skip to main content
Law Reporting
Bureau Thomas J.K. Smith, State Reporter

Appellate Division, First Department Decisions

Current Month Archived Cases Motions

November 2003 Archive

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

Cases Decided November 25, 2003
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
People v Richard Peters 2319 2003 NYSlipOp 18882
People v Anthony Bowden 2320 2003 NYSlipOp 18883
People v Juan Negron 2322 2003 NYSlipOp 18884
Michelle V. v Lillian P. 2323 2003 NYSlipOp 18885
People v Orosmar Vasquez 2324 2003 NYSlipOp 18886
Matter of Leroy Dottin v Tino Hernandez 2325 2003 NYSlipOp 18887
Han Fui Hui v Tieh Chi Ho 2326 2003 NYSlipOp 18888
Frydman & Company v Credit Suisse First Boston Corporation 2327 2003 NYSlipOp 18889
Matter of Leo A. Marino v Robert M. Morgenthau 2328 2003 NYSlipOp 18890
Yenatrid Guzman v New York City Housing Authority 2329 2003 NYSlipOp 18891
Duane Reade v Highpoint Associates IX 2330 2003 NYSlipOp 18892
People v Johnson Edwards 2331 2003 NYSlipOp 18893
Royal Indemnity Company v Travelers Indemnity Company 2332 2003 NYSlipOp 18894
Matter of New York Central Mutual Insurance Company v Angelo Jovine 2333 2003 NYSlipOp 18895
James Maxfield Duhe v Horacio J. Midence 2334N 2003 NYSlipOp 18896
Benny Fraioli v St. Joseph's Seminary of the City of New York 2304 2003 NYSlipOp 18897
People v Lance Stewartson 2305 2003 NYSlipOp 18898
City of New York v Consolidated Edison Company of New York 2306 2003 NYSlipOp 18899
People v Luis Ruthledge 2307 2003 NYSlipOp 18900
People v Delores Diakite 2308 2003 NYSlipOp 18901
Matter of Voulis Brooks v Wagner Houses 2309 2003 NYSlipOp 18902
People v George Williams 2310 2003 NYSlipOp 18903
Matter of John Fitzgerald v New York City Department of Housing Preservation and Development 2311 2003 NYSlipOp 18904
Larry Clemons v Roslynn Glicksman 2312 2003 NYSlipOp 18905
Bernardo Ramos v Champion Combustion 2313 2003 NYSlipOp 18906
Luther Petty v North General Hospital 2315 2003 NYSlipOp 18907
Victorine Christiano v Port Authority of New York and New Jersey 2317N 2003 NYSlipOp 18908
Credit Suisse First Boston Corporation v William Pitofsky Williams 1580 2003 NYSlipOp 18909
Credit Suisse First Boston Corporation v William Pitofsky 1580 2003 NYSlipOp 18910
Matter of Progressive Insurance Company v Gabriel Pineiro Medina 2335N 2003 NYSlipOp 18911
People v Victor Gonzalez 2284 2003 NYSlipOp 18912
People v Joel Velez 2285 2003 NYSlipOp 18913
Empire Blue Cross and Blue Shield v Various Underwriters at Lloyd's, London, England 2287 2003 NYSlipOp 18914
People v James Memminger 2289 2003 NYSlipOp 18915
Pamela Fletcher v Insignia/Douglas Elliman 2291 2003 NYSlipOp 18916
Alexander J.P. Gloth v Brusco Equities 2292 2003 NYSlipOp 18917
Hyacinth Atkins v Besim Malota 2293 2003 NYSlipOp 18918
People v Onoriode Eyubeh 2294 2003 NYSlipOp 18919
Matter of Katrina Maxtone-Graham v Landmarks Preservation Commission of the City of New York 2295 2003 NYSlipOp 18920
