Appellate Division, First Department Decisions

Archived Information

Documents listed on this page are archived and may not fully meet current ADA accessibility standards.

**Cases Decided January 30, 2025**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Bragino v Coachman Luxury Transp., Inc.	Index No. 30145/20 Appeal No. 3255 Case No. 2023-04700	2025 NY Slip Op 00477
Alpert v Moinian Group	Index No. 161382/19 Appeal No. 3591 Case No. 2024-03620	2025 NY Slip Op 00516
Yakte Props., LLC v Milner	Index No. 850102/21 Appeal No. 3605 Case No. 2023-03179	2025 NY Slip Op 00496
Matter of Vijungco v Metropolitan Transp. Auth.	Index No. 158756/23 Appeal No. 3604 Case No. 2024-02818	2025 NY Slip Op 00495
Soares v Rahmatulloev	Index No. 30914/17 Appeal No. 3595 Case No. 2024-03046	2025 NY Slip Op 00494
Sanchez v Bronx United in Leveraging Dollars, Inc.	Index No. 24937/16 Appeal No. 3594 Case No. 2023-06244	2025 NY Slip Op 00493
Matter of Retter v City of New York	Index No. 156293/22 Appeal No. 3601 Case No. 2023-05332	2025 NY Slip Op 00492
People v Daniels	Ind No. 3472/13 Appeal No. 3537&M-6179 Case No. 2022-02755	2025 NY Slip Op 00491
People v Sabino	Ind No. 1504/20 Appeal No. 3600 Case No. 2023-00674	2025 NY Slip Op 00490
People v Tolliver	Ind No. 627/83 Appeal No. 3596 Case No. 2019-1238	2025 NY Slip Op 00489
People v Rivas	Ind No. 2587/19 Appeal No. 3588 Case No. 2021-04567	2025 NY Slip Op 00488
People v Negroni	Ind No. 1541/21 Appeal No. 3606 Case No. 2023-02885	2025 NY Slip Op 00487
People v Guante	Ind No. 3002/14 Appeal No. 3603 Case No. 2018-1881 2023-01702	2025 NY Slip Op 00486
King v City of New York	Index No. 150749/18 Appeal No. 3599 Case No. 2024-00520	2025 NY Slip Op 00485
Matter of William J. v Jenevia T.	Docket No. P-00594/23 P-00595/23 Appeal No. 3590 Case No. 2024-00735	2025 NY Slip Op 00484
IS Co., LLC v Olsen	Index No. 651272/23 Appeal No. 3597-3598 Case Nos. 2024-00870, 2024-00962	2025 NY Slip Op 00483
Matter of 9F Inc. Sec. Litig.	Index No. 654654/20 Appeal No. 3602 Case No. 2024-02590	2025 NY Slip Op 00482
G & Y Maintenance Corp. v 540 W. 48th St. Corp.	Index No. 652108/20 Appeal No. 3607 Case No. 2024-04526	2025 NY Slip Op 00481
Casiano v R.G. Ortiz Funeral Home Inc.	Index No. 817109/23 Appeal No. 3608 Case No. 2024-03935	2025 NY Slip Op 00480
Buenano v City of New York	Index No. 23400/19 Appeal No. 3592-3593 Case No. 2023-06000 2024-02689	2025 NY Slip Op 00479
Matter of Muser	Index No. 500123/19 Appeal No. 3589 Case No. 2024-02318	2025 NY Slip Op 00478

**Cases Decided January 28, 2025**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Moghtaderi v Apis Capital Advisors, LLC		Index No. 650287/20 Appeal No. 3587 Case No. 2024-00836	2025 NY Slip Op 00402
Dickon Tong v Granat		Index No. 650264/21 Appeal No. 3566-3577 Case No. 2023-03120, 2023-06467	2025 NY Slip Op 00412
Rodriguez v Riverside Ctr. Site 5 Owner LLC		Index No. 300022/17 Appeal No. 3585 Case No. 2023-06105	2025 NY Slip Op 00411
People v Cassanova		Ind. No. 987/21 Appeal No. 2926 Case No. 2023-01425	2025 NY Slip Op 00410
People v Arriola		Ind. No. 2273/11 Appeal No. 3565 Case No. 2021-01429	2025 NY Slip Op 00409
