skip to main content
Law Reporting
Bureau Thomas J.K. Smith, State Reporter

Appellate Division, Fourth Department Motions

Current Month Archived Cases Decisions

September 2024 Archive

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

Motions Decided September 30, 2024
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF SHARON ZAJDEL V ERIE COUNTY WATER AUTHORITY, JEROME D. SCHAD, MICHELLE IANNELLO AND PEGGY LAGREETP 24-013382024 NY Slip Op 76334(U)
IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK V SCOTT P. CA 24-015082024 NY Slip Op 76333(U)
IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF CHARLES MIXON V HAMBURG FOIL OFFICER, CLERK'S OFFICE RICHARD G BOEHM, DEPUTY TOWNCA 24-015102024 NY Slip Op 76332(U)
LORI A. ELLIOTT V ROBERT A. ELLIOTTCA 23-017472024 NY Slip Op 76331(U)
THE PEOPLE V MATTHEW D. CARPENTERKA 23-008212024 NY Slip Op 76330(U)
J. GUADALUPE HERNANDEZ AND TARA HERNANDEZ V BASILIA ARANDA AND D. LOCO, INC.CA 24-008482024 NY Slip Op 76329(U)
Motions Decided September 27, 2024
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
THE PEOPLE V TINA L. WAGONER1180-202024 NY Slip Op 76328(U)
THE PEOPLE V CHRISTOPHER PEARSON932-202024 NY Slip Op 76327(U)
PB-20 DOE V ST. NICODEMUS LUTHERAN CHURCH, UPSTATE NEW YORK SYNOD OF THE EVANGELICAL LUTHERAN CHURCH IN AMERICA AND120-121-242024 NY Slip Op 76326(U)
THE PEOPLE V ANTHONY S. ORTIZ1337-182024 NY Slip Op 76325(U)
THE PEOPLE V RASHAD J. MUHAMMAD183-202024 NY Slip Op 76324(U)
BOGDAN MSCICHOWSKI, M.D. V MLMIC INSURANCE COMPANY, FORMERLY KNOWN AS MEDICAL LIABILITY MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY7-242024 NY Slip Op 76323(U)
THE PEOPLE V JOSE MEJIA231-152024 NY Slip Op 76322(U)
THE PEOPLE V OSWALD MCPHERSON, JR.940-222024 NY Slip Op 76321(U)
THE PEOPLE V SAMUEL LEFLORE417-032024 NY Slip Op 76320(U)
KEVIN CONLEY AND DENISE CONLEY V PINELLI LANDSCAPING, INC.50-242024 NY Slip Op 76319(U)
IN THE MATTER OF KEVIN V.CAF 24-011412024 NY Slip Op 76318(U)
HOI TRINH V FATHER JOSEPH THIEN NGUYEN909-222024 NY Slip Op 76317(U)
TERRI VIGLIETTA, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS EXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE OF BENEDICT VIGLIETTA, DECEASED V ASBESTOS CORPORATION207-242024 NY Slip Op 76316(U)
THE PEOPLE V BARRINGTON HARVEYKA 23-003432024 NY Slip Op 76315(U)
THE PEOPLE V DOMINIC CAVEKA 23-009472024 NY Slip Op 76314(U)
THE PEOPLE V SAMMY L. BROWN162-202024 NY Slip Op 76313(U)
UTICA FIRST INSURANCE COMPANY V COTE AGENCY INC. , BALDES PROTECTION AGENCY, INC., BALDES PROTECTION AGENCY, INC.393-242024 NY Slip Op 76312(U)
THE PEOPLE V FELIX APONTEKA 23-004692024 NY Slip Op 76311(U)
AL 557 DOE V CENTRAL VALLEY CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT, FORMERLY KNOWN AS ILION CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT, CENTRAL VALLEY970-232024 NY Slip Op 76310(U)
Motions Decided September 26, 2024
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
GEORGE C. LEE V KALEIDA HEALTH, DOING BUSINESS AS BUFFALO GENERAL HOSPITAL, JEFFREY CARTER, M.D., TIMOTHY SCHAFFNERCA 23-013102024 NY Slip Op 76309(U)
