Appellate Division, First Department Decisions

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

**Cases Decided May 30, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Winston W.		7115	2006 NY Slip Op 04173
People v James Harte		7271	2006 NY Slip Op 04174
Blaylock & Partners, L.P. v 609 Fifth Ave Partners L.L.C.		6991	2006 NY Slip Op 04175
Matter of Marc Brown v Bernard Kerik		6992	2006 NY Slip Op 04176
Linda A. Stark v Molod Spitz DeSantis & Stark, P.C.		7109	2006 NY Slip Op 04177
Najmuddin Pervez v Beth Israel Medical Center		8012N	2006 NY Slip Op 04178
Willis Re Inc. v Simon M. Hudson		8461	2006 NY Slip Op 04179
People v Eduardo Hansen		8594	2006 NY Slip Op 04180
People v Jose Cepeda		8625	2006 NY Slip Op 04181
People v Jose Serrano		8627	2006 NY Slip Op 04182
Matter of Timothy L.		8628	2006 NY Slip Op 04183
Candida Peralta v American Telephone and Telegraph Company		8630	2006 NY Slip Op 04184
Mezzacappa Bros., Inc. v City of New York		8631	2006 NY Slip Op 04185
Zanett Lombardier, Ltd. v Marvin Maslow		8633	2006 NY Slip Op 04186
Jesus Mercado v New York University		8635	2006 NY Slip Op 04187
Matter of 2960 Tavern Inc. v New York State Liquor Authority		8636	2006 NY Slip Op 04188
Nancy Giandana v Providence Rest Nursing Home	Mazzarelli	6896	2006 NY Slip Op 04189
Develop Don't Destroy Brooklyn v Empire State Development Corporation	Williams	8261	2006 NY Slip Op 04190
Matter of Morton S. Robson	Per Curiam	M-2661	2006 NY Slip Op 04191

**Cases Decided May 25, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Segundo Bolanos v City of New York		6939	2006 NY Slip Op 04151
Helene-Harrison Corp. v Moneyline Network, Inc.		7023	2006 NY Slip Op 04152
People v Shameek Harrison		8612	2006 NY Slip Op 04153
People v Sean White		8619	2006 NY Slip Op 04154
Lazar Gazivoda v Heath Sherman		8620	2006 NY Slip Op 04155
R.P.I. Services, Inc. v Jason Eisenberg		8621	2006 NY Slip Op 04156
Matter of Courtney G.		8622	2006 NY Slip Op 04157
Meir Markovitz v Susan Diamond Markovitz		8624N	2006 NY Slip Op 04158
Matter of Richard K. Lahm v Michael R. Bloomberg		7135	2006 NY Slip Op 04159
Hotel 57 LLC v Harvard Maintenance, Inc.		7288	2006 NY Slip Op 04160
Matter of Mayne Pharma (USA) Inc. v Enzon Pharmaceuticals, Inc.		7440N	2006 NY Slip Op 04161
People v Cedric Reid		7594	2006 NY Slip Op 04162
LaSalle Hotel Lessee, Inc. v Marriott Hotel Services, Inc.		7670	2006 NY Slip Op 04163
Atsco Ltd. v Haryati Zainudin Swanson		7971	2006 NY Slip Op 04164
People v Ray Santiago		8600	2006 NY Slip Op 04165
Matter of Imani J. v Monique J.		8602	2006 NY Slip Op 04166
Centaur Properties, LLC v Robert Farahdian		8603	2006 NY Slip Op 04167
People v Reggie Rogers		8604	2006 NY Slip Op 04168
Evelyn Frank v Eddie McCutcheon		8606	2006 NY Slip Op 04169
Matter of Shi Yi Tang v New York City Department of Housing Preservation and Development		8608	2006 NY Slip Op 04170
Kristen Mahan v Christopher Mahan		8611N	2006 NY Slip Op 04171
Matter of C/S 12th Avenue LLC v City of New York	Malone	7926	2006 NY Slip Op 04172