People v Gardner		Ind. No. 1517/18 Appeal No. 3575 Case No. 2019-05344	2025 NY Slip Op 00408
People v Watts		Ind. No. 71641/22 Appeal No. 3578-3579 Case No. 2023-00749, 2024-00190	2025 NY Slip Op 00407
People v Percy		Ind. No. 71405/22 Appeal No. 3582 Case No. 2023-01628	2025 NY Slip Op 00406
People v Jaswane M.		Ind. No. 387/18 Appeal No. 3584 Case No. 2019-3465	2025 NY Slip Op 00405
Pena v Intergate Manhattan LLC		Index No. 154441/17, 595531/17 Appeal No. 3576 Case No. 2023-03423	2025 NY Slip Op 00404
Moore-Reason v Manhattan Coll.		Index No. 25403/20 Appeal No. 3572 Case No. 2024-00253	2025 NY Slip Op 00403
Matter of A.E.H.L. (Florentino H.-C.)		Docket No. B-8020-23/22 Appeal No. 3568-3569-3570-3571 Case No. 2024-03670, 2024-03671, 2024-03672, 2024-03086	2025 NY Slip Op 00393
Mejia v 770 Broadway Owner, LLC		Index No. 160479/16, 595346/17 Appeal No. 3583 Case No. 2023-03422	2025 NY Slip Op 00401
Matter of Grant	PER CURIAM	Motion No. 2024-03958 Case No. 2023-05157	2025 NY Slip Op 00400
Martinez v Stericycle, Inc.		Index No. 22798/18 Appeal No. 3580 Case No. 2024-00911	2025 NY Slip Op 00399
Maignan v Watsky & Damm, Inc.		Index No. 804761/21 Appeal No. 3574 Case No. 2024-03236	2025 NY Slip Op 00398
Katsikoumbas v Katsikoumbas		Index No. 805347/22 Appeal No. 3577 Case No. 2024-01192	2025 NY Slip Op 00397
Kasowitz, Benson, Torres & Friedman, LLP v JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.		Index No. 157631/15 Appeal No. 16482-16483 Case No. 2021-03399, 2021-03400, 2022-00030	2025 NY Slip Op 00396
Beagan v Akebono Brake Corp.		Index No. 190419/2018 Appeal No. 3573 Case No. 2023-03820	2025 NY Slip Op 00395
Alvaran v New Jersey Tr. Corp.		Index No. 152106/19 Appeal No. 3581 Case No. 2023-00121	2025 NY Slip Op 00394

**Cases Decided January 23, 2025**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Allied World Natl. Assur. Co. v AIG Specialty Ins. Co.	Index No. 654162/21 Appeal No. 3564 Case No. 2024-03661	2025 NY Slip Op 00372
Matter of Kwai Hwa Yang v Governor's Off. of Storm Recovery	Index No. 160090/20 Appeal No. 3563 Case No. 2024-02806	2025 NY Slip Op 00390
People v Amparo	Ind No. 74331/22 Appeal No. 3377 Case No. 2023-04182	2025 NY Slip Op 00389
People v Rivera	Ind No. 37792/05 Appeal No. 3562 Case No. 2022-04852	2025 NY Slip Op 00388
People v Torres	Ind No. 2368/19 Appeal No. 3550 Case No. 2023-03225	2025 NY Slip Op 00387
People v Anderson	Ind No. 2567/16 Appeal No. 3545 Case No. 2018-2497	2025 NY Slip Op 00386
People v Stanton	Ind No. 4235/17 Appeal No. 3557 Case No. 2019-3860	2025 NY Slip Op 00385
People v Maldonado	Ind No. 3049/12 Appeal No. 3555 Case No. 2019-2559	2025 NY Slip Op 00384
People v Bawa	Ind No. 156/20 950/20 Appeal No. 2742-2742A Case No. 2022-05089	2025 NY Slip Op 00383
New York Mar. & Gen. Ins. Co. v Rockingham Ins. Co.	Index No. 156010/21 Appeal No. 3560 Case No. 2023-05462	2025 NY Slip Op 00382
Nunez v CH Hous. Dev. Fund Corp.	Index No. 800460/21 Appeal No. 3561 Case No. 2023-04390	2025 NY Slip Op 00381
