Appellate Division, First Department Decisions

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

**Cases Decided February 28, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Alante M. v Thomasina M.		7720	2006 NY Slip Op 01377
Commissioner of Social Services of City of N.Y. v Irving Harris		7296	2006 NY Slip Op 01378
Bank Hapoalim (Switzerland) Ltd. v Banca Intesa S.p.A.		7447	2006 NY Slip Op 01379
Matter of Gwenda Gates v Tino Hernandez		7736	2006 NY Slip Op 01380
Amy Gissen v Boy Scouts of America		7739N	2006 NY Slip Op 01381
People v Derrick Bostic		7942	2006 NY Slip Op 01382
Elena Lewis-Moore v Cloverleaf Tower Housing Development Fund Corporation		7943	2006 NY Slip Op 01383
People v Paul Person		7944	2006 NY Slip Op 01384
767 Third Avenue LLC v ORIX Capital Markets, LLC		7945	2006 NY Slip Op 01385
People v Jorge Hernandez		7951	2006 NY Slip Op 01386
Roan/Meyers Associates, L.P. v CT Holdings, Inc.		7954	2006 NY Slip Op 01387
Richard Friedman Associates, CPA PC v Susan Welsher Jereski		7957	2006 NY Slip Op 01388
People v Alwarn Hillard		7958	2006 NY Slip Op 01389
Ana S. Tavarez v City of New York		7962N	2006 NY Slip Op 01390
People v Francis Jackson		7963	2006 NY Slip Op 01391
Tars Uluslararasi Dis Ticaret Turizm ve Sanayi Limited, Sirketi v Gerald Leonard		7964	2006 NY Slip Op 01392
People v Isaac Coriano		7965	2006 NY Slip Op 01393
Matter of Kwesi H. v Sharnette T.		7966	2006 NY Slip Op 01394
People v Gabriel Joe		7970	2006 NY Slip Op 01395
Eugene Kitt v New York City Transit Authority		7972	2006 NY Slip Op 01396
People v William Rivera		7974	2006 NY Slip Op 01397
Jennifer Fitzpatrick v Maureen Fitzpatrick		7975	2006 NY Slip Op 01398
Seyed Taheri v 1878 Lexington Avenue Associates		7976	2006 NY Slip Op 01399
Julie Colyer v John Colyer		7978N	2006 NY Slip Op 01400
Ruth Shomron v Yoram Fuks		7979N	2006 NY Slip Op 01401
Matter of Leah Turell Kent v Steven John Kent	Marlow	7661	2006 NY Slip Op 01402
Matter of Zoilo I. Silva	Per Curiam	M-2609	2006 NY Slip Op 01403

**Cases Decided February 23, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v William Adams		7909	2006 NY Slip Op 01355
Valerie Ramirez v Allstate Insurance Company		7910	2006 NY Slip Op 01356
People v Fezo Garcia-Piola		7912	2006 NY Slip Op 01357
Atlantic St. John, LLC v William Yeomans		7913	2006 NY Slip Op 01358
People v Darryl Granger		7915	2006 NY Slip Op 01359
Elizabeth Combier v Fred Anderson		7917	2006 NY Slip Op 01360
People v Richard Cooke		7918	2006 NY Slip Op 01361
People v Gerald Gaines		7919	2006 NY Slip Op 01362
Morgan Barrington Financial Services v Roman Severino		7920	2006 NY Slip Op 01363
Matter of Wendy C.		7921	2006 NY Slip Op 01364
People v Melvin Rosario		6663	2006 NY Slip Op 01365
People v Darryl Best		6738	2006 NY Slip Op 01366
Phyllis Gomez v 192 East 151st Street Associates, L.P.		6994	2006 NY Slip Op 01367
Vic Char Realty, Inc. v Alliance Plus, Inc.		7933	2006 NY Slip Op 01368
Ruth Adingra v Henry Street Settlement		7934	2006 NY Slip Op 01369
People v George Gomez		7936	2006 NY Slip Op 01370
People v Jose Fernandez		7937	2006 NY Slip Op 01371
Matter of David, J.		7938	2006 NY Slip Op 01372
People v Angel Celpa		7939	2006 NY Slip Op 01373
Joe Cervini v Greystone Building Co.		7940N	2006 NY Slip Op 01374
Chunhye Kang-Kim v City of New York	Andrias	6568	2006 NY Slip Op 01375

