Appellate Division, First Department Decisions

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

**Cases Decided December 30, 2025**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Alfred v Brutus	Index No. 365106/20\|Appeal No. 5464-5465\|Case No. 2024-06665, 2025-02234\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07333
Matter of Min Wu v Institute of Elec. & Elecs. Engrs., Inc.	Index No. 159073/24\|Appeal No. 5480\|Case No. 2025-02138\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07347
Daniel Szalkiewicz & Assoc., P.C. v Liu	Index No. 150713/24\|Appeal No. 5586\|Case No. 2025-00512\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07346
Matter of Schneck v New York State Dept. of Health	Index No. 152021/24\|Appeal No. 5460\|Case No. 2024-05240\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07345
People v Walters	SCI No. 3713/2014, 3714/2014\|Appeal No. 5477\|Case No. 2015-2278\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07344
People v Diaby	Ind No. 2047/21\|Appeal No. 5466\|Case No. 2023-01046\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07343
People v Perdomo	SCI No. 74153/23\|Appeal No. 5459\|Case No. 2023-05396\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07342
People v Owens	Ind No. 74866/23\| SCR No. 72335/24\|Appeal No. 5467\|Case No. 2024-04668\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07341
People v Morales	Ind No. 71333-21\|Appeal No. 5479\|Case No. 2022-05211\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07340
People v Son y Son	Ind No. 2101/19\|Appeal No. 5481\|Case No. 2020-01634\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07339
People v Brown	Ind No. 924/84\|Appeal No. 5474\|Case No. 2023-01479\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07338
Lee v Jay Hous. Corp.	Index No. 656670/21\|Appeal No. 5475\|Case No. 2025-00542\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07337
Matter of S.J. v B.B.	Docket No. V-09665/19 V-09666/19 V-23646/18 V-23647/18\|Appeal No. 5461-5461A,5461B,5461C\|Case No. 2021-01797 2023-01403 2024-04604\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07336
Fishman v Romano	Index No. 805235/21\|Appeal No. 5478\|Case No. 2024-05527\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07335
Best Work Holdings (N.Y.), LLC v Jia (Ivy) Ma	Index No. 654826/22\|Appeal No. 5463\|Case No. 2024-03146\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07334

**Cases Decided December 23, 2025**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Bank of N.Y. Mellon Trust Co., NA v Kim	Index No. 850276/22\|Appeal No. 5449\|Case No. 2024-03145\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07219
Matter of M.T. v Lerry T.	Docket No. N-02870-72/22\|Appeal No. 5439\|Case No. 2025-00212\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07236
Rubenstein Pub. Relations, Inc. v Fleet Fin. Group, Inc.	Index No. 654299/22\|Appeal No. 5454\|Case No. 2025-00147\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07235
Rouse v Ahmed	Index No. 811894/21\|Appeal No. 5444\|Case No. 2025-01703\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07234
Rosenblatt v Rosenblatt	Index No. 320348/20\|Appeal No. 5452\|Case No. 2025-02451\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07233
Piscitelli v Deloitte Servs., LLP	Index No. 159272/20\|Appeal No. 5451\|Case No. 2025-00498\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07232
People v Rivera	Ind. No. 447/19\|Appeal No. 5450\|Case No. 2022-00583\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07231
People v Ruffin	Ind. No. 74066/23, 72749/23\|Appeal No. 5445-5446\|Case No. 2024-04029, 2024-04037\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07230
People v L.W.	Ind. No. 70387/20\|Appeal No. 4951\|Case No. 2024-06343\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07229
People v Rondon-Tavares	Ind. No. 854/18\|Appeal No. 5453\|Case No. 2020-00520\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07228
People v Dushain	Ind No. 8131/97\|Appeal No. 5447-5447A\|Case No. 2018-2225\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07227
Matter of L.P.G. (L.B.)	Docket No. NA-25727/22, NA-25728/22, NA-25729/22, NA-21013/23\|Appeal No. 4966\|Case No. 2024-02022\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07226
Ortiz v City of New York	Index No. 21877/19\|Appeal No. 5443\|Case No. 2025-00543\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07225
Keenan v Bloomberg L.P.	Index No. 155679/24\|Appeal No. 5438\|Case No. 2025-02079\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07224
