Appellate Division, First Department Decisions

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

**Cases Decided April 29, 2021**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of 400 E57 Fee Owner LLC v 405 E. 56th St. LLC	Index No. 155009/20 Appeal No. 13701 Case No. 2020-04261	2021 NY Slip Op 02587
ZDG LLC v 310 Group LLC	Index No. 656537/16 Appeal No. 13715-13715A Case No. 2019-03798	2021 NY Slip Op 02622
WDF Inc. v Harleysville Ins. Co. of N.Y.	Index No. 653108/17 Appeal No. 13714 Case No. 2020-02195	2021 NY Slip Op 02621
Matter of Tutor Perini Corp. v City of N.Y. Off. of Admin. Trials & Hearings Contract Dispute Resolution Bd.	Index No. 161175/19 Appeal No. 13700 Case No. 2020-04612	2021 NY Slip Op 02620
Torres v Triborough Bridge & Tunnel Auth.	Index No. 154199/16 Appeal No. 13710 Case No. 2020-04905	2021 NY Slip Op 02619
Sowa v Zabar	Index No. 152161/16 Appeal No. 13716 Case No. 2020-03954	2021 NY Slip Op 02618
Saiti v 316 E. 68th St. Corp.	Index No. 654127/19 Appeal No. 13694 Case No. 2020-03650	2021 NY Slip Op 02617
Matter of People v Orbital Publ. Group, Inc.	Index No. 451187/15 Appeal No. 13719 Case No. 2020-03013	2021 NY Slip Op 02616
People v Merritt	Ind No. 208/15 Appeal No. 13686 Case No. 2016-2044	2021 NY Slip Op 02615
People v Elliot	Ind No. 5605/13 Appeal No. 13697 Case No. 2018-5319	2021 NY Slip Op 02614
People v Cortes	Ind No. 231/14 Appeal No. 13704 Case No. 2019-4539	2021 NY Slip Op 02613
People v Robles	Ind No. 2423/17 Appeal No. 13690 Case No. 2019-1659	2021 NY Slip Op 02612
People v Smallwood	Ind No. 3/17 Appeal No. 13693 Case No. 2019-1708	2021 NY Slip Op 02611
People v Rosario	Ind No. 3705/12 Appeal No. 13717 Case No. 2013-02486	2021 NY Slip Op 02610
People v Rodney	Ind No. 1370/15 Appeal No. 13711 Case No. 2019-627	2021 NY Slip Op 02609
Matter of Mulgrew v Board of Educ. of the City Sch. Dist. of the City of N.Y.	Index No. 100347/19 Appeal No. 13705 Case No. 2020-03178	2021 NY Slip Op 02608
Mintz Fraade Law Firm, P.C. v Federal Ins. Co.	Index No. 651330/19 Appeal No. 13703N Case No. 2020-00772	2021 NY Slip Op 02607
Matter of Charles N.N. v Jaclyn A.M.	Docket No. V-17145/16-17D, V-17554/16-17D, V-17554/16-17E, V-17146/16-17D, V-17553/16-17E, V-17553/16-17D Appeal No. 13713 Case No. 2020-01441	2021 NY Slip Op 02606
Ping Lin v 100 Wall St. Prop. L.L.C.	Index No. 160605/15 Appeal No. 12911 Case No. 2020-03188	2021 NY Slip Op 02605
Matter of Lerner v Credit Suisse Sec. (USA) LLC	Index No. 652771/19, 657268/19 Appeal No. 13721-13722 Case No. 2020-03381, 2020-05002N	2021 NY Slip Op 02604
Kopolovitch v 200 Water SPE LLC	Index No. 101493/12 Appeal No. 13708 Case No. 2019-04742	2021 NY Slip Op 02603
Matter of Iorfida v Department of Educ. of the City of N.Y.	Index No. 650650/19 Appeal No. 13718 Case No. 2020-2855	2021 NY Slip Op 02602
Henriquez-Rodriguez v 160 W. 118th St. Corp.	Index No. 23380/14 Appeal No. 13689-13689A Case No. 2019-5774, 2019-01683	2021 NY Slip Op 02601
Gendell v 42 W.17th St. Hous. Corp.	Index No. 158100/15 Appeal No. 13712 Case No. 2020-04265	2021 NY Slip Op 02600
Matter of Gaston v New York City Dept. of Hous. Preserv. & Dev.	Index No. 155643/19 Appeal No. 13687 Case No. 2020-02240	2021 NY Slip Op 02599
Fritz v JLG Indus., Inc.	Index No. 309338/10, 303483/11, 84098/11 Appeal No. 13695-13695A Case No. 2020-02546	2021 NY Slip Op 02598
Diaz v HHC TS Reit LLC	Index No. 300530/13 Appeal No. 13699 Case No. 2020-03363	2021 NY Slip Op 02597
Cruz v Metropolitan Tr. Auth.	Index No. 157923/13 Appeal No. 13696 Case No. 2020-03487	2021 NY Slip Op 02596
Chester County Empls. Retirement Fund v Alnylam Pharms., Inc.	Index No. 655272/19 Appeal No. 13702 Case No. 2020-04534	2021 NY Slip Op 02595
Canzoneri v City of New York	Index No. 114128/09 Appeal No. 13720 Case No. 2020-01127	2021 NY Slip Op 02594