Metropolitan Transp. Auth. v Trinity NYC Hotel, LLC	Index No. 452008/23 Appeal No. 3558 Case No. 2024-03664	2025 NY Slip Op 00380
Legrand v USC-NYCON, LLC	Index No. 28973/18 Appeal No. 3549 Case No. 2024-00802	2025 NY Slip Op 00379
Khadem v Stonehill & Taylor Architects, P.C.	Index No. 657125/17 Appeal No. 3406 Case No. 2024-01684	2025 NY Slip Op 00378
Jones v Jacobs	Index No. 152766/23 Appeal No. 3553-3554 Case No. 2024-02812 2024-03706	2025 NY Slip Op 00377
Henriquez v Appula Mgt. Corp.	Ind No. 33099/20 Appeal No. 3548 Case No. 2024-02361	2025 NY Slip Op 00376
Fourth Ave. Owners Corp. v Douglas Elliman Prop. Mgt.	Index No. 655914/21 Appeal No. 3556 Case No. 2024-05562	2025 NY Slip Op 00375
Deutsche Bank Natl. Trust Co. v Marino	Index No. 850107/17 Appeal No. 3546 Case No. 2024-02947	2025 NY Slip Op 00374
Matter of Adekunle D.D. v Luxury M.D.	Index No. V-31047/19 V-15602/22 V-31047-19/22A V-31047-19/22B Appeal No. 3547 Case No. 2024-02956	2025 NY Slip Op 00373

**Cases Decided January 21, 2025**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Luke	PITT-BURKE, J.	Index No. 4233/17 Appeal No. 2727 Case No. 2019-5240	2025 NY Slip Op 00297
Yanky v 2839 Bainbridge Ave. Assoc. LLC		Index No. 808606/21 Appeal No. 3536 Case No. 2024-01629	2025 NY Slip Op 00301
TH Holdco LLC v Rubin		Index No. 650955/23 Appeal No. 3538 Case No. 2023-06262	2025 NY Slip Op 00300
Silva v 770 Broadway Owner LLC		Index No. 155857/17, 595829/18, 595586/19 Appeal No. 3532 Case No. 2023-04723	2025 NY Slip Op 00299
People v Straker		Ind. No. 1685/11 Appeal No. 56 Case No. 2018-3763	2025 NY Slip Op 00298
360 E. 72nd St. Owners Inc. v Wolkoff		Index No. 655998/21 Appeal No. 3533-3534-3535 Case No. 2024-02830, 2024-02836, 2024-02838	2025 NY Slip Op 00284
People v Williams		Ind. No. 70361/22 Appeal No. 3530 Case No. 2023-00477	2025 NY Slip Op 00296
People v Alleyne		Ind. No. 96/21 Appeal No. 3524 Case No. 2022-05317	2025 NY Slip Op 00295
People v L.P.		Ind. No. 1053/19 Appeal No. 3542 Case No. 2021-03343	2025 NY Slip Op 00294
People v Gneco		Ind. No. 1757/18 Appeal No. 3531-3531A Case No. 2019-1930, 2023-05307	2025 NY Slip Op 00293
Matter of Mungiguerra v Nigro		Index No. 150692/22 Appeal No. 3541 Case No. 2023-06789	2025 NY Slip Op 00292
Matter of M.G. v Marquise G.		Docket No. NN-6499/23 Appeal No. 3526 Case No. 2024-02938	2025 NY Slip Op 00291
Golden Integrity,Inc. v Azog, Inc.		Index No. 652255/22 Appeal No. 3544 Case No. 2024-01857	2025 NY Slip Op 00290
Garcia v Soho AOA Owner, LLC		Index No. 161262/17, 595443/18 Appeal No. 3539 Case No. 2024-00044	2025 NY Slip Op 00289
Galindo v Doherty		Index No. 152157/21 Appeal No. 3528-3529 Case No. 2023-04211, 2024-05246	2025 NY Slip Op 00288
Estrella v Uptown Health Care Mgt., Inc.		Ind. No. 28030/18 Appeal No. 3543 Case No. 2024-01406	2025 NY Slip Op 00287
Matter of 8 Ave. Holdings LLC v New York State Div. of Hous. & Community Renewal		Index No. 153005/23 Appeal No. 3525 Case No. 2023-04660	2025 NY Slip Op 00286
630 6A LLC v U.S. Bank Trust N.A.		Index No. 160960/23 Appeal No. 3527 Case No. 2024-05272	2025 NY Slip Op 00285

