
Matter of Mark Binns v Glenn S. Goord	95945	2004 NYSlipOp 08773
Matter of Charles J. Le Brun v Thomas P. Maguire	95951	2004 NYSlipOp 08774
Matter of Hill Park Health Care Center, Inc. v Antonia Novello	95971	2004 NYSlipOp 08775
Edward D. Kaiser v Mathew Van Houten	95973	2004 NYSlipOp 08776
Matter of Ronald J. Briggs v Andrew Halloran	95982	2004 NYSlipOp 08777
Matter of Moshe Sharon v Commissioner of Labor	96016	2004 NYSlipOp 08778
Matter of Oresta Arosena v New York State Division of Parole	96110	2004 NYSlipOp 08779
Matter of Richard E.	96494	2004 NYSlipOp 08780

**Cases Decided November 18, 2004**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v John Lewis Typhair	10512	2004 NYSlipOp 08263
People v Ronald Roberts	10762	2004 NYSlipOp 08264
People v Terry J. Murray	12670	2004 NYSlipOp 08265
People v Troy Whitted	12786	2004 NYSlipOp 08266
People v John Lockhart	12896	2004 NYSlipOp 08267
People v James Whitmore	13062	2004 NYSlipOp 08268
People v David J. McCrone	14199	2004 NYSlipOp 08269
People v Herbert A. Hermance	14837	2004 NYSlipOp 08270
People v Raheem Miller	14958	2004 NYSlipOp 08271
People v Brian Fogarty	76549	2004 NYSlipOp 08272
People v James Oglesby	77359	2004 NYSlipOp 08273
Matter of Patricia (Tad Bartimus) Wariner v Associated Press	94309	2004 NYSlipOp 08274
Matter of Marke Lantry v State of New York	94586	2004 NYSlipOp 08275
American Association of Bioanalysts v New York State Department of Health	94658	2004 NYSlipOp 08276
Matter of New York State Crime Victims Board v Paul Mitchell	94687	2004 NYSlipOp 08277
Matter of Mabel Chalcoff v Project One	94739	2004 NYSlipOp 08278
Matter of Johanna Carlson-Fanelli v St. Luke's Memorial Hospital Center	94800	2004 NYSlipOp 08279
Elizabeth Jones-Barnes v Congregation Agudat Achim	95039	2004 NYSlipOp 08280
Matter of Patricia McCluskey v Robert B. Howard	95078	2004 NYSlipOp 08281
Cancer Action NY v St. Lawrence County Newspapers Corporation	95134	2004 NYSlipOp 08282
Matter of People of State of New York v Frank Cuttita	95249	2004 NYSlipOp 08283
Roger D. Turcsik v Guthrie Clinic, Ltd.	95280	2004 NYSlipOp 08284
Matter of Karen Buffum v Syracuse University	95281	2004 NYSlipOp 08285
Matter of Mona Louis v Commissioner of Labor	95528	2004 NYSlipOp 08286
Matter of Brenda L. Rodd v Coram Fire District	95609	2004 NYSlipOp 08287
Frontier Insurance Company v Renewal Arts Contracting Corporation	95616	2004 NYSlipOp 08288
Anne T. Wallach v Marli Hinckley	95620	2004 NYSlipOp 08289
Matter of Keith G. O'Brien v Alan G. Hevesi	95627	2004 NYSlipOp 08290
Jeanette Macri v Jeffrey Smith	95668	2004 NYSlipOp 08291
Judith Schrade v CRDN Properties, Inc.	95674	2004 NYSlipOp 08292
Peter P. Dalton v City of Saratoga Springs	95701	2004 NYSlipOp 08293
Brad Davidson v Walter Ambrozewicz	95702	2004 NYSlipOp 08294
Matter of Richard Gordan v Town of Esopus	95746	2004 NYSlipOp 08295
George Firth v State of New York	95769	2004 NYSlipOp 08296
Joseph P. Felitti v Kenneth Daughriety	95770	2004 NYSlipOp 08297
Edward Bilinski v Bank of Richmondville	95784	2004 NYSlipOp 08298
Howard Smith v County of Albany	95833	2004 NYSlipOp 08299
Roscoe Peace v KRNH, Inc.	95834	2004 NYSlipOp 08300
Heather L. Lindaman v Vestal Central School District	95868	2004 NYSlipOp 08301