Matter of Edward C. v Latoya P.	Index No. V-2720-14/18B, V-14346-14/18B Appeal No. 13688 Case No. 2020-02879	2021 NY Slip Op 02593
Matter of Bank of N.Y. (Blumenkrantz)	File No. 212P 1961/B/C Appeal No. 13692 Case No. 2020-04459	2021 NY Slip Op 02592
Baltic Fourth LLC v Stern	Index No. 654881/18 Appeal No. 13291 Case No. 2019-04889	2021 NY Slip Op 02591
APS Contrs., Inc. v New York City Hous. Auth.	Index No. 652476/18 Appeal No. 13698 Case No. 2020-02445	2021 NY Slip Op 02590
AmBase Corp. v 111 W. 57th Sponsor LLC	Index No. 652301/16 Appeal No. 13691 Case No. 2018-1166	2021 NY Slip Op 02589
Matter of Al Saud v New York & Presbyt. Hosp.	Index No. 155151/17 Appeal No. 13706 Case No. 2020-03150	2021 NY Slip Op 02588

**Cases Decided April 27, 2021**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
American States Ins. Co. v Graphic Arts Mut. Ins. Co.		Index No. 651372/18 Appeal No. 13682 Case No. 2020-03347	2021 NY Slip Op 02485
Villar v New York City Hous. Auth.		Index No. 22235/15E Appeal No. 13667 Case No. 2020-03555	2021 NY Slip Op 02505
Sage Sys., Inc. v Liss		Index No. 650745/10 Appeal No. 13670-13670A Case No. 2020-02671 2020-03659	2021 NY Slip Op 02504
People v Green		SCI No. 820/17 Appeal No. 13671 Case No. 2018-5542	2021 NY Slip Op 02503
People v Aleman		Ind No. 2331/16 Appeal No. 13666 Case No. 2019-796	2021 NY Slip Op 02502
People v Douglas		Ind No. 4465/15 Appeal No. 13681 Case No. 2018-1894	2021 NY Slip Op 02501
People v Richard		Ind No. 925/16 Appeal No. 13677 Case No. 2019-5664	2021 NY Slip Op 02500
Napoli Shkolnik, PLLC v Greenwich Ins. Co.		Index No. 657246/19 Appeal No. 13684 Case No. 2020-04201	2021 NY Slip Op 02499
Matter of Silverman	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2021-00448 Case No. 2021-00490	2021 NY Slip Op 02498
Matter of Schneiderman	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2021-00665 Case No. 2020-03638	2021 NY Slip Op 02497
TGT, LLC v Advance Entertainment, LLC		Index No. 650633/17 151712/17 654948/18 Appeal No. 13672 Case No. 2020-01723 2020-01724 2020-01725	2021 NY Slip Op 02496
Jane Doe v Turnmill LLC		Index No. 152037/16 Appeal No. 13114 Case No. 2020-02604	2021 NY Slip Op 02495
Gumbs v MTA Bus Co.		Index No. 28330/19E Appeal No. 13685N-13685NA Case No. 2020-02237 2020-04026	2021 NY Slip Op 02494
Granite State Ins. Co. v Moklam Enters., Inc.		Index No. .158092/18 158113/18 Appeal No. 13673-13674 Case No. 2020-03274 2020-02785	2021 NY Slip Op 02493
Ginarte Gallardo Gonzalez & Winograd v Schwitzer		Index No. 159991/18 Appeal No. 13679-13680 Case No. 2019-05381 2019-05501 2020-04666	2021 NY Slip Op 02492
Galicia v Trump		Index No. 24973/15E Appeal No. 11218N Case No. 2019-03894	2021 NY Slip Op 02491
Matter of Mory F. v Hawa K.F.		Index No. V12944/18 V12945/18 Appeal No. 13676 Case No. 2020-00755	2021 NY Slip Op 02490
Matter of David H. Berg & Assoc. v Weksler		Index No. 157028/19 Appeal No. 13678 Case No. 2020-04219	2021 NY Slip Op 02489
Damon G. Douglas Co. v Mt. Hawley Ins. Co.		Index No. 655491/18 Appeal No. 13669 Case No. 2020-00609	2021 NY Slip Op 02488
CWCapital Cobalt VR Ltd. v CWCapital Invs. LLC	MAZZARELLI, J.	Index No. 653277/18 Appeal No. 12895 Case No. 2019-03826	2021 NY Slip Op 02487
Matter of Jaylina B. (Clayton N.)		Docket No. NA-40520/15 NA-40521/15 Appeal No. 13668 Case No. 2020-01300	2021 NY Slip Op 02486

**Cases Decided April 22, 2021**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Gottwald v Sebert	Index No. 653118/14 Appeal No. 12716-12716A Case No. 2020-01908, 2020-01910	2021 NY Slip Op 02456
YRN LLC v Migos LLC	Index No. 652265/18 Appeal No. 13633 Case No. 2020-02934	2021 NY Slip Op 02482
Young-Borra v New York & Presbyt. Hosp.	Index No. 162626/15 Appeal No. 13632 Case No. 2020-03576	2021 NY Slip Op 02481