PAULINE HOFFMAN V ST. BONAVENTURE UNIVERSITYCA 24-004452024 NY Slip Op 76308(U)
Motions Decided September 24, 2024
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF NATALIO B.CAF 23-018302024 NY Slip Op 75263(U)
IN THE MATTER OF THE ADOPTION OF A CHILD WHOSE FIRST NAME IS MAKAYLACAF 24-012902024 NY Slip Op 75262(U)
THE PEOPLE V TIFFANIE IRWINKA 17-017142024 NY Slip Op 75261(U)
Motions Decided September 23, 2024
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF JAMAR T. ZWIEFACH V DEBORAH HEITZMANNCAF 24-001312024 NY Slip Op 75260(U)
IN THE MATTER OF WILLIAM C.CAF 23-012362024 NY Slip Op 75259(U)
MELINDA SCHWARTZ V DANIEL A. SCHWARTZCA 24-00996, CA 24-01241 AND CA 24-015022024 NY Slip Op 75258(U)
IN THE MATTER OF PHILLIP M.CAF 24-014212024 NY Slip Op 75257(U)
PB-57 DOE V THE LUTHERAN CHURCH MISSOURI SYNOD , THE LUTHERAN CHURCH MISSOURI SYNOD-EASTERN DISTRICTCA 23-015812024 NY Slip Op 75256(U)
THE PEOPLE V DAGOBERTO C. MIRANDAKA 18-007142024 NY Slip Op 75255(U)
MONTEREY ROAD 5382, LLC V LILLY BROADCASTING, LLC, AND LILLY BROADCASTING HOLDINGS, LLCCA 24-011792024 NY Slip Op 75254(U)
IN THE MATTER OF MAGDALENA KOHLER V RANDOLPH BARDEN, JR.CAF 24-001792024 NY Slip Op 75253(U)
IN THE MATTER OF KENNETH G. KNOWLES, SR. V DEBBIE TOWNSEND AND MARAH MERRIAMCAF 24-009592024 NY Slip Op 75252(U)
IN THE MATTER OF PAULINE JOHNSON, JOANNE BOCACH AND MARY WANZER V ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS, ROBERT DUFF, MEMBER OFCA 23-021222024 NY Slip Op 75251(U)
LEROY JOHNSON, CLAIMANT- V STATE OF NEW YORKCA 24-014932024 NY Slip Op 75250(U)
TYSHON J. HOUSE V STATE OF NEW YORK, NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF FAMILY ASSISTANCE, NEW YORK STATE OFFICE OF CHILDRENCA 24-006512024 NY Slip Op 75249(U)
IN THE MATTER OF FRUEHAUF AND CHATEAU HOMEOWNERS FOR A CLEAN ENVIRONMENT, INC., SAMANTHA SMITH AND MICHAEL KOZELSKY VCA 24-014012024 NY Slip Op 75248(U)
ALBERT G. FRACCOLA, JR. V 1ST CHOICE REALTY, INC. , HONORABLE RANDALL B. CALDWELLCA 24-007032024 NY Slip Op 75247(U)
IN THE MATTER OF DENNIMNICOLE H.-C.CAF 23-018382024 NY Slip Op 75246(U)
IN THE MATTER OF THE STEUBEN COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL SERVICES, ON BEHALF OF MARISSA M. CURRAN V BRYON J. SCHWARTZCAF 24-013102024 NY Slip Op 75245(U)
IN THE MATTER OF THOMAS J. COATES, SR. V BRIANNA L. HODGECAF 24-013322024 NY Slip Op 75244(U)
IN THE MATTER OF CHANDLER W.CAF 23-016772024 NY Slip Op 75243(U)
THE PEOPLE V RAYMOND BOYDKA 20-004662024 NY Slip Op 75242(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ALBERT S. AND STACEY S.CAF 23-002642024 NY Slip Op 75241(U)
IN THE MATTER OF AIDEN J.R.CAF 23-016342024 NY Slip Op 75240(U)
IN THE MATTER OF AHREN B.-N.CAF 24-011282024 NY Slip Op 75239(U)
Motions Decided September 19, 2024
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF DAVID CHEUNG V KIM NYGEN THI TRANCAF 24-011352024 NY Slip Op 75238(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ALEJANDRO G.-P. AND NEYMAR G.-P.CAF 24-013432024 NY Slip Op 75237(U)