Eric Lopez v Tryax Realty Management 2297 2003 NYSlipOp 18921
Daniel E. Raiola v 1944 Holding 2299N 2003 NYSlipOp 18922
Siu Chuen Chan v Continental Broker-Dealer Corp. 2300N 2003 NYSlipOp 18923
Nathalie De LaFontaine v Nicholas Toms 2301 2003 NYSlipOp 18924
People v Jasmine Mingo 2302 2003 NYSlipOp 18925
Marion Sakow v 633 Seafood Restaurant 2303 2003 NYSlipOp 18926
Cases Decided November 20, 2003
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
John J. Sheehy v Clifford Chance Rogers & Wells 2124 2003 NYSlipOp 18514
J. Gerald Combs v Marc Lewis 2247 2003 NYSlipOp 18515
Carolyn James v Yoen Wah Rental 2248 2003 NYSlipOp 18516
Golub Associates Incorporated v Lincolnshire Management 2249 2003 NYSlipOp 18517
Andrew Mark v H.F. Lenfest 2250 2003 NYSlipOp 18518
Mizwell Williams v James Parke 2251 2003 NYSlipOp 18519
Promenade v Schindler Elevator Corporation 2253 2003 NYSlipOp 18520
People v Gregory Manning 2254 2003 NYSlipOp 18521
Jose Diaz v New York Mercantile Exchange 2255 2003 NYSlipOp 18522
People v Jaimel Eddie 2257 2003 NYSlipOp 18523
Matter of Ann B. v William B. 2258 2003 NYSlipOp 18524
People v James Appice 2259 2003 NYSlipOp 18525
James Froehlich v New York City Transit Authority 2260 2003 NYSlipOp 18526
People v Jaquez Nolberto 2261 2003 NYSlipOp 18527
Bernadette Tricia Rooney v Webb Avenue Associates 2263N 2003 NYSlipOp 18528
Matter of Pedro C. v Josephine B. 2279 2003 NYSlipOp 18529
Carolyn Romantini v Bruce Irrgang 2281 2003 NYSlipOp 18530
Allegro Resorts Corporation v Trans-Americainvest (St. Kitts) 2283N 2003 NYSlipOp 18531
Philip Pierce v Adam Victor 2264N 2003 NYSlipOp 18532
Skillgames, LLC v Seth Brody 1595 2003 NYSlipOp 18533
Fairfield Towers Condominium Association v Michael Fishman 1696N 2003 NYSlipOp 18534
Stephen Hall v City of New York 1797 2003 NYSlipOp 18535
Matter of Jasmine S. v Mirayah S. 1837 2003 NYSlipOp 18536
Katherine Wankel v Sergio Spodek 1916N 2003 NYSlipOp 18537
Juana Mejia v JMM Audubon 2019 2003 NYSlipOp 18538
Carol Elliott v East 220th Street Realty Company 2043 2003 NYSlipOp 18539
Albert Sangenette v Embassy Suites Hotel 2064 2003 NYSlipOp 18540
People v Liz Nivar 2085 2003 NYSlipOp 18541
Argo Corporation v Greater New York Mutual Insurance Company 2090 2003 NYSlipOp 18542
Matter of Joaquin Pena v Hon. Nicholas Iacovetta 2160 2003 NYSlipOp 18543
People v Ismael Ortiz 2272 2003 NYSlipOp 18544
Matter of Nereida Mendez v Rachel Hance 2276 2003 NYSlipOp 18545
Michael Hort v Lawrence Devine 2277 2003 NYSlipOp 18546
Shayne Industries (USA) v Scanwell Freight Express (USA) 2278 2003 NYSlipOp 18547
Cases Decided November 18, 2003
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
Helen Chayie Sieger v Union of Orthodox Rabbis of the United States and Canada 1329 2003 NYSlipOp 18374
People v Elliot Murphy 1780 2003 NYSlipOp 18375
San Ysidro Corporation v Hermann Melchior Robinow 1950 2003 NYSlipOp 18376
David Fischer v Crown Heights Jewish Community Council 2106 2003 NYSlipOp 18377