Guaman v 240 W. 44th St. Two LLC.	Index No. 157343/18, 595130/19\|Appeal No. 5440-5441\|Case No. 2024-05104, 2025-02749\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07223
Edward Tyler Nahem Fine Art L.L.C. v Lee	Index No. 653982/23\|Appeal No. 5456-5457-5458\|Case No. 2024-05085, 2024-05086, 2024-04433\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07222
Cochancela v Sutton Place S. Corp.	Index No. 162498/19\|Appeal No. 5448\|Case No. 2024-06708\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07221
Cerda v Cydonia W71, LLC	Index No. 161637/19\|Appeal No. 5442\|Case No. 2024-02844\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07220

**Cases Decided December 18, 2025**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of 200 Claremont Ave. Hous. Dev. Fund Corp. v Estate of Elsie Lewis		Index No. 571374/23\|Appeal No. 5423\|Case No. 2024-07825\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07084
SF Consultants, LLC v 28 W. Group Corp		Index No. 158320/22\|Appeal No. 5427\|Case No. 2025-00052\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07122
Yentis v Yentis		Index No. 311141/14\|Appeal No. 5418&M-05504\|Case No. 2025-00993\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07121
US Bank N.A. v Okeke		Index No. 380322/09\|Appeal No. 5414\|Case No. 2024-07022\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07120
Matter of State of N.Y. Unified Ct. Sys. v Civil Serv. Empls. Assn., Inc.		Index No. 451438/24\|Appeal No. 5397\|Case No. 2024-06271\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07119
Matter of Smith v Caban		Index No. 150554/24\|Appeal No. 5400\|Case No. 2024-06496\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07118
Sendibel Trading, S.A. v Petróleos de Venezuela S.A.		Index No. 650617/24\|Appeal No. 5412\|Case No. 2024-07807\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07117
Matter of Angelika R. v Yolanda K.		Docket No. V-30551-17/21\|Appeal No. 5398\|Case No. 2024-05837\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07116
Plotch v Citibank, N.A.		Index No. 653971/22\|Appeal No. 5436 M-6141\|Case No. 2024-05253\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07115
People v Khan		Ind No. 1279/21\|Appeal No. 5419\|Case No. 2023-00796\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07114
People v Lafleur		Ind No. 75601/22\|Appeal No. 5435\|Case No. 2023-06477\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07113
People v Quinones		Ind No. 71728/23\|Appeal No. 5433\|Case No. 2024-00558\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07112
People v Sanders		Ind No. 73907/23\|Appeal No. 5401\|Case No. 2024-01086\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07111
People v R.V.		Ind No. 70718/21\|Appeal No. 5429\|Case No. 2024-01633\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07110
People v Howell		Ind No. 1506/19\|Appeal No. 5408\|Case No. 2022-00995\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07109
People v White		Ind No. 3865/15\|Appeal No. 5416\|Case No. 2019-04977\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07108
People v Lopez		SCI No. 74987/23\|Appeal No. 5396\|Case No. 2024-02352\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07107
People v Juan Sosa C.		Ind No. 70148/21, 70258/21\|Appeal No. 5426\|Case No. 2023-01052\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07106
People v Rivera		Ind No. 72395/23\|Appeal No. 5432\|Case No. 2024-02415\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07105
People v Ruiz		Ind No. 591/20\|Appeal No. 5425\|Case No. 2022-02408\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07104
People v Saunders		Ind No. 2169/21\|Appeal No. 5413\|Case No. 2022-05406\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07103
People v Brandon S.		Ind No. 2663/17 2664/17 357/19\|Appeal No. 5402\|Case No. 2020-01447\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07102
Matter of Nussbaum	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2025-03827\|Case No. 2025-04288\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07101
Matter of Hernandez	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2025-04995\|Case No. 2025-05578\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07100
Matter of Bennett	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2025-05816\|Case No. 2025-06777\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07099
Matter of Kimberly T. v Rafael E.M.		Docket No. V-02034/20 V-04651/21\|Appeal No. 5421\|Case No. 2024-06582\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07098
Joseph v Memorial Hosp. for Cancer & Allied Diseases		Index No. 158336/21\|Appeal No. 5434\|Case No. 2025-01080\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07097