U.S. Bank N.A. v Abu	Index No. 32349/17E Appeal No. 13643N Case No. 2020-01249	2021 NY Slip Op 02480
Berkshire Hathaway Specialty Ins. Co. v H.I.G. Capital, LLC	Index No. 652750/17 Appeal No. 13644N Case No. 2020-02854	2021 NY Slip Op 02479
Salodkaya v City of New York	Index No. 450862/18 Appeal No. 13658-13658A Case No. 2020-02587, 2020-03743	2021 NY Slip Op 02478
Rodriguez v City of New York	Index No. 28675/18 Appeal No. 13662 Case No. 2019-5301	2021 NY Slip Op 02477
Matter of Krystal N. (Juan R.)	Docket No. NA-12901/16, NA-12902/16 Appeal No. 13647 Case No. 2020-00684	2021 NY Slip Op 02476
Prinkipas LLC v Charlton Tenants Corp.	Index No. 653598/19 Appeal No. 13664N Case No. 2020-03412	2021 NY Slip Op 02475
People v Johnson	Ind No. 3579/17 Appeal No. 13655 Case No. 2019-01920	2021 NY Slip Op 02474
People v Sime-Torres	Ind No. 682/16 Appeal No. 13631 Case No. 2018-2008	2021 NY Slip Op 02473
People v Taylor	Ind No. 5051/16 Appeal No. 13626 Case No. 2019-03621	2021 NY Slip Op 02472
People v Casey	Ind No. 3373/17 Appeal No. 13645 Case No. 2019-4499	2021 NY Slip Op 02471
People v Bencosme	Ind No. 242/18 Appeal No. 13636 Case No. 2019-2361	2021 NY Slip Op 02470
People v Summa	Ind Nos. 0464/16, 2630/16 Appeal No. 13650 Case No. 2019-657	2021 NY Slip Op 02469
People v Fulmer-Salvador	Ind No. 580/13 Appeal No. 13660 Case No. 2018-4460	2021 NY Slip Op 02468
People v Wilson	Ind No. 321/12 Appeal No. 13639 Case No. 2014-1801	2021 NY Slip Op 02467
Old Republic Gen. Ins. Corp. v Consolidated Edison Co. of N.Y. Inc.	Index No. 651910/17 Appeal No. 13659 Case No. 2020-02489	2021 NY Slip Op 02466
Lopez v City of New York	Index No. 450039/15 Appeal No. 13638 Case No. 2020-03422	2021 NY Slip Op 02465
Liparulo v New York City Health & Hosps. Corp.	Index No. 22539/15E Appeal No. 13665N Case No. 2020-02330N	2021 NY Slip Op 02464
Lindenwood Vil., Section C, Coop. Corp. v Denenberg	Index No. 160882/19 Appeal No. 13637 Case No. 2021-00099	2021 NY Slip Op 02463
Leasing Control Inc. v 500 Fifth Ave., Inc.	Index No. 650797/13, 150676/16 Appeal No. 13640-13640A Case No. 2020-00348, 2020-00500	2021 NY Slip Op 02462
Matter of Karim v Raju	Index No. 100720/14 Appeal No. 13657 Case No. 2020-03078	2021 NY Slip Op 02461
Doe v Bronx Preparatory Charter Sch.	Index No. 306670/14 Appeal No. 13656 Case No. 2020-04869	2021 NY Slip Op 02460
Isa Realty Group, LLC v Lamar Adv. Co.	Index No. 652724/18 Appeal No. 13661 Case No. 2020-03740	2021 NY Slip Op 02459
Matter of Hook v Snyder.	V-21829-18/19C Docket No. V-21829-18/19C Appeal No. 13628 Case No. 2019-05565	2021 NY Slip Op 02458
Hammond v Equinox Holdings LLC	Index No. 155061/19 Appeal No. 13649 Case No. 2020-04381	2021 NY Slip Op 02457
Matter of 191 Realty Assoc., L.P. v Tejeda	Index No. 570227/19 Appeal No. 13654 Case No. 2020-01891	2021 NY Slip Op 02445
Matter of Global Liberty Ins. Co. v Cambridge Med., P.C.	Index No. 30920/17E Appeal No. 13630 Case No. 2019-04393	2021 NY Slip Op 02455
Gambacorta v Giordano	Index No. 805368/14 Appeal No. 13635 Case No. 2020-02848	2021 NY Slip Op 02454
Ferraro v McGovern	Index No. 156232/16 Appeal No. 13627 Case No. 2020-00657	2021 NY Slip Op 02453
Feinberg v Marathon Patent Group Inc.	Index No. 651463/18 Appeal No. 13651-13651A Case No. 2020-04269, 2020-04270	2021 NY Slip Op 02452
Estrella v East Tremont Med. Ctr.	Index No. 28030/18E Appeal No. 13634 Case No. 2020-03688	2021 NY Slip Op 02451
Elkaim v Lotte N.Y. Palace Hotel	Index No. 150124/17 Appeal No. 13648 Case No. 2020-02991	2021 NY Slip Op 02450
Draughn v Roker	Index No. 152934/18 Appeal No. 13641 Case No. 2020-02336	2021 NY Slip Op 02449
Conway v Kaplan	Index No. 160607/16 Appeal No. 13642-13642A Case No. 2020-02964, 2020-03154	2021 NY Slip Op 02448
Chen v Lockett	Index No. 156947/19 Appeal No. 13652 Case No. 2020-01864	2021 NY Slip Op 02447