Motions Decided September 18, 2024
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF JOSE M.F.CAF 23-020512024 NY Slip Op 74798(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ALBERT S. AND STACEY S.CAF 23-003092024 NY Slip Op 74797(U)
Motions Decided September 16, 2024
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
FLOWERS BY STEVE, LLC V ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS OF THE TOWN OF MENDON AND TOWN OF MENDONCA 24-004712024 NY Slip Op 74796(U)
MELINDA SCHWARTZ V DANIEL A. SCHWARTZCA 24-00554 AND CA 24-005562024 NY Slip Op 74795(U)
MELINDA SCHWARTZ V DANIEL A. SCHWARTZCA 24-00554 AND CA 24-005562024 NY Slip Op 74794(U)
THE PEOPLE V ABDUL RAJN, ALSO KNOWN AS ABDUL RAJANKA 24-007092024 NY Slip Op 74793(U)
IN THE MATTER OF MADELINE W. AND PARKER R.CAF 24-010182024 NY Slip Op 74792(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JOHN R. V THE STATE OF NEW YORKCA 24-013572024 NY Slip Op 74791(U)
IN THE MATTER OF KWAME JACKSON V ANTHONY ANNUCCI, ACTING COMMISSIONER DOCCSTP 24-012062024 NY Slip Op 74790(U)
IN THE MATTER OF HARRY'S NURSES REGISTRY, INC. V NEW YORK STATE OFFICE OF MEDICAID INSPECTOR GENERAL (OMIG), NEW YORKTP 24-011002024 NY Slip Op 74789(U)
IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF DANIELLE DILL, PSY.D., EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF CENTRAL NEW YORK PSYCHIATRIC CENTER VCA 24-009652024 NY Slip Op 74788(U)
TOWN OF PALMYRA V KEVIN CARRIERCA 24-008282024 NY Slip Op 74787(U)
NICHOLAS PAUL BARBATO V ROCHESTER POLICE DEPARTMENT, MONROE COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE, JUDGE KAREN BAILEY TURNERCA 24-014672024 NY Slip Op 74786(U)
THE PEOPLE V SHANE T. STOKES, SR.KA 22-018312024 NY Slip Op 76307(U)
THE PEOPLE V KIMARA PLUVIOSEKA 23-008542024 NY Slip Op 76306(U)
THE PEOPLE V PAUL J. DURINKOKA 24-007592024 NY Slip Op 76305(U)
Motions Decided September 13, 2024
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF ALEXANDER PATTERSON V WHITNIE HILL, ALSO KNOWN AS WHITNIE GARTZCAF 24-012732024 NY Slip Op 74785(U)
IN THE MATTER OF TRACY L. MOSES V INDIA S. MCFARLAND AND MARKEEF ROYALCAF 24-005292024 NY Slip Op 74784(U)
IN THE MATTER OF SHAWN MCGUIRK V SARA MCGUIRKCAF 24-014102024 NY Slip Op 74783(U)
IN THE MATTER OF STACY J. CRANDELL V GRAYSON W. HEBBARDCAF 24-011692024 NY Slip Op 74782(U)
IN THE MATTER OF CONNOR B. BUSHART V AZRAEL R. GIACALONECAF 24-013602024 NY Slip Op 74781(U)
IN THE MATTER OF CONNOR B. BUSHART V AZRAEL R. GIACALONECAF 24-013602024 NY Slip Op 75236(U)
Motions Decided September 11, 2024
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
THE PEOPLE V TINA L. WAGONERKA 16-023662024 NY Slip Op 74366(U)
IN THE MATTER OF PRINCE G. TARNUE V RACHEL NYEMAHCAF 24-013762024 NY Slip Op 74365(U)
THE PEOPLE V JONATHAN SPINKSKA 23-000652024 NY Slip Op 74364(U)
IN THE MATTER OF SALVATORE Y.CAF 23-011022024 NY Slip Op 74363(U)
IN THE MATTER OF TRACY L. MOSES V INDIA S. MCFARLAND AND MARKEEF ROYALCAF 24-005292024 NY Slip Op 74362(U)