BNP Paribas (Suisse) v Chase Manhattan Bank 2112N 2003 NYSlipOp 18378
Samuel N. Goldstein v Columbia Presbyterian Medical Center 970 2003 NYSlipOp 18379
Irma Fusco v Kraumlap Realty Corp. 1006 2003 NYSlipOp 18380
Janice Young v Board of Education of the City of New York 1017N 2003 NYSlipOp 18381
James R. Shinn v Phyllis A. Catanzaro 1233 2003 NYSlipOp 18382
Matter of Bicentita Martinez v John Johnson 1252 2003 NYSlipOp 18383
Ronald C. Blum v Paine Hacking Corp. 1448 2003 NYSlipOp 18384
People v Howard Faden 1637 2003 NYSlipOp 18385
People v Jose Medina 1651 2003 NYSlipOp 18386
Regina Joyce v Manhattan College 2063 2003 NYSlipOp 18387
People v Louis Baez 2205 2003 NYSlipOp 18388
Matter of Nathaniel F. 2206 2003 NYSlipOp 18389
General Media v Demien Lichtenstein 2207 2003 NYSlipOp 18390
People v Heriberto Vazquez Marrero 2208 2003 NYSlipOp 18391
People v Domingo Espiritu 2210 2003 NYSlipOp 18392
People v Jonathan Bonilla 2211 2003 NYSlipOp 18393
People v Carlos Soba 2212 2003 NYSlipOp 18394
Board of Managers of the Europa Condominium v Jeffrey Orenstein 2213 2003 NYSlipOp 18395
Donald Warnett v A.J. Pegno Construction Corp. 2216 2003 NYSlipOp 18396
State Bank of India, New York Branch v Sakunthala Gnanamgari 2217 2003 NYSlipOp 18397
Rosendo Duarte Urena v Pace University 2219 2003 NYSlipOp 18398
Marina Perez v Moshulu Footcare 2220 2003 NYSlipOp 18399
Enis Djurkovic v Three Goodfellows 2221 2003 NYSlipOp 18400
Renee Despins Realty v Marc Roberts 2222 2003 NYSlipOp 18401
Convenient Service Center v Kojo A. Badu 2223N 2003 NYSlipOp 18402
People v Luis Quintan 2226 2003 NYSlipOp 18403
People v Eric Thatch 2227 2003 NYSlipOp 18404
People v James Otano 2228 2003 NYSlipOp 18405
Zuzana Kurtz v Richard Kurtz 2230 2003 NYSlipOp 18406
Matter of Arlene Beckles v Bernard Kerik 2231 2003 NYSlipOp 18407
Sangwoo Ahn v Joseph D. Malvasio 2232 2003 NYSlipOp 18408
People v Chun Wei Chen 2233 2003 NYSlipOp 18409
Michael Lewis v Donald Baker 2234 2003 NYSlipOp 18410
Matter of Gregory Hicks v City of New York 2235 2003 NYSlipOp 18411
Alex Hershenbaum v Irving Angerman 2236 2003 NYSlipOp 18412
Bun Sin Lee v Pathmark Stores 2237 2003 NYSlipOp 18413
Robert M. Rubin v Robin K.W. Rubin 2238 2003 NYSlipOp 18414
Michael Melnitzky v City of New York 2239 2003 NYSlipOp 18415
Raymond H. Wong v World Journal 2240 2003 NYSlipOp 18416
Matter of Saquan K. 2242 2003 NYSlipOp 18417
Ulico Casualty Company v Wilson, Elser, Moskowitz, Edelman & Dicker 2245N 2003 NYSlipOp 18418
Excel Graphics Technologies v CFG/AGSCB 75 Ninth Avenue Sullivan 1322N 2003 NYSlipOp 18419
Excel Graphics Technologies v CFG/AGSCB 75 Ninth Avenue 1322N 2003 NYSlipOp 18420
Cases Decided November 13, 2003
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Adiva B. v Tekya B. 1616 2003 NYSlipOp 18322
Walter S. Herbert v Sivaco Wire Corp. 1634N 2003 NYSlipOp 18323
People v Kendall Brown 2162 2003 NYSlipOp 18324
Matter of Ann Towpash v Raymond W. Kelly 2163 2003 NYSlipOp 18325