**Cases Decided January 16, 2025**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Matter of Kal-El A.	Docket No. D-08323/23 Appeal No. 3505 Case No. 2023-06271	2025 NY Slip Op 00266
Matter of Tsevilsky v New York State Div. of Hous. & Community Renewal	Index No. 100991/23 Appeal No. 3515 Case No. 2024-04005	2025 NY Slip Op 00282
Santana v San Mateo Constr. Corp.	Index No. 650029/22 Appeal No. 3509 Case No. 2023-03571	2025 NY Slip Op 00281
People v Perez	Ind No. 1601/18 Appeal No. 3521 Case No. 2019-03789	2025 NY Slip Op 00280
People v Bailey	Ind No. 72486/22 Appeal No. 3504 Case No. 2023-00620	2025 NY Slip Op 00279
People v Winns	Ind No. 2230/17 Appeal No. 3512 Case No. 2019-3157	2025 NY Slip Op 00278
People v Ryant	Ind No. 48/18 Appeal No. 3514 Case No. 2019-03853	2025 NY Slip Op 00277
People v Castillo	Ind No. 73708/22 Appeal No. 3510 Case No. 2023-02929	2025 NY Slip Op 00276
NY 2015 Boat LLC v Shapiro	Index No. 806264/22 Appeal No. 3518-3519-3520 Case No. 2023-06530, 2024-02311, 2024-02630	2025 NY Slip Op 00275
Lopez v Trahan	Index No. 155637/20 Appeal No. 3523 Case No. 2024-04221	2025 NY Slip Op 00274
Juman v Cape Church Assoc., LLC	Index No. 153080/23, 595618/23 Appeal No. 3506 Case No. 2024-04462	2025 NY Slip Op 00273
Gentile v Juva Skin & Laser Ctr. Medispa	Index No. 805179/19 Appeal No. 3517 Case No. 2023-04895	2025 NY Slip Op 00272
Ganieva v Black	Index No. 155262/21 Appeal No. 2932 Case No. 2023-05694	2025 NY Slip Op 00271
Efron v Efron	Index No. 365126/2022 Appeal No. 3522 Case No. 2024-01916	2025 NY Slip Op 00270
Board of Mgrs. of the Aston Condominium v Building 389 LLC	Index No. 654173/20 Appeal No. 3511 Case No. 2024-00085	2025 NY Slip Op 00269
Matter of Bi-Costal Props., LLC v Soliman	Index No. 809109/21 Appeal No. 3513 Case No. 2023-02305	2025 NY Slip Op 00268
Barbiere v 175 W. 12th St. Condominium	Index No. 653461/19 Appeal No. 3516 Case No. 2023-06166	2025 NY Slip Op 00267

**Cases Decided January 14, 2025**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
People v Dupree	SINGH, J.	Index No. 112/17 Appeal No. 2804 Case No. 2018-03559	2025 NY Slip Op 00199
State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v Able Chiropractic, P.C.		Index No. 153544/21 Appeal No. 3499 Case No. 2023-06794	2025 NY Slip Op 00206
Spoto v Matos		Index No. 156083/19 Appeal No. 3482 Case No. 2023-06558	2025 NY Slip Op 00205
Rhodes Assoc. Exec. Search of N.Y., LLC v IS Co. LLC		Index No. 657339/19 Appeal No. 3491-3492-3493 Case No. 2023-04237, 2023-04241, 2023-04242	2025 NY Slip Op 00204
Regions Bank v VativoRx, LLC		Index No. 654741/22 Appeal No. 3334-3335 Case Nos. 2024-01692, 2024-02306	2025 NY Slip Op 00203
Pyankaroo v Renali Realty Group 1, LLC		Index No. 23052/20 Appeal No. 3485 Case No. 2024-01641	2025 NY Slip Op 00202
Provenance Hotel Partners Fund I, LLC v GCKC Provenance, LLC		Index No. 653017/24 Appeal No. 3503 Case No. 2024-05072	2025 NY Slip Op 00201
People v Clark		Ind. No. 566/19 Appeal No. 3495 Case No. 2021-03911	2025 NY Slip Op 00200
Cabral v Triangle, LLC		Index No. 34985/19 Appeal No. 3484 Case No. 2023-04937	2025 NY Slip Op 00187
People v Wallace		Ind. No. 70872/22, 72515/22 Appeal No. 3501 Case No. 2022-05475, 2023-05188	2025 NY Slip Op 00198