Batlle v NY Devs. & Mgt., Inc.	Index No. 25992/16E, 43030/17E Appeal No. 13629-13629A Case No. 2019-05097, 2020-02190	2021 NY Slip Op 02446

**Cases Decided April 20, 2021**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Sarah B. v Aubrey S.		Docket No. V-22344/17 V-33610-17 Appeal No. 13707 Case No. 2020-01002	2021 NY Slip Op 02353
Vega v City of New York		Index No. 114966/09 Appeal No. 13623 Case No. 2020-02532	2021 NY Slip Op 02375
Tawiah v McNiff		Index No. 22591/20E Appeal No. 13625 Case No. 2020-04172	2021 NY Slip Op 02374
Matter of New York City Asbestos Litig.		Index No. 190446/14 Appeal No. 13620 Case No. 2020-03234	2021 NY Slip Op 02373
Salamone v EIP Global Fund LLC		Index No. 650374/20 Appeal No. 13617 Case No. 2020/04266	2021 NY Slip Op 02372
People v Rivera		Ind No. 2003/15 Appeal No. 13605 Case No. 2017-1170	2021 NY Slip Op 02371
People v Young		Ind No. 150/18 Appeal No. 13709 Case No. 2020-00687	2021 NY Slip Op 02370
People v Hennegan		Ind No. 2795/17 Appeal No. 13610 Case No. 2019-1990	2021 NY Slip Op 02369
People v Capalies		Ind No. 3243/16 Appeal No. 13615 Case No. 2018-2561	2021 NY Slip Op 02368
People v Rodriguez		Ind No. 346/17 Appeal No. 13621 Case No. 2019-4520	2021 NY Slip Op 02367
People v Dray		Ind No. 4144/17 Appeal No. 13383-13383A-[M-1002] Case No. 2019-3531 2020-03254	2021 NY Slip Op 02366
Mah v 40-44 W. 120th St. Assoc., LLC		Index No. 650927/16 Appeal No. 13611 Case No. 2020-02744	2021 NY Slip Op 02365
Liddle & Robinson, L.L.P. v Willman		Index No. 654268/18 Appeal No. 13524N Case No. 2020-01866	2021 NY Slip Op 02364
Jimenez v Greyhound Lines, Inc.		Index No. 28467/18E Appeal No. 13613 Case No. 2020-00352	2021 NY Slip Op 02363
International Franchise Assn. v City of New York		Index No. 655987/18 Appeal No. 13616-13616A Case No. 2020-02013	2021 NY Slip Op 02362
Ideal Media US Inc. v Baron		Index No. 153127/18 Appeal No. 13712-13712A Case No. 2020-03447 2020-04578	2021 NY Slip Op 02361
Hettinger v Amchem Prods., Inc.		Index No. 190015/16 Appeal No. 13606 Case No. 2020-02476	2021 NY Slip Op 02360
Matter of Girandola v Shea		Index No. 161856/19 Appeal No. 13618 Case No. 2020-02998	2021 NY Slip Op 02359
Creque v New York City Health & Hosps. Corp.		Index No. 22957/16E Appeal No. 13414 Case No. 2020-02550	2021 NY Slip Op 02358
Chawdhury v 3511 Sys. Inc.		Index No. 251506/14 Appeal No. 13508 Case No. 2018-3408	2021 NY Slip Op 02357
Benn v Beacon Capital Partners, LLC		Index No. 162065/14, 595147/15, 595390/16, 595524/17 Appeal No. 13609 Case No. 2020-02821	2021 NY Slip Op 02356
Bankers Conseco Life Ins. Co. v Wilmington Trust, N.A.	Mazzarelli, J.	Index No. 652057/19 Appeal No. 13185 Case No. 2020-02386 2020-03521	2021 NY Slip Op 02355
Bankers Conseco Life Ins. Co. v Egan-Jones Ratings Co.		Index No. 654289/19 Appeal No. 13186-13186A Case No. 2020-02393	2021 NY Slip Op 02354

**Cases Decided April 15, 2021**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of BNB Bank v HealthFirst PHSP Inc.	Index No. 161416/19 Appeal No. 13592 Case No. 2020-02887	2021 NY Slip Op 02339
Zanani v Sutton Apts. Corp.	Index No. 650099/19 Appeal No. 13599-13599A&[M-3409] Case No. 2020-00367, 2020-00369	2021 NY Slip Op 02352
Yes Contr. Inc. v CLST Enters. LLC	Index No. 654078/15 Appeal No. 13603N Case No. 2020-03168	2021 NY Slip Op 02351
Squitieri v Kaufman	Index No. 350138/06 Appeal No. 13591 Case No. 2019-2767	2021 NY Slip Op 02350
Sitbon-Robson v Robson	Index No. 314195/14 Appeal No. 13604 Case No. 2019-04374	2021 NY Slip Op 02349
Rodriguez v 352-54 W. 48th St. Hous. Dev. Fund Corp.	Index No. 154543/13 Appeal No. 13593 Case No. 2020-02260	2021 NY Slip Op 02348
People v Johnson	Ind No. 4513/17 Appeal No. 13594 Case No. 2019-3862	2021 NY Slip Op 02347
People v Galloway	Ind No. 3486/14,1322/16 Appeal No. 13597-13597A Case No. 2017-2253	2021 NY Slip Op 02346