**Cases Decided February 21, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Daniel Hernandez v Ten Ten Company		7273	2006 NY Slip Op 01251
Franklin Young v Casper Richards		7539	2006 NY Slip Op 01252
Matter of Jacqueline Sharon L. v Pamela G.		7543	2006 NY Slip Op 01253
People v Troy Dillard		7889	2006 NY Slip Op 01254
Jean E. Sealey v American Society of Hypertension, Inc.		7892	2006 NY Slip Op 01255
People v Tasha Campbell		7893	2006 NY Slip Op 01256
Juan Jimenez v Ramon A. Rojas		7895	2006 NY Slip Op 01257
David Realty and Funding, LLC v Second Avenue Realty Co.		7896	2006 NY Slip Op 01258
Matter of Najee A.		7897	2006 NY Slip Op 01259
People v David Watson		7898	2006 NY Slip Op 01260
People v Herbert Cephas		7899	2006 NY Slip Op 01261
Juan Mendez v Union Theological Seminary in City of N.Y.		7903	2006 NY Slip Op 01262
Bernabe Encarnacion v Diane Sawyer		7904	2006 NY Slip Op 01263
Robert G. Hayden v City of New York		7905	2006 NY Slip Op 01264
People v Pasha Kauffin		7906	2006 NY Slip Op 01265
Margaret O'Connor v Easyride, Inc.		7907	2006 NY Slip Op 01266
Joel Lavandier v Landmark Insurance Company		7908N	2006 NY Slip Op 01267
Matter of Elvin Lebron v John A. Barone		7941	2006 NY Slip Op 01268
New York City Off-Track Betting Corp. v Safe Factory Outlet, Inc.	Sweeny	6799	2006 NY Slip Op 01269

**Cases Decided February 16, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Allen Christopher		7855	2006 NY Slip Op 01219
People v Donald Johnson		7856	2006 NY Slip Op 01220
Matter of William R.C. v Richard C.		7857	2006 NY Slip Op 01221
People v Patricio Bautista		7860	2006 NY Slip Op 01222
Joseph Murphy v Chaos		7862	2006 NY Slip Op 01223
Zapin, Endlich & Lombardo, Inc. v CBS Coverage Group, Inc.		7864	2006 NY Slip Op 01224
Moussa Diane v Ricale Taxi, Inc.		7865	2006 NY Slip Op 01225
Zion Tsabbar v Maryann Auld		7867	2006 NY Slip Op 01226
Alfreda Royster v City of New York		7868	2006 NY Slip Op 01227
Matter of Anthony Corbisiero v Raymond Kelly		7869	2006 NY Slip Op 01228
Britti Corp. v Perry Thompson Third LLC		7870N	2006 NY Slip Op 01229
Stapleton Studios, LLC v City of New York		6737	2006 NY Slip Op 01230
Colleen Rich v North American Specialty Insurance Company		7052	2006 NY Slip Op 01231
ICBC Broadcast Holdings-NY, Inc. v Prime Time Advertising, Inc.		7497	2006 NY Slip Op 01232
People v Misael Burgos		7563	2006 NY Slip Op 01233
People v Edward Thomas		7872	2006 NY Slip Op 01234
Torrenzano Group, LLC v Hugh Burnham		7873	2006 NY Slip Op 01235
Matter of Katiuska N.		7874	2006 NY Slip Op 01236
People v Diomedes Heredia		7875	2006 NY Slip Op 01237
Matter of Peter J.File 4482/97 Lance		7877	2006 NY Slip Op 01238
People v Raymon Jon		7878	2006 NY Slip Op 01239
People v Terry McNair		7881	2006 NY Slip Op 01240
People ex rel. Battle v Warden, Rikers Island Correctional Facility		7882	2006 NY Slip Op 01241
People v Russell Cheek		7884	2006 NY Slip Op 01242
Verizon New York, Inc. v City of New York		7887N	2006 NY Slip Op 01243
Matter of Glenn J. Caldwell	Per Curiam	M-1475 Petitioner,	2006 NY Slip Op 01244