People v Parra		Ind. No. 566/18 Appeal No. 3498 Case No. 2022-05050	2025 NY Slip Op 00197
People v Ruiz		Ind. No. 1938/19 Appeal No. 3487 Case No. 2020-01526	2025 NY Slip Op 00196
People v Cueto		Ind. No. 73640/22, 73608/23 Appeal No. 3486 Case No. 2023-05630	2025 NY Slip Op 00195
Orellana v 5541-1274 Fifth Ave. Manhattan LLC		Index No. 152497/20 Appeal No. 3490 Case No. 2023-06809	2025 NY Slip Op 00194
Matter of Vikram J. v Anupama S.		Docket No. V-41775/13 Appeal No. 3483 Case No. 2023-06106	2025 NY Slip Op 00193
Gaviola v City of New York		Index No. 159758/21 Appeal No. 3502 Case No. 2023-06792	2025 NY Slip Op 00192
Matter of Destiny G. (Melvin G.)		Docket No. N33631-32/23 Appeal No. 3497 Case No. 2024-01943	2025 NY Slip Op 00191
Finch Prop. Holdings I, LLP v Blumenfeld		Index No. 651206/23 Appeal No. 3488-3489 Case No. 2023-05757	2025 NY Slip Op 00190
Dewald v Dewald		Index No. 365136/23 Appeal No. 3394-3394A M-06234 Case No. 2024-02344	2025 NY Slip Op 00189
L.D. v New York City Hous. Auth.		Index No. 70153/20 Appeal No. 3496 Case No. 2023-05378	2025 NY Slip Op 00188
Barreto v Board of Mgrs. of 545 W. 110th St. Condominium		Index No. 160421/17 Appeal No. 3494 Case No. 2024-01147	2025 NY Slip Op 00185
Bawa v JJ Operating Inc.		Index No. 25293/17 Appeal No. 3500 Case No. 2023-06038	2025 NY Slip Op 00186

**Cases Decided January 9, 2025**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
23 E. 39th St. Mgt. Corp. v 23 E. 39th St. Devs., LLC		Index No. 117303/08 Appeal No. 3459-3460-3461 Case No. 2023-05741 2023-05791 2024-01217	2025 NY Slip Op 00145
Wilmington Sav. Fund Socy., FSB v Milne		Index No. 850241/22 Appeal No. 3463 Case No. 2024-02420	2025 NY Slip Op 00181
Matter of TGT, LLC v Meli		Index No. 153682/23 Appeal No. 3457-3457A Case No. 2024-02588	2025 NY Slip Op 00180
ST1 Realty LLC v Carroll		Index No. 811054/23 Appeal No. 3443 Case No. 2023-05896	2025 NY Slip Op 00179
Spalter v Spalter		Index No. 365030/23 Appeal No. 1577 Case No. 2023-03602	2025 NY Slip Op 00178
Smartmatic USA Corp. v Fox Corp.		Index No. 151136/21 Appeal No. 3439 Case No. 2024-01388	2025 NY Slip Op 00177
Matter of Petre v Lucia		Index No. 161731/23 Appeal No. 3456 Case No. 2024-03322	2025 NY Slip Op 00176
People v Baez		Ind Nos. 4883/17 2712/18 Appeal No. 3452 Case No. 2020-00890	2025 NY Slip Op 00175
People v Luperon		Ind No. 4858/16 Appeal No. 3475 Case No. 2018-03846	2025 NY Slip Op 00174
People v Johnson		Ind No. 74671/22 Appeal No. 3442 Case No. 2024-00212	2025 NY Slip Op 00173
People v Afflick		Ind No. 3456/05 Appeal No. 3465 Case No. 2017-2701	2025 NY Slip Op 00172
People v Velasquez		Ind No. 70928/22 Appeal No. 3478 Case No. 2023-01815	2025 NY Slip Op 00171
People v Corley		Ind No. 71234/21 Appeal No. 3453 Case No. 2022-04563	2025 NY Slip Op 00170
People v Dancy		Ind No. 1588/15 Appeal No. 3472 Case No. 2018-2059	2025 NY Slip Op 00169
People v Cruz		Ind No. 70399/22 Appeal No. 3436 Case No. 2023-03070	2025 NY Slip Op 00168
People v Feliciano		Ind No. 2160/14 Appeal No. 3447 Case No. 2019-03885	2025 NY Slip Op 00167