Irizarry v Zelaya		Index No. 160011/21\|Appeal No. 5407\|Case No. 2024-04852\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07096
Hinkson v New York-Presbyt. Queens		Index No. 153104/18\|Appeal No. 5428\|Case No. 2024-01885\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07095
Green v Whole Foods Mkt. Group, Inc.		Index No. 155089/20\|Appeal No. 5422\|Case No. 2024-06371\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07094
Gelwan v De Ratafia		Index No. 654525/16\|Appeal No. 5403-5404-5405-5406&M-6112-M-6114\|Case No. 2023-05403 2024-01204 2024-01807\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07093
Domogjoni v Korpenn LLC		Index No. 158520/13\|Appeal No. 5417\|Case No. 2018-4746\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07092
Davis v Port		Index No. 654027/13\|Appeal No. 5437\|Case No. 2025-00978\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07091
Crespo v Francini		Index No. 21281/13\|Appeal No. 5399\|Case No. 2023-05340\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07090
Matter of City of New York v Board of Collective Bargaining of the City of N.Y.		Index No. 452449/22\|Appeal No. 5430\|Case No. 2024-03014\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07089
Boliak v Reilly		Index No. 153941/16\|Appeal No. 5431\|Case No. 2024-04856\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07088
Matter of Angelino v New York City Dept. of Health & Mental Hygiene		Index No. 151429/24\|Appeal No. 5420\|Case No. 2024-06445\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07087
902 Assoc. v Union Sq. 902 Suites LLC		Index No. 156065/20\|Appeal No. 5411\|Case No. 2025-00277\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07086
Matter of 320 W. 87 LLC v 320 W. 87th St., Inc.		Index No. 654793/23 \|Appeal No. 5424\|Case No. 2024-05822\|	2025 NY Slip Op 07085

**Cases Decided December 16, 2025**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Couteller v Mamakos	Index No. 160767/17\|Appeal No. 5385-5385A-5385B\|Case No. 2025-00001\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06965
Matter of N.V. (Araceli H.)	Docket No. NA-16259/21\|Appeal No. 5380\|Case No. 2023-06224\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06977
Roche v Hochfelder	Index No. 650450/23\|Appeal No. 5395\|Case No. 2025-02579\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06976
People v Roman	Ind. No. 72966/23\|Appeal No. 5389\|Case No. 2024-03830\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06975
People v Garcia	Ind. No. 1487/20\|Appeal No. 5386\|Case No. 2023-00552\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06974
People v Davis	Ind No. 357/20, 1237/20, 1369/20\|Appeal No. 5393\|Case No. 2022-02133\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06973
People v Landa	Ind. No. 73759/22\|Appeal No. 5383\|Case No. 2023-04860\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06972
People v Smith	Ind No. 256/21\|Appeal No. 5382\|Case No. 2022-04743\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06971
People v Rodriguez	SCI No. 70239/24\|Appeal No. 5378\|Case No. 2024-00991\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06970
Doan-Trang Nguyen v Dang T. Phan	Index No. 311651/17\|Appeal No. 5381\|Case No. 2025-00080\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06969
McLeod v New York City Health & Hosps. Corp.	Index No. 33513/19, 810607/22\|Appeal No. 5390-5391-5391A\|Case No. 2022-01003, 2022-03132, 2024-05320\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06968
Lee v Nejat	Index No. 800296/11\|Appeal No. 5394\|Case No. 2024-01665\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06967
Judson Realty, LLC v Judson CRE LLC	Index No. 159388/20\|Appeal No. 5379\|Case No. 2024-03617\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06966

**Cases Decided December 11, 2025**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Arias v City of New York	Index No. 301758/11\|Appeal No. 5361\|Case No. 2025-02975\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06891
Wilmington Sav. Fund Socy. v Jsang Kei Lau	Index No. 104792/09\|Appeal No. 5357,5357A\|Case No. 2024-05460 , 2024-06860\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06924
Thomas v Concourse Rehabilitation & Nursing Ctr., Inc.	Index No. 814415/22\|Appeal No. 5121\|Case No. 2024-04731\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06923
Stevens v Audthan, LLC	Index No. 101842/19\|Appeal No. 5349\|Case No. 2025-00740\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06922
Ramirez v Teixeira Bakery	Index No. 450691/19\|Appeal No. 5371\|Case No. 2024-05469\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06921