**Cases Decided February 14, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Peck Slip Associates LLC v City Council of the City of New York		7274	2006 NY Slip Op 01114
Matter of Brandon Robert LaC. v Christine DeLa T.		7653	2006 NY Slip Op 01115
People v Jose Rosario		6487	2006 NY Slip Op 01116
Anthony Costa v Mt. Hope Asphalt Corp.		6741	2006 NY Slip Op 01117
Vivia Mullings v Jeremy M. Huntwork		7363	2006 NY Slip Op 01118
767 Third Avenue LLC v Orix Capital Markets, LLC		7505	2006 NY Slip Op 01119
Cadlerock Joint Venture, L.P. v Allan E. Rubenstein		7621N	2006 NY Slip Op 01120
Cambridge Development, LLC v Dr. Antonia C. Novello		7666	2006 NY Slip Op 01121
Matter of Gregory W.		7689	2006 NY Slip Op 01122
People v James Washington		7834	2006 NY Slip Op 01123
Matter of Darisa D. v Bienvenida D.		7835	2006 NY Slip Op 01124
Matter of Rodney Reynald v Raymond W. Kelly		7836	2006 NY Slip Op 01125
People v Paul Vasquez		7837	2006 NY Slip Op 01126
People v Tomas Galan		7838	2006 NY Slip Op 01127
Robert E. Kulovany v Cerco Products, Inc.		7840	2006 NY Slip Op 01128
Joe Macchia v Nastasi White, Inc.		7846	2006 NY Slip Op 01129
Diane Scope v Federated Department Stores, Inc.		7848	2006 NY Slip Op 01130
People v Darrell Williams		7850	2006 NY Slip Op 01131
Matter of Christopher Allen v Robert T. Johnson		7888	2006 NY Slip Op 01132
Matter of Dormitory Authority of the State of New York		7894	2006 NY Slip Op 01133
Matter of Richard Boter	Per Curiam	M-6258	2006 NY Slip Op 01134
People v Stephen Grunwald	Sullivan	7175	2006 NY Slip Op 01135

**Cases Decided February 9, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Jason Lerman v City of New York		7627	2006 NY Slip Op 01082
Scot M. Laney v James N. Siewert		7678	2006 NY Slip Op 01083
People v Leroy Nelson		7796	2006 NY Slip Op 01084
People v Demetrius Perry		7799	2006 NY Slip Op 01085
Paris Balleta v 35 Park Avenue Corp.		7806	2006 NY Slip Op 01086
People v Nelson Flores		7807	2006 NY Slip Op 01087
TBS Latin America Liner, Ltd. v Abbey Sea Shipping Services de Consultores Navales S.A.		7808	2006 NY Slip Op 01088
People v Albert Ramos		7810	2006 NY Slip Op 01089
Matter of Earl G. v Makeeba S.		7811	2006 NY Slip Op 01090
Viola Jackson v Coler-Goldwater Specialty Hospitals and Nursing Facility		7812	2006 NY Slip Op 01091
Matter of Patricia Fuentes v New York City Commission on Human Rights		7813	2006 NY Slip Op 01092
Jose Rodriguez v Dixie N.Y.C., Inc.		7814	2006 NY Slip Op 01093
Bank of New York v Norilsk Nickel		7815N	2006 NY Slip Op 01094
People v Jamal Robinson		7816	2006 NY Slip Op 01095
People v Ed Sykes		7819	2006 NY Slip Op 01096
Robin Shine v Roosevelt Hospital		7820	2006 NY Slip Op 01097
People v Erick Rodriguez		7824	2006 NY Slip Op 01098
Jaileen Rodriguez v 105 East Clarke Associates and LLC		7826	2006 NY Slip Op 01099
Matter of Jonathan R.M. v Joseph M.		7827	2006 NY Slip Op 01100
People v Julio Rosario		7828	2006 NY Slip Op 01101
Matter of Kelvin G.		7830	2006 NY Slip Op 01102
People v Napoleon Orellana		7831	2006 NY Slip Op 01103
People of the State of New York ex rel. John Scott v Warden, Rikers Island Correctional Facility		7832	2006 NY Slip Op 01104
Caroline Velez v Hunts Point Multi-Service Center, Inc.	Andrias	6773N	2006 NY Slip Op 01105
Matter of Jeffrey S. Kozlow	Per Curiam	M-5939	2006 NY Slip Op 01106