People v Kamara		Ind No. 888/20 Appeal No. 3466 Case No. 2022-04517	2025 NY Slip Op 00166
Narain v Society Pass Inc.		Index No. 656956/19 Appeal No. 3444-3445-3446 Case No. 2023-04977 2023-05784 2023-05785	2025 NY Slip Op 00165
Matter of Masaryk Towers Corp. v New York State Div. of Human Rights		Index No. 160887/23 Appeal No. 3477 Case No. 2024-03532	2025 NY Slip Op 00164
Matter of J.M. (Antionette T.)		Docket No. NN-03850/21 Appeal No. 3438 Case No. 2023-05061	2025 NY Slip Op 00163
Matter of Milani M. (Fatima M.)		Docket No. NN-28663/23 Appeal No. 3462 Case No. 2024-01045	2025 NY Slip Op 00162
Lee v Grimblat		Index No. 100047/23 Appeal No. 3476 Case No. 2024-03286	2025 NY Slip Op 00161
Jobar Holding Corp. v Halio		Index No. 655689/17 Appeal No. 3471 Case No. 2021-01048	2025 NY Slip Op 00160
Interiano v Silverstein Galaxy Prop. Owner, LLC		Index No. 157311/19 595089/21 Appeal No. 3469 Case No. 2023-05097	2025 NY Slip Op 00159
Matter of John M.		Index No. 500018/22 Appeal No. 3448 Case No. 2023-04593	2025 NY Slip Op 00158
HSBC Bank USA, N.A. v Nomura Credit & Capital, Inc.		Index No. 650337/13, 595359/14 Appeal No. 3467-3468 Case No. 2024-00081, 2024-03496	2025 NY Slip Op 00157
Harper v De Almeida		Index No. 307647/17 Appeal No. 3454 Case No. 2023-05672	2025 NY Slip Op 00156
Gelles v Sauvage		Index No. 22380/15 Appeal No. 3464 Case No. 2023-03369	2025 NY Slip Op 00155
Garcia v Monadnock Constr., Inc.	MOULTON, J.	Index No. 30979/20 Appeal No. 3136 Case No. 2023-03652	2025 NY Slip Op 00154
Fadl v Katz		Index No. 805404/19 Appeal No. 3451 Case No. 2023-06010	2025 NY Slip Op 00153
Edwards v Rockland Hosp. Guild Inc.		Index No. 156523/21 Appeal No. 3474 Case No. 2024-01765	2025 NY Slip Op 00152
Matter of E.B. v New York State Off. for People with Dev. Disabilities		Index No. 100325/24 Appeal No. 3473 Case No. 2024-04229	2025 NY Slip Op 00151
Matter of Joycelyn E. v Julianne R.		Docket No. V10087/23 Appeal No. 3470 Case No. 2024-00923	2025 NY Slip Op 00150
Matter of Davis v Adams		Index No. 150427/23 Appeal No. 3449 Case No. 2023-05701	2025 NY Slip Op 00149
Cabral v Mueses		Inex No. 802132/21 Appeal No. 3455 Case No. 2023-05465	2025 NY Slip Op 00148
Black v Phoenix Cayman Ltd.		Index No. 652460/20 Appeal No. 3440 Case No. 2023-06578	2025 NY Slip Op 00147
477 Realty, L.L.C. v Wing Soho, LLC		Index No. 653418/23 Appeal No. 3450 Case No. 2024-01621	2025 NY Slip Op 00146
C3 Data, LLC v 212 Media Group Inc.		Index No. 652813/23 Appeal No. 3479 Case No. 2024-05232	2025 NY Slip Op 00182

**Cases Decided January 7, 2025**
Title	Judge	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
Abarrotes Mixteca Corp., Inc. v Brisk		Index No. 651199/17 Appeal No. 3400-3401 Case No. 2023-04641, 2024-01873	2025 NY Slip Op 00034
Kwan v HFZ Capital Group, LLC		Index No. 651518/23 Appeal No. 3434 Case No. 2024-00647	2025 NY Slip Op 00074
Matter of Zurich Am. Ins. Co. v HBC US Holdings, Inc.		Index No. 653530/21, 655777/21 Appeal No. 3416-3417-3418 Case No. 2022-00022, 2024-02639, 2024-03306	2025 NY Slip Op 00073
Matter of J.V. (Hakim H.)		Docket No. NN-35370-71/18 Appeal No. 3414-3414A-3414B Case No. 2024-01203	2025 NY Slip Op 00072