**Cases Decided May 23, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Hector Ramos v HSBC Bank		8339	2006 NY Slip Op 03996
Jeffrey R. Fazio v Main Duane Owners Corp.		8490	2006 NY Slip Op 03997
Jon Rubensccastro v Stephanie Alfaro		8144	2006 NY Slip Op 03998
Kendalle Pope v Alix Saget		8150	2006 NY Slip Op 03999
People v Leroy Brown		8570	2006 NY Slip Op 04000
Matter of James Neville v Marie Therese Martin		8571	2006 NY Slip Op 04001
Aurora Sportswear Group Ltd. v George Eng		8572	2006 NY Slip Op 04002
People v William Doggett		8573	2006 NY Slip Op 04003
Wayne Brown v City of New York		8574	2006 NY Slip Op 04004
David M.A. Elias v Lord Nathaniel Charles Jacob Rothschild		8575	2006 NY Slip Op 04005
People v Dwight Gray		8578	2006 NY Slip Op 04006
Yun-Shou Gao v City of New York		8580	2006 NY Slip Op 04007
Jay Nussbaum v Joseph D'Amico		8582N	2006 NY Slip Op 04008
People v Phillip Taylor		8583	2006 NY Slip Op 04009
Matter of Durrell G.		8586	2006 NY Slip Op 04010
People v Debra Morales		8587	2006 NY Slip Op 04011
People v Eric Salas		8588	2006 NY Slip Op 04012
Cara Campisi v Bronx Water & Sewer Service, Inc.		8589	2006 NY Slip Op 04013
Kabine Berete v Ford Motor Credit Company		8590	2006 NY Slip Op 04014
People v Justice Brunson		8592	2006 NY Slip Op 04015
Mary Lou Pendill v Furry Paws, Inc.		8593	2006 NY Slip Op 04016
Matter of Vincent P.			2006 NY Slip Op 04017
242-44 East 77th Street, LLC v Greater New York Mutual Insurance Company	Sullivan	7685	2006 NY Slip Op 04018
Matter of Fredric Zarkin	Per Curiam	M-1598	2006 NY Slip Op 04019

**Cases Decided May 18, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Parker & Waichman v Paul J. Napoli		6893	2006 NY Slip Op 03967
People v Justo Gonzalez		8537	2006 NY Slip Op 03968
People v Shamar Jackson		8540	2006 NY Slip Op 03969
Hector DeJesus v City of New York		8546	2006 NY Slip Op 03970
Mary Grace Marden v Maurice Villency, Inc.		8547	2006 NY Slip Op 03971
Delidakis Construction Co., Inc. v City of New York		8548	2006 NY Slip Op 03972
People v Troy Jackson		8549	2006 NY Slip Op 03973
Matter of Anthony M. v Carmelo M.		8551	2006 NY Slip Op 03974
People v Steven Rojas		8552	2006 NY Slip Op 03975
Min Yoon v Sara Costello		8553	2006 NY Slip Op 03976
Michael Ring v Anabil USA, Inc.		8554	2006 NY Slip Op 03977
Matter of National Bank Limited v Security Management Company, Ltd.		8555N	2006 NY Slip Op 03978
People v Edward Jackson		6782	2006 NY Slip Op 03979
Domingo Rivera v Joremi Enterprises Inc.		6913	2006 NY Slip Op 03980
Donald R. Bray v Ruben Rosas		7822	2006 NY Slip Op 03981
William Kaferstein v J.P. Morgan Chase & Co.		8152	2006 NY Slip Op 03982
Maria Pilar Bustos v Lenox Hill Hospital		8194	2006 NY Slip Op 03983
People v Hector Nobles		8384	2006 NY Slip Op 03984
People v Antonio Rosado		8556	2006 NY Slip Op 03985
People v Martin Judd		8557	2006 NY Slip Op 03986
Lynis M. Anderson v Shimella "Star" Abodeen		8558	2006 NY Slip Op 03987
Matter of John Ullah v Raymond Kelly		8559	2006 NY Slip Op 03988
People v Charles Holloman		8562	2006 NY Slip Op 03989
Douglas P. Smith v Hines GS Properties, Inc.		8563	2006 NY Slip Op 03990
People v Mark Collins		8565	2006 NY Slip Op 03991
Martin Guiry v Goldman, Sachs & Co.	Friedman	6341	2006 NY Slip Op 03992