People v Then	Ind No. 2258/09 Appeal No. 13590 Case No. 2019-04230	2021 NY Slip Op 02345
Melohn v Melohn	Index No. 301969/17 Appeal No. 13602 Case No. 2019-04744	2021 NY Slip Op 02344
Gaulsh v Diefenbach PLLC	Index No. 654346/15 Appeal No. 13600-13600A Case No. 2020-02624	2021 NY Slip Op 02343
Gateway Overseas Inc. v Sumec Textile & Light Indus. Co., Ltd.	Index No. 652588/18 Appeal No. 13601-13601A Case No. 2020-03446, 2020-03464	2021 NY Slip Op 02342
Edelman Arts, Inc. v New York Art World, LLC	Index No. 652017/18 Appeal No. 13596 Case No. 2020-02896	2021 NY Slip Op 02341
Cresser v 345 Park Ave., L.P.	Index No. 110848/11 Appeal No. 13598 Case No. 2019-4652	2021 NY Slip Op 02340

**Cases Decided April 13, 2021**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Ader v Ader		Index No. 350006/20 Appeal No. 13561 Case No. 2020-04813	2021 NY Slip Op 02234
Matter of Bergassi Group LLC v Allied World Ins. Co.		Index No. 655704/19 Appeal No. 13569 Case No. 2020-01264	2021 NY Slip Op 02265
WVH Hous. Dev. Fund Corp. v Brooklyn Insulation & Soundproofing, Inc.		Index No. 651665/16 595183/20 Appeal No. 13580-13580A Case No. 2020-02847 2020-04832	2021 NY Slip Op 02264
Matter of Iscela G. (Lorenzo T.)		Docket No. NN-9077-80/18 NN-34833/18 Appeal No. 13560 Case No. 2019-04352	2021 NY Slip Op 02263
Simon v Moskowitz		Index No. 23060/15E Appeal No. 13584 Case No. 2020-02597	2021 NY Slip Op 02262
Riehm Corp. v Brennan		Index No. 21173/17E Appeal No. 13586-13586A Case No. 2020-02303 2020-05007	2021 NY Slip Op 02261
Poyodi v Go N.Y. Tours, Inc.		Index No. 30450/19E Appeal No. 13589N Case No. 2020-04737	2021 NY Slip Op 02260
Perez v Live Nation Worldwide, Inc.		Index No. 158373/13 Appeal No. 13579 Case No. 2020-03237	2021 NY Slip Op 02259
People v Lytch		Ind No. 1757/12 Appeal No. 13562 Case No. 2016-1367	2021 NY Slip Op 02258
People v Dalton		Ind No. 289/17 Appeal No. 13583 Case No. 2019-5493	2021 NY Slip Op 02257
People v Santiago		Ind No. 2944/16 Appeal No. 13573 Case No. 2019-3948	2021 NY Slip Op 02256
People v Fidelis		SCI No. 2849/17 Appeal No. 13578 Case No. 2019-2802	2021 NY Slip Op 02255
People v David A.		Ind No. 0164/19 Appeal No. 13564 Case No. 2019-03414	2021 NY Slip Op 02254
People v Rubiera		Ind No. 2610/17 Appeal No. 13558 Case No. 2019-1871	2021 NY Slip Op 02253
Matter of Part 60 RMBS Put - Back Litig.	GISCHE, J.	Index No. 777000/15 153945/13 595610/15 Appeal No. 13084 Case No. 2019-5932	2021 NY Slip Op 02252
Louise v Hampton Jitney, Inc.		Index No. 153839/16 Appeal No. 13588N Case No. 2020-01736	2021 NY Slip Op 02251
Linder v United Metro Energy Servs. Corp.		Index No. 153947/16 Appeal No. 13568 Case No. 2020-04457	2021 NY Slip Op 02250
Lewis v Hallen Constr. Co., Inc.		Index No. 151729/17 Appeal No. 13570-13571 Case No. 2020-01427 2020-01614 2020-01615	2021 NY Slip Op 02249
Matter of Anthony L. v Bernadette R.		Docket No. F-8291-06/12B F-8291-06/17D Appeal No. 13575-13575A Case No. 2020-01295 2020-01890	2021 NY Slip Op 02248
Hyman v Able & Ready Appliance Repair Corp.		Index No. 29889/18E Appeal No. 13577-13577A Case No. 2019-5752	2021 NY Slip Op 02247
Estate of Murphy v New York City Hous. Auth.		Index No. 158442/12 Appeal No. 13183 Case No. 2020-01722	2021 NY Slip Op 02246
Hershko v Troutman Sanders, LLP		Index No. 451878/16 Appeal No. 13559N Case No. 2020-00118	2021 NY Slip Op 02245
GCS Second Ave. Owner LLC v Merchants Hospitality Inc.		Index No. 652348/17 Appeal No. 13587 Case No. 2020-01892	2021 NY Slip Op 02244
Essex Cement Co., LLC v X-Treme Ready Mix, Inc.		Index No. 655507/18 Appeal No. 13574 Case No. 2020-02424	2021 NY Slip Op 02243
E. 103 St. & Lex. Ave. Realty Corp. v Moustache Inc.		Index No. 650423/18 Appeal No. 13572N Case No. 2020-02579	2021 NY Slip Op 02242