U.S. Bank N.A. v EquiFirst Corp.		Index No. 650692/13 Appeal No. 3425 Case No. 2023-06159	2025 NY Slip Op 00071
Matter of State of N.Y. ex rel. Louis M. (Popiel)		Index No. 808187/24 Appeal No. 3432 & M-5525 Case No. 2024-03379	2025 NY Slip Op 00070
Matter of Sogoloff v Sogoloff		Index No. 150148/24 Appeal No. 3408 Case No. 2024-04512	2025 NY Slip Op 00069
Smith v Kixby Hotel		Index No. 154733/21 Appeal No. 3405 Case No. 2024-01864	2025 NY Slip Op 00068
Seibel v Scarola Zubatov Schaffin PLLC		Index No. 650912/23 Appeal No. 3403 Case No. 2023-05107	2025 NY Slip Op 00067
Perez v 1334 York, LLC		Index No. 156972/20 Appeal No. 3103 Case No. 2024-02957	2025 NY Slip Op 00066
People v Arzu		Ind. No. 1844/18 Appeal No. 3402 Case No. 2019-03692	2025 NY Slip Op 00065
People v Cintron		Case. No. SMZ - 74494/22 94/22, 2024-04086 Appeal No. 3389	2025 NY Slip Op 00064
People v Gomez		Ind. No. 2090/12 Appeal No. 3420 Case No. 2016-1852	2025 NY Slip Op 00063
People v Kirk		Ind. No. 4245/17 Appeal No. 3410 Case No. 2019-05087	2025 NY Slip Op 00062
People v Johnson		Ind. No. 502/14 Appeal No. 3407 Case No. 2018-1431	2025 NY Slip Op 00061
People v Foster		Ind. No. 1099/21 Appeal No. 3419 Case No. 2022-02677	2025 NY Slip Op 00060
People v Periera		Ind. No. 326/21, 1016/21 Appeal No. 3396-3396A Case No. 2022-05771, 2022-02857	2025 NY Slip Op 00059
People v Soberanis		SCI No. 698/19 Appeal No. 3422 Case No. 2019-03593	2025 NY Slip Op 00058
People v Taylor		Ind. No. 4887/15, 2682/16 Appeal No. 3431 Case No. 2023-05156	2025 NY Slip Op 00057
People v Wells		Ind. No. 6548/06, 41/07 Appeal No. 3404 Case No. 2019-2364	2025 NY Slip Op 00056
People v Aragon		Ind. No. 3822/18 Appeal No. 3428 Case No. 2020-03813	2025 NY Slip Op 00055
People v Moore		Ind. No. 2100/21 Appeal No. 3433 Case No. 2023-05394	2025 NY Slip Op 00054
People v Robinson		Index No. 0755/21 Appeal No. 3395 Case No. 2023-03574	2025 NY Slip Op 00053
Newson v Vivaldi Real Estate LTD.	Kennedy, J.	Index No. 452625/22 Appeal No. 2982 Case No. 2024-00261	2025 NY Slip Op 00052
Mejia v St. Barnabas Hosp.		Index No. 28364/19 Appeal No. 3423 Case No. 2024-00056	2025 NY Slip Op 00051
McWashington v Hyatt Corp.		Index No. 153070/23 Appeal No. 3415 Case No. 2024-00905	2025 NY Slip Op 00050
Matter of Kort	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2024-04056 Case No. 2024-05195	2025 NY Slip Op 00049
Matter of Dumas	Per Curiam	Motion No. 2024-05081 Case No. 2024-06248	2025 NY Slip Op 00048
Matter of Law Off. of Cyrus Joubin, Esq. v Manhattan Dist. Attorney's Off.		Index No. 158134/23 Appeal No. 3399 Case No. 2024-02152	2025 NY Slip Op 00047
Kirton v City of New York		Index No. 104534/09 Appeal No. 3424 Case No. 2023-06191	2025 NY Slip Op 00046
Irizarry v Pathmark Stores, Inc.		Index No. 152283/18 Appeal No. 3398 Case No. 2024-02890	2025 NY Slip Op 00045
Global Merchant Cash, Inc. v Tammy Tran Attorneys at Law, LLP		Index No. 155239/22 Appeal No. 3429-3430 Case No. 2024-01717, 2024-01813	2025 NY Slip Op 00044