People v Williams	Ind No. 71328/21\|Appeal No. 5347\|Case No. 2024-00206\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06920
People v Jackson	Ind No. 159/21\|Appeal No. 5344\|Case No. 2023-01544\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06919
People v Rich	Ind No. 4524/18\|Appeal No. 5339\|Case No. 2020-01855\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06918
People v Rivera	Ind No. 70029/22\|Appeal No. 5358\|Case No. 2024-07841\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06917
People v Medina-Hidalgo	SCI No. 3088/19\|Appeal No. 5353\|Case No. 2019-05509\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06916
People v Santiago	Ind No. 75468/22\|Appeal No. 5364\|Case No. 2024-00691\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06915
People v McTaggart	Ind No. 158/21\|Appeal No. 5374\|Case No. 2022-02187\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06914
People v Johnson-Watson	Ind No. 70676/21\|Appeal No. 5356\|Case No. 2022-05579\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06913
People v Taylor	Ind No. 879/21\|Appeal No. 5350\|Case No. 2022-01402\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06912
O'Rourke v Hammerstein Ballroom	Index No. 161427/19\|Appeal No. 5351\|Case No. 2024-06301\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06911
Mycklebust v Consolidated Edison Co. of N.Y., Inc.	Index No. 652679/23\|Appeal No. 5362-5363\|Case No. 2024-05149, 2025-00700\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06910
Mather v HFZ KIK 30th St. Owner LLC	Index No. 161223/19 595632/20\|Appeal No. 5367\|Case No. 2024-05955\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06909
Matter of L.M. v J.H.	Docket No. V-1414/15, V-01415/22\|Appeal No. 5341\|Case No. 2025-01761\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06908
Llerena v 975 Park Ave. Corp.	Index No. 27073/20\|Appeal No. 5354\|Case No. 2024-07386\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06907
Matter of A.K. (A.B.)	Docket No. NN-07552/24\|Appeal No. 5360\|Case No. 2025-01030\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06906
Matter of John F.B. v Maria U.	Case No. 2024-07465\|Docket No. V-02301/23/23A\|Appeal No. 5286\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06905
Jiminez v Rosi	Index No. 817378/21\|Appeal No. 5345\|Case No. 2025-03543\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06904
Jane Doe One v KIPP Found.	Index No. 70424/21\|Appeal No. 5346\|Case No. 2024-05661\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06903
J.C. v 2078 Arthur, LLC	Index No. ?810563/21\|Appeal No. 5377\|Case No. 2024-06783\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06902
Greenland Asset Mgt. Corp. v MicroCloud Hologram, Inc.	Index No. 651701/23\|Appeal No. 5348\|Case No. 2024-05167\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06901
Fishman v Fishman	Index No. 3695/19\|Appeal No. 5343\|Case No. 2024-01648\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06900
Matter of Feliciano v Caban	Ind No. 151251/24\|Appeal No. 5359\|Case No. 2024-04801\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06899
E*Trade Bank v Plotch	Index No. 380411/13\|Appeal No. 4834\|Case No. 2016-00460,\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06898
Etage Real Estate LLC v Stern	Index No. 656322/19\|Appeal No. 5375-5376\|Case No. 2024-07087 2024-07311\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06897
Di Francesco v McEnroy	Index No. 652466/24\|Appeal No. 5369\|Case No. 2025-01674\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06896
Dewinter v Equinox Greenwich Ave., Inc.	Index No. 150176/21\|Appeal No. 5373\|Case No. 2024-05544\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06895
Corbex, Inc. v New York City Sch. Constr. Auth.	Index No. 809231/22\|Appeal No. 5366\|Case No. 2024-04574\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06894
CLNC 2019-FL1 Funding, LLC v Bennett	Index No. 651851/23\|Appeal No. 5340\|Case No. 2025-03501\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06893
Ceja v Posillico Civ., Inc.	Index No. 158010/18\|Appeal No. 5342\|Case No. 2024-07053\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06892

**Cases Decided December 9, 2025**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Abramov v 230 PAS SPE LLC	Index No. 153359/22\|Appeal No. 5370\|Case No. 2024-04851\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06800
Zepsa Indus., Inc. v 401 W. Prop. Owners, LLC	Index No. 651243/24\|Appeal No. 5310\|Case No. 2025-01341\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06837