Davis v Port		Index No. 654027/13 Appeal No. 13585 Case No. 2020-3687	2021 NY Slip Op 02241
Darabont v AMC Network Entertainment LLC		Index No. 650251/18 Appeal No. 13565-13565A Case No. 2020-02984	2021 NY Slip Op 02240
Century City Mall, LLC v Waxman		Index No. 650251/18 Appeal No. 13566-13566A Case No. 2020-02039 2020-02040	2021 NY Slip Op 02239
Centre Lane Partners III, L.P. v Nature's Bounty Co.		Index No. 656486/18 Appeal No. 13582 Case No. 2020-02660	2021 NY Slip Op 02238
Carlyle Commodity Mgt., L.L.C. v Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's London Subscribing to Policy with Unique Mkt. Reference B0753PC1410840000		Index No. 651151/17 Appeal No. 13567 Case No. 2020-03383	2021 NY Slip Op 02237
Banks v Bogopa, Inc.		Index No. 23168/17E Appeal No. 13563 Case No. 2020-01943	2021 NY Slip Op 02236
Atsco Footwear Holdings, LLC v KBG, LLC		Index No. 654336/18 Appeal No. 13581 Case No. 2020-02290	2021 NY Slip Op 02235

**Cases Decided April 8, 2021**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Akel v Gerardi	Index No. 805364/15 Appeal No. 13554 Case No. 2019-04418	2021 NY Slip Op 02216
Youwanes v Steinbrech	Index No. 805038/17 Appeal No. 13544 Case No. 2020-01337	2021 NY Slip Op 02232
Vitamin Realty Assoc. LLC v Time Record Stor., LLC	Index No. 654417/19 Appeal No. 13555 Case No. 2020-03457	2021 NY Slip Op 02231
Matter of Donique T. v Administration for Children's Servs.	Docket No. L-21099/10 Appeal No. 13545 Case No. 2019-4558	2021 NY Slip Op 02230
Suttongate Holdings Ltd. v Laconm Mgt. N.V.	Index No. 652393/15, 595290/17 Appeal No. 13557N Case No. 2019-04034	2021 NY Slip Op 02229
St. Nicholas W. 126 L.P. v Republic Inv. Co., LLC	Index No. 156149/17 Appeal No. 13551N Case No. 2020-02306	2021 NY Slip Op 02228
Protostorm, Inc. v Foley & Lardner LLP	Index No. 158501/19 Appeal No. 11820&M-1389 Case No. 2020-01729	2021 NY Slip Op 02227
Phipps SC, LLC v SA SBS Myrtle Beach Managing Member, LLC	Index No. 653039/18 Appeal No. 12242-12243 Case No. 2020-02564, 2019-2413	2021 NY Slip Op 02226
People v Paskins	Ind No. 2940/17 4682/17 Appeal No. 13549 Case No. 2018-2535	2021 NY Slip Op 02225
People v Brice	Ind No. 2553/16 Appeal No. 13552 Case No. 2019-2365	2021 NY Slip Op 02224
People v Bayron	Ind No. 2682/11 Appeal No. 13543 Case No. 2021-00391	2021 NY Slip Op 02223
Matter of Jewish Press, Inc. v New York City Dept. of Hous. Preserv. & Dev.	Index No. 150695/20 Appeal No. 13541 Case No. 2020-04363	2021 NY Slip Op 02222
Matter of Jackson v New York City Dept. of Educ.	Index No. 657191/17 Appeal No. 13550 Case No. 2019-4739	2021 NY Slip Op 02221
Gibbons v Alicart Rest. Group	Index No. 162004/15 Appeal No. 13547 Case No. 2020-03273	2021 NY Slip Op 02220
Cordero v 1278 Mini Mkt. Inc.	Index No. 306551/11 Appeal No. 13553 Case No. 2020-04386	2021 NY Slip Op 02219
Bruderman Bros., LLC v Goldberg	Index No. 656979/19 Appeal No. 13546 Case No. 2020-04258	2021 NY Slip Op 02218
Ayangbesan v Finkelstein	Index No. 162328/15 Appeal No. 13556N Case No. 2020-03730	2021 NY Slip Op 02217

**Cases Decided April 6, 2021**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of 219 W. 81st Residential Holdings, LLC v New York State Div. of Hous. & Community Renewal		Index No. 161989/19 Appeal No. 13518 Case No. 2020-02478	2021 NY Slip Op 02091
Jinmei Yang v Shang Dai		Index No. 650268/20 Appeal No. 13513-13514-13515 Case No. 2020-03325 2020-03630 2020-03631 2020-03632	2021 NY Slip Op 02125
U.S. Bank Trust, N.A. v Boktor		Index No. 850251/17 Appeal No. 13315 Case No. 2020-02406	2021 NY Slip Op 02124
U.S. Bank Trust, N.A. v Stewart		Index No. 850292/17 Appeal No. 13542 Case No. 2020-03277	2021 NY Slip Op 02123
Swissgem S.A. v M&B Ltd.		Index No. 654225/19 Appeal No. 13538 Case No. 2020-02676	2021 NY Slip Op 02122
South Shore D'Lites, LLC v First Class Prods. Group, LLC		Index No. 650827/12 Appeal No. 12523 Case No. 2020-05003	2021 NY Slip Op 02121