Gibraltar Contr., Inc. v Tully Constr. Co. Inc.		Index No. 653712/23 Appeal No. 3421 Case No. 2024-01284	2025 NY Slip Op 00043
Matter of Rebecca F. (Danequea J.)		Docket No. NN-08146-48/20, NN-08147/20, NN-08148/20 Appeal No. 3391-3391A Case No. 2022-01541	2025 NY Slip Op 00042
Cornell Univ. v Patsalides		Index No. 150487/21 Appeal No. 3413 Case No. 2023-02943	2025 NY Slip Op 00041
Bullaro v Ledo, Inc.		Ind. No. 35022/20 Appeal No. 3426-3427 Case No. 2024-02508, 2024-04775	2025 NY Slip Op 00040
Breton v Dishi		Index No. 157760/16 Appeal No. 3411 Case No. 2024-00079	2025 NY Slip Op 00039
Bowlero Corp. v AIG Specialty Lines Ins. Co.		Index No. 653170/21 Appeal No. 3397 Case No. 2023-02415	2025 NY Slip Op 00038
Borek v Seidman		Index No. 805351/21 Appeal No. 3392-3393 Case No. 2023-04944, 2024-00271	2025 NY Slip Op 00037
Ascher v New York City Dept. of Educ.		Index No. 152695/20 Appeal No. 3390 Case No. 2023-05806	2025 NY Slip Op 00036
Aguasanta v City of New York		Index No. 28843/20 Appeal No. 3409 Case No. 2023-03434	2025 NY Slip Op 00035

**Cases Decided January 2, 2025**
Title	Docket No.	Slip Opinion No.
1S REO Opportunity 1, LLC v Harlem Premier Residence, LLC	Index No. 850151/21 Appeal No. 3370 Case No. 2023-06250	2025 NY Slip Op 00016
Tibbs v De'Longhi Am. Inc.	Index No. 150421/19 Appeal No. 3244 Case No. 2023-05329	2025 NY Slip Op 00033
Springs v L&D Law P.C.	Index No. 154134/23 Appeal No. 3368 Case No. 2024-01361	2025 NY Slip Op 00032
Seaman v City of New York	Index No. 152057/23 Appeal No. 3387 Case No. 2024-02280	2025 NY Slip Op 00031
Matter of People of the State of New York v Northern Leasing Sys., Inc.	Index No. 450460/16 Appeal No. 3375-3376 Case No. 2023-05369	2025 NY Slip Op 00030
People v Thompson	SCI No. 3886/16 Appeal No. 3367 Case No. 2019-04898	2025 NY Slip Op 00029
People v Perrone	Ind No. 71491/22 Appeal No. 3380 Case No. 2023-00617	2025 NY Slip Op 00028
People v Jacobowitz	Ind No. 1322/20 Appeal No. 3373 Case No. 2021-03602	2025 NY Slip Op 00027
People v Harris	Ind No. 1273/93 Appeal No. 3372 Case No. 2018-5324	2025 NY Slip Op 00026
People v Merrick	Ind No. 1319/21 Appeal No. 3385 Case No. 2023-04054	2025 NY Slip Op 00025
Nasta v Rajapaksa	Index No. 652131/23 Appeal No. 3378 Case No. 2024-02078	2025 NY Slip Op 00024
Matter of Marks v City of New York	Index No. 158886/21 Appeal No. 3386 Case No. 2022-05171	2025 NY Slip Op 00023
Matter of E.I. (Eboniqua M.)	Docket No. NN-26318-19/22 Appeal No. 3369 Case No. 2024-01073	2025 NY Slip Op 00022
Hereford Ins. Co. v Interdependent Acupuncture PLLC	Index No. 152296/19 Appeal No. 3388 Case No. 2024-02707	2025 NY Slip Op 00021
Hempstead v Hammer & Steel, Inc.	Index No. 156963/17, 595699/17, 595927/17 Appeal No. 3371 Case No. 2023-05500	2025 NY Slip Op 00020
Daper Realty, Inc. v Pizzimenti	Index No. 155325/20 655100/21 Appeal No. 3382-3383 Case No. 2024-00163 2024-02795	2025 NY Slip Op 00019
Atlantic Specialty Ins. Co. v Landmark Unlimited, Inc.	Index No. 650912/22 Appeal No. 3379 Case No. 2023-05025	2025 NY Slip Op 00018
630 W. 52nd LLC v Fresh Inventory Servs., LLC	Index No. 653016/22 Appeal No. 3374 Case No. 2024-02143	2025 NY Slip Op 00017