**Cases Decided May 16, 2006**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Cecelia Mogilansky v 250 Broadway Associates Corp.	7248	2006 NY Slip Op 03802
American Manufacturers Mutual Insurance Company v IDI Construction, Inc.	8134	2006 NY Slip Op 03803
Matter of Luis O.	7841	2006 NY Slip Op 03804
Henrietta DeCesare v Dr. Susan Kaminski	8411	2006 NY Slip Op 03805
People v James Chiddick	8503	2006 NY Slip Op 03806
Philip Wedgwood Wallace v Merrill Lynch Capital Services, Inc.	8504	2006 NY Slip Op 03807
People v Malik Akili	8507	2006 NY Slip Op 03808
NNA Restaurant Management LLC v Mahrokh Eshaghian	8508	2006 NY Slip Op 03809
People v Ivan Jones	8512	2006 NY Slip Op 03810
People v Young Min Kwak	8514	2006 NY Slip Op 03811
Matter of Jonathan C.	8517	2006 NY Slip Op 03812
Rakesh Ahuja v Ian Schrager Hotels, Inc.	8518N	2006 NY Slip Op 03813
People v Reginald Harris	8519	2006 NY Slip Op 03814
Beal Savings Bank v Viola Sommer	8520	2006 NY Slip Op 03815
People v Carl Wiggins	8521	2006 NY Slip Op 03816
People v Frank Barnes	8525	2006 NY Slip Op 03817
Alfred Pappalardi v Walter Jones	8526	2006 NY Slip Op 03818
Matter of Durand G.	8529	2006 NY Slip Op 03819
People v Stephan McConnell	8530	2006 NY Slip Op 03820
Gryphon Domestic VI, LLC v GBR Information Services, Inc.	8531	2006 NY Slip Op 03821
U.S. Bank National Association v APP International Finance Company, B.V.	8533	2006 NY Slip Op 03822
Barbara W. Hearst v John Randolph Hearst	8535N	2006 NY Slip Op 03823
Moody T. Moody v New York City Health and Hospitals Corporation	8536N	2006 NY Slip Op 03824

**Cases Decided May 11, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Maribel Flores v City of New York		8366	2006 NY Slip Op 03684
People v Jose Reyes		8485	2006 NY Slip Op 03685
People v Marvin Bristol		8487	2006 NY Slip Op 03686
Teddy Smith v 21 West LLC Limited Liability Company		8488	2006 NY Slip Op 03687
Frank Manning v City of New York		8492	2006 NY Slip Op 03688
People v Alfonso Washington		8493	2006 NY Slip Op 03689
Elliot Utrecht v 142 East 49th Street Owners Corp.		8494	2006 NY Slip Op 03690
Citicorp USA, Inc. v PM Holdings, LLC		8495	2006 NY Slip Op 03691
People v Kellen Adams		8496	2006 NY Slip Op 03692
Matter of Richard E. Malone v New York City Commission on Human Rights		8497	2006 NY Slip Op 03693
Dovin Construction, Inc. v C. Raimondo & Sons Construction Co., Inc.		8498	2006 NY Slip Op 03694
People v Willie Cochran		8499	2006 NY Slip Op 03695
324 East 9th Street Corporation v Acordia Northeast-New York		8500N	2006 NY Slip Op 03696
Courtney St. Clement v Gerald Casale		7165	2006 NY Slip Op 03697
William Gonzalez v New York City Health and Hospitals Corporation		7345	2006 NY Slip Op 03698
People v Tony Anderson		7625	2006 NY Slip Op 03699
Eric Mitchell v City of New York		8406	2006 NY Slip Op 03700
Matter of Joel A. Silberman	Per Curiam	M-5268	2006 NY Slip Op 03701