George Vasquez v State of New York	95871	2004 NYSlipOp 08302
Matter of St. James Nursing Home v Barbara Ann De Buono	95875	2004 NYSlipOp 08303
Matter of Mary Lou Carroll v Barbara Brennan, Inc.	95902	2004 NYSlipOp 08304
Anthony Biance v Columbia Washington Ventures, Llc	96004	2004 NYSlipOp 08305
Matter of Donald Deich v City of White Plains	96102	2004 NYSlipOp 08306
Matter of Joan M. Gaughan Atlas		2004 NYSlipOp 08307
Matter of Aloysius O. Ejimakor		2004 NYSlipOp 08308

**Cases Decided November 10, 2004**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Daniel Holliman	13657	2004 NYSlipOp 08006
People v Darrin E. Higgins	13676	2004 NYSlipOp 08007
People v William Ortiz	14132	2004 NYSlipOp 08008
People v Jesse Smith	14568	2004 NYSlipOp 08009
People v Aswad D. Shabazz	14657	2004 NYSlipOp 08010
People v Donald J. Travis	14672	2004 NYSlipOp 08011
People v Kenneth Bingham	14676	2004 NYSlipOp 08012
People v Andre Branch-El	14798	2004 NYSlipOp 08013
People v James L. Harres	14881	2004 NYSlipOp 08014
People v Vincent S. Long	14932	2004 NYSlipOp 08015
People v John Merrill	14979	2004 NYSlipOp 08016
People v Carl Oatman	15105	2004 NYSlipOp 08017
People v Marc A. Corrice	15275	2004 NYSlipOp 08018
People v Joseph G. Hoppe	15393	2004 NYSlipOp 08019
Matter of John J. Culkin v State of New York	93728	2004 NYSlipOp 08020
Matter of Raheem Shabazz v Donald Selsky	93828	2004 NYSlipOp 08021
People ex rel. La Joy v Bezrutczyk	94026	2004 NYSlipOp 08022
Matter of Hassib Ali v Goodyear Tire-Retail	94239	2004 NYSlipOp 08023
Matter of James Ryan v Glenn S. Goord	94647	2004 NYSlipOp 08024
Matter of Spectapark Associates v City of Albany Department of Assessment and Taxation	95048	2004 NYSlipOp 08025
Matter of Christopher D. Lue-Shing v Brion D. Travis	95077	2004 NYSlipOp 08026
Matter of James Kellish v Kellish Tire Sales, Inc.	95233	2004 NYSlipOp 08027
Matter of Stephen Abramson v Commissioner of Labor	95272	2004 NYSlipOp 08028
John Payne v County of Sullivan	95285	2004 NYSlipOp 08029
Matter of Gerard E. Thomas v Commissioner of Labor	95408	2004 NYSlipOp 08030
Grace Cutroneo v Joseph W. Dryer	95476	2004 NYSlipOp 08031
William J. Ehlers v County of Otsego	95483	2004 NYSlipOp 08032
Matter of Jean Louman v Premier Staffing, Llc	95505	2004 NYSlipOp 08033
Matter of James Blackwell v Glenn S. Goord	95513	2004 NYSlipOp 08034
Matter of Vasco Marques v Antonio Salgado	95517	2004 NYSlipOp 08035
Matter of John A. Graziano v County of Albany	95583	2004 NYSlipOp 08036
Matter of Leonard Sonne v New York State Division of Human Rights	95596	2004 NYSlipOp 08037
Matter of K. Gilbert Van Zandt v Melissa C. Sauers	95630	2004 NYSlipOp 08038
Matter of Dionisio Somerville v Glenn S. Goord	95655	2004 NYSlipOp 08039
Matter of Luis Toledo v Donald Selsky	95661	2004 NYSlipOp 08040
Theresa Magrum v Dee Dee's A Tavern, Inc.	95678	2004 NYSlipOp 08041
Matter of Joseph Carubia v Colt Industries (Crucible Steel)	95785	2004 NYSlipOp 08042
Matter of Marilynn Adorno v Commissioner of Labor	95964	2004 NYSlipOp 08043
Matter of Richard P. Larkin v Commissioner of Labor	95979	2004 NYSlipOp 08044
Matter of Nicholas T. Norvell v Commissioner of Labor	95994	2004 NYSlipOp 08045
Matter of Ronald D. Stern v Alan G. Hevesi	96062	2004 NYSlipOp 08046