Harold Rosenbaum v City of New York 2164 2003 NYSlipOp 18326
Matter of Shania Tatiara A. v Laverne M. 2165 2003 NYSlipOp 18327
People v Ricardo Rodriguez 2166 2003 NYSlipOp 18328
Patria Lantigua v 700 W. 178th Street Associates 2168 2003 NYSlipOp 18329
People v Jonnie Scott 2171 2003 NYSlipOp 18330
Gemma Development Co. v Fidelity & Deposit Company of Maryland 2172 2003 NYSlipOp 18331
Julia Davis v HSS Properties Corporation 2173 2003 NYSlipOp 18332
Thomas Stanislawczyk v 2 East 61st Street Corp. 2175 2003 NYSlipOp 18333
Paul Vita v Hertz Corporation 2177 2003 NYSlipOp 18334
People v Henry Hylton 2179 2003 NYSlipOp 18335
Tzo Kao Chang v Wei Qing Liu 2180N 2003 NYSlipOp 18336
Corinne Wilson v City of New York 2181N 2003 NYSlipOp 18337
Temily Mark-Weiner v Ira Mark 2182N 2003 NYSlipOp 18338
Jill Damaska v Selcuk Kandemir 1497 2003 NYSlipOp 18339
Diana Locke v Sherrell J. Aston 1807 2003 NYSlipOp 18340
People v Jose Rodriguez 1848 2003 NYSlipOp 18341
People v Erik Simmons 1871 2003 NYSlipOp 18342
Peter Cunningham v Office Depot 2131 2003 NYSlipOp 18343
People v Lisa Feliciano 2136 2003 NYSlipOp 18344
People v Wendell Ortiz 2140 2003 NYSlipOp 18345
People v Randy Selby 2142 2003 NYSlipOp 18346
Soci‚t‚ G‚n‚rale v Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's, London 2143 2003 NYSlipOp 18347
Matter of Anthony Gomez v Raymond Kelly 2144 2003 NYSlipOp 18348
Solow Management Corp. v Steven Tanger 2147 2003 NYSlipOp 18349
Cara Campisi v Bronx Water & Sewer Service 2148 2003 NYSlipOp 18350
Jerrold Ross v Kamel Wazne 2149 2003 NYSlipOp 18351
Metropolitan New York Coordinating Council on Jewish Poverty v FGP Bush Terminal 2150 2003 NYSlipOp 18352
People v George Lopez 2154 2003 NYSlipOp 18353
Matter of Dyandria Murray v Gerard Murray 2155 2003 NYSlipOp 18354
People v Jian Lin 2156 2003 NYSlipOp 18355
Matter of Lipper Holdings v Trident Holdings 2158N 2003 NYSlipOp 18356
People v Vincent Thorpe 2183 2003 NYSlipOp 18357
Lashanda Nowlin v People of the State of New York 2184 2003 NYSlipOp 18358
People v Richard Navas 2185 2003 NYSlipOp 18359
People v Richard Taffin 2187 2003 NYSlipOp 18360
Matter of Victoria C. v Higinio C. 2188 2003 NYSlipOp 18361
People v Lennox Rose 2189 2003 NYSlipOp 18362
Sylvester Thomas v 2 Overhill Road Associates 2192 2003 NYSlipOp 18363
Brian Moore v True North Communications 2195 2003 NYSlipOp 18364
Laura Inger Mohr v Hillside Children's Center 2196 2003 NYSlipOp 18365
Dorothy Fitch v Turner Construction Company 2197 2003 NYSlipOp 18366
Merchants Bank of New York v Gerald Itzkoff 2199 2003 NYSlipOp 18367
People v Lerun Nightingale 2201 2003 NYSlipOp 18368
Ricardo Torres v West Street Realty Company 2203N 2003 NYSlipOp 18369
Matter of Tyrone L. Jackson v Hon. Micki Scherer 2225 2003 NYSlipOp 18370
Matter of Marshall C. Berger Per Curiam M-2596 2003 NYSlipOp 18371
Matter of Andrea M. Mercado Per Curiam M-2686 2003 NYSlipOp 18372
Cases Decided November 6, 2003
Title Judge Docket No. Slip Opinion No.