URP Maiden Lane LLC v Valley Natl. Bank	Index No. 655242/23\|Appeal No. 5303\|Case No. 2024-05459\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06836
Matter of SKMF VYSE Mgt. LLC v Niblack	Index No. 801022/23\|Appeal No. 5318\|Case No. 2024-00603\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06835
Matter of R.F.S. (E.S.)	Index No. 500072/13\|Appeal No. 5338\|Case No. 2024-02471\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06834
RSD857, LLC v Wright	Index No. 158125/22\|Appeal No. 5308\|Case No. 2024-03849\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06833
Rockwell v Bobst	Index No. 951362/21\|Appeal No. 5332\|Case No. 2025-00939\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06832
Robinson v Bronx County Pub. Admr.	Index No. 156003/19\|Appeal No. 5336\|Case No. 2025-02186\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06831
Matter of Radin v Johnson	Index No. 100496/22\|Appeal No. 5316 M-3380\|Case No. 2025-3685\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06830
Quezada v Consolidated Edison Co. of N.Y., Inc.	Index No. 158013/16\|Appeal No. 5298\|Case No. 2024-04805\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06829
People ex rel. Darocha v Maginley-Liddie	Ind No. 452058/25\|Appeal No. 5333\|Case No. 2025-04537\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06828
People v Cisse	Ind No. 71052/23 70546/23\|Appeal No. 5301-5302\|Case No. 2024-00822 2024-02029\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06827
People v Jimenez	SCI No. 699/19\|Appeal No. 5317\|Case No. 2020-02179\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06826
People v Tartt	Ind No. 1913/18\|Appeal No. 5297\|Case No. 2020-01314\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06825
People v Leak	Ind No. 72953/22\|Appeal No. 5314\|Case No. 2024-02809\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06824
People v Orellano	Ind No. 73457/23\|Appeal No. 5334\|Case No. 2024-07843\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06823
People v Cruz	Ind No. 434/20\|Appeal No. 5323\|Case No. 2022-04242\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06822
People v Soto	Ind No. 2752/17\|Appeal No. 5326\|Case No. 2018-4623\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06821
People v Shuaibu	Ind No. 1440/17\|Appeal No. 5309\|Case No. 2018-03642\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06820
Parque Solar Don Jose S.A. de C.V. v Enel S.P.A.	Index No. 656415/23\|Appeal No. 5329-5330-5331\|Case No. 2024-07648 2025-00525 2025-02563\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06819
Panos v Panos	Index No. 365148/21\|Appeal No. 5140-5141\|Case No. 2025-02624 2025-03519\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06818
Ovaskainen v Ovaskainen	Index No. 157851/23\|Appeal No. 5327\|Case No. 2024-02644\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06817
Olshan Frome Wolosky, LLP v Kestenbaum	Index No. 656174/23\|Appeal No. 5321\|Case No. 2024-05853\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06816
Molina v Mount Sinai Morningside Hosp.	Index No. 805314/21\|Appeal No. 5324\|Case No. 2024-05268\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06815
Lee v Montefiore Med. Ctr.	Index No. 20565/16\|Appeal No. 5313\|Case No. 2024-04242\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06814
Jones v River Park Residences, L.P.	Index No. 26441/18\|Appeal No. 5322\|Case No. 2024-04304\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06813
Matter of A.I.	Docket No. N-25168/23, N-25169/23, N-25170/23\|Appeal No. 5319-5319A\|Case No. 2024-04327\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06812
Hanslick v UG2	Index No. 156052/22\|Appeal No. 5320\|Case No. 2025-01643\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06811
Greenway Mews Realty, L.L.C. v Liberty Ins. Underwriters, Inc.	Index No. 652364/18\|Appeal No. 5325\|Case No. 2024-05471\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06810
Garcia v 100 Church Fee Owner, LLC	Index No. 158554/18, 595447/19\|Appeal No. 5300\|Case No. 2024-04495\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06809
Matter of C.G. (E.G.)	Docket No. N37263/23\|Appeal No. 5299\|Case No. 2025-00120\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06808
Matter of J.D.	Docket No. D952/24\|Appeal No. 5328\|Case No. 2024-03491\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06807
Matter of N.C. v C.C.	V-24108/22\|Docket No. V-24108/22\|Appeal No. 5307\|Case No. 2025-02301\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06806