Santapau v Brownstone Too Condo		Index No. 157680/14 Appeal No. 13529 Case No. 2020-03477	2021 NY Slip Op 02120
Matter of Melody S. (Maryeling S. -P.)		Docket No. NN-07839/18 Appeal No. 13828 Case No. 2019-2982	2021 NY Slip Op 02119
Real World Holdings, LLC v Clark		Index No. 655499/18 Appeal No. 13527 Case No. 2020-02846	2021 NY Slip Op 02118
People v Gardner		Ind No. 133/18 Appeal No. 13526 Case No. 2019-03759	2021 NY Slip Op 02117
People v Pilmar		Ind No. 2399/17 Appeal No. 13533 Case No. 2019-04805	2021 NY Slip Op 02116
People v Muhammad		Ind No. 1025/14 3355/15 Appeal No. 13516 Case No. 2018-04138	2021 NY Slip Op 02115
People v Watts		Ind No. 1563/13 Appeal No. 13519 Case No. 2018-1403	2021 NY Slip Op 02114
People v Ramirez		Ind No. 1700/17 Appeal No. 13536 Case No. 2019-1922	2021 NY Slip Op 02113
People v Chalen		Ind No. 1970/16 Appeal No. 13530 Case No. 2018-214	2021 NY Slip Op 02112
People v Frasqueri		SCI No. 2302/18 Appeal No. 13504 Case No. 2019-1964	2021 NY Slip Op 02111
Matter of Edwin P. v Jenny L.B.		Docket No. P-18506/18 Appeal No. 13508 Case No. 2019-5265	2021 NY Slip Op 02110
Matter of Friedberg	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2020-02112 2020-03461 Case No. 2018-00100	2021 NY Slip Op 02109
Matter of Jewish Press, Inc. v New York City Dept. of Investigation		Index No. 152939/20 Appeal No. 13540 Case No. 2020-03626	2021 NY Slip Op 02108
Matter of Jewish Press v Metropolitan Transp. Auth. of the State of N.Y.		Index No. 653548/19 Appeal No. 13539 Case No. 2020-03956	2021 NY Slip Op 02107
International Pathways Inc. v University of Queensland		Index No. 657010/19 Appeal No. 13535 Case No. 2020-02747	2021 NY Slip Op 02106
Harris v Harris		Index No. 656962/17 Appeal No. 13465 Case No. 2020-03015	2021 NY Slip Op 02105
Hammer v ACC Constr. Corp.		Index No. 152347/14 Appeal No. 13512 Case No. 2019-5823	2021 NY Slip Op 02104
Gold v New York Life Ins. Co.		Index No. 653923/12 Appeal No. 13525 Case No. 2020-02641	2021 NY Slip Op 02103
Matter of Gerson Lehrman Group, Inc. v New York City Tax Appeals Trib.		Tax Trib No. 149/18 Appeal No. 13511 Case No. 2019-4129	2021 NY Slip Op 02102
G Bldrs., LLC v Bondex Ins. Co.		Index No. 655962/17 Appeal No. 13532 Case No. 2020-03161	2021 NY Slip Op 02101
Friberg v City of New York		Index No. 159850/14 Appeal No. 13517 Case No. 2020-01810	2021 NY Slip Op 02100
Matter of FGLS Equity LLC		Index No. 157170/19 Appeal No. 13531 Case No. 2020-02819	2021 NY Slip Op 02099
DePalma v DePalma		Index No. 652893/19 Appeal No. 13510 Case No. 2020-02543	2021 NY Slip Op 02098
Hettinga v Nahoum		Index No. 653691/18 Appeal No. 13537 Case No. 2020-00769	2021 NY Slip Op 02097
Matter of Caputo v Stack		Index No. 656772/19 Appeal No. 13524N-13524NA Case No. 2020-02961, 2020-03135	2021 NY Slip Op 02096
Butler v Cruz		Index No. 301399/15 Appeal No. 13509 Case No. 2020-03955	2021 NY Slip Op 02095
Board of Mgrs. of the Residential Section of the Plaza Condominium v Franzese		Index No. 654394/15 Appeal No. 13505-13506-13507-13507A Case No. 2020-00910 2020-00911 2020-00913 2020-00914	2021 NY Slip Op 02094
Blumenberg v Lora		Index No. 23971/17E Appeal No. 13534 Case No. 2020-03508	2021 NY Slip Op 02093
Aspen Specialty Ins. Co. v RLI Ins. Co., Inc.	Renwick, J.P.	Index No. 652215/18 Appeal No. 13420 Case No. 2020-04416	2021 NY Slip Op 02092

**Cases Decided April 1, 2021**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
30-32 W. 31st St. LLC v Heena Hotel		Index No. 651918/12 Appeal No. 13484-13485N Case No. 2019-5914, 2020-02931	2021 NY Slip Op 02055
Matter of Wright v Carroll		Index No. 451789/19 Appeal No. 13483 Case No. 2020-04337	2021 NY Slip Op 02089
World Wide Packaging, LLC v Cargo Cosmetics, LLC		Index No. 653546/18 Appeal No. 13486N Case No. 2019-05274	2021 NY Slip Op 02088