**Cases Decided February 7, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
David Williams v T. Moriarty & Sons, Inc.		7517	2006 NY Slip Op 00964
Parametric Capital Management, LLC v Michael A. Lacher		7530	2006 NY Slip Op 00965
People v Brian Deale		7759	2006 NY Slip Op 00966
Matter of Sal Jenkins v New York City Department of Transportation		7760	2006 NY Slip Op 00967
People v Rudy Hassen		7762	2006 NY Slip Op 00968
People v Luis Robles		7763	2006 NY Slip Op 00969
Matter of Michael Mancini v New York City Department of Environmental Protection		7767	2006 NY Slip Op 00970
Matter of Kevin H.		7768	2006 NY Slip Op 00971
Dunlop Development Corp. v Eliot Spitzer		7770	2006 NY Slip Op 00972
34 Funding Associates, Inc. v Thomas A. Pollak		7771N	2006 NY Slip Op 00973
Thomas A. Pollak v WHC, Inc.		7772	2006 NY Slip Op 00974
Matter of 425 3rd Avenue Realty Co. v New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal		7773	2006 NY Slip Op 00975
Carol Anne Herlihy v New York City Loft Board		7775	2006 NY Slip Op 00976
People v Michael Giancaspro		7776	2006 NY Slip Op 00977
New York Property Holding Corp. v Anna Rosa		7777	2006 NY Slip Op 00978
Gabriel Morillo Martinez v New York Presbyterian Hospital		7778N	2006 NY Slip Op 00979
People v Camillo Douglas	Gonzalez	5430	2006 NY Slip Op 00980
Benjamin Hendrickson v Birchwood Nursing Home Partnership		7285N	2006 NY Slip Op 00981
People v Henry Thomas		7779	2006 NY Slip Op 00982
Edward A. Kaminsky v Spencer Segura		7780	2006 NY Slip Op 00983
People v Jessie Delaney		7781	2006 NY Slip Op 00984
Matter of Elizabeth Arielle L.		7782	2006 NY Slip Op 00985
Edward Murphy v City of New York		7783	2006 NY Slip Op 00986
National Union Fire Insurance Co. v Ferrell & Myers, Inc.		7784	2006 NY Slip Op 00987
People v Anonymous		7786	2006 NY Slip Op 00988
People v William Hazel		7788	2006 NY Slip Op 00989
William Lopez v Bovis Lend Lease LMB, Inc.		7791	2006 NY Slip Op 00990
Matter of Eagle Insurance Company v Elhadji Gueye		7793	2006 NY Slip Op 00991

**Cases Decided February 2, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Julius P.		7486	2006 NY Slip Op 00675
Nicholas D. Raptis v Juda Construction, Ltd.		7538	2006 NY Slip Op 00676
Makhan Dhillon v Bryant Associates		7572	2006 NY Slip Op 00677
John Adams v Edwin Heath		7575	2006 NY Slip Op 00678
People v James White		7722	2006 NY Slip Op 00679
Gilbert Ortiz v Board of Education of City of New York		7723	2006 NY Slip Op 00680
People v Silas Mitchell		7724	2006 NY Slip Op 00681
Philip Terman v Minodora Gonta		7725	2006 NY Slip Op 00682
William Capital Associates, Inc. v River Square Realty Corp.		7726	2006 NY Slip Op 00683
Roberta Friedman v Starwood Hotels & Resorts World Wide, Inc.		7727	2006 NY Slip Op 00684
People v Alexander Warner		7728	2006 NY Slip Op 00685
Jannae Chatham v City of New York		7729	2006 NY Slip Op 00686
Matter of Judith Nole v New York City Department of Housing Preservation and Development		7730	2006 NY Slip Op 00687
People v Richard Guerrero		7734	2006 NY Slip Op 00688
Georgio Favia v Weatherby Construction Corp.		7735	2006 NY Slip Op 00689
Matter of Kianna Maria L. v Maria Daphne M.		7737	2006 NY Slip Op 00690
Joanne Pattavina v Christine DiLorenzo		7738	2006 NY Slip Op 00691
People v Christian Quinones		7740	2006 NY Slip Op 00692
People v Christian Quinones		7741	2006 NY Slip Op 00693
Matter of Shady Gandhi Shameseldin I. v Amina Mokhtar I.S.		7743	2006 NY Slip Op 00694
Matter of Robert Hawkins v New York City Transit Authority		7746	2006 NY Slip Op 00695
People v Cesar Lebron		7748	2006 NY Slip Op 00696
Matter of Michael Cipolla v Raymond W. Kelly		7750	2006 NY Slip Op 00697
People v Curtis West		7752	2006 NY Slip Op 00698
Matter of Arunkumar Patel v New York City Housing Authority		7753	2006 NY Slip Op 00699
Matter of Robert T. Johnson v Richard Lee Price	Saxe	7222	2006 NY Slip Op 00700