Bordonaro v E.C. Provini Co., Inc.	Index No. 157409/20 596019/20\|Appeal No. 5304-5305-5306\|Case No. 2025-00629 2025-0638 2025-00643\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06805
Blinbaum v Chan	Index No. 151012/20\|Appeal No. 5315\|Case No. 2025-01837\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06804
Biswas v Aramis Distribs. N.Y., Inc.	Index No. 190004/23\|Appeal No. 5312\|Case No. 2024-06848\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06803
Angen v De Jesus	Index No. 161519/19\|Appeal No. 5335\|Case No. 2024-06748\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06802
AmTrust N. Am., Inc. v Insurance Specialty Group LLC	Index No. 650020/24\|Appeal No. 4920\|Case No. 2024-05581\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06801

**Cases Decided December 4, 2025**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Aryeh Realty Corp. v 18 E. 69th St Tenant, LLC	Index No. 570353/24\|Appeal No. 5229\|Case No. 2025-01286\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06783
Matter of Windermere Props. LLC v City of New York	Index No. 161016/22\|Appeal No. 5293-5294\|Case No. 2024-01732, 2024-02289\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06798
United Medicine & Rehabilitation P.C. v Yakobashvili	Index No. 811945/21\|Appeal No. 5287\|Case No. 2025-04943\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06797
TD Bank, N.A. v A.H. Dental P.C.	Index No. 161295/21\|Appeal No. 5295\|Case No. 2024-02846\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06796
Solomon v 360 E. 72d St. Owners Inc.	Index No. 652944/24\|Appeal No. 5288-5289-5290\|Case No. 2024-05568 2025-00557 2025-00654\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06795
Rodriguez v 167, LLC	Index No. 304790/14\|Appeal No. 5281-5282\|Case No. 2024-00829, 2024-06646\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06794
Matter of Robinson v Hiatt	Index No. 151639/24\|Appeal No. 5278\|Case No. 2025-00490\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06793
People v Anderson	Ind No. 71312/22\|Appeal No. 5283\|Case No. 2022-05672\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06792
People v Jose A.	Index No. 1780/17\|Appeal No. 5277\|Case No. 2020-01115\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06791
People v Moultrie	Ind No. 928/20\|Appeal No. 5291\|Case No. 2023-02138\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06790
People v Bredy B.	Ind No. 1054/16\|Appeal No. 5285\|Case No. 2019-05337\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06789
Owens v New Empire Corp.	Index No. 654796/23\|Appeal No. 5284\|Case No. 2024-05348\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06788
Matter of Anthony L.	D-11747/24\|Docket No. D-11747/24\|Appeal No. 5279\|Case No. 2025-00680\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06787
Matter of IGS Realty Co. L.P. v Brady	Index No. 159554/17\|Appeal No. 5280\|Case No. 2025-00908\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06786
Matter of Garanes v New York City Dept. of Educ.	Index No. 100425/23\|Appeal No. 5171\|Case No. 2024-04737\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06785
Brigade Calvary Fund Ltd v Chirico	Index No. 655678/24\|Appeal No. 5292\|Case No. 2025-03695\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06784

**Cases Decided December 2, 2025**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
538 Morgan Realty LLC v Law Off. of Aihong You, PC		Index No. 153886/23\|Appeal No. 5270\|Case No. 2024-05101\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06639
ZDG, LLC v 310 Group, LLC		Index No. 656537/16\|Appeal No. 5262-5263\|Case No. 2024-03654 2024-03655\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06678
Barons Media, LLC v Shapiro Legal Group, PLLC		Index No. 652481/23\|Appeal No. 5248\|Case No. 2024-02437\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06677
Yagual v Hudson Canal LLC		Index No. 24640/20\|Appeal No. 5249\|Case No. 2024-07911\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06676
Vargas v Mavino Realty Co., Inc.		Index No. 301063/11\|Appeal No. 5254\|Case No. 2025-02444\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06675
Matter of Suarez v Rodney		Appeal No. 5276\|Case No. 2025-05890\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06674
Solis v City of New York		Index No. 150552/15\|Appeal No. 4843\|Case No. 2024-02801\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06673
Serhant LLC v Federico		Index No. 652441/22\|Appeal No. 5259\|Case No. 2025-02002\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06672
Sapini v Ferrara		Index No. 150940/24\|Appeal No. 5241\|Case No. 2024-05876\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06671