Matter of John Verbalis v New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal 578 2003 NYSlipOp 18141
People v Jose Carrion 1724 2003 NYSlipOp 18142
Matter of Sherman F. Taub v Hon. Herbert I. Altman 1784 2003 NYSlipOp 18143
Hector Contrera v Gesher Realty Corp. 1854 2003 NYSlipOp 18144
People v Maurice Rogers 2094 2003 NYSlipOp 18145
People v Dionicio Pimental 2096 2003 NYSlipOp 18146
Matter of Richard Gruber v New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal 2097 2003 NYSlipOp 18147
People v Richard Rivera 2098 2003 NYSlipOp 18148
People v Mike Velez 2099 2003 NYSlipOp 18149
George Statfeld v Donald Greener 2101 2003 NYSlipOp 18150
People v Oscar Peralta 2103 2003 NYSlipOp 18151
Jhana M. Wiggins v City of New York 2104 2003 NYSlipOp 18152
Polina Sitner v Lenox Hill Hospital 2105 2003 NYSlipOp 18153
Eugenia Ostrovsky v City of New York 2109 2003 NYSlipOp 18154
Matter of Louis Anthony Pacca v City of New York Department of Buildings 2110 2003 NYSlipOp 18155
Sherman Abrams v Port Authority Trans-Hudson Corporation 2111 2003 NYSlipOp 18156
Diana Perez Lugo v H.B.T. Housing Co. 2113N 2003 NYSlipOp 18157
People v Lupo Agurto 1801 2003 NYSlipOp 18158
Ilias Balaskonis v HRH Construction Corp. 2062 2003 NYSlipOp 18159
People v Victor M. Wang 2066 2003 NYSlipOp 18160
People v Ramon Jorge 2073 2003 NYSlipOp 18161
People v Delmar Rampersant 2074 2003 NYSlipOp 18162
Matter of Shavon H. v Keith J. 2076 2003 NYSlipOp 18163
People v Cyrress Moundo 2077 2003 NYSlipOp 18164
Fruition, Inc. v Rhoda Lee, Inc. 2078 2003 NYSlipOp 18165
People v James Lane 2079 2003 NYSlipOp 18166
People ex rel. Benton v Farsi 2081 2003 NYSlipOp 18167
Priovolos v St. Barnabas Hosp. 2083 2003 NYSlipOp 18168
Taylor v Pulvers, Pulvers, Thompson & Kuttner, P.C. 2084 2003 NYSlipOp 18169
Bat-Jac Contr. v New York City Hous. Auth. 2087 2003 NYSlipOp 18170
Savoy Little Neck Assoc, L. P. v Halpern Constr. 2089 2003 NYSlipOp 18171
Jamaica Pub. Serv. Co. v La Interamericana Cia de Seguros Generales S. A. 2091 2003 NYSlipOp 18172
Alard, L.L.C. v Weiss 2092 2003 NYSlipOp 18173
People v Darrell Bolden 2115 2003 NYSlipOp 18174
People v Andre Rivera 2119 2003 NYSlipOp 18175
Weigl v Quincy Specialties Co. 2121 2003 NYSlipOp 18176
People v Peter Parris 2122 2003 NYSlipOp 18177
Solow Mgt. Corp. v Lowe 2123 2003 NYSlipOp 18178
National Union Fire Ins. Co. v State Ins. Fund 2124 2003 NYSlipOp 18179
Galatowitsch v New York City Gay & Lesbian Anti-Violence Project 2126 2003 NYSlipOp 18180
Gershon v CDC Ixis Capital Mkts. 2129 2003 NYSlipOp 18181
Harris v Kind 2130 2003 NYSlipOp 18182
Patterson v City of New York 2132 2003 NYSlipOp 18183
Uddaraju v City of New York 2133 2003 NYSlipOp 18184
Griffin v New York City Tr. Auth. 2134N 2003 NYSlipOp 18185
Silverman & Weinraub v Gillon 2135N 2003 NYSlipOp 18186
Matter of Flemming v Tejada 2159 2003 NYSlipOp 18187

Links to or from other sites do not signify endorsement or relationship with them.