**Cases Decided May 9, 2006**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Juan Rivera v Christopher Benaroti	8447	2006 NY Slip Op 03625
Kenneth Carter v Full Service, Inc.	6380	2006 NY Slip Op 03626
Cecelia Abraham v Port Authority of New York and New Jersey	7973	2006 NY Slip Op 03627
Matter of Timothy Glass v Wendy Glass	8058N	2006 NY Slip Op 03628
People v Juan Mena	8287	2006 NY Slip Op 03629
Melissa Cohn v Seth Paprin	8323	2006 NY Slip Op 03630
Matter of Aparicio Rodrigo B.	8471	2006 NY Slip Op 03631
People v Maia Peisahkman	8472	2006 NY Slip Op 03632
Matter of Leopold Siao-Pao v New York State Board of Parole	8475	2006 NY Slip Op 03633
People v Rafael Brazoban	8480	2006 NY Slip Op 03634
People v Robert Sanders	8482	2006 NY Slip Op 03635
OPM Group Ltd. v Alejandro Williams	8483N	2006 NY Slip Op 03636
Mark Rakauskas v Grace Olivia, LLC	8484N	2006 NY Slip Op 03637

**Cases Decided May 4, 2006**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Andrew R.		8035	2006 NY Slip Op 03499
Terrick Waiters v Northern Trust Company of New York		8081	2006 NY Slip Op 03500
People v Benny Garcia		6636	2006 NY Slip Op 03501
People v Billroy Jackson		7234	2006 NY Slip Op 03502
People v Johnny White		7800	2006 NY Slip Op 03503
Anthony Petito v City of New York		8203	2006 NY Slip Op 03504
People v Adam Oliveri		8450	2006 NY Slip Op 03505
Matter of 425 3rd Avenue Realty Co. v New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal		8452	2006 NY Slip Op 03506
People v Tyrone Abraham		8455	2006 NY Slip Op 03507
Matter of Stephanie S.		8456	2006 NY Slip Op 03508
Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's, London v U.S. Adjustment Corp.		8457	2006 NY Slip Op 03509
People v David Rodriguez		8459	2006 NY Slip Op 03510
People v Asain Abreu		8460	2006 NY Slip Op 03511
Sybil Shainwald v Kenneth R. Barasch		8465	2006 NY Slip Op 03512
Dorota Linette v Hanover Insurance Company		8467	2006 NY Slip Op 03513
John Hubbard v Jonathan Kamen		8468	2006 NY Slip Op 03514
Rafael Diaz v Ford Motor Company		8469N	2006 NY Slip Op 03515
Matter of Charles C. Day	Per Curiam	M-6062	2006 NY Slip Op 03516

**Cases Decided May 2, 2006**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Winifred Coulton v City of New York	7642	2006 NY Slip Op 03446
Arlene Kesselman v Lever House Restaurant	8212	2006 NY Slip Op 03447
Pablo Seda v Port Authority of New York and New Jersey	8432	2006 NY Slip Op 03448
People v Davon Knight	8436	2006 NY Slip Op 03449
People v Michael Leifman	8437	2006 NY Slip Op 03450
People v Orlando Rodriguez	8438	2006 NY Slip Op 03451
People v Victor Quintana	8441	2006 NY Slip Op 03452
People v Rudy Sanchez	8442	2006 NY Slip Op 03453
People v Ernest Vaughn	8443	2006 NY Slip Op 03454
Matter of Rosemary R.	8445	2006 NY Slip Op 03455
Sarit Shmueli v Corcoran Group	8446	2006 NY Slip Op 03456
People v Rodney Snyder	7932	2006 NY Slip Op 03457
Jose Ramirez v Mark Miller	8171	2006 NY Slip Op 03458
People v Edward Hull	8418	2006 NY Slip Op 03459
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v United States Fidelity and Guaranty Company	8419	2006 NY Slip Op 03460
Matter of Courtney S.	8420	2006 NY Slip Op 03461
People v Khalil Curtis	8422	2006 NY Slip Op 03462
People v Shamod Murray	8423	2006 NY Slip Op 03463
People v David Santiago	8424	2006 NY Slip Op 03464
Matter of Solid Waste Services, Inc. v New York City Department of Environmental Protection	8426	2006 NY Slip Op 03465
Sal Jenkins v New York City Housing Authority	8430N	2006 NY Slip Op 03466
Charles Mayerhofer v Turner Construction Company	8431N	2006 NY Slip Op 03467