**Cases Decided November 4, 2004**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Brian Gibbs		12137	2004 NYSlipOp 07856
People v Michael C. Curkendall		13011	2004 NYSlipOp 07857
People v James Mahar		13164	2004 NYSlipOp 07858
People v David Scott		13533	2004 NYSlipOp 07859
People v Dwayne A. Lawrence		13663	2004 NYSlipOp 07860
People v Rashad Reid		13993	2004 NYSlipOp 07861
People v Kevin F. Scott		14289	2004 NYSlipOp 07862
People v Napoleon N. Tetreault		14364	2004 NYSlipOp 07863
People v Hector Hernandez		14541	2004 NYSlipOp 07864
People v Sofia Tower		14764	2004 NYSlipOp 07865
People v Gary J. Sharlow		14922	2004 NYSlipOp 07866
People v Lorraine Johnson		15020	2004 NYSlipOp 07867
People v Vincent D. Rodriguez		15022	2004 NYSlipOp 07868
People v Philip K. Boyce		15033	2004 NYSlipOp 07869
Robert Greaves v Jaclyn Burlingame		93288	2004 NYSlipOp 07870
Joseph A. Wojcik v Empire Forklift, Inc.	Mercure	94260	2004 NYSlipOp 07871
Matter of John La Flamme v S.S. Electric Repair Shop, Inc.		94312	2004 NYSlipOp 07872
Matter of Eustace Payne v Glenn S. Goord		94401	2004 NYSlipOp 07873
Matter of Chaggrit Sawangkao v New York State Board for Professional Medical Conduct		94415	2004 NYSlipOp 07874
Matter of Rene Towles v Donald Selsky		94458	2004 NYSlipOp 07875
Matter of John A. Kleinsak v R.B. Samuels, Inc.		94830	2004 NYSlipOp 07876
William P. Niver v State of New York	Spain	94879	2004 NYSlipOp 07877
Jacquelyn Sullivan v Susan Hutchinson		95154	2004 NYSlipOp 07878
Helen B. Eickhoff v John B. Eickhoff		95163	2004 NYSlipOp 07879
Arthur Marlowe v Elmwood, Inc.		95193	2004 NYSlipOp 07880
Village of New Paltz v Merlex Contracting, Inc.		95251	2004 NYSlipOp 07881
Jane Harmon v Adirondack Community College		95275	2004 NYSlipOp 07882
Matter of Elizabeth Johnson v New York State Office of Mental Retardation and Development		95345	2004 NYSlipOp 07883
Matter of Anthony J. Pelle v Commissioner of Labor		95392	2004 NYSlipOp 07884
N.A.S. Holdings, Inc. v Connie Pafundi		95456	2004 NYSlipOp 07885
Matter of Paul J. Langley v Commissioner of Labor		95564	2004 NYSlipOp 07886
Steven Aaron v Carter, Conboy, Case, Blackmore, Napierski & Maloney, P.C.		95589	2004 NYSlipOp 07887
Matter of Loretta D. Burkich		95618	2004 NYSlipOp 07888
Matter of Joseph V. Di Maio v Commissioner of Labor		95624	2004 NYSlipOp 07889
Matter of Melvin Rosario v Glenn S. Goord		95659	2004 NYSlipOp 07890
Caroline Madura v State of New York		95667	2004 NYSlipOp 07891
Bonded Concrete, Inc. v Transcontinental Insurance Company		95766	2004 NYSlipOp 07892
Matter of Myra Berlowitz v Commissioner of Labor		95780	2004 NYSlipOp 07893
Matter of Grace R.		95790	2004 NYSlipOp 07894
Matter of County of Erie v State of New York	Mercure	95828	2004 NYSlipOp 07895
Matter of Loretta D. Burkich		95862	2004 NYSlipOp 07896
Matter of Margaret Francano v Commissioner of Labor		95914	2004 NYSlipOp 07897
Matter of Mary M. Meade v Commissioner of Labor		95946	2004 NYSlipOp 07898
Matter of Luanne M. Nocera v Commissioner of Labor		96001	2004 NYSlipOp 07899
Matter of Robert M. Kurtz v Commissioner of Labor		96017	2004 NYSlipOp 07900
Matter of Virginia M. O'Halpin v New York State Comptroller		96023	2004 NYSlipOp 07901
Matter of Michael C. Weitz			2004 NYSlipOp 07902