Matter of Storino v New York Univ.		Index No. 157947/20, 157815/20, 157787/20 Appeal No. 13131-13132&[M-4134] Case No. 2020-04294(2)	2021 NY Slip Op 02087
GFE Jerome Ave. LLC v Steph-Leigh Assoc., LLC		Index No. 33597/18 Appeal No. 13498 Case No. 2019-04629	2021 NY Slip Op 02086
Matter of L.S. (Diana A.)	OING, J.	Docket No. AS-24660/17, AS-24667/17 Appeal No. 12912 Case No. 2019-1128	2021 NY Slip Op 02085
Regalis Constr., Inc. v Wonder Works Constr. Corp.		Index No. 101863/12 Appeal No. 13492 Case No. 2020-02654	2021 NY Slip Op 02084
Picone/WDF, JV v City of New York		Index No. 653642/18 Appeal No. 13503N Case No. 2020-02463	2021 NY Slip Op 02083
Perez v City of New York		Index No. 157110/15 Appeal No. 13470 Case No. 2020-03184	2021 NY Slip Op 02082
People v Peterson		Ind No. 2884/17 Appeal No. 13478 Case No. 2019-4122	2021 NY Slip Op 02081
People v Richardson		Ind No. 4734/13 Appeal No. 13495 Case No. 2017-2065	2021 NY Slip Op 02080
People v Wanko		Ind No. 99073/16 Appeal No. 13493 Case No. 2018-527	2021 NY Slip Op 02079
People v Adams		Ind. No. 1578/13 Appeal No. 13469 Case No. 2019-04704	2021 NY Slip Op 02078
People v Walker		SCI No. 675/19 Appeal No. 13481 Case No. 2019-4205	2021 NY Slip Op 02077
People v Justiniano		Ind No. 1543/17 Appeal No. 13474 Case No. 2019-4028	2021 NY Slip Op 02076
People v Espinal		Ind No. 2696/13 Appeal No. 13487 Case No. 2019-3223	2021 NY Slip Op 02075
Levin v Salvini		Index No. 650477/17 Appeal No. 13494 Case No. 2020-01798	2021 NY Slip Op 02074
Kirschenbaum v Wells Fargo Bank, N.A.		Index No. 151236/19 Appeal No. 11794-11794A & [M-1230] Case No. 2020-01563, 2020-01564	2021 NY Slip Op 02073
Kim v Francis		Index No. 650481/18 Appeal No. 13491-13491A Case No. 2020-02244, 2020-03374	2021 NY Slip Op 02072
Herrero v 2146 Nostrand Ave. Assoc., LLC		Index No. 153673/15, 595519/15, 595804/15, 595391/17 Appeal No. 13500 Case No. 2020-01218	2021 NY Slip Op 02071
Helm v PHH Mtge. Corp.		Index No. 159908/19 Appeal No. 13502N Case No. 2020-03278	2021 NY Slip Op 02070
Matter of H. (Ronald H.)		Docket No. NN-02356-19, NN-02357-19 Appeal No. 13489 Case No. 2019-03761	2021 NY Slip Op 02069
Ging v F.J. Sciame Constr. Co., Inc.		Index No. 157839/12, 590551/13 Appeal No. 13497 Case No. 2020-01241	2021 NY Slip Op 02068
Gallina v MTA Capital Constr. Co.		Index No. 157087/15 Appeal No. 13482 Case No. 2020-01706	2021 NY Slip Op 02067
Matter of L.G. (E.R.)		Docket No. N13963/18 Appeal No. 13471-13471A Case No. 2020-02812	2021 NY Slip Op 02066
Erby v 36 LLC		Index No. 161985/15 Appeal No. 13490 Case No. 2020-04169	2021 NY Slip Op 02065
Enterprise Architectural Sales, Inc. v Magnetic Bldrs. Group LLC		Index No. 657045/2017 Appeal No. 13501N Case No. 2020-00794	2021 NY Slip Op 02064
Doe v Intercontinental Hotels Group, PLC		Index No. 159963/17 Appeal No. 13479 Case No. 2020-03245	2021 NY Slip Op 02063
Ditech Fin., LLC v Rector 70 LLC		Index No. 850330/18 Appeal No. 12597-12597A&[M-623] Case No. 2019-5176	2021 NY Slip Op 02062
Dinallo Constr. Corp. v Phoenix RMA Constr. Servs., LLC		Index No. 652491/17 Appeal No. 13480-13480A Case No. 2020-02904	2021 NY Slip Op 02061
Cabrera v Thomas		Index No. 29663/18E Appeal No. 13472 Case No. 2020-04779	2021 NY Slip Op 02060
Boesky v Levine		Index No. 650756/17 Appeal No. 13475-13476-13477 Case No. 2018-6041, 2018-6042, 2018-6060, 2018-6061	2021 NY Slip Op 02059
Banco Indusval S.A. v Goncalves		Index No. 654109/15 Appeal No. 13496-13496A Case No. 2019-05122	2021 NY Slip Op 02058
Al Aabdy v 281 St Nicholas Partners LLC		Index No. 23871/16E, 43269/16E Appeal No. 13473 Case No. 2020-04689	2021 NY Slip Op 02057
600-602 10th Ave. Realty Corp. v Estate of Nusimow		Index No. 650120/17 Appeal No. 13488 Case No. 2020-01142	2021 NY Slip Op 02056