IN THE MATTER OF KEVIN V.CAF 24-011582024 NY Slip Op 74361(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JOHN W. KELLER, II V KERRY K. MCGRATHCAF 24-011762024 NY Slip Op 74360(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JEMMA M.CAF 23-019702024 NY Slip Op 74359(U)
IN THE MATTER OF DOMINICK B., MICHAEL B., AND MATTHEW B.CAF 23-004562024 NY Slip Op 74358(U)
Motions Decided September 10, 2024
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF RAVEN A. SMITH V RICHARD P. LUCIVEROCAF 24-003332024 NY Slip Op 74357(U)
IN THE MATTER OF LAUREEN SMITH V WOODROW ABRAMSCAF 24-001362024 NY Slip Op 74356(U)
IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF JOSEPH ROESCH V OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, AND ACTING EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OFCA 24-004202024 NY Slip Op 74355(U)
IN THE MATTER OF WENDELL MOORE, JR. V CARLA LEPKOWSKICAF 24-006962024 NY Slip Op 74354(U)
IN THE MATTER OF DWANE MCDUFFIE, JR. V TRAYLANTA COLEMANCAF 24-009612024 NY Slip Op 74353(U)
IN THE MATTER OF KARDAR S.CAF 24-011882024 NY Slip Op 74352(U)
IN THE MATTER OF AMELIA JAREMKO V JOEL KATZ AND DARIA JAREMKOCAF 23-019402024 NY Slip Op 74351(U)
THE PEOPLE V LUIS FUENTESKA 24-011972024 NY Slip Op 74350(U)
IN THE MATTER OF TRISTINA DEAS V RONALD CONTRERASCAF 24-013192024 NY Slip Op 74349(U)
IN THE MATTER OF DAVID CHEUNG V KIM NYGEN THI TRANCAF 24-011352024 NY Slip Op 74348(U)
IN THE MATTER OF RONNIE BURLEY V KYLE E. RICHMONDCAF 24-012102024 NY Slip Op 74347(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JOSHUA BEMAN V KRISTEN HANDCAF 24-013512024 NY Slip Op 74346(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ALEJANDRO G.-P. AND NEYMAR G.-P.CAF 24-012932024 NY Slip Op 74345(U)
IN THE MATTER OF ANDRIA ADAMS V DEMETRIUS PURDUE, SR.CAF 24-006802024 NY Slip Op 74344(U)
Motions Decided September 9, 2024
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
THE PEOPLE V DAMELL WASHINGTONKA 24-012812024 NY Slip Op 74343(U)
THE PEOPLE V CASSIDY WARDKA 23-008232024 NY Slip Op 74342(U)
IN THE MATTER OF LIANA J. VANTREESE, V NICHOLAS A. ROSS, .CAF 24-013082024 NY Slip Op 74341(U)
PEARL G. SIMMONS, AS SETTLOR OF AN IRREVOCABLE LIVING TRUST OF EUGENE M. SIMMONS AND PEARL G. SIMMONS V THE EUGENE ANDCA 23-016592024 NY Slip Op 74340(U)
THE PEOPLE V TODD D. SANDSKA 24-002262024 NY Slip Op 74339(U)
THE PEOPLE V MARKEEF ROYALKA 23-014052024 NY Slip Op 74338(U)
THE PEOPLE V ERIN E. RHYNES, ALSO KNOWN AS ERIN ROSHAD KENDRELL EDWARDSKA 19-013732024 NY Slip Op 74337(U)
THE PEOPLE V MATTHEW A. NOWICKIKA 23-008092024 NY Slip Op 74336(U)
PETER R. MORGAN V CITY OF UTICA CA 24-002372024 NY Slip Op 74335(U)
DJP DEVELOPMENT, LLC V MACERICH NIAGARA, LLC, - .CA 24-00127 AND CA 24-001282024 NY Slip Op 74334(U)
THE PEOPLE V RYAN LAWSKA 23-014892024 NY Slip Op 74333(U)
THE PEOPLE V KEENAN LAVALLEYKA 22-014452024 NY Slip Op 74332(U)
THE PEOPLE V BRETT M. HOLTKA 24-002392024 NY Slip Op 74331(U)
THE PEOPLE V TASHEONIA M. HILLSKA 19-016452024 NY Slip Op 74330(U)
THE PEOPLE V ESTRELLITA T. HIDALGOKA 23-01027 and KA 23-010292024 NY Slip Op 74329(U)