Roth v Board of Mgrs. of 299 W. 12th St. Condominium		Index No. 154315/22\|Appeal No. 5271\|Case No. 2025-00394\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06670
Rockmore Contr. Corp. v City of New York		Index No. 652483/22\|Appeal No. 4482\|Case No. 2024-05664\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06669
Rivera v Site 2 DSA Owner, LLC		Index No. 159502/20\|Appeal No. 5258\|Case No. 2024-03358\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06668
Matter of Sharlene R. v Jhovanni D.		\|Docket No. V-18850-18/21A\|Appeal No. 5246\|Case No. 2025-02427\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06667
PrairieGold Solar LLC v AGCS Mar. Ins. Co.		Index No. 650728/18\|Appeal No. 5245\|Case No. 2024-05934\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06666
People v Small		Ind No. 70051/22\|Appeal No. 5247\|Case No. 2022-03391\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06665
People v McDonald		Ind No. 2025/14\|Appeal No. 5266\|Case No. 2019-4036\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06664
People v Louis		Ind No. 2923/17\|Appeal No. 5253\|Case No. 2023-06318\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06663
People v Peroza		Ind No. 70717/23\|Appeal No. 5264\|Case No. 2024-00972\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06662
People v Montgomery		Ind No. 76044/23\|Appeal No. 5274\|Case No. 2024-03022\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06661
People v Ortiz		SCI No. 1648/21\|Appeal No. 5261\|Case No. 2023-06281\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06660
People v Canteen		Ind No. 3168/19\|Appeal No. 5255\|Case No. 2022-03612\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06659
People v Martinez		Ind No. 3944/08\|Appeal No. 5242\|Case No. 2023-04515\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06658
People v Colon		Ind No. 71622/22\|Appeal No. 5238\|Case No. 2022-05545\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06657
O'Brien v Tectonic Bldrs. Inc.		Index No. 150670/19\|Appeal No. 5256\|Case No. 2025-00321\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06656
Matter of Muce v City of N.Y. Civ. Serv. Commission		Index No. 818230/23\|Appeal No. 5260\|Case No. 2024-05258\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06655
Milchin v Milchin		Index No. 305293/19\|Appeal No. 5239\|Case No. 2024-05564\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06654
Matter of Malig	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2025-05315\|Case No. 2025-04145\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06653
Matter of Hantman	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2025-05382\|Case No. 2025-00201\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06652
Matter of Asher	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2025-04509\|Case No. 2025-02082\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06651
Matter of I.M. v I.M.		Docket No. O-05622/21 O-5622-21/22A\|Appeal No. 5240\|Case No. 2025-00360\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06650
Matter of A.K. v P.C.		Docket No. O-06624/22\|Appeal No. 5265\|Case No. 2025-01003\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06649
Health E. Ambulatory Surgical Ctr. v County-Wide Ins. Co.		Index No. 570101/24\|Appeal No. 5272\|Case No. 2024-07720\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06648
Haque v T & S Interiors Corp.		Index No. 654064/24\|Appeal No. 5244\|Case No. 2025-00566\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06647
Matter of Detering v New York City Envtl. Control Bd.		Index No. 159847/23\|Appeal No. 5273\|Case No. 2024-04806\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06646
Matter of N.D. (M.C.)		Docket No. 04202-22\|Appeal No. 5257\|Case No. 2024-06025\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06645
Burrows v 75-25 153rd St., LLC		Index No. 160082/20\|Appeal No. 17103-17104\|Case No. 2021-04654 2022-02533\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06644
Bolek-Gawin v White Plains Kensington, LLC		Index No. 24005/20\|Appeal No. 5252\|Case No. 2025-00130\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06643
Board of Mgrs. of the 900 Park Ave. Condominium v Park Park Assoc., LLC		Index No. 655999/21\|Appeal No. 5267\|Case No. 2024-07901\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06642
Black v City of New York		Index No. 26000/19\|Appeal No. 4910\|Case No. 2024-03203\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06641
Badme v AECOM		Index No. 152683/24\|Appeal No. 5275\|Case No. 2025-01695\|	2025 NY Slip Op 06640