THE PEOPLE V BRIAN T. HESSKA 24-01109 and KA 24-011102024 NY Slip Op 74328(U)
BARBARA Y. HAYES V NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN RIGHTS (DIVISION), FAIRWOOD MANAGEMENT, DANIEL A GRABOWSKI,LISACA 24-01333, CA 24-01339 AND CA 24-013402024 NY Slip Op 74327(U)
IN THE MATTER OF HARRY'S NURSES REGISTRY, INC. V NEW YORK STATE OFFICE OF MEDICAID INSPECTOR GENERAL (OMIG), NEW YORKTP 24-011002024 NY Slip Op 74326(U)
BARBARA J. GAMIERRO V THE LUTHERAN CHURCH, MISSOURI SYNOD, - .CA 23-02022 AND CA 23-020232024 NY Slip Op 74325(U)
THE PEOPLE V ROBERT A. FORBES, JR.KA 14-01486, KA 14-01487 and KA 14-014882024 NY Slip Op 74324(U)
ERIE INSURANCE COMPANY, AS SUBROGEE OF MAC'S PIZZERIA & GRILL CORP., - V CHILDREN'S PALACE CHILDCARE CENTER, INC.CA 23-004982024 NY Slip Op 74323(U)
THE PEOPLE V RAHMIERE DUNHAM COFFEEKA 22-00046 and KA 22-002592024 NY Slip Op 74322(U)
THE PEOPLE V VALENTINO DIXONKA 23-019422024 NY Slip Op 74321(U)
HARLEYSVILLE PREFERRED INSURANCE COMPANY AND HARLEYSVILLE WORCESTER INSURANCE COMPANY, AS SUBROGEE OF G.W.P. LLC, DOINGCA 23-004762024 NY Slip Op 74320(U)
THE PEOPLE V SHAMEEK M. COPESKA 23-007812024 NY Slip Op 74319(U)
THE PEOPLE V FRANKLIN CHAMBERSKA 21-011972024 NY Slip Op 74318(U)
THE PEOPLE V ERIC F. BROWNKA 24-005512024 NY Slip Op 74317(U)
GAIL BISHOP V ANTHONY BISHOPCA 24-008802024 NY Slip Op 74316(U)
Motions Decided September 5, 2024
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
PETER R MORGAN V MOVACCA 24-002452024 NY Slip Op 74315(U)
IN THE MATTER OF WILLIE BRIGHT V DANIEL F. MARTUSCELLO, III, ACTING COMMISSIONER, NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OFTP 24-010232024 NY Slip Op 74314(U)
PEOPLE EX REL. ILANN M. MAAZEL, ESQ. ON BEHALF OF BRIAN SCOTT LORENZO V JOHN C. GARCIA, ERIE COUNTY HOLDING CENTER, ANDOP 23-020852024 NY Slip Op 74313(U)
LAURA K., INDIVIDUALLY AND AS PARENT AND NATURAL GUARDIAN OF A.K., AN INFANT V ALLEGRA JAROS AND KALEIDA HEALTHCA 23-016362024 NY Slip Op 74312(U)
IN THE MATTER OF BRODY B. KOLASSA V BROOKE L. KOLASSACAF 24-000052024 NY Slip Op 74311(U)
IN THE MATTER OF TONY KIRIK V DEBRA A. MARTIN, ACTING JUSTICE OF NEW YORK STATE SUPREME COURT, THOMAS C. WILMOT, SR.OP 23-017652024 NY Slip Op 74310(U)
IN THE MATTER OF TONYA HAMMON V NICHOLAS CASTOR AND JUSTINA SACCONECAF 24-011622024 NY Slip Op 74309(U)
IN THE MATTER OF TONYA HAMMON V NICHOLAS CASTORCAF 24-011612024 NY Slip Op 74308(U)
LORI A. ELLIOTT V ROBERT A. ELLIOTTCA 23-017472024 NY Slip Op 74307(U)
IN THE MATTER OF JUSTIN COOK V JULIA ALFORDCAF 24-001102024 NY Slip Op 74306(U)
IN THE MATTER OF CERENITY C.CAF 24-009722024 NY Slip Op 74305(U)
NORA ALMONTASER, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS THE ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF SELLAH ALMONTASER, DECEASED, CLAIMANT- VCA 23-00042 and CA 23-010092024 NY Slip Op 74304(U)
Motions Decided September 3, 2024
TitleMotion No.SlipOp No.
IN THE MATTER OF DAVID P. FENTON V COLLEEN S. SMITHCAF 23-019972024 NY Slip Op 76437(U)

Links to or from other sites do not signify endorsement or relationship with them.